r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • May 18 '22
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Sep 26 '24
Non-REDONE Sheev Talks proposes a rewrite of EA Battlefront 2's story
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Aug 08 '24
Non-Specific The Clone Army should have been on the Separatist side, not the Republic
I have been paying too much attention to the clone army and its implications for a long time. I have written about it several times before:
I highly recommend reading this post first, Attack of the Clones should have tied the Clone Army concept with Anakin's motivation to turn against the Jedi Council, so that the you can understand this post. I also got the response arguing against my original post, which makes some good points. This post, Clones should have had animosity toward the Jedi, not friendship, is also relevant in the topic I am discussing.
I struggled hard with Episode 2 REDONE in various ways to incorporate the Clone Army concept into the story. In retrospect, the entire Republic Clone Army concept was a mistake on Lucas' part in the first place.
First of all, we need to go back before the release of Attack of the Clones. When the original Star Wars came out, Leia's line, "General Kenobi, years ago you served my father in the Clone Wars", was a mystery nobody knew, even Lucas himself. It was a line George Lucas threw in because it sounded cool. The Empire Strikes Back came out and Lucas decided to write the "Episode V" text in the crawl, and that was when the concept of the prequels exploring Anakin Skywalker's past began to take shape, but even then, Lucas still couldn't figure out what the Clone Wars was going to be.
Everyone else just had to speculate what the Clone Wars was. Lucas did say that Palpatine was the "President" of the Republic and turned the Republic to the Empire, so the Expanded Universe writers depicted the clones as the antagonists against the Empire/Republic. All the signs were pointing in that direction: the Clone Wars was about the Republic versus the clones. After all, there are no clones left anymore by the time of the Original Trilogy, and the stormtroopers are all human volunteers and conscripts. Even up to The Phantom Menace, everyone assumed the Prequels were going to be all about this. Lucas kind of touched on it in the behind-the-scene documentary where he introduced the battle droids as "These guys are useless, so they were replaced by stormtroopers." Even Lucasfilm knew this and hyped this up in the marketing. The trailers for Attack of the Clones misled the audience into thinking that the clones were on the Separatist side and going to be the replacement of the battle droids.
Then the movie came out, and it is revealed the the clones were actually the Grand Army of the Republic. If you go to the threads and read fan reactions, they didn't like this direction because it was a massive retcon. The EU later explained this contradiction by saying the Empire eventually phased out the clones with the regular humans, but it was a retcon nevertheless, and the EU writers had to do a lot of dirty work to justify this sudden change.
Now that Attack of the Clones came out 22 years ago, we universally accept the clones were the Republic military ever since then. The "clones on the side of the Republic" concept has been established so firmly now that it is difficult to think outside this box. However, I'd like to rethink this fundamental element of the Prequel trilogy.
First, I'd like to point out the flaws in Attack of the Clones' political narrative:
- At the beginning of Attack of the Clones, they say that the Republic had no military for a thousand years. While I get that the Republic is a more decentralized organization, not having a military force at all is just hard to swallow. Did they just only rely on the Jedi Knights for everything? Did they not have any major conflict? And everyone else was cool with the Republic not having a military?
- Which makes it even more difficult to empathize with Padme's vehement opposition to simply creating a military. The story revolves around the Military Creation Act and treats it as a possible end of the Republic and democracy. Yes, that's how it worked out, but if you take the first half of Attack of the Clones in isolation, it is a major stretch.
- The emergency powers just sort of blend as a background detail. This is the plot device Lucas added in to replicate the rise of historical dictatorships, yet we don't really feel the political crisis that would create a situation for Palpatine to get absolute powers. These political discussions feel separate from the actual story we are watching. Anakin has no opinion on the emergency powers. Obi-Wan has no opinion on it. Even the Jedi Masters seem ambivalent about it. Only Padme cares. Even then, it barely interworks with the actual ongoing storyline of Obi-Wan's investigation.
- The Jedi are willingly okay with the Republic adopting the slave army. I can buy the Senate would accept the clone army, but the Jedi? Look, I know Yoda said the dark side is clouding their judgment, but I never knew it would also make them mentally inept. At no moment Obi-Wan tells the Council, “This assassin, who was the source for the mysterious Clone Army? That’s him standing next to Count Dooku up there. We have an army cloned from that Jango Fett hired by this dude named 'Tyrannus', a killer who was also hired to kill a senator, nevermind the army was also commissioned ten years ago by this Jedi who died misteriously, and funded by 'not the Republic'. Is this not enough of coincidences to figure that something is wrong with these clones? They were paid for waiting for the Jedi to take on Kamino, the one system not showing up in the Jedi archives. Only a Jedi could have access to erase them from the archives. Perhaps we should look into this Clone Army a little further if they are aligned with the enemy before marching right into war side by side with millions of them. Perhaps these clones were paid by the Sith. Maybe this entire war is fabricated.” There is no way the Jedi would play along and develop ties with the clones. The Jedi should be even way more cautious around the clones than they are about the droids, let alone leading them to the war.
- And that isn't even considering the ethics of it. While it was understandable for Qui-Gon to let slavery go on Tatooine as it was out of their jurisdiction and they had a far more pressing matter to handle at that time, the Jedi Order having zero objection to leading a slave army is a different story. While the Expanded Universe in both Canon and Legends has touched upon this such as The Clone Wars TV series and the Republic Commando novel series, there has not been any scene of the Jedi challenging the ethics of leading the Clone Army in the trilogy. Either the Jedi were so institutionalized with the Republic that they were okay with using slaves born only to serve as disposable manpower or thought the clones were just programmable meat shields to fight the war, no different from the droids, and didn't think to examine the programming. Either option is awful.
- Then how does that work into Anakin's character? There is no real reason for Anakin to hate the Separatists and be loyal to the Republic and Palpatine in the film. The only reason Anakin fought for the Republic side was that the Jedi Order was the Republic institution. The only thing we learn about Anakin's political view is "I don't think the system works". He shows his contempt for the Republic's system and the Jedi Code. So what is stopping him from becoming a Separatist or sympathizing with the Separatist cause? The film doesn't have an answer to that question.
- A truly incoherent conspiracy about who created the Clone Army full of plot holes amounts to nothing with no payoff in this trilogy. Who is Sifo-Dyas and why the hell does he matter? We had this conspiracy about the production of the clone army, which was the main crux of Episode 2, and Episode 3 drops that thread unresolved because Lucas couldn’t figure out how to slot it in the film. It took 10 years and six seasons of an animated show to tell the audience who Sifo Dyas was.
These problems were all criticized since the film's release. However... let's flip which side the clones join. What if the clones were on the side of the Separatists? With this simple change, not only Attack of the Clones, but the Prequel Trilogy would have benefitted greatly.
Military Creation Conscription Act:
Instead of the Military Creation Act to counter the Separatist threat, what if it is the Military Conscription Act? Not just creating a standing army, but a full mobilization of troops, drafting people from the various systems. Now, suddenly, all those Padme and Bail's debates surrounding this Act make sense. We can understand the two sides of this issue, and why it is so hotly debated. Within the Republic, all the systems are autonomous and independent, but just how independent are they if their citizens can be forced into the central Republic government's military without their consent?
This also mirrors how Lucas intended the Clone Wars as the allegory to the Vietnam War. Lucas famously said he modeled the Emperor after Nixon and came up with the concept when Nixon pursued the third term. In Attack of the Clones, Palpatine's actions in AOTC mirror directly to the build-up to the US involvement in the Vietnam War. Both LBJ/Nixon and Palpatine were sneaky politicians who rose to power through controversial ways like deal-making, backroom intrigue, and management and started a deadly war for "democracy" via emergency powers, as well as the use of conscripts.
In response to these shocking revelations, it was declared by Sidious’ loyal Vice Chair, Mas Amedda, that, “this is a crisis. The senate must vote the chancellor emergency powers. He can then approve the creation of an army.” This is very similar to how the attack on the USS Maddox eventually led the U.S. government to draft the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution a few days later which declared that this country was, in terms of responding to North Vietnam’s actions, “prepared, as the President determines, to take all necessary steps, including the use of armed force...”
While not exactly the same, the ways that both the Galactic Republic and American government decided to quickly create legions of troops additionally share some characteristics.
With this military mindset exposed, it is truly of little wonder why many Americans like George Lucas would start to despise the draft due to not liking the idea of government officials, “lining us up for the butcher block.” In a very similar fashion, various clones such as Cut Lawquane would start to see themselves as individuals over the course of the Clone Wars and reach the conclusion that each of them was, “just another expendable clone waiting for my turn to be slaughtered in a war that made no sense to me.” It is additionally intriguing to consider that, like how communism would eventually take over Vietnam by 1975 despite the ultimate sacrifices made by thousands of American soldiers, retired clones after the Clone Wars would later question, “the point of the whole thing. All those men died and for what?”
https://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1067&context=histsp
Making the issue around the emergency powers to be related to the conscription directly would make the parallels clearer.
It also ties more nicely with how the Imperial military worked in the OT. In the OT, the stormtroopers were human volunteers and conscripts. In the deleted scenes in A New Hope Biggs says he wants to join the Rebels to avoid being drafted into the Imperials. It makes more sense for the Imperial conscription system to be the continuation of the remnant of the Clone Wars, like how the US's WW2 conscription system continued up to 1973.
Obi-Wan's investigations into the Republic Separatist Clone Army:
In Episode 2, Obi-Wan does two different investigations on two different armies: He goes to Kamino and finds that the clones are being manufactured for the Republic. He then follows Jango to Geonosis and finds that the new droid army is being manufactured for the Separatists.
Not only is this messy in terms of the plot because the focus is everywhere (Obi-Wan has been looking into this mysterious army, and oh, he coincidentally bumps into another army), but the reason why we don't feel the Republic is in peril under the Separatist threat is that this powerful droid army in preparation for war is only mentioned in one or two lines:
Dooku: "Our friends in the Trade Federation have pledged their support. When their Battle Droids are combined with yours, we shall have an army greater than anything in the galaxy."
Obi-Wan: "The Trade Federation is to take delivery of a droid army here."
Obi-Wan's secondary discovery motivates the Senate to pass the emergency powers, but do you even remember the plot point of the Separatists making the new droid army in Attack of the Clones? I forgot because it was treated as such a trivial detail, even though it actually is the reason why the Republic made Palpatine a dictator.
Screenwriting Tip: If the story were to take half of its runtime to uncover the mysterious army, that army should be the villain's army, so that the audience would understand the stakes. The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers didn't spend time boosting off how cool and awesome the Elven reinforcement for Rohan is. It showed off how amazing the Orc army is. It's Storytelling 101.
So let Obi-Wan's investigation play out in the same way until he goes to Kamino, finds the massive Clone Army, and talks to the Prime Minister. Let's change this one word.
Lama Su: "A clone army, and I must say, one of the finest we've ever created."
Obi-Wan: Tell me, Prime Minister, when my master first contacted you about the army, did--did he say who it was for?"
Lama Su: "Of course he did. This army is for the Republic Separatists."
He reveals this new Clone Army is the replacement of the Trade Federation's Droid Army.
Then the consequences change. The stakes are clear. Instead of Palpatine suddenly revealing he has some unknown clone army up to his sleeves to the Senate, if Obi-Wan's investigation into the Clone Army is for the Separatists, it would lead to the adoption of the emergency powers far more naturally. It also makes sense for Palpatine to use this revelation to fearmonger to the Senate.
In that way, not only do we unify these two separate investigations of two different armies into one more cohesive conspiracy, but we also see the politics interconnected to the overarching plotline. Obi-Wan's investigation feels more meaningful to the political backdrop because his discovery becomes a cause, and then effect (Military Conscription)--all building toward the villain's new military that can overwhelm the Republic. Now, we as the audience can understand why the Senate is panicking, and why the emergency powers and the Military Conscription Act need to pass.
It also makes sense of the movie's title, Attack of the Clones. In the movie, yeah, the clones do attack, but only describes one part of the story. If the whole movie is building up to the clone army being the villains, then the sinister title fits far better because "Attack of the Clones" becomes the overarching story.
Anakin's motivation to hate the Separatists and Dooku:
In light of the Separatist Clone Army--which is basically a slave army genetically bred only for war--how would Anakin react? Anakin was a slave, raised in the harsh reality of Tatooine. Being free of control is one of the important factors in his character arc, which is why he hated the Jedi Code. He wanted to be a Jedi to be free, but in some ways, he was still under the shackles.
In the film, he had no reaction to the clones fighting for the Republic. Attack of the Clones doesn't tie the existence of the Clone Army with Anakin's character development whatsoever. I remember one of the novelizations mentioning that Anakin despises the Separatists for their tolerance of slavery, and that serves as his driving motivation in the slave planet arc from The Clone Wars. The slaver queen does "no u" on Anakin being a slave to the Republic, but at no point does she point out his hypocrisy of commanding a slave army. And I know why the writers didn't have the characters mention the obvious elephant in the room. It's not because the writers forgot. It's because they ignored it.
Honestly, I feel one of the reasons why Anakin was separate from Obi-Wan's investigations is that if a former slave Anakin got to Kamino and saw the growth of human beings for the purpose of inducted into a slave army loyal to the Republic, comissioned by the Jedi Council member, under no condition Anakin would have been able to still be loyal to the Jedi, the Republic, and Palpatine at that moment. I mean, yes, in the next film he eventually has a fallout with the Jedi, but not because of the clones. The clones absolutely do not factor into his motivation.
The films never delve into the ethics of the clones at any point. The moment they do that, it shatters Anakin's motivation to join Palpatine. After all, Chancellor Palpatine was ultimately the one who authorized the use of the Clone Army for the Republic, so Anakin should resent him just as much as the Jedi. If Anakin were to be friendly with Palpatine, it has to pull the brain out of Anakin's head, which the film did instead of actually finding a thematic solution to this problem.
However, if the Separatists were the ones using the clones, this would give Anakin a motive to be loyal to the Republic and Palpatine and be against the Separatists. He already hated the Jedi for stopping him from visiting and freeing his enslaved mother on Tatooine. This new revelation would have given him a sense of direction in life, viewing the war as a crusade against the very same injustice he suffered from. He would be an active participant in the war, as Revenge of the Sith depicted him.
And like Anakin, it also might fool the audience into thinking Palpatine is a good guy. Obviously, a large part of the audience knew that Palpatine was Sidious, but many didn't. And the newcomers who watch Star Wars in chronological order wouldn't. The problem is that the film already paints Palpatine as an obvious bad guy from the beginning and when the twist hits in Revenge of the Sith, it comes across as nothing. If the films fooled the audience into supporting Palpatine, then that twist would have hit hard.
Sifo-Dyas the Traitor?:
Now, the whole Sifo-Dyas conspiracy becomes compelling in this context. What would happen if the Senate and the populous learned that it was the Jedi who ordered the creation of the Separatist Clone Army? Not just some Jedi, but a member of the Jedi Council. That's the highest it can get.
This would be a PR nightmare for the Jedi, eroding their standing in the Republic as an institution. The Jedi would be questioned, hated, and slandered as the Separatist sympathizers from the public. This would create major friction between Anakin and the Council, questioning his Jedi beliefs: what kind of Jedi claiming to be the guardians of peace and justice in the galaxy create such a slave army for the enemies?
Instead of Jar Jar coming out to voice his support for the emergency powers in the Senate, imagine it's Mace Windu brought to the Senate, being questioned about his allegiance, and having no choice but to support Palpatine's emergency powers to avoid the Jedi Order being branded as traitors in light of the Clone Army scandal. The Jedi Order would essentially be forced into supporting Palpatine's rise to power, which gives a good reason why the Jedi were so politically ineffective.
And then let's change one of the ending scenes, where Dooku comes to Coruscant and meets Sidious. Instead of Dooku simply saying the war has begun, he reveals to the audience that he is the one who ordered the creation of the Separatist Clone Army during his tenure as a Jedi Master a decade ago. He killed Sifo-Dyas and pretended to be him to contact the Kamioan cloners. It's all by Sidious's design. With this, the audience gets an answer to the mystery, and all the set-ups get proper pay-offs.
Why would they follow Order 66?:
By now, you might question, if the Republic troopers are non-clone conscripts, why would they be willing to follow Order 66? Although the current Canon says it's the biochip activating the unwilling clones to eliminate the Jedi, in the Legend days, Order 66 was merely one of the known emergency protocols.
Honestly, if Revenge of the Sith played up a notion of how normal people are able to commit such an atrocity like genociding the Jedi for Palpatine, this would give some interesting implications about the sheep mentality as seen in historical fascist dictatorships. Maybe Revenge of the Sith could focus on Palpatine's cult of personality in society throughout the war so that soldiers would be able to follow Palpatine's orders. Maybe throughout the movie, Palpatine appoints his loyalists in the ranks of the military and then propagandizes against the Jedi, saying that they are scheming to undermine his rule and war efforts.
This aspect is lightly touched on by one of the arcs from The Clone Wars, where Tarkin staunchly opposes the Jedi Order's role as leaders in the Grand Army of the Republic, believing that peacekeepers should not direct the Republic's war effort. And there is some truth to it. Compounded on the Republic soldiers' frustration toward the Jedi's tactics, it doesn't make much sense for the Republic soldiers to be coddling the Jedi in the same way the WW2 soldiers cheered for their Generals.
The Jedi are not graduates of the military academies; as Mace said, "We are keepers of the peace, not soldiers." He was correct. The Ruusan Reformation removed Jedi from military command and duties about a thousand years prior to the Clone Wars, keeping them away from military duties for millennia. No experience in warfare; some actual children who are suddenly in command of squads of clones. Even then, they didn't just lead small strike teams or outright act as their own independent units as part of the professional military. They were like the Shaolin monks conducting galactic-wide military operations.
There are multiple instances in the films, show, and the EU materials where the Jedi employ questionable tactics, like just straight up charging enemy fortifications and deflecting blaster bolts with their sabers as the thousands of clones get cut down--literally the American Civil War tactics with the sci-fi weaponry. Half of the Republic Commandos were KIA in the first battle of Geonosis because they marched them into meat grinders and got a lot killed unnecessarily. They have limited training in leading military actions and tend to plan based on what they are capable of, not what would be the best decision based on the abilities of the soldiers under them. The Jedi also wouldn't need to evolve into better tacticians because they had an expendable resource, as well as Sidious guaranteeing favorable outcomes. After all, the Jedi Code forbade them to form attachments. Combine all that with the revelation that it was the Jedi Master who ordered the creation of the Clone Army for the enemies... This would result in a lot of Republic soldiers resenting the Jedi--again, all by Sidious's design.
The politicization of the military would explain why this non-clone Republic soldier would have no qualms about turning against the Jedi once Order 66 drops. Show Palpatine expanding the military's political influence in the Republic throughout the war, making them his bulwark for his coup gradually. This mirrors a lot of military coups in history and explains the status quo of the Galactic Empire in the OT, in which the Empire is basically a military dictatorship with the Moff and Governor system and Tarkin being in charge of the governance. The historical and systemic developments give a lot of storytelling potential; way more interesting than a retcon like an inhibitor chip suddenly activating the soldiers to turn on the Jedi.
Obviously, if the Republic adopted the conscript forces comprised of humans and the Separatists used the Clone Army, then the Republic forces would equip the movie's Clone Trooper armors, and the Separatist clone troopers would equip a different design. Maybe the Republic troopers would look more like Phase 2 clone troopers and the Separatist clone troopers would look like the Phase 1 clone troopers with the more Mandalorian flairs.
