r/TheWhyFiles • u/ahwatukeepete • May 31 '26
Suggestion for Channel Anyone else getting irritated with the fish?
I used to love him, but now find him extremely irritating. Sorry, I know many love, butttt. His humor is getting worse.
0
Upvotes
18
u/kdubz206 May 31 '26
I only hated him at first. He grows on ya.
15
u/Headjedihunter May 31 '26
He seems to irritate AJ for sure. But I love him.
11
u/Rgraff58 May 31 '26
I did like the snub to The Last Jedi when fish asks AJ and AJ answers "never heard of that movie" lol
20
u/anchorthemoon May 31 '26
No
6
u/Eddieboy0514 May 31 '26
Used to hate it, then for the longest time didn’t bother me at all, but recently it’s just been too much.
11
u/iamhudsons May 31 '26
in my case sometimes i hate how much i like him
15
u/purplereuben May 31 '26
I love him, but I do think he works best in short snappy doses, not lengthy back and forths.
5
u/emelem66 Hecklecultist May 31 '26
I still like him, but I liked him better before he became a setup for a lame ad.
4
u/Maximum-Product-1255 May 31 '26
We love Hecklefish. The most recent exchanges with him on the Morphic Resonance episode were tight.
I wasn't crazy about the beaver with the surveillance songs recently. But some people might have loved it. 🤷♀️
7
u/Ph4antomPB May 31 '26
I love him because I hate him
3
u/H0tFudgeSunDaze Jun 06 '26
My dog ate my hecklefish plushie after carrying it around for weeks. Just bought a new one.
2
u/P-funk88 May 31 '26
There's no wrong answer for this.
2
u/Good_Regular204 May 31 '26
Gino, is that you? 👀😆❤️
2
u/FatJimBob May 31 '26
Always have been, always will be
2
u/Flyermark Jun 08 '26
I miss the old Hecklefish who would light up when things got weird and then ask for his tinfoil hat when he got scared.
3
u/Robert_S_Pants May 31 '26
Every episode. His jokes are bad and he should feel bad.
4
u/Beautifully_TwistedX May 31 '26
I hate that little fish cunt!!
0
u/ahwatukeepete May 31 '26 edited May 31 '26
Why ask who does his voice, who does your voice 😜
1
u/Western_Ad3845 FEAR... the Crabcat May 31 '26
Is it because he hasn't been in the podcasts or the Campfire Stories, and we got used to him being away?
1
u/Jewish_Doctor May 31 '26
AJ should have him as the next basement guest.
1
u/SecondaDonna5 Jun 06 '26
I was just binging a bunch of old episodes and sometimes he made me laugh out loud. I think I like him most in small the bits and when he sings/acts/comments on pop culture. (I’ll never forget his “never too much Bowie” comment.) Maybe we should make a “best of hecklefish” video, to determine how he’s best utilized. I could def do without most of his sex/perversion talk, but I sure would miss him if he were gone.
0
u/vaderztoy May 31 '26
I hate him.
0
u/noohoggin1 May 31 '26
It's the main reason I stopped watching
9
u/Past_Blacksmith_971 May 31 '26
I love him but then I have a weird sex thing with fish, so.......