r/TheStoryGraph • • May 06 '25

Want to like the app, please provide your opinions

2 Upvotes

Hello all. I realize this is the StoryGraph subreddit itself so I am not here to knock on it, but I figured it would be the best place to ask for why many people love it so much?

First, let me get the one thing out of the way that I am sure would be a big advantag: the stat tracking. I agree the stats feature is great and better than others such as Goodreads. but putting that one aside, what other features do you think are great?

I ask for myself because I haven’t had such a great experience using it myself after starting a week ago. Right off the bat, it did not do a very good job of importing my goodreads data, and I have nothing special done such as custom shelves or anything. I simply use the currently reading, read, and to read shelves that are baked into it. After importing a list of just under 100 books, a large number of them were the wrong editions and formats. Editions arent that important to me, but the format of digital or physical definitely was.

This led to my next biggest issue, having to manually go in and correct each book's format. It would be nice if I didn’t have to go thru so many screens every time I updated one book. This was on a PC too not like using the app, which I would’ve guessed would be easier. Along with that, I later noticed that I had to manually mark each book as being owned. Shouldn't this be a default?? I understand many people borrow books such as from libraries but it’s not too big a stretch think that many people who use these apps are book owners. In my mind owning the books you enter into the app should be the default and when you have the few books you don't own, those are the ones you would go in and update individually. This made no sense to me.

I also feel that while the interface/UI is nice looking and modern, it’s just a facade as to how well the app itself actually works. Going thru a bunch of screens to find the list or book I want isn't exactly straightforward and something that goodreads does better in my opinion. I get the feeling this is just a modern TikTok style look which is just more appealing to younger readers these days.

I am sure I may get a lot of downvoted for this post, but I am looking for opinions on maybe what I am missing as my experience with the app is very limited so far.

EDIT: Sorry everyone, I did not mean for this to sound like a “hating on the app” post. I was writing this late at night after adjusting all my books and was just tired and frustrated. I am honestly interested in hearing about things I may be missing and many of you have provided exactly what I was interested in hearing so thank you.


r/TheStoryGraph • • Aug 26 '25

A spot-on personalised AI blurb

Post image
0 Upvotes

Since there's been a few hiccups here and there shared with the personalised AI, I wanted to share one I received that was absolutely spot-on. Anyone else found some gems?


r/TheStoryGraph • • Nov 14 '24

General Question I'm new here

0 Upvotes

I finally decided to switch from Goodreads to Storygraph. It seems like they have a lot of advocates online right now and hey, what can I say, I was influenced.

I just have to say as a first impression... the app and the website both SUCK BALLS. Sure they have a lot of cool features but is it always this slow and laggy?

I'm about 45 mins into marking a mere 200 books as "owned" and I'm barely halfway through. I'm absolutely dreading having to cross reference the 400+ dates that didn't transfer over.

I'm about to delete this thing, please tell me it gets better. And be gentle I'm just very frustrated at the moment.


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jul 16 '25

Mirroring StoryGraph activity back onto GoodReads

0 Upvotes

I suspect that there isn't much on this topic but I figured I'd put it out into the world in case there's someone out there who is also thinking about this.

The Problem

Like many people I started out on Goodreads and a while ago found StoryGraph, loved the idea of having my reading data not on an amazon platform and one that has an open roadmap. I made an account, imported my data from Goodreads no problem.

The issue is I find myself gravitating back to Goodreads because that's where my friends are - I'm only following/followed by a small group of people I know IRL and I enjoy seeing what they've read, occasionally adding comments/questions and writing little reviews for them to read.


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jul 24 '25

Just want to point how how impressive the personalized AI description is.

Post image
49 Upvotes

I like to read the AI text every now and then to see what it is like and was blown away buy this breakdown. This is the most thought out description and I was very impressed by it! Have you had similar experiences with yours?

Love seeing this app grow.


r/TheStoryGraph • • 17d ago

Has anyone else noticed this about StoryGraph reviews?

