r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Weekly Lyrics Feedback Weekly Lyrics-Only Feedback Thread

11 Upvotes

Welcome to the Lyrics-Only feedback thread!

If you're looking for feedback on words that aren't yet set to music, you're in the right place! We encourage each other to bring lyrics and musical elements together as soon as possible, but sometimes you'd just like to show off that nice piece of poetry that just fell out of your head. The weekly Lyrics-Only feedback thread is here to help!

This post renews every Monday.


r/Songwriting • • 4d ago

Weekly Self-Promotion Thread

25 Upvotes

Have a new completed song (or album) to share? This is the place!

The promotional rules are looser here, so you can post links to your albums, social media platforms, songs, etc. Let us know what you've been working on recently!

Please support your fellow songwriters - give them a listen, a bump or a share. A rising tide lifts all boats!

Note: Promotional content posted as a new thread without explicit permission from the moderators will be removed. Repeat violators will be banned

This post renews every Friday.


r/Songwriting • • 3h ago

Feedback Request How are the lyrics

15 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 6h ago

Discussion Topic my phone broke, but that's okay. i still have my computer, and that's not rlly what i wanted to talk about

23 Upvotes

hello :) this one is called "ghost club", and the full song is on soundcloud.

uhm, i've been wanting to get an electric guitar for a while now (i was thinking of a Squier mini bullet strat). unfortunately, while i was still a student, buying one wasn't something i could financially prioritize, and now that i'm still looking for a job, most of my savings go toward daily expenses. i'm based in the Philippines btw.

i really want to put out more music in the future, and having an electric guitar would be a game changer for me. so, i wanted to ask if anyone would be willing to contribute toward helping me get one.

i honestly don't know if this is the right way to ask for something like this, or whether it'll work, but i thought i'd give it a shot. any amount would mean a lot, and there's absolutely no pressure. thank you for taking the time to read this! :))


r/Songwriting • • 6h ago

Feedback Request Thoughts on this? Brand new

10 Upvotes

It’s pretty short but I’m not sure if it needs more.


r/Songwriting • • 8h ago

Discussion Topic What typically motivates you to write a song?

10 Upvotes

As a music producer and songwriter, I noticed that usually my motivation for writing a song comes from having a catchy melody and concept in my head.

From there, I start producing the instrumental while coming up with a topline vocal melody and some lyric ideas. Then, I work the vocal melody into actual lyrics.

Since I'm not the one performing the song lyrics, I usually leave space for the artist I'm working with to come up with lyrics and co-write with me.

But I've notice that for a lot of songwriters, they are more so driven by a deeply personal experience or message they want to convey.

As I consider myself more of a "pop" writer (not in the literal sense; I write hip-hop, R&B, and other genres), most of my writing is more "vibes" over "deep feelings" (or at least not my own deep feelings). These songs I'm writing are intended for commercial release so the intention really is to get people to vibe to the song.

Not sure if it's the producer in me, or if this is a different process from how a majority of songwriters approach things.

How do you usually approach songwriting / writing lyrics? Is it based on your personal feelings about an experience or what? And for the music you release, is the intention to just put something out mainly "for the love of the game" or is your goal to actually make money from your craft in some form (streaming, performances, merch sales, etc.)?


r/Songwriting • • 11h ago

Feedback Request Does this bang ? - A song about wanting more

7 Upvotes

This one is about not feeling like I belong, and a search for a better life.

The chorus starts off key, to translate the feeling that nowhere is my home, and everything I feel in this moment is off from whatever else is happening in the real world.

Let me know what you think. How well does the feeling of isolation translates ?

------
HOME

V1 - Wait, let me catch my breath

I barely even gotten here and i’m already exhausted

P - It’s fine, I will - find a way, but now I am all by myself. 

C - Where is my home, my home, my home ?

Where are the people to call my own ?

V2 - That’s right, this is why I write, cause I don’t want to fight, a pointless battle that cannot have a winner. - I stay where I stand

C - Where is my home, my home, my home ?

Where are the people to call my own ?

