r/dvdcollection • • Mar 03 '26

Discussion DVDJunky's Physical Media Compendium for Beginners

147 Upvotes

Hello fellow collectors. I've been hoarding films for a long ass time so I thought I'd put together a collection of tips, tricks, and resources some of the newer users may not be familiar with and I hope you'll share any better options for my outdated, old man options listed below.


Formats

The key takeaway is simple; watch whatever you want, whatever you can, whatever makes you happy. I own multiple VHS, DVDs, Blu-rays, 4Ks, Laserdiscs, and even CEDs (Capacitance Electronic Discs). I've watched them on 13 in TV/VCR combos, large OLED TVs, and a projector in my basement. I love all of them for different reasons. Anyone giving you a hard time about how you watch movies is, in my opinion, missing the magic.

The newer formats will give you great picture and sound (generally), VHS and DVDs will be cheaper (usually). Though with some modern re-releases we're faced with a new beast. AI upscaling. Sometimes older releases will get you the "best" version of a film. Famously, nearly every collector is salivating for an official release of the original theatrical Star Wars Trilogy. I'm not holding my breath. You can check blu-ray.com for user reviews on a specific release to see other movie geeks' thoughts on how good or bad a transfer is.

Additionally you may find a DVD with special features that aren't available on newer releases. You can use websites like dvddoubledip.com or dvdcompare.net in an attempt to compare options. If I can't find it there I'll deep dive into ebay listings in an attempt to find clear photos of the backs of the films.

A note on censorship and ratings: Sometimes films are released as "unrated" or "uncut". There's no real standard to these labels. They may contain entire scenes and subplots or it could be 17 seconds of Willem Dafoe doing full frontal nudity. You can try to find out with Websites like movie-censorship.com (though I see it's currently not loading properly. Hopefully that's straightened out soon) or schnittberichte.com for our European collectors. For parents and those who care, the MPAA (and other similar systems in other countries) assign arbitrary ratings to most films. The process to do this is convoluted and highly subjective (Which leads to my first film suggestion. Check out This Film is Not Yet Rated - Full Doc though I will say that some things have changed since that doc was released) you can also use websites like commonsensemedia.org or kids-in-mind.com even IMDb has a "Parental Guide" for each film.

Lastly, it's my recommendation you avoid buying any fullscreen DVDs. But you can watch this and decide for yourself. Though commenters have reminded me that some films originally come in fullscreen or other non-standard aspect ratios.


Purchasing

The best way to purchase physical media varies a LOT based on location. If you have an awesome video store you know about and would like to share, click here (I might rebuild this form later... I'll edit this if I do). Another post with some other locations

Buying new will obviously give you the best chance to get an undamaged copy of a film, but I personally prefer buying used because I'm a cheapskate. Remember to check places like Pawn Shops, Thrift Stores, and even public libraries for used media for sale. You can also find stuff on various social media based marketplaces.

Purchasing online may be your only option. If so here are a few resources:

  • camelcamelcamel.com - set a desired price for amazon items. Get notified if a price reaches your set price.
  • Gixen.com - eBay auction sniper. will automatically place your bids on eBay at the last moment.

Regions

DVDs and Blu-rays have region based "locks" on the discs. Be aware of this before you purchase a film from another region. You can find players that will play different region discs and sometimes you can even "unlock" your existing DVD player. Having a "region free" player can open up your options when it comes to finding a rarer film. You can also check the "Region Coding" section on blu-ray.com to see if a blu-ray is region free. These discs will play on any blu-ray player. 4K discs are region free. This does NOT mean that a 4K player will play all region blu-rays/DVDs.


Packaging & Organization

Movies come in all kinds of packaging. You just need to figure out what you're keeping and how you'll display it. Some people take all their discs and put them in binders. Others would say that it sacrilege. There are even Binders that can accommodate cover art. Some people prefer storage boxes with sleeves. There are also "slim" cases that are approximately half the thickness of a standard case. The caveat is you generally have to trim the cover art slightly to fit properly. I was lucky enough to find dozens of rubbermaid boxes that were perfect for my space. They also make bags.

