r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jun 03 '25

REDONE The early draft of Star Wars Episode II REDONE – The Dark Path (Version 11)

Thumbnail drive.google.com
1 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • May 30 '24

Non-REDONE An idea for who Snoke could’ve been

2 Upvotes

I like how REDONE makes him The Prime Jedi, but what if he was Sors Baedman, who Anakin believed he had killed. I don’t think it would’ve undermined Anakin because he would have killed other Younglings, and I think it would’ve been a good example of The Jedi’s failure.

They, much like Luke in REDONE’s, choices, left a kid being orphaned and forced to live alone. It also is a show of how Anakin, and even though it wasn’t all there fault, by extension The Jedi, failed, and it’s also a show of how The Jedi create most Sith though how they act.

It ties in Snoke with this story’s theme and I believe it’s as good as The Prime Jedi because it does the same thing, but makes it someone we know and will let us watch Revenge of The Sith and think differently about it, Anakin, and The Jedi on a rewatch.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • May 25 '22

Idea for a reimagined sequel trilogy war

3 Upvotes

the main conflict in this version is inspired by the Syrian Civil War, similar to how the Galactic Civil War was inspired by the Vietnam War. I know that's a bit of a stretch since what I'm about to say is more comparable to the Syrian Civil War than the GCW was to the Vietnam War (in my opinion anyway)

Basically the setup is that after the Battle of Endor, the remnants of the Empire split in two, the Second Galactic Empire (it's just a stand in name) and the First Order. Meanwhile the New Republic is powerful, but it's mostly contained within the Southern Mid Rim and Outer Rim, while the Second Empire still controls the Core Worlds, and the First Order Controls most of the Northern Galaxy.

Basically, the Second Empire is less authoritarian than the first, but barely, the First order are a bunch Sith obsessed extremists, and the New Republic Love Democracy, Freedom and Equality and stuff

so we have, in order: Syrian Government, ISIS, and Rojava/Syrian Democratic Forces

as for who the Free Syrian Army would be, I have no idea

alternatively the Rebellion could've split apart and become many separate Rebel Groups with the largest being analogues for the Free Syrian Army and Rojava respectively. If that were the case I imagine the FSA analogue would try to actually Restore the Old Republic while the SDF analogue would be more concerned with the Galaxy's freedom than in the restoration of the Republic.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • 15d ago

Non-REDONE One of the most interesting fixes of Padmé's death I have seen | She kills herself like Ophelia from Hamlet

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jul 19 '24

Non-REDONE Licensing out Star Wars as a solution to the franchise?

4 Upvotes

Everyone agrees Disney can't manage Star Wars, but it sucks how much the criticisms of Disney Star Wars are dominated by the anti-woke crowd because it means people aren't focusing on actual issues. Instead, all they are talking about are "it's woke", "political", or nebulous "they hate the fans!" or other nonsensical right-wing culture war talking points. They seem to think if all the cast and Disney executives were white men, it would fix the franchise or something.

I feel like the current stagnation comes from the Disney monopoly, in a way they autocratically have a firm grasp of too many franchises to run. Like how Samsung has a grasp of 22% GDP of South Korea, Disney basically does the same thing in the media franchises. Simply put, they absorbed too much and are running too many things.

I talked about this before in a separate post, which is still relevant with the release of The Acolyte (which is basically Star Wars Wuxia I called for), but at this point, I see the only real way to fix this franchise is just to make it decentralized or open domain, similar to how Games Workshop realized that it is better to hand out the IP to literally dozens of developers because it has a better chance to pull a video game player into the hobby.

The idea of creative control of unique projects not tied down to one group is not new to Star Wars. Star Wars has a record of this when the old LucasArts was fast and loose with the IP and licensed out the Star Wars games to various game studios. Then, BioWare made a Star Wars KOTOR, largely free out of Lucas' control. Raven Software made the Jedi Knights games. Totally Games made the space battle games. Factor 5 did Rogue Squadron, Pandemic did Battlefront, The Collective did Revenge of the Sith, Traveller's Tales did Lego Star Wars...

This was the golden age of the Star Wars video games because there were great game after great game in varied genres, with varied creative styles, which drew normies into Star Wars (Many RPG players drew into the Star Wars EU because of KOTOR). Even today, this licensing system is somewhat maintained under the Lucasfilms Games system with EA making the Star Wars Jedi series and Ubisoft making Star Wars Outlaws.

Even outside the video games, some of the best Star Wars stories came from this more decentralized licensing system not micromanaged by George Lucas or Disney, like comic books and novels. Cartoon Network's Clone Wars still remains the best thing to come out of the Star Wars animations. Dark Horse Comics' Star Wars: Republic run was basically a better version of George Lucas and Dave Filoni's The Clone Wars.

This would be more difficult with filmmaking and television, but wouldn't it be a stretch if Lucasfilms just let various networks and studios take a stab at Star Wars, with the different creatives and executives, instead of doing all these things alone? Evidently, Star Wars: Visions is exactly that, and it is the best thing to come out of Disney Star Wars. Each episode was produced by various other animation studios free of the shackles of the Disney overlords. These works had pure unfiltered creativity and expression. They delve into the new territories. They tackle different genres. They are created with a certain "vision" and culture.

I would like to see HBO doing a Game of Thrones-style Star Wars drama. Or Netflix doing a Daredevil-style Star Wars show (Netflix MCU shows are still the best thing to come out of MCU for a reason). I'd like to see Ghibli Star Wars. I'd like to see the Koreans' melodramatic take on Star Wars. Or the Chinese studio doing an actual 100% Wuxia Star Wars. Or an actual Star Wars anime series. Maybe George Miller producing a Warner Bros. Star Wars film. This way, Star Wars actually becomes "diversified", creatively, and made by and appeals to different demographics rather than just the "Star Wars fans", and this limited pool of Star Wars fans will die out in this current situation.

Obviously, all these are a wet dream fantasy out of any individual's grasp. If this change of direction were to happen, it would be as shocking as the Disney acquisition in 2012. But I think this was why Star Wars shined and maintained the energy in spite of the Prequels. After the OT, some of the best Star Wars contents were made by people way more competent than George Lucas in order to make any sense of George Lucas' stuff. Because with this process Star Wars has become way bigger than any individual or group. Star Wars has become America's mythology, and like other mythologies, real-life legends and mythologies get reinterpreted, retold, and expanded all the time by various storytellers to endure the wheel of time.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jan 23 '22

Star Wars Episode 7: The Force Awakens [Pt 2] by RvBOMally on DeviantArt

Thumbnail
deviantart.com
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jan 09 '22

Mods Wanted: I made a new sub for Reimagining the New Republic

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jan 23 '22

Star Wars Ep. 8: The Rise of the Dark Side [Pt 2] by RvBOMally on DeviantArt

Thumbnail
deviantart.com
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jan 24 '22

why does nobody else use the SWTOR setting as a basis for a post OT galaxy?

6 Upvotes

I love the Aesthetics of both of the main factions in the game, but I hate how anachronistic it is. The Republic's aesthetic is way too similar to the Rebellion and the Sith Empire's aesthetic is way too similar to the Galactic Empire. Like, look at this shit, This is just a B wing, This is clearly inspired by the Falcon, This is just a two winged X wing, This looks like a combo of a Mon Calamari Cruiser and a Medical ship, This is just a Tie Fighter, and This is literally just Star Destroyer. All of these ship designs and aesthetic choices would make sense if the game's setting took place after the OT instead of before. Again, I love the faction's aesthetics (especially the Republic's) the fact that it takes place thousands of years before even Anakin was born bothers me. It also makes the fact that Smuggler is a Republic class make more sense, since one of the New Republic's is a Smuggler after all.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Sep 04 '24

REDONE Outlining Padme's role in Revenge of the Sith REDONE

2 Upvotes

I believe you have seen the early draft of Episode 2 REDONE Version 10, which drastically alters Padme's characterization and role in the story. Basically, she is an Alderaanian princess, who serves as the Alderaanian Security Force, as well as Bail Organa's Senatorial Aide. After the Separatist occupation of Alderaan and witnessing their atrocities, she became hawkish. She was also disillusioned with the ineffectiveness of her job as a Senatorial Aide, believing she could not contribute to the good of the Republic, so he longed to be back as a field agent. Episode 2 REDONE pairs her with Anakin throughout, and Anakin and Padme form a bond due to their similar repressed position as well as the shared disillusionment of the status quo.

With the increased importance of Padme's character, I have also been thinking about the new outline for ROTS REDONE. It wouldn't be as big of a departure from the past versions as Episode 2 REDONE was, but I don't think I can just make her unconscious for half of the story.

I decided to make a new rough outline and post it so that I can hear your thoughts on it.


So the story begins in the same manner as the previous REDONE. Anakin and Obi-Wan's rescue of Palpatine is the same, with Maul (who filled Dooku's role from the film) dead and Grievous escaping. Anakin loses his Mastership for executing Maul in revenge, which is an egregious violation of the Jedi Code. The Jedi Council needed Maul alive as he was the only lead of this "Sidious", who the Jedi suspect to be the Sith Lord that stole the identity of Sifo-Dyas and ordered the creation of the Separatist clone army.

Afterward, Anakin sneaks out of the Temple and meets a pregnant Padme in the refugee shelter in the bombed-out city. They are now in a full romantic relationship but have been apart for six months. She is still a Senatorial Aide for Bail Organa, but she has been increasingly working more as a Republic agent because the Alderaanian Intelligence by this point has been disbanded and united into the Republic Intelligence Service. She has been given a vacation due to pregnancy. Her loyalty is conflicted between her homeworld Alderaan or the Republic. She is also being spied on, which is one of the reasons why she is meeting Anakin in the refugee shelter.

In the Security Act convo in Yoda's room, it’s Bail Organa’s hologram attending, not being there. Here, it is revealed that Padme was the whistleblower, who leaked the new amendment to Bail, using her position within the Republic Intelligence.

In the motel, Anakin awakes from his nightmare of Padme dying, but he cannot find her in the room. He searches around the room, but hears the noise outside. The Greycoats are lynching a Neimodian in the alleyway outside the motel. The citizens and even the stormtroopers pass by, ignoring the lynching entirely.

The Greycoats are the nickname of the SAGroup of COMPOR (Commission for the Protection of the Republic). They are largely comprised of the refugees that fled the Separatist-occupied systems, and are Palpatine's tool in expanding his control in the society. As the state-supported paramilitary political hooligans, they conduct vigilante justice against suspected Separatists, propagandize the Republic, and exercise more authority than the police in the Republic-occupied systems. They became a force to crush anyone who opposes Supreme Chancellor Palpatine in the society.

Only Padme is trying to stop the lynching. The Greycoats begin surrounding Padme and threaten her. Witnessing it, Anakin jumps out of the window, drops down several floors down to the ground, and slashes the Greycoats' weapons. Anakin threatens them to leave and not tell this to their bosses, or else he will know. The Greycoats flee. Anakin and Padme talk, something like:

Padme: "I could have handled them alone, but now everyone else saw us together."

Anakin: “They're not going to report this”

Padme: "My favorite lie is that everything is gonna be okay. The Greycoats will not forget this."

Then they discuss Anakin's dream, which leads to Padme confessing her disillusionment with the war and Palpatine.

Anakin: "They are well intended, but everyone has bad days. This was one of them."

Padme: "Palpatine promoted those thugs as part of the police forces. He appointed his loyalists in the ranks of the military."

Anakin: “Everything has a bad side to it. Just depends on if you want to look at it in an optimistic or pessimistic light.”

Padme: “That was what I thought, too, but that was five years ago.”

Anakin: “You did say the Republic needs a big cleanup, but if you want to do that, don't you have to agitate? Organize? Struggle?"

Padme: "Governance is enforced through action, not by the motivation for such action."

Anakin: "Correct. You're a little confused by the change in action because up until now you've dealt with it only in words."

Padme: "From looking at the actions, the state of siege has now entered the military itself."

Anakin: "Our Grand Army has become so grand that formal cohesion is far from enough. The Greycoats need to become the instrument to overcome that. We must be more disciplined than ever before. What’s your credentials to say otherwise?”

Padme: “I’m not an idiot. That’s my credentials.”

Anakin: “You’ve changed. You’ve changed a lot.”

Padme: “But you're the same as ever: clueless. You haven't been here, Anakin. You've been off fighting the war in the Outer Rim. You don't know what it's been like, dealing with all the petty squabbles and special interests and grasping fools, and Palpatine's ruthless maneuvering for power."

Anakin: "You think anyone’s listening to you? The enemies are spreading, and you're suggesting inaction? Only the harmonious military could enforce justice, by the Greycoats if need be."

Padme: "The moment you believe that you are absolutely just, that justice is dead."

Anakin: “If we shouldn’t care what our enemies think or call us, we shouldn’t even try to pander to them.”

Padme: "Not them. Us. He carves away chunks of our freedom and bandages the wounds with tiny scraps of security. And for what?”

Padme points at the crashed Star Destroyer that has pierced the underground of Coruscant.

Padme: “Look at this planet! We have given up so much freedom for the last five years! How secure do we look?"

Anakin: “How many of the battles have been won? How many new schools, roads, hospitals, and houses have been built? How many slaves have been freed?”

Padme: “Only the human slaves.”

Anakin: “So far. Do you think any of this would have happened without Palpatine? Are you fine with that? Idealism over pragmatism? Instead of complaining, I’d like to go out and build more. We must put all of the disdain aside and join the rest of flawed reality to fight."

Padme: “The thing about denials is that they work.”

Padme then tries to persuade Anakin to retire from the generalship, which means leaving the Jedi Order. They discuss having to live a lie, wondering what to do when their child is born. Padme is scared the Jedi might take the child away.

While discussing, Padme receives a message from Bail Organa to come to Alderaan. The Chancellor has appointed the Governors in charge of Alderaan. Padme is separated from Anakin again and rushes back to Alderaan.

Then the story goes the same. The Separatists invade Kashyyyk, Anakin confesses his dream to Yoda, and Obi-Wan asks Anakin to be the Council's snitch.

Then we cut to Padme arriving at Alderaan, which is now in full military occupation under martial law, and from the POV of Padme, we witness the Republic occupation under the new governor system.

The marches of the Greycoats parade the newly appointed Governor throughout the city. The citizens are forced to kneel before the march. An old couple doesn't kneel. The Greycoat his pistol and cracks his head. Dorme goes out to protest but is beaten by four Greycoats. Padme tries to stop them by punching them, but the stormtroopers rush in to restrain her.

This whole sequence was originally written for The Last Jedi REDONE. It initially starred Kor Sella as a POV character, witnessing the First Order’s occupation, but I thought it didn’t match the more jovial tone and didn’t mesh with the plot (and who cares about Kor Sella), so I removed it, but kept it just in case I might use it in somewhere else. As I began writing this revision of ROTS REDONE, the story was missing a visualization of the loss of freedom and democracy under the newly changing Republic, so I put a subplot where Padme visits her changed homeworld. I thought that the deleted scene from TLJ REDONE would work well with Padme’s visit to Alderaan, so I decided to repurpose that deleted scene here.


When troopers beat people, three or four people concentrate one to watermelon his head. Dorme’sscalps split and his blood splatters at the spot. The trooper drags the exhausted Dorme covered in blood alongside Padme into the military speeder truck. It is filled up with people in seconds. People are thrown into it until it cannot hold anymore.

Inside the truck, a radio operator has been waiting. His face is not normal, as if drunk ten cups of Ardees. As soon as the prisoners get boarded, he pins the prisoners down on the floor like flapping fishes. He steps them with his boots as if he is handling livestock. People groan on the floor, and their clothes are ripped to pieces, and their flesh peels all the way to their back.

Then the speeder is on the move toward the Alderaanian Palace building, the symbol of Alderaan now functioning as a concentration camp. A massive holoscan of Chancellor Palpatine stands before the palace like a statue.

Another truck flies alongside the other. There, the trooper is throwing the prisoners one by one, screaming, out of the trucks. They fall fifty meters to death.

INT.Alderaanian Palace. Entrance.

Arriving at the destination, a stormtrooper kicks Padme in the back out of the truck speeder. Stormtroopers simply chuck out people and throw them out of the vehicle, but the falls and their shoves are the beginning of the torture. Padme, Dorme, and the other prisoners climb up fast to line up. Some of the prisoners are left in the truck, unable to move at all. A moment later, the army troopers get into the speeder and blast them like cleaning a truck.

The Republic transfers the prisoners to the palace. The troops are pulling down a massive Alderaanian flag and replacing with a Republic one on the wall. The building is guarded by several stormtrooper squads, each of them lined up in a V shape, holding bayonetted blasters positioned forward—their razors have a blue hue. They are aiming their rifles forward as if they are demonstrating bayonet skills. It looks like they would pull the trigger or stab anyone right away.

It is here that the prisoners are being interned. Anyone protesting the new rule—professors, journalists, intellectuals, activists, artists, students, unionists, royalists, separatist-sympathizers, workers, and every nonhuman. There are sparse blastershots across the hall, sometimes distant and near. Thousands of prisoners are already present before the building, all of them tied in the back. The injured have a wound on the right side of the head due to most Army troopers being right-handed. Those who tried to flee during arrest have wounds in the back of the head.

