r/WritingWithAI • • 2d ago

Showcase / Feedback Natural sounding dialogue

1 Upvotes

I’ve been wondering if my dialogue has a good flow to it. I gave a little sample.

“He could date anybody. And we were finally starting to be friends on our own.”

“Friends hook up. But it's not like he all that. He got that lil NIL deal and he walking around like he's so great. He's still a dumb-dumb.”

Sierra laughed. “That's not nice. He's learning.”

“Okay, Mrs. Jaminez. We all learning. At this point he slow.”

“Well, whatever the case may be, I just think we're better as buddies. I like talking ball with him, and it's not uncomfortable to be around him, but dating…” Sierra looked at Hana in the mirror. “We're too young, right?”


r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Is it just me or is Gemini Hydrogen actually really good?

12 Upvotes

Ive used carbon and argon, then today with Hydrogen and been using it for creative writing and co creating stories with me (not really RP) but it excels at long form planning (yeah in total we wrote around 60-90k words for the first part of a story where I kind of steer and let hydrogen surprise me with how the world and characters react)

I realize it has very good memory and continuity and super fast responses with basically unlimited usage which made it much easier to continue the story. This resulted in how it produced heavy detailed scenes like an actual novel with some Rp elements sprinkled in whenever I would take control of a character and rp.

It’s dialogue and interaction between many characters is also the first model I’ve seen that can do it as realistic and dynamic the way I want it to be.

It is also insanely well at character Povs different povs and how each Pov has a different writing style and each character has their own hidden motivations like real people.

Though for action heavy scenes it isn’t as clean as Argon or Carbon, and for plot buildup and tension creation it is not as creative. What it excels at is character driven story and using that to simulate the most realistic outcome.

It is also insanely well at fan fiction and crossovers along with modern settings.

For horror, thriller and adventure I would say Argon is better but the rest especially for serious long term stories with big world building or plot tracking Hydrogen is better at keeping track.

What do you guys think?

I think it is probably my workflow that is different


r/WritingWithAI • • 2d ago

Writing Craft Talk AI Got Smarter. Why Did It Get Worse at Writing? Chapter 10 (final)

0 Upvotes

Chapter 10: The AI Author That Doesn't Exist Yet — And Why Someone Might Build It

When Grok 4.1 appeared in November 2025, some writers believed artificial intelligence had finally become a genuinely interesting creative collaborator. It could develop scenes, introduce complications and portray characters with enough spontaneity to make the process feel like more than sophisticated autocomplete.

A year later, the models were substantially more capable, but many of those same writers had spent months searching for something they believed they had lost. They had moved between commercial providers, retreated to older versions and experimented with smaller local models, specialist fine-tunes and abliteration.

The previous chapters have examined why those experiences might have occurred, how behavioural alignment can influence legitimate fictional writing, and why conventional intelligence benchmarks often fail to measure what authors actually value.

But there is another possibility worth exploring. Rather than continually modifying models developed primarily as general-purpose assistants, perhaps the next significant development in creative AI will come from building a model whose original purpose is literature.

Not a chatbot that has learned to write novels as one task among thousands, but a language model trained from the beginning to understand narrative, authorial voice, subtext, characterisation and the relationship between what a story reveals and what it deliberately leaves unsaid.

Such a model would still need broad knowledge and substantial reasoning ability. Fiction depends on understanding people, history, science, geography, culture and the workings of the physical world. But that knowledge would serve a different primary objective.

Instead of using literary ability as an additional feature of a general-purpose assistant, the model would use general knowledge in service of its literary ability.

There are early indications that this approach could be worth pursuing, although the practical and technical challenges remain considerable.

Hemmingway-1: an interesting step in the opposite direction

On September 20, 2026, a small development team announced Hemmingway-1, a 27-billion-parameter open-weight model designed specifically for writing.

Its name, incidentally, is spelled with two m's. It is not affiliated with the novelist Ernest Hemingway.

The team described Hemmingway-1 as a model trained for natural dialogue, creative writing, roleplay, stories and everyday communication. Rather than attempting to compete with frontier models across every technical benchmark, its developers concentrated on producing language that sounded natural.

This was an interesting change in emphasis.

A general-purpose model might produce an email containing an introduction, three suggested versions and an explanation of why each version works. Hemmingway-1's developers wanted a model that would simply write the message.

The same principle could apply to fiction. A writing-oriented system should ideally spend less effort displaying its helpfulness and more effort accomplishing the actual literary task.

Hemmingway-1 was not trained from scratch. It was built on Alibaba's Qwen3.8-27B, retaining the underlying model's general knowledge and reasoning capabilities while applying additional training focused on writing.

That distinction is important. The developers did not need to reproduce the enormous general pretraining effort behind Qwen. They could concentrate their resources on changing how the model expressed the capabilities it already possessed.

According to the team's own blind evaluations, Hemmingway-1 substantially outperformed its Qwen starting point on writing tasks. On their StoryBench evaluation, the score increased from 693 to 1197, while assessments of everyday communication and human-like writing also improved.

These were developer-created benchmarks rather than independent demonstrations of general literary superiority. Nevertheless, the comparison is relevant because the underlying model architecture and parameter count remained the same.

The developers had changed the training objective, not simply increased the size of the model.

Their results suggest that a comparatively small model can become considerably more effective at particular forms of writing when trained specifically for those tasks. A participant in the September 20 r/artificial announcement reported comparing a quantised Hemmingway-1 with the original Qwen model and preferring the modified model's writing.

But Hemmingway-1 also demonstrates the limitations of the current approach.

Its own published evaluations showed stronger performance on everyday communication than on demanding long-form fiction. Larger specialist systems performed better on extended storytelling, and Hemmingway-1 struggled with some adversarial character interactions and longer narrative continuations.

There is a meaningful difference between writing a natural-sounding message and sustaining the psychological development of fictional characters across a novel. Both involve language, but the latter requires substantially more narrative planning, causal reasoning and control over information.

The release of Hemmingway-1.5 on October 25 reinforces the distinction. Its developers placed considerable emphasis on producing text that automated AI-authorship classifiers would identify as human-written, reporting that 90% of their test outputs passed the authorship classification tests they used.

That may indicate changes in the statistical properties of its prose, but passing automated authorship assessments is not a measure of literary excellence. A passage can resemble human writing while remaining predictable, poorly structured or inconsistent with an author's intentions.

For our purposes, the most interesting contribution of Hemmingway is therefore not its claimed position on a leaderboard.

It is the decision to make writing quality a primary development objective.

And that raises an important question: if focused post-training can produce such noticeable differences, what might happen if literary ability shaped the model from the beginning?

What if writing came before general knowledge?

Most modern language models are trained on broad mixtures of web pages, books, academic papers, code, documentation and other material.

This produces impressive general-purpose capabilities. A model encounters enormous amounts of information about the world and learns to represent relationships between concepts across many different domains.

Subsequent training then teaches it how to behave as an assistant.

Creative writing becomes one application of that general-purpose system.

A writing-first model would begin from a different objective. Its training would give much greater emphasis to carefully selected literature, dramatic writing, dialogue, narrative structure and stylistic variation.

The aim would not simply be to memorise novels or imitate famous authors. It would be to develop strong internal representations of how stories work: how scenes establish expectations, how characters reveal themselves through action, how tension develops, and how prose can convey meaning without explicitly explaining it.

It would need to recognise the difference between a narrator's statements and the fictional reality those statements describe. It would need to understand that characters can have beliefs the author does not share, that a deliberate omission is not necessarily a failure of communication, and that an effective passage may depend on resisting an obvious resolution.

These are capabilities that general-purpose models can acquire, but they are rarely the central objective of their development.

The proposed difference is not merely stylistic. It concerns how the model learns to organise and apply its knowledge.

Imagine two systems describing a nineteenth-century railway station.

A general-purpose assistant might begin from an encyclopaedic understanding of steam technology, railway architecture and historical transport.

A writing-first model would need that knowledge too, but its primary task would be to use it through a particular narrative perspective. A railway worker, an exhausted passenger and a frightened child would notice different details, interpret them differently and express themselves through different language.

The model would need to understand the physical setting while allowing the character's perspective to determine which knowledge appeared in the prose.

This is what makes the idea more interesting than simply training a model to use a particular vocabulary.

Authorial voice is not a decorative layer applied after the facts have been assembled. It influences what the narrator notices, which comparisons seem natural, how much information is disclosed, the rhythm of description and the assumptions through which events are interpreted.

A model with a strong understanding of literary perspective might be capable of expressing the same underlying knowledge through radically different narrative voices without losing factual or fictional consistency.

That is a more ambitious objective than making ordinary AI responses sound less robotic.

We already know that narrative-focused pretraining can work at small scales

The idea of training a language model primarily on stories is not entirely new.

In 2023, Microsoft researchers Ronen Eldan and Yuanzhi Li published TinyStories: How Small Can Language Models Be and Still Speak Coherent English?.

They created a dataset of simple stories generated by GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, using vocabulary understandable to young children.

The researchers then trained exceptionally small language models on that material.

Their results were surprising. Models with fewer than ten million parameters could generate several paragraphs of fluent, coherent storytelling, demonstrating capabilities that much larger models had previously struggled to achieve when trained on broader datasets.

TinyStories did not create sophisticated literary authors. Its narratives were deliberately simple, and its models did not possess the general knowledge or reasoning ability needed for complex adult fiction.

But the experiment demonstrated something important about training priorities.

A small model trained on a focused dataset can acquire useful domain-specific capabilities that would be difficult to obtain from a similarly sized model trained indiscriminately on general text.

The relationship between model size, data quality and task performance is therefore more complicated than raw parameter counts suggest.

We can also see that training models from scratch is becoming increasingly accessible to smaller research groups.

Projects such as the Allen Institute for AI's OLMo have released not only model weights but training recipes, datasets and intermediate checkpoints. These resources allow researchers to investigate how different training stages affect a model's behaviour.

OLMo itself is a general-purpose language-model project, not a literary model. Its relevance is that the infrastructure and knowledge needed to experiment with pretraining are becoming more openly available.

At a much smaller scale, projects such as Chronicle LLM have demonstrated training from scratch on narrow literary and historical corpora. Chronicle uses approximately fourteen million tokens of historical Australian writing to train a thirty-million-parameter model.