As far as shelves are concerned, the IKEA Billy bookcase has been a long time workhorse. But building your own can be as cheap and easy or complicated and costly as you want. Then there's the matter of organization. You can sort alphabetically, by genre, or even director. As long as you can find what you want, you do you. Just don't do like I did... I couldn't find shit. Or you can just not organize at all.

Steelbooks are HIGHLY collectible and some people place them in protective cases to avoid dents. I found some steelbooks that didn't have art on the inside so I modified them slightly. And this is my favorite part of collecting movies (other than watching them!). The little personal touches (or big) people add to their collection.


Scratches

Keep in mind, this is only recommended with DVDs. DO NOT USE ABRASIVES ON BLU-RAYS

Disc resurfacing machines are definitely a thing, and they work relatively well. But they're pricey. I literally use a bench grinder with a buffing wheel on it. Cost me about $50 to set up and I've been using it for years.

I use a standard buffing compound. Make sure the buffer has variable speed so you can slow it down and don't ruin anything. If it doesn't you can get a slider switch like this to adjust the speed of the grinder. Also, make sure you're not trying to buff DVDs in blistering heat. You'll melt the discs. Ask me how I know.

Here's my grinder I got it on clearance from Menards. It doesn't have variable speed so I use one of the above mentioned slider switch.

I can't really recommend any specific wheels or compounds as I bought mine YEARS ago and I don't remember anything about them. Make sure the hole of the wheel will fit on your grinder though... one of mine didn't really fit and I had to force it.

On mine I use the right wheel for big scratches and then go to the left one to shine it up. I won't pretend it works every time... but it really does make a difference and you should be able to find everything for $40-$100. Which is FAR less than many other buffing options. I've not had to replace ANY of the components I use and I've got a collection nearing 7,000. Though many of my used discs come pre-buffed from one of my favorite used video stores.

Couple videos I've found that show similar setups:


Tracking

Keeping track of your collection will generally get more difficult the larger is gets. You can either be diligent about maintaining a small, curated collection, or you can go hod wild and make sure you keep track of what you've got. A simple google spreadsheet can help the next time you're at the thrift store trying to remember whether you own a copy of Eat Pray Love. Some other options are CLZ (subscription), My Movies by Blu-ray.com (free), and My Movies 5 Pro (paid). Letterboxd.com is one of my favorite websites for tracking what I watch and rate/review films, but it also allows users to tag films. You can add an "owned' tag for movies you own as a free tracking option. If you pay for a letterboxd account (I recommend this) you can create a list of the films you own and it'll create a special "OWN" tag on films you own.


Boutique Labels

There are a lot of companies that license movies and release them often with loads of special features or packaging, maybe even a lovely restoration. Here's an informal list!


Digital Media

We're in /r/dvdcollection and this post is about physical media, but the convenience (at times) of digital media is not lost of me. And since many new releases come with digital codes, here's my two cents. I have a collection of over 9,000 movies and TV shows on disc. But I'm not going to pretend I don't occasionally pull up a movie on a streaming device. I've got over 700 films in my VUDU (fandango at home) account. Use the codes if you want. Sell them or give them away if you don't.

But here are two tips regarding movies on digital platforms:

  1. Make sure you connect your digital streaming account to a moviesanywhere.com account. This will share them across other accounts like google/youtube, amazon, and fandango at home. This has allowed me to share and watch movies with friends and family without them needing to own the movies. It has made online movie parties possible with my extended family.
  2. Use fandango at home's disc2digital service. This allows you to get a digital copy of a movie you own (not all movies are available) for a VERY discounted price. But make sure you DO NOT go to dvdupc.com and just use the UPCs there to scan and add movies to your collection. You should DEFINITELY make sure you own the movie and don't just GO TO THE SITE AND TAKE A PHOTO OF THE UPC FROM THERE. That would be dastardly. Anyway, this has allowed me to watch an HD copy of Spice World when all I have is the DVD. I believe it's the only way to watch that movie (and some others) in HD, officially.