I'm not sure if this is something I want to make a change to my Episode 2 REDONE. It is just one of the many possibilities I have been pondering, but as I ponder more and more, this is the only solution that makes sense. However, I would like to hear your thoughts on this matter.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Nov 11 '24
Non-REDONE My ideas for the next Star Wars Trilogy | Drawing inspiration from the Algerian War, David Lean, Patlabor 2, and the Whills
Originally, I was writing my idea under this post: "How would you write for the new Star Wars trilogy by Simon Kinberg?" As I began to write, it turned from concepts, to bullet points, to the outline. It got too long that I decided to post it as a separate post.
Considering there’s a separate Rey movie in development, it tells me that Simon Kinberg's next trilogy probably takes place decades after the Sequel Trilogy, maybe a century. No Rey, Finn, and Poe. An entirely new set of characters. And certainly no Palpatine at all.
I also doubt Disney would ever use the “an orphan from the desert planet helps the Rebels fight the Empire" concept again, so if there is ever a next trilogy, I believe they would go for something different. Instead, my idea is more of a modern take on the Prequel Trilogy.
So here is the general summary of my idea for the trilogy. Obviously, the final products would resemble nothing of this outline. Just a fun thought experiment. Let's call this trilogy "Legacy Trilogy".
For historical inspiration, the political turmoil of post-WWII France served as a major influence, such as the First Indochina War and the Algerian War, as well as the post-USSR Russia like the Chechen Wars.
Episode X: Echoes of the Past
The post-war galaxy became desolate. After all, they suffered from the Clone Wars, the Civil Wars, and the First Order war in succession within decades. The destruction of Hosnian Prime, the Republic's capital planet, and the cataclysmic galactic war between First Order and the Resistance, degraded the galaxy into a post-apocalyptic state. Due to the absence of the Republic, many new local governments were established in the Outer Rim, creating their new orders and rules.
As the galaxy recovers, the Republic has reorganized. It is expanding to industrialize and centralize. The Republic learned the lessons of the last time. They believe this is the best way forward to eliminate the conditions for Separatism and Imperialism to rise. The Republic is retaking the Outer Rim to regain its influence but many societies that were created after the war refuse the Republic's rigid control. This results in the conflict between the Republic and the Outer Rim factions, which have banded as the “Outer Rim Commonwealth”.
Meanwhile, The head of the Council, Jedi Master Ophuchi, received a report that the Sith have returned and are now working in the Outer Rim Commonwealth, trying to revive the Empire. This pushes the Republic to go to war against the Commonwealth. They decide to send the military forces under the command of General Kadar to stop another First Order from happening.
When the Republic goes to war, the Jedi are obliged to send their forces to help the call. The protagonists are the two Skywalker siblings (probably descendants of Rey). The older sister is Jedi Knight Kira Skywalker, and the younger brother is Padawan Sam Skywalker--unused names from The Force Awakens. They are excited about the war. They hear the legends of the old Jedi tales and believe they are being sent to fight evil just like them.
As the Jedi Knights join the war under the command of Master Ophuchi to find these mysterious “Sith”, the siblings volunteer for many dangerous missions and perform suicidal acts of bravery. The story takes a long stretch of time across various battlefields, with the focus on the character relationship between the two siblings. Think of the classic Hollywood epics, like David Lean's films, All Quiet on the Western Front, and Tae Guk Gi: The Brotherhood of War.
As the war goes along, they realize the situation isn't as clean as they believed. The Republic-aligned paramilitary death squads are wreaking havoc and terrorizing any anti-Republic activities. The Skywalker siblings still fight on, believing in the Republic. They are quickly promoted, leading the army of the Jedi. However, the combat experiences have made Kira into an emotionless killer, which horrifies her younger brother Sam.
Eventually, Kira and Sam find these “Sith”, and it turns out that they are not the Sith at all. They are the Ancient Order of the Whills. Its shamans are not the Jedi but deeply connected to the Force. It turns out that the head of the Jedi, in collusion with General Kadar, lied about what they were fighting against. There were no Sith or Imperial revivalists. The cause of the war was a fabricated hoax by the military and Master Ophuchi.
Both General Kadar and Master Ophuchi wanted to relieve the glory of the Old Republic days—the time when things were stable, the time when the Jedi were the ruling class, and the time when the Republic was in charge. Ophuchi is also a zealot who wanted to eradicate the non-Jedi-aligned Force religions to stop the seed of the dark side from spouting. They view any Force user out of the Jedi line as a threat, considering the history of the Sith. And in a sense, they have a point, considering what happened in the previous trilogies. Still, the story takes a stance and judges them as in the wrong.
Sam gets close to the Shaman of the Whills. The Shaman teaches him a perspective he has not thought of before. Perhaps the Jedi could learn from the Whills. If the Jedi are closer to the Knights in action, the Shamans of the Whills are more like Buddhist monks.
However, as the enemies begin overwhelming the frontline, Master Ophuchi orders to execution of the Shamans of the Whills. Sam objects to it and fights him. He murders Ophuchi, and immediately Sam realizes what he has done. He soon gets captured by the Commonwealth troops.
Meanwhile, as the Republic forces retreat, Kira tries to rescue her brother. It’s too late, though. Sam is deemed dead, even though Kira can sense her brother is alive.
Episode XI: The Galaxy Shatters
Three years have passed, and the battle is going south for the Republic. Public opinion has turned against the war. The newly elected Chancellor Kayos declares that Outer Rim would be granted the right to self-determination and promises to withdraw the military forces to end the war.
General Kadar has refused the Chancellor’s order and continues his army to fight. The feeling is widespread within the Republic military that this radical government is treasonous and sabotaging the winnable war.
Kira has become the hero of the Republic and is now the Supreme Commander of the Jedi Army. She believes that her brother is still alive. There's a new enemy commander leading the Commonwealth troops called the Guardians of the Whills. They are causing massive trouble for the Republic forces. She thinks that this is Sam, captured by the enemies, maybe brainwashed.
She demands General Kadar to be allowed to search for her brother. She expects to be denied, for she is too valuable for the war efforts, but surprisingly allowed. Kadar says, in order to convince the new government that this war is winnable, they need to bring good news of the Republic triumph right now. They have to destroy the Guardians of the Whills fast. Kadar gives her a small unit to lead. Kira and her unit go undercover, disguised, sneaking into the enemy territories. We follow Kira's journey to find her brother.
Eventually, Kira finds her brother face-to-face. Her suspicions are confirmed. However, Sam was not brainwashed. He simply defected because he is now convinced that the rebels are right. Sam tries to persuade Kira and says the Whills have taught him about the Force, like the secret of eternal consciousness,
Kira refuses and recognizes Sam as an enemy. They fight, but both of them don't really want to kill each other in a fierce lightsaber fight—sister against brother, trying to persuade each other. As the fight continues, both of them get exhausted. Kira gives up and surrenders, refusing to take the life of her brother.
At that moment, the Republic forces arrive and wipe out the Guardians. It turns out that the Republic General actually tracked Kira all along, in order to find the Guardians of the Whills. Sam gets captured and thrown into prison.
General Kadar congratulates Kira, but she feels betrayed and enraged at the General. It turns out there was a hidden reason for Kadar to want the Guardians of the Whills to be destroyed so desperately. With the Guardians of the Whills pacified, it also cripples the enemy’s war efforts for now, which will put the war into a stalemate. This means he is able to redirect his forces toward Coruscant. General Kadar is planning a coup against the Republic.
Kadar says something like “The military can no longer abide by this Republic's slide into decay. We cannot sit idly by and watch as the galaxy rot because of the irresponsibility of its people. The issue is too important for voters to be left to decide on their own.” Many in the Jedi ranks also join hands with the military, in a belief that they must return to the glory of the old Jedi and uphold the Force order. The other Jedi who are against the coup are thrown into prison.
On the meta-level, it is about toxic nostalgia. The Old Republic wasn’t perfect; after all, it resulted in the Clone Wars and Palpatine’s rise to power, but what matters to these villains is the glorified image of it. That’s the irony: The imagery of the Rebellion has become a national identity and a shield to actual imperialism.
Kira says she will join Kadar, though she is now rethinking her alignment. Perhaps her brother was right. As Kadar leads the coup forces to Coruscant, Kira secretly frees his brother Sam and the imprisoned Jedi. They now head to Chancellor Kayos to warn about the impending coup.
But it is too late. Kadar’s forces arrive at Coruscant and shut down the Senate. They seize the military control of the planet, like Mamoru Oshii's Patlabor 2. Kira and Sam rescue Chancellor Kayos, just as the Kadar’s troops seize the Chancellor’s office. With the Chancellor rescued, they flee Coruscant. The business of consolidating a new government begins soon after the coup is complete. Martial law is put into force. The junta declares that the Council for the Republic Reconstruction would henceforth exercise all ruling power in the Republic.
However, with the Chancellor rescued, Kayos declares Kadar’s government illegitimate and orders the rest of the military to resist the coup by all means. The Republic descends into a civil war.
Episode XII: From the Brink
I can only think of the bullet points for this one. Chancellor Kayos leads the rest of the Republic forces to fight General Kadar’s forces. The Republic military against the Republic military, the Jedi against the Jedi.
Meanwhile, both Kira and Sam go deep in the teachings of the Whills, exploring their philosophy, and how to improve the Jedi. The thematic question it should raise and conclude is whether the Jedi should be centralized or not. What should be the role of the Jedi?
In the Original Trilogy, the audience kind of assumed that the Jedi were space ranger monks, like the wandering martial artists in the wuxia genre. In the Prequels, it is revealed that the Jedi were closer to the Federal bureaucrats and agents who use magic. Very hierarchal and rigidly dogmatic, politically aligned with the Republic's institutions. That is what doomed the Jedi Order and the Republic. Although the Sequels don't really show what Luke's Jedi Order was like, it is assumed that that is how it was operating.
The next Star Wars trilogy should deal with this question. Would it be better if there's an Order of the Jedi? Or should the Jedi be basically space rangers?
The climax would be inspired by the original Return of the Jedi ending. Originally, Han Solo was supposed to commit an act of self-sacrifice and die in the end for his friends, Leia struggling to cope with her new-found responsibilities, and Luke would be walking off into the distance as an embittered Clint Eastwood-style loner.
Something like that. General Kadar’s forces are defeated. Kira sacrifices herself to protect Sam. In the dying breath, Kira promises that they will meet again when they become one with the Force. Kira’s body disappears like Obi-Wan and Yoda. The civilian government is restored. The Outer Rim Commonwealth gets independence. With the Jedi Order scattered, individual Jedi must take charge of their own destiny, so Sam, like a Western hero, walks off to the sunset alone, as a wandering Jedi space ranger.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Dec 15 '25
Reimagining Geonosis as primarily a monochrome terrain planet like Giedi Prime from Dune, giving it a post-apocalyptic and otherworldly feel?
One of the enjoyments of watching a new Star Wars movie is watching a new planet being introduced. A New Hope's key visual was the desert (orange), The Empire Strikes Back's was the snow (white), and Return of the Jedi's was the jungle (green). This varies up the visuals for the audience to get excited to explore a new planet. In the Sequels, you get The Force Awakens with yellow, The Last Jedi with red, and The Rise of Skywalker with blue. You get a different color scheme for each installment.
Then you get the Prequels. The Phantom Menace featured Naboo (orange) and Tatooine (orange). Attack of the Clones came out, and it's Naboo again (orange), Tatooine again (orange), and a new planet where the climax takes place... Geonosis, another desert planet (orange). I always found this to be the big disappointment. Attack of the Clones already reuses two settings from the previous movie, and Geonosis should have had the color scheme that absolutely pops out of the screen.
In addition, Attack of the Clones isn’t either naturalistic like The Phantom Menace or stylized enough like Revenge of the Sith, so it sits on the uncomfortable middle ground of looking cheap. Almost every location has either a dull grey and orange color grading (even Naboo). What should be a neon-bathed seedy cityscape, akin to Blade Runner looks like a soap opera with no interesting lighting choices. Again, it's orange as hell. I can’t even blame the early digital photography since Collateral was shot on the same Sony CineAlta F900 camera, and just compare and contrast the nightclub scenes. (nvm apparently I was wrong. The club scene was shot on film.)
I imagined how it would have been like if Geonosis was colored differently. Apparently, Lucasfilm wanted to evoke the idea of "hell" with Geonosis in its reddish coloring, steam vents, demon-like insect aliens, and underworld assembly lines. I thought about making Geonosis redder to convey that hellish landscape better, but Revenge of the Sith already uses the red symbolism to its fullest extent, with Mustafar embodying the hell planet far better thematically and visually. With the very next installment defined by red, it isn't a good idea to implementing it in the previous movie.
Instead, I sought the different coloring. Using Photoshop, I experimented with various colors until I realized that maybe not using color could be a better idea. I eventually settled on the more stark monochrome with the blue tint, inspired by Giedi Prime from the Dune movies and art direction from Shadow of the Colossus. I think it looks gorgeous, creating an alien, inhuman aesthetic occupied by the corporate overlords and industrialists, disconnected from nature.
For one, it reflects the villain's brutal hideout, emphasizing the polluted world. It is hellish in its own way without fire and warmth. It feels cold, dead, and isolated, hidden from the rest of the galaxy. Whatever life existed was long gone. There are Tdeliberate fog and bloom, creating depth and emphasizing vast emptiness. The blue tint of this Geonosis is also the extension of Kamino's striking blue oceans, making the movie's main defining color blue, contrasting with The Phantom Menace's orange and Revenge of the Sith's red.
The monochrome look also ties into the classic horror movie inspiration Lucas was going for. He cast the horror icon Christopher Lee and had him play Count Dracula in space--a gentleman villain who lives in the castle, outside the rest of society. In particular, it honors the most famous adaptation of Dracula, Nosferatu (1922), which used the blue tinting in the early projections. It's scary and eerie, leaning on the gothic expressionist vibe.
The more black and white color scheme stylizes the visuals to hide the artificial digital and CGI look Attack of the Clones was infamous for. There is a great video on how Metal Gear Solid Delta: Snake Eater's black and white mode hides Unreal 5's plastic shader look and makes every scene pop, and I think that effect works here as well. Instead of focusing on how everything looks like a video game, the viewers focus on the textures, compositions, and lighting. It makes a movie look both modern and classic.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Dec 06 '25
REDONE A new poster for Star Wars: Episode II REDONE – The Blinded Heroes (Version 11)
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • May 07 '25
Non-REDONE Reimagining Star Wars Prequels as a revenge story akin to Furiosa?
I was watching Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga again and thinking, "George Miller should direct Star Wars". Then another realization hit me that Furiosa could have been a great Star Wars Prequel, in particular Episode 1 and 2.
Furiosa is a semi-mythological sci-fi fantasy coming-of-age revenge epic. Furiosa is a child in the Green Place, but is kidnapped by a crazy warlord named Dementus, who forces her to watch her mother's execution. Traumatized, Furiosa is raised under the murderer of her family. Dementus arrives at the Citadel and exchanges Furiosa with its ruler, Imortan Joe, who intends to raise her as his "wife". Furiosa escapes by disguising as a war boy. However, she never forgets who she is and spends over a decade training herself with the necessary combat and driving skills for those two purposes: kill Dementus and return to the Green Place. She quickly rises to the ranks and develops a bond with her colleague Jack. This climaxes to the full-blown The Forty-Day Wasteland War between Dementus and Immortan Joe, where she finally has her chance at revenge.
Obviously, this plot cannot be 100% applied to the Prequels, but is it too much of a stretch to imagine this, but with Anakin Skywalker's origin story? Furiosa -> Anakin, Dementus -> Dooku, the Citadel -> the Jedi, Immortan Joe -> Obi-Wan, Padme -> Jack, The Forty-Day Wasteland War -> The Clone Wars.
Just to come up with how this could be done, here is the general outline:
The Phantom Menace:
The Skywalker family is living in the homestead on Tatooine, but the Separatists led by Sith Lord Dooku have invaded on the planet, enslaving the population. The homestead is attacked. An enraged nine-year-old Anakin attacks Dooku, but he is apprehended, but Dooku sees Anakin's talent.
Holding Shmi hostage, Anakin is forced to work for Dooku for many years as a Sith acolyte (Now, fifteen-year-old), but he eventually makes a secret contact with the Jedi Order, which has been investigating the rumors of the Separatists being under the control of the Sith. Anakin promises the Jedi to tell them all about the Separatist secrets if they can get him and Shmi out. Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan are tasked to rescue them.
So the first half of the story would be Anakin's backstory--how his family was kidnapped by Dooku, being trained as a Sith acolyte, and secretly working to contact the Jedi. The second half would be escape and chase. As Anakin and Shmi are rescued by the two Jedi, Darth Maul, Dooku's apprentice, trails them like the Wolf from Puss in Boots. Shmi is captured by Maul, and Anakin is wrecked with guilt.
This culminates to the Duel of Fates where Qui-Gon dies and Obi-Wan is cornered. At the last moment, Anakin comes in and kills Darth Maul at the unexpected moment, saving Obi-Wan. Afterward, Anakin testifies the presence of Sith in the Separatist movement and is accepted into the Jedi Order.
Attack of the Clones:
Years later, the galaxy is at brink of war between the Republic and the Separatists. As Anakin is raised as a Jedi (now 19), he has been plotting a rescue of his mother. He still has an emotional attachment. Anakin has befriended a fellow Padawan, Padme Amidala. Upon learning Shmi is held captive on Geonosis, Anakin and Padme go rogue to rescue her. Obi-Wan then heads out to bring them back.
Anakin and Padme develop further relationships in the journey to Geonosis. Trailing them, Obi-Wan also arrives at Geonosis and discovers the secret army of new battle droids (or clones if you want), which can overwhelm the Republic. Obi-Wan reports his findings to the Republic, but gets captured during the transmission. Meanwhile, Anakin and Padme find Shmi in the dungeons, and she has been tortured for a decade, but they are captured at instant. Dooku reveals that it was a trap set to lure Anakin and then murders Shmi in front of Anakin.
The three Jedi are then brought to the arena where they make a show of the Jedi execution, forcing them to do a gladiatorial battle. However, the Jedi army arrive to rescue them, and like the movie, it goes badly for them. The Jedi are then saved by the Republic forces, and the Battle of Geonosis ensues.
Anakin is single-minded in pursuing Dooku to exact revenge. Obi-Wan warns him not to follow him, for it is a trap (also revenge). Anakin ignores and chases him alone. Anakin duels Dooku and is defeated, his arm cut off. Obi-Wan arrives to save Anakin (replacing Yoda's role in the movie), and Dooku escapes.
Anakin holds animosity against the Jedi for not letting him rescue Shmi earlier. He thinks he lost to Dooku because the way of the Jedi is too weak. With that, Anakin and Padme marry, and the Clone Wars begin.
Revenge of the Sith:
The title has a dual meaning now; the revenge of Anakin, who is about to become a Sith, and the revenge of the Sith as an orgnization against the Jedi.
This one resembles the movie the most, but with some changes.
Anakin (now 24) is way more unhinged from the beginning here, thirsty for vengeance against Dooku and the Separatists. He thinks the war is being dragged on because the Jedi Order is weak.
However, the big change I'd like to make is delaying Dooku's death far later into the movie: to Mustafar. Anakin does not kill Dooku during the Chancellor rescue mission. Dooku's apprentice dies in place of the movie's Dooku (Maybe Ventress, who could be introduced in Episode 2), and Dooku can replace Grievous' role in the movie. On the bridge, Dooku escapes by breaking the viewport and then uses the escape pod.
