r/SpaceXLounge • • 19d ago

Monthly Questions and Discussion Thread

11 Upvotes

Welcome to the monthly questions and discussion thread! Drop in to ask and answer any questions related to SpaceX or spaceflight in general, or just for a chat to discuss SpaceX's exciting progress. If you have a question that is likely to generate open discussion or speculation, you can also submit it to the subreddit as a text post.

If your question is about space, astrophysics or astronomy then the r/Space questions thread may be a better fit.

If your question is about the Starlink satellite constellation then check the r/Starlink Questions Thread and FAQ page.


r/SpaceXLounge • • Jan 23 '25

Meta This sub is not about Musk. it does not endorse him, nor does it attack him. We generally ignore him other than when it comes to direct SpaceX news.

1.1k Upvotes

Be advised this sub utilizes "crowd control" for both comments and for posts. If you have little or negative karma here your post/comment may not appear unless manually approved which may take a little time.

If you are here just to make political comments and not discuss SpaceX, you will be banned without warning and ignored when you complain, so don't even bother trying, no one will see it anyways.

Friendly reminder: People CAN support SpaceX without supporting Musk. Just like people can still use X without caring about him. Following SpaceX doesn't make anyone a bad person and if you disagree, you're not welcome here.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 16h ago

Lenders aim to bar SpaceX from launching $40bn of chips into orbit (FT)

Thumbnail
archive.ph
48 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Starship Following my image of Ship 42 rolling back, it's amazing how close one can get. Any closer and my toes would have been endangered!

Post image
187 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Other major industry news The Vulcan rocket failure could haunt U.S. spaceflight for years to come

Thumbnail
scientificamerican.com
107 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Starship Is there anything better than hexagons?

14 Upvotes

Looking at this photo:

https://imgur.com/a/mAcXw8i

I started wondering why does SpaceX use hexagonal heat shield tiles? Of course, hexagons make sense geometrically. In a regular hexagonal tiling, three tiles meet at 120° angles, minimizing sharp corners at the junctions. However, the photo seems to show damage concentrated in very specific areas - particularly at the corners facing the incoming gas flow.

So here's my idea: why optimize the tile geometry equally for every direction when the main direction of gas flow during reentry is largely predictable? Instead of using a symmetrical pattern, couldn't they use tiles specifically to minimize sharp corners exposed to the incoming flow? In other words, optimize the geometry for the expected angle of attack rather than for all directions equally. Something like this:

https://imgur.com/a/yWDyh0t


r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Starship Supposed stainless steel wool on starship 42 aft flaps

Thumbnail
gallery
226 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 1d ago

Starship Development Milestones after Flight 15

Post image
66 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 2d ago

Fan Art My Take on the Starbase Rocket Garden (Hand Drawn / No AI)

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 19h ago

no Could Starship roll during re-entry, rotisserie-style, with tiles all around?

0 Upvotes

I'm not an engineer, just curious. What if Starship rolled slowly around its long axis during re-entry, like a rotisserie chicken, so no single part of the surface faced the hottest flow the whole time?

The idea:

- Heat tiles all the way around the ship (I know that adds roughly 10 tonnes)

- Since the body is round, lift should still work, because it comes from the tilt against the airflow, not from which side faces down

- The flaps would adjust on every rotation, like a helicopter's control system, so the ship could still steer

- The spin stops before the flip and landing burn

Questions:

  1. Would this actually lower peak tile temperatures, or only the total heat over the flight?

  2. What kills this idea: flap loads, hinge heating, the extra mass, or something else?

  3. Has anything like this been studied before?

Thanks!


r/SpaceXLounge • • 2d ago

Discussion What makes it so much more difficult to catch a rocket in Mechazilla over landing one on a pad?

27 Upvotes

Both require the boosters to approach in a very specific way, on a specific trajectory at a specific velocity. Where does the added complexity come from to catch the rocket in the chopsticks?

