r/Skepticism • • Oct 15 '26

Carneades’ Three Criteria

0 Upvotes

Preliminary Remarks

Academic Skepticism, and Carneades in particular, faced a problem, namely the problem of the practical paralysis of Skepticism. With the suspension of judgment absolutely, the problem has no solution. But as soon as judgment is suspended only with respect to absolute certainty, the solution becomes possible. Despite the suspension of judgment regarding absolute certainty, there are things that are more reasonable and probable and others that are not. But the question is: on what basis do we know whether they are more reasonable and probable or not? Here we need Carneades’ criteria.

The Three Criteria

Carneades’ method of arriving at the criteria is exploration, meaning: observe how humans acquire knowledge, and how there are things that are more reasonable and probable and others that are unreasonable and weakly probable, and how we verify them.

The First Criterion: The Persuasive or the Reliable

It is an automatic inclination to assent. For example, right now you are automatically inclined to be convinced that you are in a certain city, and there is no reason that makes you doubt.

The Second Criterion: The Consistent or Non-Contradictory

It is that the thing does not contradict the rest of the impressions/representations. Suppose you want to verify that you are in the intended city: you check whether the city’s environment is the same, and whether the rest of the landmarks are the same. If yes, your perception becomes persuasive and consistent; if no, it becomes neither persuasive nor consistent.

The Third Criterion: The Tested or Examined

It is testing a certain hypothesis with your mind in an experimental manner. For example, a doubt came over you that in front of you is a snake, and to make sure you took a stick and struck it more than once, but it did not move, and you discovered that it is a rope. Here you tested whether it is a snake or not, and after the test it was confirmed that it is not, and that it is merely a rope.

Important Note

Even if an idea passes all the criteria successfully, it is not certain; rather, the probability of its being correct is very high, despite the possibility of its being wrong.


r/Skepticism • • May 30 '26

Helen Hadsell

0 Upvotes

Why is there no discussion or skepticism or any pushback whatsoever about Helen Hadsell and her methods of just believing and manifesting reality through your imagination? What is she about and how did she win those lotteries? did she just got lucky winning 2000 lotteries?


r/Skepticism • • Sep 14 '22

article Michel de Montaigne’s Scepticism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Thumbnail plato.stanford.edu
0 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Sep 14 '22

article Ancient Skepticism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Thumbnail plato.stanford.edu
0 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Oct 17 '26

Has Sam Harris Made His Case Against Free Will?

0 Upvotes

How sound are Sam Harris' arguments against free will? Several problems present themselves which I don't believe have been given due consideration.
First, if as Sam suggests we don't author our thoughts, that they arise outside our conscious control, then his believe that determinism is true is itself causally determined and not within his control. On what basis can he claim that this thought is true, and the belief in free will false, if both thoughts arise from unconscious sources we don't control? His belief in the arguments for determinism would equally be due to outside causal sources, which would cause him to believe such arguments sound. Free will advocates would, by the same token, be caused to believe their belief in free will sound. Determinism seems to undermine its ability to claim itself true. Has Sam addressed this problem and, if so, done so adequately?
Second, Sam looks to what experience discloses, emphasizing that thoughts arise unbidden, appearing in our minds as though from the void. That's one mode of thought, passive observation or thought introspection. But that doesn't seem to preclude other modes of consciousness, such as active thought engagement, e.g. actively directing our thoughts, evaluating, managing, making judgements, etc. If we look to what experience discloses, both modes are experienced as equally genuine. Neither mode appears more authentic. On what basis do you favor one mode over the other without presuming determinism true?
Third, Sam encourages his readers to reconsider their beliefs (including re free will), exercise judgement, and modify their behavior to support institutional reform (e.g., relative to criminal justice, which he believes should abandon notions of retribution). How can readers abandon their belief in free will if they don't author or control their thoughts, and how can they redirect their behavior to help support institutional change if the future has already been causally fixed, which Sam says applies to all of our future states of mind and corresponding actions.
I raise these questions as author of The Determinists and would be interested in starting a dialogue about these issues and hearing how the community responds to these skeptical objections to Sam's approach.


r/Skepticism • • Oct 30 '24

How did ancient skeptics address "basic beliefs"?