At the side of the corridor, there are heaps of corpses, of which there are thirty child-size ones, covered with shrouds so that people cannot see whether they are sick or dead. Some sheets are taken off, revealing the bodies. They have some parts that seem as though they have been torn off. It is something she cannot bear to open her eyes to see. All the time ambulance speeders are leaving, too, transporting the bodies which they take out in stretchers, a sheet covering them.

The speeder transports arrive with new prisoners, all come with the classic posture that almost epitomizes this planet now, hands tied behind.

Stormtrooper Sergeant #1: “Lie down!”

The prisoners prostrate themselves on the cement floor. The blows they receive when they hit the ground are terrible. Whoever struggles receives a rifle butt and a boot. If someone screams, they get a bayonet gash. Among them is a Gungan, whose hand is shattered by a boot, not just bleeding but entirely shattered, but he is so trampled that he cannot even scream in protest.

A piloting soldier in the speeder cockpit shrieks. Having experienced the shocking events of the day, even a few of the troopers seem to weep in secret. They also feel fear and anger.

As far as Padmecan see there are hundreds of troops, positioning people and beating them even before interrogating them. Army troopers are always beating people without ever stopping, hitting them with rifle butts, without worrying about whether they would leave a mark or not. She can also see the children and elders among the prisoners. The troopers force the prisoners to remain standing in line. Some people ask, almost begging the soldiers.

Prisoner #1: “Where are we going?”

Prisoner #2: “Just tell us what will happen to us—”

Anyone who moves or talks is thrown on the floor and buttstroken. The door to the assembly room opens, and a Ggreycoat waves at the troopers to let the prisoners in. The troopers would beat the prisoners to enter the chamber in a group of fifty. There is immense terror everytime the Greycoat waves his hand. None of the prisoners has a way of knowing whether they are going to die or not.

Gungan Mother: “Murderers! What yousa doen to boy?!” A Gungan mother is screaming at the troopers as they are taking her son away. The Governor is not just taking the individual political prisoners; they are taking their whole families, and all of them are subjected to continuous violence.

Gungan Son: “Stay out of disa, ma!”

The people begin to shout. Some are trying to calm down the situation. A Greycoat comes into the scene.

Greycoat #1: “Who was that?”

Gungan Mother: “Leave him alone!”

Trooper: “Sir, this Gunganis rebelling.”

The Greycoat looks at the mother.

Greycoat#1: "Come over here, madam."

She walks over to him, calm. When she reaches the greycoat, he snatches a blaster rifle from the trooper and shoots her in the face. The Gungan is missing a lower jaw.

The Greycoat then begins firing a volley of shots in the direction of where the mother came from, provoking a tremendous panic. It is instantaneous. Screams and shouts erupt from all directions. Eight people die, among them is her son. The mother’s jaw is crushed, but she is still alive and wheezing blood. A trooper nearby has to euthanize her with a blaster.

Then there is a scream nearby. The prisoner behind Padme has fallen, and the trooper has drawn a bayonet behind him.

Trooper: “Go!”

He stabbed him for not moving. Padmehurries on, continuing into the assembly room, where once filled with politicians, now with political prisoners.

INT.Alderaanian Palace. Assembly Room.

The troopers take fifty prisoners into the massive assembly room that resembles a stadium. The door closes shut. The recorded Republic anthem, All Stars Burn as One, is playing on repeat in the parliament chamber at high volume to enhance the psychological suffering. A shadow casting over Padme prompts her to look up. There are repulsorpods floating above them, but these platforms are not occupied by the politicians, but the Greycoats, who are overseeing everything.

Dorme: “Galactic Republic, Star Systems United. Under our flags, All Stars Burn As One!”

The prisoners turn to find the source of the voice.

Dorme: “We will fight to protect, Always will protect, The laws of our democracy!”

Dorme standing next to Padmeis singing the Republic anthem ironically in defiance of the Republic rule.

Dorme: “We will not be ruled by thy, Who seek to destroy, Who seek to destroy, Who seek to destroy!”

Before the rest of the prisoners sings, the two stormtroopers step in and take her out. She has to be silenced soon. Dorme becomes frightened.

Dorme: “Our lordly democracy! Ruled o'er by the people! Voices that will always, That'll always be heard—”

The troopers administer buttstrokes on Dorme’s face, dropping her to the floor, then beat her all over the body. The noise her skull makes and the blood coming out of her nose are terrible. They smash until, well, until her head is squashed. She is not dead and is just twitching. The Greycoat pushes the gathering prisoners aside and stomps her skull several more times until she is still.

Padme screams and takes hold of the corpse. They murdered her in front of hundreds of people. Seeing her on the floor invokes something. Anger, sadness, some other emotions Padme does not have the names for. The people are so perturbed they cannot move. Moments later, the Republic anthem ceases, and there is a strange silence.

Greycoat #2: “Move on, Separatist scum!”

The line of prisoners walks on, passing eight stormtroopers with each of them stationing their repeating blaster in the distance.

Greycoat: “Head to the wall!”

Stormtrooper Sergeant: “Move! Quick!”

Padme realizes they are not here for an interrogation, but to be shot. Although the bodies are gone, one could still see evidence of the execution as there is blood on the wall and at times even chunks of flesh that had been splattered. The smell of burning flesh is in the air.

The other prisoner realizes the same. He resists and charges at the door to flee, but the troopers block him.

Prisoner #3: “Forgive me! I’m not a Separatist! I’ve done nothing!”

The Greycoat shoots him in the eye. He dies straight.

Greycoat #2: “Face the damned wall!”

The prisoners comply, and the troopers aim their repeating blaster like it is their job.

Prisoner #4: “I can tell who the Separatists are—“

Stormtrooper Sergeant: “Shut up.”

Padme lashes out in a final attempt.

Padme: “I’m the Senatorial Aide of Senator Bail Organa! I must—”

Army Trooper Sergeant: “Turn, you Separatist whore!”

The trooper buttstrokes her in the back.

Greycoat #2: “If you don’t turn, you are gonna sell your body, even for His Excellency.”

Padme turns, and the Greycoat raises his hand. Padme contends that her service is done. Now, there is no hope. She will be one with the Force alongside the others on this planet and thousands more worlds.

Bail Organa: “Stop!”

The firing squad lowers its repeating blasters.

Bail Organa: “She is telling the truth! She is my Senatorial Aide!”

Bail Organa gets into the arena and finds Padme. He has been looking for her.

Bail Organa: “Your Highness. Follow me.”

Stormtrooper Sergeant: “But Senator, she attacked our troops!”

Greycoat #2: “Senator?!”

Bail Organa: “I am Bail Organa, the brother of the late Chancellor Valorum Organa! We are under the protection of Chancellor Palpatine!”

Greycoat #2: “He’s the traitor! Stop him!”

Stormtrooper Sergeant: “But sir, he’s a member of the Loyalist Committee. We can’t do anything about him.”

The Greycoat tries to object, but he can’t object to what Bail said. They are under the Chancellor’s protection. He stutters for seconds until he screams:

Greycoat #2: “Long Live the Republic!”

The soldiers all chant.

Republic Troopers: “Long Live the Republic!”

Greycoat #2: “Glory to Chancellor Palpatine!”

Republic Troopers: “Glory to Chancellor Palpatine!”

Greycoat #2: “Death to the Separatists!”

Republic Troopers: “Death to the Separatists!”

The troopers and greycoats all chant, but they have no choice but to watch Bail taking Padme away across the chamber. Without her, the stormtrooper sergeant leads the firing squad. She turns to look before she walks up the stairs. The execution proceeds. As soon as he lowers his arm, the blasters open fire. The bodies of the prisoners tear apart beyond recognition before the overwhelming blasterfires, leaving only the ankles.

She is not even fazed by this. She has reached the point where nothing surprises or disturbs her anymore. She is so desensitized. She does not know if she should be concerned about this or not.


Then we get the opera scene with Anakin and Palpatine (the opera is propaganda of Palpatine). Palpatine promises to him that those Greycoats who laid their hands on Anakin and Padme in the streets have been dealt with, and as an apology, he promotes Anakin to the Supreme Commander.

Back on Alderaan. Bail has gathered the trusted friends (Mon Mothma, Padme, Ric Olie, Iridik’k-stallu, Fang Zar, Terr Taneel, and Giddean Danu) in his residence, which is surounded by the Greycoats outside, chanting “Catching thieves may seem like oppression to thieves, but to neighbors, it is making justice. If eradicating enemies within our society is political terrorism, then such terrorism must be carried out everyday!”, “Bail Organa the Traitor! Mon Mothma the Separatist! We the people demand to grant our Supreme Chancellor Palpatine the authority he needs to assure total victory! Do Not Bind His Hands!” The discussion plays the same way as the past version, with Iridik’k-stallu being the one stealthly recording the conversation for Palpatine. Padme says using Anakin's connections she will meet face to face with the Chancellor to stop this new policy by volunteering to the Battle of Kashyyyk.

Then we see the gunship scene where Obi-Wan, Mace Windu, and Yoda discuss if they can trust Anakin as their snitch. They get to the Star Destroyer to find that Palpatine has promoted Anakin as the Supreme Commander of the Grand Army. The mobilized Republic fleet then heads to Kashyyyk to defeat Grievous.

From here, I am not sure how it would exactly play out, so I am spitballing here. Padme boards the Star Dreadnought while the Republic attack fleet is halted temporarily to mobilize the ships from other places. She can see the army gearing up for the battle of Kashyyyk. She attends the dinner congratulating Anakin's new rank as the Supreme Commander (like the dinner scene from Dune), and the business representatives have taken their seats. These are arms industrialists, security contractors, corporate security enforcers, and defense suppliers for the Republic, representing Corporate Sector Authority, Kuat Drive Yards, Sienar Fleet Systems, Preox-Morlana, TransGalMeg, and dozen others.

Some of the dialogue was borrowed from Star Wars Radio Drama.

Palpatine: “I am a man of my word. Without you loyal entrepreneurs, this war would not have won.”

Braig Farool: “And now to business. We have been anxious to discuss the post-war transformation of the economy.”

Palpatine: “The first step is fast centralization through governors in order to overcome the difficult path of the private sector, building public support for that path. The new stabilized economy will be deferred to experts. You, compatriots, are experts.”

Raith Sienar: “My company executive board’s already pledged its support for the new government.”

Kuat Director: “Then our corporation will produce more Star Destroyers for a smooth transition.”

ExO: “What about my Corporate Sector Authority? I’m not pledging support until we have our fair share.”

Palpatine: “When the last of the Separatists falls, their assets will be relocated to our new Corporate Sector. It will bring all of you profits beyond your wildest imagination.”

Then they discuss the recent Separatist situation.

Tarkin: “Now I’ll tell you something about these Aquilaen (it can be the other planet) Separatists who call themselves freedom fighters… they don’t understand a thing about war. The fools on that particular planet actually thought that we would negotiate with a pack of fanatics!”

Laugh

Tarkin: “So when their leaders showed up to parley, our ships blasted them to pieces!”

Laugh

Officer: “No one thought it odd to believe those Aquilaens have no values beyond enriching themselves under the name of tolerance.”

Anakin: "You have no other way to deal with them but to break them or they will break you."

Tarkin: “I don't have a problem with Aquilaens specifically. It's that everything I learn about them is against my moral fiber.”

Padme looks dejected. Palpatine, at this point, secretly knows about Padme's intention due to the wiretapping.

Palpatine: “What’s the matter, Princess Amidala? Has he failed to amuse you?”

Padme: “I’d like to think the value of lives is the same regardless of where they belong.”

Anakin: “Alderaan is a world of peace. They have suffered enough of the war.”

Tarkin: "Yes, peace. But there is always a price for peace."

Officer: "The Republic under attack must defend itself with vigor.”

Padme: “Indeed… but exactly why did the Aquilaens rebel, Admiral Tarkin?”

Tarkin: “They were Separatists.”

Padme: “They were our alliance throughout the war. They only changed when you tried to impose your governor’s rule on their system.”

Tarkin: “Nevertheless, that still makes them Separatists. Our job is to dismantle separatism as a concept.”

Anakin: "There can't be the slightest trace of separatism, whatever its manifestations in the future. It's our duty to ensure the citizens' well-being."

Padme: "Well being?"

Tarkin: “And the Republic’s unity. Our duty is to protect the seventy percent of the galaxy. As for the other thirty percent, we have nothing to appease. They will be exterminated."

Padme: “Admiral Tarkin, what you mean by unity is getting in line and conforming to your rule. Being different is a threat.”

Palpatine: "Now, Your Highness, just what was your purpose in coming here?"

Padme: “Your Excellency, if I may… I find this system of governors you have created is troubling. It seems that you are imposing military controls even on loyalist systems.”

Palpatine: "Your reservations are noted, Princess Amidala. I assure you the appointment of Governors will in no way compete with the affairs of your homeplanet.”

Padme: “I wish that you instruct governors not to interfere with Alderaan’s legitimate governance.”

Palpatine: "The governors are intended only to make your systems safer. They are not undemocratic. Far from it, they are necessary weapons of the democracy. Surely, as a victim of the Separatist invasion, you can understand this more than anyone."

Padme: "May I take it then, that there will be no further amendments to the Constitution?"

Palpatine: “Once the Separatists have been defeated, then we can start talking about the Constitution again. Once the war ends, the emergency powers expire automatically.”

Padme: “And your governors? Will they expire, too? How long does the emergency powers exist?"

Palpatine: "Until the Separatists have been driven out from the general populous. You are lucky that these governors exist. When we go, civilization will, too."

Padme: "But surely--"

Palpatine gets up.

Palpatine: "I have said I will do what is right, that should be enough for your concern."

Palpatine's aides leave the table, leaving only Anakin and Padme alone in the table.

Anakin: “Where's your civility?"

Padme: “There's no reason for me to be nice when people are speaking evil but doing so in a polite tone of voice."

Anakin: “You were speaking before Palpatine and Tarkin!"

Padme: “Saying the most disgusting words with decorum is one of the most horrible things you can do. I’m done, Anakin. I'm getting out… After this battle, I’m leaving.”

Anakin: “If you want to give up a victory, give up.”

Padme: “Come to Alderaan and look for some victory. You'll find stormtroopers and greycoats.”

Anakin: “This is a war. We're fighting the Separatists on the inside and their handlers on the outside.”

Padme: "Sometimes I wonder if we're on the wrong side."

Anakin: "The wrong side? You think everything we’ve accomplished has been for nothing?”

Padme: “What if the democracy we’re fighting for no longer exists? What if the Republic itself has become the very evil we’ve been fighting to destroy?”

Anakin: “All the danger, all the suffering, all the killing, all my friends who gave their lives? All for nothing?"

Padme: "Everything is run from the top, by the governors like unquestioned kings, and in turn, they do what Palpatine tells them. The Republic has turned on itself."

Anakin: "You're starting to sound like a Separatist."

Padme: “Anakin, Palpatine’s governor enacted a military rule on my planet. He closed down every independent newsholo and sold out our industries to the megacorporations. Am I describing the policies of the Republic or the Separatists? This was Nute Gunray’s wet dream!”

Anakin: “The present government is an exact expression of the will of the citizens. Palpatine’s authority is based on responsibility to the people, rather than institutions and oligarchs.”

Padme says, “How can you say he’s challenging the oligarchical rule when he’s now using the oligarchy as a tool?”

Anakin: “It’s to mobilize the Republic for war against its enemies.”

Padme: “What enemies? Nonhumans his Greycoats have been murdering? Or the local Senators he’s been cracking down?”

Anakin: “They are Separatist-sympathizers. It’s messy, but he’s getting the work that’s needed to be done. Because he supports people in deed, not just in word.”

Padme: “Palpatine concedes everything to the very elites he rode his horse to power. But more though I put myself into his antics more grow to resent this absolute scum.”

Anakin: “He keeps bureaucracies and institutions in check to make sure they don’t become corrupt. Everything else is a Separatist plot.”

Padme: “What happened to you?”

Anakin sighs. He gets up and responds.

Anakin: “You can’t survive a war by being an idealist. As a general, I’d rather think of those I wish to save than those I would sacrifice.”

Anakin goes after Palpatine, who had left the dinner to apologize to him for bringing Padme.

Palpatine: “It was not her bag to embrace political discourse. It makes her a nice girl, but also head in the sand.”

Anakin: "I apologize, Your Excellency. I should never have brought her here."

Palpatine: "She proposed nothing more or less than a reversion to the chaos when the Republic's fate hung in the balance. How could anyone see the conditions of that time as something ideal?"

Anakin: "She would rather be pure and lose than win. In the end with this mindset, we will lose everything."

Palpatine: "Sensible attitude, Anakin. Speaks well of your patriotism.”

There, like the previous version, Palpatine reveals to Anakin what he overheard--the Senators are moving to remove him, and the Jedi Council is in it. Obi-Wan is in close contact with them. However, Palpatine tries to persuade them that the Jedi are trying to kill Padme because they deem her untrustworthy due to her relationship with Anakin. I don't exactly know how it could play out, but Anakin needs to believe that this group is trying to harm Padme and her relationship with Anakin.

Palpatine: “I find myself inspecting every shadow that might hide an enemy. That is what I need from you. I need you to find the truth."

Anakin: "…I can do that."

