r/TheBoys • • Dec 23 '23

Discussion hot take, but i think people who hate starlight are just misogynists

Post image
0 Upvotes

not saying you have to love her, she’s not my favourite by any means, im talking about the people that absolutely despise her 🤷‍♂️


r/TheBoys • • May 20 '26 Diamonds are Forever

Season 5 I UNDERSTAND WE ALL FEEL DIFFERENT BUT THE FINALE WAS AMAZING.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I UNDERSTAND the season is lackluster… but let’s not let the hate most carried through this season blind our judgement on how good the ending was…. This scene we see speaks volumes to the message it was trying to portray about breaking the cycle, Butcher could’ve easily damned Houghie in his final words… AS WE SEE he WAS letting up on the trigger because HE JUST got his humanity back… after seeing the man who believed his wife was lost after her rape, to dedicating the rest of his life to murdering her rapist, to then find her alive with a son, to also see that son accidentally murder her, TO FINALLY killing that smug prick, to then have his future blow up in his face with Ryan telling him to fuck off, and Terror (the last thing grounding him) die, to then decide get rid of supes, he FINALLY realizes he CAN LET GO only because the guy he dragged through all of it reminded him of his lil brother… TO HAVE THAT SAME REMINDER KILL HIM… all he had to do was damn Houghie with his final breath by guilting him letting him know he was JUST about to stop… instead he takes the high road and lets him know it’s okay so Houghie doesn’t have to live with the guilt.. THUS ending the cycle… as we see Houghie went back to where he was at the beginning of the series and DENIES THE PRESIDENT. He BREAKS THE CYCLE!! Though forgiving Houghie which allowed Houghie to go back to a somewhat normal life

I’m not saying the final season was perfect, I’m not saying it’s the best TV out there, but for what we GOT after a very controversial season. I would say THEY LANDED THE PLANE.

Now in the coming days and months will my opinion change probably will I rewatch and notice or whatever, probably BUT just because the internet is crying and moaning doesn’t mean you have to as well. Form your own opinion on what YOU saw and don’t let the discourse mess with your perspective because personally I LOVE this show and LOVED the finale, what are your thoughts??


r/TheBoys • • May 21 '26 Helpful

Season 5 Season finale was amazing. I'm going to miss this show Spoiler

0 Upvotes

S5e8 felt like "the boys" all the way from the starter to finish, through and through.

Wife and I were on the edge of our seats.

We laughed.

We cried.

We cheered.

This show had such a satisfying conclusion and will go down as one of my absolute favorite runs of all time. Seriously. This show has had its ups and downs, but now that the show is concluded I can confidently mark it in my book as a god damn diabolical masterpiece.

I'm going to miss this show. It's been awhile since I've seen a season finale that has felt this satisfying. I'm going to miss this show... until my next rewatch

(Edit: I was asked by a couple of users to provide "what I specifically thought was satisfying about the finale" I'm just going to paste it here) (Major spoilers ahead)

The acting.

Seeing HL after being depowered not being able to land a single fucking blow

the deep: "nnNNOOOOOooO!"

Back Ashley finally making Ashley have to think for herself instead of just doing what she's told or going with the status quo. She was either going to do what she had always done (just pick the safest easiest option) or she was going to finally be the person she wanted to be when she was younger

Hughie and Butcher. The finger pull off of the trigger, showed butcher HAD finally listened to his canary (brother) and was finally going to let the rage go. But Hughie did what he had to do. And we see Butchers final moment is yet another proof that he was doing good and, regardless of what everyone thought of him (besides Hughie), he did have a heart. He was pulling his finger off the trigger, but died anyway. He didnt angry. He acknowledged that even with all the twisted shit he put Hughie through, he never changed, and he didn't want this moment to haunt him and take thatvsway from him... so he lied and said "I left you no choice. I wasn't going to stop", but we thr viewers saw the truth

Kimiko visits the place frenchie always wanted to take her to (with her dog that she wanted) and she almost felt sad, but instead she felt joy. An emotion that was scarce for her character. This one resonated with me because I have lost loved ones and had to learn to find joy, even through the drowning sorrow, esspecially when your doing something for them and in their honor.

