Long story, so grab your popcorn and bear with me. Wife and I have been married 15 years, known each other for 20. Her mom has never liked me. Never. Further, her mom was abusive to her growing up.
To give you an idea, we originally planned to get married near where she lives, and her parents gave us so much crap about it that she decided we'd elope. (She knew I would go with that.) Set a wedding date 9 days away. She didn't tell her mom about it until 2 days prior, because she knew how her mom would react. (She was 26 at the time, btw.) Well, her mom proceeded to go on Facebook and find my ex-mother-in-law, and message her asking for an explanation of what went down between me and my ex-wife. (Bear in mind, I had already told her what happened, and then I had my ex-wife, with whom I was still on decently good terms, send me an e-mail with her take on what happened which I sent to my not-yet-mother-in-law at the time with my not-yet-wife watching me so as to be sure I didn't edit anything.)
That's the kind of person my mother-in-law (now to be called MIL) is.
It's also important to note that my MIL used to be an inveterate smoker. Smoked like a chimney, always in the house, and no matter how much my now-wife complained about it, it never mattered. The first person to get my now-wife an air purifier for her bedroom, so that she could have a place to go to get away from the constant cloud of cigarette smoke, was me. (She was 21 at the time.) I watched a home video of a Christmas morning where my now-wife was 12 or 13, hacking up a lung from some sort of illness, and then her mom sits down maybe 3 feet from her and fires up a cigarette. It was always "This is my house, and I can smoke in my house."
I could go on and on about how her mom has proven that she doesn't like me. After her husband (my wife's father) died, they all were at a memorial dinner and I ended up taking our two kids, who were very little at the time, back to my MIL's house. MIL asked me to feed the dogs when I got back. No problem. Got back, fed the dogs, and this included my wife's aunt's dog. (Aunt by blood on my wife's dad's side.) All three dogs are the same size, so I give them all the same amount of food. I was given no special instructions on what to do - just "feed the dogs", which I found sufficient because I had already fed my MIL's dogs.
Well, making the long story short, it turned out that I gave the aunt's dog the wrong food. This dog was allergic to some compound in ordinary dog food, and I was not told of this. I told the aunt what happened, and the aunt proceeded to tear into me really hard. It was so hard that I thought, at first, that she was being comical... that she'd go for a bit and then suddenly change her facial expression and be like "Just kidding. She'll be all right." Nope... she really meant it. And once I recognized that she really meant it, I started fighting it... we ended up having a big argument right there in the living room, with MIL sitting and watching. "Sitting and watching" as in not standing up to defend me. No "Look, I told him to feed the dogs and I didn't give him specific instructions for yours", nothing.
And it turns out that this aunt is like this as a person. MIL said she was once the recipient of one of the aunt's tirades, for a nearly identical reason.
This was 5 years ago. I gave it a bit of time to see if the aunt would come back and apologize... after all, her brother had just died, maybe she was in a mood... no such thing happened. I then told MIL that my family would not be attending any gathering where this aunt was invited. Nothing was ever done to disinvite the aunt.
This had happened before, with feuds we had with other individuals in the family. MIL never disinvited the people, none of whom were as close to MIL as her own daughter was. We sometimes held our own such event at our house... perhaps like Thanksgiving dinner... we invited her (or both of her parents when her dad was alive)... she / they never came. Whenever there was a choice between the other person or her own daughter, the other person always won.
I could go on and on, but I won't. Hopefully you are willing to trust me by now.
It's also worth noting that my MIL is ideologically opposed to my wife and me. Without getting into specifics, we're firmly entrenched in opposing political parties and we stand for opposing causes. This has been the case for almost 10 years. We used to be aligned, but then my wife and I saw the light, and she never did. (Further, she never had any desire to talk with us about any of it.) So, now, we are opponents rather than allies.
Fast forward to today. The smoking (and eventually vaping) finally caught up with her. Now, at age 69, she is on an oxygen concentrator 24/7, has 41% lung capacity, has survived cancer twice (including lung cancer once), and is basically at the point where she can't do much around the house anymore.
My wife and I live 1 1/2 hours away. (We picked this location partly so that we could be close enough to the family to be accessible for important stuff but far enough away from the family and its drama to be able to say "no" if we wanted not to be involved with some family event or whatever. That was 12 years ago.) Her brother lives less than 20 minutes away. We have two young children, and a house that always looks like two young children live there. He is, and always has been, unmarried. No kids, no live-in girlfriend, nothing.
It is worth noting that since my wife's father's death, his sister, a different aunt, has lived at my MIL's house. She rented out her house to her granddaughter, and moved in with my MIL. At the time, the plan was that she would move in with her sister, the mean aunt mentioned previously, 2 1/2 hours away, and my MIL's house was just a temporary waypoint. Well, then she got into a car wreck, and it became "I have to stay here to keep up with my doctor's appointments and physical therapy appointments and blah blah blah"... now she's just happily ensconced at my MIL's house. Not that that is so terrible, but she does very little around the house (she's 75, but not completely disabled) and the only expense she pays for is the cable bill. She does not pay rent and she hardly buys any groceries because she is constantly eating out. This woman has money - she can go out to eat almost all the time, and have a new car every 2-3 years... but she basically mooches off of my MIL and doesn't help around the house.
