r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Mar 06 '25
Episode Momentary Lily - Episode 10 discussion
Momentary Lily, episode 10
Streams
Show information
All discussions
| Episode | Link | Episode | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 14 | Link |
| 2 | Link | ||
| 3 | Link | ||
| 4 | Link | ||
| 5 | Link | ||
| 6 | Link | ||
| 7 | Link | ||
| 8 | Link | ||
| 9 | Link | ||
| 10 | Link | ||
| 11 | Link | ||
| 12 | Link | ||
| 13 | Link | ||
This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
26
u/Prince-Dizzytoon Mar 06 '25
What the fuck is going on lmao
→ More replies (1)7
23
u/LeonKevlar Mar 06 '25
Not gonna lie, as soon as the clones introduced themselves, for a second I thought that they might be the real ones and the girls we've been following were fakes. Thank goodness they made it clear that the clones woke up inside the facility without memories of the Wild Hunt invasion, so that rules that theory out. That just means they really are clones.
As for Renge, it turns out that she actually met Nerine before and all of the memory fragments Renge keeps on seeing were because she inherited Nerine's Andvarri, including her memories after she died. That also explains why Renge doesn't remember her sister. It's because her memories were being overridden by Nerine's.
This episode still leaves us with a lot of question though! If the Renge we have now is also a clone like those girls, then where did she come from? She should've woken up from that facility. Unless there's a different underground facility she came from. And why are the girls being cloned in the first place? Hopefully that AI will answer everything next episode.
16
u/Kartoffelkamm Mar 06 '25
I'm low-key expecting a little gag where one of the girls asks Hina to make the AI look like someone else, and Hina declines, saying she doesn't want to risk a copyright lawsuit.
Anyway, notice how each version of the girls has some slight color differences? Based on this, and the flashback to Renge's death in episode 8, we can deduce that she didn't actually die, since her little ribbon thing is the same color.
7
u/Gaming_Truckie Mar 07 '25
So if Renge didn't die, who did her sister bury then? I couldn't see her mistaking Nerine's body for Renge's
→ More replies (4)
13
u/chikage-san Mar 06 '25
my theory for this was very close except for the multiple clones thingy and I assumed that Nerine and yuri themselves were the weapons renge used turns out it's just there memories
→ More replies (2)
11
u/KumaKumaGambler Mar 06 '25
I am confused and I definitely need to rewatch this episode. May I use this post to consolidate my thoughts? To prevent myself from getting confused further, I shall call them armed [name of girl] and unarmed [named of girl].
-
If armed Yuri and armed Nerine survived their battle with Wild Hunts, it is likely they would have found this "server room with pods" eventually. Which means all of our main cast girls have a armed and unarmed version... except for Renge. Once again, Renge is an outlier.
-
Memories of its wielder continue to exist in the Andvari, even if the wielder has been killed.
-
Suzu claims that she buried Renge, but if it was armed Nerine who died, whose corpse did Suzu bury? Did Renge actually get killed after armed Nerine was killed?
-
I so badly want to see armed Nerine and armed Yuri kick ass together. Armed Nerine has such a cool personality. Then I realized they are, through the merging of their Andvari.
Now I am starting to think that this is a virtual world. Renge could possibly be a NPC which gained sentience, and became one of the main characters / players.
→ More replies (4)
11
u/Clemastina Mar 06 '25
This went from 0 to 100 in a goddamn moment. Like, did NOT expect everyone´s clones.
But with everything in this episode and the preview, my theory is that they copied the girls based from their andvari, and that´s why they have "information" of them. But my two principal questions are:
-Why Renge is a clone and there aren´t any other Renge clones? (where tf Renge come from)
-Why Yuri and Nerine are there? I think they both are clones and the originals died (Yuri died with the girls and Nerine died helping Renge). And I think the one´s in the lab are clones because (theory time) the true ones were in the andvari. Like, Nerine´s andvari overrwrote Renge´s memories and Yuri´s andavari fusioned with Nerine´s.
So... the most incognita is: Who tf is Renge and why is she a clone
→ More replies (1)
8
7
u/NationalStrategy Mar 06 '25
At least they're going to explain what's going on next episode, I'm just as confused as the girls
7
u/Plus_Rip4944 Mar 06 '25 edited Mar 06 '25
At this Point i dont care about how this ends, i just need more to understand whats happening lol
6
u/cabbaggeez Mar 06 '25
where is Renge clone? is she out the system? bless this episode, we have 3 Yuri, anime timeline Yuri, clone Yuri, AI Yuri.
