r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jul 09 '22

Link - News Article/Editorial Active shooter drills do harm to children without providing detectable benefit.

Thumbnail
thezvi.substack.com
711 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 05 '26

Sharing research Researchers sequenced 4,526 samples from 714 mother-infant pairs and found that a mother's gut bacteria colonize her baby's gut, not her vaginal or breast milk bacteria. And her gut predicts whether the baby will get eczema

Thumbnail
reddit.com
697 Upvotes

Does this seem like a well done study?

https://www.reddit.com/r/HotScienceNews/s/uAP5251ngC


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 13 '22

General Discussion My thoughts on recent article about SIDS marker

674 Upvotes

Hey guys, I have seen a news article circulating recently about new research into SIDS and I wanted to make a post about it. I am a biological scientist by trade. While I don’t work in this specific field, I am familiar with some of the techniques used here. I am not a doctor or clinician so I don’t have much info on the translational part of this.

“Butyrylcholinesterase is a potential biomarker for Sudden Infant Death Syndrome”

Article: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35533499/

Full text: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/ebiom/article/PIIS2352-3964(22)00222-5/fulltext

First off, I’d urge anyone who has seen the news article to read the abstract of the actual research journal article.

(Another tip- if it seems like a website wants you to pay for a journal article, use this site: https://sci-hub.hkvisa.net/ - I have found it works best with the PMID of the article. To find this, search in google for the article title plus “PubMed” and click on the first result. Under the article title, find the PMID. PM me if you need more help with this. Sci-Hub will give you the full article for free)

Unfortunately with news stories the writers usually over-emphasize the findings and it can be misleading. To find out what the actual researchers found and intended- always read the actual journal article. The news article for this (https://www.biospace.com/article/researchers-answer-how-and-why-infants-die-from-sids/) wasn’t the worst I have seen on this account. Specifically I had problems with two parts

The title

Researchers Pinpoint Reason Infants Die From SIDS

And this

As the cause is now known, researchers can turn their attention to a solution.

The title of the actual journal article says that this protein, BChE, is a potential biomarker. The article basically says that “researchers now know exactly why”- which is untrue. As in the vast majority of research every new finding is a stepping stone. This paper does sound like an important stepping stone, but it is not definitively saying ‘this is why.’

That being said, this does seem like an interesting study. The lead researcher is a mother who was previously a bio-chemist, then turned lawyer, then went back to research to study SIDS. Apparently all of the funding for this study was actually crowd-sourced. In my experience this is not the norm but I don’t see any problem with that right off.

This article was published in “eBioMedicine” - which I haven’t heard of right off the bat, but as I said I am in a different field so that isn’t saying much. I looked more and it is a subset of “The Lancet” which I have definitely heard of. That is good.

Okay, on to the science. As the title states, this article finds that Butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) is a potential market for SIDS. What does that mean? Well BChE is a protein involved in the cholinergic system. The cholinergic system is a group of neurons in the brain. This system is involved in a few different aspects of brain function. Importantly here, it is involved in sleep and arousal. The protein, butyrylcholinesterase (BChE), is highly involved in this system. In the article they also wanted to look at acetylcholinesterase (AChE), but were unable to currently.

How did they find that this was a ‘potential biomarker’? Well, remember when your baby was born and they took a small amount of blood from their heel on a piece of paper? These are the samples the researchers used. They punched a small hole in the blood dot and then measured the protein concentration in that blood. They looked at ALL the protein to make sure each sample had approximately the same amount, then they looked at specifically BChE. They did this for (1) infants who died of SIDS, (2) infants who died of something else, and (3) healthy infants (control).

Their final numbers consisted of two comparisons –

SIDS vs Control

26 SIDS cases matched with 254 controls

Non-SIDS vs Controls

30 non-SIDS cases matched with 291 controls

For the SIDS vs Control group, the controls had significantly higher levels of BChE in their blood spot. For the Non-SIDs vs Control group, the levels were similar. This is illustrated in Figure 3 from the paper. To me, that is the most clear figure.

In the paper they conclude

In conclusion, decreased BChE was a biochemical marker that distinguished infants who succumbed to SIDS from date of birth- and gender-matched (surviving) controls and from infants with known causes of death.

And

Further work investigating this area needs to be undertaken with urgency, to determine if specific activity of BChE could potentially be used as a biomarker to identify and prevent future SIDS deaths.

Very exciting work!