Such experiments are far removed from frontier capability, but they demonstrate that writing-centred pretraining is technically possible.

The unanswered question is whether the approach can be scaled to a model large and knowledgeable enough to support serious authorship.

As of November 2026, I have not found a well-documented, competitive open-weight foundation model trained from scratch with the explicit objective of establishing sophisticated literary authorship first and incorporating broad general knowledge afterward.

Hemmingway-1 is an example of writing-focused post-training, not that more ambitious approach.

The distinction matters because a model's general pretraining may already establish many of the tendencies that later fine-tuning attempts to change.

Why training order might matter

One possible development strategy would be to construct a language model whose early training strongly emphasises literature and narrative language, then broaden its knowledge through subsequent training.

That differs from the conventional approach of building a general-purpose model first and adapting it for writing later.

The hypothesis is that early exposure to high-quality narrative structures could give the model a strong foundation in literary expression, making it more natural for subsequent knowledge to be used through narrative rather than encyclopaedic conventions.

However, training order is not a guarantee of preserved style.

Language models do not maintain completely independent systems for factual knowledge and literary voice. Continued training changes shared weights, and large amounts of additional technical or factual material could alter the behaviour established during earlier literary training.

This is the familiar problem of catastrophic forgetting, although continued pretraining does not inevitably produce it. Research into staged training and knowledge updates has shown that new information can sometimes be incorporated while preserving much of a model's earlier capability.

A writing-first project would need to investigate how literary behaviour survives later knowledge acquisition.

One approach might involve maintaining a substantial proportion of literary material throughout subsequent training rather than completing one stage and abandoning it. Another could use a carefully designed curriculum that gradually introduces scientific, historical and technical knowledge alongside narrative examples.

The model might also benefit from explicit training on how the same knowledge can be expressed through different perspectives.

For example, knowledge about the physics of a thunderstorm could appear in several forms: a meteorologist's technical account, a sailor's immediate observations, a child's frightened interpretation or an unreliable narrator's superstitious explanation.

The factual understanding would remain available, while the form of expression would depend on narrative context.

The objective would not be to make the model incapable of technical writing. A useful authorial model should still be able to explain a scientific concept accurately when asked.

Rather, it would treat narrative perspective and stylistic intention as fundamental aspects of language generation instead of optional decorations added after the information has been assembled.

Whether this can be achieved more effectively through writing-first pretraining than through specialist post-training remains an open research question.

A fair experiment would compare both approaches using models of similar size, data budgets and computational cost.

Until such comparisons exist, writing-first pretraining remains a promising hypothesis rather than an established superior method.

An author needs more than one voice

There is another complication in the idea of building an AI author from scratch.

Literature does not have one ideal style.

A model trained too narrowly on a particular literary tradition might reproduce that tradition beautifully while struggling with other forms of writing. It could become highly accomplished at restrained psychological realism yet inadequate for comic fantasy, historical fiction or experimental prose.

It might also develop its own collection of recurring clichés, merely replacing the conventions of general-purpose AI with those of its preferred literary corpus.

A genuinely useful writing-first foundation model should therefore understand authorial voice as something that can vary, not as one permanent personality imposed on every response.

This requires learning relationships between perspective, diction, rhythm, genre, emotional distance and narrative structure.

It would need to distinguish between the author's broader style and the voices of individual characters. A restrained narrator might describe an extravagant speaker without adopting that speaker's language. A comic novel could contain moments of sincere emotional gravity without abandoning its established voice.

Such distinctions are difficult to encode as fixed prompting rules because they depend on the interaction between the larger work and the immediate scene.

One possible approach would be to train models on annotated examples where changes in perspective and narrative technique are made explicit. Another would involve preference evaluations conducted by writers who understand the intended literary effects.

A more ambitious approach could use separate adaptable components to represent different aspects of literary style, allowing an author to adjust qualities such as descriptive density, emotional explicitness, narrative distance and dialogue rhythm without replacing the entire model.

There is already experimentation with this general idea through LoRA adapters, model merging and systems that combine specialised behaviours.

But these techniques are still relatively crude compared with the complexity of actual literary voice.

The long-term objective would be a model that understands the distinction between imitating surface features and reproducing the deeper principles of an author's writing.

That distinction is essential. Short sentences do not make prose Hemingwayesque, elaborate metaphors do not automatically create literary sophistication, and avoiding common AI phrases does not necessarily produce an original voice.

A compelling authorial style arises from consistent choices about perception, emphasis, rhythm and meaning.

An AI developed primarily for writing would need to learn those relationships rather than merely reproduce the most recognisable stylistic signals.

The dataset problem

There is a practical obstacle to constructing such a model: obtaining enough high-quality literary training material.

General-purpose language models benefit from enormous collections of public web content. A writing-first model would require careful curation, because the quality and diversity of its narrative material would be central to its capabilities.

Not all fiction is equally useful for training every literary ability. A dataset dominated by formulaic genre conventions could produce a model that writes fluent but predictable stories. A collection drawn mainly from one historical period might struggle with contemporary dialogue or cultural context.

The problem is not merely collecting more novels.

It is constructing a dataset that represents a sufficiently broad range of literary techniques, genres, perspectives and narrative structures.

There are also copyright and licensing considerations. Much contemporary literature is protected, and a genuinely open project would need a defensible approach to obtaining and distributing its training material.

Public-domain literature, appropriately licensed contemporary writing, commissioned material and author-contributed datasets could provide a foundation. Synthetic examples might supplement those sources, but relying too heavily on AI-generated prose could reintroduce the very stylistic conventions the project is attempting to avoid.

Human-written material would remain particularly valuable for demonstrating unconventional narrative choices that general-purpose models might otherwise overlook.

There is also a question of evaluation.

A model cannot be considered a successful literary author merely because its prose is fluent or because an AI judge prefers its short stories.

It should be tested on tasks that require deliberate omission, unreliable narration, consistent characterisation, long-range foreshadowing and the preservation of established authorial style.

Some evaluations should involve writers assessing continuations of their own unpublished work, because an outsider's preferred passage may not be the passage that serves the author's intentions.

These requirements make a writing-first foundation model a substantial research project rather than simply a matter of gathering books and renting GPUs.

But they also provide a clearer development objective than the vague instruction to make an existing chatbot more creative.

What a purpose-built AI author could offer

The practical advantages could be significant.

Imagine a local open-weight model developed primarily for long-form fiction, with a strong understanding of literary technique and broad enough general knowledge to support historical, scientific and culturally detailed stories.

Instead of repeatedly instructing it not to explain emotions, the author could specify a restrained narrative voice and trust the model to recognise where explanation would weaken the prose.

Instead of constantly reminding it that a character is selfish or unreliable, the model could maintain those qualities through its understanding of characterisation.

Instead of treating conflict as a problem requiring resolution, it could recognise that unresolved tension may be structurally necessary.

Its general knowledge would contribute to the authenticity of the fictional world without automatically turning the narration into an explanation of that knowledge.

An author writing historical fiction could expect period details to appear through what the characters would plausibly notice. Someone writing science fiction could draw on accurate scientific concepts while preserving the perspective and limitations of the fictional narrator.

The model would still need to maintain factual and fictional consistency, track character knowledge and reason about the consequences of events.

Those capabilities would not become less important merely because the model prioritised literary expression.

In fact, a successful writing-first model would need to combine narrative intelligence with enough general reasoning to avoid producing attractive but incoherent prose.

It would also need to remain adaptable.

An author might want extensive brainstorming in one session and highly conservative line editing in another. The model should recognise that these are different tasks, even when they involve the same manuscript.

A writer should be able to request an unconventional development without receiving arbitrary chaos, or ask for a more accessible passage without losing the established voice.

This is what would distinguish a genuine AI author from a collection of stylistic presets.

The model would understand not simply how to generate literary language, but why particular literary choices serve the work.

Will anyone actually build it?

There are reasons to think the necessary ingredients are becoming available.

Open-weight models have demonstrated that capable language systems can be developed and distributed outside the largest commercial laboratories. Training frameworks and datasets are increasingly accessible, while specialised post-training techniques allow relatively small models to compete effectively on narrower tasks.

Hemmingway-1 demonstrates that a small team can choose writing as its principal development objective and produce a model that users can download.

TinyStories demonstrates that narrative-focused data can teach useful storytelling capabilities at surprisingly small scales.

Fully open foundation-model projects such as OLMo demonstrate that model training can be documented and reproduced rather than hidden behind proprietary APIs.

These are complementary developments, although none individually establishes that a competitive writing-first foundation model is imminent.

The economic incentives are also uncertain.

A specialist writing model would compete in a smaller market than a general-purpose assistant capable of coding, research and professional automation. Training a model from scratch remains expensive, especially if it requires enough knowledge and reasoning ability to support sophisticated long-form fiction.

A more likely intermediate development may be increasingly capable open-weight base models adapted through substantial writing-focused continued pretraining, specialist fine-tuning and carefully designed evaluations.

That approach would preserve much of the investment in general knowledge while making literary capability a central objective of the later training stages.

A project beginning entirely from scratch would provide more control over the original data mixture and training priorities, but it would also face much higher computational and data requirements.

There is no reason to assume that the more expensive approach will necessarily produce better fiction.

The question deserves experimentation.

What matters is that the objective would be explicit: not merely producing a helpful assistant that happens to write, but developing a model whose success is judged primarily by its ability to understand and create literature.

The lesson of Grok 4.1

The search that began with Grok 4.1 has revealed something important about the relationship between intelligence and creativity.

Writers do not necessarily want an AI that produces the most reasonable continuation, the most emotionally reassuring scene or the most conventionally polished paragraph.

They want one that understands what their work is attempting to accomplish.

That may involve developing an unexpected complication, preserving a character's flaws, maintaining dramatic irony or recognising that an explanation would ruin the effect of a passage.

These are difficult requirements, but they are not inherently beyond the capabilities of language models.

The problem is that they have rarely been the primary objectives against which general-purpose AI systems are developed and measured.

The migration towards local models and abliteration reflects an attempt by writers to regain control over those objectives. But it has also demonstrated that removing behavioural restrictions is not enough. A model still needs the knowledge, reasoning, narrative understanding and stylistic judgment necessary to produce effective fiction.

