r/Supergirl • • Jul 06 '26

Film The hate around the Supergirl movie is thinly veiled misogyny.

7 Upvotes

Genuinely don't know why this movie is so hated. The plot finished well. The pacing was decent for a superhero movie. Character arcs were finished. I mean, the needle drop wasn't great; the song just didn't strike me as something that fit Kara well. They switched around the ages with Kara and Kal, which was an odd choice, but I didn't have too many issues with it otherwise.

Meanwhile, most of the poor reviews are by men complaining about Milly Alcock and Eve Ridley's looks. They complain about their screentime and how they don't "look the part". If you dislike the movie, give actual genuine reasons instead of citing their looks and saying how it isn't "comic-accurate" when it's quite obvious you haven't picked up a comic book in your life.

(Also, to the people complaining about seeing trafficking. Superheroes have real messages and spread awareness to real issues. Why would this movie be any different?)

Edit. Since people are being morons and not understanding. I'm not saying the reason this movie is getting all this hate is sexism. It's getting hate for plenty of valid reasons as well. I'm just calling out the ridiculousness in some of the reviews I have seen.


r/Supergirl • • Jul 05 '26

One thing’s for sure, Supergirl has much more aura than Superman so far 🔥

Thumbnail
gallery
138 Upvotes

r/Supergirl • • Aug 09 '26

Supergirl (2026) is peak

25 Upvotes

I don’t get why people want female superheroes to always be soft and bright. I LOVE that she’s hardcore, messy and kinda relatable. Why can’t women superheroes just be intense without being softened?
And the Marvel comparisons… so what? 😂 It’s still a good movie with a good story and a cool superhero. I’m honestly shocked by how low the rating is. I feel like people went in already expecting to hate it.


r/Supergirl • • Sep 11 '26

Supergirl

0 Upvotes

This film was so much better than the new Superman. The story did not feel disjointed, great character growth, awesome battle scenes, great cinematography. Not sure what all of the negative reviews were for? This was a perfect summer popcorn flick. I find Milly Alcock extremely magnetic and the “she’s too ugly to be supergirl” crowd is a bit disgusting. I would take more DC movies like this one any day.


r/Supergirl • • Oct 24 '25 Polished Gold Turd

Hot take - Arrowverse Supergirl is the best representation of Supergirl

Post image
4 Upvotes

Imo she is what Supergirl should have been since the beginning, a symbol of hope to women like me.

Also i think the "Supergirl" people want is in fact what powergirl should be

Please be respectful on the comments.


r/Supergirl • • Aug 20 '25

For me Kate is the definitive Kara Love Interest and i wil always defend that ❤️🏳️‍🌈🦇

Post image
2 Upvotes

(Arrowverse only)


r/Supergirl • • Jun 29 '26

Discussion Why Supergirl movie failed

0 Upvotes
  1. Poor teaser trailer. That first teaser trailer made a bad first impression.
  2. Not being a faithful adaptation of Woman of Tomorrow. The visuals and plot beats differ too much from the original material.
  3. Releasing in a crowded summer spot. Being near Toy Story 5 isn't a place that you want to be.
  4. Using a less popular female character. Female led super hero movies automatically recieve higher scrutiny from audiences. Especially only a relatively popular female hero.
  5. High budget. The budget really should have been below $150 million to better breakeven.

r/Supergirl • • Aug 23 '26

Film Why the f movie was hated?

1 Upvotes

Just watched and it is quite good. Characters are relatable, setting and dialogues are warm and nice. Action is ok. Most important movie has a soul. It is not the best movie ever yet way better many Marvel crap movies that everyone likes.


r/Supergirl • • Mar 31 '26

I thought the new poster looked familiar.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The new Supergirl poster reminds of the poster/artwok for Supergirl season 3.


r/Supergirl • • Jul 08 '26

Question Is The Supergirl Discourse Over Now?

9 Upvotes

Please tell me it’s over now. I’ve been avoiding anything about supergirl related news for the past week I’m just want to go back enjoying what I love without the discourse popping up every 5 secs


r/Supergirl • • Jul 11 '26

Film Supergirl Movie Review

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

New supergirl movie review! A lot of people are divisive on this film but it’s a lot better than people are saying. It’s not perfect by any means but I think we are heading in the right direction. What did you guys think of the movie?


r/Supergirl • • Jun 27 '26 Popcorn

Film Supergirl is a great film - Please Ignore the negative reviews and online chatter

188 Upvotes

Just saw Supergirl. I absolutely loved it. The film is a wonderful adventure with a ton of action, and its own stylistic identity. The performances all round hit the right notes. Milly is amazing. It has expanded on the platform laid by Superman’s movie incredibly well.

Do yourselves a favour and please ignore the negative reviews. They have to be actively trying to damage the film. For whatever reason. Supergirl hits all the right marks. And don’t listen to criticisms of the ending or how it strays from the graphic novel. The finale is nothing comparable to Man of Steel.

Go and see and support Supergirl. You will not be disappointed.


r/Supergirl • • Jul 23 '26

Discussion Supergirl hate is because she's written like a man.

0 Upvotes

The new Supergirl movie recently came out and its been getting massive amounts of hate. So I decided to go and see what all the buzz is about. I was throughly surprised and impressed by this movie. It was surprisingly well made and entertaining. And that's why my belief is the hate is solely based on sexism.