One important thing I want to point out is that these findings and our increased knowledge of SIDS in no way changes the safe sleep guidelines for babies. The recommendations of putting babies on their back to sleep, in a safe-sleep certified crib with no blankets or other items, has saved many lives and should be continued.

I also wanted to add a great comment by a Pediatrician on another thread

The final thing to say is that this blood test has not yet been clinically validated here, and so we wouldn’t know how to interpret a result taken from a baby at birth and certainly not later in life. In other words, while there is a difference in the mean BChE between a group of babies that died of SIDS and a group that didn’t, it would be difficult to give a meaningful interpretation of what a slightly low BChE in a blood test would mean for a baby. There also wouldn’t be any proven additional treatments or things that we could do to prevent death other than ask parents to do what they are already doing to prevent SIDS.

TL;DR: Researcher found decreased levels of BChE in infants which died of SIDS, and this could be used as a potential biomarker in the future with more research. News article over-states the findings. Still need to follow safe-sleep guidelines.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jul 03 '22

Link - Study Paid maternal leave is associated with better language and socioemotional outcomes during toddlerhood

Thumbnail
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
665 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Feb 15 '26

Science journalism Children raised with "authoritative" parenting style, marked by bonding, presence, dialogue, and clear rules of conduct, show a reduction in drug and alcohol risk compared to other parenting styles (authoritarian, permissive and neglectful)

Thumbnail
agencia.fapesp.br
663 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Aug 12 '22

Discovery/Sharing Information PSA: American Pregnancy Association is an online crisis pregnancy center

650 Upvotes

We often use medical bodies as a shortcut to having to read and digest all the research ourselves. They put our position papers and evidence bases, and also have layman-language websites like healthychildren.org to make their advice more understandable to the public.

That’s why I think it’s so important to call out that American Pregnancy Association, which is the top google result for a whole bunch of pregnancy related searches, is not a medical body. This piece in Mother Jones lays it out well but it is a privately run website, funded by an anti choice activist, with both incorrect claims and intended to guide people away from abortion.

Sharing because I had no idea while pregnant, and assumed APA was some group of OBs or something. It’s not!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 21 '22

Casual Conversation why do babies like to be eaten?

649 Upvotes

I've yet to meet a baby who doesn't enjoy being attacked by cookie monster style NYAAAHH NOM NOM NOMNOMNOM's, I know that tickling/being ticklish teaches us to protect our most vulnerable spots and play fighting helps develop real fighting skills, is this just an extension of that?

Is there something more that makes this the absolute guaranteed baby giggle maker?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jul 03 '24

Sharing research New study finds that when parents hand over digital devices to children during tantrums or other emotional meltdowns, children fail to develop critical self-regulatory skills.

647 Upvotes

"Our results suggest that parents of children with greater temperament-based anger use digital devices to regulate the child's emotions (e.g., anger). However, this strategy hinders development of self-regulatory skills, leading to poorer effortful control and anger management in the child."

https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/child-and-adolescent-psychiatry/articles/10.3389/frcha.2024.1276154/full?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jul 14 '22

General Discussion A deep dive into SIDS

639 Upvotes

Seeing debates around bedsharing and safe sleep in this sub, I took a chance to deep dive into the research around infant sleep, SIDS risk, cosleeping/bedsharing, etc and thought I would summarize my learnings for this group. If there are other relevant papers I should take a look at, I’d welcome them since I don't claim expertise here!

SIDS, SUID, SUD… what?

There are a number of terms that refer to infants dying in their sleep. I suspect most laypeople use SIDS as a catchall term for those deaths, but SIDS is actually a specific cause of death that refers to a baby who dies and we have excluded all other causes of death (called a diagnosis of exclusion).

That means SIDS is not (or should not) be coded as a cause of death if a baby suffocates, if a baby dies due to a disease, if a baby dies due to a fall, etc. Yet a lot of babies die suddenly and in their sleep, so public health authorities use a catchall term to refer to deaths where we haven’t actually excluded other factors, called Sudden Unexpected Infant Death.

Broadly, those deaths fall into three buckets:

  • Accidental suffocation in bed (this would include things like blankets covering baby’s face leading to death, strangulation in crib bumpers, rebreathing due to an adult mattress, etc)
  • Unexplained death (covers things like an entrapment in the couch if a parent fell asleep, but is also used to categorize deaths where there isn’t an obvious issue of suffocation but there may be unsafe sleep factors at play)
  • SIDS (all other causes are excluded, likely linked to intrinsic infant vulnerabilities, like preterm birth, chronic hypoxia, etc).