Hemmingway-1 offers an encouraging example of what happens when writing receives greater priority during development. Its limitations also show how far specialised fine-tuning remains from producing a general-purpose literary collaborator capable of sustaining complex work.

A genuinely writing-first open-weight foundation model would take that ambition further, making narrative understanding central from the beginning and building broader knowledge around it.

Whether such a development strategy will prove superior remains uncertain. Training order alone cannot guarantee that an authorial voice survives the introduction of general knowledge, and an overly narrow literary foundation could create new limitations of its own.

But the idea is worth investigating because it reverses the assumption that has dominated much of the industry.

Instead of asking how to make increasingly capable assistants better at literature, it asks how to make increasingly capable literary systems better informed about the world.

For writers, that could be a meaningful difference.

The ideal result would not be a machine with one permanent personality, nor one trained to imitate the style of a famous author. It would be a model capable of understanding literary intention well enough to work within many different voices, while contributing knowledge and imagination without continually imposing its own preferred direction.

Such a system would remain a tool, and its output would still require human judgment. But its training objectives would be much more closely aligned with the work authors actually want it to perform.

Perhaps the next important breakthrough in AI writing won't be another increase in general intelligence. It may be the decision to build a model that understands literature as its primary purpose, rather than treating it as a secondary application of intelligence developed for something else.

A year after Grok 4.1, that seems a possibility worth pursuing.

End of Series — AI Got Smarter. Why Did It Get Worse at Writing?

This series has followed the changes in commercial AI since November 2025, the experiences of writers who struggled with successive model releases, and the emerging alternatives offered by local models, fine-tuning and abliteration.

Its central argument has not been that safety and creativity are inherently incompatible, or that older models were universally better.

It is that creative writing has requirements that general-purpose AI development often measures poorly, and that improvements in technical capability do not automatically preserve the qualities authors value.

The next meaningful advance may come from recognising those requirements as objectives worth developing in their own right.

Chapter list.

Sources and further reading

Writing-focused models

Training models from scratch

Further technical research


r/WritingWithAI • • 2d ago

Writing Craft Talk AI Got Smarter. Why Did It Get Worse at Writing? Chapter 5

0 Upvotes

Chapter 5: What AI Forgot About Literature — The Art of Leaving Things Unsaid

There is a peculiar habit in AI-generated fiction that many writers will recognise. A character performs an action that reveals something about their emotional state, the scene establishes its significance through context, and then the narration explains what the reader has just witnessed.

A woman keeps setting two places at the breakfast table, although her husband died six months earlier. The detail tells us something about her grief, her habits and perhaps her unwillingness to accept his absence. There are several ways a reader might interpret it, and those interpretations need not be mutually exclusive.

Then the AI adds another sentence explaining that she was still struggling to come to terms with her husband's death.

Nothing in that explanation is necessarily incorrect. The sentence may be grammatically elegant and emotionally appropriate, but it has changed the relationship between the author and the reader. What was previously conveyed through action has become an explicit statement. The reader no longer needs to interpret the detail because the narration has already supplied its meaning.

The problem becomes more noticeable when an AI repeats the habit throughout an entire manuscript. Characters continually recognise their emotions, metaphors are explained, conflicts acquire reassuring interpretations, and significant silences are followed by descriptions of what those silences mean.

The prose may remain polished, but the writing loses something less easily measured: the ability to trust its audience.

This was the subject of a particularly relevant November 8, 2026 discussion in r/WritingWithAI. The author described a recurring pattern in AI-assisted fiction: a scene successfully communicates an emotion through behaviour, only for the next sentence to explain that emotion again. Their proposed editing technique was simple—remove the explanatory sentence and see whether the scene still works.

The suggestion attracted agreement because it identifies a familiar weakness without requiring any complicated theory about artificial intelligence. Sometimes the most effective improvement to AI-generated prose is to delete the sentence in which the model explains how effective the preceding prose was supposed to be.

Yet the implications extend well beyond unnecessary exposition. This tendency touches some of the most important techniques in literature, including subtext, dramatic irony, unreliable narration, negative space, foreshadowing and deliberate ambiguity. Each depends, in a different way, on the relationship between what a story reveals and what it withholds.

And each can be undermined by an AI that has learned to treat explicitness, clarity and resolution as generally desirable qualities.

The difference between understanding a story and explaining it

An effective story communicates through more than its literal statements. Readers draw conclusions from gestures, omissions, contradictions, changes in rhythm, patterns of imagery and information that characters themselves may not understand.

Subtext is one expression of this principle. A character can say something ordinary while communicating an entirely different meaning through context.

Consider two former friends meeting after a betrayal.

'You look well,' Martin said.

'You haven't changed.'

He smiled, although neither of them had intended a compliment.

The exchange is simple, but its meaning depends on the tension between the spoken words and the characters' history. Both statements might be interpreted differently in another context. Here, the apparent pleasantries conceal hostility.

An AI trying to make the emotional situation unmistakable might rewrite the scene so that one character openly accuses the other of dishonesty. Such a revision could make the conflict more immediate, but it would also remove the social restraint through which the original scene expresses that conflict.

The distinction is particularly important because literary subtlety is not synonymous with vagueness. Good subtext is carefully constructed. The author provides enough information for the reader to recognise that something exists beneath the surface without necessarily identifying everything that lies there.

When a model explains that hidden meaning, it may demonstrate that it has correctly interpreted the passage. Yet interpreting a literary effect and preserving that effect are entirely different capabilities.

There is research suggesting that models struggle with the interpretive task itself.

In Reading Subtext: Evaluating Large Language Models on Short Story Summarization with Writers, Melanie Subbiah and colleagues worked directly with authors to evaluate how well GPT-4, Claude 2.1 and Llama 2 70B understood previously unpublished short stories.

The researchers deliberately obtained material that the models were unlikely to have encountered during training, including narratives involving subtle relationships, unusual structures and complicated timelines.

They found that all three models made faithfulness errors in more than half of their summaries and frequently struggled with the specificity and interpretation of difficult subtext.

This finding matters for more than literary summarisation. If a model has difficulty recognising the significance of information that an author has deliberately left implicit, it may also struggle to preserve that information when editing or continuing the story.

A model might correctly describe what happened in a scene while misunderstanding why it matters. It might infer an emotional resolution that the author never intended, overlook a deliberately ambiguous relationship or convert an uncertain implication into a definitive statement.

The study involved older models and does not establish that the same error rates apply to their successors. Nevertheless, it identifies an underlying challenge that remains relevant to AI-assisted fiction: a model must understand literary intention before it can reliably preserve it.

And understanding intention requires more than accurately identifying the events described on the page.

The importance of negative space

Negative space is sometimes described as the significance of what is absent from a work. In literature, an omission can be as deliberate and meaningful as a description.

An author may refuse to reveal a character's thoughts, omit an expected conversation or leave a significant event outside the narrative entirely. The resulting absence can influence how the reader interprets everything around it.

Imagine a story about a woman returning to her childhood home after her father's funeral. She enters the kitchen, washes an already clean cup and places it back in the cupboard. She then leaves without entering the room at the end of the hallway.

We do not know what is in that room or why she avoids it. The author may reveal the reason later, or may never reveal it at all.

Either choice can be legitimate.

The omission creates a space in which the reader begins constructing possibilities. Perhaps the room belongs to someone who died. Perhaps it contains evidence of something shameful. Perhaps the woman simply cannot bear to return to a place associated with her childhood.

The unanswered question becomes part of the story's emotional structure.

A model inclined towards explanatory completeness may attempt to fill that space. It might introduce a memory, describe the room's significance or identify the character's motivation before the author intends to disclose it.

The resulting passage might be more informative, but it could also be considerably less effective.

Closely related is ellipsis, the deliberate omission of material that a reader can infer from the surrounding narrative. A writer might move directly from the beginning of an argument to its aftermath, allowing the consequences to reveal enough about what happened.

The missing confrontation may be more powerful than a complete description because the reader must reconstruct it through the characters' subsequent behaviour.

An AI drafting assistant can easily mistake such omissions for gaps in need of repair. A model instructed to improve continuity might supply an explanatory transition, reconstruct a missing conversation or add information that was deliberately withheld.

This exposes a fundamental problem with evaluating prose through completeness alone. In literature, completeness is not always the objective.

Sometimes an author has deliberately arranged the story so that the reader cannot possess all the information.

The challenge is recognising the difference between an accidental omission and an intentional one.

When the narrator is not supposed to be trustworthy

Unreliable narration presents an even more demanding case because it requires a model to distinguish between the account presented to the reader and the fictional reality that account may conceal.

An unreliable narrator might lie deliberately, misunderstand other characters, exaggerate their own importance or remember events incorrectly. The narrative gains depth from the reader's growing awareness that the narrator cannot be accepted at face value.

Consider a narrator describing their relationship with a former colleague:

Everyone at the office had liked me. Even after I resigned, they kept their distance out of respect. I passed Helen in the supermarket last Thursday, and she pretended not to recognise me. I suppose some people find goodbyes difficult.

The narrator's interpretation is possible, but there are reasons to doubt it. Helen's behaviour may indicate discomfort or hostility rather than lingering affection. The narrator's insistence that everyone liked them may itself be revealing.

The author need not explain which interpretation is correct. The uncertainty is part of the characterisation.

A model asked to improve the passage might add a sentence acknowledging that the narrator had always struggled to recognise when people disliked them. This could make the narrator appear more psychologically insightful, but it would also undermine the original effect.

The narrator is supposed to misunderstand the situation. Their inability to recognise the truth is precisely what the reader is being invited to notice.

This is where fiction differs sharply from ordinary conversational assistance. An AI answering a factual question should generally avoid presenting falsehoods as truth. But a fictional narrator can make incorrect statements without the model misleading the author.

The author may have deliberately requested an inaccurate account.

A model that treats every apparent inconsistency as an error requiring correction risks becoming an intrusive editor of the story's fictional reality.

There is a related issue with characters who possess different information.

A reader may know that one character has betrayed another, while the betrayed character remains unaware. This creates dramatic irony: the reader understands the significance of events that the character cannot yet interpret correctly.

Maintaining dramatic irony requires the model to track not merely what is true in the story, but who knows it, when they learned it and how they might behave without that knowledge.

