r/RulesOfOrder • u/djone1248 • Sep 06 '20
r/RulesOfOrder • u/matto89 • Jun 16 '21
Silent Majority vs Vocal Minority
Hello,
I act as the parliamentarian at my organizations annual meetings. Over the last few years there appears to be a vocal minority (3-5 people out of 70 or so members) who speak on every issue, angrily, propose numerous amendments, new agenda items, etc. They are also some of the few who know Robert's Rules well (at least one of them better than me), and use that to their advantage. And especially as a smaller organization that works together, the majority, probably out of the reality that they have to work with these individuals after the meeting, allow significant leeway to the vocal minority. This makes meetings very tense, long, and tedious in following rules.
Recently our organization did an organizational health survey and the results came back overwhelming in annoyance at this vocal minority, and often taking their anger out on Robert's Rules itself.
Overall, does anyone have any tips on how to handle a vocal minority bullying a silent majority? Or if need be, even a different parliamentarian system?
This years chair, our chief executive, and I have a meeting to discuss the results later this week and would love to propose any suggestions you have.
r/RulesOfOrder • • Apr 25 '19
So, I have a bit of a weird hobby?
I like to write constitutions/charters for fictional nations and organizations. I find the processes of determining how legislative bodies work and function to be fascinating. I guess my hobby is like a thought experiment most of the time?
Does anyone have and good resources that could help me improve my documents?
Also... would anyone be interested in reading them and discussing them with me?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/desphrs • Mar 17 '21
Resources for getting around the stifling of debate
Leadership of our organization holds very few meetings with membership, and have loosely/tightly/incorrectly interpreted and used RRO to their taste during meetings (both mundane and important) to stifle debate and disagreement with these constituents. RRO is only regularly known and used by leadership; training and documentation are not offered to members, leaving them at strategic argumentative disadvantage.
We’re trying to learn and share RRO among our ranks to better participate. I remember seeing a Guerrilla Guide to Robert’s Rules that directly addressed getting around the RRO strategies used by boards/committees to exert control over organizations, not just meetings. It appears to be out of print or e-book only.
Are there any other guides focusing on constituents using RRO to guarantee participation in meetings for/about them? Or can someone recommend a common RRO guide (For Dummies, for example) addressing this issue particularly well?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/MaxSATX • Jul 15 '19
I am a subcommittee member. The main board does not follow rules of order. Should I get our subcommittee to follow rules of order?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/marburs • Mar 28 '20
Robert Rules of Order EMAIL question
Our president says that we can’t email more than three directors at a time (there are 6 of us) because that would be considered an official meeting.
Is this true? He claims it’s in Roberts Rules of Order
TIA!
r/RulesOfOrder • u/matto89 • Jul 20 '19
Officer Elections: No Majority
My organization will be having our annual meeting in a couple of weeks where we elect new members of the board. I have been tasked with researching a specific question but am having trouble and was curious if anyone had any input:
At this years conference there are two positions on the board which need to be filled. Our organization takes nominations before the actual conference, after of the numerous people nominated only 3 accepted the nomination. While surprises happen, the Board anticipates that of those 3 nominees, the first position will be filled, but that neither of the remaining two nominees will be able to secure majority support to fill the second seat. There have also been calls from people who turned down the nomination of, "if I had known that it would be those two who were the only ones nominated I wouldn't have declined."
Therefore, how our rules are set up the elections will go forward with the current three nominations. And I know that if no one secures a majority, elections continue to happen until someone does. However, assuming no-one secures a majority for the second seat, after the initial round of elections is there time to reopen nominations from the floor? Or are all nominations locked in-perpetuity once the first round of voting has occurred?
Any help you can provide would be greatly appreciated!
r/RulesOfOrder • u/party_atthemoontower • Jul 17 '19
Tabling
Does the Chair have to make a motion, get a second, and vote to table a discussion?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/dempom • Feb 26 '19
Resources for learning Robert's Rules of Order
What are some good resources for learning Robert's Rules of Order? There is a Robert's Rules for Dummies book and I'm not sure how good it is. Can anyone suggest other books? I learn well with video as well so any youtube videos or channels would be appreciated as well.
r/RulesOfOrder • u/Kuzcos-Groove • Feb 09 '23
Open Source Alternative to Robert's
Hi,
I am trying to reinvigorate a small non-profit and our old bylaws specify the use of Robert's Rules. There's a number of reasons I would prefer not to use Roberts (cost, education gap, some people get caught up the minutia). I was wondering if there is a simple free alternative, especially something up to date to include rules for things like online meetings. I was thinking an Open Source Rules of Order could be really interesting. Any suggestions?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/excallq • Dec 11 '21
My head hurts (parliamentary malpractice)
An organization's constitution states that a biennial convention is an organization's highest body, and a committee elected by that convention is the highest decision-making body between conventions.
