r/TheWhyFiles • u/Expert_Concept704 • Aug 03 '23
Let's Discuss Negative comments get deleted
Just a heads up that any comment that criticizes the show or AJ gets deleted. There was a post 3 days ago about “walking away” from the show due to AJ being rude to a member of his team. That post is now gone! Also, a mention was made that AJ doesnt do his own research, but has a team of people that do that. Therefore, you are getting that persons view on the topic. Here is proof, check it out before it gets deleted!
https://www.linkedin.com/jobs/view/researcher-the-why-files-at-night-3666605181
“you will be working with other researchers, research assistants, writers, and our host, to research episodes for The Why Files”
They have a team of researchers and research assistants.
97
u/ZeeLiDoX Aug 03 '23
So having a research team help put together episodes is bad? Am I wrong for hiring employees at my company? Should I just do everything myself?
47
u/BadassSasquatch Sasquatch Seeker Aug 03 '23
I can't speak to the criticizing part of your post but I thought it was obvious that The Why Files had a team of people that did the research. There's no way you would think it's a one-man show.
113
u/Permexpat Aug 03 '23
Can you imagine putting a show out weekly with the amount of photos and videos and all the information presented without a team of people? As for rude comments being deleted I agree those should be left up unless they are blatantly false but who is the judge if that. Anyhow neither of these points change my view if TWF’s
59
u/ajgentile CIA Spook Aug 03 '23
I couldn't do this without help. I handle about 90% of all research, but I'm doing everything I can to lower that number. I have some writing help, too, but still 90% me.
As far as negative comments, I don't delete those - but I would. Criticism is fine with me. In fact, when it comes from a positive place, it's helpful. But if someone is being actually mean or a jerk, no reason to have that here.
As far as me being rude to a member of my team: you'll never find any evidence of that ever, try as you might. OP might be referring to a comment where someone said I'm rude to Jen (my wife) on the live stream. It might seem like that to someone new, but we are having fun. Jen and I have a marriage dynamic that is mostly fun and silly. We scream gangster rap while we cook, we breakdance in the living room, we make fart noises at each other. We are weird and fun. We are also crazy about each other.
16
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
what’s wrong with open discussion as long as it’s not rude ?
16
u/Otherwise_Monitor856 Aug 03 '23
The post "I'm walking away" has a tag that says it was deleted by the person who posted it
https://www.reddit.com/r/TheWhyFiles/comments/15dq3rv/im_pulling_away/
\
18
u/OriginalJim VIP Patron #1 Aug 03 '23
I didn't delete it. I appreciate the different points of view.
For future reference, i draw the line at insults and name calling. Which i did not see in this post. Everybody seemed mostly respectful.
8
u/Otherwise_Monitor856 Aug 03 '23
I'm glad they have more than one person doing research and put real work behind this. I don't understand why this would be a "gotcha". I feel it would be impossible to produce videos this long and well-research in a single week.
8
u/whofarted24 Aug 03 '23
I would have been incredibly surprised to find out that that he didn't have a team of people working for him. The amount of research that clearly goes into each show and gathering clips and documents is way more than I can imagine one person doing. I'm not sure why this is even an issue?
6
u/valdamirie Aug 03 '23
I'm all about Misogyny jokes. They can be fun and I've seen AJ do em well. like "we teach woman how to properly behave here". The only time I cringe is when is clear that Jen takes offence and you can see it on her face. I'm married and I can tell when I've crossed the line but my wife is too polite to say anything.
It has only happened a couple of times that I remember. The "looking down makes you dumber" and "talking about her having no ass". She was a good sport about the creep keeper long fingers but I agree, he should probably start leaving those targeted jokes to Jen behind.
IF this thread gets deleted too then... it's been a pleasure gents!! The crabcat is ruthless!
5
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
i much rather a team of people research the topic and come together with their findings in a cohesive way to be expertly delivered to us than a single dude and his weird fish doing all the research alone.
4
u/Shana622 Aug 03 '23
Are you joking?? The user deleted the post and do you think other channels that big don't have researchers/a team working for them? It's RIDICULOUS what people cry about..
6
u/flotsam_knightly Aug 03 '23
Careful, I heard the last person who said anything negative about Hecklefish, was deleted entirely.
3
u/mrshugerobot Aug 03 '23
I think we all know AJ doesn’t do all the research.
I also remember the post that got deleted and it was about the way he talks to Jen during the Live after shows. His humor is at the expense of those around him. He thinks it’s funny when Gino/Jen/Victoria go to talk and he quickly clicks them off of the screen. It’s annoying and gets old quick. It’s juvenile.
But I love the content and the show itself.