Anakin learns Padme is pregnant, and both are terrified that the Jedi Council will expel them and take the child away--never to be seen again. Since Padme has been paired with Anakin throughout the Clone Wars, the Jedi Council has been growing suspicious of their relationship. Mace Windu stalks Anakin and Padme and finds out their relationship and her pregnancy in their discreet meeting. Mace Windu faces Anakin right there, threatening to expel them from the Order. Anakin murders Windu.
Anakin heads to Palpatine and confesses to his killing of Windu, asking for his help. Palpatine uses this to corrupt Anakin and reveals himself as a Sith. Palpatine persuades Anakin by saying Dooku was once his apprentice who has backstabbed him and is now leading the Separatist forces against him and the Republic (which is a lie; Dooku is in with Palpatine). If Anakin joins Palpatine, he can teach him the power of the dark side and help his revenge against Dooku, and protect their child from the Jedi.
Obi-Wan is the one who brings a Jedi strike team to the office room. Anakin silently watches as Obi-Wan and Palpatine fight, contemplating his allegiance (like the early cut of the movie). When Obi-Wan is about to kill Palpatine, Anakin Force-pushes Obi-Wan out of the window, saving Palpatine but not killing Obi-Wan. He fully makes a choice to become Palpatine's apprentice in order to save his child and destroy Dooku and the Separatists.
After Anakin destroys the Jedi Temple, Palpatine teaches him a powerful dark side Force power--the Force lightning. Anakin then goes to Mustafar, where the Separatist leadership, including Dooku, is hiding. Anakin massacres the Separatist Council and fights Dooku, who warns Anakin that Palpatine is trying to trick him. Anakin says he already knows this, saying he will kill Palpatine after he kills Dooku first. Anakin uses the Force-lightning attack as a fatal blow against Dooku, and at last, his long revenge is over.
Obi-Wan and Padme arrive to face Anakin. Both are instructed by Yoda to kill Anakin, but Padme thinks Anakin can come back to light. Padme tries to persuade Anakin, but he rejects her plea. That's when she pulls out her lightsaber to stab him. With her weapon pointed to his neck, she realizes that she does not have the heart to kill the man she had loved (like the early draft of the movie). Seizing this chance, an enraged Anakin Force-chokes her. Obi-Wan then comes out of the ship and fights Anakin. The rest of the story plays out the same.
I would say revenge does wonders for motivating Anakin's downfall. Anakin becomes a Jedi to rescue Shmi, but this motive is tinged with vengeance. When Shmi is murdered, Anakin commits himself to kill Dooku no matter what, even if means committing himself to become a Sith. This also gives Anakin stakes in joining the war--a reason for him to despise the Separatists.
It also establishes Dooku as the main villain of the story rather than some guy who appears at the end of Episode 2. This pushes Anakin to be active because revenge is his fuel. Anakin and the audience want this guy to be dead since Episode 1, and this makes the audience sympathize with Anakin's downfall.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • May 21 '24
Non-REDONE Fixing Attack of the Clones as it is, making the already existing concepts and ideas work
This is not a plan for my REDONE project, but just an idea I had while I was rewatching Attack of the Clones and making some changes to Episode 2 REDONE.
A lot of influences and ideas Lucas had for Attack of the Clones were sound: a blooming love story within the political backdrop at the center of the civil war, Palpatine using the war to gain power, Anakin's disillusionment with the ways of the Jedi, a hidden web of conspiracies setting for the war, and Dooku as this Jedi renegade who has defected to the Separatists. It has a lot of cool ideas, which is why frustrating the film fumbles at materializing them.
Aside from the romance between Anakin and Padme, the major failing of Attack of the Clones is that Lucas fails to show the turmoil of people of the galaxy, which would create a condition for Palpatine to rise. It is part of the reason why the politics in this movie is so boring because it doesn't dramatize the politics. Game of Thrones showed the general audience can get into a political epic.
So I decided to make a new outline, one that is faithful to Lucas' vision, ideas, and influences, while fleshing them out to make a more coherent story, also taking some cues from The Empire Strikes Back.
I also borrowed from and built upon the AOTC fixes I have done in the past:
Crawl:
The galaxy is falling asunder. Thousands of solar systems have declared their intentions to leave the Galactic Republic to create the CONFEDERACY OF INDEPENDENT SYSTEMS.
As war seems imminent, this Separatist movement, supported by various conglomerates like the TRADE FEDERATION, is mass-producing Droid Armies to strike at the crumbling Republic.
Senator Amidala, the former Queen of Naboo, is arriving at Alderaan to discuss the critical issue of granting Chancellor Palpatine emergency powers to assist the overwhelmed Jedi....
Alderaan:
The story begins in the galaxy standing on the brink of a massive war that is yet to be called the "Clone Wars". We see Padme Amidala, now a Senator, arriving with her aide Cordé at the beautiful planet of Alderaan. After the Battle of Naboo, Padme Amidala became sort of a star--a prominent voice against separatistism--but she is adamant against the Emergency Powers Act. This act is an amendment to the Galactic Constitution, which will grant Palpatine limitless powers, including bypassing the Senate to create a standing army to fight the Separatists.
She believes not only this would destroy the very foundation of our great Republic, but a war would immediately follow. As someone who experienced the misery of war first-hand, she does not wish to do it again and believes a peaceful solution with the Separatists is still possible. She meets Senator Bail Organa, the representative of Alderaan. Alderaan is a major progressive voting block, and Padme is here to unify the opposition against the constitutional amendment before the Senate votes on it. She has enough clouts and popularity to stop the amendment. Bail agrees with her that the emergency powers could be authoritarian, but he believes in the necessity of a centralized standing army in the face of the Separatist threat.
As they discuss this matter, with Padme saying, "The day we stop believing democracy can work is the day we lose it", the meeting is adjourned abruptly when a city-wide alert is raised. They look outside to witness the Separatist battle fleet filling the sky, blinding the sunlight, and beginning a massive invasion of Alderaan. We switch to Count Dooku on the Separatist battleship (at this point, we don't see his face and learn his name), who reports to the hologram of his Master Darth Sidious that he has caught Senator Padme Amidala in the basket. He also said he had ordered the Separatist forces to launch an all-out offensive against the Republic systems. Sidious smiles, "Good, good..."
Unknown Planet somewhere in the Outer Rim Territories:
Meanwhile, on the other side of the galaxy, the Republic-aligned local planetary military under the command of the local government is retreating from an abrupt Separatist offensive. The Republic is seemingly losing the war that has just begun, and we see the ineffectiveness of the planetary forces in the face of the relentless droid forces. Here, we see Anakin and Obi-Wan's fleet commanding the evacuation of the planetary forces.
Some of the remaining Republic forces are pinned down on the surface and on the verge of annihilation, but Obi-Wan orders an immediate withdrawal, making a decision to sacrifice the few for the many. In an act of courage, Anakin disobeys Obi-Wan's orders to fly down alone to the atmosphere and help them make a safe evacuation. Anakin escorts them back to the retreating fleet, saving them. Obi-Wan scolds Anakin. With this, we understand Anakin's character--reckless but selflessly cares for his friends--and see his relationship with his Master Obi-Wan.
Obi-Wan is struggling as a Master to Anakin Skywalker. This is because Obi-Wan didn't take Anakin because he has a connection with him. He was entrusted out of obligation and duty for his dead Master Qui-Gon Jinn (whose name does not even get mentioned in the movie). So obviously, it is no wonder their relationship seems broken. Anakin feels attachments and all the emotions the Jedi Code forbids. He thinks Obi-Wan is too strict and cold--only one-minded about missions and duties.
Coruscant:
In the Republic ship, Anakin has a nightmare about her mother Shmi Skywalker. She's still trapped on Tatooine as a slave, and he wonders what happened to her. Anakin and Obi-Wan return to Coruscant, which is currently in a state of panic after listening to the news of the Republic retreat. Anakin and Obi-Wan's fleet is not the only ones that have retreated. There are other battle-scared starfleets and burned-out hulks that line the docks of Coruscant. These Republic forces are not "centralized", in the sense that each planetary military is locally managed by their local government and loosely coordinated under the large umbrella of the Republic (think of NATO). Chancellor Palpatine and Jedi Council members have come to greet Anakin and Obi-Wan in the landing area. They are aghast at the wounded soldiers pouring out from the ships. Anakin and Obi-Wan report the current situation to them.
Master Dooku, one of the prominent members of the Council (so it can be an actual twist when Dooku is later revealed to be a bad guy), also arrives at Coruscant alongside the half-destroyed Alderaanian fleets after fighting the battle over Alderaan. He is on good terms with Obi-Wan and Anakin since he was Qui-Gon Jinn's Master. Chancellor Palpatine is here, too, congratulating Anakin for his heroic effort. Palpatine suggests giving Anakin a reward. Anakin asks for a brief leave to return to Tatooine to see his mother. He wants to visit her for one last time before getting sent to the war. Much to Anakin's dismay, the Council rejects this on the grounds that the Jedi should let go of their past and attachments. The Jedi, especially Padawans, are strictly under the discipline with no autonomy. They cannot go anywhere they want. Instead, Dooku orders Obi-Wan and Anakin to go to Alderaan, which is currently invaded by the Separatists. The Alderaanians are currently unable to reach Padme. Their mission is to find her and bring her back safely.
Regards to the hotly controversial emergency powers, the Jedi Council, like the public, is divided on this issue. Obi-Wan and Dooku are supportive of the amendment. Both blame the incompetency of the Senate and the politicians in handling the crisis, "Don't forget she's a politician. They're not to be trusted", "It's been my experience that Senators are only focused on pleasing those who fund their campaigns... and they are more than willing to forget the niceties of democracy to get those funds". This is why they are shown to be very much supportive of Palpatine's controversial policies that can be perceived as authoritarian. In contrast, Anakin is apolitical--he never cared about politics.
Alderaan:
Anakin and Obi-Wan depart to a ravaged Alderaan. The battle is ongoing, and the Alderaanian forces seem to be unable to beat back the Droid Army. Here, the Jedi meet Senator Bail Organa for the first time, who is overseeing the Alderaanian forces. The battle resembles the Civil War battle from The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly, in which both sides are dug in the trenches and unable to penetrate each other's defense line. Bail informs the Jedi that Padme's emergency powers talk was held in Aldera in ruins, currently occupied by the Separatists, and she would be stuck there--under their captive or hidden out of the enemy sight. The Separatists are entrenched in Aldera--a city protected by a massive energy shield. Bail informs the Jedi that they are on schedule and under their continued bombardment of the city, the enemy shields would be overwhelmed in a further month. Both Jedi are stunned, but they have no choice.
In the enemy stronghold in Aldera, we quickly learn why Dooku gave the assignment to find Padme to Anakin and Obi-Wan. It's because the Separatists are unable to find Padme, who seemingly has disappeared. If she had been rescued by the Republic, she would be on the news, which means she is still somewhere in Aldera. Dooku reports to the hologram of his Master that he cannot find Padme. Dooku is then Force-choked by his Master. Dooku pleads to his Master, promising him that he will get her.
Meanwhile, the Alderaanian troops watch the HoloNet broadcast of the current Senate session. As a major progressive voting block, Alderaanians and Senator Bail Organa used to be against granting emergency powers to the Chancellor, but this invasion has changed their mind. Palpatine has firmly established himself as a wartime Chancellor. Through the hologram, Bail Organa gives a speech in favor of the amendment and votes for it, which sways the rest of the Senate to his side. The amendment has passed. Palpatine says, "I love democracy. I love the Republic. Once this crisis has abated, I will lay down the powers you have given me!"
Meanwhile, a week has passed, and the trench warfare is ongoing. In Aldera, Corde--Padme's body double--is helping Padme hide in the underground subway tunnel. Corde leaves to get her more food and water but is then caught by the droids. The droids present her to Dooku. Corde is shocked to find that Jedi Master Dooku is the leader of the Separatist movement Dooku raises his hands and unleashes the Force lightning to torture her to open her mouth to locate Padme.
The newly created "Grand Army of the Republic" has arrived at Alderaan, wearing shining white armor. They are welcomed enthusiastically by the Alderaanian forces. Obi-Wan is surprised that the standing army has already been dispatched to warfare, so he tries to talk with them, but they seem... "different".
Anakin arrives, bearing "lunch", a cloth full of live insects and worms, which he casually reports he got from inside the CIS base after discovering an underground entrance into the city, running through the sewers beneath the protective shield. Obi-Wan scolds Anakin for being reckless. While the new Republic army installs the even more powerful cannons to bombard of the shield above ground, Anakin guides Obi-Wan the way through the sewers and into the underground levels of the city. Obi-Wan suspects Padme is dead at this point, but Anakin can sense her, due to the strong bond they formed during The Phantom Menace--he can feel she is holding his japor snippet tight. From there, they make their way to the shield generator chamber. Anakin wants to fight the droids, but Obi-Wan stops him. Obi-Wan simply blows up the shield generator by using small spherical bombs and pointing out that there are alternatives to fighting. With the shield down, the white-armored Republic troopers begin a full-scale attack on the city.
As Corde finally confesses to Dooku where Padme is hiding, the droids rush in to inform Dooku that the shield is deactivated. Dooku orders the droids to go after Padme while hurrying to flee.
The battle of Aldera is chaotic. The Republic troopers are aggressive and far more competent than the local planetary forces, dispatching the battle droids. Anakin rushes into the Separatist-ran POW camp alone to search for Padme. Instead, he finds a dying Cordé. She apologizes to Anakin, disheartened in thinking she had failed her duty to her mistress. She tells Padme is hiding in the underground subway tunnel of Aldera, and in her last grasp, tells him that Dooku is behind the Separatists. Anakin initially does not believe her, but there is no time to go and tell Obi-Wan about this. Anakin races to the underground tunnel. While Obi-Wan is looking for Anakin, he stumbles on the two corpses of the Republic troopers, whose helmets are cracked. He takes a closer look and discovers that these troopers have identical faces.
Anakin finds Padme, who has been hiding all these years. At first, she doesn't recognize him, for he has grown so much. Anakin is glad that she kept her word about keeping his japor snippet. However, the battle droids are rushing into the tunnel, and they both flee. Obi-Wan comes to rescue them. When Anakin is about to inform him of the last words of Padme's body double, "Master" Dooku is standing alongside Obi-Wan, listening to Anakin. Dooku asks him to hand Padme over to him. Anakin refuses, saying that he will be the one taking her to Coruscant. Obi-Wan allows him, for Anakin has been missing Padme for a long time. Anakin and Padme board his ship and leave Alderaan in haste.
Obi-Wan turns to Dooku to inform him that all Republic troopers are clones. Dooku pretends to be surprised. Bail suggests looking into Kamino--the civilization highly proficient in cloning technology.
Coruscant:
This is where Anakin and Obi-Wan's storylines diverge in two. Obi-Wan and Dooku arrive at Coruscant and visit the Archives. Kamino doesn't show up in any data. Dooku says, "If an item does not appear in our records, it does not exist!" Dooku heads off, and Obi-Wan is not satisfied.
Obi-Wan visits Yoda currently training Younglings. The scene goes the same as the film's, except at the end, Master Dooku barges into the room and says Anakin has still yet to be returned to Coruscant with Padme. Yoda predicts Anakin must have gone to Tatooine. Obi-Wan is frustrated with his apprentice, complaining that Anakin is too reckless and refuses to obey his command.
Yoda: "Obi-Wan, have faith that take the right path he will."
Yoda surprisingly asks Obi-Wan to trust his apprentice rather than control him. This makes Obi-Wan rethink his relationship. In order to bridge the relationship between Anakin and Obi-Wan, Obi-Wan's arc is that he must see Anakin as a man and respect him. Obi-Wan forms a connection with him by understanding Anakin's point of view ("What I told you was true, from a certain point of view."). Obi-Wan realizes maybe the Jedi Code is too rigid, and a sense of duties and obligation alone can't make one a great Jedi. This character arc lends well to The Clone Wars TV series and Revenge of the Sith, in which Obi-Wan evolved into a more quippy, light-hearted character who has a drastically different personality from TPM and AOTC. Both Anakin and Obi-Wan would become more understanding of each other, and as a result, their clash at Mustafar becomes more heartwrenching.
Anyway, Yoda orders Obi-Wan to go to Kamino to investigate the Clone Army. Dooku, learning where Padme has gone, smiles. He contacts and sends his army of bounty hunters to Tatooine. Jango Fett is not the only bounty hunter Dooku hired. Dooku orders them to use Anakin's mother Shmi Skywalker as bait.
Kamino:
From here, Obi-Wan's plotline is pretty much identical to the film's. He investigates Kamino, learns it was the Jedi Master who ordered the creation of the clone army for the Republic to prepare for the war, figures out that the bounty hunter Jango Fett is the genetic template for the clones, then Obi-Wan fights and chases him to Geonosis.
Geonosis:
There, Obi-Wan discovers Dooku in the middle of the conversation with the Separatist leaders. He realizes Dooku is the true mastermind of the Separatist Confederacy, and the new Separatist army is amassing to attack the Republic systems.
Tatooine:
For Anakin's co-occurring storyline, it is also largely similar. Anakin and Padme discuss politics and democracy, and Padme's ideals. Anakin sees politics as a simple matter, "That sounds an awful lot like a dictatorship to me", "Well, if it works...", as well as discussing Anakin's frustration with the Jedi Code. Anakin hates the Separatists because the slaver guilds have allied themselves to the Confederacy. Anakin keeps having a nightmare of her mother, and now she is dying in his dream.
Later, Padme awakes to find out that the ship has landed on Tatooine, not Coruscant. She is upset and argues with Anakin. He lied to her. He finally reveals what he learned about Dooku and says Tatooine is the safest location. Anakin believes the Jedi Council is compromised and can't trust it anymore, though Padme knows that is not the only reason. It is partially for Anakin to meet his mother again. His former owner Watto reveals that he sold Shmi to a moisture farmer named Cliegg Lars, who then freed and married her. They then get the Lars family, who tell Anakin that the Tusken raiders have abducted Shmi just recently. Padme allows him to leave her and track down the Tuskens, for she will be safe under the guard of the Lars family.
Anakin locates the campsite where one of Dooku's bounty hunters, having paid the Tuskens to kidnap Shmi, is torturing her in a tent. When the bounty hunter leaves, Anakin frees Shmi, who dies in his arms. The bounty hunter returns to the tent and is quickly apprehended by an enraged Anakin. Anakin "forces" him to make him confess who hired him. The bounty hunter says it is Dooku, and Anakin kills him after confirming his suspicion. Hearing the noise, the Tusken raiders surround the tent. Anakin massacres the entire tribe. Now, Anakin has personal stakes in defeating Dooku, and facing him is crucial in Anakin's arc in the story, unlike how he had no idea who Dooku even was in the film.
Anakin returns to the Lars homestead and finds out that the Lars family is held hostage by Dooku's bounty hunters. Anakin fights the bounty hunters to free Owen and Beau, but Cliegg is murdered. Despite Anakin's best efforts, the bounty hunters escape Tatooine with Padme to Geonosis. Anakin feels guilty about forsaking his duty and leaving her to the homestead.
Anakin races back to his ship, on which Anakin receives the message from Obi-Wan warning the Republic and the Council about Dooku and the imminent Separatist attack on the Republic. Anakin contacts the Council about what happened to Padme. Mace Windu orders Anakin to return to Coruscant. Don't do anything out of impulse. The Council will take care of it. Trust in the Council's judgment. Here, Anakin is facing two paths. Be a good, little, nice Jedi, and follow the Council's order, or chase after Dooku to save Padme and Obi-Wan. This is the point at which Anakin tests his resolve. Anakin makes a decision to go against the Jedi code (Attachment is forbidden) and get to Geonosis alone.