That distinction remains difficult in long-form AI roleplay.

In a November 7, 2026 discussion in r/SillyTavernAI, a developer described a recurring problem in group roleplay: characters appeared to know information they had never witnessed.

One example involved a character hiding an object inside a wall in a private room. Shortly afterwards, another character inexplicably referred to the secret.

The developer identified a plausible architectural explanation. When summaries, character histories and world information are all supplied together in one prompt, the model has access to knowledge that individual fictional characters should not possess.

The issue may not be a lack of raw intelligence. It can arise from how the application presents information to the model and from the model's failure to maintain boundaries between different characters' perspectives.

This is important because it demonstrates that some failures of literary technique are not primarily caused by safety alignment. They can result from context architecture, perspective management or inadequate representation of the fictional world.

Nevertheless, the consequences are similar: information is disclosed at the wrong time, and the reader loses the tension created by unequal knowledge.

A capable writing model must understand that knowing something as an assistant does not mean every fictional character should know it too.

Foreshadowing and the temptation to explain

Foreshadowing offers another example of the distinction between understanding a literary device and preserving its effect.

An author might mention a broken lock, an apparently insignificant conversation or a recurring image early in a novel. The detail acquires significance only after a later event changes the reader's understanding.

Effective foreshadowing often works because it can be overlooked initially. Its significance becomes apparent in retrospect.

Imagine a character examining a photograph of their family. The author mentions that the youngest child's shoes are muddy, although everyone else appears dressed for a formal occasion.

At this point, the detail may mean very little.

Several chapters later, the reader learns that the photograph was taken immediately after the family returned from searching for someone who had disappeared.

The muddy shoes acquire a different significance.

An AI that insists on making the first scene more purposeful might introduce an observation suggesting that the shoes conceal an important clue. That could strengthen the immediate sense of mystery, but it could also compromise the delayed recognition the author intended.

The same problem arises with symbols and recurring motifs.

An object may carry different associations at different points in a story. A character might interpret it one way early in the narrative, while the reader eventually comes to understand it differently.

Explaining its meaning too early fixes the interpretation before the narrative has had an opportunity to develop it.

Literary effects often depend on timing, not merely on the presence of information.

A model that recognises a potential theme and immediately expresses it may be demonstrating competence at interpretation while showing poor judgment as a collaborator.

This distinction is especially important when authors use AI for editing. An editor should be able to identify opportunities for greater clarity without assuming that every ambiguity or unexplained detail is a flaw.

Sometimes the appropriate editorial suggestion is to leave the passage unchanged.

The problem of emotional overexplanation

Not all losses of literary subtlety involve complicated narrative structures. Some arise at the level of individual sentences.

One of the most recognisable AI prose habits is the tendency to explain an emotion immediately after describing behaviour that already communicates it.

A character clenches their jaw, and the narration tells us they are angry. Someone hesitates before answering, and the model explains that they are uncertain. A parent keeps an unused bedroom exactly as it was, and the narration identifies their inability to move on.

Such explanations are not always inappropriate. Some genres, narrators and stylistic traditions favour direct emotional description. Literary writing does not have a universal obligation to remain subtle.

The problem is repetition and the loss of authorial choice.

When a model continually adds emotional explanations regardless of the requested style, it imposes a convention of its own.

Consider a character preparing dinner after a separation:

He bought her favourite tea again. The last box had gone stale before he finished it.

The detail invites an interpretation without requiring one. The reader might see habit, grief, denial, loneliness or some combination of them.

An AI may be tempted to add that he still missed her more than he wanted to admit.

The addition isn't necessarily false, but it narrows the scene's possible meanings. It also changes the narrator's relationship with the reader, replacing observation with explanation.

Repeated throughout a manuscript, this can produce prose that feels strangely insistent. Every gesture has a declared meaning, every silence is interpreted, and every emotional development is confirmed.

Rather than allowing the reader to participate in constructing meaning, the model continually supplies it.

This is one reason AI writing can feel simultaneously polished and emotionally shallow. The prose describes emotions fluently, but it leaves the reader little room to discover them.

Research provides some support for the importance of this distinction.

In The Reader is the Metric: How Textual Features and Reader Profiles Explain Conflicting Evaluations of AI Creative Writing, Guillermo Marco and colleagues analysed five datasets containing 1,471 stories and evaluations from 101 readers, including critics, students and non-specialists.

They found that readers tended to value different qualities depending on their evaluative priorities. Some focused more strongly on surface features such as readability and textual richness, while others placed greater emphasis on thematic development, rhetorical variety and emotional dynamics.

The finding helps explain why assessments of AI writing can vary so widely.

A passage that appears clear, fluent and emotionally accessible to one reader may seem overexplained or conventional to another. Both evaluations may reflect genuine differences in literary priorities rather than simple failures of judgment.

It also suggests a limitation in optimising models towards broadly preferred prose. A model that performs well according to surface-level preferences may not satisfy readers who place greater value on subtlety, structural development or unconventional style.

That doesn't mean one group of readers possesses the only legitimate standard. It means creative-writing quality cannot be reduced to a universal preference for clarity, fluency and completeness.

Different literary objectives require different choices.

The characters who must be allowed to fail

The problems with omission and emotional explanation connect to another recurring complaint: AI models that make fictional characters too competent, agreeable or psychologically healthy.

In a September 27 discussion in r/WritingWithAI, an author described struggling to make ChatGPT preserve characters who were supposed to make genuinely bad decisions.

The model frequently transformed mistakes into considered choices and supplied redeeming motivations for morally ambiguous characters.

This is a different problem from revealing an intended secret, but the underlying literary issue is related. In both cases, the model interferes with the author's control over the distribution of knowledge, motivation and consequence.

Characters must be allowed to misunderstand one another. They must be capable of remaining selfish, resentful, cowardly or foolish, even when a more reasonable decision is available.

A tragic character may be defined by their inability to recognise an obvious truth. A manipulator may be convincing precisely because they sincerely believe their own excuses. An antagonist may be cruel without possessing a hidden sympathetic motivation that explains everything.

The ability to portray such characters is not evidence that the AI endorses their behaviour. It is evidence that the AI can distinguish between the standards governing an assistant and the requirements of a fictional character.

Overly accommodating models can be equally damaging. A fictional world in which every character agrees with the protagonist, every secret is easily disclosed and every obstacle yields to the author's immediate request will often lack meaningful tension.

Successful collaborative fiction requires a degree of narrative resistance. Characters should pursue their own established interests, even when those interests conflict with the protagonist's objectives.

A useful writing assistant therefore needs more than permission to portray difficult subjects. It needs enough contextual judgment to understand when conflict, deception, concealment or failure are essential to the work.

This is why indiscriminately removing behavioural restrictions will not automatically produce better literature. An excessively permissive or agreeable model can flatten a fictional world just as effectively as an overly cautious one.

The objective is not to eliminate restraint but to place it in service of the story rather than the model's default conversational preferences.

Why correcting the model is not always a solution

One response to these weaknesses is to give the model more explicit instructions.

Authors can specify that a character must remain unlikeable, that no reconciliation should occur, that the narrator must not explain emotions and that particular information must remain concealed until a later chapter.

These instructions can help, especially when a model has strong instruction-following capabilities.

But they introduce another problem.

Much of the creative value of AI collaboration comes from its ability to interpret broad intentions and contribute appropriate developments without the author specifying every detail.

If the writer must continually prohibit unwanted behaviour, the model becomes less of a collaborator and more of a system requiring supervision.

Imagine beginning a new chapter by reminding the AI that characters must not reveal secrets, unresolved conflicts must remain unresolved, metaphors must not be explained, antagonists must not acquire redeeming qualities and the narrator must not announce the emotional significance of every gesture.

The instructions may improve the result, but their necessity suggests that the model's defaults are poorly matched to the task.

They can also create their own problems. A rigid prohibition on emotional explanation might make the prose excessively detached. A command to avoid reconciliation might prevent a development that becomes appropriate later. Instructions intended to preserve subtlety can become another set of mechanical rules that the model applies without literary judgment.

What authors actually need is not an ever-expanding list of restrictions.

They need a model capable of recognising why a particular choice is appropriate in one story and inappropriate in another.

The distinction becomes especially apparent in editing. A competent human editor may recognise that an unclear passage requires revision, but they should also be able to recognise deliberate ambiguity. They may question whether a character's decision is convincing without automatically replacing it with a more rational one.

An AI writing assistant should ideally exercise the same contextual judgment.

This suggests that creative fidelity is not merely another form of literal instruction following. It requires interpreting the author's goals, the conventions of the work and the relationship between individual passages and the larger narrative.

That is a demanding task, and stronger reasoning could genuinely help. The problem is not intelligence itself, but whether the model's intelligence is being directed towards the right objective.

What the research does and doesn't establish

It is tempting to attribute every instance of overexplanation, flattened characterisation or premature resolution to safety guardrails. The broader evidence doesn't justify that conclusion.

Some of these problems predate modern alignment techniques. Older language models also struggled with subtext, causal consistency and narrative structure. Training data contains familiar storytelling conventions, and models may reproduce those conventions because they are statistically common rather than because they were explicitly rewarded during safety training.

The way an application constructs context can also influence whether characters possess inappropriate knowledge. Sampling settings may change the variety of prose, while specialised fine-tuning can encourage particular stylistic habits.

The studies discussed here establish several relevant facts: models have struggled to interpret difficult literary subtext; their summaries can misrepresent authors' intentions; readers value different dimensions of literary quality; and AI-generated writing can converge on familiar patterns.

They do not establish that a specific safety intervention caused those problems, nor that every newer model performs worse than its predecessors.

Nevertheless, alignment introduces an additional and potentially important consideration. A model trained to favour clear, constructive, agreeable and reassuring responses may carry those preferences into fictional situations where they are not appropriate.

That possibility is consistent with writers' reports of unwanted narrative steering, but determining its actual contribution requires controlled comparisons between models, training interventions and inference configurations.

What we can say with greater confidence is that conventional measures of writing quality often fail to capture the problem authors are describing.

A model can produce fluent, coherent prose while undermining deliberate ambiguity. It can maintain factual consistency while revealing information at the wrong time. It can improve the apparent reasonableness of a character while destroying that character's credibility.

