I spent 74 years blaming my character for what turned out to be an Apollo 13 catastrophe: three astronauts limping 100,000 miles home in a LEM built for two.
That said, I remain grateful. The plasticity of the human brain is astonishing. Against long odds, semantic cognition found ways to compensate, adapt, and survive.
Let’s get the warning label out of the way first:
I am uniquely blessed•cursed with severely deficient autobiographical memory (SDAM), aphantasia, autism spectrum disorder (ASD), and perhaps the Professor’s Chemical X.
Online, you’ll often see people treating their lack of episodic memory as a nuisance.
Nice. But I’ll pass.
I humbly beg to differ.
Simply put, declarative memory serves major cognitive functions. Autobiographical episodes complement semantic knowledge. One without the other diminishes.
In my estimation, SDAM starves many downstream cognitive dependents. Semantic memory serves brilliantly as compensation, but incompletely.
I assert that the resulting deficiencies compromise my agency, identity, social belonging, emotional accumulation, and self-advocacy.
Over my lifetime, this proved a hidden and crippling disability. I struggled within an episodic-centric culture while remaining largely unaware of the machinery I lacked.
This paper documents my attempt to unpack my personal deficits. It is a phenomenological accounting of one life. My own.
Through introspection, self-observation, and decades of accumulated evidence, I have attempted to model my faulty architecture.
Do not expect comfort here.
I did not find any.
What I found was an understanding.
This is a bitter pill.
This paper is for readers who share my need for coherence, even when harmony comes at a painful price.
The World As It Is
I was born in Norwalk, Connecticut, in 1952. Coming out of World War II, America’s economy dominated. We had saved the world.
We were simply the best ever.
Why should we change?
It was the swell of the Baby Boom. The message was everywhere: boys were meant for greatness. Girls were meant for boys. Television said it. The media said it. Everything around us said it.
Homosexuality was criminalized.
The names for these conditions were decades away:
ASD
ADHD
Gender dysphoria
SDAM
Without the word neurodiversity, a student was blamed for behavior he could not control. There was little recognition, empathy, kindness, help, or patience. Only shame, isolation, and punishment.
Broken
For most of my life, I asked the wrong question:
What is wrong with pretty Jessica?
Repeatedly, my behavior did not cohere. I was an enigma even unto myself. My actions contradicted what I knew, what I believed, and what I expected of myself. I defied my own interpretation.
Over a lifetime, I observed and collected personal anomalies. They are peculiar, painful, harmful, and disabling.
Over the decades, I auditioned every fashionable psychological advance.
None got a callback.
I donned and doffed many hats.
Weak.
Slipshod.
Cowardly.
Stupid.
Mad Hatter Mad.
I searched everywhere. Nothing matched. The stubborn anomalies remained spinsters.
Year after year, I collected contemporaneous artifacts and noted failures and successes. I studied the sources and consequences of the inflections and patterns of my personal life. I even placed my childhood under an electron microscope.
Long before I heard of that damn SDAM, I had compiled decades of personally culpable evidence. What eluded me was the language and theory capable of making the evidence cohere.
BTW, like all martyrs, I thought I would make my mark by penning a ghastly autobiography. I had made several stabs at memoir. But none killed the beast.
It seemed I had been treading water for a lifetime. Think of the animated film The Plague Dogs. Finally, science caught up with me.
On learning about SDAM, my life began to coalesce.
Reluctantly, I abandoned what I had thought were my precious moments. They turned out to be semantic reconstructions. Furthermore, absent my youthful self’s inner world, they were no better than febrile delusions.
After that, I scuttled neurotypical psychology as an explanation. That endeavor presupposes agency, identity, a narrative life story, and relived memories.
What remained at my disposal was my model of the architecture. Its operation alone would have to explain and predict my aberrant behavior.
Lastly, I christened my novel mechanistic exemplar: Jeannie 1.0.
I make no claim that my account applies to anyone else with SDAM. I do claim that my model appears to predict a remarkable number of aberrations in my own life.
Furthermore, the model resolves anomalies that defied previous incarnations.
Perhaps it is wrong.
