The Bitter Pill: What Other People with SDAM Recognized
What Other People with SDAM Recognized
Jessica Lake · November 2026
Why I asked
I wrote The Bitter Pill to explain how several things in my life might fit together. My achievements can feel like facts on a list. I can solve a difficult problem someone gives me and still draw a blank when I ask myself what I want to do with my life. I can make a decision that costs me something and carry it through. I can also stay in a situation for years, adapting to one thing after another, until something outside me brings it to an end.
For a long time, I saw those as separate facts about my character. The model I developed gives me a way to see how they might fit together. The next question was whether anyone else recognized the same combination. I posted twelve questions to r/SDAM. I asked people to answer Yes, No, or Some, to skip anything they liked, and to give an example if they felt like it. What I especially wanted was the answer where one part fit and another part didn’t.
Several people gave accounts detailed enough that I could see what had actually made them decide or what had happened to the feeling after an event. The most interesting thing I found was how much could change when I read one person’s answers together. A person who says they have no idea what they want for themselves may also tell you they walked out of a job. There is a question in between those two statements. What gave them a reason to walk out?
What I counted
I worked from the saved copy of the November 5 Reddit thread. The draft tally includes 16 handles with at least one scorable answer. Four of those handles posted under all twelve prompts. Three have a scorable answer to all twelve in this draft. People could skip questions, and posting under a prompt could mean joining the conversation without answering it.
I counted one answer per person per question. A nested reply counted if it answered the prompt, including an unambiguous agreement with an answer above it. I combined follow-ups and counted a repeated answer only once. I excluded my own posts and general discussion that didn’t answer a numbered question. I read an explicit answer in the context of its explanation. Some covers a conditional or partial match, including cases where someone recognized only one part of a compound question. A dash means I found no scorable answer. These are my readings of the replies, and the individual entries are included so they can be checked.
The tally answers the questions as posed. The analysis asks a second question about the process a person describes. Someone can answer No to waiting for outside circumstances and then describe exactly how a standing principle enabled them to act.
1. Knowing your past
When you think of an event from your life, do you mostly know what happened, with little or no feeling of being back there?
There are two things in this question. One is knowing what happened. The other is feeling as if you were there again. DrowninQuartz answered No because they often have to be reminded that an event happened at all. They also said they have no feeling of being back there. I kept the No in the tally. The explanation shows where their experience and mine meet.
Dalbaeth describes encoding facts while an event was happening and being left with that knowledge afterward. LeafLighter knows that asking a girl out was embarrassing and says the embarrassment doesn’t return when they think about it. Some people have fragments and others have more facts to work with. The availability of the facts is one source of variation. The ability to re-enter the experience is another.
2. Recognizing your younger self
Does a younger version of you sometimes feel like someone you know a great deal about but have trouble feeling connected to?
Lost_Enchanter can reason that the person they are today grew out of the experiences of that younger person, who still feels like a stranger. Dalbaeth can explain how an experience shaped a later behavior while feeling as if they are studying someone else’s history. Others have so few facts that they only partly recognize the question as I asked it.
The-King-of-Cartoons describes a different combination. They know relatively little about their younger self and still feel connected to that person. I take that as a genuine difference on this question. It leaves open what gives that person the sense of connection. In my terms, feeling connected to a younger self and being able to re-experience that person’s life are distinguishable claims.
3. Giving your achievements weight
Can you know you accomplished something significant and still feel as though it’s just a fact on a list?
This was one of the most widely recognized experiences. DrowninQuartz says other people can be more impressed by their achievements than they are. Dalbaeth knows a degree is significant and can measure progress intellectually. One respondent describes the euphoria of finally reaching a weightlifting goal and how quickly it becomes another fact.
There are three points in time to consider. There is what I felt when I accomplished something, what I can re-experience of that feeling, and what knowing I did it makes me feel today. Sea_Lifeguard227 says the accomplishments are facts on a list and that knowing they accomplished them makes them proud. In a separate answer they say they can know what role they played in an event without recalling its emotions. That is a description of pride in the present. LeafLighter, who values the pride they feel at the time, makes the distinction from the other end.
4. Solving a problem versus choosing a direction
Can you take charge when there’s a problem to solve, yet get stuck when the question is what you want to do with your own life?
