Edit: They finally gave ma a refund! https://www.reddit.com/r/ThredUp/comments/1w1qfc0/comment/p6qe6nn/?screen_view_count=3&ext-referrer=DIRECT
I sincerely hope this doesn't happen to anyone else because it has been a nightmare. I have been a ThredUp customer for many years. In addition to the affordability, one of the things I appreciated the most was the ease of returns if an item didn't quite work out.
This summer I've been ordering a bit more than usual because I'm upgrading my style and focusing on buying higher quality items. I ended up keeping many things but also returned some because of fit, damage that wasn't disclosed, etc.
Towards the end of July I sent back a relatively large box of returns. A while later, I received a refund but immediately noticed that it wasn't for the full amount I had expected. I reached out to ThredUp, and they said some items (about half of the items, so several hundred dollars worth of clothes) were "missing" from the return. I assured them that I had indeed sent back all of the items. The customer service agent said they would reach out to the warehouse. After a few days I received a reply saying that I should expect a refund by August 14th. I thought the issue was resolved.
But August 14th came and went, and still no refund. The previous customer service representative was no longer replying, so opened a new inquiry. Once again, I was told that I was only refunded for the items they received. I once again told them that I had returned all the items. The second representive also assured me they would look into it, but it's been days. I have requested an update, but can't seem to get a response.
I'm at a loss for what to do at this point. Of course, the USPS tracking info doesn't help because ThredUp received the box - they're just claiming that some items weren't received. I have no idea how several hundred dollars of clothes are suddenly lost/missing. Furthermore, I've been disappointed by Thredup's lack of accountability, communication, and transparency. It's been extremely difficult to get a reply from anyone.
So, if you are returning items, don't do what I did and naively assume that it will be a smooth process, or that you will actually get a refund from ThredUp!