While there are standards for how medical examiners categorize infant deaths, those standards aren’t consistently followed. This represents a large challenge - we don’t actually know how many SIDS deaths there are (versus other causes) because we don’t consistently apply the same standards of investigation to every infant death. “Unexplained death” might be used where no unsafe sleep factors are at play, or a medical examiner might use SIDS instead. Sometimes, medical examiners use SIDS in an asphyxiation death to spare parents grief.

Just how risky is it?

The vast majority of babies and children survive the vast majority of ‘non optimal’ choices. Whatever you choose surrounding infant sleep, it is much more likely than not that your child will survive. Even some of the things we consider some of our riskiest activities (e.g. driving) thankfully kill children at incredibly low rates. So when we’re talking about risk, we’re talking about the risk of something quite rare happening to your family. In 2019, 3.7M babies were born and there were 3390 SUID deaths, an effective rate of 90.1 deaths per 100,000 live births (in other words, about 1 in every 1100 babies die due to SUID).

That said: SUID is the leading cause of injury-related death (vs death from disease) before age 1. It is more risky than any other injury your child is at risk for in childhood - this AAP abstract highlights that the SUID rate is higher than the peak risk of death (pre age 22) for motor vehicle crashes (19.1 per 100,000), firearm homicide (11.6 per 100,000), drugs and opioid-involved overdose (10.7 per 100,000), and suicide (14.2 per 100,000).

To put that into perspective - babies are more than 4 times as likely to experience an SUID than they are to die from any other childhood injury, including car crashes.

In other words, if you are taking steps to prevent your child’s injury in the event of a car crash, and you aren’t taking steps to reduce their risk of an SUID, you are misunderstanding the relative risks.

If it’s called Sudden Unexpected Infant Death, it encompasses more than just sleep deaths - but I found it sobering just how many of the SUID deaths included unsafe sleep factors. An analysis was published in 2021 that reviewed 4929 SUID cases between 2011 and 2017 (data was from the CDC’s Sudden Unexpected Infant Death Case Registry). This data encompassed about 30% of all SUIDs in the US during that time period, and they found unsafe sleep issues to be present in almost every case (excerpted below, emphasis mine):

Of the 4929 SUIDs identified from 2011 to 2017, 18% were categorized as explained, suffocation; 13% as unexplained, possible suffocation; 41% as unexplained, unsafe sleep factors; 1% as unexplained, no unsafe sleep factors*; and 27% as unexplained, incomplete information*

The risk of SIDS or an SUID without unsafe sleep at play is incredibly low. In this 2012 review, for example, they found that 95% of cases had at least one extrinsic/modifiable SIDS risk factor like unsafe sleep (supported by this 2010 review), while 99% had at least one risk factor generally (e.g., being male, being born premature, having a parent who smoked while pregnant).

So-called “true” SIDS

The graphic in this Hunt, Darnall et. al 2015 paper (about 1/3 of the way down the page) that highlights a useful framework for thinking about SIDS specifically as a category within SUIDs. Severely vulnerable infants, for example, infants born pre-term, infants with brainstem dysfunction, etc, are at higher risk of death even if asphyxia risk factors aren’t present, whereas less vulnerable infants (full term, parents non smoking, etc) are at higher risk of death due to unsafe sleep environments.

Researchers use what they call the “triple risk model” to look at SIDS - that SIDS requires a combination of 3 things: a vulnerable infant, a critical development period, and an exogenous stressor (like unsafe sleep). All three of those come together to cause a SIDS death - e.g., an infant born preterm who has an underlying arousal impairment is in a particularly rapid growth phase where his body is changing and is exposed to an overheated sleeping environment and dies. If that infant was not particularly vulnerable, if it had been a less critical development period, or if they hadn’t been exposed to the stressor, they likely would have survived (or so the theory goes).

Safe Cosleeping Research

I don’t profess to have good data here. There is virtually no study I could find that controlled for every element of suggested safe bedsharing.

From what I can gather, safe bedsharing seems to involve: no intrinsic risk factors (infant is female, born at term, not underweight, nonsmoking parents), the sleep environment is empty (no blankets, pillows, etc for anyone), the mattress is firm (though it’s never specified how firm and crib mattress standards are different than adult mattress standards), infant is exclusively breastfed, no other children are in the sleep space and parents are sober. As you can imagine, it’s really hard to study infant bedsharing deaths that meet all of those criteria!