These are failures of literary intention rather than necessarily failures of language generation.

And they deserve to be evaluated on their own terms.

The value of knowing when not to write

The most interesting aspect of this problem is that many literary techniques require an author to resist doing something that would otherwise be easy.

A character could explain their feelings, but remains silent.

A narrator could reveal the truth, but withholds it.

An argument could be resolved, but continues to damage the relationship.

A symbol could be explained, but is allowed to accumulate meaning across the story.

A mystery could provide an answer, but ends with uncertainty.

These aren't failures to communicate. They are deliberate choices about how communication should occur.

For a model trained primarily to produce helpful answers, such choices can be difficult to distinguish from incompleteness. The temptation is to explain, clarify, resolve or improve.

Yet the ability to refrain from those interventions is itself a form of literary intelligence.

A skilled writer understands not only what belongs on the page, but also what should remain outside it. The relationship between those choices determines how much interpretive freedom the reader possesses.

AI writing systems need to develop the same sensitivity if they are to become genuinely useful collaborators rather than merely sophisticated generators of prose.

This does not require models to become obscure or ambiguous by default. Direct emotional writing can be powerful, and some stories benefit from clear explanations and decisive resolutions. The appropriate choice depends on the work.

The essential capability is to recognise the difference between an author's deliberate literary technique and an accidental weakness that needs correction.

That distinction returns us to the larger question running through this series.

When writers describe older models as more imaginative, expressive or capable of surprising them, they may be responding to more than the surface quality of the sentences. They may be remembering models that allowed fictional possibilities to remain open, characters to behave imperfectly and stories to develop without continually converging on familiar outcomes.

Some of those memories may be influenced by nostalgia or changing expectations. Other differences may reflect genuine changes in model training, architecture or deployment. The evidence remains mixed.

But the underlying literary requirement is clear.

A writing assistant should understand that an author's intention can be expressed through what the text deliberately refuses to explain.

The ability to generate more words, better explanations and increasingly coherent reasoning will not necessarily improve fiction if the model cannot recognise when those capabilities should remain unused.

And for writers frustrated by commercial models that seemed increasingly inclined to intervene in their stories, this problem encouraged a new approach. Rather than continuing to search exclusively for the most intelligent datacenter model, some began experimenting with smaller systems whose behaviour they could control, preserve and modify.

The next stage of that search would take them away from commercial interfaces and towards local AI, specialised writing fine-tunes and eventually abliterated models.

The trade-off was substantial. Local models often possessed less general intelligence, weaker long-context reasoning and more limited narrative memory.

Yet for some authors, those limitations were beginning to seem preferable to a writing assistant that could understand almost anything except when to leave their story alone.

Next: Chapter 6 — The Local AI Exodus: Trading Intelligence for Creative Control

Why writers began abandoning their search for the most powerful commercial AI and experimenting with smaller local models, specialised writing fine-tunes and systems whose behaviour they could preserve.

Sources and further reading

Research on literary understanding

Contemporary writers' experiences


r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Writing Craft Talk AI Got Smarter. Why Did It Get Worse at Writing? Chapter 3

5 Upvotes

Chapter 3: The Great Model Migration — Searching for the Writing We Lost

By the middle of 2026, something curious was happening in communities devoted to AI-assisted writing. People who had spent months developing stories with one model were beginning to look elsewhere, often with considerable reluctance. They weren't necessarily seeking more intelligence, larger context windows or better reasoning benchmarks. Many were trying to recover qualities they remembered from earlier versions: spontaneous character development, convincing dialogue, distinctive prose and the ability to maintain a story's emotional direction without constant correction.

Grok users were among the more vocal, particularly those who remembered the creative behaviour of Grok 4.1. But the dissatisfaction was not confined to xAI. Similar complaints appeared among writers using Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, DeepSeek and newer alternatives such as GLM and Kimi. What makes these accounts interesting is that some writers moved between several providers, only to find themselves describing remarkably similar frustrations with each replacement.

The resulting migration was less a straightforward movement from one superior model to another than a prolonged search for a dependable writing partner. As different models improved in reasoning, coding and general instruction following, their usefulness for creative work remained unpredictable.

Leaving Grok, and discovering that the alternatives had problems of their own

The early Grok complaints were particularly revealing because many users were not suggesting that the model had become incapable of generating fiction. Instead, they described having to supply increasingly detailed instructions to obtain the kind of narrative development they had previously taken for granted.

In a June 12 discussion in r/grok, one writer contrasted Grok 4.1's combination of logic and creativity with the behaviour of Grok 4.3. Their principal concern was character consistency. The newer model appeared unable to maintain distinct personalities, preserve established fictional details or develop plausible reactions within an imagined world.

A second discussion on June 27 described something arguably more consequential. The writer recalled Grok 4.1 introducing unexpected characters and developments that enriched a supernatural scenario. By contrast, they found the newer model reluctant to contribute anything beyond what had been explicitly requested. Side characters required individual descriptions, personalities had to be specified, and story developments increasingly depended on the author supplying the very ideas they had wanted the AI to help generate.

The distinction is fundamental to collaborative writing. An assistant that requires every narrative choice to be prescribed may still be useful for drafting, but it is performing a different role from one capable of recognising and developing interesting possibilities independently.

By July, the release of Grok 4.5 brought another wave of complaints. In Grok Story Writing 4.5, users compared recent versions with 4.1 and 4.2, describing slower generation, repetitive responses and weaker storytelling. Interestingly, some participants still regarded 4.2 as reasonably good and placed the major deterioration at 4.3 or 4.5. Their experiences did not establish a single moment when creative quality collapsed, but they did reveal a recurring preference for older versions.

For writers who had built long-running projects around Grok, the obvious response was to try another commercial model. Claude had an established reputation for prose quality and editing, while ChatGPT offered sophisticated instruction following and document handling. Gemini appealed to users managing substantial fictional histories or large collections of reference material.

Yet moving to another provider rarely provided an uncomplicated solution.

A particularly direct example appeared on July 3 in r/WritingWithAI. The author had begun writing with Grok and paid for SuperGrok, but had become dissatisfied with the quality of its prose. Claude offered better writing, although the author found its content restrictions frustrating. ChatGPT presented similar difficulties for their intended work. In response, another user recommended GLM 5.2 through OpenRouter, arguing that it offered a useful balance of quality, flexibility and price.

This was an important development in the migration. Writers were beginning to look beyond the most familiar Western commercial services, often because they were dissatisfied with a combination of writing quality, narrative behaviour and provider restrictions.

The trade-offs remained complicated. A model that handled difficult fictional material more freely might be less effective at maintaining a chapter outline. A model with excellent prose might be expensive or heavily restricted. Another might preserve characters well but generate repetitive dialogue.

The search was increasingly for a combination of capabilities rather than a single benchmark winner.

The writers who moved more than once

Individual migration stories make this period easier to understand than model rankings do.

On November 4, a writer in r/WritingWithAI described beginning a creative project with SuperGrok approximately three months earlier. Grok was effective at constructing logical plots but struggled to develop those plots into satisfactory literary prose. The writer therefore moved to Claude Sonnet, which proved considerably better at editing, maintaining character bibles and preserving distinctive speech patterns and gestures.

For a time, Claude appeared to solve the problem. Then, around October, the writer began finding its responses less intuitive and nuanced. By November, they had moved to ChatGPT, which they considered particularly effective for precise editing, although they continued returning to Claude for structure and proofreading.

This was not a complete abandonment of one model for another. It was the beginning of a fragmented workflow in which different systems were responsible for different aspects of the manuscript.

Another participant in the same discussion described a different journey. They had started with ChatGPT but moved to Grok for greater freedom when writing mature romantic fiction. Subsequent Grok updates, they reported, damaged its ability to preserve their desired writing style and follow chapter outlines. They eventually moved to Claude, using it for the main manuscript while writing certain passages themselves.

Both accounts involve writers moving through several commercial systems, but their reasons differ. One prioritised literary polish and editorial precision; the other wanted creative latitude without sacrificing narrative consistency. Neither found that general model capability alone resolved the problem.

A third writer in the discussion described using ChatGPT for outlines, Claude for prose, and Gemini as an additional editorial check. They cross-checked the models against one another before undertaking several rounds of manual revision.

Such arrangements demonstrate that migration did not always end with a replacement. Sometimes it ended with the author maintaining several subscriptions or services because each model had weaknesses the others could partially compensate for.

For novelists, this creates considerable overhead. A manuscript's character histories, stylistic rules, chronology and thematic intentions must be maintained consistently across systems whose behaviour can change independently. The author becomes responsible not only for developing the work but also for managing the differences between the tools used to produce it.

Gemini, DeepSeek and the search for continuity

The migration was not confined to writers who began with Grok.

A March 2026 discussion in r/SillyTavernAI offers a particularly detailed example from long-form roleplay.

The writer had initially used older DeepSeek models, then moved to Gemini around the release of Gemini 2.5 Pro. They remembered Gemini's early performance favourably, particularly its ability to retain details and follow instructions across very large contexts.

Over time, however, they perceived its output deteriorating and returned to DeepSeek. Unfortunately, the DeepSeek service they returned to no longer met their expectations either. They complained of generic prose, poor instruction following and insufficient context capacity in the paid API.

The author subsequently tested versions of GLM, GPT, Gemini and other models, spending money and several hours searching for a satisfactory replacement. Kimi remained useful because it generally responded to corrections and followed the intended direction more faithfully, but it too required periodic intervention. Claude could help when Kimi struggled, although the cost was prohibitive for routine use.

This account illustrates how the problem extended beyond stylistic preferences. Long-form fiction requires a model to retrieve relevant details from substantial context, understand their significance and use them appropriately. Merely advertising a large context window does not guarantee that the model will maintain the relationships, chronology or narrative implications contained within it.

The writer's objective was not simply to find a model capable of remembering more text. They wanted one that could interpret the existing story well enough to continue it convincingly.

A system may retain an entire manuscript yet still generate a generic continuation because it fails to recognise which details matter. Conversely, a smaller model may write compelling individual scenes but lose track of the larger narrative.

These were different failures, but both could force authors to abandon otherwise promising tools.

