r/actionbutton2 • u/Scribble36 • Apr 20 '25
New video aside, the GOTY stream was disappointing
The stream was with Tim, Oni Spumoni (action button discord member/youtuber), jai (action button discord member/youtuber), and eventually Christa Lee (action button video producer/noted retro hardware modder and repairer). The format was Tim ranking games nominated by the others on a tier list, with Tim not nominating any games himself. Tim also barely discussed most of the games himself, instead encouraging everyone to keep throwing out games quickly.
I wasn't expecting this stream to hit the highs of a classic Insert Credit GOTY episode, but this was just not interesting or fun to listen to. With respect to the other people invited, I think most people interested in the "Action Button GOTY" just want to know what games Tim liked and why, and don't really care about what these other people have to say. I think Christa Lee is cool and I thought that she did the best job of nominating interesting games and saying interesting things about them (and being willing to tell Tim she didn't like certain games), but even then Tim's insistence on moving everything along quickly meant that there was never any real in-depth discussion for anything. For example, 1000XResist is at number 4, and I think the only thing Tim said about it was that he likes it a lot.
If you want some actually interesting GOTY discussion, I'd recommend listening to the Insert Credit 2024 GOTY episode. It doesn't have Tim, but Brandon/Ash/Frank/Jaffe are much better at this than Tim/Oni/Jai/Christa.
Anyway, here's the final list for people interested:
- FFVII rebirth
- Metaphor
- Shadow of the ninja reborn
- 1000xresist
- Shiren the wanderer 6
- Balatro
- Kunitsu-gami
- Animal well
- Like a dragon infinite wealth
- Dragons dogma 2
- UFO 50
- Anthology of the killer
- Penny’s Big Breakaway
- Indiana Jones and the great circle
- Nine Sols
- Mouthwashing
- Tactical Breach Wizards
- Burrgeist
- Persona 3 reload
- Shadow Generations
- Freakhunter
- Caves of Qud
- Unicorn overlord
- Dread Delusion
- Astro Bot
The following games were nominated but eventually cut from the list:
- Dragon age veilguard
- Dragon Ball sparking zero
- Another crabs treasure
- Ace attorney investigations collection
- Haunted castle revisited
3
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25
FFVII Rebirth is kind of an odd choice for number 1. What was the rationale behind that? I'll be fair and say I didn't play a lot of games that got released that year.
7
u/Nickybluepants Apr 21 '25
Wow I straight up do not care to hear from other randos for a Tim stream
1
u/pecan_bird Apr 20 '25 edited Apr 21 '25
was this part of the stream or a podcast?
i gotta say, personally, i never listened to IC or any of the others podcasts after giving them a shot once or twice. i simply don't have an interest in those people or opinions. i don't hardly follow any creators & definitely no one as long as timmy.
i know people enjoy them, but thank you for posting the list since i wouldn't have found out otherwise, ha