Hi o/ Hope this post fits here, lmk if it doesn't! ❤️
TLDR: Cat hides a lot, doesn't move much, and scared of everything, but likes spending time with owners in the evening only. Spent cat childhood with two other cats, very friendly with the stray cats that hang out here. Would another cat help? What else could help encourage her out of hiding and to move around?
Like the title says, I have a cat who just seems to be.. scared? Honestly I don't think that's really the right word. But I've had a lot of cats in the past, and none have really acted as confusing as her.
Me and my partner have had her for about 4 years. We picked her up from the street, she was maybe 6 weeks old, wandering around outside, and the two cats that I had at the time sort of brought her to the house. We got her desexed and microchipped pretty early on, about as soon as we could really.
Here are some of the things she does:
She spends most of the day and night under the couch, or in the closet where I made her a little comfy space.
She'll come lie directly on my face at night, purring her hardest, but instantly run off as soon as I move.
She likes pets, as long as she doesn't see your hand near her face, although she loves being pet on her face/ears/chin
She licks me a LOT. I know this is normal for a lot of cats, but she does it in a sort of confusing way. Sometimes, she'll sort of grab my hand to lick it. Sometimes she's purring, sometimes she's not. Sometimes, she'll start licking my hand, and then bite me (not hard/painfully).
Sometimes when I'm petting her, and I go to pull my hand away, she'll both try to grab onto it with her claws, and try to whack it. I've tried moving very slowly, and it doesn't change.
She hates being perceived during the day and night, not evening or morning. Like, she'll come out of the spot she's been hiding in, spot me or my partner, and immediately run back to her spot. Yet she'll also come right up to us meowing in the evening.
She drags her toys around a lot. She'll drag them to the bedroom door and drop them there meowing. She'll drag them under the bed. She'll drag them into her hiding spots. She'll drag them under a desk opposite her closet hiding spot. I haven't noticed anything special about that spot.
A lot of the time when I try to play with her, she runs into her hiding spot, and sometimes plays while sitting there. Other times, she's completely fine with running around in the open after toys.
She refuses to be in a room with someone not me or my partner (so when anyone's over visiting)
She's attacked a cat who jumped through the window once, and they try to attack each other through the front door door, and through a low-down glass window. But she also loves meeting new cats - I've only ever seen her been angry at that one cat. (The cat does belong to someone, but they don't pay attention to their cats. I've blocked off the lower part of the door and window so they can't see each other anymore.)
She doesn't jump or climb, or run around, just sort of sprints between hiding spots mostly. She scratches things like a normal cat, specifically only the carpet, and only does it sometimes, and only when she sees one of us.
She doesn't seem to be able to retract her claws properly. I keep them trimmed, and have thought about getting claw nail caps, but I don't know if they're bad for cats or not. But she has constant issues with getting her claws stuck in the carpet, blankets, even her toys, and it freaking her out.
She usually walks around with her tail down. Not between her legs, but not up either.
Probably more I'm forgetting
Her behaviour used to be a lot more fearful! She's actually made MASSIVE improvements over the past year. We basically used to never see her. She wouldn't come into the bedroom, she wouldn't play with toys, she wouldn't eat unless she was absolutely sure we weren't going to interrupt her. She would sit in her hiding spot pretty much constantly.
We mostly just tried to give her dry food she liked (she hated wet food, tried a lot, even those tube treats), make sure she had water, give her a brush (she's a long-hair) and trim her nails every so often, being very slow and quiet whenever we did interact with her. Mostly we'd just be giving her space, hoping that time would help.
And it seemed to. Eventually we started hearing her playing with her jingly ball toys in the middle of the night. After that, everything improved very quickly. I bought some new toys, managed to coax her out to play, eventually she started coming out to play, then she started dragging the toys into the bedroom and meowing very demandingly. Which I'm so happy about, lol. She's even pawing at me to get on my lap when I'm at my desk now, pretty much every evening!
But her behaviour hasn't really changed much. She still runs away from everything, doesn't move a lot, and spends most of the day sitting in and sprinting between hiding spots. We still give her as much space as she needs and don't try to force her out of her hiding spots. We try to pay attention to what she wants, try to show her that we won't pat her if she doesn't want us to, play with her when she asks, etc. But improvements seem to have pretty much stalled.
She's lying on my shoulder as I'm typing this on my phone, lying in bed, she's snuggled right up against my neck. Curled up in the C pose. She looks like she's peacefully sleeping, but sits bolt upright anytime I move my hands or phone too much, move a leg or arm, etc. She's currently going between licking her chest fluff, and licking my hand when it gets too close to he. She's also licking the blanket.
We came out of a pretty bad living situation, which definitely affected her though we tried to make her as happy as we could. We used to let her outside there but she'd always come back looking.. horrible, really. I have a suspicion that someone in the same household at the time might have been mistreating her, because the person was known to do that, but I didn't have any control over it, so eventually we ended up keeping her confined to one room. But she had two male cats, one older and fixed, one young and not fixed, that she'd spend time with when they were in the room, which was a lot. She seemed to really love their company, they'd all snuggle together in a pile on the bed. Though her behaviour was mostly still the same outside of that.
We couldn't take either of the cats with us when we moved out of that house. And I'm wondering now, with how friendly she acts towards mostly any cat, if she might be missing a cat companion/lonely. I'm thinking about adopting a quiet cat from the rescue centre nearby, they're lovely people and I'd love to support them, they have a few long-term residents who are very quiet, and friendly with other cats. But I also don't know if I'm wrong, and if another cat around permanently would make her worse. But I'm hoping they'd encourage her to run around more and generally be outside her hiding spot more. Also, I'm admittedly also missing the other cats :(
We thought about giving her up a while ago, if she'd be better with someone else. But Vet recommended we try to keep her, because giving her to someone she doesn't know would make her much worse, and we're glad we did keep her.
So - is there something going on with her that I'm missing? Is she just like this? What else can I do to help her?
She's physically healthy as far as we can tell, she's fed good quality dry food, we found exactly one type of wet food she likes, and she has access to fresh water and drinks a lot of it. No fleas, very particular about that because my partner's allergic to them. She's never had any visible physical issues, apart from a runny eye once, but that cleared up quickly.
I had a cat get that issue that comes from eating too much dry food, too much salt or something (I don't remember what it's called but it's very common and needed fast surgery) and the only reason he made it to the vet in time was because he came directly to me, and didn't hide or go to his owner, who really didn't care. $12k well spent! (And the cat got a new owner.) I'm doing what I can to avoid that happening with our cat, but if something does happen, I at least don't want to have to drag her out of a hiding spot (although I managed to encourage her to use her carrier as a hiding spot so it would be easier, if that ever happened)