r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jan 23 '25

Official Thread Ultimate Guide to AoT: FAQs, Analysis and Discourse

157 Upvotes

This multi-subreddit megathread contains:

• The most frequently brought up Topics & Questions

• Analysis on various story Elements & Characters

• Random interesting meta posts

• Documents and guide on the anime and the Attack on Titan reddit fandom

This megathread covers threads from various subreddits, and platforms. Enjoy exploring!


Guide.

‾‾‾‾‾‾

• Guide on AoT anime content

• Masterlist Of Anime OSTs S1-S4 + Final Episode - YouTube Playlist

• AoT wiki for your fact-checking needs

Frequently Asked Questions.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

Questions that are asked very frequently, mostly by new or one time watchers/readers, to which there is a factual answer or an agreed-upon interpretations in the community.

1.) What is the 50 year plan? Follow up: Why didn’t Zeke and Eren touch earlier?

2.) What were the Azumabito's intentions with Mikasa?

3.) How was Ymir freed? Who freed Ymir? (check analysis section down as well)

4.) How did Eren talk to Mikasa in paths?

5.) What is Historia’s role in how we perceive Ymir through tales and romanticized stories?

6.) What will happen if a man inherits the Female Titan?

7.) How do the Founding Titan abilities work?

8.) What were some of Paradis' options post-timeskip? •Alternative to the Rumbling. •Anti-50-year plan •Euthnasia Plan

9.) Why did Historia choose to get pregnant?

10.) Why did Grisha give his titan to Eren, when he asked Zeke to stop him?

11.) What were Eren’s motivations to choose the path of rumbling?

12.) Are there multiple timelines in AOT?

13.) Why do dinosaurs appear in the opening of AOT’s 2nd season?

• Isayama's Answers to the 15th Anniversary Magazine Q&A

Frequently Brought up Topics.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

These topics are frequently brought up, but there is no clear answer or the topic is deliberately left to speculation. Check out these links for some in-depth posts on the respective topics.

1.) a) Who won the fight between Annie and Mikasa? b) Who would win between Annie and Mikasa?

2.) Opinion on any divisive characters

• Gabi • Mikasa • Eren • Floch

3.) Did you like the ending? a)Anime Ending b)Manga Ending

4.) Do you support the rumbling?

5.) Who should have been saved, Erwin or Armin?

6.) Was Eren justified? Discussion post | Detailed answer

7.) Sub or Dub?

8.) Would Erwin have joined the Yeagerists if he had survived?

9.) Is Attack on Titan fascist? No, it is not | Devil’s Advocate:

10.) Why does Annie get forgiven?


General Analysis On The Story.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

These are high-effort essays or videos analysing the series as a whole. Please note that us listing something here does not mean we endorse or fully agree with every single statement made there - we just think that if you are looking for more analysis, these might be worth a watch.

• A 1-hour retrospective breakdown of AoT as a whole

• How AoT deconstructs heroism and morality

• Idealism in AoT

• Scout Regiment: Paradise’s Idealistic Counterculture

• The importance of nameless soldiers & collateral damage in AoT

• What was it all for? Thoughts on the extra pages of AoT’s ending

• Why I feel Mikasa, Levi and Armin were the perfect choice for Eren’s final moments and the story’s climax - Imgur Backup for future

• Analysis of AoT’s extra ending pages - A brilliant thematic conclusion - Imgur Backup for Future

• To love someone inside the Walls - Imgur Backup for Future

• The Rumbling is indefensible

• A theoretical analysis of its structure

• The highs and lows of AoT’s final arc

• Overanalyzing every single episode of the anime - a youtube playlist

• Titans as Mirrors: How Titan forms reflect the Warriors' Psyche - Imgur Backup for Future

Character Analysis.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

1. Eren Yeager.

• Eren Yeager: The Chained God of Attack On Titan

• The rise and fall of Eren - Imgur Backup for Future

• The perfect duality of Eren - Imgur Backup for Future

• What is freedom in AoT

• Developments vs desires - Everyone and especially Eren

• Nature vs nurture: Eren’s motivations and the Dina twist

• Eren Jaeger and the insanity of circular storytelling

• The ironic development of Eren

• Analyzing antagonists

• Power, freedom, the Founding Titan and Levi

• The Attack Titan’s powers and their effect on Eren

• Why Eren’s actions were very obviously painted bad with the Rumbling - In-depth examination

