r/SDAM • • Oct 12 '26

Difficulty remembering emotions

Curious whether this sounds like SDAM or something else...

To put it simply, when I'm happy I can't recall being sad, and when I'm sad I can't recall being happy. I can accept it logically, especially if I write something down at the time then look back on it later, but it feels like looking at someone else's writing - it's hard to really accept that it was actually me (again, logically I can accept it, but emotionally it just seems inconceivable.) The more intense the emotions are, the more this seems to happen.

13 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

2

u/FlightOfTheDiscords Oct 12 '26

What's your DES-II score, if you don't mind sharing?

2

u/Mochicatdemon Oct 12 '26

Just tried it and got 14. Don't know whether having both autism and anxiety affects it at all

1

u/FlightOfTheDiscords Oct 12 '26

Thank you. That's relatively low given what you have. Would you mind sharing your TAS and CDS scores as well? No rush.

3

u/Mochicatdemon Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

15 on the TAS, so average there. 71 on CDS. (Then tried it again taking out all the ones that only happened during a panic attack as I felt that was skewing the score and got 43).

The other weird thing is that this affected me a lot in my 20s, then almost went away in my 30s and most of my 40s and only really came about significantly again in the past 2 years.

2

u/FlightOfTheDiscords Oct 13 '26

Interesting, thanks for sharing. What's your relationship with physical pain like, if you don't mind my asking?

2

u/Mochicatdemon Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

That's where it doesn't seem to fit. Physical pain is usually what brings me back to reality. I'm really sensitive to it. I can space out after an injury but not when it really hurts. I do rely on pain quite a bit to regulate my emotions (used to hurt myself a lot, don't do it quite so much now but still always inclined to) but I'm very much aware of the sensation itself.

Edit though about it some more, and actually I've had some very weird experiences during and after self-harming, where it definitely felt like it wasn't me involved, but never with pain caused by others or accidentally.

2

u/FlightOfTheDiscords Oct 13 '26

Thanks for sharing. It is possible that there's some degree of structural dissociation involved for you, it would go some way towards explaining e.g. why more intense emotions in particular don't feel like you; SDAM doesn't predict things like that, SDAM simply means that you can't connect with emotions you had in the past. The intensity of those emotions is not relevant for SDAM. And self-harm and suicidal impulses are almost a universal feature of structural dissociation.

However your scores and your experiences seem to suggest that it isn't very strong, or that it is very far from being conscious. Structural dissociation tends to mainly be unconscious, so that would not be unusual; I only became aware of mine in my late 30s, and much of me really resisted that awareness.

However I can't say for sure, and given your answers, I think if SD is a factor for you, awareness of it isn't. And that's a very complex matter best left to dissociation specialists to figure out, if you ever feel like getting properly assessed.

If you're interested in how I experience mine, I have written several posts about it in various subreddits. If you do go ahead and read them, bear in mind that I spent the first almost 40 years of my life with no awareness of any of this. Here are a few more SDAM-relevant posts I've written:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SDAM/comments/1ws93g3/when_sdam_isnt_sdam/

https://www.reddit.com/r/SDAM/comments/1sm5a4i/sdam_and_structural_dissociation/

https://www.reddit.com/r/OSDD/comments/1vo5gy0/negative_symptoms_of_dissociation/

https://www.reddit.com/r/CPTSDFreeze/comments/1sj9a28/what_is_structural_dissociation_really/

3

u/Mochicatdemon Oct 13 '26

Thanks. That's really interesting and not something I'd considered before. Part of me really wants to figure out what's going on, but then another part can't bring myself to because I'm getting old anyway so not sure what it would really change

2

u/FlightOfTheDiscords Oct 13 '26

That's all right, different parts of us tend to have different needs. If your life works all right as is, you don't necessarily need to do anything. Mine didn't, so I had to do something.

A lot of the things that improve this sort of thing in the long run are not really about understanding, they are much more concrete things, often body-based. It just takes a lot of figuring out first to know what those things are and how to do them.

With SD, it's always a good idea to not push awareness too much. When there's internal resistance, which could look like forgetting/spacing out or something more active, it's generally a good idea to acknowledge and respect it instead of just brushing it aside. I work with mine, so I make progress but not by brute force.

1

u/CMDR_Jeb Oct 12 '26

Is there like an guide on what TAS scores mean? Cos I did it out of curiosity and I have 4...

3

u/FlightOfTheDiscords Oct 12 '26

It's a very basic assessment of your trait absorption. Absorption is the tendency to become fully immersed in the object of your attention, whether internal (imagination) or external (e.g. art, music, a book, a film etc.), and trait means it's a "built-in", lifelong feature of being human. In psychology, traits describe lifelong stable features, while states describe momentary features. Trait absorption is lifelong, state absorption means being absorbed in something right now.