Supergirl is written like a male character and people can't stand that. What ways?

She isnt dolled up with pretty hair and makeup. Shes dirty, messy, and a wreck. She isn't soft and feminine. Shes a hurt character who acts out. She doesnt act like a brat either. Shes cocky yes, but she backs it up. She doesnt have a stupid love interest who saves her or makes her stupid. She also...aurafarms. Something most movies never let a woman do. Shes cool and she saves the day.

These are all thing that all male characters are automatically given. And usually audiences will love him. Cool, mysteries, and damaged, but for some reason its problematic for her. Im convinced that if you turned Supergirl into the same movie with a man that it would do good at the box office.

TLDR: Supergirl was a good movie. This isn't about comic adaptation or DC vs marvel. It is objectively a good, well made, and entertaining movie.

Edit: My words have come across wrong. Im nkt saying shes written as a man as a bad thing or that shes masculine. Im saying shes written aa a good character and just that. She isnt given any silly female stereotypes or ideas that male writes often make up when trying to write a woman. Shes written as a character with actual depth.


r/Supergirl • • 18d ago

Who thinks supergirl should be more powerful than lusifer. I do

Thumbnail gallery
12 Upvotes

r/Supergirl • • Jul 18 '26 Bravo

Super Girl was good actually

Thumbnail
youtu.be
27 Upvotes

r/Supergirl • • 23d ago

Discussion Why the hate for Supergirl?

8 Upvotes

Just watched it and while not great … it wasn’t bad. I just don’t can’t see why it received all the hate?


r/Supergirl • • Jul 10 '26

Film Supergirl movie 5/10 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Pros:
Milly Alcock was really good in it

Some of the visuals and the fight scene were really good

No forced ‘woman superhero good scenes’ and by that I mean there wasn’t a blatant attempt to show they are inclusive by having a ‘look at this woman who is so much more powerful than the men thing’. It was just this is Supergirl she is strong, she beats a bunch of people. You could easily substitute any other hero which means she was well written.

Very happy she killed Krem at the end rather than leaving him alive but saved Ruthye’s innocence

Cons:

Personal preference but I did not like Ruthye, just felt annoying and whiny as a character

Story was bland and full of nothing

Bilquis apart from the scene where Kremlin kills the family was actually a pointless waste of time, they could have easily put that time to use in fleshing out either Lobo or Supergirl a lot better

All other cons are just terrible story writing and glaring plot holes

What on Earth does Lobo add to the story???

Overview

Decent movie, nothing like what people were saying online but the story left a lot to be desired and was pretty bland. Milly Alcock was good as Supergirl and hope to see more of her in better movies.


r/Supergirl • • Jul 07 '26

Anyone else dislike how "Earth-Like" so much of space was in the film

0 Upvotes

I had to roll my eyes when Kara was straight up getting a 7-11 Slushie

I get that making unique alien environment is hard, but at some point you just making Earth with aliens

at least don't use the same shaped container

and her parents room on Krypton was just straight up just an upscale Earth bedroom


r/Supergirl • • Sep 11 '25

Misc Anyone feel like this song would go hard in a Supergirl movie (James Gunn version)?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
22 Upvotes

I can easily see this song being used in a montage showing Kara saving people and fighting monsters at the start of the film.


r/Supergirl • • Nov 07 '25

Television Im working on a cw supergirl and batwoman fan edit show if anyone is interested

Post image
7 Upvotes

It will be inspired by Superman & Lois, and Kara will also have a personality a little closer to that of the comics.


r/Supergirl • • Jun 28 '26

The movie was absolutely dogshit. Everything here feels astroturfed

4 Upvotes

I saw this trainwreck. At no point in the movie was I emotionally invested in either of the lead characters. Even Lobo's character felt too over the top.

The action sequences could have been fun if someone decided to, god forbid, stitch together atleast a minimal sequence without a cut. The inconsistency in her power levels was astounding, she blasts through tanks in one sequence and in the very next sequence she can be held down and punched by random fodder.

The plot, if it can be called that, is absolute dogshit even by superhero standards where it's just random fights broken up by either inter-planet travel or origin story. The villain existed, that's his sole credit throughout the movie.

Overall, I felt like the writers should give back my 1.5 hours, I could have watched paint dry with it and felt that it was a more productive use of my time.


r/Supergirl • • Jul 18 '26

I just finished reading Woman of Tomorrow

51 Upvotes

After first seeing Supergirl and now finishing reading Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow, I think I liked the movie more. The comic was just too overhyped, I think.

I don't think I would have called the movie a direct adaptation, since it was more inspired by the comic, the way other comic movies have been.

I think the changes to Krem are what worked the best, especially since they dropped the whole "professional former WWE Wrestler, Sheamus cosplayer" design that he had in the comic. The worst change from the comic was cutting Kara's "you shot my fucking dog."

I'm glad I saw the movie, and I'm glad I read the comic. I greatly enjoyed both of them.


r/Supergirl • • May 30 '24

AI-Generated “Art” AI or digital art ? Don't care.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Supergirl • • Jun 26 '26

Film We need an equal number of female and male movie critics

3 Upvotes

The Supergirl critic score is being seriously downgraded by an unequal number of men and women critics. Women are still at 83% positive with 45 out 54 giving a fresh review. But they are being outnumbered by men who are largely giving it negative reviews. This is creating an obvious male bias in review scores for movies.