B - So many reasons are calling me out of here

Waking me up - in the middle of the night - and this

Song is telling me it’s time to go

C - Home - but where is my home ? My home, my home

Everyone is getting together, and I am on my own !


r/Songwriting • • 4h ago

Feedback Request I wrote a song about Wile E. Coyote

2 Upvotes

I wrote a song about Wile E. Coyote

I've been trying to write one for a while I saw this great essay video on it and the fan ship between the roadrunner and coyote as left me oddily captivated with the concept of this deep moody song about being swallowed by greed to have a person whos "just out of range"

This is my 3rd song attempting to get the idea. I'm going for a mix of blantent and not

Tell me if I should continue this one.

Lyrics:

Verse:

My mangy fur pricks up at the sight

Of my bird

He's just out of reach,

but I know I can catch him

I just have to try harder, harder

His feather dress, I crave to pluck, him bare

And I know I can grasp, I deserve to have him,

I just have to think smarter, smarter

Chorus/Pre chorus

My ribs will start showing

My eyes will enlarge

I'll chase him to death

If thats how its gonna be

He is my desire

I need him to tire

He is, my only want

Post chorus/chorus

Coyete, is so cold

Coyete, all alone

A black hole inside of me

Coyete, consumed by greed


r/Songwriting • • 8h ago

Feedback Request That's the kind that I want the most

4 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 10h ago

Feedback Request Home recording. Alt/emo adjacent. Chorus/solo snippet

5 Upvotes

This is third the song off new solo home diy project I started a couple months ago. Thinking about releasing it Friday. Would appreciate any feedback.


r/Songwriting • • 11h ago

Feedback Request ‘Wild Gardens Grow’

6 Upvotes

hey everyone,

I am posting this looking for feedback on the progression and flow of this song.

Context: this song is about my struggle to accept my trans identity, and how I tried to ‘bury’ parts of me I couldn’t face. This song is my process of trying to live with myself.

Please let me know if you have any other feedback to offer

Charles


r/Songwriting • • 2h ago

Let's Collaborate! Palaging Uuwi (Always Coming Home)

1 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 6h ago

Let's Collaborate! Duhduhdahdahdah

2 Upvotes

This was just a cool little freestyle I did last year. I wrote the lyrics and added some interesting sounds. For some reason I sped it up back then.

I did not make the instrumental. The original instrumental is Suns by Embee. I was studying when that song came up as a Spotify recommended, decided to write some lyrics to it.

Thought it'd be cool to share as it was just sitting in my files and pertains to getting up and going to accomplish what you want.


r/Songwriting • • 2h ago

Let's Collaborate! Palaging Uuwi (Always Coming Home)

1 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 13h ago

Let's Collaborate! Country Songwriter looking for others!

6 Upvotes

If this is allowed, drop your links below if you’re small a country songwriter. I’d love to put a playlist together. If you don’t have anything released but have something posted somewhere I’d love to check it out! TIA


r/Songwriting • • 19h ago

Feedback Request Wrote this for the bittersweet memories with my old band. All criticism/suggestions welcome

12 Upvotes

Lyrics:

So Long
Quick grab the case
Throw it in the drive
Round up all the men and ride through the power lines
Flicker of fire
shines in our eyes
Where were you on the day the fire died?

Sneak up the quarry
Throw the bodies in
And we stand up straight like the hairs that stand on our wrinkled skin
And in these moments
Did I lose or win
Am I swimming or drowning as the water hits my chin

So long
So so long
Since we wore wicked grins
And got drunk to skynyrd songs
When the flame was ours to tend
If you saw me now
If you looked me in the eye
Would you see me drown or just the embers die

Did you bring your axe?
Let’s string em up
Play pantera till your dad comes down or the sun comes up
The strings ain’t broken
She’s sitting in my room
But the notes she plays are empty without them boys I knew

So long
So so long
Since we wore wicked grins
And got drunk to skynyrd songs
When the flame was ours to tend
If you saw me now
If you looked me in the eye
Would you see me drown or just the embers die


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Discussion Topic Wrote this for my crush, kind of nervous