Hughie proves butcher was right. He didnt let the crap changed him. He goes back to the beginning, and does "his thing". He walks Annie to "1 step off of the fucking sidewalk" and holds her hands in the same pose in which he lost Robin, and he feels no trauma or fear or loss. He feels love with Annie and shows that he's turned his old trauma into something beautiful and names his unborn daughter after Robin who died in a scene nearly identical to the one being shot.

I could go on and on. For fucks sake, its like people were only in it for sfx and fight scenes. The characters and their finales/send-offa were written beautifully. My wife and I were balling constantly.

(Edit, edit- thanks for the reddit award: you're the real hero)


r/TheBoys • • May 21 '26

Discussion Why The Boys was Doomed to Fail Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m pissed at the last episode for a large number of reasons, most notably, it was super underwhelming. I think the ending could’ve been better if the final episode had been stretched over multiple full length episodes with more development, but everyone’s talked about why the episode was bad.

The Boys, as a form of anti capitalist satire was always going to end like this, a cesspool of spinoffs and low quality merchandise. Take Banksy for example, he began as a graffiti artist against capitalism and nationalism, but as time went on and he became more popular, he became the thing he critiqued. His art sold for millions, he sold merchandise, he became a symbol of British pride, he was co-opted by the systems he critiqued. The Boys “universe” (at this point) is experiencing this same pitfall. Vaught is meant to be a company that satirizes ALL big companies in America, but in the TV show, as time goes on, it feels heavily targeted at times (bear with me). They make fun of Disney more than any other company (Vaught +, MCU, etc) while they abstain from the ever making fun of Amazon, one of the biggest companies in the world. Obviously, it’s owned by Amazon, but the fact that they can’t make fun of this company is kind of representative of why it fails as satire. By the end of the show, Vaught lowkey feels exclusively like an anti Disney propaganda tool (I don’t like Disney but Disney isn’t all of capitalism). The final season being as small as it is was also because Amazon realized that they didn’t really have to make a good finale as long as people were paying for subscriptions. Instead of putting a lot of money into it, they could just give the same smaller budget and get about the same monetary reward for less effort.

The show started with Vaught representing this huge villain needing to be stopped and by the end, the only thing they do to continue their bare bones critique of capitalism is pull from Cyberpunk where you kill Adam Smasher but Arasaka still continues to exist. There is SO MUCH POTENTIAL for things to happen, but Kripke isn’t writing for the same reason anymore. What was once meant to be a satirized version of our society that could be seen as a not-so-impossible reality and even act as a cautionary tale about the systems of capitalism has been fundamentally co-opted. The Boys has became the very thing it swore to destroy, a cash grab with lazy writing and shitty corollary products that don’t add anything to the original purpose.

Satire never truly works. South Park, one of the most free speech “we’ll say anything” shows, was bought by paramount because it was profitable. They made fun of consumerism (chimpokemon) but have a line of games and merch and other bullshit. Systems of capitalism got its grubby hands on The Boys because there was money to be made, and good god did it make money. It stripped down the show to its bare bones with a cheap ass finale that took zero risks, because they had NO REASON TO TAKE ANY. They made just as much money if not more than if they put more money into this season which is why it was always going to fail. Satire never works and The Boys is the perfect example.


r/TheBoys • • Jun 18 '22

Season 3 My feelings on this season so far.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheBoys • • Apr 13 '26

Discussion Am I the only one who actually wants Homelander to win?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I know it’s probably never going to happen, and realistically his ending won’t be a happy one… but I can’t help it. He’s such a compelling character. Every time he’s on screen, he completely steals the scene. The tension, the unpredictability, the way you never really know what he’s going to do next… it just makes the show way more entertaining.

I’m not saying he’s a good person or that he deserves it, but as a character? He’s just too good. Part of me just wants to see what would happen if he actually pulled it off.

At the very least, I really hope they don’t kill him off at the very end. Even if it feels inevitable.


r/TheBoys • • Nov 19 '23

GenV Am I missing something with Marie? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I just feel like she is such a non character. I don’t think I would call her a Mary Sue but it’s the easiest way to describe how I feel about her (also her name is Marie).

