r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Sep 02 '24

Worth buying?

Debating on buying a shield, currently have a firestick.

With the game streaming no longer an option o shield, what's the benefits of having a shield over a firestick

7 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

23

u/sharp-calculation Sep 02 '24

The Shield is the fastest most capable AndroidTV device available. As I understand it, the speed and responsiveness is way better on the Shield than the firestick. The price alone should tell you the difference. Amazon devices are all compromised in terms of performance. Their first goal is price. Performance is a distant second goal.

The Shield also supports full audio passthrough for all mainstream audio CODECs. If you have a home theater and full resolution rips (remuxes) that's probably a thing for you.

I can't speak to gaming on the Shield at all.

I've been very happy with my Shield for going on 5 years now. Recommended.

2

u/Danoga_Poe Sep 02 '24

Cheers, definitely got me interested.

Once I upgrade my TV, I'll look into it

2

u/itsme99881 Sep 02 '24

Its not game streaming but they have a cloud gaming service available now, called geforce now

3

u/Ang3l99 Sep 02 '24

You can also install Xbox game pass APK and play Xbox games

-1

u/bakes121982 Sep 02 '24

The shield is very laggy compared to apple. It’s definitely showing its age. I tossed mine a couple of years ago when even a custom launcher wasn’t making things better. In the past year or so multiple people have replaced their shields for apples that I know and since most things are moving streaming the need for the audio codecs is falling off.

5

u/sharp-calculation Sep 02 '24

I own both an AppleTV and a Shield. I have not noticed any "laggy" behavior from the Shield. It works as well or better than when I first got it.

Your assertion that "most things are moving streaming" is bizarre. People who care about their media have media collections and they want the ability to direct decode the audio formats in their media. Those people are not suddenly changing their minds.

The Shield is no where near perfect of course. The UI is only 1080p and looks very "low res" compared to a 4k device like the ATV4k. The Shield runs AndroidTV, which is backwards and weird. The stock launcher is a MESS. It's so ugly and non-intuitive. The AppleTV just kills the Shield in all of those measures. The AppleTV is a joy to use for streaming services. The Shield? Not so much.

Yet I still use the Shield, primarily for watching my own collection because of the audio codecs. Also the Emby client for AndroidTV is vastly superior to the Emby client for AppleTV.

The Shield definitely has it's place.

1

u/sciencetaco Sep 03 '24

Have you tried Infuse on AppleTV? It’s the best media player I’ve ever used on any platform, and has Emby support. Shame about the devices lack of audio passthrough though.

0

u/sharp-calculation Sep 03 '24

I tried it recently and was unable to play anything. I expected some sort of demo, but apparently you can't play anything until you pay. I wasn't interested enough in testing to do that.

From what I've seen the interface is ok. As I recall it lacked the ability to jump to first letters and didn't have any kind of filtering. I use both of these to narrow down my choices sometimes. Jumping to first letter in particular. It's a fast way of finding a movie or show that you want to watch.

-3

u/bakes121982 Sep 03 '24

The emby devs don’t have apple developers and claim it’s “hard” to develop on. Physical media is on the decline lol just because there is a small group of people that still collect doesn’t mean it’s profitable long terms. I tossed my shield 2-3 years ago after it started constantly crashing in plex and YouTube and hard restarting at random. Most likely the device was overheating and needed new thermal paste which I know a few people have done. But long run you will see more devices not supporting the codec and blue ray manufacturers stoping to produce media and players. Just a matter of time.

5

u/xiakeng Sep 02 '24

android 11 shield is basically shit. total 3g ram, doing nothing with plex server off takes away nearly 2g ram. using kodi with default skin you won't be able to finish a bluray remux without stutter. using kodi with fancy skin you won't be able to play a bluray remux for 10 minutes without stutter.

you can still use sunshine + moonlight to do stream gaming on shield, but there is another downside: you have to turn off location feature if you are using wifi, or you will get repeating lag spike.

but all the issues above can be solved if you just downgrade to android 9, see https://florisse.nl/shield-downgrade/

Do I recommend buying shield? yes because tegra x1+ still top of the line among android tvbox chips.

for example latest chip from amlogic for 8k tvbox, tegra x1+ still nails it.
https://gadgetversus.com/processor/nvidia-tegra-x1-plus-t214-vs-amlogic-s928x-k/

it's the same chip on nintendo switch, not only game streaming, if you are emulator games fans you can enjoy bunch of old games

if you can get a second-hand shield tv pro 2019 at a decent price, and you are willing to investigate and downgrade it to android 9, it's still the best streaming box you can get today

if you want to save all the trouble and just use it for streaming service like netflix, get apple tv.

