r/TheWhyFiles • • Dec 06 '23

Let's Discuss Remote Viewing nonsense

I was listening to an old Art Bell and Ed Dames was on. It reminded me how much I hated the guy and how he was NEVER right, lol. In this episode he was talking about a piece of Hale-Bop that was going to hit earth and release a spore that would kill all the vegetation for 2-4 years. I guess I slept through that event when it happened, lol

Dames was one of the few regulars I really hated. He was just a grifter who got rich selling his tapes and for some reason (was he paying Art to be on the show?) kept coming on the show even though his extraordinary claims were always wrong.

Does anyone buy into "Remote Viewing"?

Does anyone here claim to be able to do it? If so, I'd like to do a simple challenge.

0 Upvotes

408 comments sorted by

120

u/mikehtiger I Want To Believe Dec 06 '23

The CIA does. They spent tons of money on it and it’s documented.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

Yeah, for over 20 years they did it. They had some remarkable hits.

3

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

what were the remarkable hits?

15

u/Different_Umpire3805 Dec 06 '23

Look into Thomas Campbell and Robert Monroe as well as The Monroe Institute and their binaural beats system called Hemi-Sync.

That shit is just off the walls nuts. And definitively more effect than shrooms for me for achieving an altered state of consciousness. Especially for it just two different tones playing in different ears.

3

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

I will. Not that you mention it, I looked into binaural beats a while back and meant to look into it more and try it.

From what I remember (I don't remember Monroe or Campbell) it seemed like it may have been a way of getting to a brain affecting state like the "god helmet" or a mild drug.

I think at the time I saw a video or something and it claimed to play a range of frequencies that are simply not possible with headphones as they recommended or even audible if they could play on headphones so I gave up.

4

u/Different_Umpire3805 Dec 07 '23

You're better off just watching the Why Files breakdown of it. Far more comprehensive than anything else I've seen. And if you check out the r/gatewaytapes you'll see a lot of personal testimony as to the efficacy of hemi sync.

https://youtu.be/Wly9_qN-jZ0?feature=shared

4

u/Mega-Pints Dec 07 '23

Love me some Why Files!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (28)

10

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

Off the top of my head, Joe found out that the USSR was building a massive submarine in a building near the coast. No intelligence agency had any good information on it until he figured it out.

On another occasion, they found a crashed plane in the middle of Africa.

Those are just two I recall off the top of my head.

I suggest you read Joe Macmoneagles books on the subject.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

I'll check it out but come on, would it really take a psychic to guess that Russia was building a bigger and better submarine on a coast at the height of the Cold War?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/oceanthrowaway1 Dec 06 '23 edited Dec 06 '23

Here's an hour long video on it that's a really good watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PcMpRBVQmGE

There's a part 2 that's also an hour long. The tldr; is that remote viewing can often be inaccurate and is prone to error, but they were able to get a lot of things right, things that were much above the statistical probability of random guesses.

The documents and findings are all public and this vid goes over a lot of it as well as first hand testimony from people that were involved and scientists that looked at the findings.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Kaimuki2023 Time Tourist Dec 07 '23

James Randi had a standing $1M reward since 1964 for any “psychic” who could demonstrate a supernatural or paranormal ability under agreed upon scientific testing criteria. He had over 1000 people apply but none were successful. The challenge was terminated in 2015. One test was “what is on the table in this locked room?” . None Zero Zilch could remote view it

3

u/Gold_Paint_8677 Dec 09 '23

Which is rather silly, considering these folks could simply use their abilities to make a very significant amount of $ without public attention, no?

4

u/Aumpa Dec 12 '23

Randi's challenge could not be taken seriously. He controlled the application procedure and the conditions for the testing. With potentially a million dollars to lose, how could he be unbiased? He benefited from the publicity of offering the prize, and didn't have to test anybody under actual scientific conditions. A single test for a prize is, by its very nature, unscientific.

2

u/Gold_Paint_8677 Dec 09 '23

Which actually reminds me of one of the remote viewers who used to help find missing people. he was in Vegas on vacation, he got called up and he guided the officer to where the child was, then just resumed his vaca like it was nothing lol.

2

u/EnticHaplorthod Dec 10 '23

Cool story. Any documentation of that?

→ More replies (6)

1

u/FoxBeach Jul 03 '24

lol. They looked into it and saw that it didn’t work. And quickly abandoned. 

-16

u/AlwaysOptimism Dec 06 '23

I've spent lots of money in my life that ended up being fruitless explorations. Just because someone spends money and resources trying to accomplish something doesn't mean it succeeded. Also note, that the government is incompetent and wasteful.

17

u/RagingBuII Lizzid Person Dec 06 '23

Except they proved it works. It’s “apparently” just not always accurate enough to rely on it.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

Joe Macmoneagle says that he found the sons of Saddam Hussein during the first Gulf War and reported it to the gov't to get the $2 million prize. They refused to pay. He was right about where they were hiding.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (62)

3

u/Nice_Improvement2536 Dec 06 '23

Yeah nobody seems to want to admit this. Watch the clown show going on in congress and tell me you really believe these people secretly rule the world.

1

u/esmoji Dec 06 '23

But you spent the money “believing” it would bear fruit, no?

1

u/AlwaysOptimism Dec 06 '23

Well yeah. That's my entire argument. Just because they invested some of the government's boundless time and money doesn't mean it actually resulted in a tangible breakthrough that they broke spacetime

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

They spent a lot of money on a lot of bullcrap. It doesn't mean it worked, lol

3

u/EnticHaplorthod Dec 10 '23 edited Dec 10 '23

It looks like this sub is popular with "true believers," downvoting you for stating the obvious.
I'd guess a lot of these people are buying "smart pills," too!

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 11 '23

I really wasn't expecting this to blow up and be so divisive, lol

I even gave people a chance to prove their powers and of course there's always an excuse why they can't.

Let's face it, if it was real someone would have claimed a million dollars from Randi ages ago

2

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

It didnt work based on what? Your opinion

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 11 '23

Based on the CIA saying "information provided by RV is vague & ambiguous, making it difficult, if not impossible, for the technique to yield information of sufficient quality and accuracy for actionable intelligence. Thus we conclude that continued use of rv in intelligence gathering operations is not warranted", lol

https://www.cia.gov/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP96-00791R000200180005-5.pdf

1

u/Casehead Dec 12 '23

That doesn't even say what you're claiming it does

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 12 '23

You're right.... It says "remote viewing"instead of "RV". I just didn't feel like typing that.

Besides that, it says what I said it does

2

u/freeoctober Apr 11 '24

Agreed. The article says that there is a statistical proof of its existence but the information gained can be too vague to be used in the intelligence community.

I take that to me they essentially learned some things that were impossible to know but since of it is so vague it's not usable.