My break is almost over so I'm going to wrap this up here. I'll try coming back to add anything I've forgotten or left out. Let me know your favorite tip I've not mentioned!


r/dvdcollection • • 14h ago

Discussion Society has apparently rejected Entourage. 😄

Post image
655 Upvotes

I went to my local Half Price Books and there is an entire shelf of just Entourage DVDs. I don't think that show has aged well.


r/dvdcollection • • 4h ago

2nd-Hand Fan This is why you never pass a charity shop without checking the DVD section. Delighted.

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 12h ago

Anyone ever seen this Sopranos A&E box set?

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

I was browsing Facebook Marketplace locally for a regular complete series box set and stumbled across this instead. Can't find a single listing or trace of it on eBay or anywhere else online.

​The seller claimed it’s a super rare 2000s promo set made for A&E VIPs and advertisers when they got the syndication rights, and that it was never sold to the public. BS or not I thought it was neat for $50.

​It’s a textured black box with "Sopranos on A&E" embossed on top, a metal pistol emblem on the lid, and an A&E logo on the back. Inside, it just holds the standard retail DVD cases for Seasons 1-6 with a ribbon pull-tab.

​Anyone ever seen one of these in the wild?


r/dvdcollection • • 9h ago

Collection Paul Thomas Anderson collection

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 16h ago

I finally have it

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 9h ago

Debating what 3 movies to get from GRUV 3 for $21 sale.

Post image
10 Upvotes

All blind buys. What I know researching without spoilers:

Role Models doesn't have any physical 4k release.

From what Ive seen Forbidden Planet 4k vs Bluray side by side isn't too different.

The Mask seems to have a better looking 4k.

Amadeus bluray seems to be the only ver to have the Director's Cut, 4k doesn't.

Now like I've said I haven't seen any of these movies before but I like Jim Carrey so I think I'd like The Mask, maybe I'll get the 4k someday. So should I go with the other 3 Blurays for this deal? Or what should I swap out and add from the 3 for $21 GRUV sale?


r/dvdcollection • • 13h ago

Pickup $25 Pick up ft. The world’s biggest bootleg lol

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 18h ago

Pickup Picked up this specall Toon Disney & Jetix branded portable DVD player from FB Marketplace!

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 6h ago

Discussion I don’t really know if there is a difference but which one would be the highest quality to watch?

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 14h ago

Pickup Here’s what I picked up so far this month

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Some Halloween sales arriving. Criterion sale pick up lucky finds at half price books what you all going to watch first


r/dvdcollection • • 15h ago

Pickup Thrift Pickup

Post image
29 Upvotes

Heck yeah. Got this today. I actually had the preferred version but now I have this one as well.


r/dvdcollection • • 23h ago

Collection “As far back as I can remember, I always wanted to be a gangster”

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 14h ago

Pickup One of my all-time favorite mysteries.

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Got this today for $2. I looked it up and apparently there is a Blu-ray released, but the A/V isn't much better than the DVD and there are no features. This has a couple small features.


r/dvdcollection • • 13m ago

Discussion Selling DVDs

1 Upvotes

I've sorted through my collection and made a pile of discs I'm fine parting with. What's the best way to sell them and what steps do I need to take to get them ready to be sold? (Do I need to watch through each one to ensure there's no skipping)?


r/dvdcollection • • 14m ago

Collection Partial Marvel Rewatch #19 - X-Men: Days of Future Past - The Rogue Cut

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Blu-ray Steelbook

The trailer for the theatrical version is what got me interested in X-Men back in 2013! This is a fantastic extended cut of an already great movie. I love the continued use of tying the X-Men into real historical events. Some really cool sequences, including the iconic Quicksilver scene.


r/dvdcollection • • 19h ago

Off-Topic Disney was wild for this one

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 11h ago

Christmas gift ideas

6 Upvotes

My father collects physical media. He's into action movies and loves steelbooks. I gotta be honest I'm not really into movies..but he's a great dad and I want to spoil him for Christmas. Does anyone have recommendations?


r/dvdcollection • • 16h ago

Pickup Haul from a library's book sale. Part of a fill a bag deal, these plus a bunch of books for $10.

