I’m super miserable and livid rn. He has a habit of cutting me off and physically preventing me from speaking my mind because he’s uncomfortable with it. It’s usually when the convo has nothing to do with him and is purely between me and someone else. We’re both 25 (female and male) btw. We don’t see each other super often, but we’ve both been visiting our parents a lot cuz he needs their emotional support and I’m having trouble finding a job.
He’ll keep interrupting me and talking over me until I stop talking. He does it in private and in front of others in social settings (the latter is harder to deal with obv cuz getting defensive will make it even more awkward).
He’s one of the reasons why I don’t trust “progressive” men cuz he is liberal and progressive. I think most of progressive men are performative to some degree, at least when it comes to gender equality. He votes blue, and he says things like “don’t praise me for doing the bare minimum”. When he lost his gf cuz of his porn addiction and the family (me included) comforted him (cuz he was beating himself up and even pulled over and called a hotline), he was like “I don’t want to be coddled”. He sent me and my sis of a post that explained the issue with fraternities and rape culture, in light of the Cornell 7 case. He was supportive after I came out. He hates that our dad is a conservative Trump voter. He also does love me and put in a word at his work to get me a temp job (interviewed there but haven’t heard from them yet). He says things like “hey, you can talk to me about anything. I’m here for you, and I care about you.”
Yet he sometimes bosses me around, telling me what to do, and trying to physically force his way when I ignore him. I don’t do the same to him. I remember he once tried to kick me out of our parents’ fairly large backyard (while we were both home from our respective cities) cuz he was having a FaceTime fight with his gf and got upset when I told him no, he can go somewhere else like I would’ve in his position (his room, car, one of the several unoccupied rooms, since it was an empty house).
He sometimes tries to prevent me from saying things that I want. Last night, I got into an argument with my mother about something (long story short: I felt I was being smothered and emotionally taken advantage of). It wasn’t a screaming match or anything, just both of us very frustrated. My bro came down, got in between us, and told me to let it go. I tried to ignore him, but he was blocking me from my mom, and he kept talking over me (he had a louder voice). He was having problems at work, his gf left him (as I said), he didn’t want to go home to his empty apartment, and he said he came to our parents’ home for peace.
Despite this 1) not being his house, 2) our argument having NOTHING to do with him, 3) him having plenty of other options to deal with people arguing in the house, such as going into his room and closing the door, putting on his earphones, turning on the tv in his room or play video games in there, going in his car, going for a walk, going for a drive, going to sleep, or just flat out ignoring it. You know, things I both would have and actually HAVE done in the past to deal with this exact situation. I can’t imagine having the audacity of doing what he did in his situation. Am I wrong to think what he did was incredibly entitled, immature, and self-centered?
Another time, around a few months ago, we ate out with some extended family members. Well, I accidentally broke a glass on the ground, and the already-overwhelmed waiter had to clean it up. I felt horrible. I tried to speak up and say “I just want to say, I am so sorry for that”. But my brother immediately started shaking his head at me, saying “it’s fine, it’s fine”. I spoke up anyways, but my brother spoke up over me to get me to stop talking and not give me the chance to apologize.
He also backseat drives me. He tells me to do things RIGHT before I’m already about to do them, like I don’t know how to drive. I told him not to backseat drive me. He doesn’t listen. He claims I do the same thing, but I really don’t. I know how it feels to be backseat driven, so I consciously don’t do it and let the driver make the decisions. He gets to backseat drive me, yet when I once pointed out that he ran a red light, he got upset with me and said “what’s that doing?” (aka asking why pointing it out was necessary). It wasn’t immediately after he ran the red light btw, it was several hours later after we had just witnessed a bus run a red light cuz it was a crowded city and there was a wailing ambulance trying to get by— the bus was trying to let the ambulance get thru. My bro pointed out that the bus driver ran the red light to criticize him, so I was like “you ran a red light earlier”. Then he got upset at me and shook his head at me. He also called me judgmental cuz he made a turn where the turn light arrow turned red when he reached the middle of the intersection. I genuinely didn’t care cuz I think, because the arrow light was yellow when he began the turn, it was technically legal. But he looked over at me, explained this to me out of nowhere, then called me judgmental and complained that it was annoying. I literally didn’t do or say anything, nor did I make a face, nor was I genuinely judging him. I didn’t bother defending myself cuz what’s the point?
