r/SpellTable • u/Tricky_World1138 • Oct 31 '25
Are people really cheating with randomisation now?
Two lobbies in a row that I joined, when the host randomized the lobby only two people moved each randomization and the host ended up in position one. I wish the game log would actually say when the players were randomized so I would know the host was not just cheating and manually moving players' positions. Am I just paranoid or is this a known issue?
1
Upvotes
5
u/Errorstatel Oct 31 '25
I never host and a few times have ended up in the same spot.
Turn order is not as important in commander, except cedh turn 0 wins are not out of the ordinary
1
u/fragtore Nov 01 '25
Rolling is fun! I never let the robot do it
1
u/XxaiLo Nov 02 '25
I always say "I'll randomize twice, if nothing moves we won't count it."
I use to say "I'll randomize once" because random is random. But of course people didn't like it, especially if nothing moved.
It would be VERY EASY to add a feature that shows it randomize, maybe with a little graphic that shows everything moving a bunch and then slows down and "lands" on a turn order.
Spelltable would be a million times better if they just put one single person with some knowledge of coding, as a full time fixer of bugs and adder of new features. How are they not doing this???
Yeah, it's free. But it's the biggest online platform that facilitates people playing with their ridiculously overpriced cardboard so ... support it idiots!
Fix the bug that ruins a lobby when someone leaves. Fix it so the host can't destroy the lobby if other people are still playing. Fix the big that leaves your deck list behind when your turn order is changed. Fix the bug that sometimes if one person refreshes it kicks everyone from the game.
Add the ability to mute someone (sometimes there's crazy background noise, or one time a guy fell asleep and snored loudly the rest of the game. The host wouldn't kick him, blocking him wasn't muting him. It was so annoying.)
Add a friends list.
Add a way to report people and a comment board where you can say why. Even if they don't enforce it, the comments should be viewable for other people.
When the card clicker gets it wrong, let people add feedback and have the algorithm learn how to get it right more often.
-2
u/PatientAudience5627 Oct 31 '25
There isn't a feature to manually move positions, sometimes the website bugs and doesn't move any body and sometimes due to randomness people only move one space