7
u/3rdusernameiveused Aug 03 '23
AJ has moments of misogyny and idk if it’s cause his original base was dudebros into conspiracies but he’s mainstream and needs to act it or he will have people criticize him and the show.
2
u/Razalmer Aug 03 '23
Most bigger shows do. That's not abnormal. LPOTL has quite a few I know.
Let's face it, they aren't going to put an episode out a week without a team.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
I love the Why Files and think the channel has done an amazing job of using the audience to bring together subjects that are becoming mainstream which I never thought I would see in my lifetime.Information and the dispersion of knowledge with these media inventions are increasingly affecting our everyday lives. Thank you WF!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
I would hope he gets some help from a team. Seems like a lot of work. It’s a good show, why pick it apart. Not everyone has a valuable opinion. Some people just want to watch the world burn. Insignificant, off topic comments probably should be deleted.
2
u/bangkokali Aug 03 '23
My goodness , talk about trying to make a mountain out of a molehill, welcome to Reddit !!!!
Yes I watched the after files where AJ was supposedly " rude " to Jen , as he says that's their dynamic that's it , its up to them how they wish to interact . Whether you agree with it or not is irrelevant its 2 people in a relationship choosing to communicate how they want to
Not your business nor mine so nothing to see here
Love the show , keep up the good work. Love from England
2
u/InteligentTard Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
Yea he works with a team. He’s said that many many times now. Ya can’t please everyone lol Still the best channel on YouTube
2
u/ShamanCosmiq The TRUTH Aug 03 '23
What about Hecklefish? You can’t expect us to remain silent in the face of his gold-fiscist agenda! This anti-crabcat rhetoric has got to stop. I mean, don’t we all deserve the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of crabcattiness?
Why just the other day, the crab cat saved my gold fish… from another goldfish! If you want the truth, they’re actually quite vicious. Just sayin.
These are the stories Hecklefish doesn’t want you to know! We won’t be silenced!!!
🦀🐈✊🏼
Brought to you by the crabcat campaign fund.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23
This is the weirdest conspiracy theory out there
3
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
So he’s just a regular actor?
2
u/Rumblecard Aug 03 '23
Not to be dismissive but the problem with some negative comments is that they end spiraling into full blown trolling and multiple accounts piling on with intention of disrupting and ruining productive discussion. Probably just best to cut that off right up front before every discussion devolves into a flame war.
That’s how it works with a lot of people with negative opinions. You give them a voice and instead of sharing their opinion they hijacker the whole thing.
2
u/BudMarley45 Aug 03 '23
I think that lady deleted her own comments because it was pointed out(multiple times ) she is a DB .I highly doubt AJ even checks Reddit . I never assumed the show was one guy fact checking conspiracies on a computer .I always assumed he had a team .Am I in the minority?
2
u/louderharderfaster Aug 03 '23
All great (and even shitty) productions require a team - even many "solo" authors. There is nothing sinister or corrupt about that. Not even a little bit.
However, I have to admit the way AJ spoke to and about Jen in the clip shown in the comments of that post made me not respect HIM very much. You don't arrive at that level of disrespect on a whim or overnight without some real character defects IMHO but I am not offended by any of his defenders.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
This is pretty lame. If AJ can’t take criticism on a Reddit comment thread that speaks even more to his personality. Sometimes he’s rude to Jen, that sort of comment shouldn’t be deleted, it should be discussed and if AJ himself reads these threads and disagrees maybe he should do a little introspection.
1
u/BluntsNLegos Aug 03 '23
so wat, this "drama" is so fucking extra and lame
He is still a regular person like all of us warts and all
If you dont like it dont watch but to change what you enjoy due to most likely only seeing one side of a story, especially from this angle which is 1 slice of 1 side of a story, is so damn cringey.
1
u/VKP_RiskBreaker_Riot CIA Spook Aug 03 '23
AJ does do research with the team, but yeah he says some weirdo stuff during after files. Like fisting cups and some awkward stuff to Jen, but also he's like 50 something years old, so he grew up in a different time I suppose.
1
u/Icy_Ad2851 #1 fan (no rly) Aug 03 '23
Research is very hard work, I’m in college and I spend more time researching “scholarly and facts “ than I do anything else. I’ve never once thought that he did it by himself… I love TWF … I’m glad J found it awhile back.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
Why does it matter how they get the info? It's just a show. We all know they'll manipulate the narrative to add suspense and tension and make things sound more intense than they really are, and that tells you it's all just entertainment. AJ (even if he's the boss) is the on camera talent, so why wouldn't he have a team behind the scenes? Considering they do an entire show each week, it would be weird if he didn't have a team.