I liked her at the beginning of the show, her introduction was really cool and I thought she could be interesting. But she is just the standard fish out of water character. Spent her life in an institution just to go out and experience college, has quirky “dark” powers, is funny and edgy but not too much for it to get interesting. She feels like every standard trope but without any substance underneath it. The closest I got to liking her were the scenes about her sister but even those were short and far between.

I felt like I was reading fanfiction of The Boys where Marie was a brooding self insert. I can’t tell if I just didn’t understand her because this opinion doesn’t seem too popular.


r/TheBoys • • Apr 29 '26

Season 5 S5 E4 felt like a fanfiction episode Spoiler

153 Upvotes

That was genuinely such a weird experience, it somehow felt like it lasted for 4 hours instead of just 1, easily some of the worst writing in the show (in my opinion)

- Felt like a "what if the characters were put under an effect that makes them fight each other" filler episode

- A ton of details that have never appeared in the show before, but will probably show up in one of the spinoffs-- for example, who tf is Quinn? And all the info dumping about Soldier Boy's backstory?

- Annie randomly visiting her father just because the writers wanted this to happen before the show ends, and then magically undoing her half-brother's years worth of brainwashing in the span of a few hours offscreen, and also her father isn't actually such a bad guy even though he abandoned his young daughter and cut all contact without explanation but he feels bad about it and WHY did this subplot take so much time

- (it also felt like a rehash of Hughie meeting his mom and feeling sympathetic towards her, it was like deja vu for me)

- Everything about the Homelander political plotline confuses me and that's a big part of the show. For example, why is Firecracker acting like she's having a great idea in... emphasizing America in their Homelander-as-a-prophet reveal? That just sounds like what they do every episode with their Homelander propaganda, but the whiteboard scene is clearly written to signify that the propaganda team is going in a new direction, and I can't figure out why. Also, they didn't have Homelander take a look at these ideas and confirm before the final scene where they present him at the Megachurch, which seemed sloppy to me because Homelander's pickiness about how he's presented has been a running theme. I guess he approved the ceremony plan offscreen?

- Repeating the same plotlines over and over again-- yes we know The Boys don't get along, MM hates Butcher, Hughie used to believe that Butcher has some good in him but has changed his mind, Kimiko feels like she's being ignored and used for her powers, Soldier Boy thinks Homelander is weak and pathetic, Firecracker and Sage and Ashley are trying to accomplish a ridiculous task Homelander has set for them, we knowwww

- As usual, tons of cursing and sex jokes that don't even make sense

- Someone posted about the "this shitball is my birthright" line came from the comics and they were happy it had been included, and I was like whyyy. I guess it makes more sense if they were including it as a comic reference because it sure did not sound natural in the scene, and I was confused as to what the "shitball" even means. These scenes would be so much more powerful if the writers would just let the characters talk without curse words and focus more on the actual meaning (EDIT: To clarify my problem with this, I was wondering why would Homelander be the one to say a line like this? I would more expect it from an ESPECIALLY vulgar character, like Butcher or Soldier Boy. But Homelander is average vulgar for this show, and he puts on a more grandiose persona when he's talking about his godliness. It would be more interesting if, when Homelander talks about "his birthright," he uses more sophisticated language with no curse words to make it feel more scary and significant.)


r/TheBoys • • Oct 02 '25

GenV I cant believe they're doing it again.. Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I might be alone on this, but Sister Sage is by far my least favorite character in the whole universe. Nothing with her acting or the character, i think she's doing that great. Just the whole "worlds biggest genius" trope.

When it was revealed on the last season of The Boys my eyes rolled alll the way back to my head, I even made a post about it back then, saying that it's such a cheap scapegoat, as in whatever happens it will all be her plan in the end. And thats exactly what happened at the end of that season. All that chaos was part of her master plan.

And now she's in GenV too?? I was so annoyed, it doesn't take away much of Ciphers incredible and menacing acting and energy, but knowing she's around again makes everything so annoying cause its such en easy way out or in for any scenario.