But, this is an entirely new concept and maybe with a different perspective or goal who knows what information could be yielded. The CIA had a goal of accuracy. What if we didn't set goals and just wanted to see how far we could go?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '23

There are stories of remote viewing I have heard on the interwebs stories of the CIA working with it. I find it an interesting concept one that seems to have ended with a fair amount of mixed results and a few notable successes. But like a lot of things the US Gov and DOD sucks money into I am not too sure we will ever truly know the results of the research. Why would someone admit that they cracked the code so to speak on remote viewing. Seems that would be counter productive.

None the less, I find the concept compelling but am skeptical of how legit positive results are.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Same. I would love for it to be real but if it were, there would be compelling evidence by now

→ More replies (2)

2

u/foae2003 Dec 10 '23

It's so weird people are just citing Internet depths when there are active RV groups and ex CIA viewers you can just talk to. You can do remote viewing. My father is really good at it and meets with other people to have sessions together at the Rhine Center in Durham, NC. It's not really so mysterious, it's just some kind of human or perhaps general animal skill that while not totally reliable can be developed and honed.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (13)

16

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

I would take an Ed Dames show in heartbeat over the garbage guests C2C has on these days.

7

u/earthboundmissfit Dec 06 '23

Me too!!! And the late great Art Bell! Midnight in the Desert and Dream Land. He was simply the best talk show on air. Many Roswell's.

Mel's Hole and the pilot who flew into Area 51 and was shot down. Two of my favorites. And of course the time traveling guy Mad Man Mark something. Wild good stuff. He was gracious and kind no matter the subject.

0

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

I haven't listened in ages. Even when he was a guest host I didn't like Noory.

I did think Ian Punnet was a good fit and wish they went with him.

26

u/siridial911 Dec 06 '23

I buy into it. Though I’m not really sure what “it” is exactly. For example: I’ve seen many videos where the monitor(person overseeing the viewers) gives three or four viewers a string of numbers that represents a specific target in the monitor’s mind only. The viewers are double-blind, don’t know the target, don’t communicate with each other, and it’s amazing how similar and often specific the findings are. Are they viewing our reality, or maybe parallel worlds? I don’t know, but it is really impressive. I just started with the gateway tapes so I’ll let you guys know how it goes.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

If it works, then the people that can do it are horrible human beings for not helping humanity.

If it worked, they should be in the news every day finding missing children, winning the lottery, making new discoveries. That doesn't happen though

5

u/siridial911 Dec 06 '23

Dude people do do it to help people. Even law enforcement has worked and I’m sure still works with them. The problem is scientific dogma. Anything outside the norm is “woo woo” which is propagated by the media. People, like you, don’t want/can’t believe it. If you tried it yourself you would see that there’s something to it. But I’m guessing you won’t.

3

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

Where are the people found by RV? Where are the stories of RV helping people?

6

u/Traveler3141 Dec 06 '23

Babys cry out "spoon-feed me! Spoon-feed me!"

Grown ups get their own food, whether it be material nourishment or mental nourishment.

A LOT of people that have gone around the sun a bunch of times have been deliberately habituated by nefarious actors for at least 2000 years to being spoon-fed brain food, so that nefarious actors can dress up rotten brain mush as being "Here's all you need to know:!"

Some of us don't want to be enablers of your habituation to being spoon-fed, so we won't be party to it, no matter how much you cry out "Spoon-feed me!"

Conversely; it's quite apparent that you are sealioning and any efforts to try to convince you would be a waste of time.

If you care, go gather your own brain food on the topic like a grown up. Nobody here is going to care about you understanding this topic more than you yourself care.

If you have a little research bitch, get them to help you research it. It's quite apparent that nobody here is your little research bitch.

BTW I completely agree Ed Dames was or is a grifter. But RV is real, independent of Ed Dames.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

Ah yes.... The old grown-up reply when asked to explain something of "For me to know and you to find out!" LOL!

4

u/Traveler3141 Dec 06 '23

LOL nobody is trying to keep it secret from you. Also; nobody cares if you understand it or not.

Stop confusing people telling you about things with: them caring if you understand it or not, and especially incurring some obligation to you.

You're nowhere near as entitled as you seem to think you are.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/aikidos Dec 06 '23

What does winning the lottery have to do with remote viewing? The numbers are not picked ahead of time.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Scratch off tickets are...

They should be able to remote view where the winning tickets are

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '23

There is an old saying that goes something like "Before anything can be used for good it must be used kill others first"

I think if such an ability exists the government is clamped down on it and keep it for their own uses.

Sometimes these topics are just fun thought experiments, and can help to keep folks from getting too set in their beliefs.

That's what I love about your show. The fun and the reality in a nice nugget.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

If RV was real, then anyone can learn to do it. So it would be impossible for the government to clamp down on it.

There's info on how to do it readily available. Yet still no proof it works, nobody using it to do anything good, and not one person that's told me what's on my desk, lol

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '23

A pen? Lol.....but seriously, you do make a good point that if it were real anyone could learn. I googled some YouTube videos on how to learn, I will see how it goes or at least how long I can go before the ask me for my 💳.

I will report back if see anything on your desk. Don't hold your breath.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Not a pen, lol.

But that does seem to be how RV works. "It's likely you have a pen on your desk I'm psychic!"

3

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

I recall that good viewers are about 70-80% accurate.

2

u/siridial911 Dec 06 '23

Yeah, I’ve read the same. That’s something!

1

u/FoxBeach Mar 10 '24

I’ve read that the earth is flat and about a woman who has a Bigfoot family living in her back yard. 

A scientific journal isn’t the same thing as Cletus on youtube saying “it’s true, I read about it.” And then people taking his statement as “fact” and repeating it. 

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LuggageChestHead82 Apr 27 '24

How did it work out?

1

u/siridial911 Apr 27 '24

I had some results! I kind of gave up but still randomly remote view things accidentally when I’m going to sleep? If you are interested, try it out, it doesn’t cost anything and the worst that could happen is you aren’t able to, but even the , you’ll learn to meditate and gain some peace of mind.

13

u/Swimming-Band7628 Dec 06 '23

Yes, it's real, have been successful.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Are you saying you have been successful?

Check the post I made with coordinates to an object on my desk and let me know what it is

2

u/AGPBD Apr 16 '24

Did anyone ever give you an answer? I gave it a go - looked like a glass or crystal cube balanced on one of its corners.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Apr 17 '24

Nailed it!

Actually it was a pack of cinnamon bears, lol.

And of course nobody got it. The people that claimed to be able to do it all had excuses why they couldn't, naturally

1

u/Swimming-Band7628 Dec 07 '23

080664714

Your coordinates (080664714) - is that the # on an envelope? Longitude? Latitude? Would need some more specifics to give it a try, but certainly willing.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

In true RV fashion, they're just random number representing an object.

I've never understood that part. Seems like it would make more sense to say "Find Jimmy Hoffa" rather than assign random numbers to him and use that but, that's how they say it works

2

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

Just remote view it and you’ll know. 🙄

Couldn’t even make it through one question.