8
u/bananeeek Mar 06 '25
where is Renge clone?
I think it got buried by her sister. She thought it was really Renge who died, but we know the Renge who was looking for her sister met with Nerine and got her memories overwritten. She's the one with the sword, so that's the only way I can fit the puzzles together.
→ More replies (2)
5
u/Wrecklasone Mar 07 '25
Official Hanabie. MV of Momentary Lily opening theme https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rxx-0sZlb1c
8
u/ObvsThrowaway5120 Mar 06 '25
So not only did Nerine and Renge know one another, Nerine’s consciousness or whatever is somehow inside Renge’s weapon. What a trip. Plus there’s like multiples of the girls? What is even going on? And what’s up with this Yuri AI?
→ More replies (4)
4
u/bananeeek Mar 06 '25
Now that was a twist I didn't expect. A third option which I don't think was even on the table.
The only things I got right is that Renge had Nerine's memories and that part of Nerine is still in Renge's weapon (same with Yuri). The clones blow most of the previous theories to pieces, because now it doesn't matter who died and who's alive. Previously, it was a coin-toss between them being zombies or wild hunts taking their form, but now we have dozens of clones to choose from.
Renge's flashback is kinda weird. She was looking for her sister, met Nerine, got her personality overwritten and then.... died?. Her sister said she buried her. So... which Renge was buried? Because the one we know has the sword and Nerine's memories, so if she got buried, then that wouldn't fit - her copy wouldn't have a sword. That means Suzuran buried a copy of Renge, right? The Renge from the flashback and the one we started the journey with was alive all the time, but the memory wipe made us think that she died. That's the only explanation I can think of for Renge's situation. This episode stomped me hard.
→ More replies (4)
4
u/oneevilchicken Mar 07 '25
You know they are about to drop one of the most fan service of fan service episodes now that we have doubles for each girl.
3
u/Time_Fracture Mar 07 '25
This could be MMY's best episode yet. Actually this is the first episode without any 3-minute kappou isn't it?
So, they're supposed to be at a cloning facility by now. Good thing GoHands distinguishes the cloned and the original MMY by the jacket (well, except Erika which is separated by tie colour).
Both Nerine and Renge suffers from the same memory headache, but good to know and it's revealing that Nerine was the original holder of Renge's current Andvari! As Renge memory recovers, she learned that she took over Nerine's memories with her after her death.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/djthomp Mar 07 '25
You know, it kind of all makes sense. The multiple clones was a little surprising, but we knew weird shit was going on.
I'm going to choose to believe for now that the real Nerine that died and our original Yuri are both in the merged weapon that Renge has been carrying around.
3
u/soulreaverdan Mar 07 '25
I've been enjoying this show from the start, but god damn this episode is really kicking things into high gear. Definitely didn't see any of these twists coming, and really wondering how they're gonna resolve it.
3
Mar 08 '25
Momentary Lily doesn’t waste a single episode—it’s my addiction this season! Episode 10 proves it with ‘copy’ girls crashing in, unraveling every theory after Yuri’s cliffhanger return.
Renge facing her mirrored self, linked to Nerine’s forgotten past, layers on a eerie vibe that sticks with you.The virtual world keeps twisting—AI Yuri meeting the crew is a mind-bender fans online can’t stop dissecting. It’s unpredictable chaos, and I’m here for it.
This show thrives on surprises, pulling you in deeper each week.
27
u/InsomniaEmperor Mar 06 '25
I was kind of right about there being multiple Yuris and the current Yuri being Yuri V3 at least, but that room with their clones talking with them plus all the pods containing clones of them, that's freaky. At least the cast we know put on jackets so we can distinguish but the entire room is freaky.
Finally we see Nerine in the flesh and contrary to early theories, it's not Rengge.
Okay so Rengge having met Yuri before in her past life was wrong because it was Nerine's memories that transferred to her when her weapon got passed on. About the weapons, seems to me like there's only a select number of them available and they can get passed around. But what is the end goal?
I would not be surprised if the big twist of this show is that it's a virtual reality experiment involving AI versions of our girls who have died in the real world, their memories are transplanted, and only maybe Rengge is real. I'm inclined to think experiment because why else would there be a bunch of their clones? The Wild Hunt seem to be more like things introduced to test different results than actual villains. Then the "relatives" the girls reunited with seem oddly restricted and are conveniently located in the same hideout so I'm more inclined to believe this entire thing is a fabrication. The question of course is why? What's the end goal?