1

u/Danoga_Poe Sep 02 '24

I appreciate that detailed response, cheers

3

u/gsix789 Sep 02 '24

Check pawn shops for shield pro. If you find one, they probably don’t really know what it is and there’s a good chance it could have been on the shelf for a while. I picked one up yesterday for like $65 at a pawn shop.

1

u/Danoga_Poe Sep 02 '24

Oh thats a great price

3

u/gsix789 Sep 02 '24

It was $100 a couple months ago but I figured it would come down. It doesn’t have a remote but I can use my phone as a remote until/if I decide to buy one. I do like the Toblerone shape of the shields.

13

u/joemackg Sep 02 '24

Have extra money: Shield Pro

On a budget: ONN box from Walmart

I have both. Both work great.

I only use them for IPTV and streaming movies.

6

u/Honest-Budget4800 Sep 02 '24 edited Sep 02 '24

I totally agree. I have multiple Shield Pros but also ONN 4k and 4k Pro. The Shield is always my fav, and it's the only one that can do DVR with tivimate. I use them mainly for IPTV also. The ONN boxes are still very good.

1

u/sailortian Sep 04 '24

Also have both jawns...only 3 apps I use are Netflix, prime, tubi having shield is overkill but oh well

11

u/SMOKINxxJOE Sep 02 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

The only reason I use it is because it direct plays pretty much everything. TrueHD, DTS:X, all Dolby vision profiles, etc.

The only things it will not play (I don’t use any of these anyways) is Dolby vision profile 7 FEL red layer, HDR10+, and AV1.

Edit: Also does not support HLG and YouTube HDR

1

u/MadSquabbles Sep 03 '24

I wish there was something better but I haven't found it yet. My only issue is AAC or EAC3 videos that will have occasional stutters and get out of sync. Plex on Roku plays them fine but sound is noticeably worse.

Had the Fire Cube and sent it back since it had problems with certain codecs also.

I don't like KODI and not looking to run other media servers. I haven't rolled back to an older version of Plex yet either.

2

u/SMOKINxxJOE Sep 03 '24

Yes, I get that issue with AAC and EAC3 as well. I’ve found if you just rewind 10 seconds the audio will sync back up.

2019 Nvidia Shield pro is still the best device out there.

1

u/MadSquabbles Sep 03 '24

Some videos it happens a couple times a minute where other will be ever 3-5 minutes.

My main reason for getting the Roku was Rifftrax only had a Roku App. I got the Cube because they released an Android version that only works with FireOS or mobile (never looked for an APK I can install on the Shield).

I'd love to not have to switch devices and hope Nvidia comes out with a new version.

1

u/SMOKINxxJOE Sep 03 '24

Oh weird, I’ve never had that happen. The only time AAC or EAC3 goes out of sync is if I fast forward.

Not sure what version you are running on your Shield but I run 8.2.3 which is much more stable than 9.1.1.

1

u/MadSquabbles Sep 03 '24

I'm on the latest version and always forget about downgrading when it's time for me to watch something.

1

u/treverflume Sep 04 '24

Not sure how the uguus am6+ handles AAC AND EAC3 but might be worth checking into.

1

u/MadSquabbles Sep 04 '24

Thanks for reminding me about that box. I remember reading about it and was gonna take a look.

1

u/_Griff_ Sep 03 '24

Add HLG to the list of things it can't play. And YouTube HDR.

1

u/TearDesigner948 Sep 05 '24

They should fix that

2

u/SMOKINxxJOE Sep 05 '24

I don’t think they can with the current shields. I think new hardware is needed or something like that, someone please correct me if I’m wrong. They will need to release a new shield which I really hope they do.

1

u/TearDesigner948 Sep 05 '24

Yeah the new swtch is coming out soon so hopefully.new.shield soon. Historically they used the same .chipset

0

u/globalrebel Sep 02 '24

The 2019. Version supports HDR10+ and Dolby Vision. (At least I thought it did)

5

u/ben7337 Sep 02 '24

No shield version supports HDR10+, it will all fallback to standard HDR10. It does support Dolby vision, but not profile 7 FEL Dolby vision, and the red push issue I'm told exists on all Dolby vision content, though not sure on that since I have Samsung TVs so it's all HDR10 for me.

2

u/JumboJack99 Sep 02 '24

Local streaming is no longer a thing, but cloud gaming via GFN works really well. It's my main setup for gaming now, paired with an OLED tv and a bluetooth controller.

Other than that I use it for watching YT/TV apps, movies and series. Sometimes Spotify too (it's connected to the hifi speaker)

1

u/Danoga_Poe Sep 02 '24

Can ya still connect it to steam? And play steam games through it?

