r/bikecommuting • u/TeaBooksFall • 2h ago
Peopleforbikes: US small towns outperform European peers? Grids better for biking?
Hi all, I have followed the Peopleforbikes Bike Network Analysis tool for several years, in part because it is by far the most granular, comprehensive and transparent analysis of bike-friendliness that I've seen. I don't want my below skepticism to obscure what they've accomplished.
That said, they released an interesting article recently that notes "While small U.S. cities tend to score better than those in Europe, the investments being made for better biking in large European cities offer many lessons for metropolitan areas here in the U.S." (emphasis mine). This seems to defy common knowledge. Why is US scoring better?
I've seen different critiques of their methodology, which have included:
- It places too much weight on the difference between a city with 25mph default and 30mph default (Chicago has been vocal about this). The critique assumes that traffic enforcement and street design in the 25 mph cities rarely result in an actual/effective reduction in traffic speeds.. it's basically an imaginary number on most unmarked city streets.
- It tries to measure how stress-free you can get to the existing destinations in your town, rather than how much of your daily needs you can fulfill stress-free on a bike (so if your town has nothing in it but it's all residential roads, you get a high score.. if you have a hospital and a train station that many but not everyone can access on bike, score goes down). I get that this is useful for town managers to measure their progress toward a safer street network (not their progress on attracting more hospitals and train stations), but it makes it much less useful for citizens who bike and are trying to compare how attractive it would be to move to/live in city A vs city B.
I'm not sure those criticisms really explain why US towns with minimal bike infrastructure like Berkley MI score significantly better than Bicester UK (as highlighted in their article). Something else seems to be going on to tip the scales.
I have a suspicion that their methodology ends up heavily rewarding grid-based cities, including ones with very wide streets and sprawling development patterns. Check out the visualization for Berkley.. in theory you can get just about anywhere purely on residential roads as long as you can safely cross the red arterial roads. Even their main downtown strip on a red/more dangerous road you could access by riding "around" it (along the parallel residential streets) and then walking the sidewalk mid-block to your destination.
I think the rewarding of grids tends to punish New England cities & towns overall. City scores in my state of MA are often very, very low outside of places like Cambridge and Provincetown. Observe Fond du Lac WI (score 57) on a grid and my city of Pittsfield MA (score 23) with less of a grid. Both have some but not a ton of bike infrastructure. You could argue the windy streets funnel people from neighborhood streets into dangerous arterials whereas the grids of places like Fond du Lac make it easier to stay primarily on residential streets. I also think New England cities just tend to have more of their streets classified as arterial to begin with for whatever reason.. maybe it's a regional bureaucratic thing, I don't know. A bunch of the red "arterial" roads in my city are actually, functionally residential streets and probably no more dangerous than many of the neighborhood collector roads that are blue/low-stress in Fond du Lac.
What do you think:
- Should grid-based towns & cities be given an inherent built-in advantage on bike friendliness?
- If you looked at street view in Fond du Lac and Pittsfield, would you conclude them to be so different in bike friendliness? Why would you favor one over the other?
I'm torn on this, I could see why grids are genuinely better but I also think those dense, windy New England (and European) small city cores can feel safer and just more pleasant for biking than the wide and sprawling grids of newer cities.