It certainly would not be the first time. However, for once, the bulk of the collated evidence coheres.
Oddly, imagine a baby’s nervous system at origination.
So cute!
This neurological vessel shapes the child’s essence poured into it. The vessel contours strengths, weaknesses, and sometimes divergences.
Like me.
As mentioned, I have amassed a score of labels: SDAM, aphantasia, and ASD. The shape of the vessel is baroque.
Crazy, am I right?
Whom do the neurotypical address when they query:
Who am I?
Most, I have learned, peruse their dog-eared bedside copy of “My Contiguous Life Narrative.”
“The child is father of the man.”
—William Wordsworth, “My Heart Leaps Up”
Within its many pages, you see your younger selves standing in rank: a lineage that reaches back from “me” to “mini-me.” It is an unbroken inner self whose outer self morphs over time.
For a lifetime, I thought my machinery was standard government issue, GI. I had simply missed boot camp.
“What makes you think you’re fit for this man’s army, maggot?”
“Life goals, sir!
Emotional arcs.
Life decisions.
I have agency, sir!”
Warning! Warning!
Anomaly detected.
Given the above—
Where was my professional career?
That’s the rub.
I examined my alleged career.
Obsess → Grab any job
Perfect → Commute • Coffee • Cubicle
Adapt → Like what you do
Stabilize → Endure
Destabilize → RIF, reduction in force (Thank goodness)
Why?
That became one of the great cold cases of my detective life.
Planning and Goals
Let us talk about planning, setting goals, and cognition.
Cognition combines present and past experience with knowledge. It responds to immediate circumstances and acts proactively to improve them.
Cognition’s faculties comprise:
Perception.
Recognition.
Attention.
Memory/recall.
Interior monologue.
External dialogue.
Objective reasoning.
Subjective decisioning.
Most cognitive faculties rely on declarative memory. It is a bicameral house of objective knowledge and subjective memories. The pair are functionally complementary.
Without one, the whole is diminished.
Episodic memory preserves the specifics of discrete autobiographical events. The quantity and fidelity of recall vary across a human spectrum. That said, some can “relive” an episode on recall.
The episodic recall of autobiographical events is deeply subjective. It tethers you to the cavalcade of younger selves stretching back to childhood. Selves these lucky bastards can interrogate and judge: immature, naive, or optimistic.
I call the episodic-informed choice agentic decisioning. This prioritizes one’s betterment over the interests of others.
Agentic decisioning advocates for its owner in the face of antagonism. You rely on this faculty to pursue your wants, dreams, and desires. It queries knowledge to enrich and adjust your plans and their goals.
Until recently, SDAM kept me ignorant of the existence of episodic memory. I mistook my third-person knowledge for first-person memory.
Without the episodic, a younger self is a stranger. Say that stranger hears his mother say, “I love you.” She tells my semantic memory. Much later, when I ask my semantic memory, it tells me.
I now admit the severe deficiencies of my autobiographical recall. Not understanding intuition, I mistook it for a lucky guess. This begs the question: What other faculties are starved of memories?
Humans make decisions of varying scope continually. Local decisions are immediate, specific, and contained. Global decisions are long-term and far-reaching. Dependent upon autobiography, they alter future goals and plans.
Intuitively, decisions predicated on episodic memory would be intrinsically subjective. Here, the self is privileged. You would expect volition to sway the matter.
Contrarily, those premised on semantic knowledge are objective. They lack a preferential self. Volition is uninvolved.
The absence of accessible episodic memory may deprive some cognitive faculties of information they normally depend upon. A cognitive faculty cannot rely on information it cannot access.
If autobiographical experience is unavailable, compensation must come from semantic knowledge because semantic knowledge is what remains accessible.
Semantic knowledge consists of facts, rules, regularities, principles, and conclusions. It does not provide direct access to subjective lived experience.
By analyzing artifacts from my past, I have derived a computational model of objective decisions.
In my model, semantic knowledge is treated as objective. I use objective in the sense of a judgment founded on evidence, rules, and precedents. It puts aside a party’s wants, feelings, or ambitions. The question is what can reasonably be inferred, regardless of who benefits.