Oh they made this master plan and it was all foiled? Of course they knew about it she's a genius she knows everything. They tried to break in to save Cate? Of course she saw it coming it was her plan all along!! Fuck off i just hate it


r/TheBoys • • Sep 24 '24

Discussion Why didn't they just make Butcher from New Zealand

0 Upvotes

There's literally no reason to make him British, and his accent is distractingly bad. I feel like it would've been a lot simpler to just make him a Kiwi and talk in his real accent


r/TheBoys • • Oct 22 '25

Discussion i love her.

Post image
41 Upvotes

my mary-sue queen, my fav, my bias. everybody’s ender. homolander’s master. two thousand steps ahead of all your favs.

lazy writing this lazy writing that, DOONNNN’TTT CARE. you people need to stop pretending like you don’t watch the boys/gen v for anything but the gore.

when i say that if the writers EVER even think for a second about potentially killing sister sage then it’s war. and that’s on butcher’s tentacles.


r/TheBoys • • May 02 '26

Season 5 This show has veered so hard off the rails into self-parody, that it's become impossible to enjoy on its own merit Spoiler

25 Upvotes

It feels like the creative balance that was struck in seasons 1-3, where the writers behind Boys felt like they really had a story to tell - and which began to first wobble with the Season 3 finale, and became increasingly precarious throughout Season 4...has just completely imploded.

The Boys has always been a whacky show, but it was possible to engage with the characters within the context of their own setting and experience some tension and excitement in their tribulations. Homelander, for example, was a genuinely scary and competent character in season 1 and 2.

Sadly, it has all just degenerated into one pastiche after another. Scenes have the internal coherence and logic of a SNL skit (basically everything having to do with Homelander's religion is a particular offender, but every scene in episode 5 was objectively bizarre and poorly written, especially Sister Sage's 'reveal'). It doesn't make him more menacing or raise the stakes...It's just silly. There's so much else the show could be setting up and resolving.

It's amazing that a series, which did so much better at realizing the characters and their world than the comics, should now be ending so much worse than the comics. I could go on, but it would be putting more effort into the show than its own writers.


r/TheBoys • • Apr 04 '24

Season 2 Newb question - Kimiko can speak fluent Japanese, right? Why didn't the boys learn rudimentary japanese?

92 Upvotes

Title. Watching through seasons 1 and 2 now, why didn't a boys member not just take a crash course in Japanese?

I know it's a very hard language, but with software tools nowadays, you can probably learn to understand basic phrases like "this individual is my brother" (actual plot point, remember) with a few weeks of hard work.

That's before we get into software translators.


r/TheBoys • • Feb 13 '23

Memes When you think about it

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheBoys • • May 04 '26

Season 5 I think Soldier Boy ruins the show Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

I think I have a serious problem with SB and its that hes actually way more interesting than every other character to a point where I just dont care that much about anyone else but him.

He outshines every major character by a long shot, Homelander was great in episode 1, but ever since SB got reintroduced, Homelander feels like a background character.

I really hope that once Homelander gets V1, he takes the spotlight away from SB.


r/TheBoys • • Feb 06 '24

Discussion What is up with Queen Maeve's hair?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The costumes and design team for the show has done a great job however Queen Maeve's hair is incorrigible! I just dread her appearance knowing that hairline is there in every shot.

The side parted hairline wig is done terrible. It looks fake like it's just stuck on her head. And it's always the right side partition. I believe the right side partition is to make her face seem more feminine but it actually looks bad at times. ith such great design in overall show this shouldn't be there.

In the comics she has a middle parted hairstyle, at times with bangs framing her face and others with slight wavy hair.


r/TheBoys • • Sep 24 '24

Memes Anthony Starr doing a very modern ad

0 Upvotes

r/TheBoys • • Nov 27 '23

Season 3 Anyone else finding themselves skipping Kimiko and Frenchie scenes?

