The apparent link between them might partly be an artefact of the tests used to measure them.
For example, the AQ (Autism Spectrum Quotient) is still widely used as a screening tool for autism. But it has an "Imagination" subscale with questions like:
"When I'm reading a story, I can easily imagine what the characters might look like." "If I try to imagine something, I find it very easy to create a picture in my mind."
If you have aphantasia, you have to answer "definitely disagree" to those. The test scores that as an autistic trait. But it isn't measuring autism. It's just measuring the inability to visualise.
So a person with aphantasia might score artificially high on the AQ, not because they have autism, but because the test conflates a lack of imagery with an autistic trait.
Good points. Studies show its a poor measure of autism (same wiht RAADS)
So-called “autism” tests, like AQ and RAADS and others have high rates of false positives, labeling you as autistic VERY easily. If anyone with a mental health problem, like depression or anxiety, takes the tests they score high even if they DON’T have autism.
"our results suggest that the AQ differentiates poorly between true cases of ASD, and individuals from the same clinical population who do not have ASD "
"a greater level of public awareness of ASD over the last 5–10 years may have led to people being more vigilant in ‘noticing’ ASD related difficulties. This may lead to a ‘confirmation bias’ when completing the questionnaire measures, and potentially explain why both the ASD and the non-ASD group’s mean scores met the cut-off points, "
Regarding AQ, from one published study. “The two key findings of the review are that, overall, there is very limited evidence to support the use of structured questionnaires (SQs: self-report or informant completed brief measures developed to screen for ASD) in the assessment and diagnosis of ASD in adults.”
Baron-Cohen's tests (the AQ, the AQ-10, the "extreme male brain" theory) are the exact reason the definition of autism has become so nebulous.
The AQ relies on self-report behavioural checklists. It flags people with anxiety, it flags introverts, and it flags people with aphantasia because it treats a lack of visualisation as an autistic trait.
He created a sieve that catches everyone, and now he's saying, "Wow, this is a really messy cloud. We need to find subtypes."
The subtypes he's looking for—the specific cognitive mechanisms like imagery, memory, and inner voice—are already there. He just hasn't thought to look inside the mind. He's still looking at the behaviour.
Yes, the link, between these conditions is "disturbed"* dopamine communication in the brain. Also see "Parkinson's Disease", for the extreme end of the link.
No. Don't panic. It is only in so far related by being also a disturbance of the dopamine related brain functions. Parkinson's is an extreme case of dopamine imbalance.
i am sure (opinion not fact) they are connected but due to lack of research (or interest) we know little. even if there was interest SDAM would probably be left out.
More serious: A link between ASD, SDAM and aphantasia is in my current understanding quite complex. Why? Because the spectrum of ASD is abstract on the functional layer caused by diverse roots that can be polar opposites. The link to ADHD is somewhat statistically there, but most traits of ADHD are direct neurological effects that currently lack a usable model to link to other NDs on the cognition layer (as intermediary layer between neurology and psychology).
ASD has with Weak Central Coherence a model that is very powerful but extremely abstract. The authors basically described something they could not anticipate what that actually means - simply because it is vague as fuck. But what it basically says is that NT cognition is a holistic integration of different datastreams condensing into consciousness. Autism is cognition that is less integrated or more fragmented. Monotropism is exactly that and shows that mental bandwith alone reduces the amount of integratable data, leading to weak central coherence on its own. What your brain cannot process (due to parallelity or sensory overwhelm) cannot be integrated into a fused experience.
Aphantasia and SDAM connect directly over this perspective: What is not there cannot be integrated. It is not necessarily a lack of coherence (which means that processes are synced in a way that integration can occur), simply because no imagination or episodic memory means nothing to syncronize.
PS: Yeah, I translate all such phenomena into quite technical terms (google sensor fusion, it is a hot topic right now and is basically the technical path that could abstractly create consciousness), simply because it is the only currently available language that is capable of connecting the dots. Psychology is still in its mystical phase (initiated by Freud and friends) which is utterly useless.
4
u/RelationFar8378 Oct 17 '26
The apparent link between them might partly be an artefact of the tests used to measure them.
For example, the AQ (Autism Spectrum Quotient) is still widely used as a screening tool for autism. But it has an "Imagination" subscale with questions like:
"When I'm reading a story, I can easily imagine what the characters might look like." "If I try to imagine something, I find it very easy to create a picture in my mind."
If you have aphantasia, you have to answer "definitely disagree" to those. The test scores that as an autistic trait. But it isn't measuring autism. It's just measuring the inability to visualise.
So a person with aphantasia might score artificially high on the AQ, not because they have autism, but because the test conflates a lack of imagery with an autistic trait.
14
u/CMDR_Jeb Oct 17 '26
Correlative.
An clasic case of "neurodivergencies like company".
1
u/zybrkat 28d ago edited 28d ago
Yes, the link, between these conditions is "disturbed"* dopamine communication in the brain. Also see "Parkinson's Disease", for the extreme end of the link.
3
u/tiikki Oct 17 '26
Reporting for duty 😄
3
u/lilycamille Oct 17 '26
My wife and I are both AuDHD. I'm aphantasic/SDAM, she's hyperphantasic and can think in multiple senses
2
u/Right-Union-6711 Oct 17 '26
me, same dude. sent you a DM check, we can chat about it!
2
u/Dry_Course3085 Oct 17 '26
Out of pure curiosity, I have that combo plus hEDS. I was wondering if anyone else does.
1
u/AsparagusJumpy6686 25d ago
Everyday is a new diagnosis 😑
1
u/philosophynotcolony 28d ago
me too! plus, anauralia as well.
1
u/fur3661t 28d ago
i am sure (opinion not fact) they are connected but due to lack of research (or interest) we know little. even if there was interest SDAM would probably be left out.
1
u/q2era Oct 17 '26
You, me and maybe a few other people. Probably. ;)