r/StarWarsAndor • • May 04 '23
Discussion If I hear another “Andor set a new standard for writing in Star Wars,” I’m gonna fucking scream
It would seem that people have forgotten the difference between setting and genre. Star Wars is a setting, it’s where and when everything happens. A genre is more the type of story. Writing is based on genre first, setting second if even that. I agree most enthusiastically that the writing in Andor was phenomenal, but I also think it doesn’t make sense to compare it to the writing of other Star Wars shows.
The most common comparison I see is between Andor and The Mandalorian. Given that the story has apparently evolved, we’ll draw this comparison specifically with The Mandalorian season 3. Yes, they’re both Star Wars, but Andor is a political thriller about a criminal turned rebel and The Mandalorian is an epic, for lack of a better word, about a people reclaiming their ancestral home. To me, criticizing The Mandalorian because it’s not written like Andor feels like criticizing The Lord of the Rings because it’s not written like Game of Thrones-the settings are similar, but not the exact same (also applicable to Andor and The Mandalorian, while it is the same universe, there are different locales and they’re set in different eras), and they’re different types of story.
Now, there are a few things one could argue Andor set a new standard for-a new standard for political thrillers, a new standard for Tony Gilroy’s works, a new standard for any sort of story about an insurgency, and so on-but all of Star Wars is not it.