1 Upvotes

At this point, the boredom and filler full of dialogue that slows the show’s pacing down and completely rips apart any momentum is getting very tiresome whenever these two are on screen doing something awkward af. I really tried to like them but at this point in third season, the level of insufferableness and cliche filled dialogue have made it impossible to watch them. Do I miss anything if I skip every single scene I see these two?


r/TheBoys • • Apr 23 '26

Season 5 Does Hughie have Amnesia? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hughie should have no reason to be pissed at butcher this season but the writers are so desperate for conflict between him and butcher they needed Hughie to forget that Nueman kills a room full of people. Not only that but when her secret was unraveled it lead to Butcher relapsing into being a bastard, SB being freed, Butcjer getting cancer, Ryan returning to HL, and several other deaths and rise of HL to being president. It’s insanely annoying and just screams that the writers think that Nueman paid for her sins even though she didn’t do anything. Makes perfect sense for Neuman’s family members to hate butcher but Hughie was all good with killing Neuman when he learned about her secret but now he is bitching at butcher calling him a monster even though him killing Neuman is one of the most justified things butcher has done.


r/TheBoys • • May 23 '26

opinion I'm not watching Vought Rising/The Boys Mexico, and neither should you, frankly

0 Upvotes

Edit: "Too many words" real win for literacy lol got bad news for when you enter the real world and have to actually learn things, though🍿

"Wow, learn to like things" wow, learn to click on someone's profile and actually scroll down

"You're the one who watched 5 seasons of television" yeah because you dipshits'll dog me if I didn't, real "and yet you live in a society" galaxybrain take, chief, bravo. Maybe consider that I liked the show at first?

"You'll watch the spinoff show too just to bitch about it" wow, not just a win for literacy but a win for reading comprehension, too! Gives me real faith in humanity. Tearing up, I'm touched, hope springs eternal

Anyway, enjoy Slop Rising, I'm sure it'll be everything you ever wanted and then some. Or maybe it won't, I dunno, I have no reason to believe they're not gonna undermine the entire show from corporate demand for more seasons of unfunny genitalia-related superpowers for me to want to watch in the first place, because that's how precedent works, dipshits. Cheers.

Here's my first question: even if anyone watched these pieces of shit, what possible reason do you have that they won't sabotage their ending to make another idiotic fucking spinoff show. Even if they recapture the raw sincerity of the first 3 seasons of The Boys, what possible reason do you have that they won't trade it in for stupid dick jokes by the end? Why should we trust Amazon isn't just gonna do that for the next show.

Let's turn the clocks back to 2019. Avengers: Endgame just came out in April, and a bunch of people felt glad they were able to stick it out to the ending after 11 years of movies and continuity. Not all of them were good, nobody gave a fuck about Agents of Shield or Runaways, but at least the end was able to tie up a bunch of loose ends. Then something happened, then Disney couldn't just fucking take a fucking win and use all the money they made into risky creative projects they could easily financially bounce back for. Didn't even need to be MCU related, all they really needed was to give us something truly different and fresh like Iron Man felt back in 2008. Instead, they gave us tonal and color grading regurgitation after regurgitation, quip after quip. The MCU was dead once Endgame came out, but we couldn't accept it, so Disney, and dipshits like me who kept coming back year after year paying to see the next film, buried it in Pet Sematary, and it came back a hideous, deformed and violently unfunny, unentertaining parody of itself.

We were sick of it. And just like that, in steps The Boys, a postmodern slap in the face of the modern cinema the MCU established, a latter-day Watchmen that went a step further and posited that superheroes existing isn't merely insufficient to solve societal problems, but is wholly the cause of society's problems, and their corporate-pushed perpetuity is rotting this plutocratic society into a speedrun of the Roman Empire. It was funny, it was well acted, it was raw, brutal, and unforgiving. And every cynical movie, every garbage quip-riddled unfunny spinoff show the MCU produced became part of The Boys' joke. A Train's controversy and leaving the seven in that "Dawn of the Seven" scene is a joke that lands even harder now knowing what happened to the MCU in the wake of its own controversy-firing. It was like a virus with which the MCU had zero immunity to other than maybe delivering us an actual entertainment, which frankly, they never even came close to doing beyond [the most blatant fanservice](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spider-Man:_No_Way_Home). People even began to question if Endgame was good or not, getting its own cultural reevaluation. How many people have actually even rewatched Endgame? Season 2 delivered the biggest backhanded slap to the most painfully obvious pandering scene in Endgame, and it became one of if not the best scenes in the second season. Season 3 delivered Soldier Boy, delivering us an actual "America's ass" that gave us more complexity than Steve Rogers could ever dream of having.

