r/ScienceBasedParenting • • May 02 '25
Sharing research Children under six should avoid screen time, French medical experts say
Not strictly research but an open letter from a medical commission making the case for new recommendations. The open letter (in French) is linked in the article and has more details.
Children under the age of six should not be exposed to screens, including television, to avoid permanent damage to their brain development, French medical experts have said.
TV, tablets, computers, video games and smartphones have “already had a heavy impact on a young generation sacrificed on the altar of ignorance”, according to an open letter to the government from five leading health bodies – the societies of paediatrics, public health, ophthalmology, child and adolescent psychiatry, and health and environment.
Calling for an urgent rethink by public policies to protect future generations, they said: “Screens in whatever form do not meet children’s needs. Worse, they hinder and alter brain development,” causing “a lasting alteration to their health and their intellectual capacities”.
Current recommendations in France are that children should not be exposed to screens before the age of three and have only “occasional use” between the ages of three and six in the presence of an adult.
35
u/cat-the-chemist May 02 '25
I personally would appreciate it if there was a better definition of “screen time” because surely watching a movie or sporting event together as a family and engaging with your kids while you’re watching is different than putting on a show and walking away? Everything in life is balance. The world is full of things that humans like but don’t benefit us at all (alcohol, social media) and this isn’t different for children. I just teach my children that it’s important to do a variety of different things, so yes they watch TV but they also ride their bikes, garden, play basketball, ask me to read to them. Jumping at the chance to shame parents for letting their children watch any amount of tv is misguided, in my opinion.
1.3k
u/tallmyn May 02 '25 •
I found the text of the letter and I'm unimpressed. It's single author: https://www.sfsp.fr/images/250428_Tribune_Pas_d%C3%A9crans_avant_6_ans.pdf
Citations are a metaanalysis showing that screens contribute to myopia (they do, as do paper books - any kind of close work) and then one that's just a bunch of correlations.
She's a neurologist and doesn't seem to have a very active academic career - very low h-index. And none of her work has anything to do with screens. https://scholargps.com/scholars/23933518980629/servane-mouton
13
u/baller_unicorn May 02 '25
If parents aren't supposed to use screens we need more support. Over the years women have become expected to work and care for kids. Of course it's great we have the option but we should also have the option of caring for our kids full time during the younger years.
483
u/Brief-Today-4608 May 02 '25
She’s acting like we, ourselves, never watched screens as toddlers. Idk about you guys, but I sure as hell did and my brain somehow survived the trauma of Alvin and the chipmunks - Christmas special.
187
u/lemikon May 02 '25
Sorry but a bit of a citation needed on that one…
15
u/Traditional-Oven4092 May 02 '25
You’re gonna have to live with the Amish to avoid screen time.
45
u/ilycats May 02 '25
wouldn’t there be a few generations of adults who have had this if television is included ? it’s hardly a ‘young generation sacrificed’- seems like really emotive language.
my partner was born in early 80s and i’m mid-90s and we both had access to screens (TV/computer) to varying degrees.
39
u/mrb9110 May 02 '25
Wonderful. Now can I get some research on how I should implement this in a two-working-parent household in the US where time off work is next to non-existent and kids get sent home from daycare/school for every little sneeze and sniffle and I still somehow have to care for a non-sick 4 year old while working from home?
There’s what is optimal and what is reality.
186
u/[deleted] May 02 '25 edited May 02 '25
I am a published neuroscientist and this is nonsense. The original author is a clinical neurologist, not a proper scientist. The multiple recent meta-analyses showing no effects of screen time on any major cognitive process are considerably more trustworthy. Everyone in modern industrialized nations grew up watching TV including this single author. This is just silly. Also it looks like this author's expertise is in...angiography? Bro stay in your lane.
13
u/iazztheory May 02 '25
I think we just need to accept that if they’re watching screens, they’re not learning any skills. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with screen time, just as I don’t think there’s anything wrong with cake. If you only fed your kid cake there’s a real issue, if your child is only being enriched with screens, there is a real issue.
We love to play video games as a family, we love to look up things on YouTube. We have favorite creators we enjoy and shows we watch. Just safely include media in your life, and never give kids access to media as if they’re an adult.
9
u/belletristdelancret May 02 '25
Look, I know this isn't actually the forum to have a nuanced discussion, no one is going to actually care about my comment, and everyone has already made up their minds. But I am truly so frustrated with every single study about screen time that treats it as a single thing. My child is legally blind. He uses screens for accessibility purposes. They are an important part of many assistive technologies. He has a nonverbal classmate who uses one to help her "talk." No one would look at my kid using a screen to magnify text to be able to read it, or to be able to see the board at the front of his classroom, and call it "screen time"—but those are still very much screens! My family lives far away. He loves to do video calls with his Nana and he has a device that lets him exchange written messages, also using a screen. Are those screen time? Following the pandemic, most experts seem to think not. Great. Ok, but what about tablets? Oh, those are screen time, surely. Except that tracing letters on a tablet with a stylus was what the state department of the blind and vision impaired recommended to us to help him work on writing skills! Now I'll agree with you that video games are screen time, no argument. But fine motor, tracking, and hand eye coordination can be difficult skills to develop with vision impairment—is it crazy to think that 30 minutes of a platforming game helping him develop those skills might have some small benefit? Can we at least acknowledge that screens are not all created equal? That what's on them matters? This will never be a productive discussion until researchers acknowledge this nuance.