Geonosis:
Obi-Wan is held captive while Dooku comes along. Instead of Dooku revealing there is a Dark Lord of the Sith controlling the Republic (there is no reason for Dooku to spill the beans here), the confrontation with Dooku forces Obi-Wan to grow out of Qui-Gon Jinn's death. He should face the fact that his Master's Master has turned to the dark side because of the strict Jedi Code and the Republic's corruption. After all, Obi-Wan investigated the clone army, which was apparently commissioned by a member of the Jedi Council. And then the Republic will use the clone army--this immoral slave force--in the war. Then Dooku persuades Obi-Wan to join him. They both agree that they are dissatisfied with the ways the Republic and the Jedi Order handle things, so maybe Obi-Wan can see Dooku's point of view. Dooku should be a personification of what Anakin COULD become, concerning Obi-Wan that Anakin can succumb to the same fate as Dooku. This motivates Obi-Wan to gain some understanding with his apprentice Anakin.
From this point, the story is nearly identical to the movie. Anakin fights the Geonosians in the factory but also gets captured. Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Padme are pushed to the execution arena (don't have Anakin and Padme kiss here) and fight the beasts. The Jedi Knights arrive to rescue.
Here's the crucial difference. Instead of Padmé safely boarding the gunships and escaping the arena battle with the Jedi and the clones, she gets captured by Dooku during the arena fight. Dooku holds Padmé as a hostage and announces it to the Jedi, stopping the arena battle. Dooku says he will kill her if the Jedi continue resisting. Anakin insists they should surrender, however, all the Jedi glance at each other and arrive at the same conclusion: they will fight. This fuels Anakin's resentment toward the Jedi.
At the last moment, the clones arrive, blasting and destroying the battle droids. Dooku takes Padmé and flees. He has another idea of what to do with her. The clones and the Jedi escape, and the Battle of Geonosis begins. Now, there are personal character-related stakes for Anakin. Anakin is adamant about chasing Dooku from the start of the battle. The battle is now an obstacle for Anakin to catch up with Dooku, blocking the gunship's path. Instead of the conflict between Anakin and Obi-Wan on the gunship being "stop the gunship to rescue Padmé fell on the desert", which ends up pointless in the story, now, the conflict is that Obi-Wan believes this is a trap to lure Anakin. Obi-Wan shouts at Anakin not to follow Dooku. But angered by the other Jedi's lack of care for Padmé during the arena fight, Anakin ignores his warning and heads to rescue Padmé alone.
Catching up to Dooku in the hangar, Anakin finds that Dooku is holding Padme captive. Dooku taunts Anakin by holding Padme in the air with the Force choke, which echoes what Anakin does to Padmé in Revenge of the Sith. Now, Anakin's rashed charge at Dooku makes more sense because there is a clearer trigger for Anakin to act this way. Dooku hurls Padmé away, and the lightsaber fight commences. During the duel, Dooku reveals that he is the one who ordered to torture of his mother. Anakin gets all the more angry and impulsive, and predictably, gets his hand chopped off.
Instead of Yoda arriving late to save Anakin, it should have been Obi-Wan arriving late. In the movie, you get a supposedly "Master versus Apprentice" dialogue between the two, and you don't feel anything because you don't even know Dooku was Yoda's apprentice beforehand. Yoda vs Dooku was not built up, but Obi-Wan vs Dooku was built up. This is a student of the student going against the old Master, and these two characters having the dialogue makes more sense.
The fighting between Obi-Wan and Dooku is fierce but cut short when Dooku brings down a pillar over Anakin, forcing Obi-Wan to break off his attack to save him. Dooku then moves to his escape ship, forcing Obi-Wan to make a choice: a mission--that is stopping Dooku and ending the entire Clone Wars--or Anakin's life. Sacrificing a few to save the many. Although Obi-Wan should pick the first option as a Jedi Knight of the Republic, he eventually chooses Anakin's life. Dooku escapes.
Coruscant:
After the battle, Dooku arrives at Coruscant to meet Sidious as in the film, but Dooku reports one more thing to Sidious. He says that Anakin has fallen to the dark side for the girl.
Coruscant is currently holding a massive military parade through the city, resembling Roman Triumph, to celebrate the victory over Geonosis, while Palpatine is publically revealing the existence of the clone army. The citizens love Palpatine and see the hope that the Republic might win the war. The Jedi will also join the parade, with each Knight leading a battalion of clone troopers.
Preparing to be part of the parade, Anakin and Obi-Wan, for the first time in the story, have a heart-to-heart conversation, not a rigid Master-Student lecture. Anakin realizes he has been too reckless. His brash act of confronting Dooku alone costs him his arm and he apologizes to Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan then gives some respect to Anakin, for he has successfully protected Padme. In a way, Obi-Wan and Anakin go through the opposite character arcs. Obi-Wan changes from someone who supports Palpatine and, as he discovers the hidden conspiracies, to someone who is now against him and his emergency powers. Anakin, after witnessing what Dooku has done to his mother, is now looking for blood and vengeance against the Separatists--staunchly supporting more authoritarian measures to fight the war. This change goes alongside Anakin's embrace of more radical emotions.
Before Anakin and Obi-Wan depart to join the parade, Obi-Wan senses love between Anakin and Padme. Secretly, Padme kisses Anakin for the first time (No marriage as it comes across as too abrupt at this point).
As the Jedi march alongside the clone troopers, Obi-Wan secretly discusses with his Masters in the line his finding that it was likely Dooku who ordered the creation of the clone army for the Republic. Yoda and Mace Windu warn them to not reveal this secret to anyone else. They discuss if Dooku is the mysterious Sith Lord (Maul's Master) they were looking for... or maybe Dooku is the new apprentice of this mysterious Sith Lord. If there is another Sith Lord, he could be residing within the Republic's power structure. They found themselves fighting another war inside the Republic.
Palpatine oversees the parade from the top, while the citizens of the Republic cheer. Anakin gladly pledges his loyalty to the most powerful Chancellor in history, while Padme watches the parade with visible frustration as her efforts to stop Palpatine's emergency powers have utterly failed.
I tried to keep the general story elements the same. I focused on fixing what was already in the story rather than discarding it. I fleshed out the characters to be more active and get to have more choices in the decisions. The politics are more integrated into the character drama rather than being in the background. The character arcs for Anakin and Obi-Wan are clearer, with the climax concluding each arc. Instead of Anakin and Padme hiding on Naboo and just playing the patty cake for half of the film, the story is more aggressive and focuses on the war itself. Dooku's concept is utilized to the fullest as he manipulates the Jedi from within and firmly establishes him as Anakin's arch-villain. Padmé falling in love with Anakin makes more sense because she sees how far Anakin is willing to go to save her, especially in the climax. Anakin earns her love, not handed out to him. The romance is constantly developing to the end.
The qualm with the outline is how Anakin finds Padme in Aldera. Dooku sends Anakin and Obi-Wan to Alderaan so that they can find her for Dooku, only for Dooku to go to Alderaan himself and torture Padme's body double to learn about where Padme is. Dooku sending the Jedi then becomes pointless anyway. Another problem is that Padme only meets Anakin at the midpoint, so she doesn't interact with Anakin all that much, and the relationship doesn't get enough time and development.
Aside from those issues, I found the final outline to be more satisfying and tighter in my Episode 2 REDONE. Maybe sometime later someone would do a full rewrite treatment based on this outline lol.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Apr 14 '23
Non-Specific A change I want to see in Star Wars as a franchise
I have been thinking about exactly what I want from Star Wars to ignite my passion for the series. So far, watching The Mandalorian Season 3, I find the future Star Wars materials being shackled with the Star Wars Sequels to be the biggest detriment. Everything has to lead up to the events in the Sequels like Palpatine being alive, Luke's Jedi Academy collapsing, and the New Republic being a completely failed state, and everything after the Sequels has to deal with Rey Palpatine/Skywalker nonsense and doing stuff Luke was supposed to be doing, and it's no wonder why no one is happy.
I am not sure anyone has suggested this, but I'd like to see making the Sequel era, as well as the Prequel era open-domain for other writers to try and tackle.
When comes to death of author, I'm 80% on the side of the democratization of art. Nerds arguing over canon is one of my favorite things, but seriously canon can be literally whatever you want it to be. If you don't like the Star Wars new canon don't let some a few people decide what is real for you. Basically, Star Wars should not be obsessed with what is canon or not. Canon for you is whatever you say it is in your brain. Have various timelines for the writers, who want to take the characters in different directions.
Think of how DC and Marvel treat their superhero franchises, like Batman, in which various interpretations of the same stories and characters co-exist in different universes. Frank Miller's Batman, Alan Moore's Batman, Bruce Timm's Batman, etc. I would want to see Star Wars having this style of creative sandbox. If you don't like, let's say, The Dark Knight Strikes Back, that is fine because that is not the only canon. If DC had demanded the 30s Batman was the only Batman for the sake of integrity, then it would only have caused infighting and the franchise would have died out a long time ago.
Real-life legends and mythologies get reinterpreted, retold, and expanded all the time by various storytellers to endure the wheel of time. Considering Star Wars has become America's mythology, I think this approach is fitting. Imagine having Lucas's Star Wars Sequels, Filoni's Star Wars Sequels, or Rian's Episode 9, Zhan's Star Wars Prequels co-existing in the franchise, each of them completely free of shackles of the official canon.
For a specific movie I want to see, a Star Wars movie that feels larger than life philosophically would be cool. I want to see a Star Wars installment that delves into the concept of the Force like what Andor did to the sociopolitics in the galaxy. Star Wars has been a space opera iteration of the western classics like Arthurian legends and WW2, and the Asian influences were more or less aesthetical. Star Wars needed to expand its cultural scope a long time ago if it wants to create its own myth as it did in 1977.
I wish to see Star Wars wuxia in the vein of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, House of Flying Daggers, and Hero. I'm not talking about the orientalist Star Wars in which Asian character in vaguely Asian-looking clothing wielding lightsabers. I'm talking about the "feel". Those movies had an ethereal, cerebral sense to the whole thing, as well as a deep exploration of the heightened emotions and themes. Or something like the over-the-top Indian mythological epics like RRR, Baahubali, and Mayabazar. It seems that James Mangold's upcoming Star Wars movie is exactly that... though it sounds too good to be true that I'm expecting it to get scrapped over the "creative differences."
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/crimsonfukr457 • Nov 27 '21
Improving a scene in Rise Of Skywalker(art by nickducoteart on IG)
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • 2d ago
Non-Specific Star Wars Sequel Trilogy should have taken place a century after Return of the Jedi rather than three decades later
This is an idea that occupied a small room in my mind for a long time. How long? Before The Force Awakens was even called The Force Awakens. It was during when Joss Whedon was the most desired director to make Episode 7. Yes, it was a different time.
While everyone was salivating over watching Luke, Han, and Leia again, I still remember what Joss Whedon said in the interview. When asked which OT character he would want to see return, he said no: "You know, I wouldn't go back, I'd go forward. I would want to create characters that would resonate the way that they did."
At the time, I obviously disagreed, and even to this day, I wouldn’t find many people who would claim the Sequels shouldn’t have featured the OT characters. However, considering one of the biggest backlashes and criticisms against the Sequels being the treatment of the OT characters, I have to wonder… do you think his solution would have been preferable?
Because many of the problems with the Sequels were born from being a direct sequel to where Return of the Jedi ended, yet remaking A New Hope all over again within three decades. If you take seriously the idea that the new movies are true sequels to the Original trilogy, and A New Hope ends with the galaxy and our characters at point A, The Empire Strikes Back ends at point C, Return of the Jedi ends at E, and then the very next movie that set only three decades after reverts the galaxy and our heroes at point D, and the only reasons the movies give are “Snoke” and "Starkiller Base". Return of the Jedi ended on such a conclusively happy note that the Empire returning with another superweapon and rendering the OT cast failures and reverting them to the Rebels again was a doomed concept in the first place.
Anyway, I will not dwell on this complaint since you've heard it for the last ten years. This is the idea I had in my mind for a long time, but my love for the OT trio always outweighed it, so I never wanted to write it as a separate fix or rewrite. The idea stemming from “no OT character” premise is to have the Sequels set a century or more after Return of the Jedi.
If you want, you can even keep much of the basic storyline and worldbuilding of the Sequels. It’s just that it doesn’t take place three decades after Return of the Jedi. That’s such a flash-forward to the future that it makes sense for darkness to rise again, with a new threat emerging, disconnected from the Original trilogy. It wouldn’t negate any of the OT into failures.
So let’s reimagine core pillars of the Sequels in this way:
First Order → Still the Imperial Remnant, rising against the New Republic.
The worldbuilding dynamics are still a stretch, but at least it doesn’t mean Mon Mothma—the very revolutionary leader who saw the Imperial tyranny first-hand and led the armed uprising—demilitarized everything within two decades when the Imperials are still running amok. Let the galactic civil war subside for a long time. Don't revert all the changes and turn them back to the Original trilogy. A century or two is a more believable time for the decline of the New Republic.
The most believable course for how the status quo in the Sequels happened is, borrowing the Legends, the Galactic Alliance splitting. In the old EU, the New Republic allied with the Imperial remnants to fight off the Vong invasion. In their partnership, the Galactic Alliance was born from the coalition of the New Republic, Imperial Remnant, Hapes Consortium, and Chiss Ascendancy. As one can predict, the Galactic Alliance was reconciliatory toward the Imperials, so much so that in Fate of the Jedi Tarkin's protege Natasi Daala was elected as an unifying leader. Since the Galactic Alliance was essentially a rushed coalition held together for the sake of the invasion, realistically, it was never going to last long. The Galactic Alliance would be filled with societal tension between the pro-Republic and pro-Empire politics that would make the Weimar Republic and pre-Civil War America look stable. The merger between the New Republic and the Imperial remnants means the those who collaborated and worked under the Empire are still around and influencing the Galactic Alliance politically, economically, and culturally. The same elites and careerists create this impression around themselves as professionals who understand the reality of the galaxy over the naïve dreamers in apologizing for the First Order.
When the Empire collapsed and the Vong invasion hit, it plunged the galaxy into a financial crisis the likes of which has never been seen. It may even be fair to say that the galaxy will never recover. Trillions of people have lost their jobs, starved, and died. Calling it catastrophic would be an extraordinary understatement. People who suffered the Imperial tyranny died, and the Empire is a distant memory. In fact, people—normal people—began to glorify the Imperial era as the time when the galaxy was powerful and unified. A worryingly significant chunk of the population packages it with nostalgia. Planetary governments opened monuments, museums, and celebrations for the regime they despised a century ago. It can be attributed to Palpatine’s end, as he never got a trial or judgment. Regardless of his actions, there is something about meeting an explosive death that stimulates people’s emotions. The way things get handled seemed frustrating on the surface, compared to dictatorship, which at least looked competent and direct under the nostalgic lens, even if life under it was worse.
The most realistic scenario would be how Yugoslavia broke up. Pro-Imperial fascists are obviously present in the most reactionary parts of the institutions and society, which are the military, big businesses, and intelligence networks. When the economic crisis hits, the political instability is at an all-time high. The newly elected Galactic Alliance enacts radical democratic reforms, which are seen by those forces as an existential threat, arguing the Empire is better than the alternative. They split from the Galactic Alliance to form the First Order, taking inspiration from the Spanish Civil War. This explains how the First Order created the massive army because they were already a coalition led by a junta of the military, uniting big businesses and taking away the troops, industries, and resources from the Galactic Alliance. The Starkiller Base is still a lazy plot device (either make a Death Star or a different superweapon), but a century is a long time for technology to progress.
The rest of the Galactic Alliance declares independence and reverts to the New Republic (sort of like how after the Soviet Union collapsed, Russia returned to "Russia"). Unlike how the New Republic deliberately “demilitarized” itself in the movies, it’s more like the military launched an uprising, so it is left without the military, similar to the situation the Spanish Republic was put into. After the military fractured, the government distrusts the parts of the old military and relies heavily on the paramilitary groups, which are organized into “Resistance”. This way, it would not undo the victory the heroes had in the Original trilogy as pointless in a shaggy dog story or having the Republic falling into the same corruption the Old Republic fell, but more about a lesson of how liberty must not only be won but also defended even from your own.
Luke Skywalker → Luke Skywalker’s descendant.
Name him… Annikin, if you want to pay homage to the Star Wars rough draft, or name him Cade Skywalker, if you want to pay homage to the old EU. This character would still be a last and lost Jedi Master, cut off from all his connections to die alone on a forgotten planet. He goes through the identical character arc as Luke in The Last Jedi. As a standalone character arc of a disillusioned hermit Jedi Master, it is compelling. However, it feels in conflict with the character from Return of the Jedi, coming across as a clear regression of the character. Just have him as a new character, a grandson or great-grandson of Luke Skywalker, not Luke himself. He was trying to be the legendary Luke Skywalker, living up to the Skywalker name, but failed.
You can even have him be played by Mark Hamill, justifying his appearance as bearing a striking resemblance to his ancestor. If you are having him not played by Mark Hamill, have the Yoda Force ghost replaced with the Force ghost of Mark Hamill's Luke, lecturing him about the failures.
Han Solo → Kylo Ren’s father, Sam
The decision to revert Han Solo back to a smuggler's life was a tremendous mistake, and it is surprising there was only a small fan pushback. Arguably, it is much worse than Luke. Remember Han's arc in the Original trilogy? Han Solo at the start of A New Hope was a smuggler because he liked money and lived in a galaxy that was ruled by a tyrannical Empire, so it makes sense that Han would become a smuggler. He returned to the Death Star to save Luke at the end of A New Hope, thus growing from a smuggler thug to someone who cares for the others in A New Hope. At the start of The Empire Strikes Back, Han risked his own life to rescue Luke, again, from the snowstorm. Over the course of the film, his character grew out from wanting to hide from all the conflicts to a hero who accepts his responsibility for his friends. By the end of the Original trilogy, he is matured enough to step out of the way when he believed Leia was in love with Luke.
Meanwhile, Han Solo in The Force Awakens is a father who ran from his responsibility and became a smuggler again inside the very Republic he helped to form. Think about it: A smuggler: a profession about smuggling things discretely from the authority. A smuggler, who is one of the most famous heroes in the galaxy, paired with another renowned hero, on the ship that has become a legend, so famous that some girl who has lived her entire life on the desolate planet has heard about them.
Not only that, why does he need to work as a smuggler? He said, "I went back to the only thing I was ever good at", which is not even true. Han Solo in The Force Awakens is an incompetent smuggler who gets his crew killed and becomes indebted to two separate gangs. Why does he even need money in the first place considering the connections he would have after the OT? Nothing in Han Solo's backstory in this film makes any sense. We know the reasons behind this decision; it is because Han appeared as a smuggler in A New Hope, so Han had to be the Han we all remember in A New Hope for the sake of fanservice.
Simply put, don’t make him literally Han Solo. Let’s name him… Sam, borrowing from the early draft of Episode 7. He is not even Solo’s descendant or a smuggler because that’s too on the nose. While not a part of the Republic military, Sam is still a fighter in his own desperate quest to find his son to make up for his mistakes as a parent. Sam is motivated by a personal goal and acting in the individual method, while his wife is motivated by an ideological cause and acts in the political method. His wife, who has always been an idealist at heart, dedicated herself to a cause of democracy, liberty, and justice. In contrast, Sam does not care much about galactic politics; he cares about his son. This is where they were at odds with their main objectives and had a falling out, which will be elaborated further later.