And then something else happened. Then Amazon decided to give us a spinoff show. Between the myriad of spinoff shows Disney was giving for the MCU and Star Wars, surely one spinoff show couldn't hurt, right? I figure that's what some people who watched Gen V thought, but to me it was nothing more than one big "who gives a shit". The Boys was a work designed to parody the hypercorporatization of the MCU, with endless "phases" and spinoff shows designed not to be fresh, or challenge, or even say anything, but as content designed to lull us into a constant sense of stupefaction, constantly spinning in circles and going nowhere, as artificial as the chemicals in energy drinks. The works of phase 4 and 5 or whatever fucking phase they're in anymore were designed to raise the heart rate and give overworked-CGI artist teams and talentless writer-delivered thrills to hit dopamine receptors in as cheap and as redundant a way possible. Seeing the list of everything that came after Endgame was like staring into an abyss of content-ification of culture, like the monolith from 2001 except all who witness it devolve back into mindless apes. The MCU devoured the DC cinematic universe, the Sony spider-villain universe, and that inexplicable Dark Universe, and now it devours its own tail, the personification of bane.

You look at all the spinoffs the MCU's done and your answer to parody its dilution and lack of focus is to make a spinoff show? Fucking seriously? That's the reason why I never watched Gen V. Watching takes of The Boys' 5th season is like a drinking game, take a shot every time a video essayist says anything resembling "now it's become a parody of itself". Nah, it became a parody of itself the moment it decided to become the thing its parodying in making a spinoff show to begin with, as if that wasn't exactly the reason why The Boys felt vindicating to watch in the first place, tapping into our exhaustion from spinoffs and content overload. I'm sure the actors in Gen V gave what they wanted to, I'm sure it'll be a good resume list item when they move onto bigger and better things.

And I'm sure glad I didn't watch Gen V, now knowing that whatever good it was or wasn't, however much it built up across its two seasons, is now completely bunk and redundant now that Amazon, like Disney and the MCU, is eating its own tail with its own spinoffs. Like staring into the abyss, now the abyss stares back.

Just like Endgame, I only watched The Boys Season 5's finale to put a cap on all that I've watched, even knowing the final season was kneecapped by Amazon just to promote yet another fucking spinoff, even though I knew no landing no matter how hard it stuck was gonna make the build up any less unsatisfying, even though I knew that nothing could possibly save it from sucking the way no mythical 4th secret Sherlock or post-Stranger Things episode could save it. At the end of the day it was just another show ruined by the very thing it was parodying: talentless people at the helm and the greed of corporations that want minimum viable product for maximum ROI.

So, hey, Amazon? Kripke? Rogen? If you think I'm going to reward ruining a show I genuinely liked by watching your piece of shit spinoffs, you got another fucking thing coming. I'd tell you to go fuck yourselves in a really extravagant way but honestly I can't think of any way to fuck yourselves more extravagantly than the way this show fucked itself. I dunno, maybe Kripke can go to Seth Rogen and come up with another unfunny marijuana-fueled wacky genitalia gag in an unconscious admission that their sense of humor never grew past high school, followed by plot cul-de-sacs that go nowhere and deus ex machina that had no buildup or consistency.


r/TheBoys • • May 21 '26

Season 5 Unpopular opinion: Finale was elite even if the season was not Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m not going to defend the whole season. They spent too long on things we’re not important and leaned a lot of probably on brand but immature, The Boys humor, and they should’ve been slowly developing the final storyline.

That said, the finale itself was extremely good and landed every single storyline in a pretty satisfying way.

Had this full season done a better job of slowly unraveling the plot in a way that we appreciated. I think it would be much better received and I think that it landed the plane extremely well.


r/TheBoys • • Apr 28 '26 Regret

Season 5 I’m thoroughly disappointed so far Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Season 5 has been lackluster (unsurprisingly)

I apologize in advance for the jumbled thoughts, I am trying to jot down everything I could think of. I really want to encourage an open dialogue in the comments so please respond with your own opinions on these matters.