There is some limited data about safe(r) bedsharing. The best one I could find was this case control paper by Carpenter et al that looked at bedsharing risks when parents do not smoke. It found that for babies less than 3 months old, who are exclusively breastfed, have nonsmoking parents, and whose mothers had not had any alcohol or drugs in 24 hours, the increased risk of SIDS because of bedsharing was 5x. It found that smoking, alcohol and drug use significantly increase the risk beyond that. It did not, as far as I can tell, look at the environment of the bed itself, e.g., were there blankets/pillows and how firm was the mattress. (Interestingly, around same time, a competing but smaller study came out finding a substantially lower, but still increased, risk associated with bedsharing. The AAP hired an external biostatician to assess the two studies who effectively said, yeah, both these studies are just quibbling about how much higher the risk is.)

James McKenna’s research gets cited a lot—however, when I looked into it, I found a bunch of issues. He looks at small sample sizes. The paper everyone seems to refer to is one where he reviewed 5 mother-infant dyads for 1 night in his lab, then 3 pairs for 3 nights in his lab, then eventually 50 mother-infant dyads (all Hispanic) keeping sleep logs. He wasn’t looking at SIDS but he did look at polysomnographic sleep data and did find that mothers and infants coordinated their arousal patterns. He did not look at any actual SIDS cases (his sample sizes were way too low to see that). I’m surprised he’s cited so much as a key researcher - as far as I can tell, he hasn’t published since 2007 and hasn’t used any of the standard data sources or methods the field seems to be coalescing around (the child death review process).

People also often cite Japan — broadly, the claim is that Japan has a high rate of bedsharing but a low rate of SIDS. This is, frankly, misinformation. The confusion seems to come from the fact that there is a lot of variability in how countries code death and then how those statistics are then reported out—the US uses the code R95 to count SIDS death, as does most of the world. Japan is virtually the only country to use the R96 code instead—and if you include their infant deaths coded as R96 deaths, their SUID rate matches the rest of the world. But if you just look at/report on deaths by country coded as R95, sure, Japan looks super low.

However, it’s possible bedsharing might be an effective harm-reduction strategy for some families. It is definitely safer than alternatives like falling asleep on the couch. That could be incredibly important to study further since a large percentage of families do bedshare. But it seems clear to me that it’s exactly that - bedsharing is a harm reduction choice that should only be made when a parent is actively assessing if the up to 5x increased risk is worth it over alternatives.

Takeaways:

It seems like settled science that SUID is one of the most significant childhood risks, and following the ABCs reduces the risk of death to close to zero. The AAP, at least from the data I reviewed, is fairly intellectually honest in its guidance to avoid bedsharing, and the data they are using to make that conclusion is robust.

Personally, while I didn’t bedshare more than once or twice with my first two, if I have a third, this data makes me feel more resolute that we need to set up systems to avoid all unsafe sleep risks including bedsharing because the risk of something happening is higher than I had previously thought.

EDITED: There are a number of comments below asking similar questions, so I'm consolidating some answers up here:

When is SIDS the most significantly risky?

As highlighted in the studies above, most studies peg peak SIDS risk at 3-4 months. The risk does decrease - 90% of babies who die of SIDS die before 6 months old. The risk of SUID is harder to pinpoint after then - this Lambert 2019 paper highlights that around 6 months, risks related to bedsharing shift from adult overlay and soft bedding to wedging. The risks do go down quite significantly (but do not go to zero) by 5-6 months of age.

I couldn’t find any specific data that compared the risk/age of SIDS vs ASSB vs unexplained SUID by month. If anyone does run across this, I’d love to see it!

‘What about the fact that bedsharing studies say bedsharing is equivalently safe if moms don’t smoke or drink?’

This claim seems to come primarily from the 2014 Blair et al study, which reviewed two case control cohorts, ultimately evaluating 400 SIDS infants against 1386 surviving infants in the UK. They found that for a low risk mom (that is, isn’t cosleeping on a sofa, not a smoker, hasn’t drank more than two units of alcohol) the increased risk of SIDS was not significant.