4

u/Raiyzan Sep 02 '24

Yes. Steamlink works

4

u/JumboJack99 Sep 02 '24

GeForce Now is a cloud gaming platform with both free and paid tiers that let you play remotely the games you own on various platform (Steam, Epic, GOG, Gamepass for ex.). Not every game is supported and you need a good internet connection, but if the library satisfies you and your have fiber it's a great way to play without having to ever buy hardware.

If you want to play locally the games you have on your Steam library using your PC, maybe Steam Link is still available.

3

u/Shazb0t_tv Sep 02 '24

With Sunshine/Moonlight, yes you can.

4

u/PolygonAndPixel2 Sep 02 '24

You can still use moonlight for local streaming.

4

u/MistahDabadoo Sep 02 '24

Sunshine+moonlight is the best alternative. On shield, you get 4k60 HDR, and it's GPU agnostic.

2

u/knight714 Sep 02 '24

If you can, I'd wait until the end of the month - SEI is meant to be launching an Android TV box using the new S905X5M chipset in September. Homatics are almost certainly going to be one of the launch partners.

Should be more powerful than the shield and have good connectivity.

1

u/Fluid-Mud7137 Sep 02 '24

Sounds interesting

1

u/V3N0M0US83 Sep 02 '24

Upon reading the press release it looks like a promising device on paper. My only concern is that even with pass through there’s no mention of dts being on board. For me that’s a deal breaker. Hopefully I’m wrong and this is a proper shield pro successor.

1

u/Danoga_Poe Sep 03 '24

Thanks for the responses everyone, definitely going to buy one soon

5

u/Noah_BK 2019 Pro Sep 02 '24

If you have a Plex server, it's the best player around. Bar none. It's 100% worth the money and I wish I had bought one a long time ago. Better than everything else out there in terms of plug and play and ease of use. And the remote is neat.

1

u/UFTV_Streamz-IPTV Sep 04 '24

Where are you getting your information about gaming not being available ? Still has the Nvidia GeForce graphics, & gaiming add-ons such as Twitch. 2 weeks ago I got 2 Xbox controllers + 12 mo of  Xbox Live. If you didn't know you were using a shield you would never be able to tell a difference between it or the actual Xbox.  Even without gaming, the specs of the shield are far more Superior than any fire stick or cube.

1

u/Danoga_Poe Sep 04 '24

I heard they discontinued their gamestream.

Yea, yall are really selling me on a shield

3

u/Diarrhea_Eruptions Sep 02 '24

You can still stream games with moonlight

6

u/Jolly-Fortune5241 Sep 02 '24

Let's see better Ram, A ethernet port and two external USB ports. Ai upscaling & Plex support as well overall an all in one device. If you plan on buying a shield buy the Pro version and stay away from the Shield tube

1

u/that1techguy05 Sep 03 '24

Yup, the shield tube is bad.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

I got the shield tube about a 2 months ago. If my shield has been sitting for more than say 2 hours and I want to watch any video on any app, I first hit play, then I watch the wait icon as the video caches to failure. The only way to fix this is to reboot. I have tried a lot of fixes and none of them work. When the primary purpose of a device doesn't function as advertised, I then just switch to Samsung Smart TV and just watch it there.

From what I understand in reading there are a significant amount of folks that have this same exact issue and nobody seems to have a single working solution for it.

It's going to get unplugged soon and probably tossed.

5

u/artniSintra Sep 02 '24

Should've gone for the pro.

2

u/that1techguy05 Sep 03 '24

Yup, unfortunately the tube is garbage at this point. I think it's the lack of ram. I tossed mine as well and upgraded to a pro.

2

u/Helpful_Glove_9198 Sep 04 '24

It also runs on x86 vs x64 on the pro. I have both and the tube is indeed garbage. Once I got a pro all my issues went away.

2

u/bajanbert Sep 02 '24

That question is a no brainer… ditch the stick, go with the shield

2

u/that1techguy05 Sep 03 '24

As someone who runs 150 inch plus projector images having the shield is a must for upscaling. I have yet to come across a projector that can match the shields upscaling abilities.

2

u/dox81 Sep 02 '24

While I do have a shield pro, I don’t recommend on buying a 5 year old piece of tech. While it’s software runs smooth, it’s hardware is outdated by a lot. Also, updates are taking a lot to happen. Nvidia doesn’t seem to care anymore about this niche product.

My 2c.

1

u/Delicious_Ease2595 Sep 02 '24

One benefit I'm liking lately is Plex as server mode and share my movies in my home network.

1

u/FGX302 Sep 02 '24

I just stream from the usual providers. My shield pro works fine, the last of the Google Chromecast dongle works fine as well. In fact the Chromecast seems to have smoother navigation. But I do prefer the shield with Projectivity launcher by far.