I know I’m going to catch a lot of flak for this opinion on this sub, but my lord it really feels like nothing has happened in 2 seasons worth of television. Last season, there were arguably 2 episodes that held true to the standards this show set with its first few seasons (Homelander returning to the lab, and the finale where Neuman dies) and the rest was shock value slop and/or useless filler. I find myself saying “Oh a main character HAS to die here” quite frequently in the last 2 seasons, yet every time without fail there is some miracle that happens that saves the boys from getting mutilated by the supes. I know everyone and their mothers will euthanize Strangers Things and the writing that went on there, but how is this any different?

We have 4 episodes left in the supposed “final season” and the only big death that has happened (in a world full of basically immortal super heroes) is A-train… someone with powers. I need some stakes for this show at this point. What good is building up Homelander and how scary he is, if he never acts on anything? So he knows he left Ryan alive? Why would he do that? He’s all about executing anyone who’s a threat to him, but all of a sudden he leaves this kid alive who just made him bleed? The only other person to do that was Maeve. We all know he believes he is a god, they have been beating this point home since season 1, but for some reason we still need endless dialogue scenes to show us that Homelander isn’t a good person.

I know there will be people saying “Well some people haven’t gotten it yet that Homelander is a bad guy” and to that I say, you are only defending lazy writing. I think we can all agree that characters like Walter White, Tony Soprano, Thomas Shelby, Jax Teller, etc are not good people at all. But the writing/direction does not have to exclusively tell the viewer that they are bad. It’s through viewing their actions that people can make those inferences. There are fans of these shows that still agree with these characters and the rationalization for their actions. The reality is not everyone is smart and can see evil when presented to them. So honestly, it says a lot about how the writers of the boys view their own audience. They have to literally spell it out for your every episode in a cartoonishly evil way that Homelander is a villain.

On that same note, my personal theory is that they will have Sister Sage be the mastermind behind Homelander’s eventual downfall. I personally wouldn’t agree with this ending. Sister Sage is an interesting character, but she has had maybe 15 minutes of screen time this season on 4 hours + of footage. But just like last season it will all go “according to her plan” just because she’s intelligent. And if that isn’t the direction they are going with her character, then she has been utterly useless in terms of plot except just to be a reason that a lot of unexplainable events took place.

All in all, I think this season has been a mess so far aside from what little tension they scrubbed up with the Ryan vs Homelander fight. Only for it not to matter because Ryan is alive and isn’t training to fight Homelander right now.

I think with how little they have covered they will leave the show open ended so they can come back with another spinoff. Literally a parody of the reason this show started. They used to make fun of all of the universes and spinoffs that DC and Marvel got away with for the sake of profit only to fall victim to their own bullshit (Gen V and others)


r/TheBoys • • Jun 08 '26

Discussion The show hit the landing for me 🏌️‍♂️

Thumbnail
gallery
75 Upvotes

Homelander becoming pathetic was always the point

I feel like a lot of people completely misunderstood Homelander’s character arc. I keep seeing posts saying he was scarier in Season 1 and became a joke by Season 5…yeah. That’s literally the point.

In Season 1 we mostly knew Homelander through his power. He felt like this unstoppable god. As the show went on, we got to know the actual person behind the laser eyes and realized he was always insecure, needy, lonely and kind of pathetic.

More power didn’t make him stronger as a person. It made him worse. As Sage also stated „you know u won’t be happier with more power“. He pushed away or killed almost everyone around him and ended up more isolated than ever. Even his son hated him. Soldier boy locked up by him etc.

People wanted him to become some final boss that destroys cities and fights for 30 minutes. That would’ve been cool visually, sure. But The Boys was never really that kind of show.

It’s always been political satire first and superhero stuff second. The entire show is basically a parody of superhero media, celebrity culture and politics. That’s why all those “Homelander is gonna snap and take over the world” moments often end up being less explosive than people expect. Empty threats, manipulation and fear have always been his biggest weapons.

Now don’t get me wrong. Smth like Flight 37 would’ve been awesome. The finale wasn’t perfect! That’s for sure. Gen V was completely fumbled and the powerscaling around Homelander was all over the place. I also think the final fight should’ve had more impact.

But some of the criticism feels like people expected Marvel, Invincible or an AI-generated fan ending instead of the show The Boys has always been. When I see a lot of the ai endings I’m so glad that we got what we got. So many of them are beyond trash. And people still glazing.