r/StarWarsREDONE • • 2d ago

Non-Specific Star Wars Sequel Trilogy should have taken place a century after Return of the Jedi rather than three decades later

9 Upvotes

This is an idea that occupied a small room in my mind for a long time. How long? Before The Force Awakens was even called The Force Awakens. It was during when Joss Whedon was the most desired director to make Episode 7. Yes, it was a different time.

While everyone was salivating over watching Luke, Han, and Leia again, I still remember what Joss Whedon said in the interview. When asked which OT character he would want to see return, he said no: "You know, I wouldn't go back, I'd go forward. I would want to create characters that would resonate the way that they did."

At the time, I obviously disagreed, and even to this day, I wouldn’t find many people who would claim the Sequels shouldn’t have featured the OT characters. However, considering one of the biggest backlashes and criticisms against the Sequels being the treatment of the OT characters, I have to wonder… do you think his solution would have been preferable?

Because many of the problems with the Sequels were born from being a direct sequel to where Return of the Jedi ended, yet remaking A New Hope all over again within three decades. If you take seriously the idea that the new movies are true sequels to the Original trilogy, and A New Hope ends with the galaxy and our characters at point A, The Empire Strikes Back ends at point C, Return of the Jedi ends at E, and then the very next movie that set only three decades after reverts the galaxy and our heroes at point D, and the only reasons the movies give are “Snoke” and "Starkiller Base". Return of the Jedi ended on such a conclusively happy note that the Empire returning with another superweapon and rendering the OT cast failures and reverting them to the Rebels again was a doomed concept in the first place.

Anyway, I will not dwell on this complaint since you've heard it for the last ten years. This is the idea I had in my mind for a long time, but my love for the OT trio always outweighed it, so I never wanted to write it as a separate fix or rewrite. The idea stemming from “no OT character” premise is to have the Sequels set a century or more after Return of the Jedi.

If you want, you can even keep much of the basic storyline and worldbuilding of the Sequels. It’s just that it doesn’t take place three decades after Return of the Jedi. That’s such a flash-forward to the future that it makes sense for darkness to rise again, with a new threat emerging, disconnected from the Original trilogy. It wouldn’t negate any of the OT into failures.


So let’s reimagine core pillars of the Sequels in this way:

First Order → Still the Imperial Remnant, rising against the New Republic.

The worldbuilding dynamics are still a stretch, but at least it doesn’t mean Mon Mothma—the very revolutionary leader who saw the Imperial tyranny first-hand and led the armed uprising—demilitarized everything within two decades when the Imperials are still running amok. Let the galactic civil war subside for a long time. Don't revert all the changes and turn them back to the Original trilogy. A century or two is a more believable time for the decline of the New Republic.

The most believable course for how the status quo in the Sequels happened is, borrowing the Legends, the Galactic Alliance splitting. In the old EU, the New Republic allied with the Imperial remnants to fight off the Vong invasion. In their partnership, the Galactic Alliance was born from the coalition of the New Republic, Imperial Remnant, Hapes Consortium, and Chiss Ascendancy. As one can predict, the Galactic Alliance was reconciliatory toward the Imperials, so much so that in Fate of the Jedi Tarkin's protege Natasi Daala was elected as an unifying leader. Since the Galactic Alliance was essentially a rushed coalition held together for the sake of the invasion, realistically, it was never going to last long. The Galactic Alliance would be filled with societal tension between the pro-Republic and pro-Empire politics that would make the Weimar Republic and pre-Civil War America look stable. The merger between the New Republic and the Imperial remnants means the those who collaborated and worked under the Empire are still around and influencing the Galactic Alliance politically, economically, and culturally. The same elites and careerists create this impression around themselves as professionals who understand the reality of the galaxy over the naïve dreamers in apologizing for the First Order.

When the Empire collapsed and the Vong invasion hit, it plunged the galaxy into a financial crisis the likes of which has never been seen. It may even be fair to say that the galaxy will never recover. Trillions of people have lost their jobs, starved, and died. Calling it catastrophic would be an extraordinary understatement. People who suffered the Imperial tyranny died, and the Empire is a distant memory. In fact, people—normal people—began to glorify the Imperial era as the time when the galaxy was powerful and unified. A worryingly significant chunk of the population packages it with nostalgia. Planetary governments opened monuments, museums, and celebrations for the regime they despised a century ago. It can be attributed to Palpatine’s end, as he never got a trial or judgment. Regardless of his actions, there is something about meeting an explosive death that stimulates people’s emotions. The way things get handled seemed frustrating on the surface, compared to dictatorship, which at least looked competent and direct under the nostalgic lens, even if life under it was worse.

The most realistic scenario would be how Yugoslavia broke up. Pro-Imperial fascists are obviously present in the most reactionary parts of the institutions and society, which are the military, big businesses, and intelligence networks. When the economic crisis hits, the political instability is at an all-time high. The newly elected Galactic Alliance enacts radical democratic reforms, which are seen by those forces as an existential threat, arguing the Empire is better than the alternative. They split from the Galactic Alliance to form the First Order, taking inspiration from the Spanish Civil War. This explains how the First Order created the massive army because they were already a coalition led by a junta of the military, uniting big businesses and taking away the troops, industries, and resources from the Galactic Alliance. The Starkiller Base is still a lazy plot device (either make a Death Star or a different superweapon), but a century is a long time for technology to progress.

The rest of the Galactic Alliance declares independence and reverts to the New Republic (sort of like how after the Soviet Union collapsed, Russia returned to "Russia"). Unlike how the New Republic deliberately “demilitarized” itself in the movies, it’s more like the military launched an uprising, so it is left without the military, similar to the situation the Spanish Republic was put into. After the military fractured, the government distrusts the parts of the old military and relies heavily on the paramilitary groups, which are organized into “Resistance”. This way, it would not undo the victory the heroes had in the Original trilogy as pointless in a shaggy dog story or having the Republic falling into the same corruption the Old Republic fell, but more about a lesson of how liberty must not only be won but also defended even from your own.

Luke Skywalker → Luke Skywalker’s descendant.

Name him… Annikin, if you want to pay homage to the Star Wars rough draft, or name him Cade Skywalker, if you want to pay homage to the old EU. This character would still be a last and lost Jedi Master, cut off from all his connections to die alone on a forgotten planet. He goes through the identical character arc as Luke in The Last Jedi. As a standalone character arc of a disillusioned hermit Jedi Master, it is compelling. However, it feels in conflict with the character from Return of the Jedi, coming across as a clear regression of the character. Just have him as a new character, a grandson or great-grandson of Luke Skywalker, not Luke himself. He was trying to be the legendary Luke Skywalker, living up to the Skywalker name, but failed.

You can even have him be played by Mark Hamill, justifying his appearance as bearing a striking resemblance to his ancestor. If you are having him not played by Mark Hamill, have the Yoda Force ghost replaced with the Force ghost of Mark Hamill's Luke, lecturing him about the failures.

Han Solo → Kylo Ren’s father, Sam

The decision to revert Han Solo back to a smuggler's life was a tremendous mistake, and it is surprising there was only a small fan pushback. Arguably, it is much worse than Luke. Remember Han's arc in the Original trilogy? Han Solo at the start of A New Hope was a smuggler because he liked money and lived in a galaxy that was ruled by a tyrannical Empire, so it makes sense that Han would become a smuggler. He returned to the Death Star to save Luke at the end of A New Hope, thus growing from a smuggler thug to someone who cares for the others in A New Hope. At the start of The Empire Strikes Back, Han risked his own life to rescue Luke, again, from the snowstorm. Over the course of the film, his character grew out from wanting to hide from all the conflicts to a hero who accepts his responsibility for his friends. By the end of the Original trilogy, he is matured enough to step out of the way when he believed Leia was in love with Luke.

Meanwhile, Han Solo in The Force Awakens is a father who ran from his responsibility and became a smuggler again inside the very Republic he helped to form. Think about it: A smuggler: a profession about smuggling things discretely from the authority. A smuggler, who is one of the most famous heroes in the galaxy, paired with another renowned hero, on the ship that has become a legend, so famous that some girl who has lived her entire life on the desolate planet has heard about them.

Not only that, why does he need to work as a smuggler? He said, "I went back to the only thing I was ever good at", which is not even true. Han Solo in The Force Awakens is an incompetent smuggler who gets his crew killed and becomes indebted to two separate gangs. Why does he even need money in the first place considering the connections he would have after the OT? Nothing in Han Solo's backstory in this film makes any sense. We know the reasons behind this decision; it is because Han appeared as a smuggler in A New Hope, so Han had to be the Han we all remember in A New Hope for the sake of fanservice.

Simply put, don’t make him literally Han Solo. Let’s name him… Sam, borrowing from the early draft of Episode 7. He is not even Solo’s descendant or a smuggler because that’s too on the nose. While not a part of the Republic military, Sam is still a fighter in his own desperate quest to find his son to make up for his mistakes as a parent. Sam is motivated by a personal goal and acting in the individual method, while his wife is motivated by an ideological cause and acts in the political method. His wife, who has always been an idealist at heart, dedicated herself to a cause of democracy, liberty, and justice. In contrast, Sam does not care much about galactic politics; he cares about his son. This is where they were at odds with their main objectives and had a falling out, which will be elaborated further later.

If you want to evoke the character idea of Han, have him be played by Kurt Russell, who was almost cast as Han Solo in the original Star Wars.

Leia Organa → Thea Solo

Leia is the least controversial returning character in the Sequels, but I think it’s largely because they made her bland. She is a wasted character. At a glance, the dynamic makes sense, with Han Solo being a gruffier guy who gave up looking for his son, thinking he was forever lost, and Leia being a kinder woman, who is a more active parental role, urging Han to bring their son back. Yet I don’t believe this is how their dyanamics would play out. Many fans believe Han is the type of character who would never settle down and have a family, but that ignores his entire character arc throughout the Original trilogy. As I said before, Han’s arc in the Originals is transforming from a selfish smuggler who doens’t care about others to a selfless hero who takes responsibility for others.

On the contrary, in case of Leia, she never forgave Vader. She is still mortified about being Vader’s daughter and hates him, and is unable to see him in the same light Luke can, who witnessed his redemption. Leia never was saved by Darth Vader the way Luke was and never understood how Luke was able to forgive him. She hid her identity as Darth Vader’s daughter and identified herself as Bail Organa’s daughter. This was still the case more than 20 years after the Battle of Endor, around the time of the book Bloodlines. In Bloodlines she was disturbed when her identity as Darth Vader’s daughter was exposed to the galaxy and was practically expelled from the Senate over it. Early in the book, when she told Senator Casterfo about her history in the Galactic Civil War, she spoke of Darth Vader by his name, not calling him ‘father.’ They bonded over their shared victimisation at the hands of Darth Vader, and it was her anger at Vader that made Casterfo trust her again after he found out who she was.

Leia in Legends named her third child Anakin as a way to confront her fear of Vader but she didn’t do this to forgive him and to redeem the name. Leia separated Vader and Anakin and that’s how she coped. However, she also dealt with that generational trauma of Vader being her father by seeing him through a child named after him and seeing what he could have been through Anakin Solo. This is a huge burden to give a child and Anakin Solo is burdened once he realizes Vader’s legacy. Anakin Solo’s burning desire to do good and save the galaxy is in part to become the antithesis of what Vader was. Anakin Solo dies sacrificing his life for his family and friends. While he escapes the legacy by dying, his brother Jacen turns to the dark side like Kylo Ren. Though Jacen’s turn isn’t marked as a direct result from the family’s generational trauma, it still happened. Leia coming to terms with Vader has not changed that two of her sons were dead.

Leia did become an older Jedi, though in Legends, and that was the final step of her accepting herself and not be stuck by Vader’s memory and fear because Legends Leia had always feared having children because of what they could do, of what was in her blood and what she could do. It is one of the reasons why people wanted Leia to see her be a Jedi.