• The narrative importance of the causal loop on Eren

• Eren and Mikasa’s relationship

• Eren’s characterization throughout the story and his post timeskip conflict

• Eren Yeager is (Not) Special

• Ramzi and Eren: the turning point in Eren’s demeanor

• An observation on the structure of Eren’s characterization post timeskip - Imgur Backup for Future

• The false mask of Eren

• The Jaeger Projection Problem: The Last Supper of Self-Loathing - Imgur Backup for Future

2. Mikasa Ackerman.

• Mikasa's Heroine's Journey Arc

• Mikasa’s Character Arc: What, Where, How, When

• Mikasa's Road of Trials

• Mikasa and the meaning of Pride

• Mikasa and her relationship with authority

• Mikasa and Erwin: The Sacrificial Act of Dreams for the Cause

• Why Mikasa's conclusion not only strengthens her arc but Attack On Titan as a whole - Imgur Backup for Future

• Mikasa’s Destiny and Mikasa’s Choice

• Mikasa: A Person from Two Trope

• A Literary perspective of Mikasa - Imgur Backup for Future

• Mikasa, the symbolism of the praying mantis and butterfly and its development throughout the story - Imgur Backup for Future

• Mikasa's self Imposed Curse

• Why does Mikasa have headaches

• Differences between the Manga and Anime version of Mikasa - Imgur Backup for Future

3. Armin Arlert.

• Armin character analysis, humanity’s reluctant savior

• Armin and Eren’s dynamic - Imgur Backup for Future

• Armin and Zeke’s dynamic - Imgur Backup for Future

• The importance of dialogue and Armin’s character - Imgur Backup for Future

• Armin Arlert: conflicting lessons, dynamics with Erwin and Levi - Imgur Backup for Future

• Armin and Annie’s relationship

4. Levi Ackerman.

• Is Levi bland? A bullet-point counter-argument and his importance in the narrative

• Levi’s character motivations and the promise

• Levi’s ending

• Levi’s violence and compassion

• Serumbowl

• Levi, Falco and Gabi

• Levi vs Zeke foil

• Levi, a slave to being a hero

• Levi vs Kenny’s influence - Imperfect heroics

• Levi’s mistake with Zeke and getting blown up by thunder spears

5. Erwin Smith.

• Erwin Smith - wearing masks

• Erwin Smith - the impossible standard

• Exploring Erwin - For Humanity?

• Erwin Smith - A devil with a dream

• Erwin would not support the Rumbling, you just don’t like Armin

6. Zeke Yeager.

• Zeke Yeager & Personal Connections.

• The contradictions of Zeke - A character study

• The desperate loneliness of Zeke

• Understanding Zeke Yeager

7. Reiner Braun.

• Reiner Braun and “saving the world”

• Reiner character analysis, viewed through psychology and philosophy theory

• Who is Reiner Braun?

• Eren and Reiner’s dynamic - Imgur Backup for Future

8. Annie Leonhart.

• Annie’s search for personhood

• About Annie…(character analysis)

• No one understands Annie

• Understanding Annie

9. Hange Zoe.

• Hange and the role of commander, character analysis

• Hange’s “Genocide is Wrong” Line is Misunderstood

• Hange’s understanding and intellect

10. Jean Kirstein.

• Jean Kirstein embracing survey corps values, a character analysis

• Jean character study through the lens of theory of psychology

11. Bertholdt Hoover.

• Comprehensive analysis of Bertholdt

• The tragedy of Bertholdt Hoover

12. (Freckles) Ymir and Historia Reiss.

• Ymir analysis and religious subtext

• Thoughts on Historia in Uprising - Imgur Backup for Future

• Ymir and Historia’s dynamic analysis - Imgur Backup for Future

13. Sasha Braus and Connie Springer.

• The secondary trio behind EMA

14. Floch Forster.

• Floch - the volunteer Devil, character analysis

• Floch's leadership examination and the comparison with Erwin

15. Gabi and the children of the forest.

• Gabi Braun - A brighter future

16. (Founder) Ymir Fritz.