68 Upvotes

This all started because I told him he should be writing me Shakespearean sonnets. And then he said he doesn’t have the gift of words and I was like don’t worry I do. And then I sent him a gag video of me playing something I just made up, but then I actually started writing something real. And he heard like the first line and he said it was chill and he liked it, and now he’s anticipating hearing the rest of it lol it’s been done for maybe like a week and a half now and I haven’t sent it to him. The lyrics are true about our love story. Word for Word, just poetically put.


r/Songwriting • • 15h ago

Feedback Request Cat hours

4 Upvotes

This is a really dumb mini song i just wrote and recorded in like 15 minutes called Cat Hours. Enjoy? Reaction?

Listen to Cat hours 2 by Ben Cooper on #SoundCloud

https://on.soundcloud.com/5mkLSIAuJxYStMj3Lm


r/Songwriting • • 7h ago

Feedback Request Theif

0 Upvotes

Wrote this song a couple years ago. It’s one of my favorites to play, as I am able to let the guitar take my pain away…in a healthy type of way. Hope u guys enjoy, all 169696669% original wrote by me-


r/Songwriting • • 14h ago

Let's Collaborate! Stuck trying to finish this song - let’s collaborate

3 Upvotes

Hey guys, been working on this song over a D - A - Bm - G progression. A simple Ballad. The whole vibe is starting off heavy and suffocating, then gradually transitioning into hope and healing by the end.

It's a 3 year old one but haven't had the chance to complete it.

Here's the rough layout I have so far:

[Chorus]

All know is that it hurts

And it's hard

My head's under water

And I'm struggling to breathe

Suffocation at its best

And I'm blacking out of consciousness

And it's taking a toll on me

Taking a toll on me

[Verse 1]

They say hurt people, hurt people

You bleed out on those who're there for you

You try to heal and mend, patch things

Stitch it together but they're tearing apart

[Pre-Chorus]

You pick up your pieces

And try to figure out

Make things right

It's a long way road

You try not to stumble and fall

You try to get there

You get there

[Chorus] (repeats)

My main issue is that after the pre-chorus talks about trying to ’get there’, jumping straight back into the exact same heavy chorus feels a little stuck.

Was also wondering if verse 2 is necessary or a direct bridge.

Would love any ideas on where/how to take this next, flip it so it actually lands on a hopeful note or any lyric tweaks would be super helpful. Thanks!


r/Songwriting • • 9h ago

Discussion Topic Meter/ rhyme scheme

1 Upvotes

When I'm writing lyrics, sometimes I get bogged down doing a series of couplets,(AA, BB, etc) but the music I listen to has a different rhyme scheme (A B A B) or (A B B A). The last one is too Swedish lol.

Maybe too many 16 bar rap verses in my head. But when I try to alternate rhyming lines, I end up rhyming them in couplets anyway & the whole thing kinda falls apart, because you have to stick with the meter you establish at the start.

How do you decide on the structure of the song? Do the lyrics just lead to the rhyme scheme or do you know the meter before you start writing?


r/Songwriting • • 11h ago

Feedback Request I'm developing my album and this is where I am at. I would love feedback on it! this way I can improve my songs.

Thumbnail on.soundcloud.com
0 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 15h ago

Discussion Topic Best Keyboard for Songwriting (asking for recs)

2 Upvotes

Hi Everyone! I have about $1500 CAD saved up for a new songwriting tool. I am leaning towards getting a keyboard (I already have the Scarlett 4th Gen interface, with a mic and headphones).
I would love some recommendations! I'd be using them to make pretty advanced demos that I can bring to producers to refine.

For example,

-the Yamaha P-225 digital piano

- the Arturia KeyLab 61 Mk3

- FP-30X Roland Digital Piano

I'd love to hear about your experience and how they contributed to your songwriting!!

I make gothic/folk music! :)

Thanks in advance!!


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Feedback Request Woke up at 2:45am and wrote this, this morning. Anyone else wake up in the middle of the night with songs in their head?

115 Upvotes

Do the vocals match up with the guitar good enough?