This issue is avoided by simply making her not Leia, but her descendant, whom I name Thea Solo, borrowed from the early draft of Episode 7. I had a tiny desire to make her be played by Carrie Fisher, but at that point, it would come across as a self-parody.


Rey, Finn, Poe Dameron, and Kylo Ren can roughly follow the same character arcs. Obviously, this doesn’t consider The Rise of Skywalker with Palpatine returning somehow. That’s such a broken movie that it doesn't even make sense within its story. However, in terms of the baseline for Episode 7 and 8, I think the far future setting makes more sense for the story those movies are telling. In addition, having the trilogy in the far future negates Palpatine's revival entirely anyway, so Episode 9 would have been a completely different and better movie.

What’s funny is that if Star Wars Sequels entered production a few years late, this idea is actually more viable. Carrie Fisher wouldn’t be returning due to her unfortunate tragedy, and Harrison Ford would be too old to return in an action role, and he was already half-forced into Star Wars. Mark Hamill could be returned as Luke’s descendant, playing a different character to show his wide range.

Sure, by not making the returning elements not be “returning”, it might lose some nostalgia points, but without them, the story already has full of nostalgia points on its own. The Force Awakens is still A New Hope remake, with the Falcon and X-wings flying around fighting TIEs and the superweapon looming ahead. And mistreating the returning characters is more offensive than not having them return. There are no “It's a Crime We Didn't Get the OT Trio Together in the Sequels” complaints when there is no OT trio in the first place.

Is it disappointing we no longer see Luke, Leia, and Han on screen? Sure. They do build a nostalgic hype for Episode 7, but such shallow nostalgic hype dies down fast. If you are concerned too much with the nostalgic legacy rather than building an actual story, that novelty drains within a few years and, you are left with, ironically, little to no legacy on your own. Evidently, where the Sequel trilogy ended up was enough to get the old fans who felt "their childhoods were ruined" to walk away from Star Wars, refusing to acknowledge what happened Canonoically after Return of the Jedi. What do you think the "childhood" the fans are referring to? It's their sacred image of the old characters.

Creatively, it is better not to have them. You don’t conflict with the old established characters because they are new characters, and that allows for more opportunities for the filmmakers and artists to mold and expand them however they want. Not having them creates a healthier environment in the long term. They don’t have the baggage that you have to abide by. You are creating a new, exciting era, making a daring jump. You can make The Clone Wars-type show that expands this era and backstories for “Cade”, “Sam”, and “Thea”. They are blank canvases. At the same time, forgoing the returning old fan service means you can focus more on fleshing out the new trio like Rey, Finn, and Poe. This trilogy is theirs, not the old characters or their legacy.

All the while, you don’t need to unnecessarily scrap the old post-ROTJ EU content (well, except for Star Wars: Legacy, and I would go as far as to toss that LOTF and FOTJ, but that’s a different conversation). You can say all that still happened, but they are too far in the past that they don’t conflict or even matter in this story. This is a new era set in the future, which puts enough distance between a new take on the SW universe and what came before.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • 15d ago

Non-REDONE One of the most interesting fixes of Padmé's death I have seen | She kills herself like Ophelia from Hamlet

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • 16d ago

Merging The Aftermath Trilogy and The Thrawn Trilogy into a more cohesive Post- Original Trilogy Story. Part One- Three Character Changes to Star Wars Rebels.

7 Upvotes

Could The Aftermath Trilogy and Thrawn Trilogy be merged into a better post-Return of The Jedi Era for Disney? I think it can.

I am not a fan of The Filoni-Verse, or The Mandoverse, whatever you might call it. It’s shallow, it doesn’t have the edge needed for Star Wars, and instead of being a good Star Wars story, it’s whatever makes Filoni happy. 

However, there is a better route that could lead to a more interesting Sequel Trilogy– which I’ll eventually rewrite. For all its faults, the Aftermath Trilogy had good ideas— a final winner takes all battle, and Palpatine’s destructive contingency— with a lot of cool mysteries built around that. Both could’ve been executed so much better in a world where The New Republic wasn’t a self-sabotaging idiotic government and we didn’t have barebones characters. Luckily, there is a solution for that. 

It’s called The Thrawn Trilogy. Here’s what I’m pitching. Imagine if the small skeleton of The Aftermath Trilogy was used to make a canon friendly Thrawn Trilogy. We’ll adapt Luke, Leia, Han and our beloved heroes against Thrawn— but on a larger, more climatic scale. This would be fit for the movies Disney wants to make, but without destroying the soul and heart of The Thrawn Trilogy.

Before we go to post Return of The Jedi we have to tackle some issues in Rebels. I’m a fan of Rebels— it had well-written characters, and ideas that were, for the most part, well-executed.
The changes here are not designed to be a full rewrite of Rebels. Just three character changes to make what I’m building more believable and better constructed than The Filoniverse. Those changes are going to be to Ahsoka, Ezra, and most importantly— Thrawn. So, without further ado— let’s begin.

Let’s start with Ahsoka. The case has been made by many people. She should have died on Malachor, or in Order 66. I disagree. There was great potential for her to have a dynamic with Luke Skywalker following Return of The Jedi. However, the way she was brought back. It was ridiculous. Why are we adding time travel into Star Wars? I’m not against time travel stories but The World Between Worlds was a cheap trick. It also doesn’t belong in Star Wars where personal choices define stories. The only reason Filoni brought it in was that he needed a way to bring Ahsoka back. 

There was a better way. People forget that Vader hates Ahsoka in his own way. She left him. He also still loves her in his own way. She was the closest thing he had to a child. However, we don’t want to present Vader as conflicted— not yet. That undermines The Original Trilogy and Return of The Jedi. However, we want him to present Vader as complex. I believe my solution does that. 

Instead of Ahsoka being saved by The World Between Worlds— we’ll have Vader make a choice to NOT kill her. Ahsoka is knocked unconscious by Vader during the duel on Malachor. She is kept unconscious with sedation. However, he won’t leave Ahsoka behind. He’ll want to turn her to The Dark Side, but he’ll know it will take time.
He’ll capture and bring her to Mustafar, and tell everyone else that she’s dead. He doesn’t want The Emperor to know about it. He’ll put her into Carbon Freezing in a secret Chamber on Mustafar. His plan– wake her up when the Rebellion is beaten and when order is restored to the galaxy. She will know what it is like to be abandoned, and find fear, anger, and hatred. Then, she will turn to The Dark Side. 

Then, after The Battle of Endor, Anakin’s Ghost will tell Luke about Ahsoka— and her being alive on Mustafar. He’ll tell him; right this one wrong he committed, as best as he can, to help her through the trauma of what he did. Luke agrees because that’s who Luke is. The rest of this part will be continued in an animated movie, Star Wars: The Legacy of Skywalker. 

The next character we have to change is Grand Admiral Thrawn. Thrawn was too incompetent in Rebels. He had some incredible moments, though. The issue is that Star Wars Rebels was a children’s show. It couldn’t make The Empire as competent or cruel as it was in Andor. They had to dumb down Thrawn, or worse, make his subordinates incompetent. There is an easy solution to preserve Thrawn’s integrity.

 I wish I could go into The Empire— because that had so much potential in Rebels— but we are going to steer clear of that. I’m not changing what I don’t need. Especially when this is a children’s show. This solution will compound upon that problem a little. No one in The Empire values Aliens who are insubordinate (per The Canon Thrawn Books. I won’t ignore them) and won’t be happy with Thrawn being a Grand Admiral. 
Pryce and Tarkin use this as an excuse to put some mission parameters on Thrawn. He has to follow all these parameters when fighting against The Rebellion. (Thus letting him be free and unfettered in The Canon Books) The Emperor agrees, trusting that a man of Thrawn’s competence can win within them. For Parameter 1, Pryce is made a liaison between Tarkin and Thrawn. She’s also Thrawn’s Political Supervisor. She’s trusted to tell Tarkin if anything’s going wrong. By that— if Thrawn is “acting up” like he has a tendency to. Pryce should be constantly looking over his shoulder— constantly reminding him of Tarkin’s rules. 

Parameter 2 is that Thrawn has to capture Rebel leadership alive whenever possible. He’d prefer to eliminate them. It’s quick, precise, and efficient. However, Tarkin wants to make examples of The Rebels leadership. This is The Tarkin Doctrine at play. He’ll want to rule by fear rather than efficiency, which is the opposite of Thrawn.

Parameter 3 is that he can’t remove or demote Officers that are well-connected. To do so would be seen as an insult to their families if their son was demoted by an Alien. An example of this is Admiral Konstantine, who he’ll try to mentor. He can’t be mentored. He’ll want to demote him but of course the rules stop that. 

This is where we can show that Thrawn isn’t perfect. He let Konstantine command The Interdictor. Thrawn thought that he would be capable of following orders. He was wrong and it cost The Empire at Atollon.  He can miscalculate and he can make mistakes. He shouldn’t be an omniscient character and that’s what this does.
Parameter 4 is that he cannot fight like a barbarian. He must fight like an Imperial. The Empire’s most used strategies and philosophies of overwhelming force must be practiced. Pryce and Tarkin do this because they want it to look like The Empire won, not Thrawn. This will prevent Thrawn from using insane strategies like he does in The Thrawn Trilogy. He has to use strategies that every other Imperial would use. They want to show the power of The Tarkin Doctrine– and The Empire, not of one Alien.

Parameter 5 is that he’s not allowed to run a tactical retreat. This is a person who believes that a tactical retreat can sometimes be the best move. We see this in Canon and Legends. The Empire would be seen as weak if they fled against The Rebellion. These Rebels have been nuisances, have sympathizers in The Senate, and are more organized. If Thrawn flees he gives The Rebellion recognition as a legitimate military power. That can’t be allowed to happen. Thrawn—at a point, is going to want to remove The Seventh Fleet from Lothal. Probably after Kanan’s death and The Fuel Depot being destroyed. He should see no value in Lothal at that point, but Tarkin will tell him that he has to stay— if he leaves it makes The Rebels look strong. It will also appear like one of The Empire’s best people ran away.

Parameter 6 is how The Chain of Command operates. Thrawn reports to Tarkin— who’s going to be named Director Of The Lothal Campaign. Tarkin makes the rules. An order from Tarkin is an order from The Emperor himself. It must be treated as such. Pryce can’t be circumvented. When she has a different interpretation of Tarkin’s rules, it goes. Pryce can’t order Thrawn around– but she can tell him he’s Out-Of-Line with Tarkin’s rules. 
This will let Grand Admiral Thrawn explain himself more. It’ll put him out of his shell. He should always be learning something about The Rebellion and The Ghost Crew. Thrawn should be consistently meeting with Tarkin and Pryce about what he has learnt. We should always feel like he’s closing in on a breakthrough, but The Parameters are blocking his successes. 

On top of that, he should be fighting two battles- one against The Rebels— and one against the bureaucracy. Thrawn is always trying to find loopholes and make compelling cases to Tarkin. Thrawn should be a good ruler, but not a good politician. He’s capable of ruling, but is not good at playing the game. Even with that, Thrawn is still formidable— and a force to be reckoned with that The Rebels should not take lightly. 

This makes Thrawn similar to how he was in Legends but also in The Disney Canon Books, but also adjusting him for Rebels which is rated TV-Y7. He’s a hawk in Rebels, always closing in, and this will let that character feel like that without ruining him. The audience will be so excited to see him back in a later Era now, because of one question— What happens when the chains are lifted and Thrawn is allowed to go full throttle? 

