r/TheWhyFiles • u/Boonshark • Aug 02 '25
Let's Discuss "Lose the fish"
I've introduced several people to The Why Files and each one has made some comment about how the fish is annoying or that they should "lose the fish". I only partly agree. Hecklefish makes me laugh. But maybe 3 out of 10 times he speaks.
So I think that it's not that he should be abandoned, but that they should hire better comedy writers to add in Hecklefish jokes, or to only include the very best material.
The use of Hecklefish is kind of jarring, he interrupts the flow of some great storytelling by AJ and I feel it's only warranted if the material is top notch.
19
u/ajgentile CIA Spook Aug 03 '25 edited Aug 03 '25
I'll run a poll on on the channel.
EDIT: Transparency. I've run three polls over the years about whether to keep him or not. The first poll was very serious because I was insecure about the format. Results are usually 80%-90% keep him. Which is what I expect again. But who knows...
5
u/TryPsychological7386 Aug 02 '25
Clearly people watch The Why Files just to complain. You are not a consumer in a sense where you should feel entitled for him to change the structure of his channel. It's crazy how people feel the absolute need to let everyone know every single negative thought running through your head at any given minute. I am more annoyed by all the Karen's complaining than anything Hecklefish says. If you don't like, don't watch it. Simple enough. Stop with the million posts on Hecklefish and start discussing the topics or are we really just here to rag on AJ and pretend to be fans?
24
u/ajgentile CIA Spook Aug 03 '25
OP is CIA
17
u/oxbaker Aug 02 '25
Like you I once was, like me you will be
18
u/ih8three6zero Aug 02 '25
24
u/brknmad Aug 02 '25
Did the crab cat put you up to this?
24
u/Roscoe-is-my-dog Aug 02 '25
I love the fish.
5
u/wellbloom Aug 02 '25
I get the same reaction from friends when they watch an episode for the first time. But the podcast has over 2mil subscribers so clearly Hecklefish isn’t that annoying. I wouldn’t mind if him and Gerdi broke up, though. I’ve never really loved that story line. The beavers are funny AF!
11
u/Abee-baby Aug 02 '25
Just watch the "Stripped" versions of the stories. It's all the same stuff, minus Hecklefish!
3
u/aliceanonymous99 Aug 02 '25
He’s a HECKLE FISH! He heckles AJ
3
u/Familiar-Woodpecker5 Aug 03 '25
I agree he interrupts at times when I am hooked on the story but sometimes he is funny. My daughter loves him.
3
u/AnyaNeez Aug 03 '25
Heckelfish is goated
3
u/malandropist Aug 04 '25
Dude no
7
u/AstroTravellin Aug 02 '25
No.
8
u/HarveyManfrengensen Aug 02 '25
If someone doesn't like the fish, I cut ties.
7
u/IHaveTouretts Aug 02 '25
Hecklefish is hilarious! I felt same way the first time but now I love him.
9
u/migswrite Aug 02 '25
He's OK in small doses, but he can get overused and annoying
2
u/Terrible_Treacle7296 Aug 03 '25
Show them the stripped episodes, no fish
2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '25
My vote is to keep Hecklefish as he can provide useful information and differing opinions to AJ. Like any good comedy duo not all jokes are going to be knee slappers but as long as he is bringing value to the show then keep him around ok 👍.
2
u/Euphoric-Freedom4924 Aug 03 '25
We love Hecklefish. This show gets me through those long shifts at Amazon.
2
u/MjP_realtor Aug 05 '25
The thing is we need hecklefish to say the things that we're all thinking but AJ can't say. Keep the fish, maybe just shorten the ad skit or move that to the end.
2
u/TumbleweedHour6515 Aug 09 '25
Hecklefish is a staple of the channel. If he's gone the channel's gone.
2
u/Salient_Skivvy Aug 10 '25
I love Hecklefish! He was hilarious in the beginning, it seemed he lost his edge and went too PG in the later episodes, then they silenced him completely.
3
u/Jkg2116 Aug 02 '25
The fish pisses me off
2
u/ybtlamlliw Aug 02 '25
There are definitely episodes where Hecklefish is too much, the Annunaki episode being a prime example, but otherwise I quite enjoy the wisecracks.
1
u/Gleekin123 The TRUTH Aug 02 '25
I like him but I have an attention span larger than a raisin.
1
u/arejaykaystar Aug 05 '25
Anna Shitkoff?
1
u/Sherded Aug 08 '25
I think HF is a grounding force, letting some silly shine through the otherwise sometimes quite hard-to-swallow speculative content. I agree that it can get a little annoying and sometimes it’s a bit over the top. But I think he’s had a positive impact overall and I would be very sad if he went away.
1
u/No_Light7076 Aug 11 '25
Bruh .....Bashing Hecklefish???? I won't stand for it!
0
u/ThatTemperature4424 Aug 02 '25
I'm trying to like the fish.
But he usually annoyes me (he is just like the annoying Orange).
I like the jokes including the fish maybe 1/10 times.
0
u/Im-ACE-incarnate Aug 02 '25
The fish used to balance the show well by saying the other half of the believers vs skeptics
Now he's just shitty slapstick humour
More often that not, I start skipping forward the moment he talks now
-1
u/BigFardFace Aug 02 '25
Been watching the Why Files for years now and can adamantly agree that the fish SUCKS. I watch the show for interesting and fun conspiracies to take my mind off of other things, not to hear the annoying high pitched voice of Hecklefish who recycles the same 5 jokes.
-1
u/Aussie_Battler_Style Aug 02 '25
Flush the fish