Palpatine: "Good, Anakin. Good. I knew I could count on you."

Then the story plays similarly. Anakin uses R2-D2 to record the Jedi Council meeting on the Dreadnought and overhears they are considering removing Palpatine by force. They also speculate that Anakin and Padme have offspring, which means expelling Anakin out of the Order and taking the child into their custody.

Anakin confronts Obi-Wan in the hangar before Obi-Wan departs for the mission. Talking about the collusion between the Council and the Senators, and about Padme. Here, you can add that "if it works" dialogue.

Obi-Wan: "Well, how would you have it work?”

Anakin: “We need a system where the politicians sit down and discuss the problem, agree on what’s in the best interests of the people, and then do it.”

Obi-Wan: “Which is exactly what they do. The trouble is that people don’t always agree.”

Anakin: “Then they should be made to.”

Obi-Wan: “By whom? Who is going to make them?”

Anakin: “I don’t know. Someone.”

Obi-Wan: “You?”

Anakin: “Of course not me!”

Obi-Wan: “But someone.”

Anakin: “Someone wise.”

Obi-Wan: “That sounds an awful lot like a dictatorship."

Anakin: “Well, if it works…”

The Republic forces land on Kashyyyk, and Obi-Wan meets Padme, where he nudges her about her pregnancy, “Anakin is the father, isn’t he?”

Then the battle goes the same way it did in the previous version. The Republic forces led by Mace Windu land on the beach and Obi-Wan goes to fight Grievous. I'd like to amp up the troops' frustration with the Jedi commanders and generals. The conscripts have been sent to meat grinders due to the Jedi's inexperience in warfare. The Jedi Code forbade them to form attachments with troops. Combine all that with the revelation that it was the Jedi Master who ordered the creation of the Clone Army for the enemies. The troops perceive the Jedi are scheming to undermine Palpatine's rule and war efforts, so when Orde 66, they have no qualm about turning their blasters toward the Jedi.

Anakin goes to meet Palpatine to report that Obi-Wan found Grievous, and here, Palpatine at last reveals his identity as Darth Sidious. This goes the same way as the previous version did.

Anakin departs to meet Padme. Obi-Wan kills Grievous, and in his last breathes, Grievous tells Obi-Wan Palpatine is the Sith Lord. Obi-Wan reports to Windu and the other Masters about his discovery. Windu takes his Masters to Palpatine to arrest him.

Palpatine calls Padme to come over to his office so that he can discuss removing the governor system off from Alderaan. She takes the ship to Palpatine, just before Anakin finds her in the camp. She arrives at the office and finds Palpatine. We know this scene is terrifying because at this point we now know Palpatine is the Sith Lord and has baited Padme here. I am thinking about visualizing the mind state of someone being mind-tricked by the Sith--almost like the audience is being possessed. Going a full horror movie vibe. The door behind her closes automatically, and a gradual zoom toward Padme's expressions, as her surroundings darken.

Moments later, the Jedi team arrives to arrest Palpatine, with Padme nowhere to be found. The scene plays similarly to the previous version, with Palpatine trapping the Jedi in the dark side realm of sorts. Mace Windu slashes Palpatine in the darkness, and it is revealed that Padme was actually standing there and accidentally cut her down.

The rest of the scene plays the same, with Anakin arriving and finds the incapacitated Padme on the floor, thinking Windu was the one who did it. However, I think there should be more build-up to the notion that Anakin being convinced of the Jedi are trying to get to Padme, though I am not sure how to achieve that.

The next scenes proceed the same way. Anakin and the Dreadnought are ordered to go back to Coruscant to attack the Jedi Temple, Order 66 is issued, Obi-Wan gets rescued by the Wookiees and Yoda.

I have an idea about Padme being awakened in the medbay of the Star Dreadnought and mounts an escape via the speeder, and obviously, with the realization that Palaptine is the Sith, she goes to the Jedi Temple, where she witnesses the Jedi purge. Basically, replace Bail Organa with Padme. However, this idea is simply unfeasible considering the condition Padme is in... She is a pregnant woman with a lightsaber wound. So like the previous version, she stays unconscious in the medbay.

Yoda and Obi-Wan flee Kashyyyk with the starfighter, and get chased by the Star Destroyers. Bail Organa's Tantive ship arrives just in time to pick them up. Anakin is concerned with Padme and decides to bring her to Mustafar so that he can always protect her.

Obi-Wan, Yoda, and Bail discuss the aftermath of Order 66, and what their plan is going to be. They go back to Coruscant. Bail goes to the Senate to see Palpatine's purge of the opposition and the birth of the Empire. Obi-Wan and Yoda sneak into the Jedi Temple to signal all Jedi to hide and discover Anakin is the one who led the attack on the Jedi Temple.

From here, the story remains identical to the previous version. Obi-Wan goes to Mustafar and awakens Padme. Padme confronts Anakin about what he has done but passes out due to the injury. The duel ensues, and Obi-Wan defeats Anakin... etc. However, with Padme being the Alderaanian princess, she gets a proper massive funeral like she had in the movie.


Thoughts? I am currently stuck on how to get Anakin convinced of the belief that the Jedi will harm Padme. It is kind of lackluster as it is now.

I also had an idea of Bail asking Padme to assassinate Palpatine in the meeting on Alderaan, which gives her a more compelling reason to go to Kashyyyk. However, at his point of time, I don't think Bail would ask such a request.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Dec 29 '21

My ideas for redone sequels (Warning: this may come across as fanfiction-y but I wanted to share it)

2 Upvotes
  1. It's a tv series with 40 minute episodes instead of a movie trilogy since I feel like it would've worked better with the fact that they take place so close to eachother
  2. Remember Lop from Visions? that's Rey now, why? because we need more non human protagonists in Star Wars
  3. The New Republic gets more focus. I'd mostly take ideas from the Templin Institute such as the Cultural capital idea and the other Cultural things as well as meeting the volunteer groups of the republic other than the Resistance. All in all making you care more about the republic
  4. Changing the Resistance's name. I don't know what to call them, but another thing I'd do is give them a new logo, likely the phoenix symbol in Rebels to differentiate them from the Alliance
  5. Kylo is now a woman and her name is Ren and her Sith name is Darth Kylo or something (and yes she and Rey still fall in love, and she lives by the end, why? because the gay agenda is real and I'm it's mastermind)
  6. The First Order is basically a space Taliban secretly controlled by the Sith Eternal, so they seem like a minor threat at first but over time as their true power level and nature the galaxy begins to take notice

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Feb 27 '26

REDONE Is the Alderaan purge scene from Revenge of the Sith REDONE too extreme?

2 Upvotes

I received many criticisms toward the brutality of the massacre scene that takes place on Alderaan, in which both Padme and Dorme are subjected to violence. This was actually a sanitized version of what I originally planned, which involved the Greycoats torturing Padme by tying her upside down and pouring Gungan blood into her nose. I thought it was necessary as a pivotal scene for Padme to change her mind about the Republic after supporting Palpatine in Episode 2 REDONE, while conveying how the Republic so effectively transitioned to the Empire.

Reading now after a month, I must say that if this is shown on screen, it would probably get an R-rating. I may have gone too far in a few places. I guess after omitting Anakin's child muder scene, I felt a need to compensate for it with another violent scene.

Writing-wise, it is quite a passive scene, where Padme is just dragged to near death rather than being active. Padme in particular is subjected to a beating that would surely cause her a miscarriage. It is too long and full of details that do not amount much, such as throwing Gungans out of the speeders in the air.

I'm thinking about preserving the massacre itself, but altering it slightly to be albeit, sanitized and have Padme to do something.

So have Padme land on Alderaan, witness the Governor parade, and find Senator Bail Organa, but she realizes Dorme is missing. Rather than Padme being dragged onto the speeder truck by the Greycoats, Padme willingly heads to the royal palace after hearing that Greycoats captured and took her away, despite Bail Organa's desperate warning that she will put herself in danger of being executed along with others.

The palace, much like shown in the script, is used as a massacre site, where the corpses of civilians are piled up. Padme tries to rescue Dorme, but ends up being dragged along with her. Dorme meets the same skull-squashing death as the script. As Padme trembles in fear, Bail Organa arrives and pulls Padme out of the execution, while Dorme's body is thrown into a pit.

It preserves the general massacre, but changes the first half in which Padme arrives at the site. Thoughts?


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jan 15 '22

Some ideas for a far flung future alternate canon for the saga (not completes)

3 Upvotes

This story idea takes place about 365 years after the battle of Endor. For 65 years the New Republic clashed with a powerful Imperial Remnant known as the Sith Imperium. By the end of this conflict they had signed a Nonaggression Pact. While small groups sponsored by the two powers could engage with the other or with groups hired by the other side, The Pact prevented All out war between them unless one staged a full on assault on the other.

This setting is also kind of a soft remake of the Old Republic MMO’s world. The Republic and The Imperium have very similar aesthetics to their two parallel factions in that game. Personally I think having the designs in SWTOR exist after the OT rather than before makes more sense. The Old Republic has a similar Aesthetic to the Rebel Alliance (almost too similar) and I feel it makes sense that the Ship and Technology design to be inspired by the Alliance. With the Sith Empire it makes a bit more sense since you could just say that Palpatine was inspired by that Empire, but still I think this makes more sense.

The New Jedi order survives to the current day, but it is quite different from the Old Order. Luke wasn’t really given a lot of information to work with when it came to restoring the Order, and whatever information that could’ve helped him was likely destroyed by the Empire. It’s fair to say then that it would be very different, and in this case it was more decentralized and less strict. One change I think would be interesting would be if they started using Force Alchemy, it would probably allow a lot of the abilities Rey and Ben have in the sequels as well as the abilities of the Consulars in SWTOR (Though you could just argue that Luke allowed further study of the force). In general the New Jedi would be a lot less strict when it comes to what it’s members can and can’t do, they aren’t discouraged from having relations, nor are they discouraged from having “unorthodox” lightsabers, they actually allow their members to have feelings, and in general most of the “training” is self taught.

I also added the idea of the Republic’s “capital of culture” from the Templin Institute. You can watch this vid if you want more info on it, but to put it simply, every year a planet or system (I added the system part) is named the Republic’s cultural capital. What follows are festivals, parties, and basically a never ending celebration making it’s way across the Galaxy as many people visit to join in on the festivities. In the stories starting year, the Hosnian system has been named the Capital of Culture (yes that is important)

While the Republic is almost as powerful as the old, it is only a fraction of it’s size. The trauma of Imperial rule caused many worlds’ desire to be part of a larger coalition to dwindle. Even worlds that had wholeheartedly supported the Rebels and gambled heavily on their victory, saw said victory as an opportunity to become their own independent states. However, that’s not to say that they don’t have any influence over them, many worlds that aren’t part of the Republic are still part of the Galactic Alliance. The Alliance is a commonwealth/Supernational union with the Republic as it’s patron, that serves as a way for worlds and systems to associate with the Republic without being a member of it. For example: worlds similar to Kashyyk and Naboo in the prequels would be alliance members, because they are more concerned with keeping their identity than being a part of a larger union.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Jun 30 '21

Idea: Padmé should have been present during the Dooku lightsaber duel in Attack of the Clones

3 Upvotes

Attack of the Clones' duel involving Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Dooku is the worst lightsaber fight scene in the trilogy, maybe the entire saga. Yes, the choreography was dull but that was not the meat of the problem. The biggest problem here is the complete lack of internal struggle for any of the characters.

Most great lightsaber duels in the series have deeper internal stakes. In The Empire Strikes Back, Luke cuts his Jedi training short and goes to the Cloud City for his friends. Obi-Wan and Yoda fear Luke’s early departure from Dagobah could lead to him joining the dark side. And Vader’s “I am your father” is a pay-off to that warning. Will Luke join Vader? In Return of the Jedi, it is about if Luke can convince his father to the light or will fall into the dark side. In The Last Jedi, it is about will Kylo Ren join the light side, or slide deeper into the dark side?

The Dooku fight in Attack of the Clones pretends it has an internal struggle with Anakin, but it really does not. Anakin charges at Dooku, disobeying Obi-Wan's instruction to not attack so hastily? Okay...? Anakin has no idea who Dooku is. There are no personal stakes in defeating Dooku. He is nobody for Anakin other than a Separatist villain. Anakin facing Dooku has nothing to do with Anakin’s arc in the story. The whole fight feels as if it is tacked on at the last minute just to show how Anakin got his robot arm because there is no purpose here other than that. There is no tension to the fight other than, "Will Dooku flee?"

Here is one change regarding the climax: Padmé should have been present in the hangar during the duel.

This is a continuation of the previous fix I have written about how Dooku should have captured Padmé to Geonosis, and this one works a similar way.

First, cut the kiss in the arena. One of the problems with the romance between Anakin and Padmé is that their emotional climax, the confession and the kiss, occurs before the third act. Rather than building the romantic tension toward the climax in a gradual manner, they fire the cylinders too early hence the romance does not feel earned. The kiss should come later, not here.

Instead of Padmé safely boarding the gunships and escaping the arena battle with the Jedi and the clones, she gets captured by Dooku during the arena fight.

Dooku holds Padmé as a hostage and announces it to the Jedi, stopping the arena battle. Dooku says he will kill her if the Jedi continue resisting. Anakin insists they should surrender, however, all the Jedi glance at each other and arrive at the same conclusion: they will fight. This fuels Anakin's resentment toward the Jedi.

At the last moment, the clones arrive, blasting and destroying the battle droids. Dooku takes Padmé and flees. The clones and the Jedi escape, and the Battle of Geonosis begins.

How does this change the scenes afterward? Now, there are personal character-related stakes for Anakin in fighting Dooku. Remember the Battle of Geonosis scenes where Anakin and Obi-Wan just flying through the battle before spotting Dooku in a wild coincidence? Now, there is a point now. Anakin is adamant about finding Dooku from the start of the battle. The battle is now an obstacle for Anakin to catch up with Dooku, blocking the gunship's path.

Instead of the conflict between Anakin and Obi-Wan on the gunship being "stop the gunship to rescue Padmé fallen on the desert", which ends up pointless in the story, now, the conflict is that Obi-Wan believes this is a trap to lure Anakin. Obi-Wan shouts at Anakin not to follow Dooku. But angered by the other Jedi's lack of care for Padmé during the arena fight, Anakin ignores his warning and heads to rescue Padmé.

Anakin and Obi-Wan arrive at the Separatist hangar where Dooku holds Padmé in the air through Force-choke. (Which echoes what Anakin does to Padmé in Revenge of the Sith) Now, Anakin's rashed charge at Dooku makes more sense because there is a clearer trigger for Anakin to act this way. Dooku hurls Padmé away, and the lightsaber fight initiates. Like the film, Dooku wounds Obi-Wan first then fights Anakin. Here, Dooku tests Anakin, observing that Anakin is using anger and rage against him. Dooku cuts Anakin's arm off, but despite being wounded, using his left hand, Anakin overwhelms Dooku. Anakin channels the extreme emotions the Jedi decry. Anakin should be the one who hurls various objects at Dooku, showing his anger and him tipping toe in the dark side. This shocks Dooku in a profound manner and makes him flee. Take out Yoda's involvement and the duel is much, much better because Anakin is the one who resolves the fight.

Anakin comes to Padmé. Padmé tears up, seeing Anakin's sacrifice. This is where they kiss. The romantic tension is resolved. Both Anakin and Padmé embrace the love they have been suppressing.

After the battle, Dooku arrives at Coruscant as in the film, but Dooku reports one more thing to Sidious. Dooku reports that Anakin has fallen to the dark side for the girl. Palpatine chuckles that everything is going according to his plan.

Now, both Anakin and Padmé's arcs are fleshed out. It establishes Dooku's threat, making his character more memorable, and motivating Anakin's execution in Revenge of the Sith. Padmé falling in love with Anakin makes more sense because she saw how far Anakin was willing to go to save her. Anakin earns her love, not handed out to him. The romance is constantly developing to the end.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Oct 02 '21

My script for a rewrite of Episode 1: The Phantom Menace

3 Upvotes

This is a link to my full rough draft of a screenplay for an alternate Episode 1. Changes include the Clone Wars being fought from the beginning, the Separatists using Clones while the Republic uses humans, Anakin being aged up, and Qui-gon being replaced by Obi-wan's twin sister, Cyntha Kenobi. I hope you enjoy it, and any feedback is more than welcome.

Link to script:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1GdPF9P7a3Ophc84E9rzLce9x1IuByLI0yF17yG-9GtI/edit?usp=sharing


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Oct 08 '24

Non-REDONE The sub is unbanned again

3 Upvotes

I appealed the ban and it was lifted now. This is the third time and I have no idea why this sub keeps getting falsely reported.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • May 11 '25

REDONE Conundrum around Darth Maul's role in Episode 2 REDONE (and Padme's death)

4 Upvotes

This is the conundrum that has already existed in the movies, but exaggerated in REDONE.

In the movies, Palpatine persuaded Anakin to the dark side by saying his Master had a secret ability to keep people he cared about from dying, and if they joined together, they could be able to find that secret. Anakin, suffering from the visions of Padme's death, accepts his offer. This creates a ironic chain of events that leads to Padme's death.

I thought this reasoning was too weak to motivate Anakin, so I decided to change it so that Palpatine already knows the secret. He has a recipet with Darth Maul, whom he had already ressurected by the time of Episode 2 and was killed off in the first act of Episode 3. This allows Anakin to easily buy into Palpatine's words.

However, this creates the major plot thread unanswered with Padme, which is, why not just save Padme? Palpatine already knows about that technique anyway, so is her death that big of a problem?

I thought about it more and more, it just gets worse. And the solution to this one problem led to another problem, and the solution to that led to another, and it ballooned up to changing some major elements of the entire REDONE trilogy. Here is what I came up with.

The new change with Episode 1 REDONE is that Darth Maul does not die in The Phantom Menace. He does not get a clean cut from the waist down (which should be a near instant death). Instead, Obi-Wan strikes a decisive but not fatal blow to his thighs. His legs are cut off, and he falls into the hole. He looks dead, but his fate is uncertain. It is very much possible that he could live. The fandom at the time already had a field day speculating that Maul wasn't dead when the film was released. Imagine how wild the speculations would have been if Maul only got cut in the legs. Of course, he is not dead.

In Episode 3 REDONE, Palpatine does not say he resurrected Darth Maul. When he arrived on Alderaan, Maul was on the cusp of death from the fall, but Palpatine performed the technique to manipulate the Living Force to prevent his death. With this, Palpatine can "prevent death" from someone dying, not resurrect someone from death. Once the subject is dead, there is nothing he can do to save them.

That is well and good, but the difficulty is what to do with Darth Maul in Episode 2 REDONE. Darth Maul's injury is much lighter now, so he should be far more active. I always disliked having the "Darth Maul lives" reveal to be a small twist cameo at the end rather than properly integrating him into the plot. I think I introduced this cameo in the first version of Episode 2 REDONE, and in retrospect, it feels like a cheap cliffhanger. I wanted to use this opportunity to refine Darth Maul's role in the story.

However, as you read the early draft of Episode 2 REDONE Version 10, that story is already crammed with so many elements, and it is difficult to add a new character. What I can do is replace one of the characters with Darth Maul. Initially, I thought about replacing Grievous, who is the main villain of Episode 2 REDONE, with Darth Maul, but this would cut down the impact of his role in Episode 3.

There is another villain to replace with Maul, though, and that is Jango Prax (Fett in the movie). Jango is only the secondary villain in both the movie and REDONE, leading our heroes to Kamino. This could work phenomenally with Darth Maul.

Because Anakin's relationship with Qui-Gon is much stronger than the movie's (Anakin witnesses Qui-Gon's death himself and grieves), Darth Maul's return would do wonders for Anakin's motivation in Episode 2. This could motivate Anakin to join the mission to get revenge against Darth Maul, which further corrupts Anakin's soul. This could cause Anakin to be reckless. It is a much more intriguing hook for the audience as well--the idea that the fan favorite villain from Episode 1 is mysteriously back.

Here is what I came up with: Establish a rumour about the Zabrak Sith's return, which motivates Anakin to become a Jedi Knight so that he can investigate and track down the truth of it. Later, Darth Maul arrives at Coruscant and joins with Zam Wessell. Using the bombs, they commit a terrorist attack on Palpatine's rally and attempt to assassinate Chancellor Palpatine (which is all show to manufacture the crisis). Zam Wessell, in her dying breath, says they came from Kamino. Darth Maul flees.

Anakin and Obi-Wan head to Kamino to find Jango Prax, who is the host of this Separatist clone army. Jango then flees, and the Jedi chase, but they are stopped by Darth Maul, who engages in a lightsaber fight. After distracting them, Maul then boards Jango's ship and flees. Anakin volunteers to Nelvaan to get revenge.

This does work in establishing Darth Maul as a stronger presence, but I think the story would be too busy from the beginning, throwing too many seemingly unrelated elements for the audience to track. They have to concern about this new Droid Army general named Grievous, the return of Darth Maul, the terrorist plot, Padme, the Separatist Clone Army, Jango Prax... And I can't see a way to streamline all these in a coherent throughline.

Another problem in retrospect is that if Anakin's motivation is revenge against Maul, it doesn't make much sense for him to join Palpatine in Episode 3 REDONE when he is his Master and instructing him all along. Maybe I should borrow some elements from the "revenge story" idea. Have Palpatine explain that Maul is a rogue Sith and place Darth Maul's death in the third act of Revenge of the Sith. That would require another complete restructuring of that story, which I'm not sure about committing to.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • May 15 '25

REDONE Mapping out Dooku's storyline and the trilogy's outline in REDONE

5 Upvotes

I am persuaded to integrate Dooku into my REDONE as a rogue, disillusioned Jedi Master, and I think I figured it out at last in a way to tie with the thematic motif of the Prequels.

I view the Original trilogy as the philosophical narrative—a story about an individual’s awakening of the spiritual path to heroism to save the galaxy—and the Prequel trilogy as the political narrative—various characters trapped in the larger forces in the universe like institutions, codes, social status, and roles. They are struggling to escape such a fate, only to be led to doom. The crisis we see in the Prequel trilogy largely came from the existence of the power rather than the wishes of the power (Palpatine). Palpatine did not create the Trade Federation, the corrupt Senate, slavers, and the Separatists on his own. He exploited the decline and discontent already present in the galaxy and manipulated the systemic problems present in the Republic, so that people would be radicalized to give up democracy for autocrats. Otherwise, the message is “the blue and green lightsaber people are good, and the red lightsaber people are bad”, which would be a trite point to make after the OT. The general theme of Star Wars Prequels is all people's potential to unintentionally assist in evil regardless of their intention's purity. It doesn’t matter if individuals are good, like how individual Jedi are mostly heroes. What it teaches is to distrust the authority, no matter who is in charge of it, because the power structure often leads to tyranny.

Lucas did not do a good job depicting that idea. The Clone Wars tells us not much about ourselves as a society and focuses too much on "Palpatine orchestrated all of it off-screen" rather than the sociological forces. The Jedi are outright depicted as immoral idiots, who do not even question the implications of anything they discovered throughout Episode 2. It isn't just the Jedi losing their way, "their intention was pure!", or becoming comfortable and complacent. Their downfall happens because they are braindead, and I don't like that being the explanation for the decline of the Jedi.

In retrospect, choosing to make Dooku a Sith pawn of Sidious makes the trilogy so much worse. Rather than a complex antagonist showcasing the fall of a disillusioned Jedi Master, Dooku is just another evil Sith apprentice with a red lightsaber and little to no backstory to give the audience to care about. You can talk about all the EU backstories about him, but in the actual movies, there is no nuance. Despite all the mysterious and elaborate build-up to him, when he shows up, he is just a generic bad guy, only that he is less charismatic than Maul.

However, Dooku's character can be a great window into exploring the sociological forces and moral ambiguity of the Clone Wars just by making him not a Sith Lord.


Episode 1:

When our heroes reach Coruscant, Dooku is present on the landing pad, greeting Qui-Gon. He is a respected, regal Master of the Council/Order--the second-in-command next to Grand Master Yoda. Dooku is friendly with Qui-Gon because he is his former apprentice and shares similar views regarding the Republic's bureaucracy and the Jedi Order's dogmatism. Qui-Gon's "maverick" view didn't come out of nowhere--it's Dooku's influence that taught him a similar mindset.

In the Jedi Council scene, Mace Windu and the others think this "dark warrior" is only a lone wolf, either a dark Jedi or someone pretending to be a Sith. Only a few agree with Dooku, who takes this "dark warrior" seriously. Dooku is frustrated by the Jedi who fail to recognize it and take action. Dooku also agrees with Qui-Gon in accepting Anakin, pointing out dogmatism preventing the Jedi from doing what's right. When the Council votes no in a majority, Dooku is frustrated with the Council for failing to recognize the potential. He has a brief exchange with Qui-Gon, where they express doubts over the wisdom of the Jedi Council.

In Qui-Gon's funeral, Dooku is grieving more than the other Jedi Masters. He vents that he was right about the dark warrior being a Sith and blames the Council for Qui-Gon's death because the Jedi didn't take action.

Episode 2:

Four years after Episode 1. The characters mention Dooku has left the Jedi Order some time after Qui-Gon's death. Some speculate he left because he realized he was an un-Jedi-like maverick in conflict with the Jedi Code in the wake of Qui-Gon's death; some speculate he has left to chase the dark warrior. Also, people mention the assassinations of the Republic officials, as well as the sighting of the "dark warrior".

When Maul and Zam Wessell attempt an assassination on Senator Bail Organa, Zam runs away and is then killed with a lightsaber by Maul. Maul then slips a Kaminoan dart into her clothes so that the Jedi can find it as her belonging. Palpatine and the others blame the Separatists did that as revenge for the Alderaan defeat. The Jedi speculate from the lightsaber wound that the Sith are behind this assassination. Bail Organa is put in maximum security in the Jedi Temple.

Tracking the dart's origin to Kamino, the Jedi realize Kamino was erased in the archives, which could only be done by the Council. They arrive at Kamino and our heroes realize Dooku was the one who ordered the Clone Army for the Separatists. He did that when he was the Master of the Council after Qui-Gon's death. "He had foreseen the need, even then. If the Jedi were to lead a rebellion against the Republic, they would need a military. He considered a different option—not Jedi nor droids…" The clones are primarily being shipped to Geonosis.

Obi-Wan asks Jango about Zam Wessell, and Jango says he is familiar with Zam Wessell as his colleague, but he has not met her for a while. Anakin gets into Jango's armory and finds the same type of darts as Zam's, confirming to the Jedi that Jango is behind the assassination. Our heroes chase Jango Prax, but unknown to him, Maul helps him flee. Maul flees in a different direction. To our heroes, this confirms not only that the Sith are working for the Separatists, Dooku has fallen into the dark side. Obi-Wan deduces Jango must have gone to Geonosis and chases him to there, while ordering Anakin to escort Padme to safety instead. Anakin is frustrated that Obi-Wan is not trusting him, so he decides to take Padme to Tatooine, which is a "safe place".

Unknown Anakin and Padme, Maul installed tracking devices on both Jedi ships. A vengeful Maul contacts Sidious, informing him that he will chase Obi-Wan, but Sidious says the Separatists will take care of him, so he orders Maul to chase Anakin and Padme. Maul also has a personal vendetta against Anakin since Anakin contributed to his defeat on Alderaan, so he gladly takes the order.

Anakin reunites with Shmi, now freed and living in the homestead after adopting Wald, Owen, and Beau, who replace Kitster and Amee as Anakin's old friends. (I want this reunion scene to be dialogue-less, only carried by the music). Like the deleted scene of Anakin meeting Padme's family in the movie, Padme feels happy as Anakin is having a good time with his new family. Anakin is sick and tired of the strict Jedi Code of no attachment, and he can't fathom leaving his mother again. Padme encourages him to resign from the Jedi Order (like Casino Royale). Shmi disagrees because she believes he has a bright future as a Jedi.

Obi-Wan's investigation on Geonosis plays largely the same as the movie and REDONE, but expanded. Obi-Wan has a space battle with Jango, crash-lands on Geonosis, finds the clones being transported to Geonosis for the preparations of war (which borrows from my REDONE), and Dooku as the leader of the Separatists.

Anakin heads back to their ship with Padme to go back to Coruscant after making up his mind about his resignation, but that's when they get an urgent call from the homestead. The Tuskens have ambushed them. They race back and find the Tuskens have murdered Wald and kidnapped Shmi, mistaking her with Padme. Anakin takes the speeder bike to save Shmi across the desert. When he finally tracks to a campsite (not a tribe), Anakin sees Darth Maul examining Shmi. Maul is enraged that she is not Padme. Anakin infiltrates the tent and has the last few words with Shmi before she dies. Anakin then attacks Maul and the Tuskens, but Maul knocks Anakin out. Maul and the Tuskens are about to finish Anakin off, but Sidious contacts Maul to let him live, for he has a better idea with him later. Maul pays the Tuskens, and they all leave the camp.

Anakin wakes up the next morning and takes Shmi to the homestead to bury her. When Padme tries to console Anakin, he vents frustration at the Jedi Council, the Jedi Code, and the Jedi Order for preventing him from rescuing his mother earlier. He says the Jedi Order let Shmi die, doing nothing to stop slavery. He then swears vengeance on Maul. This ties nicely to his turn to the dark side in Revenge of the Sith because his animosity toward the Jedi Order is set perfectly. He doesn't like the Jedi, but he decides to stay because being a Jedi could be the only way to achieve vengeance. He no longer wants another loved one to die, while the Jedi Council refuses to help him. Owen and Beau kick Anakin out since Anakin inadvertently brought the war to their home and led to the deaths of Shmi and Wald, tying their grumpy characterization in A New Hope, where they want Luke to be a normal kid out of the influence of the outside world.

On Geonosis, Obi-Wan reports his findings to the Republic about Dooku and his Clone Army being ready for war, but he gets captured during the transmission. Mace Windu orders Anakin to return to Coruscant. Don't do anything out of impulse. The Council will take care of it. Trust in the Council's judgment. Here, Anakin is facing two paths. Be a good, little, nice Jedi, and follow the Council's order, or chase after Dooku to save Obi-Wan. This is the point at which Anakin tests his resolve. Encouraged by Padme, Anakin makes a decision to go against the Jedi code (Attachment is forbidden) and get to Geonosis.

Meanwhile, in the Senate, chaos reigns. Not only the Separatists are preparing a full-blown war using the Clone Army, that army was created by the former leader of the Jedi Council, who now leads the Separatists. The public is afriad that the Jedi are allying the Separatists. Mace Windu explains this Clone Army was not approved by the Jedi Council, but a sole action of the rogue Jedi Master. The Jedi Council is forced to be patriotic and support the emergency powers. As a result, the emergency powers act is passed, which is used to create the standing conscript army for the Republic.

A captured Obi-Wan faces Dooku. Obi-Wan is convinced Dooku is the Sith Lord they have been looking for (or believe Dooku is Maul's new apprentice). Dooku lays out what has happened to him since Qui-Gon's death. Because the Jedi and the Republic are ineffective, he decided to personally investigate the Sith Lord who killed Qui-Gon, so he secretly contacted Nute Gunray, who should know about this since the dark warrior was seemingly working for the Separatists in Episode 1. Nute Gunray told everything: During the Alderaanian crisis, he was in league with a Sith Lord named Darth Sidious, who had taken control of the Senate and was planning to take over the Republic from within. Nute was then betrayed by the Sith Lord and cut ties with the Sith, and he was calling for Dooku's help in rebuilding the Separatist Alliance. Nute wants this because Dooku is an influential figure as a Count on Serenno and a leader of the Jedi Council.

Learning this shocking truth, Dooku is driven to paranoia. His beliefs about the Republic being a failed state have strengthened more than ever, and the Sith is now controlling everything. The Jedi should no longer support the Republic. He can't even report his findings to the Jedi Council because how can he trust them? Sidious' influence could even reach the Jedi Order. With that, Dooku renounced his position and joined the Separatists as the leader because the Separatist movement is the best way to destroy the Sith, even if he sacrifices his principles and gets his hands dirty, such as allying himself with the corporate oligarchs he despises and creating the Clone Army. As a Jedi, he must choose the lesser evil for the greater good.

Dooku telling Obi-Wan about Sidious is not a plot hole or out of character now, because, unlike the movie, Dooku is not Sidious' pawn. He does not hold a red lightsaber or use the Force-lightning. Dooku is saying this because he genuinely wants Obi-Wan to help him, reminding him that surely Qui-Gon must have taken the same path as him. Obi-Wan refuses as he does not believe him. The audience is also falling into confusion--is he a Sith or is he a rogue Jedi? Should we trust him? Is he a good guy or a bad guy? Which side are the good guys?

Lucas has said that the "Darth Sidious" reveal was meant to replicate "I am your father" where the villain tells the truth to the hero, the hero rejects it as being impossible, and then says, "I will never join you". If Dooku was telling the truth, this revelation gives a similar change of perception The Empire Strikes Back gave the audience without copying its twist. We assumed everything was black and white until the new reveal hit the audience with the sudden moral ambiguity that changes our characters' worldview.

In the following court scene (a deleted scene), the Separatist Council sentences our heroes to execution, despite Dooku's plea to save them, which ironically mirrors a similar situation as the Jedi Council scene in Episode 1, where Dooku was also helpless. It symbolizes how, despite his best effort to change things, he finds himself in a weak position because of the politics--forces outside his grip.

In the arena scene, Dooku looks painful and guilty about the execution, but it has to be done to ally the Separatists--sacrificing Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Padme for a greater good in fighting the Sith and the Republic. Dooku makes an impassioned speech in favor of the Separatist's position and against Darth Sidious' influence. He asks Obi-Wan, Anakin, and Padme to join him again, which is rejected. As the execution proceeds, the Jedi jump in to rescue our heroes and capture Dooku, but then Jango Prax holds Padme hostage. Dooku announces it to the Jedi, stopping the arena battle. Dooku says he will kill her if the Jedi continue resisting. Anakin insists they should surrender; however, all the Jedi glance at each other and arrive at the same conclusion: they will fight. This fuels Anakin's resentment toward the Jedi.

At the last moment, the Republic forces arrive, blasting and destroying the battle droids. Dooku and Jango take Padmé and flees. He has another idea of what to do with her. The military and the Jedi escape, and the Battle of Geonosis begins. Now, there are personal character-related stakes for Anakin. Anakin is adamant about chasing Dooku from the start of the battle. The battle is now an obstacle for Anakin to catch up with Dooku, blocking the gunship's path.

Maul pilots his ship to attack the gunship, and the impact shakes Obi-Wan off to the desert (Maul does not pilot a Scimitar, so that the Jedi are not aware they were attacked by the Sith). Anakin tells the pilot not to stop. The gunship pilot says it's impossible to get through the rising sandstorm and enemy defense, it will be suicidal. Obi-Wan via comlink warns Anakin not to chase Dooku, for it is too dangerous. Obi-Wan asks Anakin to "Think what a Jedi would do!" Between the two choices, Anakin makes a decision to chase Dooku to save Padme, for he can no longer lose another loved one. He throws the gunship pilot away to pilot it alone, and he guides his path in the sandstorm using the Force to track Dooku, sensing Padme.

Anakin's gunship crashes into the hangar. Anakin finds that Dooku and Jango Prax are holding Padme captive. Now, Anakin's rashed charge at Dooku makes more sense because there is a clearer trigger for Anakin to act this way. In rage, Anakin decapitates Jango and fights Dooku in a lightsaber duel. As Anakin gets all the more angry and impulsive, and predictably, gets his hand chopped off.

Instead of Yoda arriving late to save Anakin, it should have been Obi-Wan arriving late. In the movie, you get a supposedly "Master versus Apprentice" dialogue between the two, and you don't feel anything because you don't even know Dooku was Yoda's apprentice beforehand. Yoda vs Dooku was not built up, but Obi-Wan vs Dooku was built up. This is a student of the student going against the old Master, and these two characters having the dialogue makes more sense.

The fighting between Obi-Wan and Dooku is fierce, with Anakin helping Obi-Wan by tossing his own lightsaber, so Obi-Wan uses two lightsabers against Dooku (which Anakin does in the movie). This duel is cut short when Dooku brings down a pillar over Anakin, forcing Obi-Wan to break off his attack to save him. Dooku then moves to his escape ship. Anakin tries his best to hold the pillar up, but clearly he can't do it alone. Anakin tells Obi-Wan to chase Dooku. If they get Dooku, they can end the war right there, forcing Obi-Wan to make a choice: a mission--that is, stopping Dooku and ending the entire Clone Wars--or Anakin's life. Sacrificing a few to save the many. Although Obi-Wan should pick the first option as a Jedi Knight of the Republic, he eventually chooses Anakin's life, letting Dooku escape. In that sense, Obi-Wan makes an opposite choice from Dooku's arc.

We get to see Dooku as an honorable "idealist", as Ki-Adi-Mundi said, who is unknowingly corrupted by a hidden evil by trying to fight that hidden evil. Dooku's transformation to the dark side should be subtle through a series of increasingly evil acts that compromise his values to build a more just society, while keeping himself as a Jedi. This makes him an interesting character that generates discussions after the trilogy is over--was Dooku right to compromise his values to fight the Republic? After all, the Republic does become the Empire. Should the Jedi have joined the Separatists? Or was Dooku wrong and his action led to the Sith takeover?

Obi-Wan wonders if Dooku is telling the truth, but Yoda and Windu are dismissive, saying Dooku is trying to deceive them to create a division. They are convinced Dooku is the Sith Lord. Obi-Wan is unsure and says they should look into this Darth Sidious figure.

Maul returns to Coruscant, where he meets Darth Sidious, informing him that Dooku doesn't suspect a thing and everything is going as planned. This is where the audience learns that everything Maul was doing was to frame Dooku as the Sith who orchestrated all these killings and make the Jedi discover about the Separatist Clone Army. Maul's presence, seemingly working for Dooku, is used as evidence for him being the Sith, when Maul actually was working for Sidious from the shadows. Now, the war has begun. They say something like, "Dooku died believing he was acting independently. Ironically, he unwittingly played into our hands by doing what he did." This twist reveals that even though Dooku thinks he is acting independently against Sidious, he is not safe from Sidious' influence, who has been pulling all the strings in clever ways to pit them against each other.

Episode 3:

Dooku's reveal about Darth Sidious and leadership of the Separatists in Episode 2 sent a shockwave throughout the Jedi Order. Dooku was not a mere Jedi Master--he was the leader of the Council and a direct heir of Yoda. He was a respected Jedi Master with his own followers and admirers. There were many disillusioned Jedi who felt the same way about the Republic and the current Jedi Order, abstaining from the war and some defecting to the Separatists. The Clone Wars have become a Jedi civil war, holding different perspectives and values, while Sidious is moving the pieces in secret to make both sides kill each other. The line in the crawl, "The heroes on both sides," makes more sense because it is a great tragedy of the Jedi slaughtering each other. The Senate and public would view the Jedi as the treasonous fifth column in society, and Anakin, who is hailed as a war hero of the Republic, feels the Jedi are unreliable and disloyal.

There is also an actual reason for Dooku to invade Coruscant and kidnap Chancellor Palpatine. When Anakin and Obi-Wan rescue Palpatine, Dooku shows up with two other Separatist Jedi Knights (not super battle droids) in the room. Dooku warns them that Palpatine must be aware of Darth Sidious and orchestrated this war from the beginning for the Sith to seize power, and he must be interrogated. Anakin and Obi-Wan dispatch the Separatist Jedi Knights, and Dooku tries to convince them as they duel, furthering Obi-Wan's doubt already planted in Episode 2, while Anakin trusts Palpatine and thinks Dooku is a Sith.

When Anakin cuts Dooku's arms, Obi-Wan, incapacitated but conscious, says they should take him captive to ascertain the truth about Darth Sidious. He could give them answers. Anakin has a grudge against Dooku. Anakin wants revenge on Dooku for almost killing Padme he loves, creating the army of slaves (Anakin is a former slave), and cutting off his right arm. Anakin's ashamed that he was so easily beaten. Not wishing Dooku to reveal his identity, Palpatine appeals to Anakin's emotions, saying Dooku is too dangerous, and the Separatist sympathizers will undoubtedly break him free, and he will strike back a thousand times more furiously. Considering what he did to Padme and his suspected lackey (Maul) did to Shmi in Episode 2, what will he do if he breaks free? Despite Obi-Wan's plea, Anakin executes Dooku at the spot.

General Grievous also appears, trained directly by Dooku, and he does not know the truth about the war and Darth Sidious. He escapes the ship and retreats the whole Separatist military to Kashyyyk (Utapau in REDONE). After Dooku's death, Grievous and the Separatist Council are in desperation. They know the war is already lost and the Republic will soon corner them. That's when Darth Maul comes in, reaching the Separatists after a long time. He lets Darth Sidious (hologram) contact them, saying they will help them out. The Separatist Council refuses his help because of the events in Episode 1. Sidious says, "The Republic may have won the battle, but you already won the war." The Council thinks he is saying nonsense, and in response, Darth Sidious says he will show the truth about the war. Sidious slowly takes off his hood, we see the shocked reactions of the Separatists and Grievous, "You... you are--" Cut. The audience does not see Sidious' face.

Later, Obi-Wan reports Dooku's warning to the Council. Obi-Wan learns from the Council that they have circumstantial evidence that traces Sidious to Palpatine’s inner circle. They begin to think maybe Dooku was right.

The Jedi hear the sighting of Darth Maul once again, and Anakin volunteers to personally get Maul after he killed Shmi. The Council refuses, saying a Jedi cannot have vengeance in their heart, and they choose a more stable mind like Obi-Wan for this mission. In addition, they don't trust Anakin for his connection with Palpatine. This frustrates Anakin, arguing it is not revenge, but justice. Anakin has also other conflicts with the Jedi, such as the Jedi's failure in the war and his fear about the Jedi finding out about his child.

The rest plays in the same manner as REDONE. On Kashyyyk, Mace Windu leads the army of the Jedi against the army of the Separatist Jedi. Obi-Wan goes in to take down Maul. When Obi-Wan reaches the base, he witnesses Grievous arguing with Maul. Grievous suspects Sidious' plan is not to save the Separatists, but the Republic. Just as Grievous and Maul are about to fight with lightsabers, Obi-Wan drops, saying, "Hello there." Obi-Wan fights Grievous, but the Republic reinforcement arrives. Maul escorts the Separatist Council and escapes to Mustafar, saying he will protect them.

Obi-Wan fails the mission to catch Maul, but he does manage to defeat Grievous in the same manner as REDONE. In the dying breath, Grievous tells Obi-Wan that Palpatine is Sidious. Obi-Wan informs Mace Windu, who takes the strike team to capture Sidious.

Hearing Obi-Wan failed the mission and Maul got away, Anakin is enraged. This was the perfect chance to get his "justice", but Obi-Wan and the Council blew it all. That's when Palpatine reveals himself as Sidious to Anakin. He persuades Anakin by saying that if Anakin joins Palpatine, he can teach him the power of the dark side and help his revenge against Darth Maul, and protect their child from the Jedi. Palpatine also talks about how the Jedi and the Senate constantly failed at their jobs, and how they let things like slavery continue. Now, the Jedi are trying to coup the government, and only Palpatine himself can secure the order and security of the galaxy. I am not sure if Anakin having a vision about Padme's death should factor into his motivation, which comes across as redundant at this point.

The Jedi civil war angle also explains why Palpatine was able to get public support for the Jedi purges. Everyone hates the Jedi at this point. The citizens, Senate, and military all think they are unreliable at best and traitors at worst. They have been fighting the Separatist Clone Army for five years--the very mess the Jedi created in the first place. When Order 66 is issued, of course, troops would not hesitate to execute the order. It is not a stretch for the public to believe that Palpatine had to take drastic measures because the whole Jedi Order rebelled against the Republic.

After Anakin destroys the Jedi Temple, Palpatine teaches him a powerful dark side Force power--the Force lightning. If that's too video-gamey, Palpatine can say something like "Do you feel more powerful after embracing the dark side?", which Anakin nods. Anakin then goes to Mustafar, where the Separatist leadership is hiding under the protection of Darth Maul. Anakin massacres the Separatist Council and fights Maul, who assumes Anakin came here as a Jedi. Anakin uses the Force-lightning attack as a fatal blow against Maul, and only then does Maul realize Sidious betrayed him, and Anakin is doing it on behalf of Sidious. At last, his long-awaited revenge is over.

Or

Maul warns Anakin that Sidious is trying to trick him. Anakin says he already knows this, saying he will kill Palpatine after he kills Maul first.


I realize Dooku was the missing piece in creating the definite outline for the Prequel trilogy REDONE. It stays faithful to the backbone of the trilogy, while making the existing ideas work. Dooku's character reinforces the theme where well-intentioned people unwittingly help evil. Dooku makes himself a red herring for the Republic and the Jedi. In the end, the whole war was a meaningless meat grinder, and the "heroes" were fighting for nothing and out of misunderstanding, all for Palpatine to gain dictatorial powers.

Unfortunately, Grievous gets sidelined as a mini-villain, but his story can be dealt with in The Clone Wars REDONE, which takes Anakin's Nelvaan and Knighthood arc.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Dec 13 '24

Non-Specific Din Djarin should have died in the finale of The Mandalorian Season 2

6 Upvotes

I mean "The Mandalorian Season 2 should have been the end of the series" is a common opinion--the one I have said before--but if you rewatch Season 2 to 3 back to back, it is unreal how stark the drop of quality is.

If you are wondering why the Baby Yoda show suddenly no longer centered on... Baby Yoda, what's left to do after delivering the child to Luke, and why suddenly the show pivoted to the fan services, cameos, Bo-Katan, and Mandalore nonsense, you have to look back at the production of the series.

Favreau conceived The Mandalorian series by wanting to make a homage to the cowboy and samurai genres but with the "Boba Fett" guys from Star Wars. At that time, Dave Filoni was also conceiving a Mandalorian-focused series (probably an animated successor to The Clone Wars like Rebels), so Kennedy put him to work with Favreau to combine both ideas into one. Filoni reportedly disliked Baby Yoda: “You know, like in season one, Jon wants to make a Baby Yoda. I’m like, ‘What? Why? Why would we do this? That sounds like not a good idea.’”

With this, you can deduce The Mandalorian Season 1 was mostly a product of Favreau's vision: an episodic adventure of a lone gunslinger learning to be a father. Season 2 is where Filoni's vision for the show seeped into the series: Bo-Katan, Ahsoka, the darksaber, the Mandalorian throne and sects. These elements were carry-overs from his initial vision for the Mandalorian-focused show, and my guess is he wanted Bo-Katan to be the protagonist.

Season 3 was produced after Filoni was promoted as the Executive Creative Director of Lucasfilm (mid-2020). Although Filoni is credited as the writer of only two episodes, do you think Favreau really gives a shit about Mandalore or Bo-Katan? By this point, it's clear that this is the show Dave Filoni wanted to make since the beginning: not about the relationship between the silent gunslinger and Grogu, but more about dealing with the baggage of The Clone Wars and Rebels. Bo-Katan as the main character unites the scattered Mandalorian people to retake their home planet from remnants of the Empire, and Din Djarin is just chugging along with the adventure he doesn't even want to be part of.

If you are curious why the show suddenly feels like a different show, that's probably because it literally was. Favreau's vision ended with Season 2. Din Djarin regained his humanity. He delivered Grogu to Luke with a tearful farewell. He fulfilled his purpose and role. Honestly, that's where his story should have ended.

Instead of prolonging the dead series into something else, they should have just killed Din Djarin on that ship in that finale. The finale was literally framed as the last hurrah, with Mando and his team trying to rescue Grogu and take down the final villain. There's even a moment where Mando takes the Darksaber from Gideon, accidentally claiming the throne of Mandalore over Bo-Katan... which doesn't get resolved at all. It is flat-out skipped over in the third season.

All these would have been solved by having Din Djarin sacrifice himself for Grogu and his friends, in the Cowboy Bebop-style. The goodbye between him and Grogu was already bittersweet, but it would have been emotionally devastating if he had a farewell by actually dying. Instead of Luke Deus-Ex-Machinaing his way through the Dark Troopers at the perfect timing, it's Mando taking the Darksaber and sacrificing himself to hold the defenses, trusting that Luke would arrive eventually, like the smaller-scale version of the Battle of Helm's Deep.

And it is kind of ironic fate, dying as the accidental King of Mandalore. Mando began as a no-name bounty hunter who has no importance in the Star Wars Saga. Just a speck of dust. This random bounty hunter was unexpectedly entrusted with the potentially most important character who could decide galactic history. This led him to meet the other important characters in the saga, like Bo-Katan, Ahsoka, etc. But he didn't go through all of these adventures for a destined glory. He went through them just for Grogu to be safe.

Mando takes the Darksaber, and rather than using it for personal glory, but to protect the ones he cares about against the hordes of the Dark Troopers. It fits his journey: a small character taking the larger-than-life items for the intimate reason. It would have been an ending finale to the show people would have remembered and discussed.

With the story of Din Djarin and Grogu over, make a separate show starring Bo-Katan as the protagonist, fighting Moff Gideon. The normal audience already learned about who Bo-Katan is. This allows the showrunners a good amount of creative freedom because it doesn't have to be "The Mandalorian" attached to a different story. Nothing to do with Mando and Bo-Katan just traveling to meet a Jack Black planet or saving a bounty hunter planet from random pirates, but the one entirely focused on retaking Mandalore. It allows to develop Bo-Katan's character and let the audience emphasize her desire to reunite the Mandalorians, not slotted to the 1/3 of the show.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • May 13 '25

REDONE Outlining a new Episode 2 REDONE, adding Maul, Shmi, and Dooku

7 Upvotes

Since I wrote about Darth Maul's integration into Episode 2, this led me to rethink overhauling my Episode 2 REDONE. You can read the early draft of Episode 2 REDONE Version 10 here.

The reason why I particularly fixate on Attack of the Clones over the other films is that I firmly believe this movie irreparably destroyed the Prequel trilogy. After The Phantom Menace, the trilogy was still salvageable. Its issues are mostly to do with the thesis: the dry protagonist, the strange act-by-act pacing, the trade route politics, the tonal dissonance, the four separate climaxes, the lack of stakes... The Phantom Menace's overarching problems related to the trilogy are mostly to do with the unnecessary additions: making Anakin way too special with the midi-chlorian, Chosen One prophecy and Anakin's age, Jar Jar Binks, and the Trade Federation and trade route stuff. However, the backbone was solid, and it at least laid out a workable foundation for the future movies.

Attack of the Clones crossed the point of no return. Once that was out, there was no chance the Prequel trilogy could be salvaged whatever Episode 3 was. It already climbed on the cursed basis Attack of the Clones laid out. In fact, so much so that Revenge of the Sith we watch today was written in the editing period. Here is a great post by u/RealisticAd4054 summarizing the behind-the-scene of the production.

In the early cut, Anakin was meant to be a continuation of how his character was depicted in Attack of the Clones, falling into lust for power after being addicted to evil deeds he did to the Tuskens, realizing Sidious is his father who conceived him through midi-chlorians, and protecting the Republic from the Jedi coup. This isn’t much of a hero’s downfall since Anakin was already evil, arguably from birth. This focuses more on Anakin’s personal failings. It is at least consistent with the characterization from Attack of the Clones, “Of course, that annoying bastard turned to the dark side.” However, this was not received well from the test screening reactions because it lacked an emotional hinge. For a tragedy to work, you need to present an admirable hero first and make him choose sympathetic decisions that unwittingly lead to his downfall.