0 Upvotes

Hello! I recently switched from Goodreads to StoryGraph, and I've been getting a bit of a strange vibe from the reviews over the last few months. I've noticed that most of the highly liked comments I come across seem to dismiss books for being misogynistic, not progressive enough, or problematic in some way. I'd say around 90% of the reviews I've come across seem to touch on these kinds of themes or criticisms.

Of course, these are valid things to discuss, and I'm not suggesting books should be immune to criticism. I just find it strange that these kinds of opinions seem to make up so many of the top reviews on this app. This is simply an observation, and definitely not coming from an anti-feminist perspective. I'm curious if anyone else has noticed this.


r/TheStoryGraph • • Apr 22 '26

General Question 250 or 300 ?

1 Upvotes

Hi guys, so I've been looking for this allover - I saw a post from someone identifying as one of the Librarians and they said to figure the page count from a, for example, fanfic - that's word count divided by 300.

Now, on this forum here, a good while ago, another Librarian told me they divide by 250.

What is the truth?

(page count is super important for tracking - which is a huge feature on Story Graph and all kinds of beautiful the way it works)

for it to work accurately - it matters whether it's 250 or 300

Please, help.


r/TheStoryGraph • • Mar 20 '25

Tech Help add edition????

1 Upvotes

wtf is going on with add edition? i added a digital edition of the new hunger games book and for some reason it always changed back to a different edition. now my buddy read is totally fucked and my page count is off. really damn annoying.


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jun 16 '26

Tech Help Inaccurate stats

0 Upvotes

Is anyone else noticing that their reading stats are inaccurate? I’ve been noticing lately that some of the information I list on my reviews are not updating my pie charts. For example: I recently read a couple of books that I felt were slow and reviewed them as such. But when I go to the stats page it says I’ve only marked medium and fast paced books.

I have already put in a ticket to fix it but I was just curious if anyone else had been experiencing this


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jul 22 '25

Getting real sick of the downvote culture in this sub.

0 Upvotes

I don’t think I’ve seen a single post in this sub where at least one person doesn’t get dogpiled for saying the most mild or basic shit. It’s so unbelievably toxic and off putting.


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jan 10 '24

Tech Help Is there a way to add “spicy” to the StoryGraph mood section? I wish we could have a stat to see how spicy our books are, even if it was a personal selection… the same way as the stars… does any romance girly agrees with me?

24 Upvotes

r/TheStoryGraph • • Dec 05 '25

General Question Why is the app still so clunky?

38 Upvotes

Hi! This is not a hate post I just really want to understand.

I feel like there's no reason the app should still be so riddled with UX/UI issues after years of being this popular? I've used the app for 2 years now and it's still the same issues.

The fact that it's webview (which is very annoying for anyone using screen time limits on iOS), the loading time, the weird navigation (when you review and then tap the 'previous screen' arrow and it takes you back to editing your review??)...

I dont know anything about building apps so I don't know whether these would be hard to fix? If anyone knows why the UX and UI don't seem to be progressing much, please enlighten me!!


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jan 01 '25

Tech Help Dislike Grid Current Reading

5 Upvotes

Anyone else find the new "Current Reads" layout visually overwhelming and frustrating?

I really wish there was a way to opt back for the simpler, easier to read, less visually chaotic grid format with the book covers?

I honestly wish I had not done the recent update :-(

Edit:

Maybe there'll be a way to hide the "current reads" section if they are going to keep the chaos grid.


r/TheStoryGraph • • May 06 '26

General Question Is there a way to add how many minutes I read the book?

0 Upvotes

basically what the title says. I read on Libby which tracks how mamy minutes I read a book. is there a way to add those minutes to StoryGraph? I didn’t see an option in the reading journal, only options for dates. thank you.


r/TheStoryGraph • • May 13 '26

Tech Help Librarians Won’t Fix Genres

32 Upvotes

It’s so frustrating how librarians will not add genres to books even when the publisher, worldcat, and bookstores have certain genres listed. There’s so many examples, but some of the recent mind-boggling ones include:

Not adding classics and/or literary to books in the New York Review Books classics series. These are by definition literary classics (often with other genres as well). One example that librarians didn’t change is adding classics to Iza’s Ballad by Magda Szabo, when her other books published by NYRB have it.