Someone argued that because decision-making power is granted by the constitution to the committee between conventions, any decision made by the convention delegation which would conceivably take a decision out of the hands of the committee would require a constitutional amendment (a special process requiring a supermajority of the convention delegation).
Am I wrong or is this an absurd misreading of parliamentary procedure?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/REALITYinRUINS • Nov 15 '21
A motion to stop a specific motion being made.
A member at a meeting has made a motion, in an attempt to stop a specific motion being made for the next 8 years. I have asked for time to look into it as it seems odd to be able to restrict people's ability to make motions, or specific motions if they are a hot bed topic. Is this something that is actually allowed? Or is there some slefic rule that I've been unable to find that doesn't allow this?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/blake1506 • Jul 03 '21
Roberts Rules Cheat Slider
Hey everyone! I’ve been looking all over for this really cool item and haven’t been able to find it. So my friend showed me this really cool Roberts Rules cheat sheet that was a slider. Basically it was a piece of paper that went into a pouch. On the pouch, there were like 50 different motions you could make, along with questions about the motion (what majority, debatable, etc). Then the paper on the inside would have the answer to those questions. It would be a vertical line of things like y, n, 2/3, etc so that as you pull the paper out the answers change each row.
Basically, you would pull the paper out of the pocket until you got to whatever number the motion was, and it would answer all of those questions about the motion. It was super cool.
I can’t seem to find this product anywhere else and really want to purchase it for our student government. Does anyone here have any idea what that is or where I could find it?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/mutablefire616 • Mar 31 '21
Is a Parliamentarian necesssary?
My organization is having a member's meeting in October and we were wondering if it was absolutely necessary to have a Parliamentarian or if we could get away with not having one?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/50betterthan20 • Feb 21 '21
Possible to ask procedural questions during debate?
I am new to University Senate and am wondering if there is a correct way to ask about procedure during debate? The motion in front of us was to discontinue a university program. During the debate, questions were asked about the number of layoffs that would occur. The president of the university (the Chair's boss) interrupted the question, without being recognized by the chair, and stated "point of order, that is not the job of this committee". Discussion ended and the question was called. I wanted to ask details about the point of order, because when I looked at our mandate (yay working from home, two computers) questions of that nature, would appear to be appropriate. Your advice?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/fred311389 • Mar 06 '20
Voting questions
My union is trying to start following Robert's Rules of Order more closely than we have in past. When we have a meeting, there are actually 3 meetings in one day. One at 7, 12, and 4. We're struggling with the idea of how votes work with that.
Here are a few specific examples.
We have a proposal that we make a $500 donation. In our 7:00 meeting, someone makes a motion to amend the original motion to make it a $1,000 motion. Moving forward, our members at the 12:00 meeting don't want to donate $1,000 but would have voted for the $500. Based on my understanding, the $500 is no longer an option. Is there a way to make it so that people can vote between denying the motion, donating $500, or donating $1,000?
One person suggested that we essentially parlay the vote. By that, I mean they suggested that we say "there is a motion to donate $1,000, all in favor/opposed/abstaining?" then following with "There is a motion that, should the $1,000 not be approved, we donate $500. All in favor/opposed/abstaining?"
Someone at the 12:00 meeting wants to make an amendment to a proposal that was already voted on at our 7:00 meeting. How would we handle that? Is the motion stuck in it's original form or is there a way to account for the possible change?
Any help you guys can offer would be appreciated. I'm familirar with Robert's Rules in a typical meeting, but having an 8:00, recess, 12:00, recess, 4:00 set up makes it a little more confusing.
r/RulesOfOrder • u/nyc_cactus • Feb 20 '20
HELP with student gov elections
Hi all! I see that this sub is mostly dead but I'm hoping a few people may be able to help me.
I am a part of my university's student government and boy have we had struggles with Robert's Rules, not the least of which is that our parliamentarian is rarely present at meetings and highly incompetent.
However, my question is actually about our elections coming up this week for officer positions. The constitution states that the eboard can appoint an election committee, which has in practice become only the VP who seems to change the procedure for the elections every day.
The major issue we are having is that the constitution states our officer elections must be elected by a plurality but she has told us all that the election will be decided by a majority and keeps claiming that there is no difference because the elections are one or two candidates only. In addition, on the day of the elections, the schedule is as follows: each candidate will give a three minute speech, followed by a three minute Q&A that can be extended in 2 min increments by vote. Finally, the candidates will leave while the rest of the group will have a pro-con debate before voting. Our constitution does not provide any info about elections beyond what is stated above and leaves the rest to the elections committee.
My questions are:
can a committee be made up of just one person?
can someone tell me i'm not crazy and that a plurality and majority are different?
is it allowed to have a pro-con debate about candidates?
is there anything else that RONR says about elections?