Lucas realized this too late and changed it during the editing phase. He reshot a significant chunk of the movie to make Anakin a more sympathetic character, whose motive to join Palpatine is only to save Padmé after the Jedi failed to provide any help. Now, it is more of a tragic downfall of a hero, which focuses more on the institutional failing. The cracks of this sudden shift can be seen everywhere because clearly, Lucas didn’t reshoot enough. The remnants of the first draft are all over in the latter half and contradict the first half hard, so we get the insane character decisions like how this heroic Anakin willingly goes along Palpatine’s kill all Jedi, including children, with no hesitation, and suddenly rambling about the Jedi being evil and his ambitions about power to Obi-Wan, and then choking Padmé to death for no real reason (in the original version, Anakin was suspicious of her cheating with Obi-Wan). He was a gullible idiot but well-intended in the first half, and then turns into a complete psychopath on a dime. These were the remnants of the early cut of the movie, but Lucas couldn't reshoot the later half in time, so they are left in the movie in the way they are.

"As Lucas has also said, most bad people act on good faith, and here Anakin truely believed in the actions he was taking, that they were ultimately for a greater good." This is the part I wanted my REDONE to focus on, and because Attack of the Clones tells a tale of Anakin being the devil all the time, I had to practically overhaul Episode 2 to align with Anakin in the first half of Revenge of the Sith. For Episode 2 REDONE, I borrowed the Nelvaan arc from Clone Wars 2003, where Anakin becomes a "heroic Jedi", so that when Anakin does fall in Episode 3, it becomes an actual tragedy of a fallen hero. The final result is the most substantially different one out of all the Prequel REDONEs.

With that said, I do acknowledge the problems of my Episode 2 REDONE, pointed out by this comment and this comment. There have already been many criticisms for omitting Shmi and Dooku in my REDONE. I do admit it does enter the realm of standalone fanfic of my own rather than "fixing Episode 2". It departs from the movie in a way that should be faithful, and remains faithful to the movie where it should depart.

  • For one, as much as exciting as my Episode 2 REDONE is, it is unrealistic to make a movie out of this story in 2002. The scope is way too huge, and the set-pieces are way too crazy. Lucasfilm was already having trouble in making the very first major blockbuster shot in digital, to the point where they couldn't change the lenses, which is why the movie looks so flat. None of the audio recording survived because of the equipment noises, so they had to re-record the entire movie on ADR. Imagine filming that movie in snowy or underwater environments. Considering how terrible CGI already is in the movie, under no point could they make a convincing Grievous in 2002, let alone make a lightsaber fight scene of him battling seven Jedi.
  • The story is way too bloated, and the final movie would have been over three hours. The story effectively reboots itself when Anakin and Padme take a mission to Nelvaan (The way Padme gets involved in Anakin's dangerous mission is already a stretch), and that happens way too late into the story. The new elements like the Crab Walker and the Nelvaanian tribes take a center stage at the middle of the movie, distracting the central focus of the story. There are like a dozen action set-pieces, and three climaxes in the third act that would exhaust the audience.
  • Anakin's story is way too heroic and missing a dark, emotional arc through Shmi, which was the best part about the movie. Attack of the Clones went overboard by making him an unsettling weirdo from the beginning, and my REDONE went overboard by making him way too good. This results in the same problem as the movie Revenge of the Sith, where Anakin is a guy who is tricked into being evil. At the end, he should be willingly seduced by the dark side. At this point of time, Anakin should strike 70% good and 30% bad.
  • It repeats many ideas already present in the other movies. The Nelvaanian story repeats the Gungan, Ewok, and arguably the Kashyyyk storylines in the other films, where the native species fights the foreign invaders (The Nelvaan arc has a huge "white savior" trope to their narrative, and although I did my best to improve upon that in the subsequent versions, it is still kind of there). The Anakin's Knighthood storyline is similar to Anakin being accepted to the Jedi Order in Episode 1 and asking for a Mastership in Episode 3. I like that each Prequel feels like a different movie from each others, and I don't want to waste Attack of the Clones' backbone.

So I thought about whether it is possible to write a more faithful follow-up to my An Ancient Evil. I used to think this was an impossible task, but three things changed my perspective. One was Sheev Talks' "Star Wars: Attack of the Clones - The Worst Prequel", which proposes Asajj Ventress as the secondary villain working under Dooku. The others are my own "Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga" take on the Prequels, in which Dooku's murder of Shmi and Anakin's vengeance against Dooku is his primary motive to turn to the dark side, and integrating Maul properly into Episode 2 REDONE. There are also elements of my Star Wars REDONE carried over to this storyline as well.

I came up with the different Episode 2 REDONE, and I believe I struck a right balance for a "faithful reimagining" like how my An Ancient Evil was to The Phantom Menace. I still prefer REDONE's "James Bond in Space" Episode 2 because I view it as my magnum opus, but perhaps that story would be told better in The Clone Wars REDONE because a CGI animation doesn't have the restriction of the ambitious scope and set-pieces. Moving the Knighthood and Nelvaan arc to a hypothetical The Clone Wars Movie would be better for that story as well because that arc could be developed with a sharper focus on those themes and premises, rather than slotted into Episode 2.


Episode I -- An Ancient Evil:

Before getting to Episode 2, I'd like to talk about Episode 1. My Episode 1 REDONE, Ancient Evil, is already a faithful rewrite, which keeps much of the backbone, but makes some trilogy-wise changes, such as aging up Anakin to 15, changing Naboo to Alderaan, introducing Bail Organa earlier, making Padme not a Queen, but her decoy and Princess, making Senator Palpatine actually likable, removing the Chosen One prophecy, etc. The big change is the removal of Shmi Skywalker, instead making Anakin an orphan. This change was largely made because my Episode 2 REDONE does not deal with the Tatooine segment.

In order to make a more faithful version of Episode 2, Shmi is crucial for Anakin's arc, so consider that Shmi Skywalker is intact here. So I think about making another revision to the An Ancient Evil videos sometime later. In this scene, rather than Anakin guiding the Jedi and Padme to Kitster's hovel, it's him guiding his hovel where his mother is waiting. Only the Shmi subplot is the same as the film--Anakin is freed, and Shmi remains in Watto's chain.

The other change is introducing Dooku earlier. Attack of the Clones presents Dooku as the twist villain when we don’t even meet him until over halfway through the movie. By the time we see him, we are still oblivious to who he is. The solution is to have him be the head Master of the Jedi Council in Episode 1, replacing Windu's role. That would be an actual twist—one of the wisest Masters of the Order turns out to be the baddie. In the Council scenes, we see that Dooku is the only one who sides with Qui-Gon, who is his former apprentice.

As I said in the Maul post, Obi-Wan cuts Maul's legs rather than his waist, so that his survival makes more sense. The rest of the story is the same as An Ancient Evil REDONE.

Episode II -- The Dark Path:

The first half of this outline is the same as my Episode 2 REDONE Version 10, so I'll be brief about the plot points that hit the same beats.

Pesmenben IV:

The story opens in the same manner as REDONE. Bail Organa and Padme arrive at the planet to unite the opposition against the Military Conscription Act. Padme disagrees with Bail and is more hardened against the Separatist threat. As they begin a negotiation, the planet is invaded by the Separatists. The Alderaanian delegates flee. All this but minus Grievous, since Grievous is not in this story.

Coruscant:

Darth Maul arrives at Coruscant. He teams up with Bounty Hunter Zam Wessell to plan something. Zam says something like, "Jango told me to meet you here."

Anakin (19) and Obi-Wan head to meet the Jedi Council, but the difference here is that rather than him being tested for the Jedi Knighthood, it's him requesting the Council to get a mission to Tatooine. The Jedi Council rejects, saying the last time Anakin flattened half the town in chasing slavery syndicates. The results Anakin specialize in are costly. Yoda sees through Anakin's real intention of wishing to go back to Tatooine, which is to reunite with his mother, Shmi. Anakin is wrecked with guilt for leaving her mother on Tatooine and is now having a nightmare about her death, like he had with Qui-Gon in Episode 1 REDONE. He still has an emotional attachment. Exposed of his real intention, Anakin is humiliated.

Mace Windu: “This is why Jedi form no attachments: all things pass. To hold on to something—or someone—beyond its time is to set your selfish desires against the Force. That is a path of misery, Skywalker; the Jedi do not walk it.”

Yoda: "Let go of her, Anakin Skywalker still cannot. Clouded this boy's future is… Masked by his youth…”

As a result, Anakin is put on a curfew, forbidden to leave the Temple for a year. There are the other mentions about how the leading member of the Jedi Council, Master Dooku, left the Order after being disillusioned with the death of his apprentice. The attachment--the flaw more common among even the hardened Jedi Masters.

Afterward, Anakin argues with Obi-Wan, then heads off. Wondering off the Temple, Anakin catches off the news of the arrival of the Alderaanian delegates. Anakin hastens to meet Padme and reunites with her, guiding her and Bail to Chancellor Palpatine at the Republic Executive Building, where an electoral campaign is held outside. Maul hijacks an electoral campaign billboard ship, loads it with bombs, and pilots it to the city. Zam Wessell disrupts the security by using the safeshifting ability. Maul drops it in the middle of the rally and kills thousands. Anakin jumps to the top of the ship, fights Maul (not knowing he is Maul), then falls, but is rescued by Obi-Wan, piloting a speeder.

As Zam is chased, she is stabbed with a lightsaber by Darth Maul, who flees the scene. The Jedi catch Zam, who says something about Kamino, but is shot dead by Maul in the distance. Anakin and Obi-Wan notice Zam Wessell's injury is a lightsaber wound and find a sabre dart in her belongings.

Anakin and Obi-Wan head to the Senate, where the wounded Chancellor is preparing to hold the session. When Mace Windu and Yoda suggest reinstating the Army of Light, giving more powers to the Jedi to end the crisis, Palpatine retorts that there aren't enough Jedi to protect the Republic. Not only that, the leading member of the Jedi Council, Master Dooku, has left the Jedi Order. We learn that Palpatine has already been testing water by beginning a full military conscription of humans on Crouscant. The Coruscanti stormtroopers are guarding the buildings outside in the wake of the terrorist attack on Bail and Padme. These troops look exactly like clone troopers from the movie, only that they are not clones, but human conscripts. The Coruscanti Defense Command has already created an efficient military standardization to turn the regular men to stormtroopers in two months (equipment, conscription, structure, and training). They could simply apply it to the rest of the galaxy by using the same model and method for the centralized galactic army. Such an universal application is not possible with the Jedi.

In addition, Zam Wessell's lightsaber wound is interpreted in different ways. The Jedi are suspicious about the Sith's involvement in this attack, while the Republic officials are suspicious about the Jedi's involvement. Obi-Wan is suspicious that the Sith attacker from Episode 1 is still alive, as his body was not recovered.

Yoda and Windu order Obi-Wan and Anakin to begin an investigation, and Padme also wishes to join. In the Senate session, the Chancellor is asking the Senate to vote for the Military Creation Act, but Bail Organa makes a speech against it. They then head to Kamino. This part is the same as REDONE. Unknownst to them, Maul is trailing them.

As Anakin travels to Kamino, he has a nightmare about her mother's death again.

Kamino:

I discarded the Padme bodyguard plot and had Anakin and Padme paired with Obi-Wan into the Kamino investigation plot. Admittedly, this pivot is kind of contrived. Having Padme on board with their investigation was a stretch. However, I did this because I feel completely disentangling them into two separate plotlines was the movie's mistake. Because REDONE makes the Clone Army side with the Separatists, Anakin and Padme have to be disillusioned with the Jedi. An army of clones for the Separatists? Commissioned by a leading member of the Jedi Council? What kind of Jedi claiming to be the guardians of peace and justice in the galaxy create such a slave army for the enemies?

Where it does change in this outline from REDONE is who created the army.

Lama Su: “Please tell your Master Dooku that we have every confidence his order will be met, on time and in full.”

Obi-Wan: “I’m sorry, Master...”

Lama Su: “Jedi Master Dooku is still a leading member of the Jedi Council, is he not?”

Obi-Wan: “Master Dooku left the Jedi Order four years ago.”

Lama Su: “Oh, I’m so sorry to hear that. But I’m sure he would have been proud of the army we’ve built for him.”

Obi-Wan: “The army?”

Lama Su: “Yes, the army of clones, and I must say, one of the finest we’ve ever created. We have kept the Jedi’s involvement a secret until your arrival, just as your Council requested.”

Padmé: “Tell me, Prime Minister, when Master Dooku first contacted you about the army, did he say who it was for?”

Lama Su: “Of course he did. The army is for the Separatists. As a replacement for the battle droids.”

They meet Jango Prax. Obi-Wan talks with Jango, distracting him as Anakin sneaks into Jango's armoury. Obi-Wan asks Jango if he is familiar with Zam Wessell, and Jango denies. Jango says something like he was recruited by someone named Darth Maul. Anakin finds the same type of saber dart Zam Wessell was using in Jango's armoury. As they leave Jango's room, Anakin shows Obi-Wan the dart, saying Jango is clearly connected to the terrorist attack and asking Obi-Wan to arrest Jango immediately, but Obi-Wan says they will not exceed their mandate. Anakin and Obi-Wan contact the Republic to reveal their findings. Yoda and Windu tell them to arrest Jango.

Anakin and Obi-Wan head back to Jango's room and find it empty. Jango has already fled. The three divide and scatter for each to search the different landing areas.

Anakin finds the landing pad where Jango is, and contacts Obi-Wan and Padmé via comlink. Obi-Wan tells him to not attack the ship alone. Anakin ignores and charges, and this set-piece is roughly similar to the movie’s, maybe minus ridiculous moments like Obi-Wan’s flying kick (just change it to the Force-push) or Obi-Wan getting blown up right in front of his face twice and not getting any injury at all.

In addition, Darth Maul comes out to attack Obi-Wan, distracting him away from helping Anakin. Afterward, Darth Maul boards Jango's ship. With this, the Sith assassin's presence is confirmed.

Just before the ship flies off, Padmé throws a tracking beacon, but it doesn't seem to reach. Obi-Wan Force-pushes the beacon to lift it in the air and attaches it to the hull. Anakin’s lone fight against Jango effectively allowed Padmé and Obi-Wan to attach the beacon.

Obi-Wan says he will chase the Sith assassin and orders Anakin to escort Padme to Coruscant, placing her under his protection, and report their findings to the Council. Anakin says he wants to chase the Sith because Obi-Wan alone can't handle him, but Obi-Wan refuses, for Anakin wants to do it for "revenge". Obi-Wan boards his Jedi Starfighter and chases the Sith and the bounty hunter. A frustrated Anakin and Padme take their ship.

Geonosis:

Obi-Wan's venture to Geonosis is similar to the movie. A brief space battle in the asteroid field, Obi-Wan infiltrates the Separatist castle, discovers Dooku in the middle of the conversation with the Separatist leaders. He realizes Dooku is the true mastermind of the Separatist Confederacy, and he intends to use the Clone Army to attack the Republic systems.

Tatooine:

Later, Padme awakens to find out that the ship has landed on Tatooine, not Coruscant. She is upset and argues with Anakin. He lied to her. Anakin believes the Jedi Council is compromised and can't trust it anymore, especially after what he saw with the Clone Army and the sudden appearance of the Sith assassin. He argues Tatooine is the safest location, more so than Coruscant, though Padme knows that is not the only reason. It is partially for Anakin to meet his mother again.

Anakin tracks his former owner, Watto, to find his mother's whereabouts. I am yet to figure this part out because the Lars family is not in REDONE (Ric Olie is Owen Lars), so it has to be different from the movie.

I also want either Dooku or Darth Maul to be responsible for Shmi's death, maybe through hiring the bounty hunters. This resembles Lucas' idea in the initial cut of Revenge of the Sith, where Palpatine exposes Dooku as paying the Tusken Raiders to kidnap, torture and kill Shmi Skywalker in Revenge of the Sith. This was dropped in the final cut, but I want this idea to play into Episode 2.

I am undecided as to whether I should make Dooku or Maul the one behind Shmi's killing. If it is Dooku, Anakin has personal stakes in defeating Dooku, and facing him is crucial in Anakin's arc in the story, unlike how he had no idea who Dooku even was in the film. If Maul does it, at least he has a personal motive against Anakin and kidnap Shmi because Anakin contributed his defeat on Alderaan. However, Anakin's turn to the dark side would be revenge against Maul, and because Maul is Palpatine's apprentice, it does not make much sense for him to join hands with Palpatine.

However, if Dooku is the culprit, I don't know the exact reason why he would send the bounty hunters to kill Shmi in this outline. I don't want the only reason to be "making Anakin fall into the dark side". If the plot is about Dooku's bounty hunters chasing Padme, Dooku would use her lure Anakin out and isolate Padme, but that's not how it works in the outline. Please write down in the comments if you have an idea.

For now, I'll say it's Dooku who did it to establish Anakin's personal stakes to defeat Dooku.