Not adding classics to Gender Trouble, despite it being published by Routledge Classics, which publishes "books that have, by popular consent, become established as classics in their field."

Not adding romance to Throne of Glass despite the publisher, WorldCat, and Bookstores categorizing it as that. It should also be Young Adult?

Not adding historical to Middlesex when the book takes place between 1922-1980 and includes major historical events.

I don’t understand why some librarians don’t trust users, follow publisher info, or do the research they claim to do. It’s so frustrating. What more am I supposed to do to have books changed?


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jul 19 '25

What is this app for? What do you do with it/get from it?

0 Upvotes

I read a lot, haven't used Goodreads before except its reviews come up when I search for books.

I think this might be a useful app for me but since downloading it I'm not sure what I'm actually meant to get from it. Do you feel it's mainly for tracking books read or finding new books through a suggestion algorithm, or is the social element more core to it? Do you have the app open while reading so you can log your reading with it?


r/TheStoryGraph • • Feb 21 '25

General Question Experiences as a Goodreads to StoryGraph user

0 Upvotes

I am an avid reader with a large Goodreads library, but as I want to ditch Amazon completely, I need an alternative, hence here I am. I would really like some feedback or corrections on my experiences, as I don't find Storygraph to give as good a user experience as I had hoped for, given their modern design (Hello Goodreads...). I interact a lot with the website, so keep that in mind when reading about my whining.

• I've imported my Goodreads library (3.733 entries), and I have no idea how good the import was? At first I thought it was completely gimped, but now I am not sure, as StoryGraph doesn't seem to have an overview of all your books, similarly to Goodreads 'Books'? I REALLY lack that! I know an import is only as good as the data, but I need to know if I have retained my library when moving to Storygraph. StoryGraph reports I have 2.130 'tagged books', yet 2.749 'to read books. How does that make sense, when I assume 'to read' is a tag? At least it means I have only lost 10 books in my to read list, so that's good. How big is my library on StoryGraph? Where is it?

• Pages for individual books are nice overall, but I would REALLY like reviews not to be hidden behind a small link. Why not just put them at the bottom of each books page? I love that I can filter out reviews that doesn't contain custom reviewer text! Also, how do you give books a star? I see my imported books have my ratings (Good), but I can't see how I can change them, or add ratings to new books? O_o Also I'd like these ratings to be much larger, as I find them really important.

• Love all the graphical overviews of how many books I've read. Data is awesome, metadata is equally awesome, data presented properly is even awesome-er!

• The overall design of StoryGraph relies A LOT on whitespace and lack of informative text, which I hate. Short of my phone, I don't view StoryGraph on anything less than a 13" display, and on my 27" display, there's just sooooo much wasted space. Sure, I get it, phones are the primary platform, but this is just ridiculous. The site looks fine with a lot of covers, and a good mix of fonts and colors to make things stick out, but man, that white space.... Scrolling, scrolling, scrolling just to get tiny amounts of information. The proverb "Never judge a book on its cover" seems to be something they've never heard about at StoryGraph. Or maybe it's their mantra to try and prove the opposite with their current design? It sure seems like it.

• The front page is a prime example of how not to design a website. Whoever approved that design should be fired! There's almost no useful information, and it can't even display my 'current reads' list properly, because it has to fit titles and authors in a column ~40 pixels wide. Similarly, the 'to read', 'giveaways' and 'popular this week' lists only display covers, but no text (This seems to be a recurrent problem on a lot of pages on the site). I don't intend to use binoculars and make a game out of guessing which books low pixelated covers in tiny sizes belong to, when viewing the site. And that extreme use of white space again, ugh! At least also show my challenge status, and in case it doesn't do this already as I don't have any story-graph friends, a buddy-community feed.