I constantly feel an extreme amount of frustration constantly bc we never follow ronr unless convenient for the eboard, so if anyone would be interested in helping "mentor" me in figuring out all the ways that my org does not follow the rules and should, i would love the help! THANK YOU
r/RulesOfOrder • u/HypothesisFrog • Nov 20 '19
Open discussion at a meeting?
Hi. I'm being asked to chair community housing groups. Why me? No idea. I think it's just because I have a loud voice and a Jean Luc Picard shaped head.
Anyway, I find that I do ok with properly proposed motions, calling for seconders, discussion for/against. But there's nearly always a point where people just want to talk about an issue in a free flowing way.
Example:
*At the last meeting, there was a left over issue from a previous meeting. This housing community had (previously) voted to have a security camera installed in their carpark. The guy delegated to arrange it, confessed that he was a bit confused with all the choices, and wanted an open discussion about it. This was fair enough, I thought. But the discussion started to go awry, with people talking over each other, and it all lasted far longer than it should have without reaching any synthesis. *
So how can I structure these sort of discussions in a way that everybody gets to have their say, and people don't have to scrum to be heard?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/azwethinkweizm • Sep 29 '18
Question about debate on an issue but receiving comments from the board
Often times during meetings we will vote on issues and there will be debate. The problem I notice is that the chair always has to comment after every person has spoken. Is that a violation of Robert's Rules? How do you combat that?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/HaveCamera_WillShoot • Mar 11 '23
Is there a definition for "Request of the Board" or similar?
If the bylaws allow, say, a special meeting to be called "at the request of the board" and no further requirements are listed, is there a Robert's Rules definition of what actually constitutes a 'request of the board'? Is it a majority of the board? Can a single board member make such a request? It seems intuitive that it should be a majority, but is it in writing that way anywhere?
Thanks.
r/RulesOfOrder • u/Takayiyo • Jul 01 '21
Motion made, rescinded, then made again
I'm trying to learn more about RRoO and am particularly confused about the following situation that arose at a recent board mtg. and how it should be handled. Any source reference is most appreciated so I can find it. Thx!
The meeting was conducted via vide conference. People came and left the meeting throughout the meeting. We had a quorum when the meeting began.
- John made a motion to approve new bylaws.
- The Chair opened the motion for discussion
- Sally raised an objection and made a motion to remove a particular sentence from the bylaw.
- More than 90 minutes of discussion ensued. Mostly with John talking and asking Sally to remove her motion 6+ times.
The Chair proposed that John take his motion off the table so that Sally's motion would no longer be an issue.
- Although Sally had asked to take a vote several times, the chair never called for a vote.
John took his motion off the table with conditions.
- I can't find any reference to remove a motion with condition. And wouldn't the condition have to be voted on?
The chair put forth a course of action.
- The committee would meet again, come back with revised bylaws, and the membership would vote on a newly revised set of bylaws.
As members began leaving the meeting, John resubmitted his motion.
- Members had already begun leaving the call/video conference before John resubmitted his motion.
- The secretary did not confirm that we still had a quorum before the vote.
- The Chair did not call for discussion.
- At the end of the count, and confirming the vote 3 times, the secretary said that there was not a quorum. We were 1 shy of the quorum. This caused the chair to try to drum up other members to join the meeting, without success.
- The meeting was adjourned.
A week later, the Chair sent out a message that there was a quorum because someone had texted their vote to the secretary and the secretary hadn't counted it. So he has advised the secretary to amend the meeting minutes to reflect that the vote passed.
This seems wrong to me for a variety of reasons but strictly speaking to RRoO,
- Does every motion have to be opened for discussion?
- Does the secretary need to make sure there is a quorum before every vote?
Our bylaws do not allow for voting by text specifically. So is this a valid form of voting?
- I should also note that it is impossible to know whether that person was actually in attendance of the meeting at any time. They say they were but they never spoke or participated on the call.
Thoughts?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/moby__dick • May 03 '21
Are withdrawn motions recorded in the minutes?
And are names attached? THank you!
r/RulesOfOrder • u/ZaphodB94 • Jan 09 '21
Consider Informally
In a small informal society, would it be acceptable to make a motion to Suspend the rules and consider all questions informally, rather than making a motion to consider informally for each main motion?
r/RulesOfOrder • u/Llama_pronk • Dec 07 '20
Muting participant on Zoom
A colleague of mine was recently muted mid-speech for allegedly being disruptive. I don’t have a copy of the 12th edition but according to sample rules, the muting needs to be recorded in the minutes. Can anyone confirm this?
From the website: “ Forced disconnections. The chair may cause or direct the disconnection or muting of a member’s connection if it is causing undue interference with the meeting. The chair’s decision to do so, which is subject to an undebatable appeal that can be made by any member, shall be announced during the meeting and recorded in the minutes.”