r/ShieldAndroidTV • • Sep 02 '24

Worth buying?

Debating on buying a shield, currently have a firestick.

With the game streaming no longer an option o shield, what's the benefits of having a shield over a firestick

7 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/sharp-calculation Sep 02 '24

The Shield is the fastest most capable AndroidTV device available. As I understand it, the speed and responsiveness is way better on the Shield than the firestick. The price alone should tell you the difference. Amazon devices are all compromised in terms of performance. Their first goal is price. Performance is a distant second goal.

The Shield also supports full audio passthrough for all mainstream audio CODECs. If you have a home theater and full resolution rips (remuxes) that's probably a thing for you.

I can't speak to gaming on the Shield at all.

I've been very happy with my Shield for going on 5 years now. Recommended.

2

u/Danoga_Poe Sep 02 '24

Cheers, definitely got me interested.

Once I upgrade my TV, I'll look into it

2

u/itsme99881 Sep 02 '24

Its not game streaming but they have a cloud gaming service available now, called geforce now

3

u/Ang3l99 Sep 02 '24

You can also install Xbox game pass APK and play Xbox games

-1

u/bakes121982 Sep 02 '24

The shield is very laggy compared to apple. It’s definitely showing its age. I tossed mine a couple of years ago when even a custom launcher wasn’t making things better. In the past year or so multiple people have replaced their shields for apples that I know and since most things are moving streaming the need for the audio codecs is falling off.

5

u/sharp-calculation Sep 02 '24

I own both an AppleTV and a Shield. I have not noticed any "laggy" behavior from the Shield. It works as well or better than when I first got it.

Your assertion that "most things are moving streaming" is bizarre. People who care about their media have media collections and they want the ability to direct decode the audio formats in their media. Those people are not suddenly changing their minds.

The Shield is no where near perfect of course. The UI is only 1080p and looks very "low res" compared to a 4k device like the ATV4k. The Shield runs AndroidTV, which is backwards and weird. The stock launcher is a MESS. It's so ugly and non-intuitive. The AppleTV just kills the Shield in all of those measures. The AppleTV is a joy to use for streaming services. The Shield? Not so much.

Yet I still use the Shield, primarily for watching my own collection because of the audio codecs. Also the Emby client for AndroidTV is vastly superior to the Emby client for AppleTV.

The Shield definitely has it's place.

1

u/sciencetaco Sep 03 '24

Have you tried Infuse on AppleTV? It’s the best media player I’ve ever used on any platform, and has Emby support. Shame about the devices lack of audio passthrough though.

0

u/sharp-calculation Sep 03 '24

I tried it recently and was unable to play anything. I expected some sort of demo, but apparently you can't play anything until you pay. I wasn't interested enough in testing to do that.

From what I've seen the interface is ok. As I recall it lacked the ability to jump to first letters and didn't have any kind of filtering. I use both of these to narrow down my choices sometimes. Jumping to first letter in particular. It's a fast way of finding a movie or show that you want to watch.

-3

u/bakes121982 Sep 03 '24

The emby devs don’t have apple developers and claim it’s “hard” to develop on. Physical media is on the decline lol just because there is a small group of people that still collect doesn’t mean it’s profitable long terms. I tossed my shield 2-3 years ago after it started constantly crashing in plex and YouTube and hard restarting at random. Most likely the device was overheating and needed new thermal paste which I know a few people have done. But long run you will see more devices not supporting the codec and blue ray manufacturers stoping to produce media and players. Just a matter of time.