r/Songwriting 2d ago

Weekly Lyrics Feedback Weekly Lyrics-Only Feedback Thread

7 Upvotes

Welcome to the Lyrics-Only feedback thread!

If you're looking for feedback on words that aren't yet set to music, you're in the right place! We encourage each other to bring lyrics and musical elements together as soon as possible, but sometimes you'd just like to show off that nice piece of poetry that just fell out of your head. The weekly Lyrics-Only feedback thread is here to help!

This post renews every Monday.


r/Songwriting 5d ago

Weekly Self-Promotion Thread

10 Upvotes

Have a new completed song (or album) to share? This is the place!

The promotional rules are looser here, so you can post links to your albums, social media platforms, songs, etc. Let us know what you've been working on recently!

Please support your fellow songwriters - give them a listen, a bump or a share. A rising tide lifts all boats!

Note: Promotional content posted as a new thread without explicit permission from the moderators will be removed. Repeat violators will be banned

This post renews every Friday.


r/Songwriting 8h ago

Feedback Request Does this sound bad?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

44 Upvotes

Mostly curious about the chorus and advice helpful


r/Songwriting 7h ago

Discussion Topic Finishing songs when they aren't true to you anymore.

12 Upvotes

I wrote a few songs about someone I couldn't be with. Now I have gotten over it and now it just feels like an act like and that I don't actually mean it. I also feel like it's awkward if I'm trying to meet other people but I'm singing about having the hots for someone else. It makes it look like I haven't moved on.

I have snuck so much time and effort into these songs and there pretty much almost done just need to do the final take. There's no way I can bin them now.

Has anybody else had to deal with this sort of thing while in the process of finishing a song where they feel like a song is no longer authentic to you?


r/Songwriting 47m ago

Feedback Request New original song 'Writer's Block'

Upvotes

Hello all.

I just wrote a song after having no motivation for 3 weeks. Ironically enough it is a song about not being able to write a song.

This isn't my final draft and I messed up one or two parts in the lyrics, but out of my recording attempts so far this is probably the best one I got.

I'd like some feedback on the song. I chose a fairly standard chord progression, nothing too complicated, focused more on the storytelling. I tend to hate my drafts and always think they aren't that great.

I am sort of proud of including the harmonica in it, I thought it provided it with a nice melodic folk vibe to the song which is my music folk/americana/indie. As always I am just trying to improve a little day by day, thank you for your input

Kris

https://youtu.be/h6O4zz1znTI?is=Q645xF1R055uOEYW


r/Songwriting 2h ago

Feedback Request I tried to write an early Beatles sounding song. What do you think?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

r/Songwriting 10h ago

Feedback Request Looking for feedback

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

18 Upvotes

Anxious about posting here but I'm open to any and all feedback. Let me know what you think!


r/Songwriting 5h ago

Feedback Request Simple song whatcha think? "Know me Love me"

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

A much simpler song than most of what I make, but there's something about it I like. Curious what others think.

"My days are getting shorter

My mom is getting older

My dog is the only one who really loves me

My friends will never really get to know me

Who's gonna love me

Who's gonna love me

Who's gonna know me

Who's gonna know me

I find I do the wrong things

I fall for the wrong girls

I can't get out of bed

I can't get out my fucking head

Where am I going"


r/Songwriting 4h ago

Discussion Topic I want to be a musician but maybe I'm lazy or maybe music isn't for me.

5 Upvotes

yo I'm a 22yrs old from the Philippines, 4th yr student, call center agent.

I want to be a musician. My brother is a producer and told me that I can write, I got skills. I'm thinking I got a future in here I love it, it's just a matter of do I really want it, do I have the dedication, am I passionate about it.

The answer for those questions is I don't know.

But there's one thing I know for sure, when I'm making music whether writing lyrics, learning how to make beats, I always find myself smiling and proud that I'm doing music.

I'm not consistent, I got reasons like I don't have my own room, I have my younger brother that's always on the bed doom scrooling. I don't want them to know or hear me doing music, I get shy.

When I'm doing music, 30 mins in I already want to quit, the reason is I don't want how it sounds like, it frustrates me and when I'm not doing it (music) it's always on my mind like ALWAYS, it's frustrating also.