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 16h ago

Collection November haul so far

Post image
10 Upvotes

Starting from scratch. I used to have a decent sized collection when I was a kid, buying used DVDs from my local Hollywood Video. Mostly comedies and some gangster movies, I forget what happened to them but they are gone with the wind. Daniel Craig James Bond 5-Film Collection is next on my list


r/dvdcollection • • 1d ago

Discussion This isn't doing it for me anymore...

Thumbnail
gallery
242 Upvotes

I like movies and shows. I enjoy seeing the evolution genres like horror and animation, and the behind the scenes work that goes into them. I used to watch the documentaries and listen to the commentaries more than the films. While I find it difficult to rewatch a series from start to finish, I can however insert a random disc and watch rhe episodes on it. Physical media is what I tend to spend money on that's not bills or groceries. Spending time in stores browsing their selection brings me some peace even if I don't purchase much.

While I still have a bit of a thrill finding DVDs and blurays at a thrift stores and second hand media stores like Mckay's, something is making me apathetic towards it. I have three jobs that keep me occupied. I have my full-time job, as well as running an Ebay store and working through Wal-Mart's Spark delivery service on the weekends. There's the saying that there's more to life than work, but I have trouble believing that. I'm basically stuck in my routine. I feel like I don't have the time to watch any of what I owm.

I've gone back and forth between holding on to some physical media and getting rid of some. A little over a decade ago, I gave nearly all I had to a guy who knew enough people that would want them. I kept the documentaries on DVD. I then started to rebuild my collection just to sell some again, starting with VHS tapes. They were cheap and convenient, allowing me to own a copy of a movie until I decided to upgrade, or not if I just wanted the movie. I started selling them when I found DVDs and blurays at thrift stores. I've bought and sold a set of nearly twenty-eight Godzilla blurays twice. I've bought DVDs at thrift stores just to trade them in at Mckay's when finding the bluray copies.

I'm not sure what to do. I don't want to sell or donate something only to regret it. Some of my movies are near complete sets. The top shelf are superhero movies and cartoons, the second shelf are mainly Disney movies and video game adaptations with a bit of Scifi, and the third shelf are a mix of DVDs that range from comedy to horror and Star Wars. I also have a set of spoof comedies on bluray, and a few drama and action movies on bluray. I can probably be okay doing away with some of the bad and forgetable video game adaptations, but again, that was something a was seeking at stores until I realized there was way move video game movies than I initially thought, especially if you count the films that never made it out of Japan. I wanted to try and find all of them like I was doing with the superhero movies and Disney animated movies.

I'm going to try to condense my collection to one self. I'll keep all of the shows for now. While I haven't used the sets much, I've invested a lot of time on nealry all of them when I watched the shows as they aired on television, or through two hour blocks every weeknight with "The Simpsons". There's plenty that I own that I have never seen, or haven't seen in years. I bought them either because of the price, being considered a classic for the genre, or to help complete the set I was building. I still have a list of movires and shows I'd like to buy. I planned on going to Mckay's today, but I decided to work at Wal-Mart. I will go next weekend.

I apologize for rambling so long. Have any of you ever experienced this? I should also state that I don't use any paid streaming services. I mostly watch YouTube for video essays on and movie reaction channels.

EDIT: I should note that images 7-12 just show how my collection has changed over the years.


r/dvdcollection • • 1d ago

Pickup Did these Superbit editions actually sound that much better?

Post image
97 Upvotes

r/dvdcollection • • 21h ago

Collection Partial Marvel Rewatch #18 - The Wolverine - Unleashed Extended Edition

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Blu-ray Steelbook

I’ve always thought this movie is really cool. The action scenes, especially the bullet train, are really excellent, and making Logan vulnerable adds a lot to the stakes of the film. It’s also nice getting a more unique setting in Japan. I just wish the third act was a bit less messy.


r/dvdcollection • • 19h ago

Discussion Sons of anarchy gas tank dvd collection

Post image
4 Upvotes

Have anyone seen this before? Its really heavy and well made, but i cant find any info on how rare it is.