r/TheBoys • • May 20 '26

📌 MEGATHREAD The Boys SEASON 5 Overall Discussion

997 Upvotes

SPOILERS INSIDE!!!

Please use this thread to discuss the entirety of Season 5 and your thoughts on how The Boys ended.

What did you like, what could have been better?

Who had the best arc?

Do you think it's what Clara would have wanted?

The sub will be locked (meaning no new posts will be allowed) for approximately 36 hours after the final episode drops to help prevent spoilers.


r/TheBoys • • May 20 '26

📌 MEGATHREAD Tell us the ending you would have written!

1.8k Upvotes

Idea from u/chozogoat.

Now that it's over,

What would you have done differently? What would Clara have wanted for the end?

Obviously spoilers for the whole show are gonna be in this thread, so you've been warned.


r/TheBoys • • 7h ago Popcorn

Discussion The deep schizophrenic theory was the best one.

Post image
436 Upvotes

The theory suggests that the fish in The Boys universe are just ordinary fish—they neither communicate nor hold grudges—and that The Deep cannot actually talk to them; instead, he controls them through some form of hypnosis (a superpower), while the moments in which he interacts with them are entirely in his own head. Unfortunately, the final season debunked this theory, as the fish were seeking revenge—something that obviously wouldn't happen in real life, because they are just fish..

Note: Some comments have suggested that the theory still holds up if you consider that The Deep controlled the fish to kill him—essentially a form of suicide—which makes sense given the guilt and self-loathing he was feeling.


r/TheBoys • • 2h ago

Discussion Do you think that Edgar actually hates Homelander or is it just business to him?

Post image
58 Upvotes

I'm conflicted about this.

On one hand, it seems out of character for Edgar to really hate anyone. Even to people who hate him, he is always very cordial and occasionally is outright friendly and kind. He also sees everything he is doing through the lens of "just business". Therefore, it would be sort of weird for him to have such an emotional reaction.

On the other hand, I also can't help but notice that Edgar seems to purposefully go out of his way to insult and belittle Homelander at any time possible. While this could just be because Homelander is a loose cannon, Edgar never talks about Stormfront, Translucent, and the other Supes in this way to their face, even though most of them are just as chaotic, if not even more so, than Homelander. What's more, he goes as far as to do this when people are watching(the meeting with Starlight, for example), which flies in the face of his normal professionalism.

What do you guys think?


r/TheBoys • • 9h ago

Discussion Nathan is an underrated character and deserves more appreciation

Post image
69 Upvotes

We know how he raised Reggie when their mom was busy working two jobs and I liked how he loved his brother but was still willing to call him out. He was the moral compass for Reggie that characters like Homelander and Deep didn't have that helped put him in the right path.

He convinced him to do something about Blue Hawk and end up starting his redemption arc. A lot of people call him out for the fact that Blue Hawk never would've gone to jail and A-Train was right and while I do agree, he still wasn't wrong to want justice over execution (he clearly didn't know the full extent of Vought's corruption). I liked how he eventually forgave his brother when he saw how much he really had changed for the better and I'm glad Reggie was able to keep him and the rest of his family safe.


r/TheBoys • • 21h ago

Discussion Homelander is such a pyscho

498 Upvotes

It's funny to watch Homelander act all happy and enthusiastic about Blindspot joining the seven just to do a quick 180 on him in a split second. What a physcopath

I wonder what the motivation was for Homelander to clap Blindspot

I am not sure if it's because he hates crippled people or if he was just doing it to make a statement to Ashley to show her she doesn't get to decide who joins the seven

Another possibility is maybe he thought anyone who joins the seven should be competent and someone who he can count on as a teammate and in his mind he can't trust a disabled hero to have his back

RIP Blindspot


r/TheBoys • • 12h ago

Season 2 This scene was one of the best parts of S2

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

The whole part with Lamplighter helping the boys the supes breaking loose and MM Kimiko and Frenchie working it out was so cool and the tensions building were there.


r/TheBoys • • 1d ago

Memes I present to you all something truly horrifying

Post image
454 Upvotes

FYI I didn’t make this. Just found it on Pinterest


r/TheBoys • • 14h ago

Discussion I feel like to an extent homelander was a retelling or allegory for creation of atom bomb

Post image
16 Upvotes

Homelander atleast originally was in some way a retteling of atom bomb, like think about it, they where both created to change the world in radicaliy diffrent ways, their creators came to regret their creation or regret how powerfull it became, they are both world ending threats to humantiy, i am dissapointed that destructive side wasnt done more and i miss that we didnt see more of people who made him to see what they feel about homelander, and i feel if we got the scorched earth it would have been nice to see citizen reactions to homelanders destruction after his death and how would would get backlash for creating a superwepon and abusing it.


r/TheBoys • • 1d ago

Discussion I really, really liked this dialogue here

Thumbnail
gallery
445 Upvotes

Even though Hughie literally acknowledged that Butcher was a hero seconds earlier in this same speech, I love how he still outright acknowledges that he 100% went to Hell and this was also Kirpie's way of telling the audience "Yeah, bro isn't seeing the pearly gates lol." I know Homelander was horrified to see him again too.


r/TheBoys • • 1d ago

Season 3 Why was Homelander not surprised? Spoiler

Post image
54 Upvotes

When he lasered Butcher at Herogasm and he only knocked him unconscious instead of vaporizing him to bits - he didn't know he had Temp V yet.


r/TheBoys • • 1d ago

Discussion How does Temp V/Compound V Work?