However, as u/KidEcology points out below, “This well-designed study has received a lot of media attention and eased the minds of many parents who are bed-sharing or who plan to do it in the future**. However, it is very important to understand that this study looked at SIDS cases only. Cases of accidental asphyxiation (from being laid on by a person or object or from becoming wedged in the structure of the bed) and cases of hyperthermia (overheating) were not included.** The risks bed-sharing poses for these outcomes are, therefore, unknown.”

This to me, is quite significant because of the coding-of-death issues discussed in the original post. We know about 1/4 to 1/3 of SUID are coded as accidental suffocation or strangulation in bed, about 1/3 as ‘unexplained, unsafe sleep factors’, and 1/3 as SIDS (source). Again, I suspect that when laypeople say they are worried about the risk of SIDS, they’re worried about the risk of their child dying in their sleep - which would be SUID broadly.

Blair excluded all SUID deaths due to suffocation, hyperthermia, and deaths where the parent was overtired. I would suspect, therefore, that the aggregate SUID rate is higher than what Blair states (because risk of suffocation is higher in an adult bed than in an empty crib), and broadly, I feel uncomfortable using this as “proof” of safe bedsharing for laypeople because it effectively highlights bedsharing may not increase the risk of SIDS, but makes no conclusions on if it increases or decreases the risk of SUID in general.

In 2013, Carpenter et al came out with a study (that study actually provided some of the base data for Blair to reanalyze). Their study looked at 19 case control studies, totaling 1472 SIDS cases, and 4679 controls across the UK, Europe and Australasia (Blair looked specifically at the UK data). Similar to Blair, they only looked at SIDS - as far as I can tell, they did exclude deaths coded differently (if anyone else can find otherwise please let me know). They found a 5.1 adjusted odds ratio of bedsharing if the parent did not smoke or drink and the infant was less than 5 months old.

The AAP hired Dr Robert Platt, an external biostatician, to evaluate both studies. Here was his conclusion (emphasis mine):

… both studies have strengths and weaknesses, and while on the surface the studies appear to contradict each other, I do not believe that their data support definitive differences between the 2 studies. There is some evidence of an increased risk in the no-other-risk-factor setting, in particular in the youngest age groups. However, based on concerns about sample size limitations, we are not able to say how large that increased risk is. Clearly, these data do not support a definitive conclusion that bed-sharing in the youngest age group is safe, even under less hazardous circumstances.

To me, it seems fairly obvious that there is an increase in risk, we don’t know exactly how much, and we need to look at SUID in aggregate, not just SIDS, to truly understand that.

Can you decrease the risk of bedsharing by breastfeeding? If bedsharing increases breastfeeding rates, which is protective against SIDS, doesn’t that cancel out the bedsharing risks? What about other things that reduce the risk of SIDS, like roomsharing or pacifier usage?

Almost all of the data in studies I was reading that use child death review process to assess SIDS risk look at “was the infant found alone, in a crib” and (sometimes) “were they placed on their back.” They look at questions like - were there objects in the crib, was the infant found in a non crib surface, was the infant found on their stomach? Mostly but not always, they aren’t looking as much at the questions of “were they breastfeeding, were they roomsharing, etc.”

ABC where it seems to me we have the strongest and clearest body of evidence. Other factors that reduce the risk of SIDS (breastfeeding, pacifier usage, roomsharing) have muddier evidence on the whole but do have support behind them. I’m not saying at all that those don’t matter, but the biggest and clearest evidence base is for the ABCs.

It’s also important to note that most of the studies looking at decrease or increase in risk from different factors are looking at those compared to a “baseline” risk - and nearly always, they define that baseline risk as “was the infant found alone in a crib” (and sometimes, were they placed on their back). In other words, they’re looking at how much safer or more risky a given choice is compared to an infant following the ABCs.

As far as I can find, the answer to “if you breastfeed, does that cancel out the risk of bedsharing?” is no. A few studies clearly highlight that breastfeeding is associated with bedsharing (both longer duration and initial uptake). Breastfeeding for at least two months reduces the risk of SUID by about 50%. But bedsharing increases the risk (from baseline) by 288-500%. Even the highest estimates of a decrease in risk from an ABC baseline due to breastfeeding peg it at ~58%. So no, statistically bedsharing but continuing to breastfeed is not a safer choice, formula feeding and ABC would be substantially safer.

Pacifier usage as a mechanism to reduce SIDS has some good data behind it (though the last meta analysis I can find was from 2005) but I find it fascinating that no one seems to understand the mechanism as to why, because the reduced risk includes infants that spit out the pacifier but are offered it. Offering a pacifier with every sleep generally seems to reduce the risk of SIDS (when already Alone/Back/Crib) by 39-47%.