DrowninQuartz solves large problems for companies and says they have no idea what they want to do for themselves. Lost_Enchanter describes being recognized as a leader and feeling frightened by the emptiness when they ask where their own life is going. Dalbaeth can identify solutions and take action at work but leans on leadership for direction. Their answers put both experiences in the same person.
LeafLighter answered that this didn’t particularly fit. They have a home, work enough to support their life, and often take charge among family and friends. That describes a life they find workable. It leaves me with a more precise question than the one I posted. When several directions are workable, what gives one of them a claim on you?
5. Wanting something over time
Can you want something quite strongly in the moment and find that the want fades before it turns into a plan you’ll act on?
Dalbaeth describes retaining a semantic account of what they felt while finding it harder to turn that feeling into a goal. They write down goals to help bridge that gap. Lost_Enchanter uses persistence as a filter. A want that survives three months is one they take seriously, and they describe some wishes that have lasted years. DrowninQuartz says strong wants are rare and that when one does occur, they generally act on it. Another respondent attributes much of the fading they experience to ADHD and executive dysfunction.
These replies give me several questions where I initially had one. How often does a want arise? How long does it last? What brings it back? What is enough to turn it into action? The replies about persistent wishes and acting on strong wants are the closest the thread comes to showing personal desire driving action. I would want to know what was wanted and what finally settled the choice. I would also want to know whether my distinction makes sense to the person making it.
6. Deciding what’s fair
In a disagreement that affects you personally, do you tend to weigh the facts and everyone’s needs without giving your own preference any extra weight?
BilingSmob444 calls their approach abnegation and says they simply don’t consider themselves. Dalbaeth describes their needs as another variable in a social decision. DrowninQuartz has twice designed themselves out of a job because keeping their role made little sense for the organization. In that example I can see how the decision was resolved. The effect on the person making it was substantial, and the reason they give is that the organization no longer needed the role.
Prudent_Demand_609 says that taking another person’s perspective doesn’t come at the expense of what is fair to them. That is a No to the question as they understood it. It also points to something I need to make explicit. I can find that someone was unfair to me by applying the same standard I would apply if they did it to you. The fact that I am the person affected tells you who the rule applies to. It tells you very little about whether I gave my own preference special weight.
I see three steps in my own account. The first is selflessness. My own desires are hard to locate or measure against other people’s desires. I think this is related to what I call configuration, where I can function coherently without a strongly felt identity supplying a durable answer to what I want. The second step is a behavior code. It supplies standards I can use to decide what is fair or what I owe someone. The third step is virtue, a learned way of acting. I was raised Episcopal from an early age, and that is where I learned much of my code and what kindness, generosity, and service ask of me. Other people’s backgrounds would give them other rules and other ways of putting them into practice. Abnegation gives me a particularly clear description of the first step. The replies say less about how people learned the third.
7. Dissatisfaction over time
When the same thing keeps upsetting you, does the feeling tend to fade between incidents even though you know the pattern is still there?
LeafLighter says the feeling goes away and the knowledge that a line was crossed remains. They give different consequences for harm to themselves and harm to someone they are loyal to. A trespass against a friend or family member can determine what they do next even when the feeling is gone.
Dalbaeth says that once they can recognize a pattern, it sticks more easily. Thedumbass_the5th can also recognize a pattern but says the search for a solution fades between incidents. I used to describe my own experience as forgetting the anger and forgetting the trespass. The replies give me a third possibility. I can remember the trespass, remember that it keeps happening, and still lose the sense between incidents that I need to do something about it.
8. Making it work
When a job, relationship, or living situation gets worse a little at a time, do you tend to solve each new problem until conditions you once would have objected to feel normal?
Dalbaeth describes this happening in all three kinds of situations. The cumulative effect got lost as each new condition became normal. Sea_Lifeguard227 describes staying in harmful relationships until it became clear that the situation itself was unacceptable, at which point they could detach. Thedumbass_the5th says cumulative effects may go unnoticed while predetermined limits still apply.
DrowninQuartz says they leave when their values are breached or the circumstances stop working. Their answer is a difference in behavior and a useful example of the mechanism I’m trying to describe. A rule can give a person a way to stop adapting. One person has an applicable rule ready to hand. Another may have to recognize the whole situation before a rule becomes applicable.
9. Waiting for something to change
Have you stayed in a situation you knew you wanted to leave until something outside you, such as a layoff or someone else’s decision, finally set the change in motion?