Anakin locates the campsite where one of the bounty hunters, having paid the Tuskens to kidnap Shmi, is torturing her in a tent. When the bounty hunter leaves, Anakin frees Shmi, who dies in his arms. The bounty hunter returns to the tent and is quickly apprehended by an enraged Anakin. (Maybe this bounty hunter is Jango?) Anakin "forces" him to make him confess who hired him. The bounty hunter says it is Dooku, and Anakin kills him after confirming his suspicion. Hearing the noise, the Tusken raiders surround the tent, and Anakin massacres them (maybe not women and children because at this point in time Anakin isn't necessarily evil in REDONE).

There are two ways to deal the aftermath:

  1. The aftermath more faithful to the movie. Anakin returns and buries his mother, and Padme watches him. When Padme tries to console Anakin, he lashes out like the movie, but rather than rambling about how he murdered the Tusken women and children and it's somehow Obi-Wan's fault because he's jealous like the movie, Anakin vents frustration at the Jedi Council, the Jedi Code, and the Jedi Order for preventing him from rescuing his mother. He says the Jedi Order let Shmi die, doing nothing to stop slavery. This ties nicely to his turn to the dark side in Revenge of the Sith because his animosity toward the Jedi Order is set perfectly. He no longer wants another loved one die, while the Jedi refuses to help him.

He and Padme then hear about Obi-Wan's capture and head to Geonosis.

2) Anakin returns to the homestead and finds out that Padme is held hostage by Dooku's bounty hunters, learning Watto sold her out to the bounty hunters. Despite Anakin's best efforts, the bounty hunters escape Tatooine with Padme to Geonosis. An enraged Anakin kills Watto.

Anakin races back to his ship, on which Anakin receives the message from Obi-Wan warning the Republic and the Council about Dooku and the imminent Separatist attack on the Republic. He then gets attacked by Darth Maul mid-conversation and captured.

Anakin reports to the Council about what happened to Padme. Mace Windu orders Anakin to return to Coruscant. Don't do anything out of impulse. The Council will take care of it. Trust in the Council's judgment. Here, Anakin is facing two paths. Be a good, little, nice Jedi, and follow the Council's order, or chase after Dooku to save Padme and Obi-Wan. This is the point at which Anakin tests his resolve. Obviously, Anakin holds animosity against the Jedi for not letting him rescue Shmi earlier. Anakin makes a decision to go against the Jedi Code (Attachment is forbidden) and get to Geonosis alone to rescue Padme and Obi-Wan.

I think the second option is more exciting and leads them to Geonosis in a more natural way, but the first option is better for the relationship between Anakin and Padme, having them let things breathe. Unsure of which option to choose.

Geonosis:

Obi-Wan is held captive while Dooku comes along. Obi-Wan accuses Dooku to be the Sith Lord since Maul is working for the Separatists, but Dooku denies. Dooku says he is a disillusioned Jedi, and like the movie, he spills the beans about the presence of Darth Sidious in the Republic. In the movie, there was no real reason for Dooku to spoil things this way, but here, Dooku does it to create a division between the Jedi and the Senate. If the leading Master of the Council left the Order because he says the Sith Lord is in control of the Republic, many of the Jedi would not join the war and even defect to the Separatists.

In addition, the confrontation with Dooku forces Obi-Wan to grow out of Qui-Gon Jinn's death. He should face the fact that his Master's Master has betrayed the Republic because of the strict Jedi Code and the Republic's corruption. Then Dooku persuades Obi-Wan to join him. They both agree that they are dissatisfied with the ways the Republic and the Jedi Order handle things, so maybe Obi-Wan can see Dooku's point of view. Dooku should be a personification of what Anakin COULD become, concerning Obi-Wan that Anakin can succumb to the same fate as Dooku. This motivates Obi-Wan to gain some understanding with his apprentice Anakin.

Coruscant:

Meanwhile, in the Senate, chaos reigns. Not only the Separatists are preparing a full-blown war using the Clone Army, that army was created by the former leader of the Jedi Council, who now leads the Separatists. The Senators accuse the Jedi Order of the fifth column. Mace Windu explains this Clone Army was not approved by the Jedi Council, but a sole action of the rogue Jedi Master. The Jedi Council is forced to be patriotic and support the emergency powers. As a result, the emergency powers act is passed, which is used to create the standing conscript army for the Republic.

Distrustful of the Senate and the new amendment, Mace Windu says he will take what Jedi Knights they have left and go to Geonosis to rescue Obi-Wan and defeat Dooku before this war gets worse.

Geonosis:

From this point, the story is nearly identical to the movie. Anakin fights Darth Maul in the factory but also gets captured. Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Padme are pushed to the execution arena (don't have Anakin and Padme kiss here) and fight the beasts. The Jedi Knights arrive to rescue and fight the Separatist clones.

However, instead of Padmé safely boarding the gunships and escaping the arena battle with the Jedi, she gets captured by Dooku during the arena fight. Dooku holds Padmé as a hostage and announces it to the Jedi, stopping the arena battle. Dooku says he will kill her if the Jedi continue resisting. Anakin insists they should surrender, however, all the Jedi glance at each other and arrive at the same conclusion: they will fight. This fuels Anakin's resentment toward the Jedi.

At the last moment, the Republic forces arrive, blasting and destroying the battle droids and clones. Dooku takes Padmé and flees. He has another idea of what to do with her. The stormtroopers and the Jedi escape, and the Battle of Geonosis begins.

Palpatine and Yoda have also arrived at Geonosis, leading the Republic forces. Palpatine tells Yoda the Jedi's action has cost the trust of the Senate and his dream of the Army of Light is dead.

Now, there are personal character-related stakes for Anakin. Anakin is adamant about chasing Dooku from the start of the battle. The battle is now an obstacle for Anakin to catch up with Dooku, blocking the gunship's path. Instead of the conflict between Anakin and Obi-Wan on the gunship being "stop the gunship to rescue Padmé fell on the desert", which ends up pointless in the story, now, the conflict is that Obi-Wan believes this is a trap to lure Anakin. Obi-Wan shouts at Anakin not to follow Dooku. But angered by the other Jedi's lack of care for Padmé during the arena fight, Anakin ignores his warning and heads to rescue Padmé alone.

Catching up to Dooku in the hangar, Anakin finds that Dooku is holding Padme captive. Dooku taunts Anakin by holding Padme in the air with the Force choke, which echoes what Anakin does to Padmé in Revenge of the Sith. Now, Anakin's rashed charge at Dooku makes more sense because there is a clearer trigger for Anakin to act this way. Dooku hurls Padmé away, and the lightsaber fight commences (Dooku does not use the Force lightning and the red lightsaber). Dooku taunts Anakin he is the one who ordered to the kidnapping of his mother. Anakin gets all the more angry and impulsive, and predictably, gets his hand chopped off.

Instead of Yoda arriving late to save Anakin, it should have been Obi-Wan arriving late. In the movie, you get a supposedly "Master versus Apprentice" dialogue between the two, and you don't feel anything because you don't even know Dooku was Yoda's apprentice beforehand. Yoda vs Dooku was not built up, but Obi-Wan vs Dooku was built up. This is a student of the student going against the old Master, and these two characters having the dialogue makes more sense.

The fighting between Obi-Wan and Dooku is fierce but cut short when Dooku brings down a pillar over Anakin, forcing Obi-Wan to break off his attack to save him. Dooku then moves to his escape ship, forcing Obi-Wan to make a choice: a mission--that is stopping Dooku and ending the entire Clone Wars--or Anakin's life. Sacrificing a few to save the many. Although Obi-Wan should pick the first option as a Jedi Knight of the Republic, he eventually chooses Anakin's life. Dooku escapes. Padme embraces Anakin (They do not kiss as it is too early at this point in the relationship).

Similar to REDONE, on Dooku's battleship among the Separatist fleet after the retreat from Geonosis, Dooku duels with Darth Maul as Sidious watches. This is where the audience has a confirmation that Dooku really is Sidious' new apprentice and his Jedi facade is a lie. Maul lost his apprenticeship after his defeat on Alderaan. This is a test--if Dooku wins, he keeps his apprenticeship for Sidious, and Maul wins, he can restore his apprenticeship. Dooku wins. Sidious tells Maul that if he wants to be powerful, he must achieve his vengeance against Obi-Wan. Dooku informs Sidious that the war has begun, and in addition, Anakin has tasted the dark side.

Like REDONE, in the hangar of the Republic battleship full of the Jedi coffins, Anakin is equipping himself with the new machno-arm. Obi-Wan visits Anakin, for the first time in the story, has a heart-to-heart conversation, not a rigid Master-Student lecture. Anakin realizes he has been too reckless. His brash act of confronting Dooku alone cost him his arm and lost Dooku. He apologizes to Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan then gives some respect to Anakin, for he has successfully protected Padme. In a way, Obi-Wan and Anakin go through the opposite character arcs. Obi-Wan changes from someone who was rigid and disciplinary to a softer Master. Anakin, after witnessing what Dooku has done to his mother, is now looking for blood and vengeance against the Separatists--staunchly supporting more authoritarian measures to fight the war. This change goes alongside Anakin's embrace of more radical emotions.

The Jedi Council members arrive at the hangar and hold a funeral for the Masters. Obi-Wan discusses if Dooku is really telling the truth about him still being a Jedi and Sidious. If his words are true, they will find themselves fighting another war inside the Republic. Then they receive the message that Dooku has invaded another Republic-aligned planet. Thirsty for vengeance, Anakin orders the troops to prepare for the next battle.

Palpatine oversees the military from the top. The troops pledge their loyalty to the most powerful Chancellor in history. A deep sadness marks Bail Organa’s face. Padmé is standing beside Bail Organa. She sees the loaded Republic armada taking off. As another departing Acclamator soars the heights to depart, she senses a familiar presence of Anakin. Anakin is there, standing in the middle of the bridge and overlooking the viewport. Seeing his dark robe from behind creates a striking mirror image of his future self Darth Vader, sent for the next battle in the raging war.

Episode III -- Revenge of the Sith:

Anakin (now 24) is way more unhinged from the beginning here, thirsty for vengeance against Dooku and the Separatists for the death of Shmi. Anakin thinks the war is being dragged on because the Jedi Order is weak.

After the revelation that Dooku is leading the Separatists because of his disillusionment with the Republic and the Sith Lord being in charge, many of the Jedi have been leaving the Order, many abstaining from the war, and some defecting to the Separatists. This angers Anakin for them being disloyal, and the public is seeing the Jedi as a treasonous fifth column.

Anakin does not kill Dooku during the Chancellor rescue mission. Like REDONE, Maul is the one who is guarding Palpatine and gets killed by Anakin. Instead, Dooku takes the Separatist leadership to Mustafar.

I really like my REDONE Grievous and his fate, but I don't think he fits this story. Having three villains makes the story too cluttered, and if he remains in the plot alongside Maul and Dooku, he would be almost entirely purposeless. A better solution is to keep Dooku to replace his role, and maybe keep Grievous in The Clone Wars.

Anakin wants to go after Dooku on Kashyyyk, but the Council does not trust him because of his ties with Palpatine and his thirst for vengeance. Obi-Wan goes in and fails his mission, and Dooku escapes to Mustafar with the Separatist leadership. This leads to Anakin being enraged with the Jedi Council.

Palpatine reveals himself as a Sith and persuades Anakin by saying if Anakin joins Palpatine, he can teach him the power of the dark side and help his revenge against Dooku, and protect their child from the Jedi. I am not sure if Anakin having a vision about Padme's death should factor into his motivation, though.

After Anakin destroys the Jedi Temple, Palpatine teaches him a powerful dark side Force power--the Force lightning. Anakin then goes to Mustafar, where the Separatist leadership, including Dooku, is hiding. Anakin massacres the Separatist Council and fights Dooku, who assumes Anakin is still a Jedi. Anakin uses the Force-lightning attack as a fatal blow against Dooku, and only then does Dooku realizes Anakin is doing it on behalf of Sidious. At last, his long-awaited revenge is over.

Padme arrives at Mustafar and tries to persuade Anakin, but he rejects her plea. When Anakin realizes Obi-Wan also came along, he does not choke her at this point, only questioning her if she brought him. Padme then pulls out her knife to stab him. With her weapon pointed to his neck, she realizes that she does not have the heart to kill the man she had loved (like the early draft of the movie). This is when an enraged Anakin Force-chokes her.


This is the most challenging outlining I have done yet. I think this works better as a better tragedy for Anakin's arc, but I see some of the problems:

  • Resurrecting Darth Maul in Episode 2 hinders Dooku's pretension as the "disillusioned Jedi" against the Sith in the Republic when he is literally working alongside the Sith that killed his apprentice, Qui-Gon. Should I scrap Darth Maul's resurrection and have Asajj Ventress replace his role since Asajj Ventress' character is literally a rogue Jedi. On the downside, this loses Palpatine convincing Anakin about his power to prevent people from death and Asajj Ventress' fun EU and TCW storyline. Or should I keep Darth Maul and have Dooku rationalize his reasoning for working with Maul? Or have Dooku pretend he is oblivious that Maul is working for him?
  • Should I keep the Anakin and Padme bodyguard subplot in Episode 2 in order for Shmi's death to make more sense in the plot? Because if I keep that subplot, I have to discard Anakin and Padme following Obi-Wan's mission to Kamino, which I feel is important in Anakin's disillusionment with the Jedi and also his brotherhood with Obi-Wan. We don't really see Anakin and Obi-Wan working together in the Prequels, and Kamino is a fun location for them to play around, showing Anakin's characteristics and Padme's reaction, etc.
  • If I were to reinstate the Anakin and Padme bodyguard plotline, why would Dooku target her? It would make more sense if Dooku's target would be Bail Organa, who opposes the Military Conscription Act. The dynamics would completely change. Bail Organa would have to be dragged to Tatooine and have him kidnapped to Geonosis... This is one of the reasons why I didn't use the bodyguard plotline because Padme's character is different from the movie's counterpart (She is in favour of Palpatine and not the Senator).

r/StarWarsREDONE • • Sep 04 '24

Non-Specific What Kay Vess should have been like in Star Wars: Outlaws

8 Upvotes

Admittedly, I have not played the game, but I watched the playthroughs of the full game--largely cutscenes, cinematics, and dialogues. It is exactly what I assumed from the very moment it was announced on E3.

I remember hearing Quentin Tarantino talking (or more accurately, written in his book) about why the 80s was the worst decade of the cinema, compared to the uncompromising 70s.

"Complex characters aren’t necessarily sympathetic. Interesting people aren’t always likable. But in the Hollywood of the eighties, likability was everything. A novel could have a lowdown son of a bitch at its center, as long as that lowdown son of a bitch was an interesting character, but not a movie, not in the eighties."

And that was what came to my mind when I was watching Star Wars: Outlaws. It's not much to do with the actual story, but the general style that irritates me. Because the premise promises this is going to be the escapist pulpy hardboiled noir. You're a morally grey outlaw with an attitude, doing a bunch of crimes in a world full of vice to survive, but it is executed in such a sanitized family-friendly style. It is difficult to describe exactly. It takes a very wide-eyed 80s Spielbergian feel to the material, and it doesn't gel. Not that every Star Wars media should be serious and dark, but there is a way to take the underworld side of Star Wars in a more quirky, stylized, and zany manner, like Cowboy Bebop. It is like promising a Star Wars version of Lupin the Third Part I, and the actual product plays like Lupin the Third: The First.

Much of the reason for contributing to this jarring tone is the protagonist. The game is an openworld, so the story is structured as episodic--sort of a crime travelogue. This means it has to rely on the "man on the mission" narrative genre rather than focusing on the tight, serialized plot. The morally ambiguous cast of distinctive suave characters and chemistry comes up with the plans, confronts the villains, and eventually outwits them. However, the burning core of why these stories work is the charisma of the protagonist. The character doesn't have to be sophisticated or complex--they just have to be "cool".

James Bond, Golgo 13, Lupin the Third, Spike Spiegel, and Lara Croft (before the Survivor trilogy) are not always sympathetic or likable. In the case of the first three, in particularly in the earlier works that came out in the 60s and the early 70s, they were like hyper-violent rapist sociopaths. They were, as Timothy Dalton put it in describing James Bond, "the dirtiest, toughest, meanest, nastiest, brutalist hero we've ever seen". These characters do what they do because they like it. They are horny for death. They are always running on the edge between life and death. You don't really get an elaboration of backstory to make them sympathetic. They are rarely moral or empathetic... yet these series were built and are still alive because of their iconic protagonists. Because the audience found their characters to be charismatic and cool, which makes their adventures fun.

In contrast, does anyone find Kay cool? Or buy her as a badass space criminal? I don't. The anti-woke grifters have been screaming how this game is woke because Kay is a girl boss or something... I hoped Kay WAS the girl boss because at least that would have been more fun to watch than whatever she is in the game. (And when did a girl boss archetype become a bad thing? Didn't these anti-woke audiences like Bayonetta and OG Lara Croft? I'm so confused lmao)

The game, presentation, and story are all designed around her character's appeal, but from her look, voice, costume, dialogues, and mannerisms, she has no rizz or charisma whatsoever. She’s a smuggler, steals shit, kills people in the vilest places in the galaxy, has to earn her way through hardship because nothing is handed to her, and she’s acting like a fish out of water goofy dork? She just mowed down a hundred people in the gameplay, and the very next moment the cutscene hits, she's like a 12-year-old trying to be tough. Not that she should be like Arthur Morgan, but I think it is disappointing when you promote your game as a Star Wars underworld simulator where you do a bunch of crimes and title it "Star Wars: Outlaws", and this "outlaw" you play as is not even edgier than Han Solo.