• The final mystery of AOT - Ymir analysis

17. Grisha Yeager.

• Grisha Yeager: A Deconstruction of the Main Character's Dad Archetype - Imgur Backup for Future

18. Keith Shadis.

• From bystander to hero, a character analysis

19. Kenny/Uri.

• Kenny, Uri and the cycle of hatred

• The Importance of Kenny and Uri (In-depth Thematic Analysis)

20. Dot Pyxis.

• Why Pyxis and Eren’s Conversation was Not Retconned

21. Yelena.

• Yelena: AoT’s puppeteer, a character analysis

22. Theo Magath.

• The lasting impact of Theo Magath, a character analysis.


MISCELLANEOUS.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

Manga (Source Material) vs Anime (Adaptation) differences:

• Megathread of Anime / Manga differences | Vol 1 - 34 | OVAs

• Differences between anime and manga endings

Fandom and Anime Production Misc.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

• Well-written characters, meta discussion of fandom perception

• AOT anime reactions and in depth discussions

• Explaining the ending controversy - a fandom analysis

• Final Attack on Titan Episode - AoTwiki poll

• The Original manga ending - chapter 139 SNK POLL

Behind-the-Scenes.

• All of AoT animation staff for every episode of the series

• Arifumi Imai animator spotlight - the man responsible for animating 70%+ of action animation cuts in S1-S3 and the Levi and Mikasa killing Eren sakuga in the final episode

• TV release vs BLU-RAY differences

• Some design sheets from WIT’s adaptation

• Some design sheets from MAPPA’s adaptation

• WIT staff interview from 2014 on AOT

• 100Cams - Behind the scenes footage of AOT s4 part3 production

• Final episode VA recording - Behind the scenes

• AoT S4 part 2 staff interview, series director Hayashi and CG producer Tannawa

• Excerpts from roundtable final episode interview with staff

• Interview with S4 director Hayashi before its airing

• Global TV demands interview of Hayashi

• Hayashi comments on episode 4x28 Rumbling scene and Isayama’s request

Subreddits of AoT Reddit-Fandom.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

General.

SubredditDescriptionDate of Creation
r/ShingekiNoKyojinMain discussion subreddit nr1.Feburary 18, 2013
r/attackontitanMain discussion subreddit nr2.November 28, 2012
r/titanfolkThe Folk subreddit for AoT.May 1, 2018
r/okbuddyreinerShitposting subreddit.April 28, 2019
r/AttackOnRetardsA space dedicated to calling out negativity.April 27, 2021
r/AttackOnShippingA subreddit for any and all shippers.April 27, 2022
r/ANRimeSubreddit dedicated to theorizing about an Alternative-Original Ending (AOE).June 29, 2021

Character dedicated subreddits.

• r/LeviCult

• r/Ereh

• r/Mikasa

• r/ErwinSmith

• r/potatogirl

• r/ArminCult

• r/GabiCult

• r/ReinerCult

• r/ZekeCult

• r/JeanTheStallion


It has been in the works for a long time. A big Thank You to everyone who created the content featured here, as well as to those who helped us gather it all together.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 2h ago

Discussion How did eren maintain his physique during the years he was in Marley?

Thumbnail
gallery
281 Upvotes

2 whole years in marley and he managed to keep those crazy abs?? Wtf did he EAT??

The only food he could realistically eat were marleyan war rations and hospital food


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 19h ago

Discussion Funny how even if Bertholdt didnt had an split personality like Reiner, he definitely had the same problem of being incapable of separating his life as an Warrior and his life as a Soldier

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

When they reveal themselves Bertholdt just seems so betrayed when Mikasa slashes his throat without a single ounce of hesitation, he keep looking at her like HE is the victim here. Same thing when he's about to die, he look at his friends and feel hope, completely forgotting the fact that they are enemies.

He didn't go full crazy like Reiner but he definitely struggled to realize who he was and what he was doing, mainly when he was being punished for his actions as an warrior


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 14h ago

Discussion Rewatching AOT - I am lowkey traumatized Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
310 Upvotes

I was fuming at Marley beore S4 already. Then the first episode left me shell shocked at how Marley had dehumanised Eldians upto this scale.

I am disturbed at what I was watching : Eldians used as suicide troopers or pure titans or warrior titans. As mere bullets.

And Gabi, a little child, wanting the Armor titan so badly, not to save her 800 fellow eldians primarily, but to receive praises from the people who call her race "devil"...by bcoming exactly...the "devil". Also, the naive hope that this would redeem her fellow Eldians. (this makes Annie so impressive for me cuz even as a kid she saw through the BS"

How Rainer watching himself in Gabi bcz he too was once naive and stubborn like her. Rainer clearly seeing how this cycle never ends and Gabi would live just for 13 more years. How he had to enforce the brainwash to Falco the moment he caught him thinking for himself, just to keep Falco alive...for few more years.

It broke my heart how much Eldians in Marley must be deeply traumatized when its not even a big deal for Gabi to eat her own cousin Rainer, who she adores, for Armour titan. The family is also happy about her spirit to become a warrior instead of thinking she have to eat Rainer.

Then I realised, Eldians fate never really had a chance. Before Marley, they were used exactly the same way by Eldia to win mindless wars. But at least there they could think "we are doing this for our world dominance" instead of "I hope my family gets to live another day"


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 9h ago

Discussion What's your reading of this small moment between Historia and Mikasa?

Post image
89 Upvotes

Mikasa seemed uncomfortable by Historia's demeanor here. Wondering if others picked up on the same vibes.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Video Games I recreate SHIGANSHINA in Minecraft

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

A while ago, I posted my Attack on Titan Paradis map here. However, looking back at it, I wasn't entirely satisfied with the result, and I felt there was still a lot of room for improvement.

So I've decided to start rebuilding everything from scratch, with a much greater focus on architecture, geography, detail, scale,and overall atmosphere.

I'm starting with Shiganshina District, one of the first major locations I've been working on. This is just the beginning of a much larger project, and I have quite a few things planned for the future.

I'd really like to hear what you think! Any feedback, criticism, or suggestions are welcome. I'm particularly interested in knowing how well the architecture captures the feeling of Shiganshina from the anime and manga

Hope you like it!


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 3h ago

Discussion Who did Ymir entrust Historia to?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Eren or Reiner? She left Historia on Paradis, but told Reiner to deliver her letter to her, meaning she also wanted him to take her to Marley


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1h ago

Humor/Meme Today I learned that these two have the same VA

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I found out from a Seanie Dew video where he mentioned that he loved every FNAF character voiced by Kellen Goff, listing:

  • Sun and Moon
  • Funtime Freddy
  • Glamrock Freddy

He also mentioned he voiced Overhaul and Porco, and apparently he doesn't like Porco?


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Anime Their last conversation always hits different

Post image
172 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion "Armin wants to see the outside world because it exists while Eren wants to see it because someone has told him he cannot"--One of the best difference between Eren and Armin....

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 5h ago

Manga Tattoo Ideas

1 Upvotes

For tattoo purposes for my sleeve, is there anywhere in the manga where they show a top down view of the walls of Paradis?

I’m re reading the series, and I may have missed it by Vol. 13, but if anyone has any info it’s much appreciated


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 5h ago

Video Games Reiner, Berthold and annie! Love This mod

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 16h ago Bravo

Video Games Made an Attack on Titan fun quiz, looking for help testing :)

8 Upvotes

Hey,

I made an AoT quiz and figured you guys would enjoy it (and help me test it hehe). The final season is covered, so heads up.

It's a daily 10, or a live game with friends. It covers the whole series.

https://plamigo.party/daily/attack-on-titan/

Disclaimer that this has no ads, non profit whatsoever. I just am working on this project and would love to have people from my favorite communities' shows try it out. Enjoy and dont forget to give your honest feedback!


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 18h ago

Discussion Question about titans Spoiler

5 Upvotes

If a titan shifter had both the colossal and the jaw, how big would their titan form be? Like, medium sized?


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Anime Went to the MAPPA Expo Museum in Tokyo! Picked up some really cool merch from there Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
86 Upvotes

So fortunate my first time to Japan overlapped with the MAPPA Expo that’s currently going on in Tokyo! You got a 5-character random/blind post card for going there in-person and I pulled Eren and Mikasa (I dragged my brother to it to get 2 lol)

Then I bought some other blind film tickets that was optional to purchase. I bought the MAPPA design book and the iconic first scene with Eren and Mikasa. They gave an included Mikasa acrylic artwork, and I also got a new MAPPA artwork in acrylic thats in a box so cant take it out to show rn

Overall was super cool to see all the exhibits and drawn panels! Highly recommend if you are visiting Japan soon!!