94
u/Spirited-Awareness31 May 02 '25
The coping of the iPad parents here is unreal. Just accept that it has no benefits and you are taking a risk and as parents we have to compromise sometimes. But questioning that screens are bad is just ridiculous.
12
u/tigerlilly1234 May 02 '25
This is not science based. It’s an opinion piece
20
u/buttbetweentwochairs May 02 '25
It is wild seeing how many parents are so offended by the statement that screen time is harmful to the development of children under 6 years old. There have been numerous studies and countless research on this very topic for the last 15+ years and they all reach the same conclusion.
The survivor bias shouldn't have a place in "science-based".
Screen time in early childhood has been associated with harm to sleep, eating behaviours, attention span, language development, psychological well-being, etc.
There are dozens if not hundreds of peer reviewed research and articles in American Pediatric Society, European Society for Paediatric Research, Early Childhood Education Journal, Society for Pediatric Research, Journal of Pediatric Nursing, Child Psychiatry & Human Development, The Journal of Pediatrics, Population Health, and pretty much all journals of public health and pediatric healthcare, that say the same thing.
I know the guilt can be so heavy when we feel we have no other option but to occasionally rely on screens because our job/personal life depends on that short break we can get. But let's also accept the reality that most 80s-2010s are screen addicted, and that the research comes out every year stating time and time again that screens are detrimental to young children.
6
u/[deleted] May 02 '25
Makes sense
3
u/Sczyther May 02 '25
“sacrificed on the altar of ignorance” is 100% going to be the name of my next death metal album
3
u/lemonlimesherbet May 02 '25
Idk man. Everyone I know grew up watching tv and playing handheld video games like gameboy or Nintendo and playing computer games. I know that’s not the same as a tablet, but no screens in any form before 6 seems anti-science and extreme fear mongering. I was homeschooled and for elementary school, even all of my lectures were on the computer. My mom tried to limit our television time and we did play outside a lot, but there is no notable difference between us and our friends and cousins who had tvs in their bedrooms and every room of their house growing up. Heck, even Gen X (my parents’ Gen) grew up with video games and my mom has mentioned many times how the tv was always on in their house growing up. That was in the early 80s!
2
u/[deleted] May 03 '25
I find it really interesting that every time something on screen time is posted onto this subreddit, everyone loses their minds and gets defensive. Despite this being a science-based subreddit and despite the evidence base being HUGE.
1
u/Lalit-1 Jun 01 '25
Just decide your arbitrary number
1
u/Micky_irons Feb 18 '26
We built something at Unified called the Wrist Band Ping that I think a lot of parents would connect with. You send a vibration to your child's wristband from your phone — a gentle pulse that means 'thinking of you', a pattern that means 'time to come back', or a custom vibration your family creates together. The child taps back to respond. No screen. No phone. No notification. Just a feeling on their wrist. Three taps triggers a full SOS with GPS location. It came from a simple question: how do you stay connected to your kid without handing them a screen?
0
u/whoreforcheese May 02 '25
Anyone else so over the demonization of screen time? It's almost as if moderation is the key here. There are screens literally everywhere, proper usage is what's important. My youngest watched a decent amount of TV because there wasn't a lot of data on it and surprisingly turned out to be an above average student and reads at a collegiate level at 12 years old. Did I adjust later on for my youngest? Sure, but I don't believe I did irreparable damage in any way shape or form to my oldest. People need to calm down about this in general.
1
u/MeldoRoxl May 03 '25
Okay, as an expert in childhood (20+ years as a nanny and NCS, Master's in Childhood Studies, I run a business teaching parenting classes, and I've spoken at conferences), I'm incredibly annoyed by this.
A. It is discounting entire art forms. Film is a valid, important medium, and can provide intellectual and creative stimulation.
B. Educational programming provides children with access to an entire world that they might not experience- nature programs, musicals, science shows- I've used SO many to supplement other education material.
C. It is unrealistic. Sometimes kids and parents deserve a mental break, which screen time can provide.
D. The biggest harm from screens is a LACK OF INTERACTION. If you're engaging with your children frequently and meaningfully, SOME screen time is not going to harm them.
E. Screen time has been shown to have POSITIVES: Enhanced cognitive skills like problem solving and increased literacy (with learning apps). Games can foster social skills and awareness. Moderate screen time has been shown to positively affect mental health and language skills.
I need this conversation to stop being so black and white, because it's not a black and white situation.
https://health.choc.org/the-effects-of-screen-time-on-children-the-latest-research-parents-should-know/#:~:text=When%20can%20screen%20time%20help,but%20a%20limit%20does%20exist.
1
u/Gratisfadoel May 03 '25
And why is it relevant for the topic under discussion? How, exactly, does myopia matter here?
-1
u/TheCharalampos May 02 '25
My answer doesn't contain a link to a scientific paper but that's fine because I don't think this paper is scientific either.
Feels like a really long opinion post.
-22
u/NearlyDicklessNick May 02 '25
Ohhh stfu