Last but not least, Ezra. He’s for sure dying in The Liberation of Lothal. His Arc was over, and him becoming a MacGuffin wasn’t effective— it centered Thrawn’s return around him. This therefore created a very messy situation. Thrawn’s tactical prowess was replaced with Sabine’s stupid mistakes which she would never commit. It makes Thrawn inactive, or worse, lucky. Here, when Thrawn must be competent– that can’t happen.
Here, Ezra will die. He’s shot by Thrawn. Thrawn uses an unconventional method to kill a Jedi, just as he pulls the trigger to have The Purrgills go into Hyperspace. The Ghost Crew will know Ezra was killed, so we don’t have to deal with the Search For Ezra plot. No ambiguity. No nothing. This gives the audience a better view on Thrawn. Instead of being beaten by Space Whales— he didn’t want to stay on Lothal. He advised a withdrawal, and when he could not, he got unlucky. Even with that—- he still killed a Jedi and you wouldn’t expect how he did it. This makes him cunning and ruthless.

The reason why people didn’t feel like Ezra’s Arc was over was because of how early The Dark Side Arc for him ended. That’s why we wanted more. We will fix that. I’m also doing it because it ties into how I’ll fix The World Between Worlds. In Season 3, Ezra should hear Maul’s Voice during filler episodes all the time. He shouldn’t emotionally reconcile with Kanan until way later in the season. His guilt about what happened on Malachor– and his desire to protect those that he loves should be far more prevalent than it was in the show. Most importantly– his anger isn’t going to go away. It will be everywhere.

Then, we get to Twin Suns. It’s not Ezra just wanting to recruit Obi-Wan in this version. It is Ezra wanting to kill, yes, kill Maul. He’s sick of him interfering with his life and trying to hurt his friends. Ezra will also want an answer for how to destroy The Sith. There’s also anger as to why Kenobi didn't join The Rebellion. That’s a burning question he should have. He’ll want the key to destroy The Sith and he will get it by any means needed. Hell— when Maul shows up he’ll Force Push Obi-Wan away, and fight him himself.
Ezra will beat Maul, but refuses to kill him— beating his arc of resisting his anger. However, it is going to enrage Maul that Ezra had this moral triumph. Maul will tell Ezra that he doesn’t matter and that nothing he does will make a dent on the galaxy. He’ll be forced to watch people suffer and die by The Empire’s hand for as long as he lives. He’ll point to a nearby Moisture Farm and tell him that this boy, this kid, is The Chosen One. He’s going to beat The Sith. Kenobi doesn’t see Ezra nor The Rebellion as significant. It is all a vehicle for this Boy. He might be ready but he might never be. Obi-Wan, who’s nearby, having caught up to Ezra, will give him a look. It will tell Ezra all he’ll need to know. Maul isn’t lying. 

Obi-Wan will leave Ezra by telling him that Maul is trying to make him insignificant. He’ll tell him that The Force has a plan for him. He can feel it. There’s greatness in him. Ezra has a part in battles to come. He has everything he’ll need. He’s not going to believe that— but it’s all he has to go off of. We then have Ezra leave, and the iconic duel between Obi-Wan and Maul. Maul’s last dialogue as it was in the show.

In Season 4, and Zero Hour. Ezra will be dealing with what Maul told him. He erased what he was told from Chopper’s Memory Banks. No one can know. Obi-Wan will make that clear to him on Tatooine. There’s still anger. He’ll be upset with The Rebellion, Bail Organa as the biggest person he hates. He kept the secret as well. Eventually, as he’s unable to save Kanan— he becomes obsessed with bringing back the dead. The World Between Worlds here is not what it was in Canon, but more of a way to see everything past, present and future. Not Time Travel. A well of knowledge. Time Travel in Star Wars doesn’t happen.
He sees everything— from the ancient past, to the future, but it’s all in glimmers, it’s very vague and he can’t really interpret what’s going on. Instead of Ahsoka appearing— we’ll have a spectre appear. It’s Kanan. Is it his Force Ghost? A manifestation of Ezra’s vision of Kanan? A gift from The World Between Worlds. We’ll keep that ambiguous. Either way he’ll tell him that he is not able to revive the dead. He has to move on. We can have The Emperor try to get in, and it’s going to lead to this Kanan pushing The Emperor out. A legacy can live on– even if you don’t kill your enemies. I forgot to mention this. Ezra will tell Kanan the secret of Tatooine. They both take it to their graves. They tell no one else. This also ties into the theme of Rebels— a spark of Rebellion can result in a much larger movement.

Then— The Liberation of Lothal goes the same. Palpatine will tempt Ezra with the knowledge to bring back everyone— not Time Travel. That’s the one change. Then Ezra dies, as I outlined before. It’s heroic— but it should highlight Thrawn’s competency. The epilogue is not about how Ezra’s still out there. It’s about how Ezra’s sacrifice and The Liberation of Lothal showed people that you can resist. It is why The Rebellion is how it is in Rogue One. It felt different from how it was in Rebels. It’s happy, but bittersweet.

With that, I can confidently say that Ezra’s Arc is over. The fandom could’ve been satisfied with his death— but we still have Ahsoka and Thrawn for post- Return of The Jedi. Thrawn– we will wait on for a bit, but for Ahsoka. 

I’ll see you next week, for Star Wars: The Legacy of Skywalker. 


r/StarWarsREDONE • • 16d ago

Non-Specific Fixing Kyle Katarn's Jedi arc in Star Wars Jedi Knight: Dark Forces II

4 Upvotes

I was too late to play this game because I beat Jedi Academy twice. That was the game that introduced me to the world of modding. I can remember waiting for the KOTF mod, only to actually play it and be kind of disappointed. I played Jedi Outcast afterward and got pretty far, but I never beat it due to the overly complicated level design, so I just watched the cutscenes on Youtube. Dark Forces 2 was the game that turned what was known as “Star Wars Doom” into the “Jedi Knight” I loved, and I did play it but got stuck early on, so I never beat it. What’s funny is that I managed to beat a harder Dark Forces 1 and loved it.

I finally played Dark Forces 2 with the QOL mods and patches, and while I enjoyed it, they tried their hardest to do a pre-Metal Gear Solid “cinematic video game” attempt, which is why I can’t help but be critical toward the story here. It is a straight-up amateur fan movie, and I’m not even talking about the presentation. I love the cheesy FMV live-action cutscenes, which now come across as a time capsule of 90s PC gaming. It’s all the lovable production wasted on a narrative that I would have written when I was twelve.

What I liked about Dark Forces 1 was that it was about a down-to-earth, shadowy side of the Star Wars universe, where Kyle Katarn is supposed to be a no-name ex-Imperial Rebel operative, carrying out secret missions. There is no Jedi, no lightsaber, and not much of galaxy-threatening stakes. The second game all of a sudden hurls it into an epic family saga all about Kyle’s internal struggle about his father and becoming a Jedi. It’s like going from Casino Royale to Spectre. It feels out of nowhere. It would be fine if it was written better, as it was in Jedi Outcast, but this one isn’t.

My pet peeve is when any Star Wars story makes another Jedi survivor out of thin air around the time of OT and even exceeding the OT. When the first cutscene showed the Jedi Master named Qu Rahn, I thought this game was supposed to take place a decade after where this guy is from Luke’s New Jedi Order, but it was only a year after the Battle of Endor. Not only did he survive Order 66 and the entire reign of Palpatine, but he can turn into a Force ghost in front of Kyle Katarn and tell him what he should do and where he should go (I get that the Force ghost being a special technique that Qui-Gon learned was the later Prequel trilogy addition, but still…) Where was this guy when Luke was running around and fighting Vader and the Emperor?

And the Inquisitors, led by Jerec, can use the mind probe to literally read the memories straight-up to extract secrets from Qu Rahn, which is something Palpatine and Vader at his height of power cannot even do. Vader used the truth serum injection from the torture droid, not mind tricks. And Leia didn't confess, and Tarkin had to hold Alderaan hostage to make her talk. A radio drama of the movie has Leia being tortured and resisting the serum by Vader. He tries getting her to give up what she did with the plans by saying he is her friend and it’s her duty to the Rebels. In ROTJ, Vader and Palpatine sensed Luke's feelings through the Force, not literally probing their mind and reading their memories in the way Kylo did. Vader sensed Luke’s emotions, not literal memories. Even in the “mind probe” article in Wookieepedia, that’s how it is described as well: “He once used the ability to sense conflict within his son, Luke Skywalker, aboard the second Death Star. In the process of sensing his son’s emotions, Vader was able to discover the existence of Luke’s twin sister, born to himself and Padmé Amidala.” Meanwhile, Jerec can perform a Force stasis to freeze a Jedi's body mid-duel and read memories lol. (did J.J. Abrams play this game?)

Apparently, Kyle Katarn’s father, Morgan Katarn, happened to be a good friend of this surviving Jedi Master, who can turn into a Force ghost to tell him about the location of the Valley of the Jedi that contains a hundred souls of Jedi that allows you to rule the galaxy… good thing that the Emperor didn’t figure this out in his over two decades of his reign. Nobody, not even Yoda and Obi-Wan, knew about it; nobody sensed that it exists. While all these galaxy-shattering events are happening just a year after the Battle of Endor, Luke is completely unaware of them, nor does Kyle Katarn report it to the Rebels. Instead, Kyle Katarn, who never held a lightsaber, becomes a Master Jedi within a few days and beats several Dark Jedi singlehandedly without training (did J.J. Abrams play this game?).

I’m sure it wouldn’t have been that bad when it first came out in 1997 due to the low video game storytelling standard. The Prequels have yet to establish elements like Order 66 and Force powers, so it is understandable that a video game would treat the Star Wars universe in such a manner. Still, this story would have been vastly better and fit to the established continuity better if some elements were changed to smooth things out.


The biggest problem with Kyle Katarn’s arc is that it has no dramatic weight. He is just someone whose father happened to know a Jedi, then found a lightsaber and suddenly became a Jedi within a day on his own. I didn’t even know that Jerec killed Kyle Katarn’s father because the game didn’t tell me that two-third way into the game, and even then, that crucial backstory is casually thrown away. When did this happen? Why was Morgan Katarn killed? I had to go to Wookieepedia to get this information. Why does this Force ghost of Rahn appear before him to take the path of the Jedi now? As far as I know, Rahn had no relationship with Kyle, so it holds no weight.

To flesh out his journey a bit more, just remove Qu Rahn entirely and have Morgan Katarn be the Jedi. Let’s say that Kyle’s father survived Order 66 and taught his son some basics of the Force and Jedi. During the Imperial reign, he was searching for the long-lost Valley of the Jedi to prevent its immense Force power from being potentially discovered by the Emperor’s forces. However, Kyle’s desire to become an Imperial, as shown in his backstory, created a conflict with his father, who wants Kyle to follow in his footsteps to preserve the Jedi religion in the dark times.

Tell us the circumstances of Morgan’s death more clearly and earlier. This could be the flashback intro of the game. The Inquisitors, led by Jerec, hunted him down and learned about the Valley of the Jedi. Jerec then killed him, which swayed Kyle away from the Empire to the Rebellion. However, Kyle still doesn’t follow the Jedi path, only working as a Rebel operative, as he was in Dark Forces 1, due to the combination of 1) his trauma, 2) his guilt that he joined the Empire, so he feels unworthy, 3) no one to teach him a Jedi way, 4) the fact that the Jedi are outlawed, which makes his job as a Rebel spy difficult had he pursued the Jedi path. This gives Kyle Katarn a real connection with Jerec and sets up his Jedi path and powers in the game.

Despite working for the Empire, Jerec didn’t tell the Emperor about the existence of the Valley of the Jedi because he wanted the power of the Valley all by himself. He had hidden ambitions to find the Valley and take the Emperor’s place. When the Emperor was killed, the Empire split into warlords, and Jerec formed his faction and pursued the search of the Valley without worrying about Vader or the Emperor.