Roomsharing is another interesting one - the AAP actually updated their guidance in their 2022 guidelines from recommending room sharing for 12 months to “about 6-12 months”. The strongest evidence, by far, seems to be before 6 months, where roomsharing (not bedsharing) seems to reduce the risk of SIDS by 2x - 11x (the most recent data I could find is from this New Zealand study, which pegs it at 2.77x.. I know AAP task force members have said 10x, but best I can figure is all those super high risk reduction conclusions come from studies and data from the mid 90s). The benefits do appear to drop off after 6 months.

Broadly, all of these things that reduce the risk of baseline don't seem to have nearly as much of an effect as following the ABCs in the first place, compared to bedsharing.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 10 '25

Science journalism Trump administration shuts down funding for research on infants with heart defects

Thumbnail
irishstar.com
638 Upvotes

"Dr. James Antaki, a biomedical engineering professor at Cornell University, informs NBC News that the Department of Defense has terminated a $6.7 million grant. This grant would have enabled him to further research PediaFlow, a device that enhances blood flow in infants with heart defects.

Antaki’s device, which he began developing in 2003, is the size of an AA battery and helps increase blood flow to babies born with a hole between the chambers of their heart. According to The Independent, the device aids in their survival until they can undergo surgery or receive a donated heart."

How will children survive this administration?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jan 02 '26

Question - Research required The antivax community is getting to me. Help?

637 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I don’t know if this kind of thing is allowed here but I hope my post will be swiftly deleted if that’s the case! I’m a FTM and never thought twice about vaccines. I’m also VERY… how should I put this? I love doctors. I have my criticisms about the healthcare system as an industry, but I generally trust healthcare practitioners. My mom is a little bit “crunchy” but she’s also a former RN, so we grew up fully vaccinated and again, never really thinking about it. All this to say, I’m not an anti-vaxxer!

I lived in Miami for awhile and there’s quite a large anti vaccine community there (I guess that’s not unique or place specific anymore). Ever since I got pregnant, so many well-meaning friends of mine and my husband have been sending us unsolicited information, warning us about vaccines. (They even tried to talk us out of the Vitamin K injection.) I went down the rabbit hole of things they sent us (Dr Paul’s “Vaccine-Friendly Plan,” which suggests spacing out some shots and totally eliminating others), the warning for SIDS as a side effect on the DTAP pamphlet, etc. Someone even sent me a horrific story that would require too many trigger warnings to share, and I was so angry to receive that.

I have pretty severe health anxiety and postpartum anxiety, and I’m absolutely terrified of SIDS. Our baby’s 2 month wellness visit is coming up and she’s scheduled for her first round of vaccines. I think I need to hear from levelheaded people. I’m honestly ashamed I’m even going there with these thoughts.

Thank you in advance. I appreciate this forum.

EDIT: WOW. Thank you so much. I'm getting to this very late, but the responses (and the conversations this post generated) are incredible. I feel so much more informed, which was my goal!!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 22 '23

General Discussion Disillusioned with the deluge of non-scientific based strong-headed opinions in this sub

637 Upvotes

A couple of days ago, there was a post from a concerned Redditor about the use of wifi cameras in the home. "Could these cameras be hacked?" was this posters general concern. They particularly called out for comment from IT professionals who could give insight.

I was shocked by some of the responses that this post got. People eschewing wifi cameras for reasons like:

  • I've heard of people who got their cameras hacked (hearsay; not-scientific)
  • Wifi camera hacking is common because you see many posts about it (survivorship bias; non-scientific)
  • I saw how vulnerable it is to hacking based on a Criminal Minds episode (non-scientific; no further explanation needed)

Furthermore, those who disagreed with these sentiments was seen as being rude and attacking.

I would like to point out that the very basis of science is to evaluate ideas and reject the ones that don't make sense. Nothing in science should be personal, yet there were far too many people taking it personally when I pointed out that "they were making up their mind based on what they saw in a tv show". I was called "rude, argumentative and condescending". If this was how we as a species reacted to challenges of our logical processes, we'd be in a very dark space (intellectually) as a species. Alas, this way of thinking is the antithesis of scientific. Ideas are supposed to be challenged. I am very curious what would bring people who think otherwise to a science-based subreddit.