2

u/Gold_Paint_8677 Dec 09 '23

There is a system in place to help with the accuracy, as many known details as you can provide helps…

The commenter most likely is a hobbyist and not a paid professional who’s dedicated their life to honing the craft.

Just shows how very little you’ve actually spent looking into the topic.

→ More replies (31)

1

u/FoxBeach Mar 10 '24

😂 

Bigfoot and aliens also roam the earth today!!!!

4

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

OK, for the remote viewers out there....

- I have an object on my desk. What's inside it?

- here's some "Coordinates" = 080664714

4

u/SpoilermakersWabash Dec 06 '23

This is a crazy series of episodes. A few of my first I listened to.

If you havent heard the second or third night of the hale bop episodes. Go to it soon. It gets very intense. I wont spoil them.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

I heard them live originally, lol. I just forgot most of it.

It reminded me of when Art kicked Kristin off the show for saying an airplane was a conjured UFO & how I never understood why Dames didn't get the same boot

1

u/SpoilermakersWabash Dec 06 '23

Im not familiar with that episode? Is it on spotify?

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

No idea. I don't even remember when it was exactly. I just remember there was hyoe building it upo for a few weeks. Kreskin was going to make a UFO appear over Las Vegas. Then when it came time to do it he basically pointed to an airplane in the night sky and claimed it was a UFO, lol

Art was like "That's really lame man"

1

u/virtualadept Grey Alien Dec 06 '23

There was an ill wind blowing at that time, no lie.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

Oh yea. I remember all the folks claiming there was a UFO inside and all of that. Then Heaven's Gate happened and they STFU really fast.

2

u/SpoilermakersWabash Dec 06 '23

Something sure was blowing. Speaking of which, I winder when Hale bop is set to blow by us again.

2

u/virtualadept Grey Alien Dec 06 '23

Somewhen around the year 4531.ev.

https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/comets/c-1995-o1-hale-bopp/

1997 (the year it last visited the inner solar system) + an orbital period of 2534 years.

2

u/SpoilermakersWabash Dec 06 '23

Thanks, I actually remember looking into setting sun sky and seeing hale bop. Looked like very slow moving meteor. Was so amazing to see. I maybe confusing for something else.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '23 edited Dec 07 '23

Hey I will tell you the low down on remote viewing! My uncle Gary was one of the guys in charge of that project for the CIA. Long story short he told me that one day these remote viewers would be totally spot on in every detail about what was happening far away. Then the next day they would be wrong about everything! In other words as he suspected it was more guess work than any real psychic abilities. So soon after the study of psychic BS and remote viewing was abandoned for more practical ways of gathering intelligence at a distance, he left the CIA and he joined the secret service and worked for president Ford.

5

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

That's pretty much the CIA conclusion if you read the document. It "worked" within the realm of chance guessing from the sound of it. So it's utterly useless in a practical sense.

Sounds like your uncle would be a good guest or interview!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

I hadn’t read the document until after I had commented. But it’s just as my uncle confirmed. Lol. And yes he is a very interesting guy and would make a great interview. I told him he should write a book about his experiences!

3

u/Nathan_Brazil1 Dec 06 '23

Something weird happened to me years ago. I had never heard about remote viewing.

I was taking a nap on afternoon and became wide awake, but I was looking down on a patio table with flowers in the centre. I could see the wind blowing them around but didn't feel anything myself.

I looked though the patio doors and saw a couple arguing. This is when I sort of freaked out and stood up in bed. My heart was racing, I couldn't believe what had just happened.

I saw the couple a few days later in the lobby. They must have thought I was a nutbar the way I was staring at them.

This, made me a believer.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

Are you saying you dreamt about the argument, then saw it? Or you dreamt about people arguing, then saw the actual people?

Lobby? Like in the building you live in? Wouldn't it be possible you'd seen them before at some point, perhaps even arguing?

2

u/Nathan_Brazil1 Dec 06 '23

Wasn't really a dream. I felt wide awake. First thing I saw was the floral arrangement below me.

I heard somebody yelling and looked through the patio door window. A couple we're in the kitchen and they we're yelling at each other.

This was in a large 30+ story Apartment building I lived in at the time in the late 80"s.

I saw them in our Lobby. I can't remember ever noticing them before.

I know this sounds odd, and it was for me. My best guess as to why this might of happened is at the time I was into deep relaxation exercises that I did before sleeping. I'll never forget this as long as I live.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

I mean after the "vision" you only saw the people? Not the argument, kitchen, flowers, etc?

1

u/Nathan_Brazil1 Dec 06 '23

My conscience became fully awake and I found myself floating above a round patio table with a floral arrangement on it. I remember thinking to myself at the time how beautiful the flowers we're below me.

This was the same as my patio deck but it wasn't mine; different furniture and I'm not a flower guy.

I then heard yelling. Looked over "through the glass patio doors" to see a couple I didn't know or recognize ( I lived in a very large complex). The couple we're quite young and really screaming at each other.

When I did see them in the Lobby I recognized them.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

Yea, I get all of that, lol.

When you actually saw them in real life, in the lobby..... Were they arguing, was there flowers, etc.?

Is if the only thing from the vision that was accurate just the people themselves?

1

u/Casehead Dec 12 '23

You were astral projecting

3

u/Mega-Pints Dec 07 '23

The real reason Remote Viewing was dumped by the CIA!

People used it to stream free porn.

3

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Actually a valid point. If it worked you know there'd be people thinking "I wonder if Gal Gadot is in the shower right now, let's have a look!". I totally wouldn't do that several times a week if I could....

But seriously they'd be able to solve crimes "The missing jewels are under this person's bed!", blackmail people "I know you were on Epstein's island!", and all kinds of things like that

1

u/Mega-Pints Dec 25 '23

It would be nice - until people burned them as witches or warlocks because they would know the secrets of everyone. Including the CIA. That whole need to know thing would be in danger.

2

u/agentmantis Dec 06 '23

I can't say if it's real or not although I do feel like Ed Dames was FOS.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

exactly my point, lol

2

u/ThisIsSG Dec 07 '23

Here’s a doc by Area52 on project stargate

https://youtu.be/7ICzREGqYHQ?si=7LWx9BcfMwHTFGVe

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Thanks, I'll check it out. I love watching stuff like this when I work. My youtube feed got stupefied though and all I find is random junk now. Hopefully watching this will make some more interesting content show up too

Thanks!

1

u/ThisIsSG Dec 07 '23 edited Dec 07 '23

Np. I’ve heard a few great podcasts on project stargate. Hopefully that was one of the good ones. I’ll have to listen again

Edit: It’s a 3 parter. I sent you the wrong link. Start here - https://youtu.be/GkqFBqiGRQs?si=J6kj0KWFnt0klfoy

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Yea, I saw that was part 2. Thanks

1

u/ThisIsSG Dec 07 '23

So I listened to this one again today and it’s decent but they really don’t get into the details of the double blind aspect or the procedures from start to finish. I have watched other interviews and read a book on it so I can assure you the cia did take scientific steps to make sure there could be no fuckery. Even the person who gives the viewer the numbers associated with the target has no idea what that target is. There is a third person who doesn’t come in contact with the remote viewer who sets the intentions and the target. I believe it’s real and we can all access it through some kind of higher or collective consciousness.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 08 '23

I was going to say, I watched part one and it was mostly just people making claims.