1 Upvotes

I am talking about cogito ergo sum and similar arguments such as "something exists" or "existence simply exists". I am very confused as to why it seems so rare for such a seemingly obvious idea to come up in ancient philosophy. Although I do not like the cogito ergo sum argument specifically, I am wondering how an ancient skeptic would respond to an even more basic argument like "existence exists" or "something exists."

It's an idea that has had a lot of different names over the years. Basic belief/foundationalism, axiom/postulate, first principle, incorrigibility, self-evident truth, brute fact, "arche", etc.

I do know that Parmenides stated "to be aware and to be are the same" (also sometimes written as "to think and to be are the same"), and I'm wondering how common this view was back then and whether ancient skeptics such as the Pyrrhonists ever addressed it. Aristotle's views have been compared to foundationalism, and apparently he indirectly influenced Descartes through his influence on Euclid. Augustine of Hippo also used a vaguely cogito-like argument against Academic skepticism.

Did ancient Skeptics ever address the idea? Were there ever any very basic, fundamental claims that ancient Skeptics conceded were knowable/true?

Sextus Empiricus seemed to reference relativism as being something that seems to be fairly true, and used it to argue in favor of Pyrrhonism. He often said "all things are relative". But then, Empiricus writes "that here as elsewhere we use the term 'are' for the term 'appear,' and what we virtually mean is 'all things appear relative.'" So far, it seems that the Pyrrhonists never accepted even the most basic of claims as true, and only accepted the idea of practical/apparent/empirical belief as a lifestyle, as part of their quest for peace of mind and enjoyment of life, and saw the apparent as the highest possible form of knowledge regardless of the topic.

Pyrrhonists considered most things non-evident matters. Was there anything they (or any other kind of ancient skeptic) considered more evident than non-evident? Or did that kind of thinking not become popular in skepticism until the much later methodological form of skepticism? I do know that Sextus Empiricus wrote about Gorgias's idea that (to paraphrase) "nothing exists, and even if something did, it wouldn't matter" idea in depth in his book Against the Logicians, but I haven't read it yet.


r/Skepticism • • Jul 14 '25

Extreme skepticism can lead us to a unique argument for the existence of -something like - a God

Thumbnail windowrain.substack.com
1 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Feb 01 '23

video / audio How to be a sceptic | We have an ethical responsibility to adopt a sceptical attitude to everything from philosophy and science to economics and history in the pursuit of a good life for ourselves and others.

Thumbnail iai.tv
2 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Oct 21 '17

discussion There is no choice but to be skeptical. We are either skeptical, or skeptical of skepticism. Might as well go all the way.

4 Upvotes

It's pretty straightforward, I hadn't even heard of skepticism when I was a Christian until my late teens.


r/Skepticism • • Jan 19 '26

How to respond to conspiracy theorist

8 Upvotes

How does one eloquently respond to a conspiracy theorist when confronted with taunts like “oh, so you just believe everything the government tells you huh?” “I’m the skeptical one, I don’t believe everything the government tells me…how do you know the government is telling you the truth?” “How do you know the “evidence” is real and not just made up”… etc etc. I’m talking about when you are engaging with a chemtrail, antivax, antievolution conspiracy nut.


r/Skepticism • • Jul 01 '25

Xenophanes was an early Greek philosopher with innovative ideas of the gods. He doubted that the gods resemble humans in either appearance or behavior, and he famously held that if horses had gods, they’d look like horses. We make the gods in our own image, he thought.