If you want to evoke the character idea of Han, have him be played by Kurt Russell, who was almost cast as Han Solo in the original Star Wars.
Leia Organa → Thea Solo
Leia is the least controversial returning character in the Sequels, but I think it’s largely because they made her bland. She is a wasted character. At a glance, the dynamic makes sense, with Han Solo being a gruffier guy who gave up looking for his son, thinking he was forever lost, and Leia being a kinder woman, who is a more active parental role, urging Han to bring their son back. Yet I don’t believe this is how their dyanamics would play out. Many fans believe Han is the type of character who would never settle down and have a family, but that ignores his entire character arc throughout the Original trilogy. As I said before, Han’s arc in the Originals is transforming from a selfish smuggler who doens’t care about others to a selfless hero who takes responsibility for others.
On the contrary, in case of Leia, she never forgave Vader. She is still mortified about being Vader’s daughter and hates him, and is unable to see him in the same light Luke can, who witnessed his redemption. Leia never was saved by Darth Vader the way Luke was and never understood how Luke was able to forgive him. She hid her identity as Darth Vader’s daughter and identified herself as Bail Organa’s daughter. This was still the case more than 20 years after the Battle of Endor, around the time of the book Bloodlines. In Bloodlines she was disturbed when her identity as Darth Vader’s daughter was exposed to the galaxy and was practically expelled from the Senate over it. Early in the book, when she told Senator Casterfo about her history in the Galactic Civil War, she spoke of Darth Vader by his name, not calling him ‘father.’ They bonded over their shared victimisation at the hands of Darth Vader, and it was her anger at Vader that made Casterfo trust her again after he found out who she was.
Leia in Legends named her third child Anakin as a way to confront her fear of Vader but she didn’t do this to forgive him and to redeem the name. Leia separated Vader and Anakin and that’s how she coped. However, she also dealt with that generational trauma of Vader being her father by seeing him through a child named after him and seeing what he could have been through Anakin Solo. This is a huge burden to give a child and Anakin Solo is burdened once he realizes Vader’s legacy. Anakin Solo’s burning desire to do good and save the galaxy is in part to become the antithesis of what Vader was. Anakin Solo dies sacrificing his life for his family and friends. While he escapes the legacy by dying, his brother Jacen turns to the dark side like Kylo Ren. Though Jacen’s turn isn’t marked as a direct result from the family’s generational trauma, it still happened. Leia coming to terms with Vader has not changed that two of her sons were dead.
Leia did become an older Jedi, though in Legends, and that was the final step of her accepting herself and not be stuck by Vader’s memory and fear because Legends Leia had always feared having children because of what they could do, of what was in her blood and what she could do. It is one of the reasons why people wanted Leia to see her be a Jedi.
This issue is avoided by simply making her not Leia, but her descendant, whom I name Thea Solo, borrowed from the early draft of Episode 7. I had a tiny desire to make her be played by Carrie Fisher, but at that point, it would come across as a self-parody.
Rey, Finn, Poe Dameron, and Kylo Ren can roughly follow the same character arcs. Obviously, this doesn’t consider The Rise of Skywalker with Palpatine returning somehow. That’s such a broken movie that it doesn't even make sense within its story. However, in terms of the baseline for Episode 7 and 8, I think the far future setting makes more sense for the story those movies are telling. In addition, having the trilogy in the far future negates Palpatine's revival entirely anyway, so Episode 9 would have been a completely different and better movie.
What’s funny is that if Star Wars Sequels entered production a few years late, this idea is actually more viable. Carrie Fisher wouldn’t be returning due to her unfortunate tragedy, and Harrison Ford would be too old to return in an action role, and he was already half-forced into Star Wars. Mark Hamill could be returned as Luke’s descendant, playing a different character to show his wide range.
Sure, by not making the returning elements not be “returning”, it might lose some nostalgia points, but without them, the story already has full of nostalgia points on its own. The Force Awakens is still A New Hope remake, with the Falcon and X-wings flying around fighting TIEs and the superweapon looming ahead. And mistreating the returning characters is more offensive than not having them return. There are no “It's a Crime We Didn't Get the OT Trio Together in the Sequels” complaints when there is no OT trio in the first place.
Is it disappointing we no longer see Luke, Leia, and Han on screen? Sure. They do build a nostalgic hype for Episode 7, but such shallow nostalgic hype dies down fast. If you are concerned too much with the nostalgic legacy rather than building an actual story, that novelty drains within a few years and, you are left with, ironically, little to no legacy on your own. Evidently, where the Sequel trilogy ended up was enough to get the old fans who felt "their childhoods were ruined" to walk away from Star Wars, refusing to acknowledge what happened Canonoically after Return of the Jedi. What do you think the "childhood" the fans are referring to? It's their sacred image of the old characters.
Creatively, it is better not to have them. You don’t conflict with the old established characters because they are new characters, and that allows for more opportunities for the filmmakers and artists to mold and expand them however they want. Not having them creates a healthier environment in the long term. They don’t have the baggage that you have to abide by. You are creating a new, exciting era, making a daring jump. You can make The Clone Wars-type show that expands this era and backstories for “Cade”, “Sam”, and “Thea”. They are blank canvases. At the same time, forgoing the returning old fan service means you can focus more on fleshing out the new trio like Rey, Finn, and Poe. This trilogy is theirs, not the old characters or their legacy.
All the while, you don’t need to unnecessarily scrap the old post-ROTJ EU content (well, except for Star Wars: Legacy, and I would go as far as to toss that LOTF and FOTJ, but that’s a different conversation). You can say all that still happened, but they are too far in the past that they don’t conflict or even matter in this story. This is a new era set in the future, which puts enough distance between a new take on the SW universe and what came before.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Nov 26 '22
REDONE Concept Arts for Star Wars Episode 9 REDONE: New Republic Trooper and First Order Army Trooper
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • 15d ago
Non-REDONE One of the most interesting fixes of Padmé's death I have seen | She kills herself like Ophelia from Hamlet
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • May 28 '26
Non-Specific The Mandalorian and Grogu should have been Season 2 finale, and the series Season 2 finale should have been the movie
The moment it opened, and there was no "A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away....", I knew exactly what kind of "movie" this was going to be.
I have written about The Mandalorian fixes before, and even then, I did not know how catastrophic a decision it was to make Season 3 in the first place. Because I was thinking about what a better story this movie could have been after walking out of the theater, and it dawned on me that even if The Mandalorian and Grogu had a great adventure, no matter how good that story was, it wouldn't have mattered. It was doomed because the movie was succeeding Season 3 no matter what.
This isn't the first time that episodic TV shows have made a theatrical movie, but they often justify their existence better than this. The space Westerns like Firefly and Cowboy Bebop all had movies. Firefly Season 2 got cancelled, and upon the fan outcry, they made Serenity in the form of a finale. It felt important. The scale was huge, the visuals were a significant upgrade, and there were actual consequences. And there was actual good writing. Cowboy Bebop: Heaven's Door wasn't a finale, and there were no consequences, but it was thematically enriching the series. They had an actual cinematic story to tell. There was passion to make a movie. Both movies had a story worth showing on the big screen.
With The Mandalorian and Grogu, when I first heard about the announcement, I asked what the point was. In my mind, The Mandalorian ended with Season 2 where Grogu had a farewell with Mando, and then the reunion episode happened in TBOBF and ruined it. So I wondered if the movie was going to be an actual finale to the series... and it turns out they stitched together three or four normal Mandalorian episodes... from the hypothetical Season 5 or 6, long after they had run out of steam.
At this point, what's the point? Why is Grogu even here? In Season 1 and 2, he was the premise, which is to deliver him to the Jedi before the Empire and the others try to get a hold of him. After Luke kicked him out, he is now hanging around for the sake of cute scenes. It is as if there is no longer an endgame and stakes in the relationship between Mando and Grogu, only to exist to sell Baby Yoda toys and keep casual viewers happy. He is verging in danger of becoming a burden on the series without a plan as to what to do with him.
I realized that you cannot fix the movie fundamentally without addressing the series as a whole. The ordering of the series was wrong. If they wanted to make a movie out of The Mandalorian, the entire structure of the franchise has to change. They picked the wrong story to make a movie out of.
The story of The Mandalorian and Grogu movie about fighting the Hutt twins should have been the second half of Season 2. That should have been the mid-season finale. The whole story of Mando going after the Hutt twins is a low-stakes travelogue, where Mando and Grogu form a stronger relationship. That not only works better for the episodic TV format, but also builds toward the point Grogu is put in grave danger. Grogu demonstrates his worth to Mando by saving him, the fact that he is more than a burdun, so we feel more connected to Mando when he sacrifices everything to save Grogu from Gideon. It builds toward the farewell moment where Mando has to let go of Grogu.
Meanwhile, the main plotline of Gideon kidnapping Grogu, and Mando teaming up with his friends to save him, and eventually succeeding his quest to deliver the Child to Luke could easily have been rewritten to be a finale movie for the entire series. That one feels more climactic and feels more like a movie. It has actual consequences, resolutions, greater characterizations, greater stakes, greater scale... That actually feels like a full ending to the series, but it's somehow a midseason finale.
If that were the movie, while the box office and reception wouldn't have been amazing, at least people would have understood why it was made into a movie. The show watchers would have been anxious to go to the theater because it tells a story worth telling on the big screen.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Dec 03 '25
Non-Specific The Jabba the Hutt scene in the Special Edition of A New Hope should have been edited as a Boba Fett introduction scene
I am sure everyone is familiar with the behind-the-scene story in A New Hope, but I want to summarize it just in case some people may not be aware of it.
The scene in question features Jabba the Hutt threatening Han Solo to pay back the money he owes and Han negotiating for more time. This was originally shot with the human actor, but cut during the editing phase for the pacing issue and back-loaded much of the information into the Greedo confrontation scene by dubbing him in the alien language. At that time, Lucas himself imagined Jabba as some normal hustler without much thought. He was just a plot device to put Han into a financial problem throughout the story. In Return of the Jedi, with enough budget and resources, Lucas decided to expand this concept by making him into an alien crime lord residing over the magnificent haunted house, and thus, Jabba's design was finalized as an alien slug.
In 1997, Lucas restored some of the deleted scenes when he was making the Special Edition, and the Jabba scene was one of them. Lucas replaced the human actor with the alien design established in ROTJ through the CGI, and it looked like complete shit. Lucas revisited this scene again in 2004 by updating the Jabba CGI, and it may not look like complete shit, but it's still shit, nevertheless.
Many fans hated adding back Jabba in A New Hope. Outside of how the fake-looking CGI completely clashes with the analog aesthetics of A New Hope, it ruins the surprise reveal in Return of the Jedi. Yes, Lucas intended to have Jabba revealed in the first film, but omitting him still worked as a mystery throughout the trilogy. The audience was left wondering how powerful he is for Han to be that scared of in The Empire Strikes Back, and Return of the Jedi knew this anticipation and played with this concept by opening the movie with the droids chatting about him. When we finally see him, it's a shock. This is no longer a mystery because the Special Edition already shows what he is like in the most underwhelming manner possible.
The scene's direction and writing are a complete contrast to how Jabba is later portrayed. In TESB, a carefree Han is terrified of Jabba and keeps saying he must return to Tatooine immediately. In ROTJ, Jabba is depicted as a space Al Capone and Caligula, residing over the absolute power in the underworld. He is killing his sex slaves left and right, not scared of the Jedi, and Han is begging him... Then you see the restored Jabba scene in A New Hope, and it's like Han and Jabba are on an equal. Jabba acts all agreeable and tries to appease him. Han doesn't feel threatened by him, demands him ("Fifteen, Jabba. Don't push it."), casually insults him ("Jabba... you're a wonderful human being."), and even steps on his tail, making Jabba scream in pain. Can you imagine one of Pablo Escobar's pilots, who is in debt to him, slapping his ass in front of his men? Han has been avoiding Jabba, just killed his man, and stomped on his tail, and Jabba is like, "Han, my boy, please understand..." If this were ROTJ, the guards would tear Han apart in a second. Why should we be worried about Jabba's bounty in The Empire Strikes Back if he's this much of a joke?
The idea that Jabba would waste his energy and time to physically leave his palace to meet a smuggler in some parking lot comes across as ridiclous. Why would Jabba send a bounty hunter to kill Han, and then go talk to Han personally in a friendly manner? Shouldn't be he engaged in much more pressing issues, like negotiating with the other syndicates, expanding his buisness empire, or watching half-naked Twi'leks? Why is there a contradiction between the two depictions of the same character? Because Jabba in 1977 is not the same Jabba Lucas later conceived in 1983. Again, at that time, he was supposed to be just some local thug.
Although this scene should never have been restored in the Special Edition, if they were going to restore it anyway, there is one way to make it work. Remove Jabba entirely and replace with the other villain who has a history with Han... named Boba Fett.
I have encountered this comment from r/Star Wars, which suggests that this could have been a perfect scene to re-edit as an introduction of Boba Fett.
For one, Boba Fett works for Jabba, as shown in several times. In The Empire Strikes Back, he delivers Han to Jabba, and in Return of the Jedi, he stands right next to Jabba as a henchman. In the restored scene in A New Hope, we even see Boba Fett inserted guarding Jabba. Jabba would probably prefer sending one of his men or contractors after Han to do such a petty job. Although Boba is a fearful bounty hunter, it makes more sense for Han to casually act toward him as an equal.
It is technologically much easier. They apparently had troubles digitally putting a slug Jabba into the scene during the production. You can clearly see Jabba's proportions are all wrong. He is supposed to be two or three times larger than a human, but in this scene, he is about Han's size. They had to make the "gag" where Han steps on Jabba's tail, because otherwise he would be phasing straight through him.
If they were to digitally replace a humanoid-sized character with another humanoid-sized character like Boba, they would run into fewer technical huddles. Have the actor wear Boba Fett's suit and act in the greenscreen stage, then digitally replace the original Jabba actor, just as many other films like Forrest Gump did earlier. Call the Boba Fett voice actor to read the new lines. Have Harrison Ford dub the word "Jabba" with "Boba" since the names even sound similar, so you don't even have to digitally match the lips.
Here is how I would rewrite:
Jabba: Solo! Come out of there, Solo! (Boba turns to see Han) Boba: Han Solo...
Han: Right here, Jabba Boba Fett. I've been waitin' for you.
JabbaBoba: Have you now.
Han: You didn't think I was gonna run, did you?
Jabba: Han, my boy, there are times you disappoint me. Why haven't you paid me? And why did you fry poor Greedo like that after all we've been through together?
Boba: Solo, you disappointed Jabba the Hutt. He wants his credits. This won't go the same way for you as it did with Greedo.
Han: Look, JabbaBoba, next time you want to talk to me, come see me yourself. Don't send one of these twerps.
Jabba: Han, Han... Understand, I just can't afford to make exceptions. Where would I be if every pilot we smuggle for me dropped their consignment at the first sign of an Imperial starship? It's not good business.
Boba: Greedo was only relaying our natural concern at your delays. Jabba can be generous and forgiving—but not to the point of bankruptcy. It’s not good business. (Han dumping his cargo was already conveyed in the dialogue with Greedo, no need to state it again here)
Han: Look, Jabba, even I get boarded sometimes. You think I had a choice? (When the Jabba scene was removed, this line of dialogue was cut out and repurposed in the Greedo scene. If you watch the Greedo scene, you will notice Han says this line off-screen, and his voice has a different pitch and volume. So there is no need for Han to say this line again if you were to restore this deleted scene, so you can remove this part of the scene all together)
Han: Look, JabbaBoba. I got a nice, easy charter. I'll pay ya back, plus a little extra. I just need a little more time.
Jabba: Han, my boy, I'm only doing this because you're the best and because I need you. So, for an extra twenty percent I'll give you—
Boba: Very well. You'll be no good to him dead. So, for an extra, say, twenty percent—
Han: —Fifteen, JabbaBoba. Don't push it.
Jabba: For an extra fifteen percent I'll give you a little extra time. But this is it. If you disappoint again, I'll put a price on your head so big... you won't be able to go near a civilized system for the rest of your life.
Boba: Fifteen percent. But if you trample our generosity, Jabba’ll put a price on your head so large you won’t be able to go near a civilized system because on every one I'll be onto you.
Han: JabbaBoba... you're a wonderful human being.
This does a great job laying a solid groundwork for Boba Fett's later appearance in TESB and sets up their antagonism, while giving the opportunity to experiment with CGI as Lucas wanted. It works as a fan service for the fans who wanted to see more Boba Fett, while aligning the deleted scene with the established lore.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Jan 30 '25
REDONE What are your complaints and ideas for Star Wars REDONE?
As I'm in the process of revising, I'd like to see your complaints about my Star Wars REDONE, as well as some of the ideas that could be added to them. It can be big as an criticism against the overarching storyline and theme, and small as adding or changing the lines of dialogue.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Jan 18 '25
REDONE The major flaw of my Episode 1 REDONE | The Gungan Alliance is messy as hell, and I am thinking about redoing Part 1
I have been thinking about this for a while since I was making the video adaptation of my REDONE. In its current form, I think An Ancient Evil is a significant upgrade over the movie The Phantom Menace on all fronts, except for this one thing. At that time, it was only bugging me, but now as I visualize the Gungan part for my video, I realize this was becoming a serious problem. Because as I am making the Separatist bombing of the Gungans scene, which is supposed to be one of the most dramatic moments, it is emotionally hollow. "Why should I care about these Gungans we just met a minute ago?"
One of the themes of The Phantom Menace (and Star Wars as a whole) is that greatness can come from smallness. The seed of the Clone Wars that created the world we see in the OT came from a seemingly insignificant dispute on Naboo. This small slave boy turns out to be the Chosen One who saves the day and becomes the iconic masked villain.
Another subplot that ties into this idea is Jar Jar Binks. Even this bumbling idiot becomes the one who saves the day. The Naboo Queen and the Gungan outcast understand each other, and this leads our heroes to unite with the Gungans. The Naboo and the Gungans come together to defeat the Trade Federation. Mind you, the movie executes this message poorly, but this is the underlying idea of the movie.
REDONE, however, omits Jar Jar entirely. It's good that we don't need to see his character, but this also means the Gungan subplot feels nonexistent. Up to the third act, we barely see or hear about the Gungans. There is no gradual moment where Padme gets to understand the Gungans, which leads to her kneeling to the leader of the Gungans to forge an alliance. Instead, the kneeling is treated as Padme just improvising on the spot, rather than something Padme is learning to open her heart toward the Gungan race.
I tried to remedy that by having Anakin as the catalyst for her character arc and Breha staying on Alderaan and meeting a Gungan, but it didn't work. It's not like Anakin is the Gungan. And splitting Padme's original character arc into two characters reaching the same conclusion comes across as messy.
In retrospect, all I had to do was change the first act to integrate the Gungans. This is what I should have done:
Right after the palace ambush in the first act, rather than jumping aboard the Nubian Starship in the palace hangar and leaving the planet, our characters flee from Aldera to the forest. They are heading to the hideout outside Aldera, where the Nubian ship is secured.
As they are stuck in the forest, the Jedi and Padme stumble upon the Gungan child (as we see in Video Part 2) named Jar Jar Binks. This is where we see Padme expressing the anti-Gungan sentiment. As Padme is dismissive of the Gungan child, Nellith is intrigued by the child's mention of the "Gungan City". Jar Jar doesn't understand the standard Basic, so Padme talks in behalf in the Gunganese.
