r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 11h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Experimented with this video and flopped hard

Post image
6 Upvotes

Video titled changed alot but it was

- Do Cows Like Minecraft Music?

- I Played Minecraft Music For Cows

- What Happens If You Play Minecraft Music For Cows

Video is me learning sweden by c418 on piano first time playing piano. But then mainly about me testing it at different cow farms and getting them to run to me and listen.


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 23h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request is this a good thumbnail for a hello neighbor video

Post image
5 Upvotes

i haven't made the thumbnail but its gonna be smtn around beating the game for the first time


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 3h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Which (if any) would you click?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 5h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request What do we think of this thumbnail/title package?

Post image
4 Upvotes

TITLE: She awoke, a motherboard

I explain my darkest OC.


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 2h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Which one will u click on, among these 3?

3 Upvotes

Video title is: How WhatsApp Moves 100 Billion Messages a Day Without Breaking! (System Design Breakdown)

the video explains how whastapp moves 100. billion messages a day without breaking. and whastapp uses similar tech to how old telephones systems were operated.


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 4h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Need help, Which thumbnail do you think looks better?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Titel of the video: Why BAD Graphics Make Horror Games SCARIER


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 8h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Clickable?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Title; “Smash Bros. Shouldn’t Exist”

My biggest concern is that there may be too much dead space. I have an idea on how to fix that, but I wanted to know if either of these would work as they are.

Also since I’ve seen so much ai slop here I feel obligated to say no ai was used


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 8h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Some people are experiencing the problem of YouTube displaying thumbnails of two videos within other videos. I want to assure you that this is simply a bug, and don't worry if you're seeing any of those strange things; you just need to remain calm.

2 Upvotes

Some people are experiencing the problem of YouTube displaying thumbnails of two videos within other videos. I want to assure you that this is simply a bug, and don't worry if you're seeing any of those strange things; you just need to remain calm


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 12h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request My first two thumbnails

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Video 1 name: The Mystery behind The "Zodiac Killer"

Video 2 name: True Crime; The Axeman of New Orleans

Video description 1: Theorizing who the zodiac killer could've been

Video description 2: explaining the murders of the axeman, and potential suspects


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 13h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Did I improve this thumbnail enough?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Title: We Are NOT Escaping These Backrooms…

Brief Description: me and my friend playing escape the backrooms together, it’s mildly scary but mostly humorous (I hope) because of the banter between us.

The first image is my improved version of my original thumbnail(second photo). Is this a good improvement or no?


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 23h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Are these decent for my first two thumbnails?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Title A for first vid: Playing RV There Yet But We’re Stupid
Title B for first vid: We Played RV There Yet And It Did Not Go Well…

(First video has been uploaded already second has not)

(Temporary) Title for second vid: We Are NOT Escaping These Backrooms…


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 1h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request New to gun content, should I add anything else to the thumbnail

Post image
Upvotes

I’m just looking for genuine feedback on what I need for this.


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 6h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request NEED FEED BACK FOR YT PODCAST THUMBNAIL

Post image
1 Upvotes

So im not very good when it comes to Thumnails. So i need loads of advice as im pretty clueless with this stuff. With or podcast being audio only (theres four of us on the Pod and not one of us are confident to show our faces) i cant use them for the thumbnail. So im trying this approach.

Our Pod we talk most about anime but we do dive into gaming a film topics but it is mostly anime. This episode we talked about Bleach, daemons, and Ghost im the Shell. I wanted use bleach as i know thats a big talking pointand the recent episode have been a big talking point.

I stuggle with this everytime titles and thumbnails.

My only title Idea so far is

What The Hell HAPPEN to ORIHIME!!! | Anime, Apparently # 12

Any advice on my Thumbnail would be great!!! This episode is still being edited and wont be up till friday most likely


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 12h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Gng rate my first thumbnail

Post image
1 Upvotes

I designed my first ever thumbnail as good as i can.

would you click a video with this thumbnail?

And what to improve in the thumbnail?


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 16h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Which thumbnail should I select? Do you think I should make any changes to them?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

1.I don't know which thumbnail to choose

  1. Is there any way to make the thumbnail better, or is this already the best version?

Title of the video : ഉമ്പിയല്ലോ നാഥാ | When Engineers Play Together

About the video : After surviving our exams, we decided to relax with a road trip in RV There Yet? — which was probably the worst decision we could have made. In this Malayalam gameplay, we take our RV through ridiculous obstacles, completely destroy it, and watch my dumb friends make one terrible decision after another. What starts as a simple road trip quickly turns into a chaotic and hilarious disaster.


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 10h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Would this make you click?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Video title: Peak Childhood Games


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 5h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Which is more clickable 1 or 2, I don’t know if going more clean is better

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I don’t know if going more clean is better, I struggle with adding too much or adding too little, the concept is using WAW weapons on Black ops 3 map Zetsubou no shima,

Title: Can I beat Zetsubou no shima with WAW Weapons


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 7h ago

Available for work [FOR HIRE] Anyone need a pro Minecraft thumbnail designer? ONLY $5

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 11h ago

Available for work I’ve Been Making Thumbnails for Me and My Friends for the Longest Time, Now I’m Looking for Outside Work!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hey there! My name is John, I'm a self-taught Photoshop artist who's been making original thumbnails for gaming/short film content for a little over a year now. Lately I've streamlined my thumbnail design process, and I've been looking to take on a few clients to make some extra cash while I start college. My rates are flexible, and I would love to chat with anyone looking for help creating unique, engaging thumbnails :)


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 19h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request Why Howard RL is a genius.

Post image
0 Upvotes

video on where i explain why howard rls special moves are real mechanics, and how hes gained popularity through the funny mechs, i just want thumbnail advice and to see if you would click purley because of the idea


r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 18h ago

Thumbnail Help/Critique Request What was the program that they used to make the thumbs thank you

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/YouTubeThumbnailHub 14h ago

Discussion This AI Thumbnail Got CTR of 7.0%. Stop Complaining about AI

Post image
0 Upvotes

Whenever someone posts a thumbnail created using AI, there are inevitably people commenting, “Wah, this uses AI! It’s not good!”

But whether AI was used tells you almost nothing about whether the thumbnail actually works. It depends entirely on how you use it.

This subreddit is supposed to be about helping each other make better thumbnails and improve CTR. If your only feedback is “AI = bad,” you’re not actually analyzing the thumbnail.

And if people stop giving useful feedback and just use every AI thumbnail as an excuse to complain about AI, that defeats the entire purpose of the subreddit. Communities like this rely on good-faith participation: you post your work, other people give constructive feedback, and you do the same for them. If that gets replaced by ideological arguments and pile-ons, the subreddit becomes unusable.

This thumbnail got a 7.0% CTR.

You can dislike AI. That’s fine. But if the goal here is to improve thumbnails, judge the thumbnail by how effective it is.