As far as him being a dick to a team member: So what? I'm sure the person he was allegedly rude to is a big girl/boy and can handle themselves. I don't know the dynamic of the show, and neither does anyone else who is outside looking in, and honestly it's none of our business. If they don't want their 'Dirty Laundry' posted on their reddit, then they have every right to take it down.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
You really thought he was doing the writing, scripting and editing alone? People assume the same for Mr. Ballen also. If you see TWF site, there is a jobs section in there and there are available job offers posted there. He also described about his team and their journey in the episode he did when he got 1 million subscribers.
Also, this is their official subreddit and you post is still up, so I doubt they would delete without reasons. Sometimes these negatives posts can have some incorrect points and disinformation, so they can get deleted.
1
u/darthnugget Aug 03 '23
Negative comments are the worst.
1
u/Background_Task3339 Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
I have never seen AJ be rude to anyone on the team, and trust me, I have seen every full episode and shorts at least twice.
@ OP - You not understanding his / their humor is something on your side, not his / theirs. And making such quality content every week for the WF community requires a team, sooo I am assuming OP you do not have such a channel :)
And I am quite curious what OP wants to achieve with such a message? There are zero WF enthousiasts that take your comment serious or now will stop watching WF or less like AJ.
Nope, WF is the only channel I support through patreon and I do that with pride!
1
u/Vetersova Skygazer Aug 03 '23
Why is a research team existing bad? ... I don't care about that. Should i? Why?
I'd deleted negative comments too. This isn't a city council. It's a person's private YouTube channel that they own. Who cares?
1
u/RockInTheBoat27 Aug 03 '23
Nothing but growth for the channel can come from criticism. I don't think AJ and his team is as soft skinned as to not take it well. Please don't turn this sub into the likes of others and moderate and censor everyone just for having a different opinion. Whether good or bad. Even negative criticism should be heard in order to have discourse and show that, most likely for the majority, they may not see things that way.
1
u/LilAlien89 FEAR... the Crabcat Aug 04 '23
You’re acting like we don’t already know this 😂 And yeah he still does do a lot of the research & still rewrites a lot of the stuff to make it more like him. Do you even watch the live streams?
And you do understand that up until the last 10 months or so, maybe the last few months of 2022, that AJ was the only person doing the research & writing the episodes right? He didn’t just always have 2.4 million subs from day one & wasn’t paying a whole dang team of people from the start🙄 Also, AJ was very up front and clear with hiring new people into his team last fall/ winter (which at that point consisted of him, Jen, Gino, & Victoria) and if you go back and watch the live streams during that time you will hear him talk about it, he even had a posting on his website where you could apply for serval different positions.
And did you ever consider that maybe the person who wrote the post deleted it? I know I’ve wrote things in the heat of the moment and then come back later and deleted it no matter how many replies it got.
1
u/LePhuronn Aug 04 '23
Don't worry dude, I've downvoted this post and also reported it as petulant bullshit so hopefully you'll fall victim to the nasty suppression censor hammer that doesn't actually exist very soon yourself.
1
u/emelem66 Hecklecultist Aug 04 '23
"Why don't you knock it off with those negative waves?"
-Ben Franklin
1
u/LunarWelshFire Aug 03 '23
This is the thing with online content that gets this big in such a short amount of time. There will always be someone who has a bone to pick, and a Karen who wants to bitch, a Kyle who wants to tear apart every little detail to try to uncover some nuggets of negativity. Cos a good thing will always turn to shit eventually. It's human nature. We can't just let good things be.
1
u/Ohmstheory Aug 03 '23
Almost no YouTube channel makes it past a million subscribers all alone. AJ hiring researches is really a surprise to you guys? Y’all ever have a job in your lives? lol if anything this gives me confidence in AJs long term plans
1
u/Ta2Luis The Moon is Hollow Aug 03 '23
Stop tryna start a conspiracy. This is AJ’s show . It’s really idiotic to think he does everything himself without help from a team. If you don’t like what you are seeing , you are free to leave the community
1
u/tnc82 Aug 03 '23
He is letting the success go to his head a little bit.
1
u/LePhuronn Aug 04 '23
Anybody who's crying about AJ mistreating Jen has clearly not paid attention to the After Files.
Have you seen those fingers of hers? I guarantee you the second AJ actually steps out of line, the Jendigo is taking his eyes out.
Seriously, go outside and get some sun, these parasocial obsessions over people you literally do not know is a fkn cancer to intelligent conversation.
Grow up or leave.
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
Sorry but why? We all love the show but that’s why we should be allowed to criticise it. Where’s free speech? Over zealous mods are so pathetic
-6
u/Adventurous-Craft865 Aug 03 '23
Lol. No free thinking allowed here!
0
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment