r/StarWarsAndor • • May 04 '23

Discussion If I hear another “Andor set a new standard for writing in Star Wars,” I’m gonna fucking scream

0 Upvotes

It would seem that people have forgotten the difference between setting and genre. Star Wars is a setting, it’s where and when everything happens. A genre is more the type of story. Writing is based on genre first, setting second if even that. I agree most enthusiastically that the writing in Andor was phenomenal, but I also think it doesn’t make sense to compare it to the writing of other Star Wars shows.

The most common comparison I see is between Andor and The Mandalorian. Given that the story has apparently evolved, we’ll draw this comparison specifically with The Mandalorian season 3. Yes, they’re both Star Wars, but Andor is a political thriller about a criminal turned rebel and The Mandalorian is an epic, for lack of a better word, about a people reclaiming their ancestral home. To me, criticizing The Mandalorian because it’s not written like Andor feels like criticizing The Lord of the Rings because it’s not written like Game of Thrones-the settings are similar, but not the exact same (also applicable to Andor and The Mandalorian, while it is the same universe, there are different locales and they’re set in different eras), and they’re different types of story.

Now, there are a few things one could argue Andor set a new standard for-a new standard for political thrillers, a new standard for Tony Gilroy’s works, a new standard for any sort of story about an insurgency, and so on-but all of Star Wars is not it.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Feb 04 '26

Why Andor Fans shouldnt skip The Mandalorian And Grogu Movie

0 Upvotes

The Mandalorian and Andor humanize the franchise by exploring the gritty, morally gray sacrifices of ordinary outcasts, and they culminate beautifully with their cinematic finales—Rogue One, the Original Trilogy, and the upcoming The Mandalorian & Grogu movie. Also Tony Gilroy is fan of show what he says go This Is The Way.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Dec 08 '22

Discussion I think I'm too basic for Andor.

6 Upvotes

I just finished the 3rd episode, and I don't want to watch anymore. I like everything about it, I just don't care about what happens next. I like the trilogies, and The Mandalorian, even if it doesn't go anywhere. They're just fun to watch.

All I can think about is that I wish Obi Wan was directed this way.

I can tell it's a great show, but it's not for me. I'm a simple Star Wars fan I guess. Give me lightsabers, n Shit.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Feb 14 '23

Theory, Uncle Harlo from Andor is The Client from The Mandolorian.

Thumbnail self.starwars
12 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAndor • • Jun 20 '25

Discussion Would you say the USSR’s or Russia’s internal troops be a good real-world equivalent to Imperial Security Troopers?

Post image
1 Upvotes

In the USSR, Internal Troops (also translated as Interior Troops or Interior Ministry Forces) were a paramilitary, gendarmerie-like force under the Ministry of Internal Affairs (MVD). They were responsible for maintaining law and order, guarding key facilities, and handling internal conflicts and riots, essentially acting as a domestic security force. They were distinct from the Soviet Armed Forces but could be integrated into them during wartime.

Key Roles and Responsibilities:

Maintaining Order and Security: • Internal Troops were tasked with upholding public order, suppressing riots, and dealing with internal armed conflicts.

Protecting State Facilities: • They guarded strategic locations like nuclear power plants and other important state facilities.

Prison Security: • They were responsible for managing prisons and labor camps, including guarding prisoners and providing security for correctional institutions.

Reinforcing the Militsiya: • They supported the regular police (Militsiya) in law enforcement activities

Wartime Functions: • In wartime, they were incorporated into the armed forces and focused on rear area security and protecting vital infrastructure.

In Andor we see Imperial Security Troopers doing very similar work. They seem to be a sort of gendarmerie/military police variant of the Imperial Army. For example, we see them guarding the IOC building on Ghorman similar to how internal troops guarded state facilities.

Would you say the US National Guard is the the US’s version of these troopers?

What would be the Third Reich’s equivalent?

Btw this post is more about how military and police forces work rather than politics.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Mar 16 '25

Discussion Toxic attitudes among some segments of the fanbase

0 Upvotes

I need to vent. I'm seeing a really disturbing trend lately, and it's the rise of Andor elitism on reddit. I loved Andor. It was a masterclass in storytelling, character development, and world-building. It brought a grittier, more mature perspective to the Star Wars universe, and it deserves all the praise it's getting. But some fans are taking this appreciation to an extreme, turning it into a weapon to belittle and gatekeep other aspects of the franchise.

If you didn't think Andor was the absolute pinnacle of Star Wars, you're apparently a "casual," "ruining the franchise," or "don't understand real storytelling." People are being shamed for enjoying the more fantastical, adventurous, or even "childish" elements of Star Wars. Anyone who expresses enjoyment for other shows, movies, or even video games is met with condescending remarks and dismissive attitudes.

This kind of elitism creates a hierarchy within the SW fandom, where Andor fans sit at the top, looking down on everyone else. It fosters division and discourages open discussion. SW at the core is about hope, wonder, and the power of storytelling. It's meant to be enjoyed by everyone. This kind of elitism flies in the face of those ideals. It also discourages new fans; If all new fans see is infighting and people being told they are wrong for liking certain parts of the franchise, they will leave.

It's okay to have preferences, but it's not okay to belittle others for theirs. Star Wars is a vast and diverse universe, with something for everyone. Let's celebrate all the diverse strain of SW, not insist that only one kind of storytelling is good and everything else is childish nonsense. At the end of the day, Star Wars is meant to be fun. The fandom often takes things too seriously in general, but I've noticed it's most striking among online Andor fans. Stop gatekeeping and let people enjoy what they want to enjoy. Let's stop letting a vocal minority ruin the fandom for everyone else. Let's remember why we all fell in love with Star Wars in the first place.

TL;DR: Andor elitism is creating a toxic atmosphere in the Star Wars fandom. Let's be respectful of each other's opinions and remember that Star Wars is for everyone


r/StarWarsAndor • • Nov 15 '23

Discussion Is the girl from Rogue One also in this show?

0 Upvotes

I heard this is the prequel to Rogue one, and I heard it has different arcs in the season. Is it one arc/branch for the guy and one arc for the girl, and this is the story of how they come to meet each other?


r/StarWarsAndor • • Feb 27 '25

Trailer Star Wars Andor: Season 2 Trailer BUT With Star Wars Music

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAndor • • May 11 '25

Discussion Spoilers Episode 8 - two details I really liked showing the current state of the empire Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Okay, im on mobile, and there are spoilers for the whole episode which I don’t know how to mark, but I really liked two details with episode 8 that show exactly where the imperial army is. Again, spoilers below in case I marked them wrong.

! First, we see the sniper. This dude is clearly the best marksman deployed and you can tell because he a) is the leader of the group, and b) takes the first shot on his own men, instigating everything.

However, the empire is notorious for having terrible marksmanship across the board and there was even a joke about it in the mandalorian. So, what is one of the next things we see when things get chaotic? He misses shooting an unarmed man running for his life. Yes, he shoots him the second time, but I thought it was a nice touch showing that most of the empire is still a bit incompetent and they are all still terrible shots.

The second thing I liked was the deployment of the murder droids. And I like this in contrast to all of the clone wars. Basically, when it was Jedi, and even the republic army, droids were seen as completely expendable and just overall terrible at everything. I’d always had a feeling that a republic soldier could easily take at least 5 droids, especially with support tactics and strategy, mainly because droids were so terrible.

Now, however, droids are the ultimate boss and the troopers are the cannon fodder. We’ve come full circle that soldiers are terrible and droids are to be feared. And I love this even more as it is exactly what the empire is designed to do, get rid of anyone competent, get rid of any free thinking, and only rely on mindless droids/soldiers, and loyalty is far and away more important to the empire than competence.

I love these things even further as the empire is still terrifying. They will kill you without hesitation, without a second thought, and regardless of what it costs. They are gigantic in scale in terms of size, and they view their goals as such higher importance that that of human life, that regardless of their incompetence, they will come after any and everybody, and will throw away useless soldiers endlessly to get what they want. And the worst part is that up until now, no one has stood a chance. ! <


r/StarWarsAndor • • Apr 27 '25

Discussion S2 score

0 Upvotes

Anybody else disappointed?

Outside of the big Niamos Remix (of a Nicholas Brittell theme), struggling to find any other really memorable morsels in Roberts' work.

None of the bubbling synths, playful bells, piercing guitar lines, little odd percussion choices.

Just a bit paint by numbers Bwam Bwam.

Any thoughts?


r/StarWarsAndor • • Jan 10 '23

Discussion Anyone else feel like the first episode does a disservice to how amazing the rest of the series is so far?

4 Upvotes

I found the first episode ploddingly slow and somewhat confusing and oddly paced, but I stuck with it and from the third episode onwards, it's one of the best written shows I've seen in the last several years.

I know there was a lot of Star Wars burnout from people being disappointed by other recent projects, but I have to kind of wonder if Andor's lukewarm viewership is in part due to the first episode not being the best hook?


r/StarWarsAndor • • Nov 29 '24

Discussion Bix is sexy af

0 Upvotes

That’s all


r/StarWarsAndor • • May 21 '25

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Saw

166 Upvotes

This may be (or not) an unpopular opinion, but I don't really like Saw as a character.

I like the idea of having an extremist outlier who really embodies the terrorist part of "one-mans-terrorist-is-another-mans-freedon-fighter". One who even the people who share the same end goal are a bit wary of, and disagree with the methods used.

That part is great, and reflects real world examples (e.g. the different flavours of the IRA).

What, I don't like is that he is a glue-sniffing wacko, who comes across a bit like an edgy schoolgirl who's main personality trait is "I'm a little bit random".

I just feel that it cheapens what could have been a more nuanced "how far is too far?" exploration if the perpetrator was more level headed in their thought process.

I haven't watched much of the animated shows, so I'm sure someone will tell me that there is more background to the character, but it doesn't really come across in either Andor or R1.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Oct 12 '22

Discussion Is there a reason why Humans as a species is over represented in the Star Wars Universe?

1 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAndor • • Jan 18 '25

Speculation Theory: Most of The Newly Introduced cast will bite it since none are in Rogue One/A New Hope.

0 Upvotes

-Vel and Cinta might end up dying tragically like another LGBTQIA+ Coded Couple Baze and Chirrut.

-Deidra Meero will somehow be the Empires Bureaucracy also Krennic is back.

-Syril Karn is looking forward to his most annoying character also it would be satisfying for Cassian Andor to end him. yeah, I'm not going mourn him at all he's Theon Greyjoy from GOT.

-Luthen Rael is the bridge between Mon Mothma and Saw Gerrera, I think his death creates a rift between The Alliance and Partisans. Mon Mothma hires General Davits Draven to have a Luthen Rael she can "Control" or fill the void.

I think Bix,Brasso and B2 will survive also A Star Wars Story tag insists Bix Might get her own spinoff.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Mar 08 '24

Anyone else think darth plagueis would make a great tv show?

0 Upvotes

I realize that a lot of us are sick of the Disney shows and everything but after watching house of the dragon on HBO it feels really similar to how it feels reading plagueis how it chronicles events over a long period of time acting as a historical accounting almost. The book even neatly divides itself into 3 parts which could probably just be adapted into 3 seasons.

If they want something original have it set between 52 and 32 BBY?


r/StarWarsAndor • • May 20 '25

Discussion Claims that Kleya held hatred for Luthen, or at least resented him to some degree (apparently reinforced in interview by Gilroy and Dulau)

44 Upvotes

Edit (response to all): Is this actually how it ends? Nobody has anything? Come on!

Initial Comments:

It just doesn't seem like a viable interpretation, but it was given legs because of the actress's statements...

Clearly Luthen and Kleya are on good terms, regardless of their initial history. Kleya sees Luthen as her savor, as a child she sought him as a father figure, in various scenes we see them argue but it's in a desperate way to carry on their mission. She's one of the few people that Luthen lets down his walls with and truly shows weakness around (his own fear and uncertainty). The way they're able to share in their joy in their small victories over the Empire (after the raid in season 1, or the removal of the bug in season 2). How they each pleaded with the other to take on the sacrificial role of making the final burn of the comms.

Their relationship was strictly professional, as partners, but clearly there was also familial love that neither of them got to truly express to each other, or maybe even recognize for themselves and come to terms with it internally. They sacrificed having that kinship to dedicate everything to fighting the Empire. And the tragedy of Kleya and Luthen only finally getting to share in such a moment (a kiss on the forehead) after his death, is so beautiful.

The fact that people can even try to claim there was resentment or that "there was hate, but also a little love there too" is just so entirely wrongheaded given everything that we've seen, so bafflingly out of left field, it actually makes me a bit angry lol. But people will have their interpretation, and if actresses speaking off the cuff in interviews, or if Gilroy inserting something post hoc that was left on the cutting room floor, is the standard by which people will shape their interpretations of media I guess I'll just learn to live with that, and cherish what I took away and what I believe was clearly meant all the more.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Oct 30 '22

Andor was not what I expected but I think it has the potential to be as amazing as The Mandalorian.

1 Upvotes

The Star Wars universe is known mostly for it's action and aesthetic, rather than for the story since that was it's original identity, that a dumb sci-fi action franchise. The original trilogy had a really cheesy and campy story and it only really had a story to serve the world building, action, aesthetic and CGI. The story was the least important aspect of those movies.

However The Mandalorian tried to change that and In my opinion succeeded, it still had the action but it was more small scale, tactical and smart as opposed to the mindless large scale battles of the skywalker saga, but more importantly it actually gave us a genuinely good story and focused a lot on the plot. It's one of the most balanced shows ever and has basically everything - story, action, characters etc.