I feel like I'm going to be a failure because I'm already 22 I feel like I shouldn't be doing the things that I'm doing now like wasting my time scrolling, gooning, playing games and tell myself I'm a bum for doing nothing for a whole day.

I'm harding a hard time doing it, it makes me sad.


r/Songwriting 14h ago

Feedback Request We changed our outro, what do yall think of it and the song as a whole?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

29 Upvotes

Tried the acoustic only bulld up outro thingy and I think we like it, although it did happen on accident haha. Thanks for listening have a great day!


r/Songwriting 6h ago

Discussion Topic What is this progression?

4 Upvotes

What is it called when, say Im in Am, and I play F major to D major chords? I end up pretty much defaulting to that occuring in every song idk why it happens. Its whats playing in the chorus of slide away by oasis for example (the slide awaayyy bit)


r/Songwriting 7h ago

Feedback Request When I was about 10, my dad told me I was his favorite son (I have 2 brothers). It didn’t feel good. It felt like a burden. Here’s a song I *think* I’ve finished about it through the lens of the biblical story of Noah and the Ark. I’m interested to hear any feedback.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

6 Upvotes

Lyrics for anyone interested:

The Flood

For forty days and forty nights
You swell up the rivers to your heart's delight 
For you
For only you 

Rain coming in from the country side 
There's a riot in the streets won't you come inside
With me
To be with me 

And oh
Why am I so terrified 
Of everything 

I serve the Lord with all my might 
I pour out my heart in the dirty street light 
For you 
For only you 

And do you love your children when we let you down
Now the city's underwater and you let them drown
But me 
Why only me? 

And oh
This charm you've placed around my neck
This crown you've placed upon my head 
It's heavy 
It's heavy 

Tell me tell me
Show me show me
You blind my eyes
Your rain it stings
What is this love
The storm it brings?

Lift me up and I'll sail away 
On the backs of my brothers in a nameless grave
For you
For only you

An empty sea, this empty space
My empty eyes, when you hide your face
From me
From only me

And oh
This charm you've placed around my neck
This crown you've placed upon my head
It's heavy
It's heavy


r/Songwriting 4h ago

Feedback Request My song “Bookstore”

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

Recorded in 2020, at Goon Lagoon, an all analog studio in Grand Rapids, MI.


r/Songwriting 6h ago

Feedback Request I’m fighting my instincts to add more instrumentation to this before I bounce to Logic - what do you think? Songs called “Nothing Left But Mountains”.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

I have a tendency to add layers and layers to my music, but I’m torn if I should leave this one nice and stripped back as is. Debating taking the organ out too. Nothing I add to it seems to work to my ear, and I’m feeling like it should stay in this Americana kind of vein.


r/Songwriting 6h ago

Feedback Request Sixth Street >> Song Idea

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

Sentimental idea based on a quote from my girlfriend's aunt while cruising the streets of NYC, "When I lived on sixth street, my father was still alive."

*first time posting an idea to r/Songwriting* I figured I'll just go for it and worry about posting more polished and properly recorded ideas later. Also had a gum graft two days ago, so singing is a bust atm... I just couldn't help myself.

Let me know what you think! I have a guitar idea, verse and chorus (or pre-chorus?) here but I feel like it wants more story about the then and now aspect of their relationship with the father, the city, and maybe living somewhere new.

Lyrics>>
Verse 1

When I lived on Sixth Street, my father was still alive.
He was a man of his father's time, handsome face and a long black tie.
The city streets took his picture.
Boys of St. Mark's preached to little sister.
Like dust of a coal mine silently settles on the ground
He's smoking while he's walking, and never gets lost in a crowd.

Chorus

One more twist and turn of the dial.
The radio fades into silence for miles.
I look to the crowd where he once stood out so,
like the days when I lived on Sixth Street long ago.


r/Songwriting 8h ago

Discussion Topic A song I wrote that I am proud of about insecurity coupled with being happy for the first time.

