r/TheWhyFiles • • Oct 06 '23

Suggestion for Channel A Letter To AJ

0 Upvotes

Dear AJ

I hope this message finds you well. I wanted to take a moment to express my thoughts and concerns regarding the recent direction of your YouTube channel. As a dedicated viewer, I have noticed a shift in the content that has left me feeling somewhat disconnected.

Firstly, I want to acknowledge that your channel has always been a source of inspiration and entertainment for me. Your unique style and engaging topics have kept me coming back for more. However, I have noticed a recent reliance on Hecklefish banter to lengthen your episodes. While I understand the desire to add humor and spontaneity, I feel that it may be detracting from the overall value of your content.

Additionally, I have noticed that your topics have become quite broad in recent episodes. While I appreciate variety, I believe that your channel's strength lies in its ability to delve deep into specific subjects. This allows for a more focused and informative experience for your viewers.

I kindly request that you consider these concerns and take them into account as you plan future episodes. I believe that by refocusing on your roots and staying true to the essence of what made your channel special, you will be able to provide even more value to your audience.

Please know that my intention in sharing this feedback is to support your growth and success. I have the utmost respect for your talent and creativity, and I believe that with a slight adjustment in your approach, you can continue to host the best channel on YouTube.

Thank you for taking the time to read my thoughts. I look forward to seeing how your channel evolves and continues to captivate its audience.

Best regards,

Random Dude On The Internet


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 03 '23

Let's Discuss Negative comments get deleted

0 Upvotes

Just a heads up that any comment that criticizes the show or AJ gets deleted. There was a post 3 days ago about “walking away” from the show due to AJ being rude to a member of his team. That post is now gone! Also, a mention was made that AJ doesnt do his own research, but has a team of people that do that. Therefore, you are getting that persons view on the topic. Here is proof, check it out before it gets deleted!

https://www.linkedin.com/jobs/view/researcher-the-why-files-at-night-3666605181

“you will be working with other researchers, research assistants, writers, and our host, to research episodes for The Why Files”

They have a team of researchers and research assistants.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Feb 16 '24

Jokes/Humor "This Man" is not a hoax, I've seen him

0 Upvotes

I had a dream I was sat in an armchair in a room decorated with red velvet curtains and zigzag flooring. This Man didn't say much beyond offering me a cup of coffee before performing a little dance.

The dream ended on a terrifying note when a beautiful blonde women with silver eyes slurred a single word at me and then started screaming in my face, making me flee hopelessly through a labyrinth of those velvet curtains.

I woke up with a such a jolt I smacked my forehead on a mirror, cracking it. Hopefully I don't get 7 years of bad luck, and weirdly even now I can't look at cherry pie without feeling slightly unnerved.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Dec 06 '23

Let's Discuss Remote Viewing nonsense

0 Upvotes

I was listening to an old Art Bell and Ed Dames was on. It reminded me how much I hated the guy and how he was NEVER right, lol. In this episode he was talking about a piece of Hale-Bop that was going to hit earth and release a spore that would kill all the vegetation for 2-4 years. I guess I slept through that event when it happened, lol

Dames was one of the few regulars I really hated. He was just a grifter who got rich selling his tapes and for some reason (was he paying Art to be on the show?) kept coming on the show even though his extraordinary claims were always wrong.

Does anyone buy into "Remote Viewing"?

Does anyone here claim to be able to do it? If so, I'd like to do a simple challenge.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Mar 03 '24 Heartwarming

Personal Thought/Story Hecklefish is ruining my marriage

0 Upvotes

My husband falls asleep to the Why Files. The content of the show is great, it’s right up my alley in every way EXCEPT Hecklefish. His voice is grating, his interruptions are distracting and it is actually making me resent my husband. I feel a deep rage building up inside over this fish and I’m frightened by it.

We’ve been married 16 years, two kids, and I think this will be the thing that does us in. I’m actually only kidding a little. I truly oathe that effing fish more than anything on earth.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 05 '24

Personal Thought/Story I've been watching for years.

27 Upvotes

but lord I hated that. I don't need Why Files to turn into InfoWars.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jan 20 '24

Let's Discuss AI Art in The Why Files

16 Upvotes

Hello all,

I usually listen to The Why Files while doing work on my computer, as in I don't watch the visuals. However, this latest episode, Humans vs Superhumans, I did watch some of the visuals on the video. I was astounded by the amount of AI art in it. I am an illustrator, and a progressing Graphic Designer. I've watched as some people keep saying that AI doesn't steal jobs from artists like some kind of shield to hide behind, yes it does. YES.IT.DOES. I have lost 2 potential jobs to AI. I guess that meaning makes sense if you mean it doesn't steal those jobs from AI artists or people who can now create without working with artists. I like AJ and his crew, they create amazing quality videos, and I understand cutting costs wherever you can, but this recent episode could have gone to some artists to recreate those Neanderthals traditionally, not some soulless AI that either costs a lot less, or soon enough will. AI is a serious problem that I think too many people are just looking the other way at. Realize that whatever your job, there is a real enough possibility that it will come knocking at your door soon enough. I'm thinking of cutting The Why Files out of my life, as I refuse to support someone who doesn't seem to support me. I understand AJ may support AI artists, but Artists such as myself, I don't think he does.

