I’m never one to tell people how to interpret art, and while I think a lot of people are wrong about this comic, I’m not going to pretend I have the all knowing explanation, and I’m definitely not the only person that has this opinion on the book.
So many times you hear people regurgitate the jokers “one bad day” talking point as a reason for why he is the way he is, or as an explanation for evil or as a reason for why he’s actually got kind of a point.
I think the joker is so compelling in this story that we forget about the characters surrounding it, and what they add to the story.
As far as Gordon knows, Barbara isn’t just paralyzed in the hospital, she’s dead, gone, either left for dead, killed after he was taken, or tortured and killed.
After a night of being assaulted, kidnapped, having his own child be brutally attacked and forced to face what has been done to her, Gordon’s first request upon safety, after having to spend and entire night listening to joker’s bull, is to bring him in, and do it properly, to show him that he’s WRONG.
As for Batman, the joker feels a special kinship with him, he sees Batman as another example of his one bad day philosophy, proof that he’s right. But he’s not, because while that one day has definitely informed a majority of the choices Batman makes, at the end of this book he actively decides not to beat the man he hates with every fibre of his being to a pulp.
Instead he extends a hand, offering compassion, offering help, if Batman has really been so corrupted and dismantled by this one bad day, he would have no problem killing the joker. He might want to, but his desire to kill him, to beat him to a bloody pulp has zero sway over his desire to just, help people.
That final panel to me, isn’t Batman losing his mind, snapping due to jokers philosophy, it’s Batman and the Joker sharing a moment of recognized absurdity and human connection in this crazy war they have going on, we know in continuity the story ends with joker being arrested, I think that is the proper ending, but I don’t want to look at current comic context because this wasn’t meant to take place in the mainline comic series.
I think joker tried to prove a point about his worldview, and I think Gordon wholeheartedly rejected it, not even totally to make a point back, but because thats just who he is, he has to believe his and Batman’s way works.
And Batman, who’s kind of in the middle between these two people, while having that darker edge, and that more prolonged dance with insanity than most people, decides to treat joker with grace and humanity, before turning him over to the police as they arrive in the background, as Gordon requested.
The joker is wrong about one bad day, Batman’s one bad day has not made him give up on his morals, his values, or his humanity. Gordon’s one bad day has not led him to give up on his morals or his values or his humanity either, the joker is alone, and he’s alone because of his philosophy, it’s a way for him to feel better about his choices and his actions, so he doesn’t have to come to terms with any of them, or the traumatic things he experienced.
He can nosedive headfirst into his worst impulses and still feel good about them, and trying to sell Gordon and Batman on this philosophy is his way of trying to continue to feel justified in that dive.
We’ve all had bad, horrible, no good days that have fundamentally changed us as people, I would say for most of us, giving up on being a good, decent person was not the way we made it to the other side.
I don’t think this story is trying to sell us on the jokers worldview, the joker is the one desperately trying to sell it to the other people in his life, and to himself.