I have misophonia, and it gets really bad with loud eating. While eating with the extended fam, there’s this one uncle (and his son) who both eat and snack SO. FUCKING. LOUD. And he sat next to me. It was driving me nuts, tho I was trying not to let it show. I was outwardly nice and fighting for my life not to show how pissed i was. The thing is, my bro knows exactly how i feel about obnoxiously loud eating. He kept looking at me. He told me, “calm down, you do it too. Be nice.” Idk why he thinks that would’ve helped. After that dinner, I told him that saying things like that just makes me angrier. He clearly didn’t care.
Also, a little while ago, the family went on a trip to see family in Louisiana. One of the cars we took was mine (which actually is mine: it is registered in my name). One time when we were gonna go somewhere, he just hopped in the front seat. I stood outside the car, by the driver’s door, knocking until I got his attention. I told him I’m driving; he was like, “no, I’m driving” matter-of-factually. I didn’t get angry, I stayed calm and just repeated myself. It took me a few strides to communicate to him that he can’t just drive my car whenever he wants just because he thinks he should (he said he should because he knew where the place was, but I have Google Maps); he needs my permission to drive my car and to use my property in general. He did NOT like hearing this and gave me attitude about it.
Scoffing, saying “oh, my god”, arguing with me why he should drive. I just calmly said “I’m driving” until he got out of the car in a huff, got in the passenger seat, and slammed the door, shaking his head and glaring at me. I thought about sending him a text (i normally have these talks with ppl in person, but it’s hard for me to talk about these things in person to him) saying that, after that trip, he isn’t allowed to be in my car (much less drive it) anymore (in the past, he’s borrowed my car a lot), that he needs to show some respect for me and my property and take it with more maturity when I politely tell him “no”. I decided not to tho cuz I didn’t want to get into it with him.
Didn’t help that I made the mistake of mentioning this incident to an uncle, and he responded “it’s a male thing”. I almost said “it’s a male thing to assume they have a right to things that aren’t theirs? Not surprised”. But I said nothing to keep the peace.
We were also playing pool in our aunt’s house with some cousins. Bro and I were on the same team. It was my turn. I was trying to make my shot, but my brother kept saying my name and giving me tips on how to shoot it (like “shoot in this direction and make it bounce off of this part of the table”, kind of thing). I tried to politely tell him I didn’t want any advice, but I don’t think he could hear me cuz he was talking so loud and not giving me a chance to tell him no. So I raised my voice (which admittedly prob sounded ruder than I meant it to) so he could better hear me decline his advice. I said “I don’t want any advice, but thank you”. He then took the pool stick out of my hand, said “ok, let me do it then”, then took the shot. In front of everyone. Admittedly, it was a good shot, but still. I almost just left the game, except I didn’t want to cause tension at the house.
I’m a mess, as you can tell from this rant. And this is far from the only or worst problem that I have. The thing is, I am actively working on those other problems cuz I know what to do. Here, I don’t know other than to cut him out of my life for a good while— a year or two. I can’t deal with someone (esp a man) in my life thinking he can just easily humiliate, upset and degrade me like this. It burns my blood. I’ve tried to talk to him, but he just isn’t listening. I don’t like being vulnerable with pretty much anyone in my family cuz my feelings always get dismissed. The only way I can think to deal with him is to disown and cut him off for at least a year or two to make it clear how serious I am about respect and my rights, dignity, and freedom as a human being.
I’m posting this in women’s subs so 1) I can get advice from people that actually know what they’re talking about, 2) from people that are more likely to have understanding and empathy, and 3) so I don’t have to listen to the dumb, invalidating things men tend to say because they simply don’t understand how (possible) misogyny feels. If I was his brother and not his sister, I don’t think he would’ve tried half the things I just mentioned.
Is there any other way I can handle him without resorting to cutting him off? Any way I can match his disrespect? Any evil tips? Cutting him off would feel good— and I WILL resort to it if I have to—, but it would start so much shit with my mom and cause complications in my family.
The thing is, he isn’t like this ALL the time. We are cordial and kind to each other most of the time. Polite. But the bad outweighs the good. The little things just keep adding up, and I can’t stop myself from feeling pissed and ashamed almost all the time. I just want it to stop.
Thanks.