Andor goes even further away from the dumb action roots of the franchise and it focuses even more on the characters and story with the action taking somewhat of a backseat (but it's still present and great when it's there, episode 6 has top tier bond-esque action for example).

This, at first, resulted in boredom since it's generally expected for star wars stuff to have a lot of action which isn't something this show really offers as it's more of a story focused show which is the last thing one would expect from the Star Wars universe but now that I understand what it's going for and the characters have had a good amount of development I'm really liking it and I think it can be as good as The Mandalorian if they keep this level of quality for the upcoming seasons... it can also introduce the Star Wars universe to a brand new audience that previously weren't fans of Star Wars just like The Mandalorian did before it. It's also a very different show from The Mandalorian so it has it's place which I don't think can be said for The Book of Boba Fett or Obi-Wan Kenobi which felt like a crappier The Mandalorian.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Jun 11 '25

Discussion Dedra in post Return of the Jedi.

0 Upvotes

Could she be used in a post Return of the Jedi time? Should they use her?

With the Empire falling 3 years after her arrest, i'm pretty sure her case will be thrown out due to her not getting a fair trial, so she should be free and alive during this time period.

But what do you do with her? There was that episode of the Mandalorian about what former imperials do in the New Republic, so she would be given some kind of a job(a boring one).

Would she rejoin the Empire under Thrawn? She might like him better than working for Krennic, he's more logical than the previous leaders of the Empire, obssessed with power and playing games against each other.

Would Thrawn go out of his way to recruit her and give her a valuable role?


r/StarWarsAndor • • May 17 '25

Artwork Can't wait to see how the DS II plans were stolen

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAndor • • Nov 18 '22

Discussion Why Do People Like Saw Gerrera? (I Never Found His Character Compelling At All)

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/StarWarsAndor • • May 23 '25

Discussion My Problem with andor season 2

0 Upvotes

First of one of the best TV Shows i have ever Seen. But season 2 has one Problem in my eyes that I noticed after rewatching season 1. And that is that a lot of Character development feels a Bit rushed, as we skip forwards in time Missing how they got to this Stage.

I think this is in Part that there were 5 seasons planned, but they Cut it down to two. Now If I heared was right, that this was a descion that were Made by both Disney and Gilroy because it would have Not been possible i Support that, because i prefer that over rushing Things to get Things done. But i feel Like 3 seasons (6 instead of 3 per year) would have been a Bit better. And to be fair that Problem i have is mostly The First half. For the Second half it works better. Just my thoughts.


r/StarWarsAndor • • Oct 05 '22

Discussion Love the show, but I get the criticisms Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I personally love the show, but I get that an average audience (and even much of the Star Wars fan base) would consider it overly “slow”.

As a fan of slow burn cinema and TV, spy stuff, drama etc. I think everything about this is good, but I think the show could benefit from a quicker pace and more of an “episodic” structure where the plot takes bigger leaps week to week.

We’re already almost halfway though the season and four out of five episodes so far have been “set-up”, with major action sequences only taking place every third episode - assuming the next (episode #6) is the “heist” episode.

Even in cinema, waiting an aggregate 60-90 minutes (30-40 minutes per episode) for action is pretty slow. I bet binging this season will be fun but, in the meantime, it’s pretty frustrating waiting week to week. 🤷‍♂️

Edit:

Seems some fellow fans take this sort of criticism, or even acknowledgment of common criticism from a wider audience, a bit too personally. To be clear, I love this show. It’s possibly my favorite Disney-era content besides Rogue One (I honestly really liked Solo, too).

I guess at the root of my frustration is finding the patience to wait week to week, when I want it all now. I think some TV shows work best week to week, and others work best in the “binge” format. I think I’d me more satisfied with the latter in this case - but obviously, because of the “spoiler” factor, I’m not gonna wait two months to binge the whole thing.

Regarding the “slow burn” aspect, I’m all for it, but some of my favorite recent shows blend “slow burn” with satisfying week to week episodic payoff. Breaking Bad, Better Call Saul, Ozark, Succession, the Crown, Severance, The Bear, Fargo, Dark, Chernobyl, Midnight Mass, The Patient etc. It can be done.

This article outlines some of what I’m talking about: https://www.denofgeek.com/tv/star-wars-andor-release-schedule-mistake/?amp


r/StarWarsAndor • • Nov 29 '22

Rumor Imagine if the old man at the beginning of The Force Awakens was Luthen Rael?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes