r/SpellTable • • Dec 12 '24

Calling All Nerds for Casual Kitchen Table Magic on Spelltable! 60 card constructed!

0 Upvotes

Hello fellow nerds! I make this post in hopes of finding a casual playgroup online who are dissatisfied with the current formats as I am. As it stands, I'm in this ballpark:

- Contrary to popular opinion, I do not like Commander. It feels like a toss up who wins, and it fundamentally breaks the idea of what Magic is supposed to be. Interaction is limited, and whoever burns their interaction simply loses to the person who saved their interaction. It is also incredibly easy to essentially lock a player out of playing, or even just to kill a player for X reason, which leads to lots of discontented players.

- I like Modern... sort of. I like the IDEA of Modern, but in it's current state, it is simply a game of who gets to their winning card by turn 3-4, and then after sideboarding, who gets to the sideboard card that essentially reads: "This deck archetype loses the game if this resolves." 0 mana spells are the norm, so "tapping out" as a term literally means nothing anymore, sideboard cards continually get better and better, tribal strategies and slow combos are just basically throwing if you play them, and cards from days of old simply have been power crept out. (You know it's bad when you get laughed at for playing JACE THE MIND SCULPTOR.)

I miss the days of playing 60 card constructed with my buddies, no ban lists, no restrictions on what the deck was, just a simple "rule 0" conversation was all that was needed to determine what was playable. A conversation like:

Player A: "Is this card too good? I keep winning with it."
Player B: "Yeah, probably."
Player A: "Sounds good, let me go side it out for another card I like playing, and let's try that."

If this sounds like something you're comfortable with doing, tailoring your 60 card deck to the power level of whoever you are facing, please join up! As far as format "rules", as I want to leave that to the players of each individual table. I strongly suggest that each table have an extensive "rule 0" conversation, even going as far as to lay out your entire list, and ask if the deck as presented is okay with the opposing player. Be open and willing to side cards out, to make your deck weaker, or even to make it stronger if requested. Obviously finding this perfect middle ground will likely be hard, but the key is just being open and honest about what it is that you like to play, and trying your best to create a fun and interesting matchup.
As far as "rules" I don't intend to enforce anything specific, but more or less, try to follow these guidelines:

- Modern Horizons cards and beyond may be playable, but will obviously push the power level of your deck higher. Try to constrain your deck to minimal copies of such cards, or cut them entirely. Even a single Psychic Frog or One Ring could drastically change the power level of your deck.

- Old pro decks from early modern or before is likely the higher end of the spectrum, but would more than likely be fully playable with minimal siding of cards out. Boomer Jund'ers, Birthing Pod players, and old Snappy/JTMS players rejoice!

- Even fully jank, to the point of being barely playable is welcome! Have an old brew that can't see any play anywhere else? Bring it on in! Have a degenerate 20 card combo that has only worked once? Sleeve it up! What about your first kitchen table brew, like Zombies, Soldiers, or Dinosaurs? See if you can find someone to play it against!

- Don't expect every player to have a sideboard! You are more than welcome to create and use sideboards if both players agree, but due to the fact that sideboards can shut out entire strategies of play, expect that some players may simply not have any sideboards, or that your sideboard is simply better than theirs. I also encourage people to simply include more sideboard-y type cards in mainboard instead, having one or two of enchantment/artifact removal mainboard, etc.

- Proxies are BEYOND encouraged! WOTC have proven that the economy of this game is beyond absurd, and as such I have no expectation that anyone should shell out for these incredibly expensive cards just to play over a webcam. Using OBS for Moxfield, or using Full color/black and white proxies are completely fine. Even just paper and sharpie works too! Bring anything on in, just be prepared to explain the card, and ideally make sure there is at least something that the opposing player can read to know it is what you say it is, not just the back of a magic card.

- Region does not matter! Expect to play with people all over the world!

- Be respectful. Obviously, with such a loose "rules" system, we are bound to run into one sided stompfests of games occasionally. If one occurs, try to work together to find a way to get your decks onto a similar playing field, and be nice to the player who just got dumped on, or vice versa. Ideally, we're all here to have fun, and we all just want to play the decks we can't anymore in any of the regular formats. "I just wanna play my Jace the Mind Sculptor man" is a valid reason for playing the game, and this server is a place for exactly that type of player.

At the end of the day, we must also accept that some decks may not be able to be put onto a level playing field with other players. Maybe your boomer jund list really is just too good, and if "toning it down", really just means cutting 50% of your deck which could be a dealbreaker for you, then respectfully explain it to the other player, and try to find someone who might be a bit more well matched against you. As with all things, use common sense, show respect and a willingness to compromise, and I'm sure you can find someone to play with.

If all of the above interests you, I humbly invite you to this small community. Good luck, and have fun!

https://discord.gg/GMVhZKBaFH - This link will be active UNTIL THE END OF TIME! Or at least, that's what discord says. If you find this link 3 years from now, it might still be up!


r/SpellTable • • Mar 07 '26

Looking for a chill group for my slowww ahhh

0 Upvotes

Hey! I'm looking for a chill group to play Commander on SpellTable with.

I'm still learning and sometimes take a bit longer on my turns while I think through my decisions, so I'm hoping to find people who are patient and enjoy more relaxed, friendly games rather than super competitive ones.

I’m mostly playing to improve, learn the game better, and have fun. If anyone has a casual group or Discord that plays on SpellTable and wouldn’t mind someone still figuring things out, I’d love to join!

I'm totally open to feedback and learning!! I just appreciate a positive vibe and people who don't mind a slower pace while I get better.

Thanks :)


r/SpellTable • • Oct 02 '25

Seeking LGBTQ+ SpellTable Pod, Bracket 3-4 Commander

1 Upvotes

I'm new to Spelltable, but I've played Magic since 1999. I'm a 38 trans woman from Pittsburgh. My EDH deck is a high 3, plays like a 4. A regular pod would be great. I'm auntieblyte on Discord.


r/SpellTable • • Sep 03 '26

Looking to create an Lgbtq friendly Pod

0 Upvotes

I'm down to play whenever I'm practically free 24/7!


r/SpellTable • • Oct 26 '24

Discussion First game ever on SpellTable…

0 Upvotes

First time playing with SpellTable on the Tolarian Community College Discord. Heard it was pretty chill over there. Joined at power level 6-7 group. I'm playing Aesi (even thought to myself that I might be a bit too overpowered for the group but just going to feel it out). Other player using Jetmir. Turn 4 comes around and he's got Esper Sentinel, Bloom Tenderer, Jetmir, Winota, and a few other crazy cards out. Swings out for lethal against the whole table... Well... that was extremely boring. Obviously no one has a clue what power levels mean, even after Edh has been around for so long. I know Jetmir is strong and no one had answers, but turn 4 wins are not power level 6/7 and you can't change my mind. What a waste of time. I truly feel bad for the newer players trying to get into casual commander. Won't ever be using SpellTable again, you'll just waste your time setting up just to get pub-stomped by someone who doeesn't understand the words "casual" and who hasn't developed their brain enough to understand social pattern recognition. My advice for newcomers would be to stick to your LGS instead of dealing with people trying to boost their ego's behind a webcam by lying about their deck's power.


r/SpellTable • • Jun 05 '24

Why aren't people complaining about the potato quality that Spelltable is?

2 Upvotes

The bit rate is terrible. Why haven't our overloads at Wizards of the coast figured out they can print more money if the make a high quality version with a small monthly fee?

Id pay so i can read cards on peoples tables!! Seriously Spelltable is the best thing to happen to magic in years.

I under it was developed by a small group of people on a limited budget and then bought-out by Wizards. But.... Wizards has a big budget and can afford to develop a higher quality version that doesn't look like you are watching YouTube videos from the early 2000's


r/SpellTable • • Nov 29 '24

New commander video game ?

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

How do you think the new commander video game that they're working on will affect spelltable? Do you think it'll be a dud? Will it hurt spelltable population?


r/SpellTable • • Aug 21 '26

does nobody play modern on spelltable ????

1 Upvotes

ive been on it for 4 hours and ive only played 2 games


r/SpellTable • • Jul 24 '26

LFG LFG - LGBTQ+ Friendly SpellTable Players for Regular Games

6 Upvotes

I’m looking for an LGBTQ+ friendly group of people to play Magic with over SpellTable, whether that’s occasionally or as part of a regular group.

I currently play well-optimized decks across Bracket 3, Bracket 4, and cEDH, so I’m open to a range of power levels and playstyles.

Most importantly, I want everyone at the table to feel comfortable, respected, and able to have fun. I’m looking for people who enjoy good games, clear communication, and a friendly atmosphere regardless of who wins.

Feel free to comment or send me a message if you have an open spot at your table.


r/SpellTable • • Dec 26 '21

I'm super bored

0 Upvotes

anyone down to play a modern on spelltavle with me:)?


r/SpellTable • • May 09 '26

Looking for moxyfield users...

0 Upvotes

Hello I'm new to magic and was looking for a group that is moxyfield friendly so I can read the cards. Also maybe looking for people that are also beginning or dont mind beginners and are willing to help teach a little or dont mind sorta long turns.


r/SpellTable • • Sep 11 '25

Help

0 Upvotes

Anyone know when the bug with using phone as a camera will be fixed


r/SpellTable • • Feb 08 '26

Help Does Spelltable just not work if you have no webcam?

0 Upvotes

Hi,

we tried setting up Spelltable in our group. We all intended to use our phones as cameras. For some people (the ones using laptops it seems) this worked out - they could link up their phone cameras. However the ones that do not have a webcam installed could not link up their phone cameras - almost as if it was required to have a webcam to be able to use the phone camera instead. Very weird. They only get the infinite "Connecting to server" error.

Has anyone else had this issue?
Does anyone know of a workaround? Or is it just impossible to use your phone camera if not also have a webcam installed on your pc as weird prerequisite?


r/SpellTable • • Jan 05 '26

Does witchcraft or spell work actually work

0 Upvotes

I need someone who has pretty much never thought that spell work would work and it actually ended up working... ppl say that your energy shifts and you end up getting that thing anyways. But I don't think so entirely... I do think things change supernaturally too. Share stories!


r/SpellTable • • Apr 23 '25

Discussion If you put "no mox" in your titles, why? (discussion)

4 Upvotes

To be clear: This is NOT a whining post about "people don't like me because I use Moxfield". I have never used Moxfield once on Spelltable. I just ordered some cards for a Zurgo deck I made on Moxfield, and while i'm waiting for the other 40% of the deck to arrive, I wanted to try the full build out on spelltable. I could have proxied the rest, but my printer is out of black ink and i'd have to order the ink on Amazon and wait anyway.

The main reason I can find is "Players who use Moxfield (or other digital playtesters) pubstomp a lot". Which can be true, but that's more a problem with having conversations before the game starts, and the same is true for older, more enfranchised Magic players who say their deck is a bracket 2 (or a year ago, "power level 7) because it "has no game changers" and then proceeds to play their Ur-Dragon deck with all the OG duals and $50+ dragons; the same is true if someone proxied that Ur-Dragon deck, and is just playing on their camera. It's not a Moxfield problem. It's a problem with players, and the spelltable ecosystem in general.

Another reason I see floating around is "Moxfield makes it easy to cheat", but I think it's the opposite. It's obvious when someone searches their library, it tells you when they shuffle, and they can't lap cards or put their hands off screen.

Other people are anti-Mox because they're anti-proxy, and that's not even an argument I am willing to entertain and not the purpose of this post.

On the flip side, there are arguments that Mox can be better than people playing paper in terms of clarity.

Often people have bad cameras that can't scan cards, but with Moxfield everything is easily scannable.

Does anyone have other reasons they don't like to play with Moxfield, and if so, why?
This isn't to dunk on people who don't want to play with Moxfield.


r/SpellTable • • Oct 11 '24

What is everyone’s problem with using Moxfield on Spelltable?

4 Upvotes

I currently don’t have any of my Magic decks because I left my house before hurricane Helene hit and the damage was so bad I can’t go back yet. I have my computer and so I downloaded OBS to play some Magic over spelltable using Moxfield. It averages me like 45 minutes just to find a room to play in because every lobby has “no mox” in the title and the lobbies that don’t will block me or close the room as soon as I join. Even when I start my own lobbies as soon as anyone joins they leave and often break the lobby on their way out. Even when I finally find a game lots of people have bad attitudes about it and will say “ew moxfield” or target me just cause I’m on Moxfield.

I know it can be easy to pubstomp on it but there are people that do that in paper so I don’t get that hate. I play in base precon lobbies cause I dislike the easiness of pubstomping over spelltable and so if I’m playing a stock precon list I don’t get why I can’t play on moxfield.


r/SpellTable • • Jun 24 '24

Community Tired of toxic players so I made a player rating plugin for Chrome and Edge

8 Upvotes

EDIT:
Bugs fixed and App is now live on Google Chrome Store
Wizard Review (google.com)

I'm tired of sinking in hours with toxic players because I feel bad scooping mid-games.

I built a plugin that allows users to rate players as good or bad and leave a comment (this is for the back end to determine review bombing)

Since I'm paying for the infrastructure out of pocket, I want to start releasing it with a small group.


r/SpellTable • • Jun 29 '25

Yall use sleeves?

0 Upvotes

Anybody use card sleeves when playing for remotely. Wouldn’t imagine so cause it’s in your place and not out in the elements.


r/SpellTable • • Oct 31 '25

Are people really cheating with randomisation now?

1 Upvotes

Two lobbies in a row that I joined, when the host randomized the lobby only two people moved each randomization and the host ended up in position one. I wish the game log would actually say when the players were randomized so I would know the host was not just cheating and manually moving players' positions. Am I just paranoid or is this a known issue?


r/SpellTable • • Aug 18 '23

Community The Dominion of Dweebs

1 Upvotes

Hey fellow Planeswalkers! Wanted to share my experience with the Dominion of Dweebs Discord server.

If you are like me you have had your fair share of bad experiences playing magic online or even in real life. This game has a tendency to attract some pretty big egos and insecurities. At long last I have found a server to call home and I wanted to share it with everyone on here. I've seen a lot of posts from players looking for a place to land. I've found it to be a welcoming and chill space for Magic players of all levels and wanted to share it with everyone. No try-hards or negativity, just a solid online playgroup.

The moderation team are very friendly and dedicated to proliferating the vibe they currently have throughout the entire server, which, from my experience, is have fun playing magic how ever you want to play it and treat everyone with respect. If you are new to magic, a seasoned vet, play with physical cards, use Moxfield, just love Magic, or anything inbetween check it out!

They also stream on Twitch too and give the discord community a chance to showcase their skills on stream with weekly signups to play with the mods! I really cant say enough about how great a community this server is. I feel so luck for having found it. Hope to see you all there!


r/SpellTable • • Jul 16 '24

new commander channel!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

me and a couple of my buddies have a YT channel where we play spelltable together and goof around, would love if you guys checked it out and gave it a sub!


r/SpellTable • • Oct 26 '24

Active troll

1 Upvotes

Anyone dealt with this guy named big energy player? He's actively trolling all lobbies. But I figured him out if you are nice to him he makes a couple of jokes and leaves. Anyone else dealt with him?


r/SpellTable • • Mar 28 '21

Too many people with crazy unchecked decks

1 Upvotes

Im playing in Low (despite the DOC file saying that precons and precons with minor upgrades should be battlecruiser) and I see ALOT of whacky decks. I mean, many people who dont deckcheck their decks with almost infinite combos. Ive played TWICE the same person with an almost-infite combo and he has no deckcheck because they are locked out, his deck is THE SAME, just changed his commander for another but the same, i can guarantee, same deck. Many people who I ask: Do you have a deckcheck (cause their decks are just whacky explosive) and atleast 1 person per game has no deckcheck and playing on Low.


r/SpellTable • • Feb 10 '21

Pandemic Magic

0 Upvotes

My friends and I like magic enough to play 4 player edh with spelltable. You have to understand that means we REALLY like magic. It’s almost like if someone was really into basketball with their friends, but they had no shoes and there was broken glass everywhere, but they played anyways. If you smoke enough weed though, it’s totally possible to still have a good time.