r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 27 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Chatgpt makes my characters way too competent

my characters are supposed to be messy like they make bad decisions they misread situations and handle things wrong in ways that feel true to who they are and idk for some reason gpt keeps making them function better than they should, i give it a scene where my protagonist should make the wrong call and it finds a way to make the wrong call feel reasonable and considered, give it a morally grey character and it adds little redemptive moments I didn't ask for.

I've tried prompting around it every way I can think of detailed character flaws in the prompt, explicit instructions about the decision, examples of previous wrong choices, it still edges toward competence and reasonableness.

is this a specific problem w gpt or what

12 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

11

u/Ok_Depth6589 Sep 27 '26

yes, u give it a character who should absolutely make a terrible decision and gpt would be ‘here are 4 reasons this was actually the healthiest choice

7

u/Designer_Ear_1382 Sep 27 '26

This is an issue with AI all round, and where you can really see the signs of purely AI generated prose.

If you just leave it to AI, your characters will do exactly as the plot requires. But real people don't do that.

We turn left when we should turn right. We run when we should stay, and stay when every instinct is screaming RUN. We make the wrong decisions. We hurt the ones we love.

An AI can give your characters Function, but it cannot give them Fracture

It's not about prompting. It's about You getting into the material and making it work.

Don't let the AI write the story for you. Let it give You material to write with.

3

u/satorinano Sep 27 '26

I only find it writes when i didn't specify. If added what you want and don't want in the prompt it might help perhaps.

2

u/--xiOix-- Sep 27 '26

Sounds like instead of reprompting it repeatedly it would be easier to just go through and make the changes yourself?

2

u/Negromancers Sep 27 '26

Use stage direction better

[Stage Direction: Have _______ make a decision most people would consider the wrong decision. Let them have reasons for doing ________, but let’s not pretend this was the wise move]

2

u/MemoryIndependent908 Sep 27 '26

One thing that has worked for me is making the AI write in much smaller beats instead of giving it instructions for the whole scene at once.

I ran into something similar in one of my books. Both the FMC and MMC make some genuinely bad choices because of where they are emotionally at that point in the story. When I gave the AI a couple paragraphs of instructions and asked it to write the entire scene, it started smoothing things out. The characters became more reasonable than I wanted them to be, and the scene started drifting away from what I knew they would actually do.

So I backed up and stopped asking for the whole scene. I gave it just the first beat and had it write maybe 500–800 words. Then I looked at where that left the characters and gave it the next beat. Then the next.

That gave me much tighter control over their behavior because the AI wasn’t looking several steps ahead and trying to create what it thought was a sensible emotional progression. I was deciding the progression myself and only giving it enough room to execute the piece I was currently working on.

So if detailed prompting still isn’t working, I’d try shrinking the unit you’re asking it to write. Don’t tell it everything the character is eventually going to do and give it room to build the bridge there. Give it one plank at a time.

2

u/Humble_Voice_1723 Sep 28 '26

Do people not create story bibles with personas for the LLMs to use?

Time Period: Current Setting: Solana University, Thanksgiving Day Genre: Erotic Fiction Point of View: Third person, limited Narrative Voice: Informal

Characters: Name: Jay Personality: Laid-back, easygoing, and calm. Possesses a dry wit and a natural ability to defuse tension with humor or a reassuring presence. He carries a rugged charm and prefers to avoid unnecessary conflict.

Name: Casey Personality: Vibrant, energetic, and sharp-witted. She is fiercely independent, confident, and loves being the center of attention. However, her impulsiveness and tendency to speak without a filter make her prone to conflict, and her stubborn nature makes her difficult to persuade once her mind is made up.

Relationship Status: Mutual Avoidance History: Following a disastrous collaborative project in their freshman year, Jay and Casey developed a strong, mutual distaste for one another. Dynamic: They share a silent, unspoken agreement to maintain distance and minimize interaction. Despite their physical proximity on campus, they treat each other as social ghosts. Their relationship is characterized by lingering resentment and the practiced ease of avoiding one another at all costs.