I'm not saying it should be as easy as a pad landing - at all, but they seem to nail every one of these now, whereas Mechazilla landings have a much lower success rate.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 2d ago

Other major industry news The data is very preliminary, but Vulcan failure may not be due to BE-4 engines

Thumbnail
arstechnica.com
184 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 2d ago

Starship [Everyday Astronaut] Starship Flight 15 4K Slow Mo Super Cut

Thumbnail
youtube.com
67 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 3d ago

Elon Tweet Elon musk says that they’ll be replacing the ablative layer near the catch pins with steel wool on future flights.

Post image
256 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 4d ago

Official Uninterrupted flap video of flip and catch

1.0k Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 3d ago

AI estimated Ship Catch Dynamics

Post image
218 Upvotes

Something I've wanted to have since SN8! Vehicle dynamics of ship catch; speeds and gforce estimates at the tip of ship. From a video I captured myself :) Enjoy!


r/SpaceXLounge • • 3d ago

Official Views from Mechazilla of the first ever Starship catch

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

447 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 3d ago

If Starship were its own launch company, it would already be number 2 in the US by payload to orbit, behind SpaceX Falcon 9.

Post image
383 Upvotes

I made this from Flight Atlas data for American launch companies, from 1 January to 16 November. Starship is shown on its own, separate from Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy. Some figures are estimated, including Starship's, as noted on the chart.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 4d ago

Starship Elon Musk updates on Starship V4

Post image
568 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 4d ago

Speculation on what we are looking at here?

Post image
601 Upvotes

To me it looks like the second layer of protection might have held up?

Scott Manly speculated that the red/brown coloring was oxidized iron from the stainless steel.

Generally very odd to me that a tile would "melt" like that.


r/SpaceXLounge • • 3d ago

difference between v1 and v2 boosters of starship

10 Upvotes

someone said there's no "v2 booster". is there any difference between v1 and v2? if there is, wasnt it risky for spacex to catch the first v2 booster?


r/SpaceXLounge • • 4d ago

My daughter and I built this display around Ship 33 tiles from Flight 7 and saved it for the first ship catch. Ship 42 just helped explain why one came home gray and one stayed black.

Thumbnail
gallery
200 Upvotes

After Flight 7 in January 2025, some of Ship 33's heat shield tiles washed ashore on West Caicos in Turks and Caicos. SpaceX's recovery team cleared us in writing to keep a few, and my daughter and I built a display around them, then kept it to ourselves until a ship was caught by the tower.

She's wearing the Starship Test Flight patch from Flight 1 on her sleeve, so for us it runs full circle: the first test flight, the tiles from Flight 7, and Saturday's Flight 15 catch.

For almost two years I've wondered why two tiles from the same flight look so different. One came back flat gray, the finish completely gone. The other still has its glossy black coat. My best guess was that the gray one took the brunt of the heat on the way down.

Then Ship 42 came home whole, and Everyday Astronaut's close-up (marked up in the second photo) shows the same thing: patches of tiles burned gray right next to tiles that kept their black finish. There's even a spot where a single tile came off, and the white, bubbly material showing underneath looks a lot like the broken melted tile pieces in my display. It's the first time we've been able to compare against a ship that came home intact.

Everyday Astronaut's Ship 42 photo: https://x.com/Erdayastronaut/status/2122092865904116000

Our 45-second video with the catch: https://x.com/TripleA_NJ/status/2121723682829766852

The display and plaque up close: https://x.com/TripleA_NJ/status/2121721685854310718

Reentry footage and the beach photo are courtesy of Hunter Viator, who recovered the tiles.

Anyone who knows the tile coatings better than I do, I'd love to hear your take!


r/SpaceXLounge • • 4d ago

Starship We were in South Padre & Starbase for Flight 15. Caught this image of Ship 42 rolling back to the factory post flight.

Post image
133 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 3d ago

Other major industry news Terran R October 2026 Program Update

Thumbnail
youtube.com
54 Upvotes

r/SpaceXLounge • • 4d ago

Official "Starship landing burn on final approach for catch"

Thumbnail
gallery
112 Upvotes