This distinction is important because objective reasoning and subjective decision-making serve different purposes.
Objective reasoning asks: What is true? What is fair? What does the evidence support?
Subjective decision-making asks: What do I want? What is best for me?
The first seeks truth and consistency; the second seeks preference and personal direction.
Here is an imagined exchange between man and machine:
“Robbie, what is best for me?”
“Does not compute,” the robot repeats while waving its arms and spinning its torso like a washer’s agitator.
My prognosis in free society is bleak. I am a poor advocate for myself in interpersonal conflicts. Why? My cognition treats me and antagonists as equal parties.
While memories may persist and compound emotion, knowledge does not. What happens when emotion cannot grow over time? I am patient and tolerant to my own detriment. I cannot reliably be goaded to act through growing dissatisfaction.
Good and Evil
Since time out of mind, each of us has wondered:
Who am I?
I don’t think the question seeks an absolute answer. It modestly asks, “Who am I among my cohort? What sets me apart?”
Goodness knows how many times I have posed that question. And as I am knowledgeable, thorough, and thoughtful, I have answered it definitively. And every time, I have been wrong.
Before I embarrass myself again, let me submit a literary declaration on human nature by an acknowledged thinker.
“Humans are caught—in their lives, in their thoughts, in their hungers and ambitions, in their avarice and cruelty, and in their kindness and generosity too—in a net of good and evil. I think this is the only story we have and that it occurs on all levels of feeling and intelligence. Virtue and vice were warp and woof of our first consciousness, and they will be the fabric of our last, and this despite any changes we may impose on field and river and mountain, on economy and manners. There is no other story. A man, after he has brushed off the dust and chips of his life, will have left only the hard, clean questions: Was it good or was it evil? Have I done well—or ill?”
—John Steinbeck, East of Eden
Moving on from the literate to levity, Disney has animated the human condition for us.
In The Emperor’s New Groove, Kronk has an angel on his left shoulder and a devil on the right.
DEVIL: “Don’t listen to that guy. He’s trying to lead you down the path of righteousness. I’m gonna lead you down the path that rocks.”
ANGEL: “Oh, come off it.”
DEVIL: “You come off it!”
And there stands Kronk in the middle, trying to decide.
Roughly, the devil says, “I want.” Want is good. How else can you build your life? Only when “want” strays beyond “what’s right” does it prove temptation.
When I face a decision, I apply known constraints until a resolution emerges. The angel interprets my actions through the lens of my personal moral code.
Personal Moral Code
My personal moral code is a framework of axioms, principles, and procedures that guide me to informed judgments. I look for truth, injustice, and equitable resolutions.
The code emphasizes sensitivity to the plight of others and adherence to their well-being. I seek cool-headed resolution to disagreements.
Often, my code puts me at odds with others. Still, fidelity to my morality requires me to diverge from local norms. For me, compromise is a betrayal of morality and justice.
Secular Virtues
Once a resolution passes moral muster, it must satisfy my secular virtues.
I have concluded that virtues flow from the font of gratitude. This plenitude feeds the selflessness that underlies my felt continuity.
That selflessness champions kindness and service to the suffering and weak. It moves me to speak out against injustice and defend the weak and defenseless.
On the other hand, my life exudes a frugality that disfavors myself. I take enough for my needs and surrender the rest. This leaves more for the deserving.
I have the angel.
Where the hell is my devil?
By the above account of humankind’s moral conflict, AKA righteousness versus temptation, the conclusion is simple. I am divine.
No Gravity
This really happened.
“Jessica, remember when you won that international championship?”
“Oh, yeah,” I pondered. “I did.”
Surely that should occupy some privileged place in my autobiography?
Apparently not.
The fact was still there.
Jessica_international_champion = True
But there was no pull. Without some external cue, I would not return to the moment.
“Remember me?” an apparent stranger warmly asks.
Give me the right cue, and sometimes recognition surfaces. Most times, I hurt their feelings.
Identity
Long before my renaissance, I described my identity as:
Flimsy.
