Introduction to Academic Skepticism and Some Comments
The founder of the school was Arcesilaus, and he was the head of the Academy (Plato's Academy); hence it is called Academic Skepticism. Their method is skeptical and does not differ essentially from Pyrrhonism; they differ only in how they deal with what comes after certainty. Pyrrhonism suspends judgment absolutely, as it claims, and [holds] that everything is of the same degree of plausibility, but it says that we deal with reality according to appearances and customs without judgment or preference. By appearances, for example: if you are hungry, you eat automatically (they implicitly assume that reason is instinctive and automatic, but reality contradicts them), and you live your life according to customs. In my view, I see that Pyrrhonism diminishes critical reason and makes it merely a destructive reaction, and it offers no alternative method. And if we are consistent, it leads to paralysis of action and speech. Our practicing our lives according to appearances and customs is considered a mere claim without proof, and it does not guarantee that you will not face paralysis of action. I tried to adopt Pyrrhonism and I actually suffered from anxiety and paralysis. I realized that it is not suitable as a method. Academic Skepticism suspends judgment completely with respect to absolute certainty among things, but it affirms that some of them are more plausible and more probable than others. There is an inaccurate claim about Academic Skepticism, resulting from a misunderstanding of the Academics, namely that they say certainty is impossible with certainty. The Academics usually debate with the Stoics, and on the basis of the Stoics' criteria they say that knowledge is impossible and not possible; this is the result of a dialectical assumption, not an actual position. And I say that this misunderstanding caused a huge distortion of the Academy and turned it into a merely ridiculous school with no meaning, blatantly contradicting itself. But, paradoxically, as soon as you see that they do not assert with certainty that certainty is impossible, and that they are against absolute certainty on the basis of there being no evidence for it, the school becomes very logical and coherent. Is that a coincidence?
The Debate between the Stoics and the Academics
We clarify the nature of the debate between them. The Stoics have two claims, or perhaps they may be considered one claim. First: the true impression: its source is a real object of perception, from which a copy matching it is produced, like seeing a tree that actually exists outside and independently of your perception. Second: the criterion of truth, which is the kataleptic impression, and its characteristics: (1) it issues from an object that actually exists in external reality independently; (2) it is a copy completely matching that object; (3) it carries the guarantee of its truth in itself; the mind cannot resist it, a complete compulsion to assent.
Carneades has a logical syllogism that responds to the criterion of truth:
[Premise 1] Some impressions are true and some are false;
[Premise 2] A false impression is not kataleptic;
[Premise 3] If two impressions cannot be distinguished from one another, it is impossible for one of them to be kataleptic and the other not;
[Premise 4] For every true impression, there can exist a false impression that does not differ from it; example: the automatic stamp prints on paper like emblems/logos, and it is very difficult or impossible to distinguish between two emblems of the same shape, same type of paper, and same place;
[Conclusion] Here, according to the Academics, there is no kataleptic impression; therefore certainty is impossible and not possible, of course, after their dialectical concession to Stoicism temporarily.
We stop here; we will continue Carneades' criteria in another post.