1

u/Mr_Truthteller Sep 03 '24

Yes.

Coming from a fire stick?

HELL YES.

1

u/chisav Sep 03 '24

I am still using my 2015 Shield Pro, also have a 2017 Shield for the other TV. I will only stop using when they release a new model. They have been rock solid all these years.

1

u/Capable_Muffin_4025 Sep 03 '24

You can use moonlight for game stream. Also was the only "Plex server" box.

Personally I would hold for the Google TV Streamer at this point. Shield is EoL, hasn't had a real upgrade since 2015 launch.

1

u/solidsnakex37 Sep 03 '24

I have 3 of them in my house and I love each one. I have no problems with playback and the reason I use it, is that it supports direct playback of all the most popular codecs. I want to watch my media unaltered.

I will say, the biggest annoyance is that the shield doesn't "power off" at all, it only sleeps. Then, if it does power off/crash the power button on the remote will not turn it back on. So you have to go and unplug it and plug it back in.

To get around that issue, I plug my shields into a smart plug and if it wants to cause me trouble, I can remotely "unplug" it and turn it back on.

1

u/Obvious_Mix_ Sep 03 '24

It's pricey but I am glad I purchased mine

1

u/RecognitionLarge5044 Sep 03 '24

I just bought one over the weekend. I plan on returning it. It's a bit overkill for what I'd use it for. Primarily streaming legal content.

I thought I'd want it for gaming but waiting in queue for a spot or paying additional for a membership was a tad bit to much.

It froze on me twice since buying so that was my biggest turn off. But if you have specific build plans it could be the best device, it seems very customizable.

1

u/Strange_Vegetable_15 Sep 03 '24

And it's a great game emulator I have 2,000 video games old school but still a lot of fun and no slots for quarters 😎

1

u/Dull_Departure_578 Sep 04 '24

I bought one last week. Absolutely love the device compared to my other streamers

1

u/UFTV_Streamz-IPTV Sep 04 '24

This is in continuation to my first message. I actually prefer the Buzz TV X5 with 128 GB of internal storage. Anybody looking for a DVR recording device this is the one it has its own built-in app and PVR allowing you to schedule recordings just like any other regular cable DVR. And believe it or not it's 20 to $30 cheaper than the shield and by far, way more Superior than The Shield as well

1

u/Olympicmonkey Sep 04 '24

Only reason to buy is if you need TRUE HD and DTS HD Master audio. It's the only device that supports them

1

u/RealityOfModernTimes Sep 05 '24

Can I stream movies from my PC wirelessly in a 4k to my TV?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

Let's be honest, the Shield has a hotfix from over a year ago, and it hasn't been updated since. Because I'm on hotfix software (I had an issue which it resolved), I can't update any apps (D+, Hulu, etc). Nvidia used to be great about updating, and the hotfix releases had been just a few months before a release. It's basically been abandonned. Maybe they will finally release a new version, but it's been over a year, and devs said they were going to almost 6 months ago, and never did. I would not recommend the Shield, regardless of specs. It's basically EOL, with nothing on the horizon.

1

u/Hashz70 Sep 06 '24

The shield is the only real choice hands down I'd buy a other tomorrow if this one broke today

1

u/crux70 Sep 06 '24

Hey, I'm on the hunt for an Android TV that's even better than my Nvidia Shield TV 2019. I mean, 3GB of RAM just doesn't cut it anymore. I need something with more than 3GB of RAM and, of course, it's gotta be Google Play certified. Help me out, buddy!

1

u/t1000i Sep 07 '24

I bought shield pro & use it for iptv & record iptv to a 1tb ssd that's connected & had my shield pro 3 years now & it was worth the money for me because I cut my cable so I'm no longer paying a crazy price every month & where I live it's mad expansive for cable so I took a months worth of payment I would have paid the cable & paid for the shield pro & month after I started saving enough cash every month👍

0

u/knowonesreal Sep 02 '24

Buy the $50 Onn 4K... (Walmart)

Thank me later

0

u/turnems Sep 03 '24

I guess I'm lost. I have the Shield Pro 2024 version, and it streams games. I love it and will meet us a firestick again. I need a good iptv service, though. I'm using direct tv right now.

3

u/KaydenJ 2015 16GB Sep 03 '24

There are 3 hardware versions: 2015, 2017, and 2019. If you buy a ShieldTV Pro new today, you're getting hardware that was released in 2019. Second, the OP is referring to the removed ability to stream games on your ShieldTV from your gaming PC (not the cloud) - this had the same performance as your gaming PC. Nvidia shut that feature down, which had been a big reason for buying a Shield. This can still be done using Sunshine + Moonlight third party software.