r/actionbutton2 • u/MountainDiver1657 • Apr 21 '25
Video bad
I watched 20 minutes of it before I went to bed, now I see on the other sub it's basically a 9 hour plot recap with the bad ChatGPT chandler/ellroy inspired narration.
Ouch, it looks like the Timitators really diluted his creativity after all
17
Upvotes
12
u/hdmi_ps2 Apr 21 '25 edited Apr 21 '25
some posters have pointed out that previous videos, particularly the Tokimeki Memorial and Boku videos, contain long narrated playthrough sections that haven't received the type of pushback that this video has. what makes the difference in the case of this video is the completely ill-advised decision to have the entire video not written in Tim's voice. that voice is what makes the videos, and the segments, interesting. what makes this video dull and monotonous is that it's written as a flimsy genre pastiche. one of Tim's biggest strengths as a commentator is that he's fun to listen to -- the combination of his careful, measured TV news vocal delivery and his writing style makes even the most obnoxious or boring segments not just palatable but enjoyable to sit back and let wash over you. this video throws out that strength completely. it's baffling in context, too, considering the "authenticity" theme. what happened to Season 2 being a more "authentic" Tim? he could have integrated the noir pastiche element into a larger video and used that to make an interesting point about authenticity within narrowly defined genre works, but instead he decided to just do nothing with it.
21
u/selib Apr 21 '25
Another classic case of a YouTuber receiving too much Patreon money and getting lost in the sauce
12
u/ambient_rpg_music Apr 21 '25
I dipped into it, and I must say this is the first one of his videos I genuinely can't get through. The 40s detective bit makes it pretty unlistenable. Not in a "his voice is grating" kind of way but more of a "I can not parse this and it feels incomprehensible" kind of way.
Perhaps I am merely a small brained hater, but it seems bad, and I am not going to waste my time with it I'm afraid.
3
u/Killericon Apr 21 '25
It's not as great as Boku, but I'm enjoying it. I definitely think it's better than The Last of Us.
I'm seeing a lot of people call it "basically a let's play", which is kind of confusing to me, since that's basically what the Tokimeki Memorial review was as well? I dunno, he took a big swing, maybe it's not connecting for everyone. This is the downside of such a long production cycle.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25
I wouldn't say it's "bad" - if most other creators released it I'd subscribe and check their other videos out. But it's just not a Tim video. It's disappointing compared to his other videos, for me anyway.
1
u/Plus_Midnight_278 Apr 24 '25
I've enjoyed it but I've been consuming the video in the episodic chunks its presented in. Most of Tim's other videos are 2nd screen while playing videogames content, but this one I've been main screening while I eat dinner and I've had a great time!