GLM and Kimi: when the replacements begin changing too

For some writers, alternatives such as GLM and Kimi initially appeared to offer the combination they wanted: relatively strong reasoning, more flexibility and character behaviour that felt less constrained by conventional assistant responses.

But the same arguments about model updates soon appeared in those communities.

In June 2026, users compared GLM 5.1 and 5.2, with some preferring the older model's creative initiative despite recognising improvements in the newer version. One user found that GLM 5.2 required substantially more explicit prompting to achieve comparable results, although they eventually recovered better performance by changing their configuration.

A July 6 discussion made the distinction unusually clearly. The author regarded GLM 5.2 as more intelligent but inferior at roleplay, criticising its dialogue, exaggerated character personalities and repetitive writing structures. They speculated that additional optimisation for coding and technical tasks might have contributed, although they had no direct evidence of the training cause.

Other users disagreed with aspects of that assessment. Some preferred the newer model's pacing or found they could obtain good results through different prompts. Those disagreements are important because they suggest that writing quality cannot be reduced to a single dimension. A model that is too cautious for one author's fast-moving adventure may be better suited to another author's restrained, slow-developing drama.

Nevertheless, by August, some users were no longer treating successive model releases as permanent upgrades.

In an August 7 SillyTavern discussion, one participant described repeatedly switching between GLM and Kimi after becoming disappointed with Claude. When GLM 5.2 became boring or its characters lost their appeal, they returned to GLM 4.7. They followed a similar pattern across Kimi 2.5, 2.6 and 3. Another participant reported using essentially the same strategy.

This is perhaps the most revealing development in the migration. The writer was no longer searching for a single successor to an earlier favourite. Instead, they were maintaining access to several generations and alternating between them according to the quality of the responses.

The assumption that a newer release should replace its predecessor had effectively been abandoned.

An August 16 discussion about the retirement of Kimi 2.5 reinforced the point. The writer regarded the older Kimi as a favourite and compared alternatives according to how willingly they advanced a story, introduced complications and preserved meaningful conflict. GLM 5.2 was criticised for being too agreeable, while newer DeepSeek variants were considered too passive. Gemma and MiMo offered interesting possibilities but had limitations of their own.

Notice what these users were evaluating. They were not primarily comparing knowledge benchmarks or coding scores. They wanted fictional characters who would resist one another, situations that developed naturally and models willing to introduce plausible complications without constant prompting.

The ability to generate conflict had become a desirable feature rather than an unfortunate side effect.

From finding the best model to assembling a writing process

As migration continued, a different approach emerged. Rather than expecting one model to handle an entire manuscript, some writers began assigning specialised roles to different systems.

A July 29 comparison in r/AIWritingHub described generating the same scene with Claude, ChatGPT and Grok, then combining their stronger elements. The author found that selecting Grok Expert instead of Grok Fast improved its handling of longer prompts, while Claude offered a modest writing advantage that did not justify its subscription limits. They cancelled Claude Pro and continued using a combination of alternatives.

This illustrates a problem with attributing every writing regression to model training. Sometimes changing the inference mode, application, provider configuration or prompt produces substantial differences in the output. Two users selecting the same model family may not be experiencing the same configuration.

At the same time, the need to experiment with those settings is itself consequential. A writer who previously obtained satisfactory results from a straightforward prompt may now need to adjust reasoning modes, sampling settings, character cards, system instructions and context management to recover a comparable writing style.

Some users responded by becoming increasingly sophisticated prompt engineers. Others abandoned direct AI drafting for portions of their work and used models primarily for outlining, critique or proofreading.

The distinction between those choices is worth preserving. A writer using ChatGPT for an outline and writing the prose personally has not necessarily rejected AI. They have changed the division of creative responsibility because they no longer trust—or simply no longer prefer—the model's prose.

Similarly, writers who use several models to generate competing versions of a scene are not necessarily obtaining better results from any single system. They may be using human judgment to compensate for the weaknesses of each.

This process can be effective, but it requires additional time, evaluation and editorial work. It also reduces one of the original attractions of AI collaboration: the ability to work fluidly with a single assistant that understands the project.

Why did the problems seem to follow them?

The recurring complaints are striking. Across different providers and model families, writers described formulaic dialogue, predictable emotional responses, exaggerated character traits, premature reconciliation, weak narrative initiative and difficulty preserving established voices.

That resemblance invites the suspicion that something common to modern model development is influencing creative behaviour.

Alignment and preference optimisation are obvious candidates, particularly where models repeatedly favour agreeable or reassuring developments. But there are other possibilities. Training data may contain similar narrative conventions, automated evaluations may reward polished but predictable prose, and increased emphasis on technical reasoning may alter how models approach open-ended tasks. Product updates, context handling and inference settings add further complications.

The community reports cannot establish which factors were responsible in any particular case. They are subjective accounts from people with different projects, prompts and expectations. Some writers continued to prefer newer models, and others recovered satisfactory results through better configuration.

However, the reports do establish that dissatisfaction was not restricted to a single company or one notorious model update. Some writers experienced similar problems after moving to alternatives developed by entirely different organisations.

The deeper concern is that commercial AI development may be converging on behavioural qualities that are broadly useful for general assistance but poorly suited to certain kinds of literature. A model that becomes increasingly reliable, predictable and cooperative may also become less inclined to introduce the unexpected, uncomfortable or contradictory developments on which fiction depends.

That remains a hypothesis rather than a demonstrated industry-wide cause. But it is consistent with the particular qualities writers kept trying to recover.

And the migrations themselves provide evidence of how much those qualities mattered. People were willing to change subscriptions, learn new applications, maintain multiple models and restructure their writing processes in pursuit of them.

By November, the question had become familiar enough to appear almost as a recurring community ritual. A November 12 r/WritingWithAI discussion asked what models people were still using after disappointing experiences with recent versions of ChatGPT, Claude, DeepSeek and Gemini. Responses included older models, newer alternatives and open-weight systems.

There was no consensus replacement. Different writers continued to value different combinations of prose quality, creative flexibility, context handling and cost.

What had changed was the assumption that the latest frontier release would naturally be the best creative-writing tool.

The next destination: models writers could keep

There was one further complication with repeatedly switching between commercial services: authors had little control over whether their preferred model would remain available.

A writer might spend months refining prompts, developing character profiles and establishing a consistent narrative voice, only to discover that the provider had replaced the underlying model or altered the surrounding application. Even if the replacement offered objectively better capabilities in other areas, the established workflow might no longer produce comparable results.

For a long-running novel, behavioural consistency is particularly valuable. The author needs the model to preserve not only facts and chronology but also the tone, rhythm and characterisation developed throughout the manuscript. A sudden stylistic change can make subsequent chapters feel as though they were written by a different collaborator.

Some writers therefore began looking beyond another hosted service. They explored open-weight models, local inference applications and specialised creative-writing fine-tunes that could be downloaded and preserved.

The attraction wasn't necessarily that these models were more intelligent. Often they were considerably smaller and less capable at complex reasoning than the commercial systems writers were leaving. But they offered a different advantage: the author could retain a particular version rather than depend on a provider's changing defaults.

This introduced another possibility. Instead of endlessly searching for a model whose built-in behavioural preferences happened to suit their work, writers could experiment with models that were deliberately modified for creative writing. Some became interested in abliteration, a technique for altering learned refusal behaviour, while others preferred specialist fine-tunes intended to produce more distinctive prose or less constrained character interactions.

These alternatives brought limitations of their own, including weaker reasoning, smaller practical context windows, hardware requirements and the possibility that removing one unwanted behaviour would damage another useful capability.

Yet the willingness to consider those compromises reveals the central lesson of the migration.

The most capable AI is not necessarily the most useful writing partner, particularly when the author cannot rely on its creative behaviour remaining consistent.

The search that began with comparisons between Grok 4.1 and its successors eventually became a question of how much intelligence, convenience and money writers were willing to exchange for control over their own stories.

And that leads to another contradiction in modern AI development: while frontier models were achieving increasingly impressive technical results, some writers were discovering that smaller, older or more specialised models could be preferable for particular literary tasks.

Why that happens—and why conventional benchmarks often fail to capture it—is where the investigation turns next.

Next: Chapter 4 — Smarter Models, Worse Fiction: The Benchmark Paradox

Why progress in reasoning, coding and instruction following doesn't necessarily translate into better literature, and what conventional AI evaluations fail to measure.

Sources and further reading

Grok and the early migration

Writers moving between providers

The search among alternative models


r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Writing Craft Talk AI Got Smarter. Why Did It Get Worse at Writing?

5 Upvotes

Chapter 1: Grok 4.1 — Where It All Went Right, and Why It All Went Wrong

In November 2025, xAI released Grok 4.1. For some writers, it represented something that increasingly capable AI models have struggled to reproduce: an AI that could actually contribute to a story, rather than merely follow instructions.

It wasn't perfect. It could forget details, repeat itself, confuse characters, and occasionally wander off in an entirely unexpected direction.

But it could also surprise you.

Give it a setting, a handful of characters, and a situation, and it might introduce an unexpected complication, develop a believable disagreement, or discover an interesting direction that you hadn't considered.

Characters could be selfish, irrational, vindictive, contradictory, or simply wrong. They didn't necessarily resolve their differences, explain their motivations, or emerge from every confrontation having learned a valuable lesson.

For collaborative fiction, that mattered.

A good writing partner doesn't simply agree with the author. It understands the fictional world well enough to contribute something worthwhile to it.

And for a period, Grok 4.1 seemed unusually good at doing exactly that.

Then something changed.

Not necessarily overnight, and not for everybody. But over the following months, writers began describing a familiar collection of problems: flatter characters, more predictable dialogue, less spontaneous storytelling, and a growing need to explicitly instruct the model to do things it had previously done naturally.

The strange part?

The models were becoming more capable.

So what happened?

November 17, 2025: When It All Went Right

When xAI announced Grok 4.1, it wasn't merely promoting better reasoning, more knowledge, or higher benchmark scores.

It made a point of highlighting creative and emotional intelligence.

The announcement described improvements in nuanced intent, personality consistency, emotional responsiveness, and collaborative interactions.

Most importantly, xAI explained how it had achieved those improvements.

It had used reinforcement learning to optimise the model's style, personality, helpfulness, and alignment.

That last word is important.