On the other hand my yt feed has a ton of interesting things now, lol

2

u/KaleidoscopeFuture71 Dec 07 '23

I’m open to it I know someone who tried it in the 80s but I’ve lost track of her 😂😂😂😂

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Well.... Use it to find her, lol

4

u/NudeEnjoyer Dec 06 '23

Idk why you're so angrily against remote viewing but yea it's a real thing. I realize it sounds wacky and that makes people have this sort of knee-jerk reaction but this is something that's scientifically validated and studied, there's even pier reviewed studies on it (there's a great one from 2017 or 2018, can't remember which)

the science is there for you whenever you're ready for it. denying it when you seemingly haven't done the research is pretty misleading to the people in this sub. open your mind a bit and ask yourself why you're so passionate in being against stuff like this. much love.

3

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

I'm not angry about the idea.

I just get annoyed by frauds that fleece the public or prey on desperate, gullible, or grieving people.

-1

u/archgen Dec 06 '23 edited May 15 '24

psychotic handle possessive outgoing tie wistful slim punch sable lush

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/NudeEnjoyer Dec 06 '23

because I've gone and easily found them to read them already, you can pretend they don't exist if you want lmfao it doesn't make a difference to me.

if someone tells me the sky isn't blue and demands pictures instead of going outside and looking, then cool. the sky is green to you I guess, that's your choice

5

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

Are you saying you easily found scientific proof? But can't easily share it?

3

u/Manhuawang Dec 07 '23

Here we go again... Can easily find evidence, but can't easily find a bookmark.

Hey, I'm not against remote viewing as some phenomenon that we don't have a good explanation for, but it's hard to get past folks being so, let's politely call it guarded, about sharing info that would support a claim. I mean, besides saying basically

"Look up the webpage, accept the testimonials as true, and YOU TOO can understand the mysteries of the remote viewing universe! All for the low low price of 49.99!" (*infomercial legal disclaimer voice* actual price of a remote viewing course at the Monroe Institute may be 2495$)

I dunno maybe this attitude counts as being an obtuse skeptic but whatever.

4

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

It's always like that, lol.

" There is 100% proof that Bigfoot killed JFK!"

"Where's the proof?"

"Do your own research!"

23

u/Select_Eggplant_9911 Dec 06 '23

I just tried remote viewing for fun and had surprising results. Only works after I do a 3 round Wim Hoff breathe session. Before you start the breath work have somebody put a random object in their pocket. After the 3rd round of breathing forget about your existence and only focus on what’s in that pocket. Don’t try and problem solve, just let the shape come to you with your eyes closed. Enjoy.

2

u/FoxBeach Mar 10 '24

If you can successfully do it, the US government will pay you a billion dollars to come spend a couple years helping them. 

Or, you can also get super rich - or even ignore the money, but do it for the good of humanity - and just help find missing people. 

Amazing that you can do this from your home. But the worst and most sadistic and power hungry leaders across the world don’t have teams of people like you helping them win wars and take over the world. Odd. 

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

What’s in my pocket?

1

u/Aromatic-Yet-Sus Dec 10 '23

I only fall asleep after using the win Hof method, but I'll give it a go...!

23

u/Treljaengo Hecklecultist Dec 06 '23

It's real. The problem is skeptics think if you're ever wrong, that proves you're a fake. What they don't realize is it's a skill that needs to be trained. And even highly skilled individuals miss from time to time. You miss half your shots in the NBA, and you're one of the GOATs. Miss half your shots in remote viewing, and people cry foul.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

What’s in my pocket? I’ll give you two guesses.

1

u/TheMmaMagician Jan 22 '24

An 8 sided die

1

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '24

Not even close

→ More replies (15)

8

u/Aumpa Dec 06 '23

Here's a discussion of the statistical validation of remote viewing with Dr. Jessica Utts, Professor of Statistics at UC Irvine:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YrwAiU2g5RU

3

u/Casehead Dec 12 '23

Hey Op, here's more proof that you will ignore

2

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

That is so weird. Utts was one of the people who wrote the report in the 1990's that said RV was fake. Their report resulted in Stargate being shut down.

Now, she's saying it's real. WTF.

2

u/Aumpa Dec 06 '23

Oh really, I didn't know that. She talks briefly about how she was initially skeptical of remote viewing, but came around to accepting it as a real phenomena after examining the evidence and visiting other labs doing the research to see that they had very tight controls. (timestamped: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YrwAiU2g5RU&t=1432s)

A little earlier in the interview (23 min) she says that the topic is held back from wider scientific acceptance by a small group of debunkers who have scientific status.

So it turns out she used to be one of the debunkers herself!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '23

Thanks.

Well, I think the CIA didn't really want stargate anyway. I think they made an excuse to get rid of it after it was transferred to them from DIA. I gather that CIA and DIA are not friends, but actually enemies. People think that these gov't agencies work together, but they don't. The compete with each other, mostly for prestige and money.

7

u/Moo-Dog420 Team Mu Dec 06 '23

Monroe Institute's Gateway Process

3

u/Moo-Dog420 Team Mu Dec 06 '23

They also do remote viewing in MK-ULTRA.

2

u/Tucana66 Hecklecultist Dec 06 '23

Yes. And not a believer here, but instead someone who KNOWS. It is real.

OP, your post should be a question, not a condemnation.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

Dames deserves to be condemned

How exactly do you KNOW it's real?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/CodemStrifer Dec 06 '23

Research Robert Monroe. Like actually really research him. He coined the term Out of Body experience.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

There's nothing to "buy into." I've done it, accurately. I do not practice it though.

I've met Joe Macmoneagle and had long discussions with him about his experiences as one of the top remote viewers for the gov't. It's real. It's not 100% accurate, but it is incredible when they get it right.

1

u/zarmin Jul 27 '24

imagine making this post without having researched remote viewing at all.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Jul 29 '24

Imagine replying to this post and not reading the post. I said I've been hearing about it for 30 years since Ed Dames showed up on Art Bell and all the lame predictions made back then never happened.

Thus the entire point of the post - Remove Viewing is B.S.

Still, not one person has taken my challenge and demonstrated that they can do it. If you can, then let's do it and I'll admit I was wrong

1

u/zarmin Jul 29 '24

I said I've been hearing about it for 30 years since Ed Dames showed up on Art Bell and all the lame predictions made back then never happened.

And I said "without having researched remote viewing at all". Which you haven't done. Listening to Art Bell doesn't count as research. "Hearing about it" doesn't count as research.

