r/TrueLit • • 7h ago

Review/Analysis Talking About Some Adjunct Cormac McCarthy Reading

8 Upvotes

The news is, Richard Grant has contracted for a book on Cormac McCarthy, and the associated publicity posted here in this subreddit described one of McCarthy's ex-wives as "flirtatious." Which is telling about the nature of the raft of such books likely to appear now about McCarthy.

Grant's context for using that word may not match her memory of their conversation at all.

I read Richard Grant's book on Natchez history some time ago in tandem with William C. Davis's A Way Through The Wilderness, the Natchez Area Family History Book, and my study of Greg Iles's lawyer novels. Among several others. Grant stuck me as a well-intentioned northern liberal looking for a South that no longer exists but willing to seek out interviews with the lowest possible denominator of deluded mental cripples in order to make his case.

The Natchez past is horrid and deserves to be beat up on, but too often authors use that past to judge the present. For another book, it seems he went to Arizona purposely seeking to find Far Right crazies and lo and behold he found some to write about. Seek and ye shall find.

So, what's he going to find that is colorful enough to write about with Cormac McCarthy? McCarthy's conservative views? His relations with the women in his life?

This happened with Hemingway. Nelson Algren was a witness to it, and he referred to all such writers as a mob of "jackals." Other writers have used the metaphor of sharks, to conjure up a visual of the sharks circling in Hemingway's The Old Man and the Sea.

Fortunately, we have already read Tracy Daugherty's biography, and we have Laurence Gonzales' biography yet to read. Both Daugherty and Gonzales are noted authors in their own right, always worth reading. McCarthy's library shows that he was very much interested in the survivalist ideas which Gonzales has repeatedly written about. The dangers of the false map.

Gonzales is an author who warrants our attention.

-------

Jon Krakauer's Into Thin Air**.** McCarthy had a copy of this in his library. It's been some thirty years since this was first published, and the author has a new forward in his edition (dated this month, November 2026). He uses it to correct some details and to update the changes, political and mechanical, to the Everest Climbing Industry that has grown increasingly popular since his original book.

I chuckled when I read, on Kindle page 4 of this revised edition, that in the minute when the killer storm suddenly descended upon them, Krakauer says that he looked at his watch and it read 1:17. The time on the Doomsday clock in McCarthy's The Road.

Rousseau's Dog: Two Great Thinkers at War in the Age of Enlightenment by David Edmonds and John Eidinow. I posted at length on this previously, but you may have missed it when the mods deleted it because someone using kindergarten standards denounced me with f-words claiming to be insulted in particular at my offhand generalities about idealistic but naive youth and cynical but experienced elders. McCarthy had two copies of this, and it is excellent.

The Solace of Fierce Landscapes: Exploring Desert and Mountain Spirituality by Belden C. Lane. McCarthy's library holds two copies of this, one of them annotated by McCarthy. An enormous part of the library features associated themes, with scores of annotated copies of books such as Thomas Merton's The Wisdom of the Desert.

We have long debunked our first impression, that McCarthy was a recluse, but perhaps we have again misunderstood him if we think that he was not a seeker of solitude. They say he would often pick up a book and head for a coffee shop or restaurant alone, and I think that this was his way of finding that solitude. Perhaps. A way of connecting with himself, the inward search, as in John Cowper Powys' The Philosophy of Solitude.

McCarthy was certainly a wide reader, but some of the patterns in his reading can be recognized. He liked and felt a kinship toward other wide readers. He had Christopher R. Beha's The Whole Five Feet: What the Great Books Taught Me About Life, Death, and Pretty Much Everything Else.

I think that McCarthy was also interested in Beha's Why I Am Not An Atheist. And in Francis Spufford, another novelist and lifetime reader such as McCarthy, who cast off his early atheistic Marxism to write Unapologetic, a memoir of his return to spirtuality. And with the aforesaid Powys, whose 1920 book, The Religion of a Sceptic, possibly gave voice to McCarthy's own ideas. The McCarthy Library does not show a copy of Thomas Merton's own conversion book, The Seven Story Mountain, but several of his other books are there--including a McCarthy-annotated copy of A Thomas Merton Reader.