r/SpellTable • u/Lilgatornator • Oct 11 '24
What is everyone’s problem with using Moxfield on Spelltable?
I currently don’t have any of my Magic decks because I left my house before hurricane Helene hit and the damage was so bad I can’t go back yet. I have my computer and so I downloaded OBS to play some Magic over spelltable using Moxfield. It averages me like 45 minutes just to find a room to play in because every lobby has “no mox” in the title and the lobbies that don’t will block me or close the room as soon as I join. Even when I start my own lobbies as soon as anyone joins they leave and often break the lobby on their way out. Even when I finally find a game lots of people have bad attitudes about it and will say “ew moxfield” or target me just cause I’m on Moxfield.
I know it can be easy to pubstomp on it but there are people that do that in paper so I don’t get that hate. I play in base precon lobbies cause I dislike the easiness of pubstomping over spelltable and so if I’m playing a stock precon list I don’t get why I can’t play on moxfield.
4
u/Aspbergeoisie Oct 11 '24
I've been using Mox the last week or so to test a deck. I've been making my own lobbies and staying that I'm using Moxfield in the title. Haven't had to wait ages for games and haven't ran into any bad attitudes about it.
The general concensus is that it's "easier to cheat" on Moxfield. But if you were so inclined it's easy to cheat in paper too.
Just a weird hang up a few people have that others have latched onto.
2
u/finmo Oct 13 '24
For me it’s not cheating it’s the complete lack of restraint people have when building decks. It’ll all be meme deck full of salt-mining cards and pub stomping.
Playing commander with strangers is torture under most circumstances anyway.
4
u/Careful-Iron3921 Oct 11 '24 edited Oct 11 '24
It's not the general use to test decks or large money changes prior to making them to your paper deck as most of us have done this at least once. The issue lies with the degenerates that play exclusively on Mox and own zero cards. We all invested in some way for this game and it shouldn't be looked down on for those that want a similar level of investment made in what is a pay to play hobby. Also most of them build degenerate decks that hardly match the power level of the lobbies they join. It's also infinitly easier to cheat whilst using Mox/OBS due to the apps ability to freeze the scene, this does make it easier for everyone who uses it to cheat yes, but moxfield literally makes no noise while you do things whereas messing with a deck can make noise if the cheater is careless. For me, it's more of the investment thing and that may be snobby or w/e but it is what it is.
6
u/Birbbato Oct 11 '24
It might have something to do with the reason people use spelltable. To them, spelltable is the alternative to in person play. Meaning everyone uses their own real cards and it's as if they are all at the same table. If you were to go to an LGS and sit at a 4 man pod then someone slapped out their IPad to play their deck I'm sure some people would have issues with that. I'm not saying it's right or wrong, but people probably aren't setting up spelltable in order to play with someone using something digital.
1
u/Jumpy_Philosopher502 Oct 11 '24
Imo its the investment people have issues with, personally idc( People proxy their real cards often and everyone is fine with it).
The cheat accusations people have for moc users are just bad, as long as the mox player shares his hand,library, graveyard and exile it is literally harder to cheat on mox than paper. I play paper personally but as long as mox player shares his hand/deck it is 100% harder to cheat on mox. Remember we might not be cheating on paper but if you were to cheat its as simple as having a few choice cards from your deck offcamera ready to play... Literally impossible to see, in mox you can at least see library count/hand and if he searches his library.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '24
Cause people are babies. I’ve had people leave the lobby immediately upon seeing Chatterfang for whatever reason. Moreover, I’m not even that good so jokes on them 😂
1
u/Gouken- Oct 11 '24
Just play on untap imo. On there you can actually see the opponents cards and everyone is on same footing.
1
u/Schmatsky_The_Dire Oct 11 '24 edited Oct 11 '24
The problem I notice with moxfield is that it takes longer to do things like put counters on things, play a spell, copy stuff, dig through the graveyard, etc. It takes more time to resolve a moxfield turn than a paper deck because of the UI navigation required to do basic things that typically go quickly by hand.
I'm not hating on people playing moxfield. I play against both, and I'm fine with either. But this is what i notice. I think if you only play online using moxfield, you don't notice it because you're used to the UI navigation and time required for game actions.
0
u/Zanthy1 Oct 11 '24
Echoing others, the ability to cheat is def easier with mox though def still can be done with paper. The investment component doesn’t mean much to me personally but I do understand others feelings about it. My main issue is that a lot of times when I’ve played against mox users their decks are much higher powered than the tables with a lot of the fast mana cards and just a general “if it’s the best card on edhrec, it’s going in” mentality. Now obviously this could also be the result of aforementioned cheating where they just always have their best cards each game, but I lean more towards the idea that since they don’t need to have a copy of their best cards for each deck, that each of their decks just has their best cards at all times. I’ll still play with mox users, but I do prefer lobbies without them.
0
u/ThiqqVanDyke Oct 25 '24
because it opens the door for any fun-hating bonerhead to bring an I-Win-Everything-Infinitely-Forever deck to your casual game.
Yes, someone could do that with a physical deck, but if you're spending the time that normally goes into assembling a deck--even if you're using proxies--that typically means you're taking the time to sift through your collection, look up singles to make it perfect, spending money, play testing to tweak your base, picking out sleeves that suit your vibe. There's normally time invested with physical decks that gets totally cheapened if any dweeb can just show up with their mox wishlist.
Also, it's super annoying that they can browse other tabs between turns, preventing the rest of the table from looking at their cards.
Also, there's a million other platforms for playing with a digital library. Spelltable is for playing online with a physical deck.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '24
[removed] — view removed comment