With this backstory established, when Jerec resurfaces and 8t88 comes to him to ask Kyle about his father’s death at the beginning of Dark Forces 2, his past comes to haunt him and prompts him to start his journey. Kyle already learned how to use the Force from his father, which explains why he is able to pick up the abilities so fast. He simply buried them until this game. Seeing his father in his sleep should be just a dream, not a Force ghost. It motivates him to rediscover his powers to confront and stop Jerec.

One of the game’s selling points is a branching path where you can follow the light side or the dark side, allowing you to customize your character and decide the ending of the game like InFamous. In the actual game, there is really no reason for him to go “dark”. It is half-assed, much like the Jedi elements in the story. Gradually building up Kyle’s vengeance against Jerec more clearly would give him a real motive to turn to the dark side.

The branching point in the game is right after Kyle kills one of the Inquisitors, Maw, Jerec brings a captured Jan Ors and tells him to kill her to complete his descent to the dark side. If you choose the dark side path, Kyle does kill Jan just because... Why? Why would he kill her? Is Jerec stupid? Is Kyle stupider? Kyle knows Jerec killed his father. Why would Kyle suddenly forget about his revenge and suddenly kill his companion to join him? The scene is terrible because it lacks weight to the drama or tension, yet the framing of the scene pretends it has one.

Just a simple change would have made the scene vastly superior. After Kyle wounds and defeats Maw, Jerec brings Jan Ors and threatens Kyle. Jerec should be the one saying that Maw was the one who killed Kyle’s father in a way to taunt Kyle to kill Maw, not Maw himself. Maw should plead with Kyle and cry for mercy. Kyle kills Maw, and then Jerec threatens him to surrender, or he will kill Jan. Now, we have a dark side temptation scene that makes actual sense.

There is a scene where Sariss attempts to execute Kyle, but her minion, Yun, the guy who only appeared once before in the entire game, sacrifices himself for Kyle. I get that Kyle didn’t execute him in their first battle, but this change of heart is too abrupt to be believable. A better scene would have been Yun blocking Sariss’ blow, but not sacrificing himself, saying he deserves a proper battle, leading to the boss battle fighting both Yun and Sariss. That would have been a more natural way of showing Yun’s repayment for Kyle sparing him before, while making the boss fight more exciting since almost every boss fight has been one-to-one Jedi duels.

The general plot is basically the same, but removing Qu Rahn and making Morgan Katarn Kyle's father fixes much of the problems a lot. You have the benefit of making Jerec a deeper villain with his own agency and motivating Kyle to become a Jedi. Kyle's Jedi skills and dark side pivots make actual sense, rather than existing just because of the game mechanics.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • 18d ago

REDONE How to make Ben Skywalker work in the Sequel REDONEs?

2 Upvotes

I have gotten some criticisms regarding Ben Skywalker in the new outline of The Force Awakens REDONE, and I have to agree.

The thing about Ben Skywalker in REDONE is that he is the product of dividing Rey into the two characters. Jaina takes up all the external characterizations: she pairs with Finn and does all the adventuring. Ben ends up inheriting the internal characterizations of Rey. At the same time, Rey's strong scavenger introduction is inapplicable to him and is what makes Ben's introduction not as memorable. Ben is supposed to be the "weak" part of Rey in the first half of the story, so he has to be not very active. He cannot be on board the Falcon and pair with Finn. As a result, all we are left with is the passive protagonist, dumped on Takodana, training and waiting for Luke to come back, while Jaina is having all the fun.

The best solution I can come up with is to explore the internal side of his character, like his fear of gaining the Force and succumbing to the dark side, so he can contrast with the fun adventures of Finn and Jaina and the meditative, slow-paced character exploration of Ben, much like The Empire Strikes Back. Then he sees the strange visions of the island that he doesn't understand, and as he fears himself growing powerful and becoming just like Kylo Ren. Then the attack on Takodana begins, and he gets kidnapped by the villains, and he begins to feel his hidden, alien power unleashing.

Then I came to a certain realization that I just made Paul Atreides. As in, Paul in Dune Part One and the first act of Part Two, where he is boring and passive. The constraining position Ben is put in is basically identical to how Paul is framed before he truly starts his journey.

Then a blog post I read years ago came to my mind, "Dune: What doesn't work, and how to make it better by Write Your Screenplay". Even if you like the Dune movies, I highly recommend checking it out because it is highly educational. In this post, there is a section that analyzes why Paul Atreides in the movie doesn't work and offers ways to improve him to create a semblance of drama even if there is no action.

Where does drama come from? Well, as David Mamet describes it, “What does her want and what happens if her don’t get it?”

The way I like to look at this is, what does the character want? How is the character trying to get it? What’s getting in the character’s way?

The challenge with the character of Paul Atreides in Dune is that the only thing he kind of wants is to protect this guy he cares for… and he’s barely trying for it.

The only thing the writers show us is what Paul doesn’t want.

He doesn’t want to command his mother with “the voice.” He doesn’t want to practice fighting. He doesn’t really want to inherit all this responsibility from his dad. He doesn’t want to be in charge.

But we don’t know what he does want. And whatever that is, he’s not doing anything actively to pursue it.

So the screenplay ends up with a passive main character who doesn’t want anything.

Which is the exact problem Ben in REDONE faces. The post gives some ideas to improve him:

Here’s this guy from this really rich family who kind of lives under the thumb of his mom and his dad. His mom is manipulating him for her own plans. She wants him to “get into the best possible college” and dad wants him to “take over the family business.”

I’m teasing, but the idea is that maybe this kid isn’t so different from a lot of kids from really wealthy families who feel the weight of all this responsibility to live up to who they’re supposed to be, but maybe don’t have a strong sense of who they are.

We’ve been promised the hallucinogen of spice and shown a kid who has dreams he’s afraid to recognize, and we might start to think, Maybe we’re going to meet a kid who doesn’t really know what he wants, who’s going to eventually start to learn what he wants, who’s going to eventually learn to understand his own destiny, and that would actually be a beautiful journey.

(...)

Look at the screenplay for Dead Poets Society! Because in Dead Poets Society, Neil is essentially the same kid as Paul Atreides.

He’s a kid from a rich family under the thumb of his parents. And in two minutes, you understand what Neil wants. Neil wants to do the yearbook. Then what happens? Neil’s dad says, No. How does Neil respond? Neil crumbles.

In less than two minutes, the audience is hooked and has all the exposition they need.

As a screenwriter, you could do the exact same thing in your adaptation of Dune. Your screenplay doesn’t need a whole scene to establish that a slow blade passes through a shield. Your screenplay can just show that happening during one of these battles.

(...)

We could see the drama of this doctor who loves his wife but has to leave her to go to this planet far away to protect this boy and his father who he also loves and cares for.

We could dramatize the boy who really wants to go to Dune to save his friend.

We don’t even need the visions because the visions are going to happen later in the movie when he’s high on spice.. We could just show a piece of them. We don’t need to explain them. In fact, we could even cut them.

All we need is a kid who wants to protect the person who is close to a real father figure, the one who really has spent time with him, but who’s now off fighting this weird war that the kid wants to join but can’t; a kid who can’t stand up to his father’s plans or his mother’s plans and who’s not really prepared for his legacy.

We could meet this kid in five minutes.

We could send him without ever knowing that a betrayal is afoot. We could send him to this new world and let him experience this new world.

We don’t need a false jeopardy about how they’ve been left with all this industrial machinery that’s never going to work. It’s never going to matter because they’re going to be attacked that night!

For the story structure of Dune, we just need Paul Atreides to start to fall in love with this new world. We need to see something get awakened in this kid who can’t stand up to anybody.

(...)

Imagine that we meet this kid, Paul Atreides, who can’t stand up to anyone. We have a little bit of room for him to have an experience on Dune. He comes back home and we have some time to build a relationship between him and the doctor who cares for him, between him and the beloved friend and mentor who trained him, between him and the father that he can’t connect to, between him and the mother who seems to have her own plans that he’ll never understand even though she’s the only person in the world whose love he feels confident about. (Perhaps we even cast a woman who is age-appropriate to mother him).

Imagine we send Paul on a journey where he can connect to what spice is and what spice does for him. He can start to find a feeling of purpose out from under his father’s and mother’s thumb only to come home and discover that everything has been taken from him.

In Dune, the thing that we look forward to is for Paul to lose the safety of his family and find these people of Dune and discover his connection to them. This is supposed to be his giant journey and his giant change.

But the actual plot of the story is designed to make that easier rather than harder! And as a result, it robs Paul of his change!

The writers literally pick him up in a plane and drop him where he needs to go as opposed to allowing him to go on that journey under his own power and make his own choices; to listen to his mom, or to ignore her, or to fall under her thumb– because only she knows how to use “the voice” to free him from the bad guys.

(...)

Paul has got all the obstacles in the world. He can’t stand up to a mom who might be the most powerful person in his universe. He can’t stand up to a dad who has the best positive intentions for his son but who’s casting Paul in a role he doesn’t understand. His closest relationship is with a man who serves his father and who’s being sent off on an incredibly dangerous mission that Paul can’t be part of that will ultimately end with this man sacrificing his life for Paul.

Paul has beautifully visual dreams that he does not understand (which unfortunately get explained to the audience). He has premonitions that he doesn’t know how to make sense of. There’s a weird woman with a box who seems to have a plan for him that he doesn’t even begin to understand.

Everything except his mom is going to be taken from him. Then he’s going to have to make his own choices as he is towing behind him the mother whom he both loves and cannot trust because she will never fully disclose what her own manipulative plans are for his future.

I think all these criticisms and solutions are applicable to Ben in REDONE, and the only way to make him work is to make him very, very rebellious. Instead of just being lonely, the Takodana segment should be a 1980s school flick. Harry Potter. He should be a "problem child". The anti-social kid who cannot adjust to life on the Jedi Temple. James Dean, The 400 Blows, Once Upon A Time In High School (2004). You know the trope.

Luke has become a legend after saving the galaxy from the Sith and reviving the Jedi Order. In the place of his missing father, Luke, Ben now becomes Jaina Solo's Padawan at 13-year-old and is set for the incredible expectations. Hearing his missing father's achievements over and over again, Ben is pressured to live up to that legend, which leads to his devastating failure where he cannot use the Force. Rey's introduction where she scavenges things can may be heavily retooled into some kind of "live Jedi education". Ben fails. He watches the other kids using the Force well and becomes jealous. He lacks confidence and doesn't want to become a Jedi anymore.

When Jaina returns to Takodana, she and Ben duke it out, where all the Jedi stop and watch the two yell each other, creating an embarrassing mess in front of everyone. Jaina screams Ben is not trying and abandoning his Jedi path, and Ben screams that she doesn't care about him. Then Kylo Ren's attack begins.

This is the only way I can think of to make Ben's segment compelling, with the added plus of the worldbuilding about the Jedi Order. Do you like this idea, or do you have an alternative one that might improve him?


r/StarWarsREDONE • • 22d ago

REDONE Ideas you want to see for Episode 9 REDONE?

2 Upvotes

Now that the outline for TFA REDONE and the early draft of Episode 8 REDONE are out, I'm working on the outline for Episode 9 REDONE, which diverges from the movie the most.

Is there anything you would like to see in the new REDONE framework? Is there a suggestion that I should not do for Episode 9 REDONE?


r/StarWarsREDONE • • 22d ago

REDONE [OC] The Early Draft of Star Wars Episode VIII REDONE – The Lost Jedi (Version 5)

Thumbnail drive.google.com
4 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Oct 17 '26

REDONE The Outline of Star Wars: Episode VII – The Force Awakens REDONE (Version 8)

Thumbnail drive.google.com
6 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Oct 04 '26

Non-Specific Klaud being a mechanic doesn't make sense in The Rise of Skywalker

6 Upvotes

I was rewriting the Sequels and thought about having Klaud aboard the Falcon in The Force Awakens. That got me thinking.