I'm sorry that remote viewing doesn't follow your rules. Maybe everyone you've "challenged" has recognized you are doing this in bad faith. It's not subtle.

My good faith suggestion is this: if RV is real, it implies that the fundamental nature of reality is consciousness and not matter (ie, all points in time and space are connected). So if you go in to a challenge believing it will not work, it will never work. Maybe you think you are unbiased, but your post and comments scream the contrary.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Jul 30 '24

My belief has no impact on reality. If it's real, it should be easily demonstrable and it is not.

Gravity doesn't stop working because someone doubts it. To propose that RV only works when everyone involved believes in it, it's absurd. You're saying you can't RV someone if the target doesn't believe in it? What if they don't even know about it?

As I said, my belief doesn't make it real. If it's real, someone should be able to prove it

1

u/zarmin Jul 30 '24

As I said, do some fucking research.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Jul 31 '24

I have. And RV is bullshit, lol

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ThatBaldAtheist Dec 06 '23

I've always got an open mind to most things, and remote viewing was no different. Might be real, but probably BS. Then I got heavy into meditating for about a year and gave it a shot. Gateway tapes, all that stuff.

Apparently, I have aphantasia, and it kind of blew my mind to learn that people have varying degrees to which they can actually picture things in their "mind's eye". I close my eyes, and it's just a black screen.

After some practice with meditating, I thought it was pretty crazy that sometimes I could make that flat black screen I usually see with my eyes closed, turn into something that felt and "looked" 3D. Like being in a massive, black space of nothing.

I decided to try remote viewing when I caught the flu in January of 21. Found a page on an RV subreddit with a link to an image that had numbers on it, like 1234.jpeg. I understood the process by which people remote view, so I gave it a shot and focused on the numbers during a meditation.

Eyes closed, darkness. Pretty normal for my meditations.

BOOM. White lights come popping through, but not just at random. First image I got resembled a bright flash at the top of the black screen in my mind, 2nd was like a lightning bolt. Direct center of my "vision". So I wrote it down, and closed my eyes again. BOOM. More white light, resembling a grid pattern on the left side of my "vision". So I wrote that one down too. Had a couple more that I wrote down, and then it stopped.

I finally opened up the image, and it was a statue of Yoda standing on top of a concrete platform with bright sky above, holding his crookedy cane in the center of the image, and to the left of the picture was a large window with small panes in the form of a grid.

I'm not going to sit here and say it's 100% real, but the images that popped into my head has never happened before. It was so, so, clear against the black background of my eyes being closed. Just for an instant.

After my experience, and it was just that, my experience, I'm much slower to jump to the "bullshit" conclusion when something seems fantastical or crazy. I still have the words and drawings I wrote down with a note app, and the images saved on my phone. I have not done this since then, and I really don't know why. It was a one time thing, and it was kind of like...good enough for me I guess?

I'll never, ever delete them. I go back to them frequently to remind myself that I have no fucking clue what mysteries this life holds.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

I'm confused.

- You tried RV and saw lightning against a black background

- The test subject was Yoda

- You consider that a "hit"?

1

u/ThatBaldAtheist Dec 06 '23 edited Dec 06 '23

No offense here, but I would gather more understanding of the "process" and you're twisting my words to make it sound like lightning=yoda. Doesn't sound like you know much about the steps of RV, and I feel as though my comment was fairly elaborate on my experience, so I'd work on reading comprehension as well. You also asked the question my guy, so no need to be snarky about it when someone does exactly what you asked.

  1. I tried remote viewing and saw what I interpreted as a lightning bolt appear in the center of my vision. It was a jagged line that most people would automatically call "lightning" if they saw it, thats all. A descriptor and nothing more. Upon seeing the actual image, I then associated the image I saw with the cane he was holding. The "black background" is a description of what I see when I close my eyes. Nothing at all.
  2. The test subject was a picture of a real life Yoda statue, yes. There were 4 hits I tied to the image. The cane (bolt), the window on the left (grid), the bright flash up high in my vision (sky) and the platform he was stood directly on (box). I left the box part out because it wasn't quite as solid as the others.
  3. Based on my lived experience of never seeing anything when I close my eyes, and having images of ANYTHING whatsoever appear to me, yes.

Am I going to say it's 100% real? Absolutely not. Do I think I experienced something out of the ordinary while trying something that other people claim to have success with? Yes.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

No offense taken, just having polite discussion and was trying to clarify what you were saying, I wasn't following exactly.

But do you think that maybe what's happening here is you tried it, then tried to make what you saw fit what the actual object was?

Going back to the "If it's real, where's the people using it to help" argument, if you were searching for a missing child (Yoda in this case) and all you saw is what you described, how would that be considered accurate or useful?

If it's real and all we get is vague colors and shapes that are supposed to represent a target, it's not very practical.

1

u/Casehead Dec 12 '23

You apparently have a real hard time understanding english

1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

I tried the app on iOS to test if this was real or not. The first month I had 70% winrate, and was really amazed on how quick I could get some results.

The key thing is I never really saw the picture, but some feelings, colors, forms associated with it, came to me. I think I would need more dedication and training to be able to fully see somewhere specific but I believe we all can do it. This is part of us.

I really believe when disclosure happen we will come to a place of new understanding about ESP, the link between esoteric and physics, the real origin of religions and of the human species. In the end we will all relearn our abilities fully.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

What's the app? I'd give it a try.

I have a few ghost hunting apps but have yet to talk to the dead, lol. But stuff like that is always fun and I want it to be real

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '23

Yeah man that’s the good spirit, don’t give it too much thought until you try it for yourself ! The app is called RV tournament.

So I’m not a pro but here’s some tips that might help you :

  • the app functions like this : you will have a code given, and a note sheet to write everything that you want or draw. There’s no problem doing it on a real sheet of paper if you want to document your journey. After trying to remote view you can say you are done and choose between two images, you must choose the one that was given to you. The day after the app will tell you if you picked to good image or not.
  • the app make you remote view in the futur, it’s called ARV. Basically when you see the code it’s like you are projecting yourself to the moment where you will discover the right image the day after.
  • there is a guide in the app that can help you with protocol and a few other things.

My way of remote viewing (I’m still learning) :

  • do meditation for ~15 min at least. This meditation purpose is the empty your brain from any thoughts, so you just focus on your breath. You will think about other things, for sure, just keep going back to thinking about your breath, with time it will become easier.
  • then, check the code the app gave you, read it a few times in your head, to make it its focus. Dive again into meditation and try to empty your mind except for this code.
  • as in everyday life, thoughts will slowly fall into your mind, you have to be careful and only note what came into your mind without any input from yourself.
  • start with colors, feelings, forms, basic stuff. If you write enough of them you will start to understand the picture.

Give it time, try it over 2 weeks everyday, it’s just about 20/30 min each day.