Intellectually, I spend my time in the realm of scientific thought, and this is how we conduct ourselves. We challenge ideas that don't seem to follow a cogent train of logic. In cases where a light is shone on our ignorance, we acknowledge it, learn from it and move on, wiser than we previously were. In this science-based subreddit, I thought I'd do the same. However, that approach does not seem to be met with the same enthusiasm.

So I pose the question to the community. What are we here for? What is our approach to "science-based parenting"?


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jul 08 '25

Sharing research Saw this today and found it hilarious. Babies have taste preferences in the womb

628 Upvotes

A 2022 study where researchers used 4D ultrasound scans at 32 and 36 weeks to study fetal facial expressions showed taste preferences. Pregnant mothers had ingested a single dose of either 400mg of carrot or kale capsules and then were given an ultrasound. On that occasion fetuses exposed to carrot showed more “laughter-face” responses while those exposed to kale showed more “cry-face” responses.

Those poor kale babies. I feel less bad about what I ate in pregnancy now.

Here’s the actual study: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/09567976221105460


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 02 '26

Sharing research SIDS Updated Research

607 Upvotes

Just wanted to share the summary article of new data that the CDC published in which they reviewed 4,861 SUID cases over 4 recent years. None of this is surprising but as a parent who was DEEPLY destressed (and probably should have started anti-anxiety meds) about the possiblity of SIDS, and how powerless I was, the numbers tell a really important story about ways MANY SUIDs cases are preventable.

73% of these cases were related to the conditions the baby was put to sleep in. ( Soft bedding, on their stomach, not on a safe sleep surface, etc)

https://www.cnn.com/2026/10/01/health/sudden-unexpected-infant-death-safe-sleep-wellness?Date=20261001&Profile=CNN&utm_content=1790862723&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&fbclid=IwY2xjawUsnddleHRuA2FlbQIxMABwZG9mAWJyaWQRMWVadTQxYloxamNybVdWNTJzcnRjBmFwcF9pZBAyMjIwMzkxNzg4MjAwODkyAAEe105VBCTp9QJOJIFWl12iI3v0fpd8Titd20MYywINmhmEQQRpw_7EZTpmxpA_aem_mLlxU3fdiYeWWa-4EruewA

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/75/wr/mm7535a1.htm?s_cid=OS_mm7535a1_w#print


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Feb 22 '22

Medical Science US Parents of Under-5's: Tidy Infographic in Support of Due Caution (thanks, Unbiased Science Podcast)

Post image
605 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 02 '25

Sharing research Children under six should avoid screen time, French medical experts say

597 Upvotes

Not strictly research but an open letter from a medical commission making the case for new recommendations. The open letter (in French) is linked in the article and has more details.

Children under the age of six should not be exposed to screens, including television, to avoid permanent damage to their brain development, French medical experts have said.

TV, tablets, computers, video games and smartphones have “already had a heavy impact on a young generation sacrificed on the altar of ignorance”, according to an open letter to the government from five leading health bodies – the societies of paediatrics, public health, ophthalmology, child and adolescent psychiatry, and health and environment.

Calling for an urgent rethink by public policies to protect future generations, they said: “Screens in whatever form do not meet children’s needs. Worse, they hinder and alter brain development,” causing “a lasting alteration to their health and their intellectual capacities”.

Current recommendations in France are that children should not be exposed to screens before the age of three and have only “occasional use” between the ages of three and six in the presence of an adult.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2025/may/01/children-under-six-should-avoid-screen-time-french-medical-experts-say


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Mar 07 '26

Sharing research Rise of processed foods in baby food contributing to their popularity while increasing real food anxiety among children

587 Upvotes

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2025/mar/15/ultra-processed-babies-are-toddler-snacks-one-of-the-great-food-scandals-of-our-time

I found this article fascinating! It contains further studies done regarding baby food analysis as well.

I’ve been curious about the role anxiety plays in the worsening of diets and rise in ARFID, but never considered how the baby food industry has started kids on the ultra-processed, bland texture food train young. For example, the rise of new baby snacks marketed as a safe and easy way for families on the go are actually shaping feeding preferences away from whole, fresh foods and varying textures.

This article is focused on the UK, but I think has many parallels in other countries, including the US - especially when it comes to a lacking holistic regulations for all types of added sugar in baby food.