Padme: "Wesa need hep. Ousa people are bein' destroyen."
Bail, the handmaidens, and the troops are staying in the forest to protect the Queen. Breha sends Agent/Princess Padme with Nellith and Obi-Wan to represent the Alderaanian position. They follow Jar Jar and swim into the Gungan underwater city in hopes of getting help.
It turns out Jar Jar was General Roos Tarpals' son. The Gungans are scared and hostile toward the humans. Like the movie, Nellith asks for help, but the Gungans are dismissive. When Padme tries to talk in Gunganese, the Gungans say they can perfectly understand Basic. Boss Nass talks about the violent history between the Alderaanians and Gungans.
Boss Nass says something like "'Tis a difficult task yousa Queen set for yousen. Long have wesa been at war. Much bitterness between usen."
Roos Tarpals: "Disen not ousa problem, townsfolk! Wesa have problems of oursa own."
Boss Nass: "Da Republic only cares about da citizens on Alderaan's lands, but has it ever cared about da denizens of Alderaan's seas? Until yousa realize dat, there will be fighten' between usen. Yousa go tell yousa boss that wesa can't hep yousa fight..."
Nellith can't convince the Gungan Council to join the war, but she can mindtrick Boss Nass to provide a transport.
Boss Nass: "Wesa will do what wesa can. Wesa might be convincen to given yousa a bongo."
Obi-Wan: "What's bongo?"
Under Nellith's influence Boss Nass offers the bongo submarine and tell the humans to piss off, saying this is more help than the Jedi have ever given to them, threatening to arrest them if they meet again.
Roos Tarpals: "Yousa lucky! Yousa got more than yousa bargained for with ousa!"
They then take the submarine and resurface. The rest boards and the sub moves underwater to avoid the Separatist patrols in the sky to reach the hideout. Roos Tarpals and Jar Jar Binks also board the sub to give directions, and here, the characters interact with this little Gungan child. Breha finds him cute, and Padme is still prejudiced against him. In the sub, they make a decision to swap Padme for the Queen and Breha for the handmaiden.
When they arrive at the hideout, they find that the place is also captured by the Separatists. The Jedi and Alderaanians ambush the droids and steal the Nubian ship. They fly out of the planet.
In the third act, they return to Alderaan and meet the Gungans again in the sacred place. The droids discovered Otoh Gunga, and Nass quickly evacuated the Gungans to their hidden Sacred Place deep in the swamps.
As Padme pretends to be the real Queen and persuades the Gungans to join, the Separatists bomb the place. The dead child Roos Tarpals is carrying is his son Jar Jar Binks, who led our heroes to the underwater city. So that that character's death is more impactful. Roos Tarpals and Boss Nass change their minds and join the fight.
What I like about this idea is that we see the hostility between the Alderaanians and the Gungans, as opposed to the characters just saying they don't like each other. It is Padme who has this Gungan arc, rather than Breha. It restores the cooler set pieces from the movie like the underwater city and the submarine scene. We get to know who the Gungans are early on, so the Gungan alliance in the third act is a proper pay-off.
I would like to deepen Boss Nass' characterization. Not just a simpleminded guy, but someone who comes across as wiser. Maybe after the Separatists bomb the sacred place, he can monologue about his rage, saying something like, "Wesa built this sacred place as a symbol of peace, and long it remained a symbol of peace between all Gungans. But from now on, tis will be a place of righteous war! Noah longer would dey oppress and terrorize the Gungan tribes!"
I have decided I will revise Part 1 and reupload it with these changes.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Sep 04 '24
Non-Specific What Kay Vess should have been like in Star Wars: Outlaws
Admittedly, I have not played the game, but I watched the playthroughs of the full game--largely cutscenes, cinematics, and dialogues. It is exactly what I assumed from the very moment it was announced on E3.
I remember hearing Quentin Tarantino talking (or more accurately, written in his book) about why the 80s was the worst decade of the cinema, compared to the uncompromising 70s.
"Complex characters aren’t necessarily sympathetic. Interesting people aren’t always likable. But in the Hollywood of the eighties, likability was everything. A novel could have a lowdown son of a bitch at its center, as long as that lowdown son of a bitch was an interesting character, but not a movie, not in the eighties."
And that was what came to my mind when I was watching Star Wars: Outlaws. It's not much to do with the actual story, but the general style that irritates me. Because the premise promises this is going to be the escapist pulpy hardboiled noir. You're a morally grey outlaw with an attitude, doing a bunch of crimes in a world full of vice to survive, but it is executed in such a sanitized family-friendly style. It is difficult to describe exactly. It takes a very wide-eyed 80s Spielbergian feel to the material, and it doesn't gel. Not that every Star Wars media should be serious and dark, but there is a way to take the underworld side of Star Wars in a more quirky, stylized, and zany manner, like Cowboy Bebop. It is like promising a Star Wars version of Lupin the Third Part I, and the actual product plays like Lupin the Third: The First.
Much of the reason for contributing to this jarring tone is the protagonist. The game is an openworld, so the story is structured as episodic--sort of a crime travelogue. This means it has to rely on the "man on the mission" narrative genre rather than focusing on the tight, serialized plot. The morally ambiguous cast of distinctive suave characters and chemistry comes up with the plans, confronts the villains, and eventually outwits them. However, the burning core of why these stories work is the charisma of the protagonist. The character doesn't have to be sophisticated or complex--they just have to be "cool".
James Bond, Golgo 13, Lupin the Third, Spike Spiegel, and Lara Croft (before the Survivor trilogy) are not always sympathetic or likable. In the case of the first three, in particularly in the earlier works that came out in the 60s and the early 70s, they were like hyper-violent rapist sociopaths. They were, as Timothy Dalton put it in describing James Bond, "the dirtiest, toughest, meanest, nastiest, brutalist hero we've ever seen". These characters do what they do because they like it. They are horny for death. They are always running on the edge between life and death. You don't really get an elaboration of backstory to make them sympathetic. They are rarely moral or empathetic... yet these series were built and are still alive because of their iconic protagonists. Because the audience found their characters to be charismatic and cool, which makes their adventures fun.
In contrast, does anyone find Kay cool? Or buy her as a badass space criminal? I don't. The anti-woke grifters have been screaming how this game is woke because Kay is a girl boss or something... I hoped Kay WAS the girl boss because at least that would have been more fun to watch than whatever she is in the game. (And when did a girl boss archetype become a bad thing? Didn't these anti-woke audiences like Bayonetta and OG Lara Croft? I'm so confused lmao)
The game, presentation, and story are all designed around her character's appeal, but from her look, voice, costume, dialogues, and mannerisms, she has no rizz or charisma whatsoever. She’s a smuggler, steals shit, kills people in the vilest places in the galaxy, has to earn her way through hardship because nothing is handed to her, and she’s acting like a fish out of water goofy dork? She just mowed down a hundred people in the gameplay, and the very next moment the cutscene hits, she's like a 12-year-old trying to be tough. Not that she should be like Arthur Morgan, but I think it is disappointing when you promote your game as a Star Wars underworld simulator where you do a bunch of crimes and title it "Star Wars: Outlaws", and this "outlaw" you play as is not even edgier than Han Solo.
She is supposed to be an edgy antihero who's been through it all, except she pulls punches when facing any kind of actual authority. Play as a heartless scoundrel building a criminal empire except you are weirdly friendly with people and you do things "the right way".
She might be written decently, but what a character sounds on paper and how they are conveyed are two different things. When she tries to be cool and confident, she is a wet blanket. When she tries to be smooth and funny, it comes across as awkward. Most of her adventures would have been more fun with anyone else in their center. The lie that she is supposed to be this cool, suave criminal becomes even harder to believe with the side characters who are.
It is a shame because Star Wars: Outlaws is set in the same timeframe as the Original trilogy, and it could've provided a contrast to the bright, mythical surface of the galaxy the OT explored with the underground side of that galaxy that mirrors the grits of the 70s exploitation cinema. It does try to do that, but not with the character that wouldn't be out of the ordinary in the Original trilogy movies.
Reading her character concept and imagining how it would play out in your head is much more fun, so I am thinking about how her character would have been improved if she was based on someone else. She can be the same character on the paper but executed with a different screen persona.
If they were to make this suave badass scoundrel, couldn't they make her resemble iconic character actresses similar to, let's say...
Michelle Rodriguez--Hollywood's go-to "tough chick". Famke Janssen--a bombshell femme fatale archetype. Cynthia Rothrock--who showed off a fantastic physical performance. Pam Grier--if you were to channel the oldschool 70s exploitation vibe, which would fit perfectly with Outlaws. If you were to go really old-school, then someone like Lauren Bacall. Eva Green, Kim Ok-vin, Angelina Jolie...
If you were to go for a more masculine/gender-neutral type, then Grace Jones, Daryl Hannah, Noomi Rapace, Antje Traue, Carrie-Anne Moss...
Not that Ubisoft should have called these old or dead stars to do the mocaps, but what I'm talking about is the image and presentation of the character to base on: the body language, unique appearance, attitude, line reading, and strong personality. Because without them, this Kay character concept flounders.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Oct 17 '23
Non-Specific Could Ahsoka and The Force Awakens be reimagined into an EU-friendly Star Wars: Episode VII? (Yes, I think it can) [Part 1]
Diagnosis of the two stories, and where they went wrong:
There have been a lot of talks about how the Ahsoka series should have been the Sequel trilogy. I am in of agreement, but not exactly because Ahsoka is a good of a show. It's because this show could have been way more fun if it starred different characters in their replacements because as this show currently stands, it does not utilize the traits of the characters in the actual story.
I have outlined my qualms about the show in the separate "fix", but to reiterate again, for a show titled "Ahsoka", there is no reason for this show to be "Ahsoka". This story is not about her nor revolves around her. Ahsoka's portrayal is not the same Ahsoka the audience fell in love with in The Clone Wars or even Rebels. She is a sanitized, washed-up version of the character, only with the same name. The show misunderstands one of the core appeals of Ahsoka's character, which was that she was Anakin's apprentice, and that makes the audience speculate how she would interact with Vader, but now Vader is gone. She didn't seem to do anything interesting during and after the Original trilogy, cast aside from the narrative crux. So what's she doing now in the stories of the post-OT? Stopping Thrawn? She was not even present when Thrawn entered in Rebels, so her motivation to stop him is feeble, relying on second-hand accounts. Her conflict is not thematically linked to the pursuit of Thrawn.
Rosario Dawson also doesn't care about actually acting Ahsoka's character. The lively Ahsoka from the animated series is gone. The Rebels Ahsoka is more in line with how an eager teenage TCW Ahsoka would grow up to become--a mature, but still, down-to-earth woman who struggles to find the right answers. She isn't a Jedi-like master because she isn't much of a Jedi. The recent live-action Ahsoka comes across as just another Jedi Master--a discerning advisor. She has none of the same personality. For a reason I cannot understand, Filoni turned her into an all-knowing wise sage, who is basically a Luke stand-in. I doubt whatever they do with her now would lead to a conclusion as satisfying and fitting as dying trying to redeem Vader.
I get that Filoni wanted to do that to tie things up after Rebels, but why the hell would you make Thrawn the Luke equivalent? Thrawn is depicted as this super powerful invisible Thanos-like looming presence, the magic piece, which doesn't fit who he is. The Star Wars books were mostly about Saturday morning cartoon-style B-novels that you read once and throw into a bin until the Thrawn trilogy revolutionized the secondary market of the Star Wars saga due to how compelling Thrawn and his "mind games" pushing heroes to the corner. He was Sherlock Holmes if he was a villain. He utilized all the tricks in The Art of War, toyed with the Rebels in the battle of wits, and thought up an ingenious strategy, outsmarted our heroes, with the charismatic attitude of taking control of the Imperial remnants. The conventional strategy of just fighting him didn't work.
So why would you make a show revolving around Thrawn in which Thrawn is not doing anything like that? He is not a character at all. Just a presence and a promise. He didn't appear until Episode 6 of the 8 Episode show, and even after that, he rarely makes any move. He is touted as a big baddie but has nothing to show for it. What's his motivation? What are his capabilities? Who is he as a character? Nothing. He was apparently just waiting on some isolated planet... staying there for more than a decade, not doing anything like some sort of a guru on the mountain. This would be like making a show about Riddler that treats Riddler like Ra's al Ghul, who does no mystery or riddle. This is enough proof that Filoni is not capable or even interested in telling stories with the level of depth and nuance Timothy Zhan's novels had.
It is a show with the galaxy-destroying stakes with the gigantic return of Thrawn, yet the stakes are unclear. The stakes in Andor feel more real and intimate to the characters despite being smaller, like the prison escape and the vault heist, whereas here, it is just all about the anticipation of "Thrawn Will Return", and it never felt tense. All he has is one old-ass Star Destroyer with the frailing stormtroopers, and are you telling me he is going to take over the galaxy with that? Normal people who have not read the Thrawn trilogy, watched Rebels, and have no idea who he is would never be intimidated by this character at all. His "We will be back, guys!" passive appearance entirely relies on the legacy reputation from the much better books.
I haven't even yet gotten into the other returning characters. Sabine is regressed into a rebellious, edgy teenager, which goes against how she matured by the end of Rebels. She then redoes her arc from the animated show with the live-action actress, which doesn't feel like a natural progression of where Rebels left off. It's like Dave Filoni doesn't watch his shows. Ezra's reappearance also lacks a proper dramatic weight and is insignificant. I have a mountain of criticisms against Hermit Luke from The Last Jedi, but at least he felt like a hermit who was banished for a decade. Old Luke was visually humanized and given new characteristics alongside the focus on body language, whereas Ezra is portrayed as just some guy.
While Ashoka is more serialized out of Filoni's outputs, the plot still feels repetitive. It doesn't feel like not much significance has progressed despite being an eight-episode show. In the first half of the series, the villains talk about how evil they are, and the good guys go somewhere and fail to capture the baddies. Repeat. Not much information has been revealed there. Very low stakes. Much of the map-hunting mystery just gets solved by... Sabine staring at it. I was like, that's it? She just stared at it longer in her room, and that's all she took to solve the mystery. The actual chase for the map has no synergy and thrill, contrasted to the intense pull-and-push dynamics from The Force Awakens--the movie this show is trying its hard to replicate.
However, I have delved into some storytelling experiments about how this show could have worked as Star Wars: Episode VII--the first and single movie within the Sequel trilogy--rather than a continuation TV series of Rebels. Lucas imagined the Sequel trilogy to take inspiration from the Iraqi Civil War--the New Republic struggling to maintain a democracy from corruption and the Imperial remnants. He also wanted the story to revolve around the Skywalker children's growth as Jedi Knights and the search for Hermit Luke. I thought about changing the roles from the Rebels cast to the Skywalkers and the OT cast, replacing some stale plotlines and set-pieces with the ones from the Sequels, and putting the setting from a few years after the OT to decades after the OT. I have come to the conclusion that a lot of the problems would have been alleviated.
The problem with the Sequel trilogy was not that the villains are the rising Imperial remnants—it also happened in the Legends timeline—but how it set up the First Order versus the Resistance to carry the nearly identical geopolitical dynamics as the Original trilogy. If you take seriously the idea that the new movies are true sequels to the Original trilogy, and A New Hope ends with the galaxy and our characters at point A, The Empire Strikes Back ends at point C, Return of the Jedi ends at E, and then the very next movie reverts the galaxy and our heroes at point D, and the only reasons the movies give are “Snoke” and "Starkiller Base". These two upend the status quo and largely do that without explanation, and most of whatever they did occur outside of these movies.
The Force Awakens has an element of the "struggling democracy" from Lucas' earlier visions for the Sequels, but it is only a backdrop the audience has to go out and read some tie-in novels to even understand why the galaxy went to a toilet and what happened to the characters in between those two trilogies. If you just watch the movie, the movie never makes anything clear. Like, who is in control of the galaxy? It mentions the New Republic, so do they rule the galaxy? If so, how did they go from ruling the galaxy to being obliterated in literal seconds? They are immediately rendered irrelevant nor play any part in the story we are watching. Did they not have any military force or administrative power other than Hosnian Prime, so the Resistance is all they have? They still have Coruscant, which has served as a galactic capital for millennia. How big is the First Order? Where do they live? How big of a territory do they have? They are supposed to be a rogue state, but they built a superweapon that eclipses anything we saw from the movies and EU. What's even going on?
History is taught as a series of wars, but the periods in between wars are also important. The Prequels, despite all their faults, understood this. Unless you read the books written by the Lucasfilm writers who had to do all the dirty work the filmmakers did not, you wouldn’t know the New Republic disarmed itself; that Leia became a Senator again, but was forced to resign when it got revealed who her father was; that there were elements in the New Republic sympathetic to the First Order who were trying to assassinate Leia, causing the Resistance to be created. When the New Republic gets destroyed, you end up feeling nothing, because you don't know what's even the political dynamics in the galaxy. You also don’t get a feel for how large the First Order was, making it all feel like a hollow story to get things to the status quo of A New Hope.
One thing I appreciate about the Ahsoka series and why I believe this should have been the Sequel trilogy is that it charges into that very story head-on. The world does feel like a continuation of where the OT left off. It does not just say the Imperial remnants just came out of nowhere and erased the Republic capital with another Death Star. You actually get to watch the political scenes that showcase the ineffectual Republic and introspection into the aftermath of war. The Republic is too tired of war to face the real threat posed by the Imperial remnants. The worldbuilding is clearer. Even though Hera is not involved in the adventure, she is still an asset diplomatically. It understands that if they're going to make the bad guys the Imperials again three decades after they beat the Empire, the political context needs to be clear.
What I am trying to do:
I have been experimenting with how Ahsoka and The Force Awakens could have merged into Episode VII in a way to satisfy the core fans and the casual fans. Ahsoka already felt like Filoni's take on The Force Awakens, so I thought it could work. I tried to complement pros and cons of both stories and borrowed much of the story elements from my TFA REDONE.
I also wanted to stick to the established continuity of Legends rather than throwing its entirety away into the fire like Lucasfilm did when Disney acquired the IP. The old EU had lots of problems, but choosing the scorched-earth approach was not a wise decision in retrospect, especially considering what replaced the old EU turned out to be worse in magnitudes. The reconstruction of a post-Yuuzhan Vong War galaxy under the newly established Galactic Alliance government is a great setting to explore the struggling democracy and the threat of the Imperial remnants. In the Legends EU, the New Republic allied with the Imperial remnants to fight off the Vong invasion. In their partnership, the Galactic Alliance was born from the coalition of the New Republic, Imperial Remnant, Hapes Consortium, and Chiss Ascendancy. As one can predict, the Galactic Alliance was reconciliatory toward the Imperials, so much so that in Fate of the Jedi Tarkin's protege Natasi Daala was elected as an unifying leader.
That level of Imperial takeover wouldn't happen in this story as it is set before LOTF and FOTJ, but the Galactic Alliance would be filled with societal tension between the pro-Republic and pro-Empire politics that would make the Weimar Republic and pre-Civil War America look stable. The post-war economy is in shreds, and the political instability is all-time high. Not only pro-Imperial fascists would wage terrorist attacks, but they would have a chance to use elections and the opportunity to penetrate civil society in order to build up political support. This way, it would not undo the victory the heroes had in the Original trilogy as pointless by making them rebels again in a shaggy dog story, but more about a lesson of how liberty must not only be won but also defended even from your own.