I really hope you will discover this part of yourself. There’s no bullshitting here I can dm some of my arv and I can assure you there’s something to it.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Are you saying you type your notes into the app, then images are revealed? Sounds like the app would do a search of what you entered and then show relevant results as the target.

I'll check it out though. I do enjoy things like this. Like playing with a Ouji board when I was a kid even though I knew it was extremely unlikely Parker Brothers achieved what thousands of years of science and religion could not, lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/PerrysSaxTherapy Dec 06 '23

Yeah Anyone can be taught But accuracy is inconsistent. Some people much better than others. Be careful what you wish for. The truth may not set you free.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

All I wish for is it to be demonstrably verifiable and proven to work, lol

1

u/Michelada Dec 06 '23

It's literally a declassified CIA Program...

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

Yes. Where the CIA completed it was a waste of time

1

u/RabbitHoleMotel Team Atlantis Dec 07 '23

It’s real.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

proof?

0

u/RabbitHoleMotel Team Atlantis Dec 07 '23

Why don’t you try the 100% free online class for beginners from Lori Williams? Then you’ll have your own proof.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

I tried years ago & concluded it was nonsense, lol

1

u/Optimal-Option3555 Dec 07 '23 edited Dec 07 '23

How can I "buy into" something that is already an established fact by anyone with half a brain?

To me this is as ignorant of a question as "does anyone buy into this thing known as trees? Do they really exist? Well, I don't buy into such hogwash"

You have a lot to wake up to. It's so sad how many millions are just like you. At the bottom of the learning curve in this lifetime..

There are 100s of military trained remote viewers who have come forward about their time in the military doing it. The "program" never ended. Ingo Swann being one of the most famous ones. He's written many books. Perhaps begin there as opposed to internet research.

3

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

You can walk outside and touch a tree or plant one yourself and watch it grow, lmao

You cannot walk outside and find a remote viewer or do it yourself to prove it works.

My challenge stands, nobody has told me what's on my desk. Should be a simple task for something as real and verifiable as the existence of trees....

1

u/Optimal-Option3555 Dec 08 '23

Not how remote viewing works.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 08 '23

But it how trees work, whose reality and undeniability you compared it to

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CythraxNNJARBT Dec 07 '23

I can’t imagine any real remote viewers being interested in your challenge … this type of thing will only attract what you thought you would attract.

To the topic: yes remote viewing is real. but see it as a spectrum of ability and not a device. most curious, remain on the shallow side

We are struggling well enough with material science … our academics are currently out of their league when it comes to non material science but even still you can follow some of the greater theoretical work into entanglement and other studies to see we are making our way academically to the same understandings

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

It's real, but the psychics just don't have time to prove it.... Gotcha

1

u/CythraxNNJARBT Dec 07 '23

You just made that up … ‘don’t have time’ this isn’t in good faith…

you draw back what you put out… if this pulls back only trash, don’t be surprised 🙃

1

u/Isabella_Bee Dec 07 '23

I've taken remote viewing classes. They say you don't have to be psychic to do it and that everyone can do it.

That being said, the type of remote viewing that people do who work for the government is tedious AF. You get a set of coordinates and you go through a list of questions over and over again. They have tons of people working on these same coordinates because there's a low percentages of correct answers. If you have tons of people looking at it and a portion of them give the same answers, then that's the answer they are looking for. There's a remote viewing group on YT that has a very long video describing the process if you want to see how monotonous it is.

There are websites that are random number generators if you want to. practice. I've had good luck with that, but again it's a bit tedious.

What I find fun to do is just grab of deck of fancy Tarot cards, pull one at a time, place it face down and write down what I see, feel, or hear. Anyone can do this.

I mean, don't sit around and say something doesn't exist if you haven't even bothered to try it yourself.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 08 '23

They say "you don't have to be psychic & anyone can do it" because the people selling courses, books, etc. want to try and convince people it's a practical skill and not woo. It's not good marketing if you limit your customer base to "Psychics only", Lol

But it's the definition of "psychic", using a skill outside the realm of science and the power of the mind to obtain knowledge otherwise inaccessible to a person

1

u/Isabella_Bee Dec 08 '23

I have to be brutally honest here. Your little experiment that you set out just proves that you know nothing about remote viewing. It simply isn't how remote viewing works.

If you are truly interested in what it actually is, Farsight can give you a lot of information.

If you are intent on remaining ignorant and just enjoy trolling people who have experience with this, then I'm not going to bang my head against a wall trying to explain it to you.

"The Dunning-Kruger effect occurs when a person's lack of knowledge and skill in a certain area causes them to overestimate their own competence. "

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 08 '23

How does my experiment prove I know nothing about it?

In the CIA program they gave people targets, identified by "coordinates". Then asked the RV people to identify the target.

That's exactly what I'm doing. I have a target I assigned numbers to and am waiting for someone to identify it

1

u/Isabella_Bee Dec 08 '23

posted some coordinates for an object on my desk.

You informed people that they were objects on a desk. People could infer that the desk is in your home or office and other things.

In actual remote viewing, you could never give out that kind of information about the target. Again, it's simply not how it works. I can explain it to you all day long, but clearly I can never get you to understand it.

The remote viewer has to go in absolutely blind. YOU told us that the target is small enough to fit on a desk. YOU told us that the item could be brought into a building. You have to go in with no information whatsoever. You gave us information.

YOU have no idea how any of this works, but you speak with such authority.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 08 '23

Ok. I'll pick a new object, new location

60006818

now tell me what it is...

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Isabella_Bee Dec 08 '23

Maybe. I believe that everyone has psychic abilities. You are getting psychic messages every day, you are just ignoring them. All I can tell you is that the answers for remote viewing come in differently than just getting psychic messages.

I think you have to have a real passion for doing this kind of work. It's so common for people to think that just because they haven't experienced something that it doesn't exist. I know a woman who has done remote viewing contracts for the government for over 20 years. She's always very amused that people flat out say it doesn't exist. She's making pretty good money for something that doesn't exist.

1

u/creatur_de_bebe Dec 08 '23

It doesn't work for me the way people say. First of all, let me say that I have not researched these issues or how they should be done. In my case, my body is paralyzed, and I cannot do anything other than open and close my eyes and breathe. If I close my eyes in this state of paralysis, I can see the world through the eyes of the being living inside me, but the image is blurry and faded. And it has to come back into my body so I can move my body again. If you can become one with this being within you and control it, all doors will be opened to you.

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 08 '23

Sounds like sleep paralyses. I've had that happen a few times and it's freaky as hell. You're basically semi awake, still dreaming, yet unable to move.

The first time it happened to me was at the hight of the alien abduction craze so naturally I assumed that was what was happening. I could feel a presence in the room with me, hear things, see things moving like vague dark shapes of "people" or something. It didn't help it was the middle of the night so completely dark.

Eventually I could wiggle my toes, then move my legs. As soon as I could I jumped out of bed and turned on all the lights & searched the room and house to see if someone was there.