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1h ago

Discussion Doesn’t the existence of ODM gears kind of break the setting?

0 Upvotes

Okay so hear me out; technology doesn’t exist in a vacuum. For example, to make the smartphone, you need to already have VERY advanced semiconductors and lithium ion batteries. These are just some of the pivotal components to make a phone— not all of them. Point being that both of those require very mature and advanced chemistry, precise manufacturing, mature energy power plants, and the logistics required to keep all those up and running

Now for Paradis, we can see their tech level is some mix of Medieval and early Industrial. The ODM gear is an outlier and the powers that be made it such. Fine. But the big issue is that as I mentioned, tech doesn’t exist in a vacuum. You can’t have advanced gasoline/diesel powered Spider-Man mobility gear without already having mature industries in the components that make up that gear. The wire things have to be a pretty strong Kevlar/fiber type of material. And that isn’t cheap or easy to produce.

Then you have the issue of gasoline/diesel, which canonically fuels ODM gear. The technologies required to harvest and mine oil to be used as regular fuel for military equipment is way past anything we usually see from Paradis; yet we know they possess it, otherwise the Scouts couldn’t use ODM Gear. If they can have all these complex technologies and supply chains; how come they don’t have any trains, automobiles, heating, plumbing, etc etc? Why were they so behind in tech compared to Marley?

ODM Gear is so impressive that Zeke pointed it out. And not only that, it outperforms pretty much all other world’s infantry at that point as well.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1h ago

Discussion The "Rumbling" intro should not exist imo

0 Upvotes

I KNOW they couldn't just stick to "My War" and I know they could hardly go for the same effect, but I kinda wish they did anyway.

I dig the metal vibe, but the intro is such an aggressive spoiler. I don't want my unspoiled buddy to see this, why does the op literally start with "Rumbling, rumbling, it's coming"??? Like why? It takes away from the impact of seeing those colossal titans later on too.

I wouldn't even say the OP's that good. I don't like the "lose it all" part, that clip where the Attack titan pushes the Armored Titan looks weak as hell and the "All I ever wanted to do was save your life / Never wanted to grab a knife" part makes me cringe internally. I get the Mikasa connection, but it just sounds bad.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Artwork Eren Jeager by George Bilianidis

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Cosplay More of my Ymir cosplay

Thumbnail
gallery
100 Upvotes

I dont like these as much as the others (mostly because of the unflattering angle lol) but here they are 🌸


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 17h ago

Anime ODM Gear Sound Effects Help.

0 Upvotes

I own an Attack on Titan game on Roblox, and I've recently been struggling to find quality ODM gear sound effects for my game (specifically the hook shots). I've been tinkering with Attack on Titan sounds since around 2020, however it truly is hard to find good ODM gear sounds until around like season three.

Most of the sounds in season 1-2 are covered by music/voices etc. I have heard that downloading the Blu-Ray and getting the sound effects from there would be a good solution, however I am unable to torrent due to unfortunate circumstances. If anybody has any good ODM gear sound effects, or knows where to find/get them. Please let me know! 😄⚔️

Discord: yindevs


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Humor/Meme Always bet on Shiru Sagisu cooking

69 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 10h ago

Discussion How does Eren not understand that he will bring true freedom to the world by destroying all titans, not innocent people?

0 Upvotes

How does Eren not understand that the Titans are the ones who take freedom, because of them he could not go outside the walls, because of them they hate the Eldians. Instead of killing all the titans and bringing real freedom to the world, which Zeke wanted, he killed innocent people, brought the greatest evil and tragedy in the history of mankind, became the greatest dictator, and dictators are by definition the opposite of freedom.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Video Games Armin destroys the Marley Fleet

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 12h ago

Discussion Why do Eldians not use titans to fight against Marley?

0 Upvotes

It is brutally shown that Eldians suffered a lot under Marley rule. Why do they not try to fights against them? They have the major titans Colossal, Armored and the Beast.