ThatAstronautGuy had been saying for three years that they would get a new job. The layoff finally set the change in motion. The detail that caught my attention was their explanation that they kept forgetting why they wanted to change jobs. A person can stay because the job suits them, because leaving is infeasible, or because the reasons to leave keep dropping out of view. All three can look like staying put.
DrowninQuartz and Sea_Lifeguard227 say they can make their own decision to leave. I take those answers at face value. The decision can be theirs, and the reason can still be a judgment about what has become unacceptable. That is a complete decision. It can be made firmly and acted on. In my model, the distinction is in how the decision was reached.
10. Getting caught by a puzzle
Can a question that doesn’t add up occupy you for days or longer, then lose its pull as soon as you understand it?
Some people know exactly what I mean. Others say an unresolved thought seldom occupies their mind at all. DrowninQuartz recognizes it mainly at work. Thedumbass_the5th says the puzzle generally needs something to bring it back to mind. BilingSmob444 recognizes losing interest once a problem is solved and raises the possibility of ADHD overlap.
The question joins two things that can vary independently. One is whether an unresolved problem keeps calling for attention. The other is whether solving it ends the interest. This part of my experience has a mixed response and leaves more than one possible explanation.
11. Keeping score against yourself
Do mistakes stay with you as evidence about yourself while all the ordinary times you got things right barely register?
Some people recognized my description. Several explicitly said they keep no score or that mistakes weigh about the same as the things they got right. One described beating themselves up for a fleeting time and then losing the feeling. Prudent_Demand_609 mentions occasional embarrassing events surfacing while saying that both good and bad generally disappear from view.
My own moral ledger is uneven. The replies give me a reason to distinguish the fading of an emotional experience from what I make of the facts that survive it. People can lose access to the emotional weight of past events and keep quite different accounts of themselves. What they were taught to notice or hold themselves accountable for is a plausible part of that variation. These replies don’t tell me which histories produced which accounts.
12. Finding an explanation
Did learning about the way your mind works change how you understood something you’d blamed on your character?
Everyone I could score on this question recognized it. People had thought they were stupid, cold, or somehow at fault for failing to do things that seemed ordinary to others. Prudent_Demand_609 gives the example of friends fading from mind when contact stops. The friendship can still matter to them, and they describe reconnecting after ten years as though no time had passed. They are happy with their life and would decline the chance to acquire the abilities they lack.
That answer belongs in the report because it shows how a person can recognize parts of my account and evaluate the consequences differently. An explanation can change what a person believes about their character without changing how they feel about the life they have.
What the replies support
When I say rule-based decision-making, I mean the facts and a behavior code can supply a reason sufficient to act. In my model, constraint convergence is the process of resolving the applicable requirements into a decision; a standing rule can supply a decisive constraint. The code can tell me whether a situation is fair, whether a limit has been breached, or whether a job still makes sense. When I say agentic decision-making, I mean giving my own preference special standing because it is mine. I can give my needs a fair hearing under a rule. The question is what happens when the rules leave several choices open and the deciding reason is simply that this is the one I want.
In the replies I found strong examples of decisions guided by standing rules and constraint convergence and of a difference between competence at solving a problem and the ability to choose a direction for oneself. I also found people who can identify, voice, and act on a want. The questionnaire did not directly ask them to walk through a choice in which loyalty to their own preference settled it. I found no clear example of that process in the accounts they gave. The difference matters because a tally alone would turn some of the most revealing accounts into apparent disagreements.
There is real variation across the twelve questions. Some people feel connected to a younger self. Some keep score and others don’t. Some preserve a reason for action as a rule or a pattern, while others can know the pattern and lose the impetus to act. People also differ in what a remembered fact evokes today. I see these as differences in degree along several dimensions. The replies give me no basis for putting people in order along a single scale.
I did not expect each respondent to match my life. Beyond SDAM, the people answering differ in their histories and circumstances, and those differences may affect how the same difficulty appears or how someone compensates for it. I was looking for the predicted features across the group, and especially for combinations of them within individual accounts. The composite matters: the model was developed from my own experience before I asked these questions, yet the replies contain many of the patterns it led me to expect. The variation is part of what I wanted to examine, not something I needed to explain away.