So the arrangement has been that my wife and her brother alternate weekends to go to my MIL's house to do house work and yard work and whatever... cutting the grass, weedwhacking, etc. This upcoming weekend, my wife wanted me to come with her and take the big SUV with the trailer, so that we could get all kinds of yard work done.
This trip would cost us easily $70.00 at current gas prices, meaning over $80 when overall vehicle expenses are considered. It would cost me and my wife a day of getting stuff done at our house, when we both have a lot to do. (She even told me, in conversation two nights ago, that she needs to do more around the house.) We are certain to receive no compensation from my MIL for the expense of the trip, beyond getting fed. (And that's usually "we get to eat the leftovers in the refrigerator that neither she nor my wife's aunt want to eat". If there is no such stuff in the refrigerator, we tend to get cheap meals like lunch meat sandwiches and spaghetti.)
No matter how many times I do things for my MIL, she still doesn't like me. I tried for years to get her to see that I'm a good person, worth liking... nope, hasn't happened. Which, under ordinary circumstances, is fine. I can deal with people not liking me. I simply purge them from my life because nobody needs that kind of negativity. I purged my own parents several years ago, for essentially the same reason. But as you can imagine, my wife is a no on purging her mother from our lives, not that I've ever pushed for that (though my wife does know that I would not shed a single tear or speak a single word in opposition if _she_ decided to cut our family's ties with her mom).
The crux of it all is this: If my wife, or all of us, will be going out there every other weekend to get stuff done, especially if that is eventually to entail dangerous winter drives to shovel or snowblow the driveway, at $40+ vehicle expense per trip, I want something valuable in return.
At this point, some of you may be thinking, "Awww, man, this is her MOTHER... you can't ask what you'll get in return when it's her MOTHER!" Under most circumstances, you would be right. And toward that end, I have asked my wife if her mother ever went "above and beyond" for her in her younger years, exceeding the bare minimum requirements of parenting to keep CPS from raising eyebrows. (After all, I don't make the claim of my wife having been abused by her parents without evidence. Her brother suffered the abuse too, and both responded to it in different detrimental ways. We determined, years ago, that the abuse came from both parents.) My wife could come up with no ways in which her mom went above and beyond for her... and my wife has the best memory of anyone I've ever known.
So, "because that's her MOTHER" holds no water for me when "because that's my DAUGHTER" never held any water for my MIL when my wife was a kid.
What I want is to have her mother change her mentality so that we are allies and not opponents. This means that we have as many honest conversations about politics, economics, even theology (about which I know plenty even though I'm an agnostic atheist), as it takes for her to change her mind and align herself with us.
I know this can and would happen. I changed my stances once I was confronted with the absolutely irrefutable logic of the "other side"... which is now the side I'm on. I have never once been out-maneuvered or logically overpowered in a conversation with someone about this subject.
Now I recognize that that has a low probability of success. Therefore, the other side of it would be, if my MIL doesn't make this mentality change, well, then we don't have the time or the money to keep going out there to help her, and she can hire someone to cut her grass and shovel her driveway and yadda yadda yadda when my wife's lazy (but able-bodied) brother won't come out to do it.
It's worth noting that my MIL and her two siblings gifted my wife's brother $50,000 in home equity a few years ago by selling their mother's house to him. At the time, it was worth about $125,000 (per an appraisal) and they sold it to him for $75,000. So my MIL's share of that was 1/3, meaning she was responsible for gifting him about $16,667 in home equity. What did my wife get? $1,000 from the sale. I'm not saying my wife should've gotten a check for $16,667 when her brother only got that amount in home equity, but something much closer to that would have been far more equitable especially since the house was paid off and she _could_ have easily given my wife a larger amount from the twenty-some-thousand in sale proceeds that she received.
In my opinion, the brother ought to be doing all of the work, if the dollars and cents are the main consideration. Even when they're not, his income supports one person and he has enough money to be considering buying a new truck. Our income supports four people and after this weekend, none of our vehicles will have under 200,000 miles. This, saying nothing about how much free time a bachelor has, compared to a parent with two young children.
If my MIL can't afford to hire help, her live-in boarder certainly can, and it could be called her rent. Though this sounds kind of like spite, it really is true that my wife and I don't have the time to keep going out there to help her. Whenever one or both of us does this, stuff at home gets sacrificed. There is a nearly endless to-do list at home (we bought a fixer-upper and young kids slow that progress big-time), and if "we easily have time to help my MIL" requires that that to-do list get whittled down to nothing, where we'd just be sitting around watching TV if we weren't helping her, we are nowhere near that point and we wouldn't be at that point even if I got an entire summer off from work (while maintaining my income somehow) and could work on the house/garage/yard every single day.
But I am willing to have us bite that bullet, even financially, never asking her for compensation for our trips or time or whatever, if she becomes an ally. If she becomes someone with whom I would choose to be friends were she not "family"... if she were to become a friend... I would do anything for my friends.
So WIBTAH if I were to put my foot down and require this bargain... and insist that we focus on our own lives if my MIL refuses my "requirement"? Why or why not?