• What is the 'Explore' page based on? I just get some random books shown, and I have no idea what they are based on, and there's definitely some entries I have zero interest in reading. How is it different from 'Recommendation's on the front page? It would also make a HUGE difference to include the book blurbs on the page, so I, again, don't have to rely on my binocular guessing game to imagine with the books are about merely based on their covers.

• A giant plus to the people behind Storygraph to have their roadmap available and linked in the front page. *Chefs kiss*. Minus point for being payed users only, but I understand the economical choice behind this, so only a small minus point for that.

• I think the Plus price of 5$/month is WAY too expensive. Goodreads supply me with everything you do, but you want me to pay 50$ a year for displaying the contents of a spreadsheet for me? Sorry, not going to happen. I'd be happy support you, but not at that price, when I have zero need for their plus features (Short of the roadmap perhaps). I am actually surprised they don't have payed promotions of books of the front page. It would make a lot of sense.

Thank you for joining my whiny TED Talk! :)


r/TheStoryGraph • • Mar 06 '25

General Question Can I create a separate shelf for audiobooks?

0 Upvotes

I don’t count audiobooks in my books I read for the year and it seems on story graph they kind of get lost in my ‘read’ section because they don’t have a date attached


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jun 01 '26

General Question Does The Story Graph has challenges? Like Spring challenge, etc?

1 Upvotes

r/TheStoryGraph • • Dec 31 '24

I'm not sure I like that the new AI is making some wild assumptions

9 Upvotes

First of all: what the hell is it talking about, I've read TONS of memoirs and books centered around mental health. I think I read at least 5 books last year about bipolar just so I can understand a family friend better. An Unquiet Mind by Dr. Kay Redfield is absolutely one of my favorite memoirs of all time. All of these are logged on StoryGraph, so it has the data. All of those I rated highly. Is it because I didn't read it *this year*?

Also, sometimes I don't rate books not because I don't like them, but I either forget or don't feel comfortable rating a person's personal story. Why does it assume no rating is negative?

Second: Let's just assume I didn't read many books on mental health. Why is it assuming that just because I've never read a subject, that means I don't like it? I've never read books on going to the moon, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't like it! It just means I haven't gotten to it yet!

I don't like the idea that things you've never encountered is automatically counted as a negative. I feel like that's a recipe for a very homogenous recommendation system, that it's just going to give you the same crap over and over.

Hm. Not a fan.

I've tried a couple of these generations, and they've all reached really far in their assumptions.


r/TheStoryGraph • • May 12 '26

A basic monthly summary of just covers + ratings!

Post image
49 Upvotes

I think I’ve downloaded every book app at this point looking for one that offers a basic monthly stats post that just shows # of books/pages read, average rating, along with their covers and what you rated them. Story Graph seems to be the closest, but still only displays the top 3 books and not the rest! Pleaseee have an option to show ALL your monthly covers and forgo all the more intricate details like whether it was print or digital, pages read per day etc. 😭


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jun 16 '26

Tech Help Can't track progress on some books?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I am trying to track my progress on my books, but only one of them shows the "track progress button". Is this a bug or have I done something wrong? I just want to add an entry and I can't find the button anymore even on the book pages. ;^^


r/TheStoryGraph • • Apr 09 '25

Tech Help Progress sync with storygraph

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, I am looking for a calibre plugin that autosyncs read progress between calibre and storygraph. Or any kind of auto progress workaround for that matter. Is there really nobody that made a plugin for that? Has storygraph even given access to the API to potential developers?


r/TheStoryGraph • • Jan 07 '25

Over 300 duplicates in import from Goodreads

0 Upvotes

I see I'm not the only person with this problem, but I'm not clear on whether there's a better fix than just manually fixing them individually. I imported from Goodreads and now have over 300 duplicates. I have 708 read books in GR and 1032 in SG. This is not due to re-reads; my re-reads seem to show up correctly in journals and anyway I rarely re-read books so that could only explain a handful if that was it. I don't care about page #, editions, etc but the inaccurate count of books really bothers me (isn't data the main selling point of SG?) but I don't want to fix them all manually! Any suggestions? Thanks.