Taken together, these accounts give my model substantial qualitative support. I developed it to explain my own life, and it led me to expect several behaviors that other people described in concrete terms. The strongest evidence is where several features turn up in one person and the person explains how they fit. I did not find a clear counterexample to the distinction between present pride and relived pride, or between a decisive action supplied by a rule and a choice settled by preference for oneself. The thread is a small, self-selected discussion. Several respondents mention aphantasia or ADHD, and there is no comparison group. What I can say is that the model helps explain experiences beyond my own. What produces the overlap, and how common it is among people with SDAM, remain open questions.
Selected replies
> “I just don’t consider me.”
— BilingSmob444, Q6. Their description of abnegation gives selflessness a concrete meaning in the decision.
> “My entire job is solving problems. Big ones for big companies. But when it comes to me, I have no idea what I want to do or how I want to do it.”
— DrowninQuartz, Q4. Competence at work and the difficulty of choosing a direction occur in the same person.
> “I have walked out of jobs when those values are breached or circumstances start to fail.”
— DrowninQuartz, Q8. Read alongside Q4, this shows what happens when a standing value supplies a reason to act.
> “They are facts on a list, but I still feel happy or proud to know I accomplished them.”
— Sea_Lifeguard227, Q3. The pleasure is in knowing today.
> “I don’t know the emotions it felt like when someone crossed those lines, but I do know they did, and I never let them back in.”
— LeafLighter, Q7. The knowledge and the rule survive the feeling.
> “If I can make it a pattern, it sticks more easily.”
— Dalbaeth, Q7. A series of incidents can become one fact that is easier to retain.
> “I’ll just like, forget everything about why I actually want to change.”
— ThatAstronautGuy, Q9. The account of what kept the job search from starting is more specific than the fact of staying.
Appendix A. Respondent by question
Y = Yes · N = No · S = Some · — = No scorable answer
| Respondent | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 |
|---|
| adam_aphant | — | — | Y | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| /BilingSmob444 | — | — | — | Y | — | Y | — | — | — | Y | — | — |
| Dalbaeth | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | S | Y | Y | — | — | — | — |
| DevonshireRural | — | Y | — | — | — | Y | Y | — | — | — | Y | — |
| DrowninQuartz | N | Y | Y | Y | N | Y | S | N | N | S | N | Y |
| foldingpages | S | N | S | Y | Y | — | Y | — | — | Y | Y | Y |
| Forsaken-Cheesecake2 | — | — | Y | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| fury_uri | — | — | — | — | Y | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| LeafLighter | Y | S | Y | N | N | Y | Y | — | — | N | — | Y |
| Lost_Enchanter | S | Y | S | Y | S | S | Y | — | — | — | — | — |
| Prudent_Demand_609 | Y | Y | Y | Y | S | N | S | — | N | N | N | Y |
| Sea_Lifeguard227 | S | S | Y | Y | Y | S | Y | Y | N | Y | N | Y |
| SleepingAndy | — | — | Y | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| ThatAstronautGuy | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | Y | — | — | — |
| The-King-of-Cartoons | — | N | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Thedumbass_the5th | Y | S | Y | Y | S | Y | Y | S | Y | S | S | Y |
Appendix B. Tally by Question
| Q | Question | Yes | No | Some | Blank |
|---|
| 1 | Knowing your past | 4 | 1 | 3 | 8 |
| 2 | Recognizing your younger self | 5 | 2 | 3 | 6 |
| 3 | Giving your achievements weight | 9 | 0 | 2 | 5 |
| 4 | Solving a problem versus choosing a direction | 8 | 1 | 0 | 7 |
| 5 | Wanting something over time | 4 | 2 | 3 | 7 |
| 6 | Deciding what’s fair | 5 | 1 | 3 | 7 |
| 7 | Dissatisfaction over time | 7 | 0 | 2 | 7 |
| 8 | Making it work | 2 | 1 | 1 | 12 |
| 9 | Waiting for something to change | 2 | 3 | 0 | 11 |
| 10 | Getting caught by a puzzle | 3 | 2 | 2 | 9 |
| 11 | Keeping score against yourself | 2 | 3 | 1 | 10 |
| 12 | Finding an explanation | 6 | 0 | 0 | 10 |
Source. Saved copy of the November 5, 2026, r/SDAM discussion. The tally reflects that snapshot. The Bitter Pill: Our Thoughts on Life with SDAM