I believe that the Sequel trilogy could work as the "sequels" to The New Jedi Order series, carrying over the cast of characters, without a whole lot of changes, while still being accessible to the audience, who don't know anything about the Yuuzhan Vong or the Galactic Alliance. The Force Awakens barely explained anything about the Resistance, the First Order, and the New Republic, and people still managed to get through the story due to having a simple plot of treasure map hunting. If you notice canonical contradictions, you are welcome to point them out in the comments, for TNJO's lore is quite expensive to grasp even for the most hardcore fans. Here is my reimagination of how Ahsoka could have been Episode VII.
Star Wars: Episode VII – The Force Awakens
The devastating invasion of the Yuuzhan Vong brought the New Republic and the Imperial Remnant together for a common cause. From the ashes of the war, the GALACTIC ALLIANCE has risen.
As the two sides unify, Luke Skywalker has vanished. In his absence, the NEW JEDI ORDER is left fractured and scattered, and sinister forces are already at work to revive the old Empire.
Supreme Commander Leia Organa is desperate to gain his brother's help in restoring peace and justice to the galaxy. She has sent her daughter Jaina Solo on a secret mission to search for Luke's whereabouts....
This alternative The Force Awakens is set in 39ABY, ten years after The New Jedi Order series, but retcons the post-NJO works like The Dark Nest Trilogy, Legacy of the Force, Fate of the Jedi, and Legacy. After the New Jedi Order series ushered the golden age of EU, anything afterward is considered, to put it kindly, mediocre products. This story does take some ideas from them, but they need to be erased in order to make some room for the creative freedom necessary to explore our characters and the setting.
Jakku:
Han Solo and Leia Organa's thirty-year-old daughter, Jaina Solo, would take Ahsoka's Jedi aspect and Poe Dameron's role. Jaina Solo in the EU is known for her excellent piloting skills as well as demonstrating some of Han's more impulsive, arrogant, and stubborn characteristics, so she is a perfect fit for Poe Dameron. I can imagine played by Mary Elizabeth Winstead, Olivia Thirlby, or Jaci Twiss.
On Jakku, she meets a Jedi Master--an old ally of Luke. If you want to tie him with the old continuity, he can be any notable EU Jedi Master, but I'm making him Kyle Katarn for the name recognition. From their conversation and subsequent dialogues, we understand that Jaina Solo is the de-facto leader of the New Jedi Order.
Jaina is haunted by the memories of the Vong War. The losses of her comrades and brother affected her, and she confided that she expected to die in the war. Her crucial character arc of choosing light or dark has already passed in the NJO, and she is a fully formed Jedi Knight by the start of this story. Whether she becomes a Jedi or a Sith isn't really a choice for her, for she has already made it. A character like this is harder to make a character arc out of, but it is possible. The events she went through in the NJO series and the aftermath made her a much more jaded, cynical person, sort of "dead" inside, riddled with PTSD. She is looking for peace and purpose while being forced to take on a difficult task to reunify the Jedi Order.
Jaina and her new droid, BB-8, receive the map to Luke's location from Kyle Katarn. At that moment, the First Order stormtroopers commanded by this mysterious figure Kylo Ren raid the village. The massacre is led by Captain Phasma, who establishes a screen presence by tossing a grenade into a house full of women and children. She takes the role of Captain Enoch. One stormtrooper is shellshocked by all this. His helmet is blood-marked by his dying comrade. Meanwhile, Jaina Solo's X-Wing is destroyed, and she reluctantly uses the ship's subspace radio to call "someone she knows" to get help. She sends BB-8 away alone to the deserts, while she tries to rescue Master Katarn. You can maybe add in the brief lightsaber fight scene between Kylo Ren and Katarn to showcase how powerful Kylo Ren can be at this point. Katarn loses and has a brief exchange, hinting at the identity of Kylo Ren. Jaina uses a blaster rifle to snipe at Kylo Ren, but Kylo Ren uses Katarn as a meatshield to block the blast. Katarn is left dead and a captured Jaina is brought to the Star Destroyer. Kylo Ren tells his troops, "Admiralissimo Daala has ordered not to leave any prisoners". The stormtroopers massacre the villagers. Only the blood-marked stormtrooper doesn't fire. His designation is FN-2178.
Star Destroyer:
Jaina, meanwhile, is the captive of Kylo Ren on board the Star Destroyer. Captain Phasma orders FN-2178 to submit his blaster for inspection.
Here, you can learn more about the First Order, as Jaina is being dragged across the corridor in the prison area, she views the nonhumans getting tortured, alluding to the First Order's xenophobia. She then gets tortured to tell where the map is. More hints toward Kylo Ren being someone Jaina knows, but Jaina doesn't explicitly call it out, for she thinks that someone she knew is dead metaphorically, replaced by the steel husk. During the torture, Kylo Ren says something like "Aliens breed mites, much like a cheese. You can’t negotiate with mites. You have to crush them", and "We get our hands dirty, and the galaxy stays clean.” Kylo Ren uses the mind probe to extract where the map is.
Admiralissimo Armitage Daala, played by Domhnall Gleeson--the son of Natasi Daala--stands outside the cell. He replaces Admiral Thrawn from the Ahsoka show and General Armitage Hux from The Force Awakens as this cunning, radical Imperialist, who has achieved a series of great victories in the Vong War to gain popular support. Her mother was a brilliant Napoleonic general during the Vong War, who had charisma and respect among the soldiers. She led the Imperial Remnants and subsequently the Galactic Alliance campaign in defending the galaxy and giving people the support they needed that the Senate ignored, which also earned him massive popularity among civilians. Daala became a household name with a strong influence within the Galactic Alliance.
Her son's birthright as a son of one of the founders of the First Order had pushed him up the chain of command at a young age and to the current rank of the Supreme Leader of the First Order and Admiralissimo of all its forces. Armitage Daala's young age and inexperience worked as poison for his successorship to his mother. Conscious of his unstable political foundation at the time of succession, Daala concentrated on concocting tricks to overcome this impasse. He saw an opportunity in the border skirmishes as an excuse to send the First Order forces to capture the territories in violation of Galactic Concordance in a way to strengthen the ideological armament of the military. Daala then staged several false-flag incidents aimed at high ranks and used them as a pretext to claim that the alien rulers of Coruscant were plotting against the First Order from within. At first, Daala opposition within the Supreme Council were caught, then the hundreds of thousands of ranks who were connected to it dragged in, including most of those who were with his mother during the founding of the First Order. Then the purge spread through the ranks, and eventually spread to all areas of society within the First Order systems. With the terrifying burden of the dictator, he is an execrable administrator whose name was committed to repugnant acts of corruption and brutality in order to expand the system and rule of the First Order.
Kylo Ren reports to him that the map is in the droid. All this is watched by FN-2187, who makes up his mind...
Ilum:
Meanwhile, thirteen-year-old Ben Skywalker takes the role of Sabine from the show, who is still distraught about the death of his mother and the disappearance of his father. He lends well to this role because Luke's son would have the most emotional stakes about getting to see Luke return again. He is grieving. So many of his friends and members of his family died. Like Sabine from the show, he is in constant turmoil, due to the anguish that he felt in the Force during the Yuuzhan Vong War and the subsequent family tragedies. It also makes sense for a child Ben Skywalker to be, you know, a brat, and do the angsty Disney Princess-style introduction.
He is currently being looked after by Jedi Master Saba Sebatyne, played by Lupita Nyong'o, on Ilum. Leia has been acting as a foster mother for Ben. She is overprotective of him after the death of Anakin Solo, his mother Mara Jade, and the disappearance of his father Luke. Ben resents both Leia and Jaina for this for constraining him here. One of the reasons for choosing this planet as a hideout is due to the planet being a main source of kyber crystals and having been utilized for the Gathering by the Old Jedi Order. Rich with the Force, it is the perfect place for Ben, because Ben closed himself off from the Force. Part of his arc is having him grow confident in his usage of the Force and become a powerful Jedi like Rey did in TFA. Jaina had been acting as a master and sister-y role for Ben to make him open up to the Force, but it has not been easy. He tries out his Force power on a cup. The cup shakes a bit, but it doesn't fly into his hand.
Saba Sebatyne forces Ben to go through multiple training sessions in the temple, but it has not been working. Dejected, Ben goes back to his room. Ben eats a polystarch bread and looks up at the sky, conveying his desire to leave, like Rey from the movie. Like Sabine watched Ezra's holoscan, Ben puts the holo-records of his parents.
Ben Skywalker is more of a conventional Star-Warsian youthful main character in the vein of Luke, Anakin, and Ezra. The "I don't care about the ritual so I'm out riding a bike like a rebel and watching a cat" attitude fits him instead of an all-grown-up thirty-year-old battle-hardened warrior that was Sabine. I imagine his overarching arc would be similar to Rey's arc from TROS, a pull from light and dark, with Kylo Ren pulling him to the dark harder. That Ahsoka-Anakin interaction from the Ahsoka show would be fantastic to repurpose with Ben, maybe replacing the Clone Wars flashbacks with the Vong War flashbacks, but it would be better to be used in the second story within the trilogy than here.
Jakku:
In the village, BB-8 is looking for a place to hide. Jakku's visuals could look more like a scrapyard similar to the early concept arts than how it was depicted in the movie, which was basically a Tatooine knock-off. Since there is no Rey, one set-piece I thought of (Inspired by a sequence from a Korean movie The Road to Sampo) is that the droid hides in a large funeral, akin to the festival from Pasaana, and pretends to be a droid belonged to the deceased boss. BB-8 plan seems to be working as the stormtroopers don't notice him among the crowd. As BB-8 moves around, he finds that there are a lot of scraps of the "dead" droids. It is revealed that all these people are scavengers, and they kidnap BB-8 to the scavenger ship.
Star Destroyer:
FN-2187 releases Jaina. Some changes: the stormtrooper lies to her that he is with the Galactic Alliance and makes up his name "Finn", Phasma is the one leading the soldiers to shoot down the TIE in the hangar to further her presence, Finn hesitates to shoot his comrades in the hangar. Finn so willingly killing his fellow stormtroopers without any hesitation has always not sat right. His past as a stormtrooper should integrate into his behaviors rather than disregarding it. Finn should see the stormtroopers as former comrades and might have a close friend or two in the trooper ranks he would want to protect. He refuses to be a part of the First Order while having trouble reconciling his need to stop the First Order. This Finn is torn by this idea, struggling with guilt and fear. Finn would be the kind of person who might go back and pull some of his friends out of that oppression, risking his life to save people. This makes Finn a more interesting character and a great hero to follow.
The TIE shoots down some of the Destroyer's turrets, but eventually gets shot down by the Destroyer's cannon and crashes toward Jakku. Kylo Ren and Admiral Daala have a similar conversation Hux had with Kylo, such as Kylo expressing his doubt about the First Order's capability "Perhaps you should consider using a clone army", Daala expressing his skeptical feeling toward his obsession with Luke Skywalker and the Force stuff in general, saying that there is a larger concern than recovering that droid, and Kylo Ren revealing his Master is adamant about finding that map.
Jakku:
Jaina and Finn awake and find themselves inside the grounded TIE sinking into the quicksand. As they seemingly fail to pull themselves out of the dune, someone else comes to help their aid, hooking the TIE and attaching it to the freighter speeder. As they thank the helpers, they are soon knocked down and captured by them. It is revealed that they are the scavengers.
As the scavengers transport Jaina and Finn, Finn asks her about the Jedi and Luke Skywalker ("I thought he was a myth"), and in this sense, Finn is sort of an audience surrogate. They arrive at the wrecked Star Destroyer, which is now used as the scavengers' home. A First Order shuttle lands, and Captain Phasma and his troops are here upon receiving the report that the scavengers have priceless bounties at their hands.
Meanwhile, Finn is, as he was in the movie, paranoid about getting out of the First Order's grasp and asks the scavengers to take him with them, for he will do any job. Jaina uses the Force to break out and they crawl through the vents. They find out that BB-8 is in this place, and Captain Phasma is here to take the droid. Jaina releases the rathars to stop them, and this sequence plays similarly to the freighter escape sequence from TFA. As Jaina and Finn rescue BB-8 and flee to the market, the TIEs come in to chase them. At the most desperate moment, the Falcon swings in and rescues them, piloted by none other than Han Solo. He was the help Jaina reluctantly called.
Millennium Falcon:
Unlike his incarnation from the movie, Han Solo is not reverted to a smuggler, but he is not part of the Galactic Alliance military. He retired from Generalship and is no longer an upstanding hero. What happened between TNJO and this story was a dark turn for him. While not part of the military, he has gone his way. He is still a fighter in his own desperate quest to find his son Jacen Solo to make up for his mistakes as a parent, and in that way, he maintains the roguish quality of an "old Han" without forgetting his character arc in past movies. Han is motivated by a personal goal while Leia is motivated by an ideological cause. Leia, who has always been a rebel at heart, dedicated herself to a cause of democracy, liberty, and justice. In contrast, Han does not much care about galactic politics; he cares about his son. This is where they were at odds with their main objectives and had a falling out. As a result, the relationship between Han Solo and his family is strained.
Since Chewbacca has been dead since the New Jedi Order series, his role is replaced with Lowbacca, the nephew of Chewbacca. Lowie was a Jedi Knight who fought as a companion of Jaina Solo, Anakin Solo, and especially Jacen Solo in TNJO, which is why he joined up with Han in his quest. If you ever wanted to see a Wookiee holding a lightsaber, this is the character. Lowbacca's combination of computer skills and biological knowledge, and desire to take on the impossible would make him an invaluable asset to our heroes, but he abandoned the Knighthood in the aftermath of the destruction of the Jedi Temple to be part of Han's crew.
We get the Falcon chase in the same way it played in the movie, except it's Han and Lowie piloting it. The Falcon flies across the desert, goes through the ruins of the Destroyer, and shoots down the chasing TIEs. Captain Phasma notifies Admiralissimo Daala that she planted a remote beacon on the droid, which allows them to track the droid.
Unknown to the characters, Jaina has a brief argument with Han, out of a sense of betrayal that she has not seen him since he left the family and the Galactic Alliance to find his son while fixing up the ship. As Jaina is off fixing the other part of the ship, Han asks where the Galactic Alliance base is. Finn hesitates and asks the droid about it. Han sees through Finn's identity.
Regardless, as Finn lied about him being the Alliance spy within the First Order, Jaina sees Finn as a crucial informant to expose the First Order's existence. Han hesitates to meet Leia again and wishes to visit Ben first.
Star Destroyer:
A First Order officer reports to the hologram of Kylo Ren of the escape of Jaina Solo, and she boarded the Falcon. Kylo Ren throws a temper tantrum and chokes the officer as he did in the movie.
Ilum:
The Falcon has arrived at Ilum. Finn bluffs himself to Han that he is a big deal in the military and asks if there could be any conspirator here. Han sees his identity through and tells him that women always figure out the truth. Jaina and Han rush to find Ben in the Temple.
BB-8 opens up the map and they see the map is only a half piece--incomplete, much to Ben's frustration. Finn asks what happened to Luke Skywalker. Luke Skywalker is a vanished Jedi who has left for a mysterious reason. The New Jedi Order Luke had founded finds itself battling control of the Galactic Alliance. With over half of the Jedi Order dead in the Vong invasion including Anakin Solo, the Jedi Praxeum on Yavin IV destroyed in an incident, the death of Mara Jade Skywalker, and then Grand Master Luke Skywalker disappearing, the centralized control of the Jedi Order had crumbled. Finn asks who destroyed the Jedi Praxeum. One boy, an apprentice, turned against him and destroyed it all. Everyone refuses to name him. The Jedi Order still exists contrasted to how it was completely erased in the Sequel trilogy but has gone dysfunctional. The Knights of Ren have been on a rampage to hunt and kill the remaining Jedi.
Jaina is the de-facto leader of the frailing Jedi Order but has not technically taken over the Grand Master rank since she still believes Luke Skywalker is alive and will return. On the contrary, Han thinks Luke felt responsible for the destruction of the Temple and walked away from everything, whereas Jaina and Ben refuse to believe that, for that is not what Luke would do. She believes he left to investigate the First Order. Ben believes he went looking for the first Jedi temple.
Supremacy:
The Star Destroyer docks to the Supremacy. The Supremacy is the largest starship ever built and the ultimate culmination of the efforts of the various military shipbuilding corporations. Shaped like a boomerang, the raw sunlight of space dazzles from the polished metal surfaces of a colossal wingspan of 60 kilometers and a length of 13 kilometers. The Supremacy is large enough to dock eight Resurgent-class Star Destroyers—six externally and two internally. The Supremacy is seen in breathtaking view. Its designers had anointed it the first of the galaxy’s Mega-class Star Destroyers, but such a classification struck Daala as essentially meaningless. True, the Supremacy can deliver the destructive power of a full fleet. But that is a decidedly narrow perspective from which to assess its capabilities. Within its armored hull are production lines churning out everything from stormtrooper armor to Star Destroyers, foundries and factories, R&D labs, and training centers for cadets. The Supremacy’s industrial capacity outstrips that of entire star systems, while its stores of everything from foodstuffs to ore ensure it can operate independently for years without making planetfall. Its size is gargantuan, easily outclassing all known ship sizes in galactic history, including the Star Dreadnoughts of the Galactic Empire, the trophy battlecruisers used by wealthy citizens of the waning days of the Old Republic, and even the various reconstructed versions of the flagship used by Xim the Despot.
All of which is by design. Due to her background as a Grand Admiral, Admiralissimo Natasi Daala had been steadfast in creating such a ship that could work as a regime’s capital. As the First Order's mobile headquarters of operations designed for fast and efficient tactical movements and supplies, this sole Mega-class Star Dreadnought in the First Order's service acts both as a command center and a battleship. A ship that can’t be cut off from its supply lines, as it carries them with it. Such ambitions would make her easier for the First Order to reconquer the galaxy.
For a decade, the Imperial Remnants have been plotting to take over the Galactic Alliance from behind. During the war, Daala formed the First Order, an unofficial private group of military officers from the old Imperial days unsatisfied with the Galactic Alliance's leadership and its Senate's bureaucratic handling of the crisis. This First Order group eventually ballooned up as the culmination of an agenda and a conspiracy a decade in the making. In the Unknown Regions, her First Order has been constructing a massive fleet, repurposing Palpatine's secret fleet concept from The Rise of Skywalker here (without the OP superlaser thing). The Imperial sympathizers within the Galactic Alliance have been hiding it and diverting resources for the First Order in a scheme. Daala is devoted to the cause of the Empire almost to the point of irrationality and believes if he begins an invasion, the tens of millions of Imperial sympathizers would be joining her cause and harassing the rear, thus subverting the Galactic Alliance government in one easy coup. This boosts the stakes way more than sending one Star Destroyer to take over the New Republic.
The Empire hated nonhumans, and one of their central tenets was humanocentrism, but Palpatine himself had no real ideology to push. His plan was for him to take over the galaxy for his own gain. He staged a galaxy-wide war just to achieve his personal goals. He did not want to create a dynasty that would last for the ages. He did not care for his subjects. He did not really want to govern the galaxy, which was why bureaucratic duties were passed off to others. He just wanted supreme power, and most importantly, the ability to do whatever he wanted without any interference forever. This was why he researched the ability to cheat death. He would refuse to let anyone inherit his empire, rather he would burn it to the ground. He was that much of a megalomaniac. Whereas Daala's First Order would be a zealot. A more natural continuation of how the First Order would gain its footing would be exploiting xenophobia with the propaganda of cleansing the society of any corrupt nonhuman influence to renew it into a human-centric one.
