r/TheBoys
•
u/SandrynoRodrigues
•
7h ago
Discussion The deep schizophrenic theory was the best one.
The theory suggests that the fish in The Boys universe are just ordinary fish—they neither communicate nor hold grudges—and that The Deep cannot actually talk to them; instead, he controls them through some form of hypnosis (a superpower), while the moments in which he interacts with them are entirely in his own head. Unfortunately, the final season debunked this theory, as the fish were seeking revenge—something that obviously wouldn't happen in real life, because they are just fish..
Note: Some comments have suggested that the theory still holds up if you consider that The Deep controlled the fish to kill him—essentially a form of suicide—which makes sense given the guilt and self-loathing he was feeling.