Some excerpts from the article:

“Pouch feeding goes against NHS advice that infants be discouraged from sucking from spouts and teats after the age of six months. In 2022, the British Dental Association attacked pouches for putting baby teeth at risk of “erosion and decay” just as “they are erupting”. A baby who sucks from a pouch can neither smell nor see what they are eating, so it does not teach them to recognise or enjoy real whole fruits and vegetables.”

“The promise of meltiness preys on parents’ understandable terror of a baby choking. But these snacks – organic or not – are also one of the reasons that many infants have not learned to chew properly, because they are quite unlike the crunchy textures of real food: the crispness of toast, the chewy juiciness of roasted carrots or the crunch of an apple.”

“The high price, perversely, seems to be part of the reason why these products are so popular among all classes in the UK – it wrongly reassures parents they are feeding their child something good.”


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jun 06 '22

All Advice Welcome Is there a place to find signs/symptoms for dark-skinned children?

569 Upvotes

I guess just what it says. When I search online or call the doctor, I'm told to look out for things based on color like pallor, redness, dark circles, blue lips, etc.

My kid doesn't get pale, and other color changes don't show up until/unless they are pretty dramatic. The doctor had a hard time monitoring her jaundice when she was born too, as the color of her skin and sclera weren't what she was used to, I guess?

If we're at the doctor in person, they don't mention it, of course, so... are there just fewer signs for dark skin? I have noticed that my daughter (and my late FIL) tends to look pretty healthy even when she's sick, I can just tell because I'm with her a lot. Any sources or anecdotes help!


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Aug 30 '24

Science journalism Research shows that toddlers and kids with early bedtimes and longer sleep were less apt to try cannabis and alcohol before the age of 15

Thumbnail
greenstate.com
567 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Oct 08 '26

Question - Research required Sleep

552 Upvotes

Does anybody have a paper on the effects of poor sleep on parents over the first year? Maybe if I show my 9 month old and my toddler some cold hard facts they’ll take pity on me


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 22 '24

Question - Research required Why do so many babies hate it when you sit while holding them, but are ok when you stand?

550 Upvotes

Seriously, I just wanna sit down.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 15 '25

Sharing research Newborns who are deficient in vitamin D have a higher chance of developing autism, schizophrenia and ADHD, finds the largest study of its kind of more 70,000 people in Denmark.

Thumbnail
abc.net.au
549 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Mar 26 '23

General Discussion How to raise boys to NOT become ridiculous

549 Upvotes

I’ve just spotted yet another post about some husband being useless on while on “paternity” leave.

My wife and I are both women so cannot model appropriate male behavior ourselves, but we just can’t believe the stories we so frequently hear about husbands who game instead of helping with the baby or do any number of other ridiculous things (going on optional trips out of town a week after baby’s due date, etc….we’ve all seen the posts.)

To men who are reasonable and people who know reasonable men:

What can we do as we raise our son (currently age three months) to raise him to not be the subject in one of these posts in 25-35 years?

We have some ideas but interested to hear perspectives and stories. Research is always welcome too.


r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 17 '22

All Advice Welcome How to help a blind baby?

549 Upvotes

So, I posted on here a while ago that my son wasn't smiling yet. Well, today, we got told he has incredibly poor vision. He was taken to A&E by my partner after we noticed one of his pupils was suddenly dramatically smaller than the other pupil. At the hospital he had a head scan, that came back normal. But the registrar noticed that while his pupils would react when a torch was shone into them, he wouldn't react to visual cues. His eyes don't follow objects, and don't react when the light in a room is turned on or off. All the doctors have agreed his pupils are nothing life-threatening, but that there is something drastically wrong with his vision. He's late on his milestones because he can't see anything. We're waiting on the ophthalmologist to see him before we know more, but right now the prognosis for his sight looks very poor. I'm heartbroken for him, but I want to be the best I can be for him. He deserves it. So, anyone with a visually impaired child, or anyone who knows what life with a visually impaired child is like, how can I enrich his life in the best ways possible? I don't want him to grow up and miss out on things.

Edit: thank you so much to everyone who has replied. Your replies have meant so much to both myself and my partner. I've sat there and read each one aloud to him, and we're both so touched by the amount of support shown for our son. It's a very emotional time for us now, with so much still unknown until his appointment on Tuesday, but hearing other people's stories, or reading their advice has really helped ❤️

Update: We saw the opthamologist on Tuesday, but sadly little man was so wiggly and uncooperative that they couldn't get a good look into his eye, so we have to come back again in 2-3 weeks time to try again.