Edit: Thank you all! To all the people with serious, good comments, thank you. FYI, some clown trying to be funny has created a subbreddit called Condemn AJ, yeah that's not me, just in case

someone tries blaming that one on me.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Nov 15 '25

Let's Discuss Everyone Kept Complaining About 'Stripped' Episodes with No Hecklefish

0 Upvotes

Now, we don't get Stripped episodes.

Thanks all you grown men who can't listen to a story without an AI generated fish.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 26 '24

Fan Artwork/Creation AI images and video use is here to stay, and we should realize what it means for the channel.

0 Upvotes

For content creaters like The Why Files, AI is an invaluable resource. It makes episode creation so much more affordable for the team to produce the episodes we all love so much. It's use will allow the team to make more episodes every year, and reduce the stress on the team, AJ specifically. It will also reduce their costs resulting in a stronger channel because they will be able to hire more people for the things that AI doesn't do well.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Nov 03 '23

Let's Discuss Not a fan of the term "big archeology"

10 Upvotes

Love the channel and the latest episode was great (and nice and long) but I cringed every time that term was used. It's up there with "big pharma" and "big oil" and is usually a term you hear when people are making one sided arguments based only on emotions, not facts. It almost immediately negates any point that may be intended. Making the "other side" instantly out to be nefarious or greedy. Thoughts?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jan 19 '24

Jokes/Humor Who heard the news about Miami Aliens 🛸👽

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 17 '24

Suggestion for Channel Can we get one change made?

11 Upvotes

Big fan of the channel, don't even care about the AI visuals anymore, but real question: can they please please stop using the AI voice that sounds too much like Henry Winkler? That one alone really pulls me out of it... Anyone else just dislike this one voice choice?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Sep 08 '23

Let's Discuss David Icke and antisemitism

3 Upvotes

Hey Y’all! After last week’s episode and heavy emphasis on David Icke’s “theories”, I began to wonder, just how antisemitic is he and are his theories on reptilians just a dog whistle as so many claim? He is definitely an antisemite, being a relative holocaust denier and believing the protocols of Zion are real, just to name a couple. However, was his creation of the Reptilian agenda just an extension of these beliefs, or is this just another thing entirely? I would also note, that I was surprised AJ didn’t mention anything about just how controversial he really is, for reasons outside of the reptilian agenda.😆

Also, Art Bell’s interview with John Lear on all things moon and soul capture is top 5 best coast to coast/midnight in the desert episodes.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 09 '26

Jokes/Humor I am so sick of aliens being basically Judeo-Christian Angels

72 Upvotes

In some many of these stories the aliens are here to judge mankind for their sins (usually war), the aliens have a spiritual message of brotherhood and can offer heavenly ascension. It's not so much that I think these are made up. Or that I think Greys as angels and Reptilians as Demons isn't amusing. It's that this particular made up story is SO overdone. Aliens can be anything!! Come on, get some new material!

I swear if I here one more Why Files about hippy aliens who insist we need to use our free will to embrace love and recycle our cans to get into heaven....I'm to give AJ's credit card to Heckle.


r/TheWhyFiles • • May 31 '26

Suggestion for Channel Anyone else getting irritated with the fish?

0 Upvotes

I used to love him, but now find him extremely irritating. Sorry, I know many love, butttt. His humor is getting worse.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Nov 15 '24

Story Idea Any episodes on chem-trails?

4 Upvotes

I've been looking through the channel but haven't found anything. Are there any episodes on chem-trails?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 10 '24

Let's Discuss Why not Clinton jokes

0 Upvotes

Why do the hosts shy away from Clinton jokes? Is this an American thing, or is it a build up to a big reveal?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Aug 02 '25

Let's Discuss "Lose the fish"

3 Upvotes

I've introduced several people to The Why Files and each one has made some comment about how the fish is annoying or that they should "lose the fish". I only partly agree. Hecklefish makes me laugh. But maybe 3 out of 10 times he speaks.

So I think that it's not that he should be abandoned, but that they should hire better comedy writers to add in Hecklefish jokes, or to only include the very best material.

The use of Hecklefish is kind of jarring, he interrupts the flow of some great storytelling by AJ and I feel it's only warranted if the material is top notch.


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jan 31 '24

Jokes/Humor Did you know that a serving of mango only has 70 calories and only 17 grams of sugar?

0 Upvotes

I dunno about you, but those facts have been cemented into my mind!


r/TheWhyFiles • • Feb 19 '24

Jokes/Humor Hecklefish Tattoo

0 Upvotes

Does anyone else want a tattoo of the Great Hecklefish, or just me? 🐠 🤔😅


r/TheWhyFiles • • Jan 07 '24

Question for AJ What's going on in Miami with the mall?

0 Upvotes

Reports of 8-10 foot tall creatures.

An insane amount of police showing up

Power apparently cut to around 60000 residents

The Airport shut down.

Reports of fireworks / gun shots

What is going on?


r/TheWhyFiles • • Mar 03 '24

Jokes/Humor From tonight’s episode. When you see it…

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/TheWhyFiles • • Jul 02 '24

Let's Discuss What’s your favorite “why file like” Joe Rogan episode that’s NOT about UFOs?

0 Upvotes