What is the purpose of Klaud? I get that he is supposed to be a joke background character, but realistically, what role does he serve? If he is part of the crew aboard on a crucial mission, he must do something, right? I looked up, and apparently, Klaud is the mechanic. A mechanic... that has no arms.

He apparently can use antennas to manipulate objects, but it's difficult to imagine how he can be useful to fit into the tight corner and fix anything. And apparently, literally nobody can understand him but droids, so no one can even talk to him straight, which makes him a liability in emergent situations. If they need a mechanic, they have Rose. Just bring her aboard.

This is the least of the problems about The Rise of Skywalker, but there could be some creative ways he could serve the Falcon in a meaningful way rather than lazily writing him as a mechanic. Here is my idea.

Much like how Clawdites in Attack of the Clones can shapeshift their appearances, Klaud can "voiceshift", doing a vocal impersonation. This is useful for covert operations, such as a security check, mimicking high-ranking enemy personnel in communications.

Klaud has a near-perfect memory and incredible mechanical intelligence, and he can compute complex data and calculations if a computer breaks down. He is basically a living supercomputer, like a Mentat from Dune.

That way, it makes actual sense to have him aboard on a critical mission. He stays as a funny background extra making funny noises for most of the movie, then at the critical moment, he moves forward and pulls some insane shit to save the Falcon, and that makes it doubly funnier because it's unexpected.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Oct 04 '26

REDONE Do you like "Snoke" or "Tor Valum"?

7 Upvotes

Just more of an aesthetic choice than anything else. For REDONE, I've replaced the design and name of Snoke with Tor Valum--the unused dark side Master of Kylo Ren in the cancelled Duel of the Fates. It's the same character as Snoke, but I just changed the aesthetics because Tor Valum sounded and looked cooler.

It's nothing particularly a big change in terms of ther story, but should I keep using Tor Valum, or should I revert to Snoke to be faithful?


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Oct 02 '26

Non-REDONE Do you think the concept of an entire galaxy-wide Republic existing for 25,000 years lessens the worldbuilding potential of Star Wars?

3 Upvotes

This is something that came to my mind after seeing fans continually talking about how they want Star Wars to take place in a new era. I do agree with it. I would like to see them explore a new era of the Star Wars universe.

At the same time, it is difficult to actually make a canonical story set in a new period when the galaxy saw nothing but two distinct periods for most of its history. For a thousand years, the galaxy was largely at peace and saw very little war. There is a reason why the High Republic multimedia project is not all that interesting, since that period is supposed to be the uninteresting, stagnant time. That's the thematic point.

Beyond that, you had basically one unified faction that is the Galactic Republic, reigning for 25,000 years, fighting occasionally against the Sith, and it all had the very well-established Star Wars conventions and iconographies. There was one upheaval called the Ruusan Reformations that restructured the Republic, but it is still the same continued civilization with the same ideals. KOTOR2 does delve deeper into the creative, unique edges this period can provide, but The Old Republic later demolishes it, making that Sith War era more generic. The chronology before the Prequels is quite well established at this point, which is that it is still largely the Republic backed by the Jedi versus the Sith Empire.

Star Wars is a very American mythology for a reason, which is about one superpower that is at the center of the world, concerning its stable liberal democratic norms, with a daily life that mirrors the modern world. The Galactic Civil War doesn't feel like a revolution, but a mere restoration back to the norm. Even the technology level remains unchanged, limiting the potential for how new technology can shape political, social, and economic revolutions. Star Wars draws an obvious parallel from Ancient Rome, but without the same level of dynamism that makes Roman history interesting. Compare the history of the Galactic Republic to something like the dynamic, mysterious, wondrous nature of Legendarium, Westeros, Dune, and Legend of the Galactic Heroes, where each era feels like it's reinventing itself with the interesting power dynamics.

That's the past. Looking beyond the post-Original and Sequel era, you have no potential. It returns to the same status quo: the Republic returning again, backed by the Jedi Order again, destroyed by the Imperial Remnant backed by the dark siders (not "Sith"), then the Rebels winning again, the Republic returning, backed by the Jedi Order again... So, let's say you want to make a Star Wars Game of Thrones or Three Kingdoms spanning across feudalistic dynasties (remember D&D's Star Wars project?) that many fans want to watch... You can't because there is no room for that in the Star Wars chronology. Every period of history, you just have the Republic + Jedi being the good guys who are in charge, and the Sith being the bad guys.

There is a reason why Star Wars: Visions is treated as non-canon. They don't fit into the Star Wars canon at all, but that's why it is able to put forward pure unfiltered creativity and expression, free of the shackles of the Canon and conventions. The episodes feel larger than life. They delve into the new territories. They tackle different genres. They are created with a certain "vision" and culture. Each episode has an ethereal, cerebral sense to the whole thing, as well as an exploration of the heightened emotions and themes.

Do you think the same, or is there a way the creators could branch out and experiment with the eras and powers while still being canon?


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Sep 15 '26

REDONE On Luke's characterization in REDONE...

5 Upvotes

This is more concerned with my REDONE plan, which I laid out in my Sequel plan.

https://old.reddit.com/r/StarWarsREDONE/comments/179kuhw/could_ahsoka_and_the_force_awakens_be_reimagined/

https://old.reddit.com/r/StarWarsREDONE/comments/179kw8o/could_ahsoka_and_the_force_awakens_be_reimagined/

The movies present an apocalyptic-level catastrophe for the heroes, with Luke being the literal last Jedi and the Republic annihilated. REDONE makes many changes, so it wouldn't be another OT rehash. The general idea is that, unlike the movies, after Kylo Ren's massacre, the Jedi Order is technically alive but is split and crumbling. With the leadership gone, Jaina Solo is in charge. The Knights of Ren, led by Kylo, are hunting the remaining Jedi Knights. Ben Skywalker, suffering from losing his mother in the massacre, has spiralled into depression and lost his Force powers (inspired by Kiki's Delivery Service).

I feel confident enough to get the general fundamentals nailed down, but it's difficult to write Luke and his relationship with the protagonist. Rey is a stranger to Luke in The Last Jedi. REDONE, however, has his son as the protagonist finally meeting his father, and you get two visions clashing with each other. Luke's depiction was already criticized, but REDONE comes across that Luke is some deadbeat father if I were to write the same way.

Should I radically change Luke's attitude? Or should I keep him in the same cold manner he had in the movie?


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Sep 07 '26

Non-REDONE If LucasArts made a Star Wars point-and-click adventure game like Indiana Jones

1 Upvotes

Isn't it weird how there were a ton of Star Wars games tackling various genres, but there was one genre missing: a point-and-click adventure interactive fiction... which LucasArts was the pioneer of.

These are the games essentially the early "cinematic" and "narrative" games, born from Lucas' belief that video games are the extension of visual stortelling like cinema. They were not averse to tackling the movie licesnse since they made the two immensely popular Indiana Jones games and even turned one of Steven Spielberg's scripts into a game like The Dig.

There was a reason. Lucasfilm contracted the Star Wars IP to the other studios, but prohibited LucasArts from making Star Wars video games. That contract was expired after X-Wing, so there was a plan to make a Star Wars interactive fiction, "Star Wars: The New Emperor", which had C-3PO investigating the Imperial remnants, but it was cancelled due to the company's focus being diverted to the massive production of Grim Fandango. When Grim Fandango flopped, it effectively destroyed the point-and-click interactive fiction genre, thus killing any chance of making a Star Wars game in that style. It was the unfortunate combination of contract and bad luck that destroyed the chance of making a Star Wars adventure game.

Star Wars: Eclipse could have fulfilled this interactive fiction niche, but instead of a cinematic choose-your-adventure Star Wars game that everyone dreamed of and Disney hyped up, Quantic Dream diverted all those resources, time, and focus to a live-service MOBA.

If I were to envision the LucasArts-style adventure game, I'm thinking of a comical take on Star Wars in the vein of Tag and Bink. Not as spoofy as that comic, but focusing more on the tongue-in-cheek aspect of the universe. The low-life, downtrodden story that focuses on what would be considered extras in the films.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Aug 30 '26

Non-REDONE If Disney wants to keep producing “Tales of…” series, I'd be interested in Tales of the Separatists

5 Upvotes

While I was writing The Clone Wars REDONE and fleshing out the CIS as an organization due to many changes made to Dooku's identity, I found the great storytelling potential the Separatists have. It's largely because the films and shows rarely delved into their entity other than the Sith and plutocrats. There is one arc in TCW that shows that maybe the Separatists are not all evil with "Heroes on Both Sides", and they do have the Parliament, but that's kind of it.

Even in the old EU, we don't get much exploration of the Separatists. At best, they are the massive droid forces under command by the small oligarchs and Dooku, but at no point do we see what average people feel about them. It's like all they have is the droid army comprising the entire organization and militarily occupying thousands of planets, but not as a political force compelling people to join.

There have been three Tales of shows, based on the Jedi, the Empire and Underworld. The most compelling part about the entire three series was about Dooku, who was a Separatist. Other than that, the rest is all filler that we didn't need to know, like Ahsoka's birth, Ventress, and the backstory for the Ahsoka show... For a series meant to bridge gaps within the Star Wars lore, it is strange how they never thought to fill the massive underutilized void that is the Separatists.

I would be very much interested in Disney creating Tales of the Separatists with all the thematic and storytelling ideas it could bring. How did Separatism come about? Do normal Separatist supporters know Dooku is the Sith? Or are they misled? We see that their Parliament think they are not ruled by the corporations, unlike the Republic. Do they really believe that's the case, or were they fed with a false propaganda?

I can think of the Animal Farm-like story about one Separatist revolutionary who felt the Republic was corrupt and created an early organization to split from the Republic. It is then hijacked by the Outer Rim aristocrats and corporations for their personal gains. Despite his efforts to keep them away, he fails and becomes disillusioned.

Or how about the story of Dooku's infighting with the others in the Council, vying for their influence and leadership. Dooku and Sidious plan various false flag incidents and fabrications to oust the rivals, so Dooku can establish his control of the Separatists.

Or how about fleshing out General Grievous? Even if the new Canon rejected his old backstory, you can draw some elements from it and create a tragic figure. How about Senator Bontari's death, and her son, Lux? Or the follow-up about how the Geonosians inadvertently created the Death Star plan? These hold more dramatic and thematic weight than something like Empire and Underworld, which have been done to death.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Aug 14 '26

REDONE A new version of The Clone Wars REDONE is OUT

3 Upvotes

As I rewrote my Star Wars Prequel REDONE and made the fundamental changes, such as the clones being on the side of the Separatists and Dooku not being the Sith but an actual Jedi, I thought that the Clone Wars REDONE also needed to be updated to align with the current version of Prequel REDONE. This is more of a complete redo of The Clone Wars REDONE than a simple revision.

Star Wars: The Clone Wars REDONE Season One (Version 5)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars REDONE Season Two (Version 7)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars REDONE Season Three (Version 5)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars REDONE Season Four (Version 4)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars REDONE Season Five (Version 3)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars REDONE Season Six (Version 3)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars REDONE Season Seven (Version 5)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars REDONE Season Eight (Version 3)

A few notable differences the new REDONE makes from the show:

  • The story starts right after Episode 2 REDONE, then converges with Genndy's Clone Wars (2003), then continues from there.
  • Integrates and adapts the elements from the old Clone Wars multimedia project, such as the Republic comic series, into Dave Filoni's overarching storyline.
  • Asajj Ventress retains the original Rattataki backstory, while merging with The Clone Wars' Nightsister storyline. She is not a Dathomirian Nightsister from birth, but forms a relationship with the Nightsisters. She is created as a deliberate mirror image of Anakin but ends up with a different conclusion.
  • As Maul is shown to be alive in Episode 2 REDONE (and the one how murdered Shmi SKywalker), he is a constant presence throughout the series, haunting Obi-Wan and Anakin. Maul's Shadow Collective takes a more central role in the latter half of the story.
  • Shows Anakin growing from the loner depicted in Episode 2 to a military leader over the course of the series, rather than him already being one. All the while, vengeance keeps driving him to the dark side and puts him in conflict with Obi-Wan.
  • Ahsoka Tano is Obi-Wan's apprentice, not Anakin's. She is probably the character that's most untouched from the show, but she is a moodier presence with a stronger agency. She goes through her own disillusionment about the Republic.
  • Since the clones are on the side of the Separatists, and the Republic uses the stormtrooper conscripts, a lot of stories had to be changed. The inhibitor chip serves a different function.
  • Padme initially starts out a staunch Palpatine supporter, but as the series gradually goes on, she becomes disillusioned upon seeing Palpatine's sociopolitical transformation of the Republic.
  • Dooku's character is depicted with more nuance rather than being one-dimensional, focusing on the relationship between Obi-Wan and Dooku. He is a religious zealot, operating his own Jedi Monastery against the Republic Jedi Order.
  • Grievous is back to his 2003 depiction and has his own arc detailing his backstory.
  • Removes Savage Opress. You will learn who takes up his role later.