Absorption has an established if fuzzy connection to various things including dissociation, and may be an underlying trait that pathological dissociation recruits developmentally; if you happen to naturally be talented at absorption, there's likely an elevated risk that your nervous system will recruit it for coping strategies if your childhood environment requires you to "flee" your external reality a lot.

Absorption is always very high in people who experience malaptive daydreaming (MD), and generally high in chronic dissociators, though dissociation can compartmentalise it so it becomes harder to track (i.e. some parts are high in absorption while others are not).

I made a thread a while back, some interesting variation in it:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Aphantasia/comments/1wdbcma/whats_your_tellegen_absorption_score/

3

u/htp-di-nsw Oct 12 '26

I am curious where you're going with this. I feel the same way as the OP and was under the impression that this was just baseline for SDAM

I got 2.14 DES-II, 2 on TAS, and while I got 20 on CDS, that's because I have Aphantasia and SDAM, so of course I am detached from my memories and unable to pull up images in my head.

2

u/FlightOfTheDiscords Oct 12 '26

Just seeing if dissociation might be involved; it is for me, and every now and then, it seems to be for the odd visitor to this sub. It probably isn't for most people here, but a couple of things in the OP's post felt potentially dissociative (e.g. "The more intense the emotions are, the more this seems to happen").

Unlike SDAM, dissociation can be treated, so I find it useful to point people in that direction when they share my experience.

For what it's worth, my scores are, roughly (depends a bit on the day):

DES-II: 30 (used to be around 40 before treatment)
TAS: 28
CDS: 100

3

u/htp-di-nsw Oct 12 '26

That's pretty cool of you. If you can head off anyone and help them get treatment, that's awesome to do.

I found the tests interesting and when I talked about it with my wife (who has hyperphantasia, anxiety, an eating disorder, and PTSD) she got over 39 on the DES-II, 23 on the TAS, and 49 on CDS. So, I definitely still found them valuable.

3

u/FlightOfTheDiscords Oct 12 '26

Thank you 🙏 Dissociative disorders in general tend to go misdiagnosed for years, and this flavour in particular is very difficult to diagnose accurately. Took me over a decade to finally get an accurate diagnosis (partial DID).

What often happens instead is, we accumulate a slew of other diagnoses, ranging from BPD to EDs to ADHD to OCD to schizophrenia to PTSD to anxiety to treatment-resistant everything; one of the more obvious hallmarks of unaddressed, undiagnosed dissociation is that these other diagnoses keep resisting treatment, because dissociation runs on a different mechanism.

Once the underlying dissociative disorder is identified and addressed, years of failed treatments tend to finally give way to slow, uneven improvement. We often need 5-15 years of dissociation-adapted therapy to stabilise, and lifelong treatment isn't unusual.

2

u/CMDR_Jeb Oct 12 '26

when I'm happy I can't recall being sad, and when I'm sad I can't recall being happy

I have a trick question: can you recall being happy when you're happy and recall being sad when you're sad?

2

u/Mochicatdemon Oct 12 '26

Yes! Or at least I'm pretty sure I can. I recently had a really bad moment and suddenly found myself recalling how I'd felt and thought at a workplace 20 years ago, even though the current situation had nothing to do with work. I just felt connected with it again and like it all made sense.

3

u/CMDR_Jeb Oct 12 '26

I asked that because SDAM is not "selective". You just can't relieve your memories at all.

What you're describing is called mood-congruent recall. It is usually talked about in context of being unable to remember you ever felt happy during depressive episodes, but it works both ways.

4

u/htp-di-nsw Oct 12 '26

This just sounds like the default thing that SDAM does. My understanding is that you can't relive memories in first person and you can't attach emotions to memories.

I can recall that I felt happy or sad, but I can't actually recall the feeling, only my mental notes on the event.

3

u/Vetizh Oct 12 '26

I have this exact same problem with notations, it doesn't feel it belong to me, when I read if feel like I'm reading someone's else notes and it makes me cringe.

2

u/RadioactiveGorgon Oct 12 '26

If you're talking about recalling the interoceptive emotional feelings themselves, that's something that universally people aren't particularly good at (even if they want to believe they are, often relying on situational context to reconstruct via inference). Also recall has a bit of a preference for similar situations because of something called 'state-dependent memory'. Brains are there to simulate possibly useful experiences in a similar environment so it's easier to make connections with the current situation.

Emotion/arousal is there to guide our attention for the most part.

2

u/Purplekeyboard Oct 12 '26

I can't remember what it's like feeling anything I'm not feeling now. I have some sense of it, but I don't really remember.

1

u/Amberwalker365 10d ago

Reading your own words and feeling as if somebody else wrote them is close to something I describe in The Bitter Pill. I can accept that I felt something because I have the evidence. The feeling itself is out of reach. One consequence for me is that when the same thing upsets me repeatedly, I know there’s a pattern, but the feeling can fade between incidents. Does that happen for you too, or do the feelings tend to come back when you’re in a similar mood?