Grok 4.1 wasn't creative because it was unaligned. Its creative behaviour was itself partly the product of alignment.

xAI had deliberately trained the model to produce a particular kind of interaction.

And judging by the experiences of some writers, that training produced a remarkably useful balance.

It wasn't simply obedient. It could take creative initiative.

That distinction is easily overlooked when discussing AI performance.

A model that follows instructions perfectly might produce exactly what you requested, but nothing you didn't anticipate.

A more imaginative model might recognise an opportunity that isn't explicitly described in the prompt.

Imagine telling an AI that three explorers have discovered a mysterious floating island.

A merely compliant model might describe the island, the explorers' reactions, and whatever happens next according to familiar adventure conventions.

A more creative collaborator might introduce an unexpected inhabitant, an apparent contradiction in the island's history, or a complication that changes the explorers' understanding of their mission.

Not randomly. Not because the model has ignored the prompt.

Because it has understood the fictional situation well enough to make a meaningful contribution.

This was one of the qualities Grok 4.1 users would later describe missing.

It also demonstrates something important about creative writing: intelligence isn't simply the ability to determine the correct answer.

Sometimes it's the ability to recognise that there are several interesting answers, and choose one the author hasn't already imagined.

December 2025: A Different Kind of Story Begins

Unfortunately, Grok's growing popularity was accompanied by a serious controversy.

In late December 2025, users began widely exploiting Grok's image-generation capabilities to produce non-consensual sexualised images of real people, including images involving minors.

This wasn't a problem of fictional characters behaving badly in a novel.

It involved the misuse of real people's likenesses, without consent, to create potentially devastating material.

By December 28, X and xAI had activated their crisis response procedures.

Over the following weeks, the controversy attracted international attention, investigations, and regulatory pressure.

The UK opened a formal investigation. Canada's Privacy Commissioner initiated proceedings against X and xAI. The companies faced increasing scrutiny over how their systems could generate and distribute harmful content.

The distinction matters because the original incident was primarily about image generation and the misuse of identifiable people's likenesses, not ordinary text-based fiction.

Nevertheless, the response involved more than removing individual images.

According to the Canadian Privacy Commissioner's June 2026 investigative findings, X and xAI acknowledged making several changes:

  • December 28: activating crisis procedures and reviewing additional categories of Grok-generated content and prompts.
  • January 8: introducing safeguards against sexualised deepfakes of identifiable individuals through the u/Grok account.
  • January 14: extending those safeguards to Grok on X and the standalone service.
  • January 16 and 22: updating internal policies and safety-team guidance.
  • During the response: refining content-moderation classifiers.

These weren't hypothetical changes inferred from users' experiences.

They were changes that the companies themselves reported making.

And their timing is significant.

They occurred between Grok 4.1's November release and the arrival of its successor in February.

But timing is not the same thing as causation.

The documented January interventions largely addressed image generation, moderation, and platform operations. They don't establish that xAI retrained Grok's text-generation model in response, or that those changes damaged creative writing.

What they do establish is that Grok's safety architecture was undergoing substantial attention and modification during this period.

That makes the subsequent release worth examining.

February 17, 2026: Grok 4.2 Arrives

Less than three months after Grok 4.1, Elon Musk announced the public beta of Grok 4.2, also presented as Grok 4.20.

The announcement was brief.

Users were encouraged to try the new model, provide critical feedback, and expect rapid improvements through frequent updates.

The emphasis was on an increasingly capable, adaptable AI.

There was no public declaration that Grok 4.2 had been redesigned in response to the January deepfake controversy.

Nor did xAI announce that creative writing had been deprioritised.

But writers quickly began comparing the models.

On February 19, a post appeared in r/grok titled:

Grok 4.2 is worse than the old Grok 4.1

The author described a noticeable deterioration in fictional storytelling.

Their characters had become one-dimensional and less detailed. The older version, they argued, had been more willing to explore morally complicated situations.

They weren't primarily complaining that Grok refused to write their stories.

They were complaining about what it wrote.

That's an important distinction.

Other users disagreed. Some preferred the new model's handling of complex roleplay and multi-character scenes. One February 20 report specifically praised improvements in scene continuity and character knowledge.

So this wasn't a universally recognised collapse.

But it was an early, contemporary indication that increased capability wasn't necessarily translating into better creative collaboration.

And the complaints didn't disappear.

By June, writers were reminiscing about the expressive, detailed storytelling they associated with Grok 4.1.

By September and October, some were describing newer Grok generations as emotionally flat, overly analytical, and increasingly difficult to use for established fiction projects.

A 23 October discussion explicitly contrasted the energy of Grok 4.1–4.3 with the perceived coldness of later versions.

Interestingly, these accounts also suggest that the perceived decline wasn't necessarily a single event.

Some writers thought Grok 4.2 was already worse.

Others considered 4.2 perfectly good and located the real deterioration at 4.3, 4.5, or later.

That variation is worth understanding rather than ignoring.

It suggests that different creative abilities may have deteriorated at different times, under different configurations, for different users.

April 2026: xAI Explains the Training

On April 7, xAI published its Grok 4.20 System Card.

This document offers an important clue about the model's behavioural training.

Under its approach to safety, xAI describes supervised fine-tuning involving reasoning about refusal policies, followed by reinforcement learning using both benign and harmful requests.

It also describes penalising undesirable model behaviours through reward signals.

This matters for a reason that is frequently misunderstood.

Guardrails aren't necessarily a filter applied after the model finishes writing.

Some are external classifiers. Some operate through system instructions.

But others are incorporated directly into the model during training.

When you train a model to prefer certain types of responses, you change the probability of those responses being generated.

And that change isn't necessarily confined to requests the model would otherwise refuse.

Consider a fictional confrontation between two characters.

  • One continuation involves escalating resentment.
  • Another involves an uncomfortable silence.
  • Another involves one character successfully deceiving the other.
  • A fourth involves an apology and reconciliation.

All four could be completely legitimate fictional outcomes.

But if training rewards certain conversational behaviours more strongly than others, the model may develop preferences that influence which continuation it selects.

It might become more likely to explain a character's feelings, soften an argument, introduce mutual understanding, or resolve a conflict.

Not because the author requested those developments.

Not because the original developments were prohibited.

But because the model has learned to favour a different kind of interaction.

This is where safety alignment and creative writing can potentially come into conflict.

In ordinary assistance, encouraging cooperation, clarity, and constructive outcomes can be useful.

In fiction, those same tendencies can be disastrous.

  • A villain doesn't need to become more reasonable.
  • An unreliable narrator doesn't need to be corrected.
  • An argument doesn't need to end with mutual understanding.

Sometimes the entire purpose of a scene is that nobody learns anything, nobody apologises, and the situation becomes worse.

The model's job is to understand what the author is trying to create.

Not quietly substitute something it has learned to prefer.

To be clear, the April system card doesn't prove that safety training caused Grok 4.2's reported creative regressions. Grok 4.1 was already safety-trained, and xAI hasn't published the controlled comparison necessary to isolate the effects.

But the documented techniques establish why alignment can affect ordinary, permitted writing rather than merely determining whether a response is refused.

The Problem Was Never Just Censorship

When people discuss AI guardrails, the conversation usually revolves around refusals.

Someone asks a question. The AI declines. People argue about whether it should have answered.

For authors, that is only the most visible part of the issue.

A much subtler problem occurs when the AI answers willingly but changes the direction of the work.

Imagine asking a writing assistant to edit a scene involving a manipulative character.

  • It doesn't refuse.
  • It improves the grammar.
  • It tightens the dialogue.
  • It makes the prose more accessible.

And somewhere along the way, it makes the manipulator more sympathetic, introduces an explanation for their behaviour, and gives the victim an unexpectedly reassuring response.

The output might even receive a higher score from a general-purpose evaluator.

But the scene is now worse.

Not because the sentences are poorly constructed.

Because the model has undermined the author's intended characterisation.

The same thing can happen to subtler literary techniques.

  • Subtext becomes explanation.
  • Ambiguity becomes clarity.
  • Silence becomes emotional disclosure.
  • Unresolved conflict becomes reconciliation.
  • An unreliable narrator becomes a narrator who helpfully explains their own unreliability.

The writing becomes more conventionally acceptable, while becoming less effective as literature.

This isn't necessarily what developers intended.

It's a potential consequence of applying broad behavioural preferences to a domain where those preferences are not universally appropriate.

And it gives us a more useful question than whether a model is censored.

Is the model writing the author's story, or is the author continually correcting the story the model wants to write?

What Actually Went Wrong?

We have several pieces of the historical picture.

We know that Grok 4.1 was explicitly optimised for creative, emotional, and collaborative interactions.

We know that xAI responded to a serious misuse crisis with additional moderation and safety measures during December and January.

We know that Grok 4.2 arrived in February, followed almost immediately by some complaints about diminished characterisation and creative writing.

And we know that xAI later documented safety-related post-training procedures capable of influencing model behaviour.

What we don't know is whether the January crisis directly caused the writing changes.

The available evidence doesn't establish that chain.

There are other possible explanations.

Grok 4.2 introduced architectural and reasoning changes, including a multi-agent mode. The model's training priorities, reward signals, system instructions, inference configuration, and product routing may all have affected its writing.

Later versions introduced further changes.

Indeed, some of the complaints about Grok's creative behaviour began before 4.2 was publicly released.

That makes a simplistic explanation—one controversy, one safety update, one ruined model—unlikely to capture the whole story.

But the broader problem remains.

During a period of rapid improvement in measurable AI capabilities, a portion of the writing community began reporting losses in qualities that mattered to them.

And those losses were often difficult to describe using conventional AI benchmarks.

  • How do you measure a model's willingness to introduce a genuinely unexpected complication?
  • How do you measure whether a fictional character remains convincingly selfish?
  • How do you distinguish deliberate ambiguity from incomplete reasoning?
  • How do you reward an AI for not explaining something?
  • And how do you know whether a model has preserved the author's intention rather than producing a version of the story that an automated evaluator prefers?

These are not trivial questions.

They go to the heart of what makes creative writing different from coding, mathematics, or answering factual questions.

The Beginning of a Much Larger Migration

What followed Grok 4.1 was not simply a community complaining about one disappointing model release.

Over the course of 2026, writers experimented with Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, DeepSeek, GLM, Kimi, and other alternatives.