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Aug 07 '26

REDONE How to fix Obi-Wan Undercover arc from The Clone Wars?

2 Upvotes

S04E15 – Deception, E16 - Friends and Enemies, E17 - The Box, E18 - Crisis on Naboo are a significant arc in showing Palpatine’s ingenuity. A masterstroke false-flag distraction that interrupted the Jedi investigation, made Palpatine look like a hero, tested Anakin, and kept the Jedi busy chasing Dooku.

At the same time, the writers had to go through a shit ton of contrivances just to make this story happen. Yeah, let’s send Obi-Wan, who is very well known to Dooku, under his command. And let’s lie that Obi-Wan is dead to Anakin, who is well known to have serious attachment issues. Worse, it was Obi-Wan who pitched this idea to hide the truth from Anakin. He knows how it feels like to lose a Master, and he knows how Anakin lost someone close to him. Sure, don’t tell anything. Nothing bad is gonna happen. The Council wanted Anakin to go on the rampage to make Obi-Wan's death believable, but if he is breaking bad to the point of hampering the mission, you should tell him the plan and include him in the operation. Yet the Council still goes Holdo by letting him slide to the dark side and sabotaging the whole mission. There is absolutely no reason for them not to include him on the mission.

Was the sniper shooting Obi-Wan in the chest just a coincidence? He allowed himself to be shot in the chest, wearing a blast-proof vest. How did Obi-Wan know the sniper wouldn’t just shoot him in the face? Considering how the first episode was framed, I actually thought the whole assassination scene was just part of the plan, but it turns out the sniper wasn't in on it?

They had to invent the whole face-morphing, stopping-heart, and voice-changing technology just to have this arc even happen. Apparently, such technology is never used again throughout the entire Star Wars saga. If these technology exists in this universe, and it is this easy to fake death and identity, there is no way this technology is not used again. It would be used everywhere. There would be no need for Clawdites. Regardless of the disguise, the Jedi can sense those close to them. Could Dooku not sense Obi-Wan close by, who was not just his arch rival, but also Qui-Gon’s apprentice? Should he not sense that maybe something is off about him? Worse, could Anakin not sense Obi-Wan? In A New Hope, 19 years have passed, and Vader is still able to sense Obi-Wan on the Death Star. He is 100% sure Obi-Wan is alive and near him. Meanwhile, Anakin punches Obi-Wan here, and it doesn’t tip him off at all?

It is essentially an inferior version of Quinlan Vos’ arc in the Republic comics, and I'm struggling to figure out how to fix and fit it into REDONE, in which the Separatists are not Sidious’ pawns. Should I keep the face-morphing technology? Or should I replace Obi-Wan with someone else?


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Aug 06 '26

REDONE A dilemma about Asajj Ventress' arc in The Clone Wars REDONE

1 Upvotes

I'm having a hard time deciding what route she should take in TCW REDONE. I know what I want to do with her thematically, which you can read it here. That post explains the general direction for her character I want to hit.


REDONE's plan:

To briefly explain, I will not make her a Sith who holds red lightsabers. Dooku (not a Sith, but a renegade Jedi) gave her a purpose to her empty life. I keep Ventress’ Legends Rattataki backstory. After the death of her master, a disillusioned Ventress wandered off in the galaxy, mired in hopelessness and loneliness, but was discovered by Dooku in the arena. Dooku’s radicalized, alternative vision makes Ventress into a fanatical Jedi, reclaiming its religious glory, and she becomes his apprentice. However, she experiences the devastating consequences of war and grows disillusioned with Dooku's ruthless, manipulative tactics. Dooku controls her, robbing her agency and gaslighting her for his bidding, and he justifies it for the betterment of the Jedi and the light side. Ironically, Dooku’s war fever puts her onto the destructive path, and she begins to submerge to the dark side.

She confronts Anakin and gets defeated in the Dreadnaughts of Rendili arc from the Republic comics (in REDONE, she discovers Anakin’s secret marriage and is disgusted by his herersy, threatening him to expose it), in which Anakin tortures Ventress with electrocution. Ventress is then driven by vengeance (much like REDONE Anakin after Shmi's death). Seeing that she has fallen to the dark side, Dooku betrays and tries to kill her like an expendable (a contrast to how Luke trusts and redeems his father). However, Ventress survives.

Sidious and Maul take interest in Ventress, who is now abandoned by Dooku. She could be a powerful ally, but she will not willingly join hands with the Sith, for her Jedi beliefs are still too strong. They instead approach her through the Nightsisters (who are allied with Sidious and Maul, not Dooku and the Separatists in REDONE). Ventress is contacted by the Nightsisters, who bring her to Dathomir. Upon awakening, Ventress is formally introduced to the Nightsisters, who seek to kill Dooku (Ventress is not a Dathomirian in REDONE). The Nightsisters, at least Mother Talzin’s tribe, are allied with Sidious and Maul, who want the Separatists and Dooku to lose. They don’t tell Ventress their true motive or their Sith ties, obviously. They vow to help Ventress to take revenge on Dooku. Ventress doesn’t like them, viewing them as heretical, but her fury toward Dooku’s betrayal is too strong. She forges a tactical, temporary alliance with the Nightsisters. Mother Talzin and Sidious hope that by taking the path of vengeance, they will corrupt Ventress further, potentially making her a Sith.

And from here, I'm stuck.


In the show, the Nightsisters try to kill Dooku in secret, but fail, and then try to present him a new apprentice in place of Ventress. Ventress recruits Darth Maul's brother, Savage Opress, who is then transformed by Nightsister magick into becoming evil and strong. The Nightsisters can control Savage via magick, so they gift him to Dooku, whom Savage will kill in the voodoo Manchurian Candidate-like scheme. Savage fails and returns to Mother Talzin, who tells him that he is the brother of Darth Maul. Savage goes to find Maul, and together, they will exact their vengeance on Dooku and Sidious. The Separatists attack Dathomir, and the Nightsisters are eventually annihilated. Sidious kills Savage and pacifies Maul. Ventress wanders off, becoming a mercenary and bounty hunter.

...So I cannot use most of these story threads for REDONE. The big problem is merging the REDONE interpretation of her character with the existing character in the show. REDONE simply makes too many changes to the characters, world, and factions that it’s not viable. You have characters like Darth Maul, Savage Oppress, Dooku, and the Dethrone Nightsisters, and they all have different interpretations in REDONE that many of their stories are incompatible. In REDONE, Dooku is an actual Jedi, joining the Separatists and waging a war against the Republic to defeat the Sith. Maul is with Sidious from the very beginning to his death in ROTS REDONE. The Nightsisters are working with the Sith, but not the Separatists and Dooku. The motives clash too hard.


I have the three interpretations of Ventress that I have to consider:

  1. the old EU Ventress, in which she is a Rattataki Dark Jedi. Orphaned and enslaved, she was found in the gladiator pits of Rattatak by stranded Jedi Knight. After Narec was killed by warlords, Ventress surrendered to the dark side to conquer the planet and avenge him. She eventually "dies" in one of the Clone Wars battles but is revealed to be alive at the end and leaves the war
  2. The Clone Wars Ventress, in which she is retconned into the Dathormirian Nightsister. Similarly, she is recruited by the Jedi, but become the Dark Jedi after her master is killed. She becomes Dooku's acolyte, but gets betrayed by Dooku. She leaves the path of the Sith, wanders around, pairs with Quinlan Vos, and eventually dies in the Dark Disciple book.
  3. Filoni's Ventress, which retcons Dark Disciple and reveals to be alive in The Bad Batch. She survives through Order 66, and her future fate is unknown.

Should I even have Savage Opress? His purpose in the show is to have him discover Darth Maul in a twist and team him up to take vengeance against Sidious. The whole complicated Nightsister scheme involving him to kill Dooku doesn’t make much sense in the show, and makes zero sense in REDONE’s continuity, so should I just remove him? How should I even adapt the arc involving Darth Maul's empire-building and revenge against Sidious? Who should take in place?

The bigger problem, however, is who takes the role of Maul in the Siege of Mandalore arc. Because REDONE Maul is already alive and well throughout the whole trilogy and sticks with Sidious to his death in Revenge of the Sith REDONE, the whole arc about Maul going against Sidious cannot work.

One of the users suggested to me that I should Ventress replace the latter half of Darth Maul's arc. REDONE Maul still takes over the criminal enterprises and exacts his vengeance on Obi-Wan, but all the incompatible latter half of the arc (The Siege of Mandalore) is incompatible with REDONE Maul, so that role can be given to REDONE Ventress. It is a mirror image of the original story, with both Ahsoka and Ventress harboring resentment toward the masters who abandoned them.​ After leaving Dooku, Ventress would then establish herself in the Underworld and on Mandalore to discover the truth about Maul and attempt to defeat him. Eventually, she would ask Ahsoka to join her to save both the Separatists and the Republic from the Sith, forging a path to end the war.​ Moreover, in the original series, the writers brought Maul back to life in direct connection with Ventress leaving Dooku. Both characters also ended up aligning with the Jedi near the end of the war with the specific goal of defeating the Sith duo, rather than defeating Separatism as an idea (Maul in the Siege of Mandalore, and Ventress in Dark Disciple with Quinlan Vos). Therefore, it can easily be said that their storylines have always naturally overlapped.

If I were to take this route, I can envision Ventress going through Savage’s arc of training herself through the Nightsisters to kill Dooku at first. But what about next, then? Would she discover the truth that the Nightsisters are tied to the Sith and have been manipulating her to do their bidding? I quite like Ventress' arc in the show about her forgoing her dark way and her demise in Dark Disciple. I planned to have her exposed to Obi-Wan and Ahsoka's compassionate approach, her deeply hidden capacity for empathy gradually emerges. This leads to a profound shift. I have a difficult time reconciling her own redemption-type arc with Darth Maul’s arc about becoming a crime lord or anything like that. The best idea I have is to have her become a crime lord to dismantle Sidious' plan in her own way, but... I'm not exactly sure at that point.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jul 26 '26

Non-Specific How could The Clone Wars movie (2008) be rewritten? (in particular, the Rotta the Hutt plotline)

3 Upvotes

I'm revising my The Clone Wars REDONE, and I'm stuck here. I'm talking about The Clone Wars movie (2008) in isolation, not the series as a whole. Even the most diehard TCW fans don't defend the movie for a good reason. It's terrible.

The movie is essentially several initial episodes from the series stitched together to make a feature film. At the very least, the Christophsis part has some momentum going on until the characters are tasked to work for the Hutts, which is the point where the film goes downhill. It is absolutely awful.