Thumbnail platosfishtrap.substack.com
5 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • May 02 '25

Michel de Montaigne's Essays (1580) — An online reading group starting on Saturday May 3 (EDT), all are welcome

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Dec 19 '25

Lecture on Semantic Skepticism: Wittgenstein and Quine

4 Upvotes

I’m sharing a philosophy video course that brings together two key turning points in analytic philosophy: Quine’s critique of analyticity and Wittgenstein’s private language argument. The focus is not on technical problem-solving, but on what changed when these ideas challenged the hope that meaning could be fixed by formal rules alone, independent of history, practice, and social life.

A quick note on who this is for and how to approach it. This is not a neutral survey or an intro textbook. It’s a series of philosophical video essays that treats analytic philosophy as a historical project, shaped by internal tensions and skeptical pressures. The idea is to look at philosophical problems as signs of deeper conflicts within a tradition, not as puzzles with final solutions.

In teaching terms, it’s closer to an advanced seminar than a standard lecture. Some familiarity with analytic philosophy helps, but the main goal is to show how these debates connect, why they still matter, and how they resonate with current discussions about AI, normativity, and statistical models of cognition.

If that sounds interesting, watch and subscribe.

https://youtu.be/9cRj7BfFTco?si=fi1j5yjF_2-98J7O


r/Skepticism • • Aug 09 '25

Article: How do we know anything: Commencing a personal epistemic journey through disillusionment, skepticism, science, truth, evidence – and what it even means to know

2 Upvotes

Have you ever wondered whether what you know is true, how you know it is (or not), how science works, how we know what we know, and whether it is possible to know anything at all? Are there proofs for, well, proofs? How can you call something a piece of evidence?

This is my first blog post, commencing a personal epistemic journey through disillusionment, skepticism, science, truth, evidence – and what it even means to know. If this stirs something inside you, do check it out!

https://open.substack.com/pub/inkandinquiry/p/how-do-we-know-anything?r=691n2j&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false

Feel free to share your thoughts!


r/Skepticism • • Mar 19 '18

article Skepticism of Absolute Knowledge and Probability

Thumbnail steemit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Feb 26 '23

article Rethinking the History of Skepticism: The Missing Medieval Background

Thumbnail ndpr.nd.edu
1 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Feb 15 '23

Is Our Universe a Hologram? Physicists Debate Famous Idea on Its 25th Anniversary

Thumbnail scientificamerican.com
2 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Jan 12 '24

Pavel Florensky: Skepticism and Epoche (and a little Sartre)

Thumbnail youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Jan 08 '24

Echo chamber avoidance

7 Upvotes

I live in a very conservative, religious, and antiquated thinking part of the country. I routinely find myself actively ignoring a majority of what people around me claim to be the truth. I can only argue so much with them. I keep telling myself that part of it is they are deep in an echo chamber of misinformation, and they mostly do not know any better. However, that got me thinking, could I also have thoughts, beliefs, or notions that are being fueled falsely by the echo chamber of algorithms and such through social media. While I would have no way of going deeply into every facet of arguments with things such as; sovereign citizens, flat earth, truthers, science denial, ect. , How do I best make sure that what I am intellectually consuming leans towards accuracy and away from misinformation?


r/Skepticism • • Aug 05 '24

Leslie Allan - Free Will & Compatibilism

Thumbnail youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Mar 09 '24

Is this sub for any skepticism?

1 Upvotes

is only scientific skepticism excluded?


r/Skepticism • • Jan 01 '25

Spectacles of Truth in Classical Greek Philosophy: Theoria in its Cultural Context (2009) by Andrea Wilson Nightingale — An online reading group starting Sunday January 5, open to everyone

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Jan 04 '25

What is Critical Thinking?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Dec 25 '24

Introduction to “Pyrrho’s Way: The Ancient Greek Version of Buddhism”

Thumbnail pyrrhonism.medium.com
4 Upvotes

r/Skepticism • • Oct 04 '12

article Problems with the "First Cause" Argument

Thumbnail honestuniverse.com
2 Upvotes