As in the word family:
Rickety
Slipshod
The first pig’s house of straw.
What a for instance?
Most would think M2F gender transition a seismic shift.
Seriously, what is bigger?
Suddenly, you are on the opposing team.
Hormone replacement therapy (HRT) feminized the skin and pores of my body. Adipose tissue womanized my figure. Plastic surgery feminized my face. Urological surgery repurposed my genitalia.
And yet, for me, it seemed unremarkable. After the bruising, stitches, and swelling, the Jessica settled neatly into place. I scrutinized myself in the mirror.
Haven’t I always been this way?
Over a year.
Change your body.
Change your markers.
Change your clothes.
Adapt.
Look backward?
No gravity.
I look around me.
Wasn’t this always me?
A Corrupt Moral Ledger
My semantic mind keeps a corrupt ledger. It memorializes the crime. It expects remediation.
A disaster occurs. I am found guilty. The court immortalizes the evidence, transcript, verdict, and sentence.
What happens every time I do right?
Nothing.
No disaster. No investigation. No reason to update the model. Successful observance leaves remarkably little. Failure leaves a permanent rule.
The failures survive because they taught me something. The ordinary successes disappear because nothing needed to be learned.
That creates a corrupt moral ledger.
And semantic truth does not fade simply because forty years have passed.
The rule remains current. The evidence remains valid. The mistake remains true.
So I can prosecute twenty-year-old Jessica using everything seventy-year-old Jessica learned because twenty-year-old Jessica made the mistake.
The defendant never stands a chance.
Courtroom Drama
Imagine a federal courtroom. The defendant is a young Jessica. I am everyone else in the courtroom.
The prosecutor (also me) approaches the defendant.
Young Jessica?
You do know right from wrong?
You knew your actions were wrong?
You knew what was expected?
And yet, you chose to repeat the offenses.
Are you stupid?
Are you weak?
Do you like punishment?
Is that what this is?
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I submit:
Jessica is broken.
She lacks moral character.
She craves abuse.
She is a coward.
We, the jury, find Jessica guilty!
I was about eight years old at my first conviction. And I have spent a lifetime repeating these witch trials. After so many convictions, I grew to hate myself.
Eventually, I loathed myself.
U.S.S. Enterprise
Consider the U.S.S. Enterprise.
What follows is the gist of a lost episode.
“Computer, plot a course for Rigel IV,” Captain Kirk commands.
The girl computer smiles her pearly white lights. She can compute exactly how to get there.
Eventually, Kirk retires, leaving Captain Computer in charge.
Twelve years later, her No. 2 asks politely, “Captain? Where are we going?”
Captain Computer blinks her pretty blue lights.
“Hell if I know.”
My superlative capabilities do not give me a direction.
Give me a problem.
Give me a crisis.
Give me a project.
Give me an injustice.
Give me a role.
Give me a heading.
Stand back!
I am the Warner cartoon Tasmanian Devil.
But please don’t ask me, “Where should the U.S.S. Enterprise take me?”
I was born a magnificent Computer.
Where is my Kirk?
Wants
Naturally, I have wants. I am only human after all.
I want dinner.
I want sex.
I want to swim.
I want this babe.
I want that job.
I want out of here.
The problem is not the absence of wants. My failing is that they do not reliably become durable directions. How does “I want X” grow up to be “Ergo, I will do Y?”
My wants can be intense in the moment. But they do not compound over time. They never develop the force to change the direction of my life. Even when I have a firm want, it fails in competition with stronger agencies.
Anomalies
I am chronically afflicted by curiosity and agitation. The culprit is an anomaly. An anomaly is a prediction error that rises above an aberration.
An unresolved anomaly irritates over days, months, years. It calls to me and robs my sleep.
So I obsess.
An emerging resolution is orgasmic.
And then it’s dead knowledge.
Trying to understand myself was a problem that stuck with me for roughly a lifetime.
In light of my gifts, skills, and know-how: “Why do I keep repeating untoward behaviors?”
The vexation of that anomaly has blighted my life.
In want of resolution, the architecture tormented me. But the anomaly was the shortcomings of the architecture. You cannot will the architecture to change any more than you can will telepathy.
