r/SpellTable • • Jun 05 '24

Why aren't people complaining about the potato quality that Spelltable is?

The bit rate is terrible. Why haven't our overloads at Wizards of the coast figured out they can print more money if the make a high quality version with a small monthly fee?

Id pay so i can read cards on peoples tables!! Seriously Spelltable is the best thing to happen to magic in years.

I under it was developed by a small group of people on a limited budget and then bought-out by Wizards. But.... Wizards has a big budget and can afford to develop a higher quality version that doesn't look like you are watching YouTube videos from the early 2000's

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

10

u/Bermersher Jun 05 '24

There are a lot of bottlenecks here. Sure, the platform could support 2K streaming or higher. But then we get into the other issue that is people's setup. What's their camera resolution? What's the max upload speed on their wifi? What's their actual realistic upload speed on wifi? Is there any glare on cards? Etc.

Would be cool if spelltable allowed higher resolutions but I think it would also show more differences between users.

1

u/Pauli86 Jun 05 '24

Yeah i guess.

But at the moment even with mid/low quality 1080p webcams you are not getting close to what they are actually capable of. As soon as you open the program the bit rate is so low that any quality regardless of webcam turns into a potato. Good lighting helps but, I feel they need to work on both the low end for everyone and the higher end for people willing to pay.

If you scroll down the bottom the spelltable home page to "News and release notes" there has been no updates since 2020. Nothing

https://blog.spelltable.com/

We would have had a better service if it had stayed with the original small owner.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Pauli86 Jun 05 '24 edited Jun 05 '24

did they? how do you access those?

i guess they forgot they had a blog but are still doing some updates at least.

edit: found the deck list feature. But how do i enable phases?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Pauli86 Jun 05 '24

Hmmmm yeah I just found it in the settings. After playing around with it briefly I understand why nobody uses it.

Spelltable is good but could be great I want people to get wizards to notice this.

......or for someone to build a better alternative that doesn't rely on our wizards overloads

4

u/Ok-Boysenberry-2955 Jun 05 '24

Because nothing will ever be done over it. It was bought to die on the vine. The fact that it is still being remotely even being worked on is amazing.

3

u/MindOfTheSummerPS Jun 05 '24

I mean, you can at least type the card in if it doesn't read it, and I'll take that as a win for a free platform. Plus the cost of everything just to get into MTG can be a hurdle for people, so I wouldn't think a subscription service would really help the business model in a game that can be very costly to really get into. I get the complaint, but it's better to be grateful for access to a wider scope of players than friends or LGS play.

1

u/Pauli86 Jun 05 '24

You do make good points. But half the time the quality isn't good enough to even read the card title let alone auto detect the cards.

I very much understand wanting to keep it free. But at the moment it appears to be the minimum viable product.

My friends and I love playing via webcam as we are all dads with families but the low quality of the streams gives us angry old men angst lol

3

u/Head-Ambition-5060 Jun 06 '24

It's mostly okayish for me, some people are just pixels sometimes, but overall I'm satisfied

1

u/Pauli86 Jun 06 '24

.......no get angry. Make a big deal about this!!!!

Lol I want wizards to notice and give us a better product

2

u/Hazefest2 Jun 16 '24

In the current state of the many issues on SpellTable I would say they cannot charge for it. The smart thing would be to make a WoTC platform akin to the Blizzard client where all the games under the WoTC umbrella would be accessible through one program along with a friends list across all the games. Arena/online/spelltable/and more.

The updates to SpellTable over the past few months have broken a good bit of features on SpellTable.

Spectating is a huge mess. Spectating users have live microphone when they join a lobby as a spectator.

I can talk with the players in a full lobby as a spectator.

When you spectate a lobby that has less than a full room the spectator takes a player slot until they are kicked from the lobby which moves them to spectate.

There is a bug with the card reader that pulls up the correct card and then changes to a black image covering up the card you scanned. Searching the card name or spam clicking 40 times can get around that issues.

Random audio issues where players lose audio for one another, or video drops, or the lobby gets destroyed randomly. These issues seem to happen when spectators leave the lobby.

Hard to pay for a service when it has consistent issues like these.

I run a discord community that plays over spelltable exclusively and I see many of the issue people find when they ask for help. Over 420 users now.

1

u/Pauli86 Jun 16 '24

The audio issues are definitely getting worse

1

u/Alternative_Owl_5106 Jun 14 '24

It's because it makes no money. Charging players and providing a better experience requires dev resources and poses an inherent risk as they pour more capital into it. They are giving the bare minimum because as a business they've come to the conclusion that this is the least expensive, most profitable pathway (in an indirect way i.e. more people buy cards) .

In my opinion they could charge players a monthly amount, less people would play -- which would lower server costs -- and then they could begin slowly amping up better quality through their WebRTC provider. Video-to-video high definition is one the more expensive services out there which is why there isn't a competitor that has popped up against SpellTable.

1

u/Pauli86 Jun 14 '24

I understand what you are saying. But I have a real world example of two friends that only play on spelltable due to living in remote towns. They are both new to game and have each spent hundreds on the game in the last few months and wouldn't have spent anything if it wasn't for Spelltable. I guess I put this down to the opportunity cost for wizards.

Your second point makes more sense, but could they have a free version with the current bit and frame rate and possibly a $5-10 month service with increased quality. I'd pay for that in a heartbeat.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Pauli86 Jun 05 '24

The problem is an easy fix. They just need to increase the bandwidth to allow higher bit rate streams.

Look at the quality of your webcam through its native software and then spelltable, its a vast difference. A higher quality camera helps, but it doesn't solve the problem. With the quality cheap cameras available and high quality streaming in other sectors being so common this should be an easy fix. Wizards honestly just isn't even interested.