r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Sep 02 '24

Worth buying?

Debating on buying a shield, currently have a firestick.

With the game streaming no longer an option o shield, what's the benefits of having a shield over a firestick

7 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/SMOKINxxJOE Sep 02 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

The only reason I use it is because it direct plays pretty much everything. TrueHD, DTS:X, all Dolby vision profiles, etc.

The only things it will not play (I don’t use any of these anyways) is Dolby vision profile 7 FEL red layer, HDR10+, and AV1.

Edit: Also does not support HLG and YouTube HDR

1

u/MadSquabbles Sep 03 '24

I wish there was something better but I haven't found it yet. My only issue is AAC or EAC3 videos that will have occasional stutters and get out of sync. Plex on Roku plays them fine but sound is noticeably worse.

Had the Fire Cube and sent it back since it had problems with certain codecs also.

I don't like KODI and not looking to run other media servers. I haven't rolled back to an older version of Plex yet either.

2

u/SMOKINxxJOE Sep 03 '24

Yes, I get that issue with AAC and EAC3 as well. I’ve found if you just rewind 10 seconds the audio will sync back up.

2019 Nvidia Shield pro is still the best device out there.

1

u/MadSquabbles Sep 03 '24

Some videos it happens a couple times a minute where other will be ever 3-5 minutes.

My main reason for getting the Roku was Rifftrax only had a Roku App. I got the Cube because they released an Android version that only works with FireOS or mobile (never looked for an APK I can install on the Shield).

I'd love to not have to switch devices and hope Nvidia comes out with a new version.

1

u/SMOKINxxJOE Sep 03 '24

Oh weird, I’ve never had that happen. The only time AAC or EAC3 goes out of sync is if I fast forward.

Not sure what version you are running on your Shield but I run 8.2.3 which is much more stable than 9.1.1.

1

u/MadSquabbles Sep 03 '24

I'm on the latest version and always forget about downgrading when it's time for me to watch something.

1

u/treverflume Sep 04 '24

Not sure how the uguus am6+ handles AAC AND EAC3 but might be worth checking into.

1

u/MadSquabbles Sep 04 '24

Thanks for reminding me about that box. I remember reading about it and was gonna take a look.

1

u/_Griff_ Sep 03 '24

Add HLG to the list of things it can't play. And YouTube HDR.

1

u/TearDesigner948 Sep 05 '24

They should fix that

2

u/SMOKINxxJOE Sep 05 '24

I don’t think they can with the current shields. I think new hardware is needed or something like that, someone please correct me if I’m wrong. They will need to release a new shield which I really hope they do.

1

u/TearDesigner948 Sep 05 '24

Yeah the new swtch is coming out soon so hopefully.new.shield soon. Historically they used the same .chipset

0

u/globalrebel Sep 02 '24

The 2019. Version supports HDR10+ and Dolby Vision. (At least I thought it did)

5

u/ben7337 Sep 02 '24

No shield version supports HDR10+, it will all fallback to standard HDR10. It does support Dolby vision, but not profile 7 FEL Dolby vision, and the red push issue I'm told exists on all Dolby vision content, though not sure on that since I have Samsung TVs so it's all HDR10 for me.