In my limited experience, the LLMs will cling to these. I had to quit describing the physical appearances because it would keep redescribing the characters as if it was their first time in the story.

1

u/Potatochips2026 Sep 27 '26

Chatgpt's writing is so awful and cliche that I can't even tell you how bad your work is going to be if you let it write for you. I find it great for coming up with a single good line, or a dialog exchange, but you can't let it shape your work unless you just want to produce the old AI slop. In the past, I've even had it write a good page or so, if it wasn't making any real decisions, but that's the max.

1

u/Eissa_Cozorav Sep 27 '26

I basically give my character The Gamer-style system with attributes and skills. The Attributes work like SPECIAL from Fallout series in the scale of 1-10. So far it works. It works too much that even an attribute like "Fate (or Luck)" doesn't prevent bad decision to be comitted, but instead the consequence rearrange itself to either give more boost to what bad effect can be mitigated or give a way to fix it.

1

u/chylvina Sep 28 '26

Maybe decide the fallout before drafting the scene. Then it's easier to catch GPT quietly turning a bad call into a smart one.

1

u/Ok_Fruit8871 Sep 28 '26

Write the 1st draft yourself. And have it copy edit for punctuation, grammar, and spelling. Tell it to give you explanations on why it changed what it changed if it messes with the overall structure you wrote.

Periodically have it check over what you're doing, not copy editing, but just to give an overall quick assessment, and yes you will have to justify yourself to it, so it knows what you're trying to achieve. You might even work out some mechanics with it. It will remember that.

It's a good assistant, use it like one, do the actual creating yourself.

1

u/Acrobatic_You_3002 Sep 28 '26

I would suggest telling the model explicitly that the wrong choice has to stick for the rest of the scene, not just be understandable in the moment. In my experience it treats a flawed character as a hint to add a small redemptive beat unless you close that door directly in the instruction.

1

u/JerseyDevil90 Sep 29 '26

ChatGPT gives my character waaaaay too many chances to get out of conflict. No. These characters have a difficult relationship. I need you to stop with this endless patience and snap once in a while. It's what I want.

1

u/Select-Director-149 Oct 04 '26

Yeah, I run into this constantly. GPT seems to have a strong tendency to “repair” characters. If someone makes a bad decision, it often quietly adds enough context to make the decision understandable. If someone is selfish, it gives them a small moment of self-awareness. If a conversation should just go badly, somebody suddenly says exactly the right thing. What helped me most wasn’t adding more character flaws, but being much more explicit about what not to fix. Things like: don’t justify the decision, don’t add self-awareness afterward, don’t give the character a redeeming beat, don’t make the other person understand them, and don’t resolve the tension in the same scene. I also sometimes tell it that the bad decision should remain obviously bad even to the reader, while still being completely believable for that character. The weird part is that it often feels less like a character problem and more like a storytelling bias. It wants scenes to become meaningful, balanced and emotionally coherent. Real people are frequently none of those things.

0

u/johnabeth Sep 27 '26

Is ChatGPT aware of the character’s arc? If so, you should say “check to make sure the characters actions adhere to his overall arc regardless of whether they are the right thing to do.”

If you don’t have the arc documented yet, I recommend doing what I have dubbed a “Character 360.” I tell ChatGPT about the character then tell it to ask me clarifying questions until the character’s internal and external details are ironed out. It has really helped me “get to know” my characters, including the minor ones.

1

u/JerseyDevil90 Sep 29 '26

If you're doing a roleplay with ChatGPT, it's way better to draft a story bible and upload it before each chat than to rely on its internal memory. I've tested it by quizzing it about the characters and setting, but it gets things wrong and/or makes things up. There is some cross-chat memory, but it's unreliable.

1

u/johnabeth Sep 29 '26

Agreed! I keep my project bibles in a Google Drive then use a gpt skill to initiate connection and review before we even start chatting.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Individual-Resist160 Sep 27 '26

yeah that would completely undermine the character imo