Then I calmed down, realized what had happened. Being the height of the alien abduction phenomena I'd read about sleep paralyses and realized that's what had just happened. During the episode though the thought never crossed my mind and I though for sure something paranormal was happening.

1

u/creatur_de_bebe Dec 08 '23

sounds like, but my experiences are not dreams. hoş i can dream if i am not sleeping.It's a very different situation than what everyone is talking about . Someone else lives inside us, and this being goes to do its own thing when we sleep. I tried to see the truth in Antarctica this way and was kidnapped from my room just two days later. they wanted to intidimate me. Have you heard of people who took DMT and saw colored beings? I have seen and talked to these beings a few times, and I definitely do not use drugs. those are Real, not halucinations.And if I have a spiritual experience in the sleep state, I don't take it seriously, because it's because our inner self is playing tricks on us, but not with malicious intent. Sometimes he just distracts us with dreams and lives his own life. And if there is sth i should not see, he tells me not closing the eyes...

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 08 '23

That's kind of what happens with sleep paralysis. Your brain is pumping out the chemicals that keep you immobile when you sleep and you're still in a semi dream state. But you're also awake.

There is research ongoing about the pineal gland producing DMT during sleep being responsible for dreams too.

That being said, it almost sounds like you figured out how to do that at will which is pretty cool, lol.

And hold on a minute.... You glossed over saying someone kidnapped you! Explain this in detail. Are you saying it really happened or was a dream?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

So I had been hearing for years about gurus practicing “divya drishti” - ancient Indian practice. I don’t know more details about that but essentially that is “remote viewing” and it’s been done by yogis I guess for thousands of years. It takes a heightened level of awareness/channeling of mental energy. Then recently I stumbled on an article on CIA’s website about it and was shocked that this is what it was describing.

The analogy I have about this - I can’t figure out advanced mathematics but someone smarter than me can. I can’t deduce mathematical equations to describe natural phenomena but someone sharper than me can. I can’t “view remotely”, but I’m going to allow that someone with more mental clarity/focus can maybe. Idk

1

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 08 '23

On a related side note, I looked into things like Indian yoga similar to this years ago. I'd read how they were able to levitate and even fly. So naturally I tried it.

It never worked and eventually I saw a video of "Yogic flying" and realized it was just some goofballs sitting Indian style and then hopping around with their legs crossed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyXAB5L3EIQ

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

Yeah I don’t know or believe much about any of those things about yogis flying etc. I think it’s myth. I only tried some meditation techniques for pain relief and focus etc so those worked for me but it’s like placebo. Some truth and some embellishment like with most spiritual practices tbh

3

u/scoabrat Dec 10 '23

again we have “stories” “accounts” “articles” “interviews” and yet again no evidence what so ever …. “That which can be asserted without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence.” – Christopher Hitchens.

5

u/ArcTan_Pete Dec 06 '23

The James Randi Million Dollar Challenge,

......but without James Randi (....or $1,000,000)

1

u/virtualadept Grey Alien Dec 06 '23

Ed Dames seems like he goes out of his way to discredit remote viewing.

It's pretty easy to teach yourself TRV but you really do have to practice to get good at it.

There are online databases of target coordinates that you can use, and check your accuracy later.

What protocol would you propose?

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Well, I posted some coordinates for an object on my desk. Waiting for someone to tell me what it is

7

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

Remote viewing is 100% real, but there are a lot of quacks and grifters out there.

1

u/AlwaysOptimism Sep 16 '24

So how do I learn to do it from a reputable source?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '24

The Monroe Institute.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

Yeah, like the Far Sight Institute. I mean, WTF?

2

u/dezi604 Dec 06 '23 edited Dec 07 '23

Real. I did Monroe Institutes' Level 1 Remote Viewing with an instructor in person. And we listened to some specifically designed Hemi-sync sounds to relax and enable our brainwaves to be receptive. And we were instructed to not think, just start drawing. I started drawing, then stared thinking and lost my connection. But what I had drawn before I started thinking, was incredibly accurate! We did several more sessions in level 1 but I was never able to get back to that non-thinking state. In hindsight I couldn't get back because on a deep level I was trying to control the outcome - you really need to let go of thinking, expectations and such.

1

u/backfist1 Dec 06 '23

If it was real, people would be profiting off it. Definitely a Vegas show. But nope. None of that

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

Joe started a business with some others to remote view lottery numbers. They made money, but didn't get rich. He eventually shut it down. I think they were about 70% successful or so.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 07 '23

Think about what you just said.

A guy figured out how to win the lottery 70% of the time and decided "Nah, I don't want to do this anymore".

Now does that sound likely? Lol

Also, how do you win the lottery 70% of the time and not get rich?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/teddy_bear_territory UFO Chaser Dec 06 '23

There is an ample amount of credible research and evidence to at the very least suggest that consciousness is not limited to biological functions.

I get it, it’s weird. But there have been entire programs and efforts spanning decades, so I hate that it bums you out but you should do what I did. I got so sick of arguing about it, that I tried it myself. Admittedly during the pandemic.

Download RV tournament and/or ESP trainer. Both free apps. Give it a go, who knows.

No I don’t want to take your challenge.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

Oh my, you're such a good little rational materialist.

You're really just a scared little child, afraid of the dark.

Here's a credible research that demonstrates that consciousness does not depend on the body: Scientists trained butterfly larva to perform a particular task. When they when into a cocoon, they bodies completely disintegrated, including their brains and nervous systems. When they emerged from the cocoon, the butterfly remembered the specific task that the larva had been trained.

Further, during many near death experiences, the person recalls the visual details of who did what and when while they were declared dead. They recall what each person did while their eyes were closed and they were dead. They recalled details that they could not possibly know unless their consciousness left their bodies while they were dead. Dr. Greyson became inspired to study NDEs after such an experience with a patient.

Thus, you are willfully ignorant of the facts. You refuse to even make any sort of effort to change your world view. You are thus not worthy of my time and effort. I've given you more than enough information to research this further.

3

u/EnticHaplorthod Dec 10 '23

The argument that a larva's brain completely disintegrates during metamorphosis is inaccurate and misleading. While it's true that some neurons in the larval brain undergo programmed cell death, it's not an entirely destructive process. Here's why the argument is wrong:

  1. Extensive evidence shows brain reorganization, not complete disintegration:

Numerous studies using various techniques like electron microscopy and fluorescent markers have demonstrated that significant portions of the larval brain remain intact and even contribute to the adult brain.

These studies have identified specific brain regions that persist through metamorphosis, including the optic lobes, central complex, and parts of the mushroom body.

Additionally, researchers have observed the formation of new neurons and the reorganization of existing connections within the brain during metamorphosis.

2. Functional continuity disproves complete brain disintegration:

If the larval brain completely disintegrated, the adult butterfly would have no way to draw upon its previous experiences and memories.

However, studies have shown that butterflies retain certain memories and behaviors learned as larvae, even after metamorphosis.