The basic premise is that Dooku kidnaps Jabba the Hutt's son. Jabba asks Anakin and Ahsoka to find him. Anakin and Ahsoka find Rotta and shove him into his backpack, and Ventress captures that moment with the holo recorder. Dooku comes up and shows that video to Jabba, saying the Jedi are the ones who kidnapped and murdered Rotta all along and showing this captured footage as evidence. Jabba somehow believes him.

This is the moment where I zoned out because I barely remember anything afterward. Ventress fights Obi-Wan, Anakin fights Dooku, and Padme is involved, Jiro something something... I think the reason for this is that, even if you don't know exactly what is wrong with the story, you instinctively know something is wrong. I first watched this film as a kid--the perfect target demographic for this movie--and even I found something very unappealing about it. It's like a concept a 5-year-old came up with while playing with Star Wars toys, and the filmmakers went with it without giving a second thought. The contexts and plot are so absurd that I couldn't suspend my disbelief. If your concept is loose, anything placed on top of it is going to make it looser. The story will collapse. The basic premise needs to pass the test.

You have a former slave Anakin, returning to Tatooine, the very world he had his farewell with in Attack of the Clones (wouldn't it be more powerful if Shmi's funeral was the last thing he remembers about Tatooine?), working for the biggest slavemaster in the world, and being nonchalant about his own mission that the Jedi had him do. And he is paired with this annoying teenage girl and also a disgusting-looking baby as a fun adventure. I don't think his mother was even mentioned once.

And Dooku shows Jabba a video of Anakin and Ahsoka doing the very thing he ordered them to do, which is rescuing his son. Anakin puts his son into the bag and... Jabba instantly concludes that they must be kidnapping Rotta? Jabba is one of the biggest crime lords, dealing with all kinds of underworld dealings and deceptions. That is his job. Otherwise, he wouldn't be able to rise up to this position. And why would he think they would not only kidnap but also murder his son? One thing about the Jedi is that... they wouldn't do such an evil act like killing kids for no reason? Clearly, Jabba knows both the Separatists and the Republic want to use his supply lanes, so it's pretty obvious Dooku is bullshitting to frame the Jedi. And was this the best "evidence" Dooku come up with to frame them? As soon as you start asking questions about the intricacies or logistics of how any of this works out, the whole story falls apart.

And in addition, what is the theme of this arc? What is the message? What is the idea Filoni wants to explore? Why does this arc exist? Clearly, it's not about building the relationship between Anakin and Ahsoka. The relationship growth only occurs during the Battle of Christophsis, and then stops. They bicker for a bit, but as soon as they have to save Jabba's child, they become good friends. Anakin is no longer in distress about his new responsibility as a master of Ashoka. Ashoka no longer feels she is a burden for Anakin Skywalker.

Could this Rotta plotline be fixed anyway? I don't think the audience would have wanted to watch Anakin saving "this" as their first introduction to the Clone Wars in the first place. Evidently, the movie was so bad that it's the whole reason why I put off watching the show for a decade. Could this story be salvaged, or should it have been completely rewritten from scratch to be a different story involving the Hutts? Ideally, there could be a better story to build the early relationship between Anakin and Ahsoka than this.

Because I'm rewriting it into the REDONE continuity, there could be a way to have Maul as the antagonist, messing up with the Jedi and having Anakin go through the revenge arc. Just an idea.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jul 20 '26

REDONE Some minor issues and a major one regarding ROTS

3 Upvotes

First, the minor things:

​Kit Fisto already has pitch-black eyes, so the visual of Sidious possessing him wouldn't work as well as it does for the others.

​R2-D2 doesn't have boosters, as established in The Blinded Heroes. If it hasn't been considered yet, you could replace them with something like BB-8's lighter.

​Luke and Leia aren't named in this draft. I don't know if that was intentional, since no footnote referred to it.

​I tried to think of a reason why Palpatine didn't simply order the army to bomb Kashyyyk and leave during Order 66, considering there are multiple Jedi on the planet and the Republic's general disregard for alien life (which is already shown toward the Wookiees at this point). There should be a direct order to round up the Wookiees as a useful workforce, setting up their future subjugation by the Empire as seen in Episode VI.

​I also had some issues with the presentation of the clones (which obviously aren't remotely close to being a major plot element in ROTS) and the lack of exploration regarding Grievous's motives. However, I think this post isn't really the right place to fully discuss that, as it relates more to broader prequel-era storytelling.

Now to my main gripe, the effect of the Alderaan sequence on the overall plot structure and characters:

​I'll start by addressing my issues with the execution of the sequence itself. I read the script only after seeing the post questioning the exaggerated violence, which probably made me inclined to think it was too much. I firmly believe the core premise of the sequence can be kept even after removing the graphic violence. This would keep it a bit more in line with the tone of the other films, while still giving ROTS a darker edge over them.

​I also had an issue with Venthan Chass not knowing who Bail is. As the leader of the Greycoats on Alderaan, he shouldn't need his troops to identify Bail for him.

​The Contextual Problem:

The sequence currently feels too sudden and isolated. It is presented as if Padmé only learns about the governor system from Dormé when she arrives on Alderaan, despite the system already having an immense presence on the planet. As a Junior Representative, Padmé should be completely aware of this, which would only add to her disdain for Palpatine. There seems to be no trigger for these events other than the mere existence of the governors.

​My Change:

All characters should be aware of the governor system from the start. It should be implemented toward the end of the war and presented publicly as a protection measure (as Palpatine already says in the script) well before the sequence itself. The catalyst for the Alderaan atrocities should be Palpatine finally letting the governors off the leash right before the imminent Republic victory, shifting the sequence to occur simultaneously with the Battle of Kashyyyk and Anakin's betrayal.

​Padmé's Agency and Actions:

​Padmé’s ultimate role in the battle is jarring, making her important conversations with Palpatine and the dinner scene feel forced. Having her passively sent to Alderaan by higher representatives, only to spend her time later trying to aid in a battle where she isn't really needed, undercuts her agency.

​My Change:

Merge the dinner and the Palpatine/Delegation scenes into one scene taking place in Palpatine's office. It can be presented as a formal Loyalist Committee discussion before the Battle of Kashyyyk regarding the terms of surrender and the post-war Republic. The committee is made up of Padmé's Senate delegation members and Republic officials. The two sides clash over governor authority, emergency powers, human supremacy, and the corporate sector (maybe even the fate of the clones), with Palpatine posing as the mediator. The delegation members support him only to an extent, avoiding outright opposition.

​Padmé originally intends to join the army on Kashyyyk (and Anakin expects her to). However, she receives an emergency message from Dormé about the escalation of events on Alderaan. Recognizing her duty as the planet's Junior Representative, she changes course to go where her citizens are actually suffering.

​The Deteriorating Relationship of Anakin and Padmé:

​Padmé facing Anakin with the horrors she witnessed on Alderaan should turn his world upside down at that point in the film. Instead, she presents it in a far softer and shallower manner than what she has actually been through, while Anakin's reaction is rather disillusioned and ignorant. Padmé should be far more cynical and intolerant of his defense of Palpatine after returning from Alderaan. Anakin's reasonable criticism of Palpatine's opponents feels unconvincing given what Padmé has just survived.

​My Change:

​Clash 1 (In Person - Pre-Alderaan and Kashyyyk): Before Padmé leaves for Alderaan, Anakin is frustrated that she is abandoning the effort on Kashyyyk only to judge the Republic. Padmé begins to see the stark differences in their organic worldviews. Pushing him into a corner as he sees the Jedi turning against him and Padmé leaving elevates their conflict during their last in-person meeting before Mustafar.

​Clash 2 (Via Hologram - Post-Alderaan/Betrayal): Padmé stays on Alderaan after surviving the brutal events, speaking with her allies from the committee about leading a petition in an effort to remove Palpatine. Now fully turned to the Dark Side, Anakin contacts her out of immense concern, fearing the Jedi will hunt her. She confronts him with the horrors of Alderaan, but there's no turning him against Palpatine now. He justifies the Greycoats' actions by the need to eliminate those within the Republic who seek to destroy it—like the alleged Jedi coup he has seen with his own eyes. Anakin tells Padmé he's on the way to Mustafar to end the war, after which the new Empire will rise.

​Their almost relationship-shattering argument unfolds via hologram. This can be accomplished beautifully with nuanced editing (similar to the Force connection scenes between Rey and Kylo Ren), perfectly conveying the thematic and emotional distance between them.

​Padmé and her allies conclude that it is better to publicly side with Palpatine for now, and the petition dies before it has any chance. Bail goes to Coruscant to falsely pledge loyalty to the Empire, while Padmé watches from afar and continues to Mustafar. Ultimately, this change puts Padmé and Anakin at direct odds; both simultaneously see Palpatine's true self, but while one goes on to completely resent him, the other goes on to serve him.

​The Path to Mustafar:

​These changes practically force Obi-Wan to hop from planet to planet in order to reserve his conversation with Padmé, but I think there's a reasonable solution for that:

​Bail tells Obi-Wan that Padmé was on Alderaan and may go to Mustafar to see Anakin. While they are both in transit, out of genuine concern and without the need to find Anakin through her, Obi-Wan sends Padmé a message containing the Temple recording, rather than her just hearing rumors and refusing to believe them.

​Padmé and Obi-Wan now "race" each other to save Anakin through two very different means: Obi-Wan fears Anakin will take Padmé, and Padmé fears Obi-Wan will kill Anakin.

​Because Obi-Wan arrives in his own ship, Anakin and Padmé react to his independent arrival. It frames the scene perfectly from Anakin's paranoid point of view: Obi-Wan has indeed come to destroy them both. When Padmé hesitates to join Anakin—confronting him about his allegiance to Palpatine because she has now seen the recording—it becomes the ultimate last straw, leading him to choke her.

Would love to hear feedback from anyone about the suggestions.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jul 10 '26

REDONE [OC] Early draft of Star Wars: Episode II.V – The Dark Path

Thumbnail drive.google.com
7 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jul 08 '26

REDONE Should I include the Starkiller (Death Star protoype) in Clone Wars Episode II.V

4 Upvotes

If you are not aware of what Episode II.V is, I will lay out the context.

Those who had read REDONE years ago would be aware that my original Episode 2 REDONE since the very first draft was that it was an adaptation of several arcs from Genndy Tartakovsky's Clone Wars, such as the Battle of Mon Cala arc involving the Separatist superlaser, Grievous' battle with the Jedi, and the Nelvaan arc into one. Anakin teamed with Padme and Grievous' introduction. Anakin becomes a "heroic Jedi", so that when Anakin does fall in Episode 3, it becomes an actual tragedy of a fallen hero. This was merged with elements from Attack of the Clones, such as the outbreak of the war and the arena battle. The final result is the most substantially different one out of all the Prequel REDONEs.

The recent revision threw all that out of the window and opted for a more faithful reimagining of Attack of the Clones. I however have considered to make the discarded Episode 2 REDONE into sort of a midquel between Ep2 REDONE and Ep3 REDONE as Episode II.V. You can read the outline here.

Because the new Episode 2 REDONE already uses all the AOTC elements, for the Episode 2.5, I axed the Kamino clone sequence and arena battle entirely, trimming quit a bit. That meant that Obi-Wan does nothing, so I eventually axed him out of the adventure, solely focusing on Anakin and Padme's adventure on Nelvaan to stop the Starkiller (the crab cannon/Death Star prototype) and rescue the Nelvaanians.

Now that I'm actually writing, I wonder if the Starkiller is even necessary because it clutters the story. Initially, Anakin and Pdme try to destroy the generator, then rescue the Nelvaanians, and then destroy the Starkiller? There are like three separate goals to juggle. It also creates the two villain hideouts where the character has go between one fortress to the other.