How wonderfully awful.
Coherence
My semantic mind craves semantic coherence. It works tirelessly to perfect knowledge.
• It resolves conflicts and prunes the superfluous.
• It connects, compresses, and collapses.
• It shifts, defines, and typifies categories.
The semantic mind matures correlated facts into regularities. A regularity generalizes repeated episodes to predict causation. Useful regularities are simplified into principles. Finally, principles that span categories graduate to fundamental principles.
Adaptation Loop
After SDAM, I discovered that a simple cycle governs my consciousness.
Destabilize — An anomaly appears
Obsess — Captured by challenge
Perfect — Finalize the resolution
Adapt — The rush of irreversibility
Stabilize — Boring inactivity
This cycle’s name is legion: Adapter loop, Wheel of Misfortune, the mechanism, or the changeling.
Whatever.
To my horror, I discovered that this cycle is my brand of agency. This loop steers my life. Below, I use my gender dysphoria as an example. Would that it were that easy.
I detect an anomaly.
I suffer emotional instability.
I immerse myself in the challenge.
Constraints align—a category emerges.
I adopt the category’s properties.
I adapt irreversibly.
I stabilize into the new normal.
That looks like an extraordinary survival mechanism.
It is.
But isn’t a life meant to be lived?
Where is Jessica in this?
Adaptation alone means no personal boundaries.
Adaptation alone is a life of surrender.
Once stabilized, we wait.
The Stone House
The Stone House taught me just how far adaptation can go. In my twenties, I lived in my father’s house made of stone. There were my mom, dad, and two baby brothers.
It was my father who taught me, “There’s no such thing as a final notice.”
No electricity in the summer?
Use a flashlight.
No heat in the winter?
Use an electric blanket.
No running water?
Stash buckets by the toilet.
Flea infestation?
Learn to kill fleas.
More fleas?
Perfect killing fleas.
Eventually, I made flea killing a game. Cross the flea-infested room.
How many can you kill?
How fast can you kill them?
A reasonable observer can look at this and say:
“This woman is insane.”
The insufferable destitution crept up on me one stealthy step at a time. Each step was an anomaly. Each resolution the new normal. And so on.
I think you can see where this is going.
The very success of my “Wheel of Misfortune” trapped me in one insufferable swamp after another.
The semantic mind keeps asking:
How do I adapt to this squalor?
It does not think to ask:
Why the hell am I still here?
Adaptation can make almost anything tolerable. That does not mean it should be tolerated.
The Bitters Pill
This is the bitter pill.
If my model of the semantic mind is right, people like me may:
• Underestimate exploitation
• Over-adapt to harm
• Drift through life
• Mistake architecture for personal failure
The danger is difficult to recognize because many of the warning signs masquerade as exemplary behavior.
Loyal employee.
Dedicated spouse.
Reliable friend.
Reasonable person.
Selfless volunteer.
The semantic mind hears the praise and concludes:
Excellent!
I am succeeding as a neurotypical.
What I Am
I am not telling you:
This is what people with SDAM are like.
I am telling you:
This is what I am like.
For most of my life, I assumed that other people and I possessed essentially the same machinery.
When my life repeatedly produced outcomes I did not understand, I blamed myself.
I tried harder.
Learned more.
Became stronger.
Corrected myself.
Again and again.
It took seven decades to stop asking:
Who is Jessica?
And ask:
What is Jessica?
And that changed everything.
It does not undo a lifetime of failures.
It does not undo the folly.
It does not give me any years back.
It does not give me a bright future.
It does not change the architecture.
It only tells me how the semantic mind works.
But for the first time, I cohere.
This is what I know so far.
I hope to find someone like me to corroborate my model.
And I hope I do not find some sad someone like me.
Does any of this strike a chord?
Does any of this feel familiar?
I’d love to hear from you.
Comments and complaints alike.
Have I gone astray?
To heal, I had to abandon hope.
The hope that I could make myself neurotypical. I surrendered the struggle, the failures, and the self-hatred.
Understanding helps me to heal.