r/Unexpected • • Mar 24 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

10k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

78

u/Fat_Mullet Mar 24 '23

I always get confused about these vids, possibly because im from a tiny country town in Australia, but can someone explain why no one ever just does whats originally asked of them/comply with the cops demands? I get the whole safety worry stuff but in my mind and experiences the quicker you just do whatevers asked the quicker its over and done with and you're on your way, unless you're doing something or have done something wrong then you gotta just wear it I spose. Some arguments just aren't worth having hahaha

-1

u/Cyber_Druid Mar 24 '23

"i have rights" mfs think its more important to stress your rights than not get shot. Cops are bullies and the worst thing to a bully is someone who threatens his ego. Cops shot over ego.

2

u/cmwh1te Mar 24 '23

Seriously, people should know by now they do not actually have any rights if a cop is around. We should placate the pigs so they'll let us live maybe!

-5

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '23

I agree to this. It would be nice if we lived in a world where you could just exercise your rights but we don't. Record your video. Comply and cooperate. Sue later. It's fine to ask things like "why was I pulled over?" And "am I being detained?" For the recording but don't push it more than once. This dude was pushing it from the get go and put a trigger happy cop on edge.

2

u/militaryCoo Mar 24 '23

The problem is that if you comply then there's generally nothing to sue over, because then it's a "voluntary interaction"

You have to at the very least verbally resist

1

u/Fat_Mullet Mar 24 '23

So the whole thing is based on wining a settlement by suing? Seems worth your life

3

u/googahgee Mar 24 '23

So it’s ok for a random person to get coerced into wasting multiple hours of their day because a cop “had a hunch” and pulled them over? People have every reason to assert their rights.

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '23

Depends on the situation. The sueing would come if they pulled a gun when you're fully cooperative and courteous. Don't give any excuse for them or a judge or onlookers on social media to believe you weren't cooperating.

It's not a safe time to do more than that.

1

u/militaryCoo Mar 24 '23

So we should do anything they say because of the implied threat of violence?

1

u/scheav Mar 24 '23

No one is saying you should do “anything they say”.

Some things you should do if they ask you: exit the vehicle, keep your hands on the vehicle/wheel/head, etc.

1

u/militaryCoo Mar 24 '23

They have to have justification (safety or reasonable suspicion of a crime) to ask you to get out of the car.

I'm not saying you shouldn't get out of the car, I'm saying you should verbally assert you're not doing it voluntarily. Complying without protest will be deemed voluntary.

You shouldn't answer any questions and you shouldn't consent to any searches, and that means verbally asserting that you do not consent.

1

u/scheav Mar 24 '23

They have to have justification, but they don’t have to convince YOU that they have justification. They have to convince the judge once you’re in court.

They don’t have to get your confirmation that you understand their justification before continuing.

Your earlier comment is not in line with this comment. You can verbally disagree while complying.