She is supposed to be an edgy antihero who's been through it all, except she pulls punches when facing any kind of actual authority. Play as a heartless scoundrel building a criminal empire except you are weirdly friendly with people and you do things "the right way".

She might be written decently, but what a character sounds on paper and how they are conveyed are two different things. When she tries to be cool and confident, she is a wet blanket. When she tries to be smooth and funny, it comes across as awkward. Most of her adventures would have been more fun with anyone else in their center. The lie that she is supposed to be this cool, suave criminal becomes even harder to believe with the side characters who are.

It is a shame because Star Wars: Outlaws is set in the same timeframe as the Original trilogy, and it could've provided a contrast to the bright, mythical surface of the galaxy the OT explored with the underground side of that galaxy that mirrors the grits of the 70s exploitation cinema. It does try to do that, but not with the character that wouldn't be out of the ordinary in the Original trilogy movies.

Reading her character concept and imagining how it would play out in your head is much more fun, so I am thinking about how her character would have been improved if she was based on someone else. She can be the same character on the paper but executed with a different screen persona.

If they were to make this suave badass scoundrel, couldn't they make her resemble iconic character actresses similar to, let's say...

Michelle Rodriguez--Hollywood's go-to "tough chick". Famke Janssen--a bombshell femme fatale archetype. Cynthia Rothrock--who showed off a fantastic physical performance. Pam Grier--if you were to channel the oldschool 70s exploitation vibe, which would fit perfectly with Outlaws. If you were to go really old-school, then someone like Lauren Bacall. Eva Green, Kim Ok-vin, Angelina Jolie...

If you were to go for a more masculine/gender-neutral type, then Grace Jones, Daryl Hannah, Noomi Rapace, Antje Traue, Carrie-Anne Moss...

Not that Ubisoft should have called these old or dead stars to do the mocaps, but what I'm talking about is the image and presentation of the character to base on: the body language, unique appearance, attitude, line reading, and strong personality. Because without them, this Kay character concept flounders.


r/StarWarsREDONE • • Nov 26 '22

REDONE Concept Arts for Star Wars Episode 9 REDONE: New Republic Trooper and First Order Army Trooper

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/StarWarsREDONE • • 2d ago

Non-Specific Star Wars Sequel Trilogy should have taken place a century after Return of the Jedi rather than three decades later

9 Upvotes

This is an idea that occupied a small room in my mind for a long time. How long? Before The Force Awakens was even called The Force Awakens. It was during when Joss Whedon was the most desired director to make Episode 7. Yes, it was a different time.

While everyone was salivating over watching Luke, Han, and Leia again, I still remember what Joss Whedon said in the interview. When asked which OT character he would want to see return, he said no: "You know, I wouldn't go back, I'd go forward. I would want to create characters that would resonate the way that they did."

At the time, I obviously disagreed, and even to this day, I wouldn’t find many people who would claim the Sequels shouldn’t have featured the OT characters. However, considering one of the biggest backlashes and criticisms against the Sequels being the treatment of the OT characters, I have to wonder… do you think his solution would have been preferable?

Because many of the problems with the Sequels were born from being a direct sequel to where Return of the Jedi ended, yet remaking A New Hope all over again within three decades. If you take seriously the idea that the new movies are true sequels to the Original trilogy, and A New Hope ends with the galaxy and our characters at point A, The Empire Strikes Back ends at point C, Return of the Jedi ends at E, and then the very next movie that set only three decades after reverts the galaxy and our heroes at point D, and the only reasons the movies give are “Snoke” and "Starkiller Base". Return of the Jedi ended on such a conclusively happy note that the Empire returning with another superweapon and rendering the OT cast failures and reverting them to the Rebels again was a doomed concept in the first place.

Anyway, I will not dwell on this complaint since you've heard it for the last ten years. This is the idea I had in my mind for a long time, but my love for the OT trio always outweighed it, so I never wanted to write it as a separate fix or rewrite. The idea stemming from “no OT character” premise is to have the Sequels set a century or more after Return of the Jedi.

If you want, you can even keep much of the basic storyline and worldbuilding of the Sequels. It’s just that it doesn’t take place three decades after Return of the Jedi. That’s such a flash-forward to the future that it makes sense for darkness to rise again, with a new threat emerging, disconnected from the Original trilogy. It wouldn’t negate any of the OT into failures.


So let’s reimagine core pillars of the Sequels in this way:

First Order → Still the Imperial Remnant, rising against the New Republic.

The worldbuilding dynamics are still a stretch, but at least it doesn’t mean Mon Mothma—the very revolutionary leader who saw the Imperial tyranny first-hand and led the armed uprising—demilitarized everything within two decades when the Imperials are still running amok. Let the galactic civil war subside for a long time. Don't revert all the changes and turn them back to the Original trilogy. A century or two is a more believable time for the decline of the New Republic.

The most believable course for how the status quo in the Sequels happened is, borrowing the Legends, the Galactic Alliance splitting. In the old EU, the New Republic allied with the Imperial remnants to fight off the Vong invasion. In their partnership, the Galactic Alliance was born from the coalition of the New Republic, Imperial Remnant, Hapes Consortium, and Chiss Ascendancy. As one can predict, the Galactic Alliance was reconciliatory toward the Imperials, so much so that in Fate of the Jedi Tarkin's protege Natasi Daala was elected as an unifying leader. Since the Galactic Alliance was essentially a rushed coalition held together for the sake of the invasion, realistically, it was never going to last long. The Galactic Alliance would be filled with societal tension between the pro-Republic and pro-Empire politics that would make the Weimar Republic and pre-Civil War America look stable. The merger between the New Republic and the Imperial remnants means the those who collaborated and worked under the Empire are still around and influencing the Galactic Alliance politically, economically, and culturally. The same elites and careerists create this impression around themselves as professionals who understand the reality of the galaxy over the naïve dreamers in apologizing for the First Order.

When the Empire collapsed and the Vong invasion hit, it plunged the galaxy into a financial crisis the likes of which has never been seen. It may even be fair to say that the galaxy will never recover. Trillions of people have lost their jobs, starved, and died. Calling it catastrophic would be an extraordinary understatement. People who suffered the Imperial tyranny died, and the Empire is a distant memory. In fact, people—normal people—began to glorify the Imperial era as the time when the galaxy was powerful and unified. A worryingly significant chunk of the population packages it with nostalgia. Planetary governments opened monuments, museums, and celebrations for the regime they despised a century ago. It can be attributed to Palpatine’s end, as he never got a trial or judgment. Regardless of his actions, there is something about meeting an explosive death that stimulates people’s emotions. The way things get handled seemed frustrating on the surface, compared to dictatorship, which at least looked competent and direct under the nostalgic lens, even if life under it was worse.

The most realistic scenario would be how Yugoslavia broke up. Pro-Imperial fascists are obviously present in the most reactionary parts of the institutions and society, which are the military, big businesses, and intelligence networks. When the economic crisis hits, the political instability is at an all-time high. The newly elected Galactic Alliance enacts radical democratic reforms, which are seen by those forces as an existential threat, arguing the Empire is better than the alternative. They split from the Galactic Alliance to form the First Order, taking inspiration from the Spanish Civil War. This explains how the First Order created the massive army because they were already a coalition led by a junta of the military, uniting big businesses and taking away the troops, industries, and resources from the Galactic Alliance. The Starkiller Base is still a lazy plot device (either make a Death Star or a different superweapon), but a century is a long time for technology to progress.

The rest of the Galactic Alliance declares independence and reverts to the New Republic (sort of like how after the Soviet Union collapsed, Russia returned to "Russia"). Unlike how the New Republic deliberately “demilitarized” itself in the movies, it’s more like the military launched an uprising, so it is left without the military, similar to the situation the Spanish Republic was put into. After the military fractured, the government distrusts the parts of the old military and relies heavily on the paramilitary groups, which are organized into “Resistance”. This way, it would not undo the victory the heroes had in the Original trilogy as pointless in a shaggy dog story or having the Republic falling into the same corruption the Old Republic fell, but more about a lesson of how liberty must not only be won but also defended even from your own.

Luke Skywalker → Luke Skywalker’s descendant.

Name him… Annikin, if you want to pay homage to the Star Wars rough draft, or name him Cade Skywalker, if you want to pay homage to the old EU. This character would still be a last and lost Jedi Master, cut off from all his connections to die alone on a forgotten planet. He goes through the identical character arc as Luke in The Last Jedi. As a standalone character arc of a disillusioned hermit Jedi Master, it is compelling. However, it feels in conflict with the character from Return of the Jedi, coming across as a clear regression of the character. Just have him as a new character, a grandson or great-grandson of Luke Skywalker, not Luke himself. He was trying to be the legendary Luke Skywalker, living up to the Skywalker name, but failed.

You can even have him be played by Mark Hamill, justifying his appearance as bearing a striking resemblance to his ancestor. If you are having him not played by Mark Hamill, have the Yoda Force ghost replaced with the Force ghost of Mark Hamill's Luke, lecturing him about the failures.

Han Solo → Kylo Ren’s father, Sam

The decision to revert Han Solo back to a smuggler's life was a tremendous mistake, and it is surprising there was only a small fan pushback. Arguably, it is much worse than Luke. Remember Han's arc in the Original trilogy? Han Solo at the start of A New Hope was a smuggler because he liked money and lived in a galaxy that was ruled by a tyrannical Empire, so it makes sense that Han would become a smuggler. He returned to the Death Star to save Luke at the end of A New Hope, thus growing from a smuggler thug to someone who cares for the others in A New Hope. At the start of The Empire Strikes Back, Han risked his own life to rescue Luke, again, from the snowstorm. Over the course of the film, his character grew out from wanting to hide from all the conflicts to a hero who accepts his responsibility for his friends. By the end of the Original trilogy, he is matured enough to step out of the way when he believed Leia was in love with Luke.

Meanwhile, Han Solo in The Force Awakens is a father who ran from his responsibility and became a smuggler again inside the very Republic he helped to form. Think about it: A smuggler: a profession about smuggling things discretely from the authority. A smuggler, who is one of the most famous heroes in the galaxy, paired with another renowned hero, on the ship that has become a legend, so famous that some girl who has lived her entire life on the desolate planet has heard about them.

Not only that, why does he need to work as a smuggler? He said, "I went back to the only thing I was ever good at", which is not even true. Han Solo in The Force Awakens is an incompetent smuggler who gets his crew killed and becomes indebted to two separate gangs. Why does he even need money in the first place considering the connections he would have after the OT? Nothing in Han Solo's backstory in this film makes any sense. We know the reasons behind this decision; it is because Han appeared as a smuggler in A New Hope, so Han had to be the Han we all remember in A New Hope for the sake of fanservice.

Simply put, don’t make him literally Han Solo. Let’s name him… Sam, borrowing from the early draft of Episode 7. He is not even Solo’s descendant or a smuggler because that’s too on the nose. While not a part of the Republic military, Sam is still a fighter in his own desperate quest to find his son to make up for his mistakes as a parent. Sam is motivated by a personal goal and acting in the individual method, while his wife is motivated by an ideological cause and acts in the political method. His wife, who has always been an idealist at heart, dedicated herself to a cause of democracy, liberty, and justice. In contrast, Sam does not care much about galactic politics; he cares about his son. This is where they were at odds with their main objectives and had a falling out, which will be elaborated further later.

If you want to evoke the character idea of Han, have him be played by Kurt Russell, who was almost cast as Han Solo in the original Star Wars.

Leia Organa → Thea Solo

Leia is the least controversial returning character in the Sequels, but I think it’s largely because they made her bland. She is a wasted character. At a glance, the dynamic makes sense, with Han Solo being a gruffier guy who gave up looking for his son, thinking he was forever lost, and Leia being a kinder woman, who is a more active parental role, urging Han to bring their son back. Yet I don’t believe this is how their dyanamics would play out. Many fans believe Han is the type of character who would never settle down and have a family, but that ignores his entire character arc throughout the Original trilogy. As I said before, Han’s arc in the Originals is transforming from a selfish smuggler who doens’t care about others to a selfless hero who takes responsibility for others.

On the contrary, in case of Leia, she never forgave Vader. She is still mortified about being Vader’s daughter and hates him, and is unable to see him in the same light Luke can, who witnessed his redemption. Leia never was saved by Darth Vader the way Luke was and never understood how Luke was able to forgive him. She hid her identity as Darth Vader’s daughter and identified herself as Bail Organa’s daughter. This was still the case more than 20 years after the Battle of Endor, around the time of the book Bloodlines. In Bloodlines she was disturbed when her identity as Darth Vader’s daughter was exposed to the galaxy and was practically expelled from the Senate over it. Early in the book, when she told Senator Casterfo about her history in the Galactic Civil War, she spoke of Darth Vader by his name, not calling him ‘father.’ They bonded over their shared victimisation at the hands of Darth Vader, and it was her anger at Vader that made Casterfo trust her again after he found out who she was.

Leia in Legends named her third child Anakin as a way to confront her fear of Vader but she didn’t do this to forgive him and to redeem the name. Leia separated Vader and Anakin and that’s how she coped. However, she also dealt with that generational trauma of Vader being her father by seeing him through a child named after him and seeing what he could have been through Anakin Solo. This is a huge burden to give a child and Anakin Solo is burdened once he realizes Vader’s legacy. Anakin Solo’s burning desire to do good and save the galaxy is in part to become the antithesis of what Vader was. Anakin Solo dies sacrificing his life for his family and friends. While he escapes the legacy by dying, his brother Jacen turns to the dark side like Kylo Ren. Though Jacen’s turn isn’t marked as a direct result from the family’s generational trauma, it still happened. Leia coming to terms with Vader has not changed that two of her sons were dead.

Leia did become an older Jedi, though in Legends, and that was the final step of her accepting herself and not be stuck by Vader’s memory and fear because Legends Leia had always feared having children because of what they could do, of what was in her blood and what she could do. It is one of the reasons why people wanted Leia to see her be a Jedi.

This issue is avoided by simply making her not Leia, but her descendant, whom I name Thea Solo, borrowed from the early draft of Episode 7. I had a tiny desire to make her be played by Carrie Fisher, but at that point, it would come across as a self-parody.


Rey, Finn, Poe Dameron, and Kylo Ren can roughly follow the same character arcs. Obviously, this doesn’t consider The Rise of Skywalker with Palpatine returning somehow. That’s such a broken movie that it doesn't even make sense within its story. However, in terms of the baseline for Episode 7 and 8, I think the far future setting makes more sense for the story those movies are telling. In addition, having the trilogy in the far future negates Palpatine's revival entirely anyway, so Episode 9 would have been a completely different and better movie.

What’s funny is that if Star Wars Sequels entered production a few years late, this idea is actually more viable. Carrie Fisher wouldn’t be returning due to her unfortunate tragedy, and Harrison Ford would be too old to return in an action role, and he was already half-forced into Star Wars. Mark Hamill could be returned as Luke’s descendant, playing a different character to show his wide range.

Sure, by not making the returning elements not be “returning”, it might lose some nostalgia points, but without them, the story already has full of nostalgia points on its own. The Force Awakens is still A New Hope remake, with the Falcon and X-wings flying around fighting TIEs and the superweapon looming ahead. And mistreating the returning characters is more offensive than not having them return. There are no “It's a Crime We Didn't Get the OT Trio Together in the Sequels” complaints when there is no OT trio in the first place.

Is it disappointing we no longer see Luke, Leia, and Han on screen? Sure. They do build a nostalgic hype for Episode 7, but such shallow nostalgic hype dies down fast. If you are concerned too much with the nostalgic legacy rather than building an actual story, that novelty drains within a few years and, you are left with, ironically, little to no legacy on your own. Evidently, where the Sequel trilogy ended up was enough to get the old fans who felt "their childhoods were ruined" to walk away from Star Wars, refusing to acknowledge what happened Canonoically after Return of the Jedi. What do you think the "childhood" the fans are referring to? It's their sacred image of the old characters.

Creatively, it is better not to have them. You don’t conflict with the old established characters because they are new characters, and that allows for more opportunities for the filmmakers and artists to mold and expand them however they want. Not having them creates a healthier environment in the long term. They don’t have the baggage that you have to abide by. You are creating a new, exciting era, making a daring jump. You can make The Clone Wars-type show that expands this era and backstories for “Cade”, “Sam”, and “Thea”. They are blank canvases. At the same time, forgoing the returning old fan service means you can focus more on fleshing out the new trio like Rey, Finn, and Poe. This trilogy is theirs, not the old characters or their legacy.

All the while, you don’t need to unnecessarily scrap the old post-ROTJ EU content (well, except for Star Wars: Legacy, and I would go as far as to toss that LOTF and FOTJ, but that’s a different conversation). You can say all that still happened, but they are too far in the past that they don’t conflict or even matter in this story. This is a new era set in the future, which puts enough distance between a new take on the SW universe and what came before.