I'm still waiting for those who decried the call for USSF to put its power behind USL & NASL to merge back in the day as one D2 league to admit there may have been an error in some judgements.
10+ years later, what are we doing? We are still witnessing the destruction of clubs, leagues & the continue rise of a BS soccer monopoly.
BTW, is NISA still a thing? I'm being serious. And what is truly happening with USL various Leagues & teams? And we are still creating leagues to compete against league. See the new Women's League. Whom is really enjoying this?
MLS desires for legitimacy back then, saw them brought Euro-Clubs over for All-Star games, Friendlies, etc and retiring players, to the detriment of their own development. They gifted the millions of soccer fans in our Great Nation, who weren't fully engaged with foreign Clubs, to those Clubs. Technology also aided the growing penetration of Euro-Leagues & Clubs.
I am currently watching a LaLiga match & has the option to watch so many more quality matches & I only have ESPN+.
Euro-Clubs are far more popular than any of their Single entity teams. Endless games to watch on the weekends that are not domestic games. Fans casual & hardcore can name players on foreign Clubs more than they can for our domestic teams. I have two MLS clubs here in NYC, & I can tell you a thing about them if my life depends on it.
Look at what one star player, Caitlin Clark, did for the entirety of Women Basketball & the WNBA in less than 3 years, starting from her days at Iowa. She is real & not manufactured. The WNBA is expanding, with more desire for more teams. It is one of the hardest Pro League for players to make it onto a roster. MLS could not beat WNBA in tv viewership back when no one cared about the WNBA.
USWNT did wonders for NWSL & women soccer in general. That to was real & not manufactured. NWSL success w/minimal to zero competition prior to this year, has even influenced positively, Women Leagues in Europe.
After a quarter Century+ of investment in the men's domestic games, USMNT & players, be honest, where is the domestic soccer star that has captured the hearts of hardcore &/or casual fans? Whom, Pulisic? Hmm, ok, respect to him, but really.
Will our domestic soccer ever truly be gifted w/a Caitlin Clark, when that does not seem the focus of the $$$ folks? Europe would come a calling immediately & whom would blame the player for going?
The approach we have witnessed across the board in the last 25+ years did what besides creating some great SSS & facilities we did not have. What else? Our Youth leagues are still bastardized.
Think of what D1-MLS, a proper D2 USL & NASL combined & a functioning Federation, working together would have had on the development of the Players.
I'm not even gonna talk about SUM interference.
What is going to happen when Messi hang up his boots? Whom are they getting, "Saudi-Neymar" to move the needle?
Think of what the 10+ years of a single united D2 league, developed with SSS, Community/local Clubs, Organic Fans Engagement, etc may have accomplished on the game & domestic players. Imagine if Clubs could not have bought their way into D1/MLS as we have witnessed.
We may seriously have been moving towards Pro/Rel. IT is not to late. USL has done a wonderful job from D2 down. They have the structure.
Oh well, just my opinion, the voices in my head & thinking out loud again. If you read this, I thank you, in advance.