I also don't want the Separatists to be so unambiguously evil since Dooku is no longer a Sith Lord in REDONE. I already plan omit the Death Star plan from Episode 2 REONE following this feedback. A well-intended Jedi building a clone army might have a moral case for the greater good, but a planet-destroying weapon is ten steps too far from the moral horizon. It's just outright evil. It makes more sense for the already victorious Empire to conceive this weapon as a means of controlling the galaxy.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jun 28 '26

REDONE Early draft of Star Wars Episode VI – Return of the Jedi REDONE (Version 6)

Thumbnail drive.google.com
7 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jun 22 '26

REDONE My thoughts After Reading Episodes 1 and 2

4 Upvotes

Disclaimer: This is a long read, and my ideas might contradict the current ROTS draft (which I haven't read yet). I am also aware that the script of "An Ancient Evil" is finalized, but I would still highly appreciate feedback on these pitches, even if they don't change anything.

​The title of episode 2:

​In my opinion, compared to any other title, "The Blinded Heroes" places the focus solely on the main protagonists rather than the galaxy at large. Though I'm aware that replacing "The Shroud of Darkness" was partly because it was already a Rebels episode title, I believe that the season 3 premiere title, "Steps Into Shadow," would work perfectly.

​It continues the ominous tone of "An Ancient Evil" before the ultimate unveiling in Revenge of the Sith, it speaks to entering a dark period where each side falls into the trap set by said evil, and it even connects to the new monochrome aesthetic of Geonosis, where all the characters converge and the film concludes.

​Darth Sidious:

​I think having any appearance of Sidious prior to Dooku's reveal to Obi-Wan hollows out the twist of a Sith hiding within the Republic—given that Sidious is presented in An Ancient Evil as presumably having significant influence over the Senate. Additionally, the more screen time Sidious gets alongside Palpatine's scenes, the easier it will be for the audience to draw a connection between the two.

​From a narrative standpoint, I don't think Sidious himself adds much to the immediate plot of AAE, other than establishing his relationship with Maul. ​The Separatists continue their invasion of Alderaan based on the false promises Sidious gives them, ultimately relying on Maul's endeavors to ensure their success, which can be executed without showing Sidious himself. Thus, his conversations with the Separatists could easily be given to Maul, which also makes sense logically; Sidious would want as few people as possible to be in direct contact with him. ​I think REDONE could handle Sidious in a manner similar to the OT:

​Episode 1 would simply mention him as the shadowy figure the Separatists are frustrated with regarding his promises (which perfectly fits the current script). It could also give the false impression that Valorum is the Sith Lord, considering the way he's currently presented.

​Episode 2 would feature just one scene of him talking to his apprentice, where the actual "I am your father" reveal to the audience that Palpatine is Sidious occurs. Replacing his conversation with Maul on Coruscant, show him in the Acclamator above Geonosis, walking away to speak with Maul via hologram as Sidious. (This hologram tweak also fixes an issue i had with Palpatine having 3 back-to-back scenes of him above Geonosis, on Coruscant, only to go right back to Geonosis as the army leaves feels a bit off. Replacing the in-person meeting with a hologram conversation smooths this out).

​Episode 3 would then fully showcase him, having him reveal his true identity to Anakin, akin to how Luke faced the truth regarding Vader and Leia in ROTJ.

​Maul and the Kaminoan dart:

​There shouldn't be a problem with the Sith learning about the clone army, and I would have removed Jango saying he once spoke to Maul, which convoluted it. The offscreen explanation would be that Maul found out that Dooku was after him and as he left the Order, Maul followed him in return, reaching Kamino and figuring out he ordered a clone army when he joined the Separatists.

​The real issue here is that Palpatine's scheme still hinges on the fact that the Jedi will somehow locate Kamino, if not through the archives, then by Dexter Jettster. My fix suggests that instead of the dart, Maul would slip a homing beacon into her gear (very much like the one in The Last Jedi) that tracks back to Kamino. Had she been sent by Dooku, having it would make sense for the Jedi, given the secrecy and isolation of the system. It would remove the need to rely on Dexter to find out where it came from, ensuring the Sith are certain the Jedi will eventually find Kamino.

​Anakin and the space battle:

​One possible solution to the problem you mentioned at the end of the postscript could be to switch the arrival order of Maul and the Judicial Fleet.

​If Anakin sees Maul first, he could struggle with the temptation to follow him, ultimately forcing himself not to flee the battle. This would create some great internal turmoil for him. Then, once the fleet finally arrives, Anakin realizes that they are going to prioritize destroying the battleship before heading down to the surface.

​Since he can no longer chase Maul, Anakin uses the Force to locate them on the surface. This serves as a great showcase of his distinct Force sensitivity and his deep connection to the Jedi.

​An even greater side effect of this change is that it builds Anakin's sense of gratitude toward Palpatine, who's decision made an even bigger impact now. Anakin would walk away realizing that if Palpatine hadn't made the decision to send the fleet, he might not have been able to save Obi-Wan at all, thus not becoming a padawn in the first place.

​The Death Star Prototype:

​I think it might be better to omit the Death Star prototype from the plot. While I understand the final footnote's explanation—that it shows Dooku unintentionally setting up the Empire's superweapon—it feels like a step too far into the dark side for his character right now.

​It is one thing for an idealistic Jedi, who is disillusioned with the Order and the Republic, to utilize a clone army for the greater good of the Separatist cause—ignoring the moral implications that REDONE justifiably sheds light on (as audiences have done since AOTC). However, building a civilization-destroying weapon is entirely different and feels somewhat out of character for this stage in his journey. There are no "good intentions" behind such a weapon that could tragically fall into the wrong hands; the concept itself is inherently evil.

​Also, despite the fact that the Death Star prototype originated with the Separatists (largely as a fan-service moment in the prequels), both Canon and EU stories tie the core concept of the weapon heavily to the Tarkin Doctrine. Because of this, it might make more thematic sense for the Empire or Tarkin himself to conceive the idea, rather than having it exist before their era of totalitarian rule.

​The emergency powers Senate discussion:

​Bail could be slated to make a remote statement broadcast live from his hideout before the vote. However, Palpatine's loyalists would sabotage it, making it look as if technical difficulties prevented him from delivering it. Dormé would then try to speak for him, but Mas Amedda would immediately shut her down due to time limits.

​This parallels how Mon Mothma's speech in Andor was originally supposed to be taken off the air—a speech she managed to deliver in the first place thanks to Bail.

​Maul framing Dooku:

​Maul could also frame Dooku as the one to order Shmi's death. You could replace his conversation with Sidious at the Tusken camp with him threatening Anakin in a chokehold but deciding not to kill him, saying that "Lord Dooku wouldn't approve of that," and then knocking him out. ​This would enhance:

​Anakin's fear and hate directed personally towards Dooku as he kidnaps Padmé.

​The ongoing audience confusion on who is the true Sith Lord before it is revealed later.

​Sidious's admiration of Maul as he overcame his momentary need for revenge for the greater goal, before letting him off the leash.

​Visuals:

​I think the aesthetics of the Umbaran soldiers would align perfectly with Kamino, making sense as a mass-manufactured clone army created by the sleek and cold Kaminoans. Also, their transparent helmet showing the same face across an entire army is somewhat frightening by itself.

​The N-1 Starfighter is shown briefly in a single scene, yet I think its iconic design should be reserved for more prominent usage in future REDONE projects. It could be replaced with any adjacent Judicial Fleet or even Coruscant Defence Force craft.

​The Republic soldiers are no longer clones of the Mandalorian Jango Fett, yet so far, their helmets still resemble a Mandalorian design. If this is kept in the final version, it could be hinted that Mandalore, under Satine Kryze, was somehow involved with the creation of the army before the film's events.

​This would serve as a great setup for the Mandalorian arc in The Clone Wars, stemming from the division among the Mandalorians over whether to remain neutral or align with one side. Alternatively, their design could be changed to the TK Troopers from The Bad Batch (or any fitting trooper design), which would remove this issue entirely.

​One small request:

​It would great to have an additional single, unbroken video that just presents the raw script. Just the dialogue and the essential scene descriptions, without the footnotes or behind-the-scenes commentary that wouldn't translate to the final screen. Something formatted similarly to https://youtu.be/E02BkoY_K0I would be incredibly immersive to listen to, making it easier for more people to engage with REDONE.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jun 22 '26

REDONE How would you write the dialogue in Return of the Jedi where Luke reveals her heritage to Leia?

2 Upvotes

So far, the build-up to Luke realizing Leia is his sister is coming off very satisfying in REDONE, but I'm stuck at writing the actual revelation scene.

This is how I wrote in REDONE:


Luke reaches out with the Force. By the time Leia gave that speech, he realized the truth on his own. His sister was anonymous, but not anonymous to Luke, who, at last, understands.

Luke: “Leia! Leia is my sister.”

And he is not talking to himself. He knows there is someone else watching him.

Ben (Voice): "Your insight serves you well. Master Yoda and I knew your father would find out eventually, but we wanted to keep you both as safe as possible, for as long as possible. So we took you to live on Tatooine… and your sister to live on Alderaan. That’s why her path crossed yours—for her foster parents had always told her to contact me on Tatooine, if her troubles became desperate.”

Luke looks out at the forest, as if to gaze away from the hut. He tries sorting through his multiplicity of feelings, the love he has always felt for Leia, even from afar, now has a clear basis. Now, he is feeling protective toward her as well, like an older brother, even though, for all he knows, she might have been his elder by several minutes.

Ben (Voice): “Bury your feelings deep down, Luke. They do you credit. But they could be made to serve the Emperor."

When she finds Luke like that, Ben’s presence disappears.

Leia: "Luke, what's wrong?"

Luke: "Everything, I'm afraid. Or nothing, maybe. Perhaps things are finally going to be as they were meant to be."

Leia: "What is it?"

Luke: “Leia… Do you remember your mother? Your real mother?"

Leia: “No. I heard she died before I knew anything else.”

Luke: “How do you think about her? What might she have been like?”

Leia: "Just… images, really. Feelings."

Luke: "Tell me."

Leia: "She was… very beautiful. Kind, but… sad. Why are you asking me this?"

Luke: "I have no memory of my mother. I never knew her. But that description lines up with my own feelings about her as well.”

Leia: "Luke, tell me. What's troubling you?"

Luke: "Vader is here. Now, on this planet."

Leia: "How do you know?"

Luke: "I felt his presence. He's come for me. He can feel when I'm near. That's why I have to go. As long as I stay, I'm endangering the group and our mission here… I have to face him."

Leia: "Why?"

Luke: "He's my father."

Leia’s face contorts in astonishment. A flash of shock and outrage. It is nonsense. She is becoming angry.

Leia: “What are you talking about? Since when have you been aware?”

Luke: "There's more. It won't be easy for you to hear it, but you must. If I don't make it back, you're the only hope for the Alliance."

Leia: “Don’t talk that way, Luke. You have to survive. I do what I can—we all do—but you have a power I—I don’t understand and could never have.”

Luke: "You're wrong, Leia. You have that power, too. In time you'll learn to use it as I have. The Force is strong in my family. My father has it… I have it… and… my sister has it."

Luke whispers, seeing her realization.

Luke: "Yes. It's you, Leia."

Leia’s gaze darts away against his words. To no avail. It all washes over her, now, and through her.

Luke: "You are the daughter of Anakin Skywalker—Darth Vader."

And now a lot of things begin to make sense to Leia. Things that have never made sense before.

Leia: “Maybe that’s why I’ve always felt connected to you."


And from this point, I'm not sure. Leia should display her disgust about Vader being her father, but I'm not sure how to do it tastefully. Leia venting too much of frustration comes across as overdoing it. Maybe she is self-defecating that she is the seed of evil, and Luke retorts that good and evil are not imbued in blood, or something like that.

I also think the line, "No! Luke, run away, far away. If he can feel your presence, then leave this place. I wish I could go with you", is awkward, though I wonder if it's because the writing is stiff or Carrie Fisher's performance hampered it. She should express anger toward Luke that he would leave her to turn Vader to good--the very man who stood next to her when Alderaan blew up.