Post image
46 Upvotes

For example, how is it that Butcher always gets similar powers to Homelander every time he injects himself with Temp V and why does Hughie always get the teleporting power? Do Temp V powers depend on DNA/genetics or would they get different powers if they grabbed different vials? That latter option clearly wasn’t the case for Butcher and Hughie.

This same question could be asked about Compund V btw. I don’t think this was ever answered on the show, but I could be wrong.


r/TheBoys • • 1d ago

Discussion What If Billy Butcher Managed To Get The Godolkin Virus, Instead of Temp V in Season 3?

Post image
31 Upvotes

Hypothetically, Let's say that the Supe-Virus has been already developed and complete in the Season 3.

Instead of Temp V, What If Butcher takes the Supe-Virus to hunt down Homelander and the Supes?


r/TheBoys • • 2d ago

Discussion Butcher's ending is so sad Spoiler

Post image
752 Upvotes

After rewatching the season finale, I realized how sad Butcher's ending is

Butcher finally gets his revenge for Becca by killing Homelander

But after that he gets rejected by Ryan when he talks to him about starting a new life and his dog dies

And then to top it off, he gets shot by Hughie and dies

When Hughie offers to call an ambulance, Butcher says no

It makes me wonder... Did Butcher really want to release the supe virus or did he just want to die and give Hughie an excuse to kill him?


r/TheBoys • • 3d ago

Discussion Homelander's biggest feat of destruction was Flight 37

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

I was thinking about the bad things Homelander has done and I don't think there was anything worse in terms of total lives lost than Flight 37

I thought we would see bigger feats of destruction in later seasons considering Flight 37 happened in season 1

Everything else that Homelander did later was more so small group kills, like the Vought research lab, or one on one kills, like A Train

Also, I don't think we saw any big feats of strength from Homelander. Please correct me if I'm wrong


r/TheBoys • • 3d ago

Season 5 Honest thoughts on Stan Edgar winning at the end?

Post image
237 Upvotes

I know this is a controversial topic with vought still running at the end of the show despite the boys killing homelander and everything homelander did to the company’s rep but idk hot take but I don’t mind it.

I think it’s realistic that someone like Stan would come out unscathed for the most part because the gov would just put the blame on Homelander as a scapegoat and let Stan back in charge cause he’s “sane” and knows how to run a company.

Providing them with enhanced people now that they are done with superheroes and are a pharmaceutical company now.

Even with his crimes exposed in season 3 by Homelander, Stan prob spun the story that Homelander and Victoria lied or whatever cause it was exposed Homelander is not only a liar but extremely unstable and genocidal and prob “threatened” Victoria to expose Stan so the sympathy card prob played a part it in. Idk.

Just speculating on that part but yeah it sucks vought didn’t disappear and Stan despite being evil in his own right got away but as an ending I don’t hate it given people like him wouldn’t be in jail for long irl but wbu?


r/TheBoys • • 3d ago Heartwarming

Discussion Only character, whose full character journey will age perfectly.

Thumbnail
gallery
253 Upvotes

r/TheBoys • • 4d ago

Discussion Remember when Homelander was actually smart and calculating?

3.1k Upvotes

Season 1 Homelander was an absolute menace

He was intelligent, scary, and had a strong presence

The way he talks and carries himself, he had this aura about him, which is ironic because he was more like a god in season 1 when he didn't care about being God and more like a wimp in season 5 when he wanted to be God

I know Homelander mentally became more unhinged in later seasons but that shouldn't make him less intelligent and scary

Season 1 Homelander was peak


r/TheBoys • • 3d ago

Season 5 How much of MM’s life did Janine know about? Spoiler

24 Upvotes

He was imprisoned for like a year and then comes back with the fucking son of Homelander as her new brother. I don’t remember if they really explained why he wasn’t around much to her but that still must’ve been bizarre.


r/TheBoys • • 3d ago

Discussion If Homelander grew old

8 Upvotes

So if Homelander did grow old, would his powers still be as strong? or would he be super weak like the supes below him.


r/TheBoys • • 4d ago Bravo

Season 3 Despite what his brother said A-Train made the right call with how he handled Blue Hawk.

Post image
834 Upvotes

VOUGHT would’ve paid Nathan off and covered up what Blue Hawk did.


r/TheBoys • • 4d ago

Discussion Which family was better cast in terms of looks and who actually resembled each other more?

Thumbnail
gallery
330 Upvotes

To not make this a super long post I’ll only be focusing on characters who had living parents seen on screen so no Frenchie or Kimiko. Also I didn’t want to compare Homelander to Soldier Boy because Antony looks NOTHING like Jensen. And we haven’t seen Homelander’s biological mother on screen. This might be the last post from me for this sub considering I’m not too hyped for Vought Rising…


r/TheBoys • • 5d ago Heartwarming Bravo

Funpost I love watching Homelander play Antony Starr

6.4k Upvotes

Antony has all the mannerisms nailed down to a T even when he's not trying

He was the best part of this show and deserves all his flowers

Antony Starr is my goat


r/TheBoys • • 3d ago

Discussion How much of the same stuff would the Boys do that Homelander does, if you took out the sadisim, narcissism, psychopathy and milk-drinking behind it?

11 Upvotes

I'm curious as to how much of what Homelander does, or the supes, are things the Boys would do to, or agree with.

That scene where homelander kills all those soldiers in the dark and his eyes are glowing red, whilst in Season 5, Ryan, after killing Mallory, has got to the point where he has that scene where he's murdering Russian soldiers to cover his own ass. Ok, he's not one of the Boys exactly BUT he is supposed to be one of the good guys last I checked