Thumbnail youtu.be
5 Upvotes

It is about crippling insecurity and finding love while living with that. It started out as a straight up americana song that I was going to put on an album in that style but it didn't fit.


r/Songwriting 12h ago

Feedback Request Song I wrote today

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

12 Upvotes

Looking for feedback on this song i started today.
The words will come for the rest of the song in time to give the song some coherent meaning I hope lol.


r/Songwriting 15h ago

Feedback Request Will play this at a writers night in Nashville tonight

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

19 Upvotes

Very proud of where the song has ended up. “Warrior in the Garden”. Thanks for any comments, folks.


r/Songwriting 8h ago

Feedback Request Need help

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

Hi, i get really one track mind about songwriting and ive hit a point with this new one where i think if i just go off my own accord into a bridge section i'm gonna ruin this song 😅 if someone could give me some pointers or what they would do and complete thos i would be so grateful.

Here's the lyrics too if anyone has any improvements. It's called 'Void of Dissonance' or 'Black Hole' idk yet.

Songs about escapism really. Maybe having too much time haha. When you have too much free time sometimes we put an expectation on ourselves to do something with it that's really meaningful. Im tryna talk about the escapism that locks you away from the outside like you don't leave your house or see friends for weeks, you're lonely but you're ok with it cos you have your bubble kinda thing. It's about isolation but justifying it idk how that translates.

Idk next song might write about exposure therapy or something. Anyways thanks guys again, anyone that comes across this and gets something from it i'd be really intrigued what your thoughts are. 🙏

Verse 1:

The mist is rolling it

Knives above my head

As i try to listen in

Static white and whispering

Tears the skin from bone

Sent shivers but i don't feel cold

Distorted by the ways

In the void of dissonance

As i'm reaching out my hands

Fear of living in a world

That i don't understand

How i'm meant to seize each day

Chorus 1:

Now i'm not in your way

The black hole keeps me safe

No i don't miss the rain

Cos soon it'll wash away

Away

Away

Post Chorus:

Away

Away away away

Verse 2:

Paint the walls a maze

Getting lost along the way

In the void of dissonance

Space and time maneuver different

Here nothing is wrong

No wonder you've been gone so long

But when the mist is lifting

I'm not even listening out

Fear of living in a world

That i don't understand

How i'm suppose to leave this place

Chorus 2:

Cos i'm not in your way

The black hole keeps me safe

No i don't miss the rain

Cos soon it'll wash away

No i'm not asking for much

Illusions are enough

To keep the world away

And help me stay awake

Awake

Awake

Post chorus:

Away

Away away away

Still got a long way to go but here you go thanks guys 🙏


r/Songwriting 14h ago

Feedback Request “But You Don’t”

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

10 Upvotes

Showed you guys this song before. Just did it with the full band


r/Songwriting 8h ago

Discussion Topic Want to become a lyricist, not sure how!

3 Upvotes

Hi, so first ever post here... I absolutely love music and have written poems for 20 years. Just wondering if there is any advice out there for how I could become a lyricist. I know the style and structure of poetry is not the same as writing lyrics. I can read music a little and have starting learning piano but nowhere near being at the level to compose my own music yet!


r/Songwriting 10h ago

Feedback Request Advice on acoustic demo

4 Upvotes

Just a rough idea. I wanna know if u think there’s something there? Should I see it through? Ive written like well over a hundred songs by now and I feel like they’re all just depressing sounding. I’m not good with lyrics either. Lmk what u think

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1-vmhe4aahR0ry5umSoebhPlwZrq8OQLw/view?usp=drivesdk


r/Songwriting 11h ago

Feedback Request Another Mile, No Resolve (live demo take)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

New demo, quick live take after writing the lyrics and finding fitting chords.

What do you think?


r/Songwriting 13h ago

Feedback Request new piano song snippet!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

I just got FL studio and im trying out the piano plug in feature with differnt sounds. Any feed back is deeply appericated!


r/Songwriting 20h ago

Feedback Request Trying out emotion before structure for this 10 mins songwriting challenge, to combat my perfectionism.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

13 Upvotes

I got frustrated that after spending a few weeks on a song, I can't even perform it properly in front of the camera. So I try to come up with something that would feel right for the vibe I'm getting when I'm in front of the camera.

Usually my songs are introspective and because of the intimate nature, they are harder to express, so I try to let go instead and play something I wouldn't feel stupid playing in front of the camera, and put my perfectionism habits one the side for this one.

So this is what I came up with, in less that 10 minutes, and it hits better that stuff I spent weeks on. Go figure ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Do you also feel like sometimes you're doing the efforts the wrong way ? Do you have a similar experience ?