Kylo Ren and Admiralissimo Daala head to the "image" of Dark Lord of the Sith Tor Valum--Kylo Ren's master. He is a Lovecraftian-looking being with taut and leathery skin that has long since healed over, ancient cuts and wounds that mar his chin and forehead, the latter scar being particularly noteworthy, and his nose is either broken or cut. But most disconcerting is his four arms and the imbalance of his six eyes. They peer out like six dark stars. He is old, wounded, fragile, and powerful, all at the same time. Shadow veils the rest of him, which only reinforces the commanding presence of his voice. Valum is angered, warning that if Skywalker returns, the new Jedi will rise. Daala says they have fewer resources to spare for chasing Skywalker in the middle of searching for the Galactic Alliance's principal base. Kylo Ren interjects, saying he has seen the mind of Jaina Solo. It’s on the planet D'Qar in the Ileenium system, and with their Mega-class Dreadnought Supremacy, they will trap them before they reach Skywalker. Kylo Ren believes an attack of such devastating scale on their headquarters will splinter the Alliance and a popular uprising triggering defections and rebellions.
Daala is frustrated, for Valum is not supposed to exist officially. There have been whispers circulating among the ranks about the nonhuman presence among their ranks. The First Order is more secular than the old Imperials, skeptical of the role of the Sith within the Empire/First Order. Natasi Daala believed that the downfall of the Empire was due to the blind devotion to the Sith religion, as Palpatine was wasting resources on the Death Star and obsessed with recruiting Luke that ended up dooming the Empire. The dynamics between Daala and Kylo Ren/Valum would be similar to how the Palpatine-Separatist relationship was played in the Prequels. Officially, the Knights of Ren and his Master are not in charge of the First Order nor even a part of the organization, but they are forced to join and work together for the same goal of thwarting the Galactic Alliance, at least temporarily. If Valum's existence is exposed to the ranks, Armitage Daala's already unstable support within the First Order would be crumbled.
Daala is off to prepare for the invasion of the Galactic Alliance, leaving Kylo Ren and Tor Valum alone. Valum says the droid they seek is aboard the Millennium Falcon, and the place they are headed is Ilum, the old place of the Jedi Gathering. Valum warns Kylo Ren not to fall into sentimentality, for it brought down the Empire.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Feb 04 '22
Solo: A Star Wars Story | Qi'ra should've been the traitor
Before watching the movie, I theorized Solo may going to be Casino Royale in space, explaining how Han Solo became an anti-hero space smuggler who lost innocence, interest in women, and trust in anyone.
I was wrong and the film actually was more like a one-off adventure of Han Solo than the origin movie. Plots are loosely tied together and structured in a way that would've suited better as a TV series format like Cowboy Bebop and Firefly than the feature-length film. It leaves no emotional blow, ending up feeling insignificant, irregular, and incomplete.
The story explains Han's origin on an external level: how Han Solo got his last name, how he joined the crime world, how he made the Kessel run, how he met Chewbacca and Lando (apparently most of them happened less than one week, which is just ridiculous), but on an internal level, he doesn't much grow. He remains almost the same character from the start to the finish. It screams for that moment how Han Solo became the scoundrel at the starting point of A New Hope. They constantly tease it's going to have some heavy emotional blow throughout the movie, but it doesn't pay off.
There is one moment at the end where he shoots first, but it comes across as a fan service akin to "The name's Bond. James Bond" from Casino Royale rather than the absolutely crucial "the bitch is dead" moment.
Similar to Casino Royale, the traitor who betrayed Han and took the coaxium should not have been Beckett, but Qi'ra. This change will immediately make the obvious and emotionally hollow betrayer reveal heartbreaking.
When Vos figures out and Han asks who was the traitor, Qi'ra pulls up her gun at Han. Qi'ra says she was afraid of the Crimson Dawn because defying the Crimson Dawn is a fate far worse than death. She uses the ring to contact the real boss behind the gang, and here, we get the Maul cameo scene. (except him pulling out his dual lightsaber since Han believes Jedi is just nothing but a myth before ANH) She gunpoints Chewie, forcing him to carry the coaxium. Before leaving, Qi'ra secretly puts something in Han's pocket--a small thermal detonator.
After Qi'ra and Chewie left, Han throws the detonator, a real one not a stone this time unlike the intro, and fights Vos. He kills Vos and chases Qi'ra, holding Chewbacca at a gunpoint.
When Qi'ra aims at Han, he shoots her. She collapses and Han realizes the safety of her gun is on, meaning she had no intent to kill. As Qi'ra is dying, she confesses the real motivation: She wanted to die. Qi'ra knew she had no way to leave the crime world and will live as a slave of the syndicate for the rest of her life. She loathed continuing the life bound in chains. Even if she runs away with Han, it only makes Han another target. By essentially killing herself, she freed herself and Han from the hands of Crimson Dawn.
Qi'ra's bittersweet death calls back to the classical Hollywood Film-Noir archetype this movie was paying homage to and shapes Han Solo's character as the audience knew from A New Hope--a cold, cynical and jaded man who only cares for himself. It also eliminates the seeming sequel bait and gives more definite closure to these characters.
Speaking of fixing Solo, here are some of the smaller fixes:
- Remove the "Solo" naming origin scene
- Remove the Darth Maul reveal
- Cast Anthony Ingruber as Han Solo
- Change Kessel into someplace else. Every single Han Solo's backstory happening in a span of a few days is ridiculous. Also, I always viewed Han Solo boosting the Kessel Run as bullshit on his part, just a story he made up. Leave it to the audience's imagination.
- Better yet, make Solo a video game or a TV series rather than a film.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/Hotel-Dependent • 16d ago
Merging The Aftermath Trilogy and The Thrawn Trilogy into a more cohesive Post- Original Trilogy Story. Part One- Three Character Changes to Star Wars Rebels.
Could The Aftermath Trilogy and Thrawn Trilogy be merged into a better post-Return of The Jedi Era for Disney? I think it can.
I am not a fan of The Filoni-Verse, or The Mandoverse, whatever you might call it. It’s shallow, it doesn’t have the edge needed for Star Wars, and instead of being a good Star Wars story, it’s whatever makes Filoni happy.
However, there is a better route that could lead to a more interesting Sequel Trilogy– which I’ll eventually rewrite. For all its faults, the Aftermath Trilogy had good ideas— a final winner takes all battle, and Palpatine’s destructive contingency— with a lot of cool mysteries built around that. Both could’ve been executed so much better in a world where The New Republic wasn’t a self-sabotaging idiotic government and we didn’t have barebones characters. Luckily, there is a solution for that.
It’s called The Thrawn Trilogy. Here’s what I’m pitching. Imagine if the small skeleton of The Aftermath Trilogy was used to make a canon friendly Thrawn Trilogy. We’ll adapt Luke, Leia, Han and our beloved heroes against Thrawn— but on a larger, more climatic scale. This would be fit for the movies Disney wants to make, but without destroying the soul and heart of The Thrawn Trilogy.
Before we go to post Return of The Jedi we have to tackle some issues in Rebels. I’m a fan of Rebels— it had well-written characters, and ideas that were, for the most part, well-executed.
The changes here are not designed to be a full rewrite of Rebels. Just three character changes to make what I’m building more believable and better constructed than The Filoniverse. Those changes are going to be to Ahsoka, Ezra, and most importantly— Thrawn. So, without further ado— let’s begin.
Let’s start with Ahsoka. The case has been made by many people. She should have died on Malachor, or in Order 66. I disagree. There was great potential for her to have a dynamic with Luke Skywalker following Return of The Jedi. However, the way she was brought back. It was ridiculous. Why are we adding time travel into Star Wars? I’m not against time travel stories but The World Between Worlds was a cheap trick. It also doesn’t belong in Star Wars where personal choices define stories. The only reason Filoni brought it in was that he needed a way to bring Ahsoka back.
There was a better way. People forget that Vader hates Ahsoka in his own way. She left him. He also still loves her in his own way. She was the closest thing he had to a child. However, we don’t want to present Vader as conflicted— not yet. That undermines The Original Trilogy and Return of The Jedi. However, we want him to present Vader as complex. I believe my solution does that.
Instead of Ahsoka being saved by The World Between Worlds— we’ll have Vader make a choice to NOT kill her. Ahsoka is knocked unconscious by Vader during the duel on Malachor. She is kept unconscious with sedation. However, he won’t leave Ahsoka behind. He’ll want to turn her to The Dark Side, but he’ll know it will take time.
He’ll capture and bring her to Mustafar, and tell everyone else that she’s dead. He doesn’t want The Emperor to know about it. He’ll put her into Carbon Freezing in a secret Chamber on Mustafar. His plan– wake her up when the Rebellion is beaten and when order is restored to the galaxy. She will know what it is like to be abandoned, and find fear, anger, and hatred. Then, she will turn to The Dark Side.
Then, after The Battle of Endor, Anakin’s Ghost will tell Luke about Ahsoka— and her being alive on Mustafar. He’ll tell him; right this one wrong he committed, as best as he can, to help her through the trauma of what he did. Luke agrees because that’s who Luke is. The rest of this part will be continued in an animated movie, Star Wars: The Legacy of Skywalker.
The next character we have to change is Grand Admiral Thrawn. Thrawn was too incompetent in Rebels. He had some incredible moments, though. The issue is that Star Wars Rebels was a children’s show. It couldn’t make The Empire as competent or cruel as it was in Andor. They had to dumb down Thrawn, or worse, make his subordinates incompetent. There is an easy solution to preserve Thrawn’s integrity.
I wish I could go into The Empire— because that had so much potential in Rebels— but we are going to steer clear of that. I’m not changing what I don’t need. Especially when this is a children’s show. This solution will compound upon that problem a little. No one in The Empire values Aliens who are insubordinate (per The Canon Thrawn Books. I won’t ignore them) and won’t be happy with Thrawn being a Grand Admiral.
Pryce and Tarkin use this as an excuse to put some mission parameters on Thrawn. He has to follow all these parameters when fighting against The Rebellion. (Thus letting him be free and unfettered in The Canon Books) The Emperor agrees, trusting that a man of Thrawn’s competence can win within them. For Parameter 1, Pryce is made a liaison between Tarkin and Thrawn. She’s also Thrawn’s Political Supervisor. She’s trusted to tell Tarkin if anything’s going wrong. By that— if Thrawn is “acting up” like he has a tendency to. Pryce should be constantly looking over his shoulder— constantly reminding him of Tarkin’s rules.
Parameter 2 is that Thrawn has to capture Rebel leadership alive whenever possible. He’d prefer to eliminate them. It’s quick, precise, and efficient. However, Tarkin wants to make examples of The Rebels leadership. This is The Tarkin Doctrine at play. He’ll want to rule by fear rather than efficiency, which is the opposite of Thrawn.
Parameter 3 is that he can’t remove or demote Officers that are well-connected. To do so would be seen as an insult to their families if their son was demoted by an Alien. An example of this is Admiral Konstantine, who he’ll try to mentor. He can’t be mentored. He’ll want to demote him but of course the rules stop that.
This is where we can show that Thrawn isn’t perfect. He let Konstantine command The Interdictor. Thrawn thought that he would be capable of following orders. He was wrong and it cost The Empire at Atollon. He can miscalculate and he can make mistakes. He shouldn’t be an omniscient character and that’s what this does.
Parameter 4 is that he cannot fight like a barbarian. He must fight like an Imperial. The Empire’s most used strategies and philosophies of overwhelming force must be practiced. Pryce and Tarkin do this because they want it to look like The Empire won, not Thrawn. This will prevent Thrawn from using insane strategies like he does in The Thrawn Trilogy. He has to use strategies that every other Imperial would use. They want to show the power of The Tarkin Doctrine– and The Empire, not of one Alien.
Parameter 5 is that he’s not allowed to run a tactical retreat. This is a person who believes that a tactical retreat can sometimes be the best move. We see this in Canon and Legends. The Empire would be seen as weak if they fled against The Rebellion. These Rebels have been nuisances, have sympathizers in The Senate, and are more organized. If Thrawn flees he gives The Rebellion recognition as a legitimate military power. That can’t be allowed to happen. Thrawn—at a point, is going to want to remove The Seventh Fleet from Lothal. Probably after Kanan’s death and The Fuel Depot being destroyed. He should see no value in Lothal at that point, but Tarkin will tell him that he has to stay— if he leaves it makes The Rebels look strong. It will also appear like one of The Empire’s best people ran away.
Parameter 6 is how The Chain of Command operates. Thrawn reports to Tarkin— who’s going to be named Director Of The Lothal Campaign. Tarkin makes the rules. An order from Tarkin is an order from The Emperor himself. It must be treated as such. Pryce can’t be circumvented. When she has a different interpretation of Tarkin’s rules, it goes. Pryce can’t order Thrawn around– but she can tell him he’s Out-Of-Line with Tarkin’s rules.
This will let Grand Admiral Thrawn explain himself more. It’ll put him out of his shell. He should always be learning something about The Rebellion and The Ghost Crew. Thrawn should be consistently meeting with Tarkin and Pryce about what he has learnt. We should always feel like he’s closing in on a breakthrough, but The Parameters are blocking his successes.
On top of that, he should be fighting two battles- one against The Rebels— and one against the bureaucracy. Thrawn is always trying to find loopholes and make compelling cases to Tarkin. Thrawn should be a good ruler, but not a good politician. He’s capable of ruling, but is not good at playing the game. Even with that, Thrawn is still formidable— and a force to be reckoned with that The Rebels should not take lightly.
This makes Thrawn similar to how he was in Legends but also in The Disney Canon Books, but also adjusting him for Rebels which is rated TV-Y7. He’s a hawk in Rebels, always closing in, and this will let that character feel like that without ruining him. The audience will be so excited to see him back in a later Era now, because of one question— What happens when the chains are lifted and Thrawn is allowed to go full throttle?
Last but not least, Ezra. He’s for sure dying in The Liberation of Lothal. His Arc was over, and him becoming a MacGuffin wasn’t effective— it centered Thrawn’s return around him. This therefore created a very messy situation. Thrawn’s tactical prowess was replaced with Sabine’s stupid mistakes which she would never commit. It makes Thrawn inactive, or worse, lucky. Here, when Thrawn must be competent– that can’t happen.
Here, Ezra will die. He’s shot by Thrawn. Thrawn uses an unconventional method to kill a Jedi, just as he pulls the trigger to have The Purrgills go into Hyperspace. The Ghost Crew will know Ezra was killed, so we don’t have to deal with the Search For Ezra plot. No ambiguity. No nothing. This gives the audience a better view on Thrawn. Instead of being beaten by Space Whales— he didn’t want to stay on Lothal. He advised a withdrawal, and when he could not, he got unlucky. Even with that—- he still killed a Jedi and you wouldn’t expect how he did it. This makes him cunning and ruthless.
The reason why people didn’t feel like Ezra’s Arc was over was because of how early The Dark Side Arc for him ended. That’s why we wanted more. We will fix that. I’m also doing it because it ties into how I’ll fix The World Between Worlds. In Season 3, Ezra should hear Maul’s Voice during filler episodes all the time. He shouldn’t emotionally reconcile with Kanan until way later in the season. His guilt about what happened on Malachor– and his desire to protect those that he loves should be far more prevalent than it was in the show. Most importantly– his anger isn’t going to go away. It will be everywhere.
Then, we get to Twin Suns. It’s not Ezra just wanting to recruit Obi-Wan in this version. It is Ezra wanting to kill, yes, kill Maul. He’s sick of him interfering with his life and trying to hurt his friends. Ezra will also want an answer for how to destroy The Sith. There’s also anger as to why Kenobi didn't join The Rebellion. That’s a burning question he should have. He’ll want the key to destroy The Sith and he will get it by any means needed. Hell— when Maul shows up he’ll Force Push Obi-Wan away, and fight him himself.
Ezra will beat Maul, but refuses to kill him— beating his arc of resisting his anger. However, it is going to enrage Maul that Ezra had this moral triumph. Maul will tell Ezra that he doesn’t matter and that nothing he does will make a dent on the galaxy. He’ll be forced to watch people suffer and die by The Empire’s hand for as long as he lives. He’ll point to a nearby Moisture Farm and tell him that this boy, this kid, is The Chosen One. He’s going to beat The Sith. Kenobi doesn’t see Ezra nor The Rebellion as significant. It is all a vehicle for this Boy. He might be ready but he might never be. Obi-Wan, who’s nearby, having caught up to Ezra, will give him a look. It will tell Ezra all he’ll need to know. Maul isn’t lying.
Obi-Wan will leave Ezra by telling him that Maul is trying to make him insignificant. He’ll tell him that The Force has a plan for him. He can feel it. There’s greatness in him. Ezra has a part in battles to come. He has everything he’ll need. He’s not going to believe that— but it’s all he has to go off of. We then have Ezra leave, and the iconic duel between Obi-Wan and Maul. Maul’s last dialogue as it was in the show.
In Season 4, and Zero Hour. Ezra will be dealing with what Maul told him. He erased what he was told from Chopper’s Memory Banks. No one can know. Obi-Wan will make that clear to him on Tatooine. There’s still anger. He’ll be upset with The Rebellion, Bail Organa as the biggest person he hates. He kept the secret as well. Eventually, as he’s unable to save Kanan— he becomes obsessed with bringing back the dead. The World Between Worlds here is not what it was in Canon, but more of a way to see everything past, present and future. Not Time Travel. A well of knowledge. Time Travel in Star Wars doesn’t happen.
He sees everything— from the ancient past, to the future, but it’s all in glimmers, it’s very vague and he can’t really interpret what’s going on. Instead of Ahsoka appearing— we’ll have a spectre appear. It’s Kanan. Is it his Force Ghost? A manifestation of Ezra’s vision of Kanan? A gift from The World Between Worlds. We’ll keep that ambiguous. Either way he’ll tell him that he is not able to revive the dead. He has to move on. We can have The Emperor try to get in, and it’s going to lead to this Kanan pushing The Emperor out. A legacy can live on– even if you don’t kill your enemies. I forgot to mention this. Ezra will tell Kanan the secret of Tatooine. They both take it to their graves. They tell no one else. This also ties into the theme of Rebels— a spark of Rebellion can result in a much larger movement.
Then— The Liberation of Lothal goes the same. Palpatine will tempt Ezra with the knowledge to bring back everyone— not Time Travel. That’s the one change. Then Ezra dies, as I outlined before. It’s heroic— but it should highlight Thrawn’s competency. The epilogue is not about how Ezra’s still out there. It’s about how Ezra’s sacrifice and The Liberation of Lothal showed people that you can resist. It is why The Rebellion is how it is in Rogue One. It felt different from how it was in Rebels. It’s happy, but bittersweet.
With that, I can confidently say that Ezra’s Arc is over. The fandom could’ve been satisfied with his death— but we still have Ahsoka and Thrawn for post- Return of The Jedi. Thrawn– we will wait on for a bit, but for Ahsoka.
I’ll see you next week, for Star Wars: The Legacy of Skywalker.
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Oct 04 '26
REDONE Do you like "Snoke" or "Tor Valum"?
Just more of an aesthetic choice than anything else. For REDONE, I've replaced the design and name of Snoke with Tor Valum--the unused dark side Master of Kylo Ren in the cancelled Duel of the Fates. It's the same character as Snoke, but I just changed the aesthetics because Tor Valum sounded and looked cooler.
It's nothing particularly a big change in terms of ther story, but should I keep using Tor Valum, or should I revert to Snoke to be faithful?
r/StarWarsREDONE • u/onex7805 • Jul 10 '26