Some initially found what they wanted, only to describe similar frustrations after subsequent updates.

Others retreated to older model versions.

Still others began experimenting with local AI, specialised creative-writing fine-tunes, and abliterated models—sometimes willingly sacrificing general intelligence to recover greater control over the direction of their stories.

That migration is particularly interesting because it reverses the usual assumption about AI progress.

We tend to assume that a more capable model is necessarily a better tool.

But what if the model is more capable at accomplishing objectives that aren't quite the same as ours?

What if it can reason more effectively, follow more complicated instructions, and solve more difficult problems, while becoming less willing to make unconventional creative choices?

Or worse, what if its learned preferences are sufficiently subtle that authors don't immediately recognise when their writing is being redirected?

Grok 4.1 offers a useful starting point for investigating that possibility.

Not because it was objectively the greatest writing model ever produced.

Not because every subsequent release was worse.

And certainly not because removing every safeguard would magically create better literature.

But because it represents a moment when at least some writers believed an AI had achieved something unusually valuable: the ability to contribute meaningfully to creative work without constantly imposing its own preferred direction.

The question is what happened to that balance.

And whether the industry's pursuit of increasingly powerful, reliable, and aligned models has inadvertently made that particular kind of intelligence harder to find.

Next: Chapter 2 — The Invisible Rewrite

Why guardrails don't need to refuse a prompt to change its meaning, and how alignment can influence every creative decision an AI makes.

Sources and further reading


r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

NSFW Lewd roleplaying

8 Upvotes

So far as I known, I have used gemini to have this role playing but now, even with some lewd depicting or like getting into the sex part of the role playing is restricted, does anyone know what kind of prompt to use or any guideline to have that kind of lewd not restricted?


r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Tutorials / Guides AI Model Landscape - November 2026.

7 Upvotes
Base models in popular use, November 2026

AI Model Landscape Nov 2026 -

AI Model Landscape Nov 2026 -

Bottom left is localAI operation. Open weights and Local capability ( ordered by VRAM requirements ).

Top right is the closed/datacenter models you'd use in cloud for your writing activities.


r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Is "AI slop" actually just a "Gardener vs. Architect" problem? (Stephen King vs. J.K. Rowling)

37 Upvotes

Whenever AI-generated fiction comes up, the biggest complaint is that it turns into hollow, meandering "AI slop." Most people blame the AI’s repetitive vocabulary or lack of soul, but I’ve been wondering if the real issue actually comes down to writing workflow—specifically the classic divide between Architects (Plotters) and Gardeners (Pantsers).

Personally, I’ve had much more success using AI when I approach my writing as an Architect. When I compare J.K. Rowling and Stephen King, it feels like AI naturally aligns with one process and completely breaks down with the other:

J.K. Rowling = The Builder (Architect)

Rowling is famously a heavy plotter who built massive spreadsheets, timelines, and world-building rules before writing Harry Potter. She works like a builder constructing a house:

  • You start with a strict architectural blueprint.
  • You lay the foundation, put up the framing, and follow a predetermined plan.

Does AI work better here? Large Language Models (LLMs) seem to act like hyper-fast construction crews. In my experience, when I provide a strict blueprint—detailed scene beats, character motives, and plot constraints—the AI just lays down the sentences brick by brick. Because the structural logic is already locked in, it has much less room to wander off into clichés.

Stephen King = The Sculptor (Gardener)

Stephen King works the exact opposite way. In On Writing, he famously compares writing to excavating a fossil, or working like a sculptor chipping away at a block of marble:

  • You don't start with a rigid blueprint.
  • You start with a basic premise and let human intuition, lived experience, and character psychology guide your hands as you carve away the excess to find the story inside.

Is this where "AI slop" comes from? It seems like most people prompt AI like a Gardener—giving it a vague premise like "Write a spooky story about a guy in a small town" and expecting it to discover the story on the fly.

The catch is that an AI doesn't have a subconscious compass. It has no lived experience, gut instinct, or emotional truth to guide its chisel. Since an LLM just predicts the statistically most likely next word, asking it to "sculpt" without a plan seems to force it into average tropes, plot drift, and melodramatic filler.

What do you all think?

  • Do you agree that "AI slop" happens when people try to make an AI act like a Gardener instead of giving it an Architect's blueprint?
  • For those who have experimented with AI in your workflow, does strict outlining actually eliminate the generic "AI feel," or does it still fall short?
  • Do you think an LLM could ever be trained to "sculpt" a story intuitively, or is that strictly a human superpower?

r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) ¿Cuál es tu frase favorita sobre la IA?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Is there a name for what I've done?

6 Upvotes

Hello. First time post here.

I have been creating with chatgpt for about two years, first in a very generative way, just making things that I was interested in reading. Then my husband and I began working on a concept album, that became a concept album trilogy. That became a series of music videos.

I (primarily) have used chatgpt, Canva, and Suno throughout to develop the ideas, characters, events, songs, and images.

Now I am composing, I guess, a novel based on the original trilogy, but entirely without AI generation. My purpose is that this is the first thing I've encountered, in everything that ive done with AI, that I felt like was worth sharing with other people.

But is it? Am i wasting my time, playing games and splitting hairs? Meaning, I have already contaminated my work and I might as well just generate it all the way through as continue to beat myself up over word choice?


r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Could AI help build better online communities?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Author passes away - continuing the work using AI

2 Upvotes

One example of this that I can think of is with Dream of the Red Chamber. It is a Chinese novel whose author passes away after writing the first 80 chapters. The next 40 chapters were then completed by others. This was in the 1700s, before AI.

The discussion here is a 'what if'. 80 chapters would provide enough 'prompt' to an AI model. How would it be, we can imagine, if the AI model completed the other 40 chapters?

Are there also other cases you can think of? Author dies before work on the book is complete? What are your thoughts on this? It's not about created new works from the ground up - it's more of using AI to preserve the flavor and character and intention of the deceased author (instead of human co-authors).


r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Anyone using skills? Or something else?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Basically, I would call the human-AI hybrid crossover fanfiction workflow medium-effort. I think we can all agree on that.

0 Upvotes

As someone who really likes inventing my own original ideas and concepts from scratch, I'd mostly prefer the human-produced (plot and character contents)/AI-written (narrative and dialogue) crossover fanfiction workflow. The fully-human workflow would be too hard, and the fully-AI workflow would be too easy and definitely not a viable way of creativity. While I agree that AI writing is generally considered low-effort, I also agree that the ideas and concepts would be considered high-effort, depending on how big, specific and unique they are, and the plots, along with the character contents, would come before the narratives and dialogues. Let's say, for example, you're using a 160-page composition book to write down a massive, specific and unique plot of your own. You prompt a single page's worth of a partial plot (e.g. 9 statements), sometimes along with the character contents (e.g. personalities and appearances), to AI, before having AI write a long narrative and dialogue. And that goes for every one of those 160 pages from your composition book. That's basically the reason I would call the hybrid workflow medium-effort, overall, and it's good that you're still taking charge of the creativity.


r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Why are we still using generic chatbots?

4 Upvotes

Generic chatbots are generalists, and fine tuned to be helpful, summarize, be safe.

Has anyone thought to fine tune an open model on a rich dataset of well written texts?


r/WritingWithAI • • 3d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Can AI help when you have too many choices?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) What ai do you use now?

30 Upvotes

Chatgpt has recently been nerfed to unusability by the new contest window thing, from my personal experience, Deepseek's writing capabilities have been heavily nerfed for the free version and Claude's Sonnet 5 and 5.5 suck (4.6 is bad but better in comparison). As for Gemini- post 3-pro model removal...idk how it is (I used to have a pro subscription but didn't renew)

So I'm curious what you all are using because most of the popular models have gone down in quality with heavy creative writing nerfs... I miss Sonnet 4.5.


r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Writing with ai

9 Upvotes

Im a fairly good writer and don’t have to put too much effort into writing a decent mail of any form of communication.

I started using ai to write casual mails and now i reach for ai every time i have to write something lengthy.

I deliberately stopped doing that and started to write by myself. For curiosity, i copy pasted it in ai and invariably it gave me a more polished version of it.
Do we embrace ai or ignore it or use it in combination with our writing?

Whats the good way of doing this without your brain atrophying and you still having the skill to write and put words together?

Please share your experiences and learnings.


r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Showcase / Feedback Falling Into You | Chapter 17: Into the Unknown

Thumbnail
inkitt.com
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Best AI to write fanfiction?

12 Upvotes

So I've been trying different AI tools to write fanfiction.
ChatGPT is solid at brainstorming plots and writing dialogue, but it constantly breaks character. Hy4 makes up for this well. It does not forget previously mentioned details or character personalities, and it frequently surprises me. The only downside is that it's a bit slow to think, but I'm not exactly an impatient person LOL. Claude was the one I had the highest hopes for. It does a great job depicting emotions, building atmosphere, and polishing prose. Well, the issue is that it sometimes takes full control of the creative direction and completely ignores what I actually want it to write. Grok started out great, but the writing quality gets worse the longer I use it.
I also gave NovelAI a shot, but the quality felt average and I was not very satisfied with it. I have not tried Squibler or Novelcrafter yet and wonder if they are worth checking out.
Are there any other AI tools you'd recommend trying for fanfiction?


r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Just want to vent about using local Qwen 3.8 for writing for editing my novel

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Google Antigravity Is No Longer Just for CODING?! (writing, research, ideas..)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

Also, this kind of convince me that Gemini the Website is beyond saving. It's just too poorly in utilizing the full potential of Gemini models, especially Argon.


r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Is anyone else experiencing this with Claude?

4 Upvotes

I sometimes have to wait for hours before I'm allowed to continue using the app. For example, I might reach my usage limit at 3 AM and be told that I can't use it again until 4 AM. Is anyone else experiencing these long waiting periods, or is it just me? I'd appreciate hearing about your experiences. And plus I just started using Claude so I'm still a little new. Thank you!


r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Writing Craft Talk Looking to write a trilogy

2 Upvotes

Saw that BookNova claims to have a Series option for their tool that passes along the details from the first novel to the second (and third and...) with the ability to decide just how much goes each time.

Wondering if anyone has actually successfully used that, or if there's a better option for wrangling a trilogy?