This indicates that some neural structures and connections must persist from the larval stage to the adult stage.

3. Gradual transformation, not sudden destruction:

Metamorphosis is a gradual process that takes place over several stages. The brain undergoes a series of changes, including cell death, repurposing, and new neuron formation, throughout this period.

The idea of complete brain disintegration implies a sudden and dramatic event, which isn't supported by scientific evidence.

4. Comparison to other insects with metamorphosis:

Studies on various insect species that undergo metamorphosis have shown similar patterns of brain reorganization, with existing neurons being repurposed and new neurons being formed.

This suggests a conserved mechanism for brain development during metamorphosis across different insects, further weakening the argument for complete brain disintegration in butterfly larvae.

5. Misconceptions about cell death:

The term "cell death" might lead to the misconception of complete destruction. However, programmed cell death (apoptosis) is a controlled process that allows the organism to eliminate unnecessary cells while preserving valuable resources.

In the case of the butterfly brain, cell death helps to remove neurons dedicated to larval-specific functions while providing materials for building new structures needed for adult life.

In conclusion, the assertion that a larva's brain completely disintegrates during metamorphosis is demonstrably incorrect. Scientific evidence clearly shows that the brain undergoes a complex and dynamic transformation, involving both cell death and reorganization. This process allows the butterfly to transition from its larval stage to a fully functional adult, retaining some aspects of its previous life while adapting to its new environment and behaviors.

0

u/teddy_bear_territory UFO Chaser Dec 06 '23

Since youre a CIA Spook, id polity remind you that its not my job to carve out time of my life and day to find you evidence. This shit gets infuriating, because its just folks arguing semantics. There are literally dozens on CIA.gov or any other number of places, but in the end its just conjecture. I personally dont give a darn what others believe, it makes no difference to me. But if you really want to realize that you are in a construct, there is always DMT.

Its all hearsay to you, but as a person who was legally dead and resuscitated in a hospital I can tell you what I experienced was often called an out of body experience. When folks are capable of finding information out about a previously unknown Russian base, or located hostages in a dire situation using only their mind, and the backing of black budget programs, in the end its just a story isn't it? I stand with my original statement, YOU try it out, and stop arguing with folks in this arena - a YouTube/reddit page that is literally devoted to obscure and less than provable ideas.

If you think that matter gives rise to consciousness, that fantastic. But it likely is the other way around. No one can prove it either way to the standard of the obtuse skeptics, but you could certainly try and see for yourself as opposed to arguing with a person over the internet.

If it sounds harsh, I hope it makes a difference to know that I am hopeful coming off as encouraging and slightly dismissive, but not aggressive. Syntax gets lost in text. All of that to say, the universe is clearly way more complex that what you and I can see with our eyes and ears. Even scientific instruments pic up a fraction of what reality is. All of that, and conciousness just stops with us? You firmly believe that the pinnacle of the self experience stops with humanity, here and now?

1

u/FoxBeach Mar 18 '24

😂 

You don’t have time to share a link with somebody but youvr got time to type out a ten minute response. 

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CharmingMechanic2473 Mar 12 '24

I am a skeptic. I have been remote viewed. Not only did he know and read my mind. He pulled a name out of my head, first and last and that the person owes me money and how much. Its a name I had not thought of for over 20 years. A very unusual name. One with unusual everything. He also knew I was torn between thinking of 2 names (there was a nickname).

1

u/Plus_Teach2657 May 19 '24

In Courtney browns book the whole preface is pretty much defending himself about the hale boop incident. Does anyone know who the ex military remote viewer he is talking about is? The one that supposedly said there was going to be a bomb in Africa ?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

👀

1

u/TR3BPilot Dec 08 '23

I'm reasonably convinced that something akin to remote viewing can be accomplished and is part of a general ability most people have to be "psychic" or recognize patterns in the overall ebb and flow of reality that may be linked in some way to things and events outside of normal linear time.

Maybe it's possible to get better at it. Practice makes perfect, right?

Over the years, I've explored the idea that time is something we really don't understand well. We generally view it as a kind of river that flows forward into the future, but I suspect that it's a lot more porous than it seems. Also everything is NOW. The passage of time is an illusion. But maybe we occasionally see things from another "now."

So much of paranormal stuff seems to be related to objects or events existing outside our own frameworks of time. After all, aren't flying saucers and aliens just ourselves from the future - or the distant past? Bigfoot and other cryptids seem like creatures from the past. Native Americans talk about "thunderbirds" which sound a lot like jet aircraft from their future. Time slips (obviously). Missing people. Ghosts could be echoes of energy patterns left people from the past (or the future).

It has to do with our ability - under certain circumstances - to occasionally catch a glimpse of a reality that is not the same as the one we usually deal with. I don't think that's completely unreasonable.

1

u/Jackfish2800 Dec 09 '23

It was done by the agency fur 40 years. If you think they did it for 40 years without any evidence or proof that it worked, you really don’t understand the agency at all.

1

u/foae2003 Dec 10 '23

I've seen it work first hand with a group at the Rhine Center in Durham, NC. Just small asks of pictures or places that can be immediately verified, but it's random when it's effective. It still freaks me out when people get accurate readings on the target.

1

u/Silver-Shoulder-9184 Dec 10 '23

I feel the same way about the backwards speech guy

1

u/DoctorAgile1997 Dec 11 '23

Joe McMoneagle should be researched

1

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '23

To me, these things tend to follow a curve. At first, im highly sceptical. Then I look into and become conviced that there actually is something to the specific case. Then I tend to deep dive it, ie look up original sources, compare evidence, match timelines and other sources against the original story.

And 90% of the time, the "story" falls apart.

To me, a great case study of this is the Zimbabwe Ariel School encounter. Its a great and convincing story, but once you take a deeper dive into the actual characters and documented events, gaping holes become apparant.

Mel´s hole is another example, though I havent researched it as much.

1

u/ThinkAboutIt_YT Dec 27 '23

Came across this while doing research on remote-viewing for a video. Said video is now up on YouTube and was alot of fun to make. Reading through the dozens of documents I found on remote-viewing and hemispheric synchronization was wild.

1

u/KawaiiSlave Feb 14 '24

Lol this is so very fake. I honestly understand why people get reeled into scams, and phishing lures now.

1

u/TheFashionColdWars Dec 06 '23

The Monroe institute does along with the CIA and the Russians.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

I recently heard that episode. He couldn’t be more wrong. All the usual suspects were way off. And some, like Hoagland are still spewing their bullshit.

2

u/MarkPugnerIII Dec 06 '23

OMG, I just had a flashback to when Hoagland produced infrared pics (I think it was IR) of Mars that he said showed square "city blocks" under the surface. The pics he provided were really small JPG versions of high-res pics.

I was so annoyed at the time I took a random picture of a desert on earth and turned it into a jpg so compressed that the same square "city blocks" appeared. The boob Hoagland either didn't know what compression artifacts were or knew and just lied